12 ms·
Starting Sunday, cable companies can no longer ‘rent’ you the router you own
- millisecond 6y agoWhy do we need a special case law for this? Seems like it should already be covered.
- vezycash 6y agoI believe the real problem is pricing. The ability to advertise $30 (bait) and charge $50 (switch) basically begs for scams like this.
- spaetzleesser 6y agoExactly. Same for phone plans. The advertised price should be the price you pay. They shouldn’t be able to add random fees they just make up.
- ghaff 6y agoIt's unfortunately true with a ton of things: hotels, rental cars, etc. Taxes, franchise fees, other taxes, facilities charges, etc. can all add on 20% or more. Especially if you're comparison shopping, you really need to verify whether you're looking at a base fee or the final tally.
- baskire 6y agoAirbnb does this all the time. Their advertised prices don’t include cleaning fees. If Airbnb included those fees the pricing would often come out higher than a hotel in many cases. And hotels include cleaning costs as part of the nightly rate
- josho 6y agoMany hotels have responded by adding “resort fees” on top of the base rate. This is all attributable to weak consumer protection laws.
- ghaff 6y agoResort fees aren't new. Perhaps they've become more common but I haven't noticed. The more common issue with hotels, which isn't really their fault, is you might have 5 different taxes added to the bill which can add up to a good 20% of the total bill.
- arebop 6y agoIf you search for a certain date range, Airbnb will calculate and display the full price for each property on the SERP. It makes sense to compare asymptotically when you don't know the length of stay. The cable and telephone companies billing practices on the other hand are purely deceptive with no utility for the consumer.
- loftyal 6y agoTry airbnb.com.au Australia made legislation requiring companies to give the full price.
- spaetzleesser 6y agoI think requiring to advertise full price is even more market friendly than sneaking in more fees. This just incentivizes dishonest behavior. It’s hard to advocate against such a rule. The US health system is also in dire need of such a rule.
- spaetzleesser 6y agoI have had several cases recently where the added fees almost doubled up the final price making the search feature almost useless.
- tyingq 6y agoAirline fares are easy to compare because the DOT compels them to make it so. https://www.transportation.gov/policy/aviation-policy/airline-rules-fares#DisclosureFullFares https://www.transportation.gov/policy/aviation-policy/airlin... This is one area where regulation is probably the only real solution.
- dmurray 6y agoYou can rent cars, houses, computers - what law would normally forbid those financial relationships? Cable companies and other utility providers need special treatment in the law because they enjoy special advantages as monopolists. Instead of saying "anyone is allowed to dig up the road, bury cables and let the customers choose the provider with the best service" we often allow only one or two cable providers and add some special rules to make them treat their hostage customers better.
- TheRealSteel 6y agoOnce again, just like with Covid, we can look to what New Zealand did for the obvious and correct answer: Have the government lay fibre to every home and business, and allow any ISP to compete for service over that fibre. Australia tried, and around 10% of homes got connected. But the conservative Liberal government got in power and changed it from fibre to DSL, a move that was universally derided as unfeasible both economically and technologically. It was known to be a waste of tens of billions of dollars - but Rupert Murdoch doesn't want poor people to have access to information outside his propaganda network, so he handed the election to the Liberals (the conservatives) in exchange for destroying the network and salting the earth so it was hard for even a future government to fix. Telstra, the big incumbent ISP with a monopoly in many areas, also had alot to do with it. Instead of gigabit fibre, we now have 25mbit DSL, which doesn't work when it's raining even lightly, or in strong winds. This network was also slower to build, and far more expensive than the fibre. But as long as it's built with fibre, it works. New Zealand's network is enourmously successful, and now anyone has access to gigabit fibre on their choice of ISP. It works both in theory and in practice, you just must not allow a conservative government to hand it over to monopoly corporations. The common "government can't be trusted" rubbish is bunk, the government only screwed it up in Australia because that was their goal, the fibre networks have always been a success.
- kaczordon 6y agoSo as long as the government does it it’s ok as long as the government doesn’t do it incorrectly? Therein lies the problem, governmental failure is always a possibility as Milton Friedman observed, and if they fail there’s no penalty to failing other than the size of government increasing :) Even in America the issue is that we’ve over-regulated the internet industry to the point where even a company like Google has issues, although one could argue they did it for different reasons i.e. to force the existing companies to lay down fiber faster. Regulatory capture is the real issue.
- Jemm 6y agoCable companies will just rename the rent to service contracts. The root of these issues is letting sociopaths have the power they do.
- cxr 6y agoNot wrong, but maybe thinking of things in terms that are too simple, i.e., the natural corollary that if we would just stop letting sociopaths do what they do, then we wouldn't have things like this. But it's usually not sociopaths versus normal people. Sure, maybe there are a lot of CEOs who could be clinically diagnosed as sociopaths, but a lot of average people who don't fall into that bucket are able to rationalize their way into doing shitty things. I'm talking about everyone from waitstaff and gas station attendants to people doing admin work and small business owners—not just people in conspicuous positions of power making many times the national average income. I'd wager that if you were able to get your hands on an oracle that could provide the true count of incidental contact and the measure of impact on the average person's life by sociopaths versus good people who do bad things as a matter of performing their daily routines, the difference is probably an order of magnitude heavier on the side of the latter. Not to mention Hanlon's razor and all that.
- dylan604 6y ago> maybe there are a lot of CEOs who could be clinically diagnosed How many times is it that the CEO comes up with the idea to do something like this? For start ups, I can see the CEO actually having this kind of involvement. Jobs/Musk/Zuck all come to mind of a CEO that is in total control. ATT/Spectrum/Comcast/etc all seem to be on a different level. This adding of fees type of schemes seems more like something the bean counters come up with, and then eventually the CEO is informed/blesses the decisions. Would a CEO in these companies really be the ones scheming up ideas like this or be more concerned about the next acquisition?
- cxr 6y agoI don't think this line of thought is without value, but I also don't think it materially affects the point I was making.
- FunnyLookinHat 6y agoTo be clear, this law prevents a company from charging you the rental fee even if you provide your own modem. They often do it under the guise of support - while still admitting that they will not actually be able to provide support for models that are effectively not in their support database (because they only include the models they rent)!
- nobody9999 6y ago>They often do it under the guise of support - while still admitting that they will not actually be able to provide support for models that are effectively not in their support database (because they only include the models they rent)! Because I purchased a (supported) cable modem from a third party, my ISP won't provide services which are supposed to be included in my service. Their systems don't "recognize" my cable modem as existing on their network, so services that should be provided through my link are denied, claiming that my devices "aren't on the network." It's a huge scam. We need real competition in internet service providers.
- sitkack 6y agoFile a formal complaint with your state attorney general.
- nobody9999 6y ago>File a formal complaint with your state attorney general. Not a bad idea. But since I don't actually use the services I'm not getting, I'll likely just vote with my wallet instead.
- edoceo 6y agoHow could you vote with your wallet if there is not competition?
- nobody9999 6y ago
- thedanbob 6y agoWhen I changed my internet service recently an equipment rental fee was included in the cost per month, even though I have my own modem. I was pleasantly surprised when the first bill came and I wasn’t actually charged that portion. Nice to know that will be the expectation from now on.
- cududa 6y agoEarlier this year I purchased my own router and modem and when I called Spectrun to cancel my rental, I was informed I needed to sign up for a new package - the price of which was about $2 more than I was previously paying WITH rented equipment
- jcomis 6y agocomcast did the exact thing to me. I had to sign up for a new plan. But they also wouldn't let me use the new plan promos. Oh, and a month later when I got my first bill at the new rate it still had rental fees. Took about 8 months of calling each month to have the rental fee go away. And then when I finally cancelled because I was moving they charged me for not returning the modem/router I returned over a year ago. Fun times.
- alyandon 6y agoThat's amazingly customer hostile. In this area with Spectrum you can self-service swap out your cable modem as often as you want by logging into a support portal and entering the MAC address of the new modem and waiting a minute for their system to provision it. No CSR interaction required.
- cududa 6y agoLucky man. I was doing this during the start of lockdown (when spectrun was having an outbreak at their CS office). So calling to get the modem provisioned took about an hour and a half. The initial provision file was wrong so had to go through waiting on hold again
- yummypaint 6y agoClassifying ISPs as the utility companies they are is the only way to end the gouging and systematic fraud.
- wpietri 6y agoYup. I'd love to see some sort of automatic regulation for situations of market failure. E.g., If the 2 largest players in a market have more than an 80% market share, the presumption should be regulation. In SF, I have multiple ISP options. I get gigabit fiber for $40/month and no nonsense. But my girlfriend lives in an area with Comcast only, where the price is much higher, the service is much worse, and they had loaded her bill down with absurd equipment rental charges. When sufficient competition doesn't exist, we shouldn't just abandon people to predatory companies.
- MereInterest 6y agoIn general, I agree, though I think I'd also include some consideration of size or barriers to entry. As an example, photomultiplier tubes are used to detect very small amounts of light, down to a few photons. They are primarily produced by Hamamatsu, which has about 90% market share for PMTs. And they are ridiculously reliable, used in detectors that last for decades. Even without competition in PMTs, they make good products. It's a very small market, and doesn't have room for much competition, so I don't think that market share alone can be the sole determinant. That said, if the quality were to drop, if they were to engage in anticompetitive behavior, if they were to provide tools to subvert an election, if they were to repeatedly buy out competitors, or any combination of the above, I would drop them in a heartbeat.
- wpietri 6y agoIn that case, I think there's not a lot a regulator has to do. But I think it's still appropriate to have a regulator tracking the space, so that they can quickly respond to the sorts of declines you discuss.
- tesmar2 6y ago
- tobr 6y agoIn the US.
- OJFord 6y agoWhere else is it a problem? I don't know if it's actually illegal/regulated against in the UK, but it's never happened to me.
- tobr 6y agoNo idea if it’s a problem anywhere else, but then I didn’t know it was a problem in the US either. I just don’t like it when people assume everyone on the internet is an American.
- eatbitseveryday 6y agoYes, because the FCC is a US entity and HN is likely majority US-based.
- tobr 6y agoBut the title doesn’t mention the FCC, and nothing else suggests which country it concerns either. HN is an English-language website, which often translates to majority US. We can further speculate that HN is likely majority able-bodied, heterosexual, male, cis, white. That’s not a reason to make it less inclusive of people outside those majorities.
- 9HZZRfNlpR 6y agoIt's not, dang has written about these percentages all over again, us is not majority here.
- paulcarroty 6y agoAlways prefer to use my own router from security & privacy reasons. openWrt support is must have.
- stefan_ 6y agoThis law is missing a key ingredient that we have in the EU: the ISP need to provide you the credentials you need to access your service. No tricks where only the ISP provided router is whitelisted to get them from the network.
- linux2647 6y agoYeah this is how AT&T fiber forces you to pay for their router/WiFi combo box. The box contains an authentication certificate that is required for connecting to them. So frustrating
- fingerlocks 6y agoIs this part of PPPoE, or can you put the router in bridge mode and then connect your own hardware?
- unstatusthequo 6y agoI’ve neutered my AT&T fiber router with some Ubiquiti scripts: https://community.ui.com/questions/INSTRUCTIONS-Bypass-ATT-Fiber-Residential-Gateway-with-a-USG/2d8b1559-4623-40bb-9aae-af0348dd39a8 https://community.ui.com/questions/INSTRUCTIONS-Bypass-ATT-F...
- lgats 6y agoStill paying the monthly fee though
- powersnail 6y agoFrom my experience, you can set the firewall to pass-through, and connect from its LAN to the WAN of your own router.
- toast0 6y agoThankfully, AT&T doesn't run PPPoE on fiber (but hush before they get any bright ideas), but even if the 'residential gateway' is in bridge mode, it's performimg a useless function for users that don't need/want it to do NAT or WiFi or whatever it does for TV. Ethernet on one side, and ethernet on the other, a couple ms between them.
- jamesmehaffey 6y agoEven though I have begged the cable company to address the underlying issue, I have gone through several dozen modem/DVR boxes due to lightning strikes. I can only assume that the equipment is super inexpensive, otherwise they would have sorted the problem ages ago. They have been making a fortune on renting out marked up junk for years, but I am sure they are already thinking of some clever ways to claw that revenue stream back.
- enobrev 6y agoComcast's ahead of this in Illinois. They gave a significant discount for using their modem / router for "unlimited" internet. I'd rather not use their modem. I already gave my own, but it would cost about $500 more per year to use my own.
- koolba 6y agoWhy would they want you to pay less to use hardware they provide? Is it to force you to provide an Xfinity hotspot?
- enobrev 6y agoThat's my guess. I get a discount, they get to share my internet with others. On my block that's not really going to effect me. As far as I'm concerned, they're simply charging me to use my own equipment.
- yborg 6y agoThey have essentially monopoly control in a lot of markets and there are practical limits to how much they can charge people before the outcry makes regulatory capture more expensive. So the play is to take more household budget from other companies, they're pushing hard into mobile. Having their ISP customers provide them with blanket Wifi coverage allows them to deliver this service in residential areas without battling for tower space.
- 1123581321 6y agoXfinity Mobile, at least in Illinois, is a Verizon MVNO. So presumably their wifi network just gives them negotiating leverage for their carrier arrangement.
- easton 6y agoNo, because you can easily disable the hotspot.
- tzs 6y agoIs that because you have some sort of big discount while under contract? Once your contract is up, it should be $60/year more for unlimited using your own modem. Unlimited with your own modem is $30/month. Unlimited with their modem is $14/month for the modem/router + $11/month for unlimited = $25/month.
- JMTQp8lwXL 6y agoStarting Sunday, Cable companies can increase your main charge or institute some other new fee that doesn't fall under this exact stipulation.
- cronix 6y agoI already got the email from Comcast last week that they were raising rates. Now I know why.
- pinewurst 6y agoThough to give Comcast some (microscopic) credit, they've never attempted to charge me to rent my own equipment in the decade or so I've been dealing with them.
- sigstoat 6y agoi bought my own cable modem, installed it, never got around to calling them or returning their modem, and after maybe another month or two, comcast just stopped charging me the rental fee and didn't ask for their modem back. so... pretty decent on their part.
- medmunds 6y agoThey will charge you for it if you ever cancel service. (And they'll charge the full retail price when it was new, not the current value.) Return their modem, get a receipt, double check the serial number on the receipt matches the equipment you returned, and save that receipt. You may need it if you ever move or drop Comcast in the future.
- sigstoat 6y agowe're about 8 years too late for that. i'll get back to you in 5-10 years to let you know how it goes, but i'm not very concerned.
- roflchoppa 6y agoThere was a strange thing I noticed when I moved from the rented router/modem combo provided by Comcast to a netgear Cm1000. The speed rate average dropped from 700mbps to 2-300mbps. Is this a configuration problem?
- arcticbull 6y agoCan they give everyone a free router and charge a $10/month system access fee regardless of whether you use their router? This is how cell service in Canada used to be structured haha. Generally I’m not a fan of this kind of targeted legislation and rule making. Pricing should be mandated to be advertised all-in or left alone; these folks aren’t gonna let this income go.
- dvtrn 6y agoCan they give everyone a free router and charge a $10/month system access fee $10 says this is exactly what they’re going to do.
- arcticbull 6y agoAnd then to make sure nobody runs off with a free* router, they can add a $100 account early termination fee. Thus solving the problem once and for all.
- dvtrn 6y agoBingo. I’m looking to get away from all the sorts of access fees and charges with my current carrier, yet after doing the math the ETF would have come out to a full calendar year of the same fees plus about 3%. Oh except despite having multiple carriers in my city, none of the other ones seem interested in servicing my building. I hate this damn racket.
- comeonseriously 6y agoThey'll just find another "fee" to tack on to make up for it.
- iJohnDoe 6y ago100% This. Another company did this. It was AT&T or Verizon. There was actual uproar over it and they eventually reversed the decision. However, you can’t always count on an uproar to always have any impact.
- snarfy 6y agoI sent Frontier's router back the day my service was installed, yet they still charge me $10/month for the last two years to rent it. If there is a class action against Frontier, sign me up.
- iJohnDoe 6y agoIf you join that class action you can bet that you’ll never get any of that money back. The best you can hope for is a coupon for 10% off one month of Frontier service, but you’ll need to provide your SSN and other personal information to a third-party that is processing the coupon requests. Most won’t risk exposing their PII in such a way for very little return. However, the lawyers will receive millions from the class action.
- snarfy 6y agoI'm absolutely not looking for money back. Soulless corporate citizens with no morality need punishement for bad behavior.
- rconti 6y agoComcast has never charged me for bringing my own modem. More frustratingly, though, they charge you more for internet-only service than they do for TV+Internet. Every time you try to go Internet-only, they offer you a 'deal' where they throw in cable TV service for -$5. And then they ship you a cable TV box that you store in a box in your attic under penalty of hundreds of dollars if you lose it and can't return it at the end of your service. I've returned the cable TV box before, and they just ship you a new one. ("We've noticed you have TV service but do not have a cable TV box, here is the equipment you need! Aren't we nice?!") Thankfully I've got FTTH now. Slightly-less-thankfully I'm on ATT so I've got to pay the rental fee, but it's still a much better deal than Comcast ever offered. When Sonic finally serves my house directly Real Soon Like Now, the bill will be cut in half again. But still, mandatory rental fee.
- rantwasp 6y agoyou can get the internet for the best price they have if you are willing to just cancel. call them and ask for the best price for internet only. explain you’re going to cancel. if they give you the best price great. if not cancel and switch to a special price for a new customer for your SO. I’ve done this so many times that I’ve lost count. I sucks that it’s a time drain doing this + last time I cancelled I had to buy a new modem (because the old one was not supported- which is BS because it worked for 5 years on their network already)
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> explain you’re going to cancel Actually say you want to cancel. You will be routed to a cancellation department. They are ridiculously empowered. I have a memo to do this with a few services once a year.
- gnicholas 6y agoI'm curious to know where you live. I've had Comcast for a long time and have looked into pricing on a regular basis. It has never been less expensive for me to add other services, and I never have. Instead, I just go with the "starter' level of service, which is currently 25 mbps. When it's running properly, that's more than enough speed for us.
- vinay_ys 6y agoIs there any research on the cost economics of a small-town ISP? I wonder if the ecosystem is conducive for a small-town ISP to come up and operate the last-mile? Is there competitive pricing on the metro core and transit ISP bandwidths? Is there a settlement free peering exchange with major content providers? What are the long-term or minimum-commitment contracts one would have to sign-up to become a successful small-town ISP? How much capital is required? etc etc. I wonder why would they do these obviously bad pricing choices like charging for modem that's not even taken by the customer.
- allpratik 6y agoWow... I don't know why people tolerated this for so long? I wonder if there isn't a better way to be organised and put back the pressure on these monopolies? Or it could be true that many have tried and failed at it? Back in India, we still have a 100 Mbps connection for ~$16/month (500 GB cap and thereafter 2 Mbps unlimited)... There are more cheaper options than this still available.
- ruph123 6y agoAs a German I was shocked to find out that in the US Charter would not let me configure anything in “my” Charter modem. No dynDNS server, no ports forwarding, not inspecting what is wrong, not even blocking internet for certain MAC addresses. And when I asked if I can just buy my own modem, they said that whenever there is a problem and you have your own modem, they will charge you a fee PER DEVICE that is connected (how would they even now if I use my own modem?). Quite overwhelming for me who just ALWAYS just buys and configures Fritz!Boxes anytime I need to setup a new internet connection somewhere. Here we have the richest country in the world, inventor of the internet with the most innovative tech companies with the absolute worst internet experience among developed countries: Overpriced, bad quality of service and zero flexibility. Customers are treated like absolute dummies, it is a totally different world. And Germany is actually quite bad compared to asian countries.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ssalazar 6y ago> Here we have the richest country in the world, inventor of the internet with the most innovative tech companies with the absolute worst internet experience among developed countries It makes sense when you consider that the US has a much higher resistance to business regulation and consumer protection- less overhead for innovative new businesses but also allowing entrenched interests to consolidate as much as they have.
- maxerickson 6y agoThe thing is, the company they are talking about is probably operating with regulatory monopoly over the lease/permission to run coax to homes. Here I can get high speed cable or crappy DSL and that's the options that exist for wired service. Both of them are incumbent regulatory monopolies.
- samstave 6y agoThe city of Alameda originally had municipal coax network throughout the island - but the city council voted to turn over control of the network to comcast - and they dont allow any municipal networks to be installed... I wonder who got bribed for that one?
- chiefalchemist 6y agoIf the fee is unavoidable (e.g., Verzion FIOS equipment) then it should be included in the advertised price. As it is, Verizon's tactics are closer to bait & switch. Adding $20 to $25 or more in proprietary equipment - with no opportunity to purchase - is shady. Sure, I can and do choose Comcast intead. But the pricing creates a false sense of price, competition, etc.
- xivzgrev 6y agoOne thing to call out is that if you buy your own router, you’re going to have a bad time getting internet connectivity issues fixed. Unless there is an outage in your area, your ISP will just blame your router. So it may be worth the extra cost just to hold them accountable and ensure reliable internet
- tjohns 6y agoAt least with Comcast Business, I never had this problem. I used my own modem and router, and the few times I had a line problem they just asked me to connect my laptop directly to the modem with an ethernet cable to troubleshoot.
- colechristensen 6y agoSame experience with comcast, I had connectivity problems a few times and there were no differences between when using their equipment and mine.
- jimmydddd 6y agoThis is 100% correct.
- ComputerGuru 6y agoIt’s not really just a “bottom drawer internet service” thing. Comcast rents me a Juniper switch for their metro Ethernet. I just consider it part of the price of the service. If they weren’t renting out the equipment, they’d just bump their prices up.
- colechristensen 6y agoThat’s not what this is about. This is about the few providers which charge you a fee for “rent” when you don’t have their equipment (which is absurd). I have owned my own equipment with at least half a dozen providers large and small and never had to pay this fee.