25 ms·
Cyberpunk 2077: How 2020’s biggest video game launch turned into a shambles
- gogopuppygogo 6y agoIt’s like No Mans Sky all over again, except with more human genitalia customization...
- kbar13 6y agofunny how cyberpunk's woes are basically the inverse of NMS lol... no man's sky's tech was mostly there, but there was no content. there's a good amount of story and voice acting in cyberpunk... but the tech to support it is extremely broken or not there.
- shash7 6y agoNo Man's Sky actually aged like fine wine with the updates they pushed over time. We still have to see what happens with CP2077.
- ehsankia 6y agoIf they do plan to milk the IP and eventually make a multiplayer for it, they need first to salvage this. I think I heard that they won't be planning the MP until 2022 or 2023, so I assume they'll be spending the next year at least fixing this up before working on the MP.
- gogopuppygogo 6y agoIf it's like Witcher 3 they will sell expansion packs to further monetize CP2077. I wouldn't hate this. I loved Witcher 3.
- Hamuko 6y agoNo Man's Sky has actually won a bunch of awards for an "ongoing game" now, most recently winning Best Ongoing Game at the Game Awards 2020, so maybe there's hope for Cyberpunk 2077 if they follow the same trajectory.
- torbital 6y agoFirst time looking at Cyberpunk 2077 stuff online, after having just beaten the game at ~50 hrs. Super surprised it's not being praised, it's certainly the best game singe-player I've ever played. I can't believe the reaction I am seeing.
- MacsHeadroom 6y agoPart of the reason is that it wasn't supposed to be a "beat the game" (linear) game in the first place. It was marketed as primarily "open world" with a largely optional main quest line. The problem is, if you play it that way (ignoring the main quests) it's pretty boring and repetitive real quick. Skyrim, GTA V, and Breath of the Wild set the bar for open world games and CP2077 was marketed as pushing the bar. It did not.
- Der_Einzige 6y agoYou can't fix this game like you can NMS though.
- throwaway189262 6y agoWhat hurts about CyberPunk is how well polished some parts are. The voice acting, story, and world are beautiful and polished. It's clear that they just didn't have time to implement like half the gameplay they promised. The result is a big beautiful and empty world with a linear path. There's little to do, and really little point to the huge open world. 90% of missions are inside buildings on foot. And the ones that aren't uniformly suck because vehicle mechanics and AI just isn't there
- yani 6y agoTo me, the voice did not match the way characters were moving. It seemed very unnatural and not polished. Quite a big diff in sync between audio and video on my end.
- woutr_be 6y agoI need to agree with you on this one, some of the NPCs throughout the story have terrible voice acting, but I can forgive it because they're a small part of the game. But the players' character is something that bothers me everything he speaks, it feels so emotionless, and often doesn't match the environment they're in.
- Hamuko 6y agoI haven't had too much to gripe about with the female player character voice acting thus far.
- BoorishBears 6y agoSomething I will never understand... your character never uses personal pronouns in reference to their self. And I don't mean gendered pronouns, just pronouns like "I" and "We". It seems none of the characters do. - Instead of: "I need to get lunch" It's: "Need to get lunch." - "We need to get in there, and we need to do it fast" "Need to get in there. Need to do it fast" - "I'm tryin' alright?" "Tryin' alright? - "I like chocolate" "Like chocolate" - It's even more grating when you add in the forced sounding "Gruff Guy" voice the male V uses. I don't know what kind of weird tough guy vibe they were going for but it's like nails on a chalkboard sometimes.
- 8f2ab37a-ed6c 6y agoLet's not forget about Anthem in that same club. Billboards and ads everywhere followed by massive disappointment.
- tus88 6y agoIt's nothing like Anthem. CP is a good game that was rushed out, Anthem was just bad.
- tdsamardzhiev 6y agoAgreed. Youtubers talk about the bad stuff in CP because that generates the most clicks, and people who haven’t played the game get the idea that it’s like Anthem. Meanwhile, most PC players are 20+ hours in (On average! In a week!) and having a blast.
- djhworld 6y agoThe big weight around their neck was releasing it on the last gen consoles. I suspect it wasn't that high on their priorities to optimise it on 7+ year old hardware. It's a tough one, maybe they could have bit the bullet early and said this will be a PS5/Xbox SX/PC release only, but hindsight is wonderful thing...
- pault 6y agoCurrent (last?) gen consoles were the original release target though. They started development before the new generation was even announced.
- tus88 6y agoExactly. The problem is simple - CP came out a year too early. It needed a LOT more play-testing and refinement. Unfortunately few studios/published take a true "it's done when it's done" approach.
- Hamuko 6y agoI'm not even sure why. Half-Life 2 was famously delayed by a ton and yet people don't really remember that - they just remember what a massive gaming milestone it was. The original release date was in September 2003 and it came out in October 2004 since it was so unfinished in 2003.
- leshokunin 6y agoFor a game to launch unfinished and to turn out disappointing is pretty common. Batman Arkham Asylum, Assassin's Creed Unity and No Man's Sky come to mind. Some even required full reboots, such as Final Fantasy XIV and the current work on Artifact and Anthem. What's different here is that this is the first that that a major release is getting delisted or refunded by all the major retailers. CD Project Red did not have a track record of thrashing, or shipping something half-baked. The Witcher 3's main game and DLC are among the most polished AAA releases ever, and great value for their price. This drove lots of people to be excited by Cyberpunk, since 2013. It's not just a story about crunch and unmet hype. It's a studio that simply let a lot of people down.
- shp0ngle 6y agoArkham Asylum was disappointing? The 2009 game? I thought it was universally loved
- TAForObvReasons 6y agoThe studio also refused to let reviewers comment on the console versions, which is where a lot of the anger is directed. So you have a bunch of gamers who went on the PS4 version based on what they were seeing from the PC alone, not knowing the state of the game. The reaction wouldn't have been as strong if people knew what they were getting before committing
- vinkelhake 6y agoPerformance on last gen aside, looking at the online reaction you'd get the idea that this game is a non-stop bugfest. Meanwhile, I'm just sitting here enjoying the hell out of this game. The world is absolutely beautifully realized, both inside the city and outside. The glitches I've encountered are of the "Bethesda" type and I haven't run into any game breaking bugs yet. I've probably spent around 25 hours in it so far, with a good chunk of that on side missions. Just like in The Witcher 3, some of the side missions are really good. This game is a solid 8 for me right now, and it'll only go up with patches. Playing on Series X fwiw.
- fossuser 6y agoI'm playing on the older Xbox One X (series X still impossible to find), but my experience is roughly the same. It's buggy, there are sometimes crashes/game breaking bugs, but the autosave makes recovery easy. The world and story are really good and make up for it.
- twiceaday 6y agoSame. 50 hours in on pc.
- PUSH_AX 6y agoA large part of the backlash is around unfinished systems. Without reeling off an exhaustive list the resulting world feels pretty soulless and shallow, it certainly feels like they released it far from being finished.
- BoorishBears 6y agoI've taken the liberty to reel off said list in the past https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25468522 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25468522 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25471233 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25471233
- SZJX 6y agoWell said. I simply don’t understand the amount of people defending the gameplay/story/“open world” here on HN while it’s receiving scathing reviews on Steam and Metacritic. Maybe game players actually more casual here than on those game-centric platforms?
- chrysoprace 6y agoIt's interesting that it's getting so much media attention, considering many other AAA titles had a much worse release. Even when Assassin's Creed Unity was released, there were some seriously game-breaking bugs in that game and unlike CyberPunk it wasn't removed from stores (so far as I was aware), but now stores are actively removing the game and refunding purchases. I won't defend the game, but it's interesting to see the correlation with how hyped people were for a game, and the magnified reception when issues were encountered.
- Narishma 6y agoMaybe trying to hide the poor state of the game on consoles before launch has something to do with it.
- chrysoprace 6y agoAnd Ubisoft didn't? I'm not excusing either company, but it seems the reaction this time has scaled in proportion to how hyped people were for the game. This is the first time I've heard of vendors pulling a big AAA game from their stores and offering refunds immediately.
- Narishma 6y ago> And Ubisoft didn't? I don't think so. Unless I missed something.
- robswc 6y agoI feel the "reaction" is over blown. Especially when I see what some people complain about. There's tons of legitimate criticism, pretty much pertaining to bugs but damn... I remember Skyrim being just as "buggy" but I don't recall the reaction being nearly as bad. I'm bias though as I've played on PC and had a phenomenal experience. Last gen players should 100% get a refund. Beyond that though, I just don't see it. There's some other viable critisim but when I weigh that against what the game is I just don't get it. Its objectively the most detailed city in a first person action/RPG. It objectively has the most detailed quests:quantity. I can excuse the bugs... again though, talking from a PC experience with 0 real bugs. I can see how it would be annoying with bugs but I've played GTA and Skyrim, I can survive them lol
- houseofzeus 6y agoI really think it's mostly the issues with having advertized it for last gen consoles and then not actually delivered a playable experience on them. It sounds like there are indeed a lot of other bugs, but those seem like issues they would have been permitted to patch their way out of over time. COD Cold War is another big title this year and is quite buggy, but it is playable in spite of those bugs on all the systems it was advertised to work on.
- _dibly 6y ago> Its objectively the most detailed city in a first person action/RPG. It objectively has the most detailed quests:quantity. Sure, it's gorgeous and the on-rails scripted side-quests are fantastically written and animated, but driving around the city just makes me realize how empty it all feels because only the handful of vendors actually programmed to have an inventory are capable of interacting with you. But then on the other hand, they didn't animate half of the immersive shit you actually can do, like buying a drink from a bartender. It feels like a game that wants to be an immersive sim, but the second you try to immerse yourself in it you realize that it's just a massive facade.
- a_wild_dandan 6y agoThis is far and away the biggest letdown of 2077 for me. There's no emergent gameplay. The world is simply a beautiful aquarium filled with schools of mindless, swimming NPCs. Think about the rich interactions in Skyrim: you arrive in the town of Whiterun. Your inventory is full of junk so you drop some. A beggar picks up a discarded sword and excitedly asks you if he can keep it. Just as you say yes, a brood of vampires attacks! Peasants run for the hills, but your new friend and the nearby blacksmith joins your side and smashes them to bits with her majestic warhammer! The fight resolved, you decide you want that warhammer. So you wait for her to end her shift, head home, and fall asleep. In the dead of night, you steal into her home and snatch it for yourself. But her husband was awake and saw your robbery! The guards are alerted! You escape town with your life, but just barely. You decide to sleep off your wounds in a bedroll outside of town. But when you wake up, your eyes glow! You have fangs! You've become a vampire! So you decide... I could go on. (Hell, I probably went on too long there.) Point being, Skyrim is flush with these unique experiences. Given CDPR's claims, I really, really hoped we'd get at least a few mechanics for unique encounters. But the world CDPR created is a beautiful corpse.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- antfarm 6y agoSeems like overworking your developers to meet a deadline is not such a good idea after all. What a surprise! https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-09-29/cyberpunk-2077-publisher-orders-6-day-weeks-ahead-of-game-debut https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-09-29/cyberpunk...
- ghoomketu 6y agoDoes anyone know what kind of sales revenue this game has generated? I'm not a gamer but this is the only game I've heard off recently that has not only taken over my news feeds, hn, reddit, youtube and it was also on TV last night. I haven't seen so much media coverage (good or bad) for a game like this before personally. Is all this bad publicity actually working out for them eventually? I know they are apologizng and everything but at the end of the day it's just a business and so is synonymous with sales.. when the dust settles was it a winner or a loser?
- Hamuko 6y agoRevenue is kinda hard to estimate at this point when CD Projekt, Sony and Microsoft have opened up pretty generous refund policies for the game and with Sony stopping the digital sales entirely. CD Projekt said in an investor call that they would probably not disclose how much they lost in refunds.
- cromka 6y agoI listened to it and ai clearly remember this second or third question, which they answered to by saying they couldn't just tell yet, because it was too early – they only had begun issuing refunds a few days before the call and didn't actually see the numbers. This also isn't something they can withhold as a publicly traded company.
- Hamuko 6y ago>Q7: Thanks for that and regarding refunds – there’s no chance that the market will receive an update on the volume or number of refunds before the sales report around Christmas, yes? >AK: We don’t know yet. Before Christmas we will release sales numbers, but in terms of refunds – we’re not sure if we’ll share this information outside of the company.
- joveian 6y ago"Cyberpunk 2077 has likely already paid for itself. In a memo issued Friday [Dec 11], CD Projekt — the parent company of developer CD Projekt Red — said that its revenue from digital pre-order sales alone exceeds all of Cyberpunk 2077’s production costs and all of the company’s marketing and promotional costs for the game this year." https://www.polygon.com/2020/12/11/22170468/cyberpunk-2077-sales-revenue-cd-projekt https://www.polygon.com/2020/12/11/22170468/cyberpunk-2077-s... CDPR said they had 8 million preorders, and Steamspy is saying 10-20 million copies sold on Steam alone. The game industry has been growing quite quickly the past decade so it maybe isn't that surprising that they are certainly in the top 50 best selling games of all time already and could be in the top 20. It seems likely they will make quite a lot of money even with issues. Sony has a new more capable system to sell anyone disappointed with the performance of the old one so I'm thinking they will do quite well also and both of them are just playing up the issues for free media attention. The game industry is strange, buy at release and you usually get a low quality product. Wait a year and not only will it work much better but you have a good chance of getting it 50% off as well.
- l33tman 6y agoI went through this, as I tried the game first on my Windows 7 PC (it had stated support for Win7). Crashfest. After I upgraded to the latest Windows 10, latest Nvidia drivers etc. I've played 40 hours without a single crash or bug. Its an amazing game, so incredibly detailed. I guess they should have done a lot more testing on consoles though before releasing on them.
- davidkuhta 6y agoHere's to wishing Cyberpunk 2077 a 'V' shaped recovery.
- dkarlovi 6y agoI love puns and this one was excellent, thanks for the chuckle.
- Bakary 6y agoIronically there's something pretty cyberpunk about all this, from the angry reactions to the development hiccups to the description of the bugs themselves
- 1-6 6y agoTwo words: Overpromised, Underdelivered
- willis936 6y agoUnderbaked, underproved.
- EugeneOZ 6y agoI hope CD Project Red devs are reading HN today. I want them to hear: if you feel that the whole world is against you - it's not true. Many people are silently enjoying the game and you will not hear as much from them as from the whiners exactly because of this - they have nothing to whine about. For me, this game already took the place in my personal Hall of Fame: next to Oblivion, Red Dead Redemption 2, and GTA SA. Thank you! And you should know: you’ve proved that you are professionals. Don't let your managers make you answer for their promises. Don't feel guilty, you should be proud actually.
- pier25 6y agoThe main issue is not that people aren't enjoying the game, but that CDPR outright lied with their marketing videos.
- EugeneOZ 6y agoI still don't think that marketing videos is the developers’ fault.
- pier25 6y agoCDPR didn't produce and publish those videos?
- dharmab 6y agoCDPR is made up of developers, artists, QA staff, managers, marketers, a board of executives and other roles. Journalism reports and publicly available call transcripts are painting a picture of internal conflict between the creators and leadership. In this context, “developers” means the creative roles within CDPR.
- deadbunny 6y agoDevelopers as in the people writing code? Sure. Developers as in the company developing the game? Absolutely.
- some1else 6y agoInteresting to contrast the outcome with discussions under the Unity S-1[1] and similar threads. Some engineers outside of AAA game dev complain that certain core tenets of software engineering are hard to come by in Unity & Unreal projects, while insiders claim that the kinds of stringent quality controls being proposed are untenable, and in themselves demonstrate a profound misunderstanding of how things work in the industry. Could a launch-flop like Cyberpunk 2077 cause the pendulum to swing the other way? 1: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24261559 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24261559
- jrimbault 6y agoIn that vein, keybindings are again a trouble point in CB2077 like it was for Witcher 3. And I wonder that can be ? From a complete ignoramus to VG programming, but not to programming in general, that seems like a really easy already solved problem, and certainly it is compared to the really hard problems VG run into. No hard coded values, swapable config objects, that seems like easy good practices ? I'd really appreciate some perspective on this from someone who knows ?
- b0rsuk 6y agoThere's a rumor on a Polish website that CP2077 underwent a major plot overhaul in the middle of development. According to this hypothesis, supported by some early quotes, there were initially going to be 3 mentor characters to choose from: Johnny Silverhand (tech solutions, tech weapons), Morgan Blackhand (handguns?, power weapons), Saburo Arasaka (Hacking, smart weapons) It is said that 2018 e3 gameplay presentation featured the choice of mentors. Then Keanu Reeves turned up. Eventually the marketing team had a brilliant idea to get more out of Keanu. And since he's so awesome, why not make the game MORE about Keanu... In fact, why waste budget and manpower on the other 2 actors? This type of problem with high profile actors is endemic in movie industry. A movie with Bruce Willis or Ryan Gosling will be about Bruce Willis and Ryan Gosling. The actors don't have to even act that well because plot will be adjusted to play into their strengths.(Look how much screen time aging Bruce Willis got in Looper and the new Blade Runner!) (polish) https://www.wykop.pl/link/5853285/czy-rola-keanu-reevsa-jest-jednym-ze-zrodel-problemow-w-cyberpunku2077/ https://www.wykop.pl/link/5853285/czy-rola-keanu-reevsa-jest... There are various speculations in the thread, including that the game is so lacking in its systems (police, NPC schedules, driving...) because they were ordered to cut them out. They were meant to be in the game initially, but major direction shifts in the development meant they had to reassign developers to something else. Some content in the game seems to support this line of thinking. There's a quest with a monk that works slightly differently depending on which story act you're in. There are some hints that developers really wanted to make a great game, but were gaslighted and bullshitted by the management. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-12-18/cyberpunk-game-maker-faces-hostile-staff-after-failed-launch https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-12-18/cyberpunk... ---------- If you want to know my opinion, I think CDPR also overestimated their ability. A modern, urban world works very differently than fantasy sword game. CDPR had 3 games to perfect the formula, then they jumped into completely different setting. I don't blame them, in fact I feel for them because it's nice to work on something different once in a while.
- pier25 6y ago> I think CDPR also overestimated their ability Totally agree. Third person combat wasn't amazing on the Witcher 3, after 3 games polishing those mechanics. Then suddenly CDPR thought they could pull off a FPS with stealth, open world, driving, hacking, etc. They simply needed more time.
- b0rsuk 6y agoMarketing hype backfired. People are angry not just because the game was released buggy and unoptimized (although maybe standards are higher on consoles in this aspect). People are angry because they were promised a groundbreaking game, a landmark game, and got an unremarkable mix of Deus Ex and GTA. Except for raytracing, there's nothing exceptional about this game. No new mechanics even. I watched the disaster from sidelines, but what makes me angry is that the hype was so strong it made gamers fight each other, blame each other, and make excuses for the company. Gamers are not to blame for the game except for the fact they preordered. The deceptive behavior was rewarded and costs were recouped from preorders alone. Yes, CDPR is taking a reputation hit, but fans will believe what they want to believe.
- mattnewton 6y agoI think the hype was part of the problem, but the developers focus on the game might be the bigger issue. It's hard to me to say from the outside if the hype caused the lack of focus or vice versa, or was just an aggregating factor, but after beating it (and having a blast), I think it would have been better to release only some of the ideas with more polish. The game was extremely well written in my opinion, the gunplay was good, sneaking worked and combat reasonably executed. As a result, the linear parts worked well, but it has a smattering of rough open world mechanics tacked on, just enough to draw comparisons to gta (which are all very unfavorable), and many rough edges around core gameplay things like vehicle driving, enemy ai, and scripted events triggering out of order / not triggering at all. And that's assuming you are playing on pc, and not a console brought to it's knees every hour. My diagnosis is that it feels designed by committee with no one willing to make deep cuts, and as a result suffered from trying to be everything ever marketed to everyone, and ended shipping all the ideas both late and unfinished. They seemingly had no time to polish the core of the game because it was too big.
- pier25 6y agoI agree the writing is exceptional. But other than that, all gameplay aspects are mediocre or even poor. Gunplay, stealth, hacking, driving, etc, have been made much better in games even 10 years older than Cyberpunk. And let's not forget about the outright lies in all the marketing videos. CDPR promised many features which are nowhere to be seen, even on videos that were released weeks before the final release date.
- pier25 6y agoI played about 14 hours on PC before uninstalling it. The performance was fine and I had minor glitches here and there. The story bits were simply amazing, but the gameplay needed another year or two of development. This is clearly an unfinished game and most of the promised features are not in the game. I reinstalled Deus Ex Mankind Divided and the tutorial level has better gameplay (gunplay, stealth, hacking) than Cyberpunk. I will certainly revisit it in a year or two. Hopefully CDPR will keep on improving the gameplay, not only solve bugs and performance on consoles.
- mabbo 6y agoMaybe I'll reach that point, but honestly, apart from a couple of asset glitches now and then, I'm loving the game. The story is solid, the voice acting great, the gameplay is pretty darned good. I don't see what has everyone so upset I guess.
- pier25 6y ago> I don't see what has everyone so upset I guess. In part it's because many people (me included) think the execution of the gameplay is poor. And the other major part is that the game simply did not deliver the promised features on all the marketing videos by CDPR.
- fossuser 6y ago> And the other major part is that the game simply did not deliver the promised features on all the marketing videos by CDPR. Like what? I keep seeing this, but nobody is being specific about it. I’m genuinely curious.
- d3nj4l 6y agoThere's a whole thread full of them on reddit[1]. I encourage going through the linked threads in the post, a lot of the details are crucial, and the sources for the "promise" are damning. 1: https://www.reddit.com/r/cyberpunkgame/comments/kcve8s/promised_but_missing_feature_list_will_update/ https://www.reddit.com/r/cyberpunkgame/comments/kcve8s/promi...
- muro 6y agoWorks very well on Stadia. Didn't expect this game would make a case for Google's streaming platform. Now if Google were so kind to add ray tracing to make it look as good as on a RTX 3080 :)
- banjomet 6y agoCan we talk about the AI? Why is the AI so bad? From driving, to police not being able to chase you in cars, to spawning randomly. Does the game use Lua or a scripting language for the AI? If not, I think that would easily explain the problems, as it seems like so much behavior of the NPCs was never iterated on.
- jhloa2 6y agoThis is my main complaint. What's the point of having an open world if there's no mechanics. I can shoot a cop in the face and walk half a block a way and they'll just give up.
- cbozeman 6y agoYeah but in fairness, if you just stare at the cops too long in this game, they'll shoot you. So I don't mind breaking out the monowire and fucking up every single one of them - even MaxTac - until they give up. Which is also funny... lop the heads off about 8 patrol officers and 4 MaxTac enforcers, and the cops get the message.
- Ardren 6y agoIMO it's just placeholder stuff from earlier in development that management didn't think was worth finishing. Driver AI? Let's just assign them a route to follow to see how it looks, we'll worry about real AI later. Police AI? Just give them gang member AI (shot on site, aggressive when looking at them) until we can do a better pass. Wanted System? Just spawn in mobs to something happens when the player gets a wanted star. We'll sort the real system when Driver AI and Police AI is finished. Etc. Etc.
- dopu 6y agoThe game is great on PC, and sure there are some bugs, but nothing catastrophic. I've been playing the game on GeForce Now and I was pretty amazed with how much game streaming tech has progressed since it was first introduced. There's something amazing about playing Cyberpunk on my mac mini with ultra settings and ray tracing on. Latency's not even noticeable if you have a good connection!
- johnjungles 6y agoThis. Was an early adopter of GeForce now and now on stadia because of the free controller with a cyberpunk purchase. Can say streaming is the future. Looking forward to Mighty and other cool companies doing something awesome
- sitzkrieg 6y agomaybe for single player games only
- sidibe 6y agoDoubt it. It's hard to tell the difference between console and streaming (I'll believe harder core gamers can still tell, but I can't). As streaming grows the servers will be closer and closer to the user. Already the main source of latency is not in the networking, and definitely not in the speed of light.
- temac 6y agoOne of a common modern thought about how to be successful when software is involved, is to favor time-to-market, ship first and patch later. That in a good number of areas bugs are said to not really matter that much because you gonna have some, so why not having some more so that you can sooner have something instead of nothing. One of the sector where this can arguably be applied the most is videogames. Nobody dies in real-life, nor has their data stolen, when a video game crashes (esp. a single player one). Or when the polygons are sometimes all over the place. Or when characters randomly T-pose pantless on their motorcycle for 2s. Or when scared NPC just disappear when out of your field of view. Well actually this is a reminder that enough is enough, and that garbage is garbage, and not a sign of success nor wisdom. And don't even get me started on the consequences of this attitude for people doing the real work. Would CDPR codebase be more easy to improve right now if management had not imposed this failed launch after repeatedely telling plain lies during months? I don't know, but from my experience this is likely. Maybe on some axis the operation will have some net temporary positive results, but in the long run this is just a complete disaster: the reputation and trust that permitted such many pre-orders in the first place is likely broken for years. This will also affect other important things for their business: current or prospect employees might be less likely to want to work there. This is also a reminder of how fragile the value brought by giant digital stores is, (if it is even net positive, considering your own priorities). Between Sony and MS selling unreviewed garbage to their clients, GoG refusing games for political reasons, and concerned digital stores commonly leveraging (abusing?) being for a specific hardware platform for imposing partial (only possible digital store) or total (if the only possible digital store is the only possible way to install software) monopolies for said platform with completely arbitrary and changing rules, sometimes even fighting local consumer protection laws, one might think carefully if the positive things that remain, if any, are worth it. The current overall situation may not be in the interest of the developers, and even less so of the users. At least I consider it not being in my interest.
- vasilakisfil 6y agoI have been playing this game in Google Stadia since last week and it has been mostly a joy. It has crashed 2 times, but that's all the bugs I have encounter. My only complain about the game is the npc AI is pretty low, but then you can always treat it as an arcade rpg fps kinda game. In any case I have been enjoying it a lot.
- corytheboyd 6y agoSo far to me this game is a slightly better than average shooter with some shallow RPG and stealth elements. I’ve been a gamer most of my life, learned my lesson about hype a long time ago, but also just don’t assign as much importance to games in general as much anymore. I hope they continue to improve the game, now that it’s just out there it will be easier to fix? Or maybe CDPR should just give up and hand over mod tools so at least the PC community can create the game they wanted for themselves. Sorry, not a spicy take, but there are enough of those :P
- tnli 6y agoEh, I'll buy it from a discount sale in two to four years if they've fixed all the bugs. Don't do this, though, I need you to buy it fresh so that new games continue to be made.
- jds375 6y agoEvery single hacker news thread about the Cyberpunk fiasco has had a ton of top comments about they haven’t had any issues with the game. Performance/bugs aside, what about the completeness issues? How can the game be acceptable or fun when cars run on tracks and NPC’s don’t have a problem being attacked? That’s my main concern - I’m sure the performance/bugs will be worked out. But will the game actually be finished?
- tracer4201 6y agoI haven’t played the game and don’t play video games too often, so my thoughts here perhaps sound naive. “NPCs not having a problem being attacked” and “cars running on tracks” could be intentional design choices, right? We can speculate that the game’s feature set is unfinished, but is it also not possible that this video game in its “finished” state just isn’t what people wanted it to be? Clearly there are bugs and I agree the product right now isn’t finished, but once any glitches and performance issues are fixed, I’m not sure if the gameplay will ever meet expectations. Edit: not sure of why I have -5 points.
- cbozeman 6y agoNo. The game is simply not finished. The problem with creating a huge open-world game and then stating in all your promotional material that this, "will be the most immersive open-world game we've ever created" means that it has to surpass, at a minimum, The Witcher 3. However, you paint yourself into an even worse corner with that, because everyone's going to compare you to Grand Theft Auto series as well when you use the phrase "open-world game". And that's a real titan to go up against. Its clearly obvious this game needed a bare minimum of 6 more months of development, if to do nothing more than fix just the bugs. But it really needs about 12-18 months of development just to add the features they claimed the game would have at launch.
- tracer4201 6y agoSaying it’s the most “immersive open world game” is just marketing speak. Unless they promised a specific feature, it’s hard to say much. I’m not arguing that it’s not a finished game, so don’t get me wrong. I’m just saying that people assumed this was going to be the perfect video game. It’s clearly not, and performance/glitches aside, I’m not convinced of why everyone seems so surprised it’s not.
- benlivengood 6y agoWhat I'm really looking forward to is the modding community. A game about cyberpunk hacking and bodymods can only be enhanced by customization. What the communities have done with Oblivion, Skyrim, and Fallout series is amazing and I am sure we'll see some very good mods for 2077.
- b0rsuk 6y agoThe mere fact that CP2077 is still called 2020's biggest game launch is a testament to how much overhyped the game was. Biggest by what measure? Nah. Most marketed.
- cbozeman 6y agoI really do feel bad for CDPR in a sense, because people have been waiting on this game for 7 years now. Hell, I actually forgot the Announcement Trailer released in 2013, a full two years before The Witcher III. That said, they probably needed either another 30-50 people working on the game from the start, or they needed another 2-3 years to totally flesh the game out, which in reality is what happened with The Witcher III. The last patch for that game was released in 2018. To build a huge city from the ground up is a monumental task. Rockstar already has a lot of assets from earlier GTA games available. CDPR had to do this all from scratch. I think a Cyberpunk 2077 II will be a fantastic game in 5 or 6 years.
- b0rsuk 6y ago> I think a Cyberpunk 2077 II will be a fantastic game in 5 or 6 years. Assuming you can patch the missing systems back without disrupting the game balance and stuff. Will the voice actors hang around forever to modify plot lines? The game doesn't react much to your actions. Assuming unfinished systems even make sense in broader context and will interact nicely when fleshed out. If you make civilians properly panic and run away, or call police, won't that break some quests? How many cases do you have to handle in a quest if NPCs start wandering around?
- jokoon 6y agoStill waiting it to turn in a No Man's Sky, I hope? I guess agile methods are just leaking into game development, and it means games cannot really have a release date anymore. Anyway as always, ambitious game visuals must die and leave room for creative gameplay. Of course there is a market for visuals, but the AAA game market with their burned-out crunch time developers, high costs etc, will keep having trouble, to the joy of the many independent game developers who want to get the money blockbusters are getting.
- Hamuko 6y ago>it means games cannot really have a release date anymore. Well, if Cyberpunk 2077 is proving anything, it's that release dates matter. Especially if it's too soon.
- willis936 6y agoWhen I was working with agile I would hear about “minimum viable product”. If Cyberpunk is the victim of bad management a la agile, then the stakeholders clearly don’t understand what a “minimum viable product” looks like. MBAs can’t bend reality.
- oijk 6y agoI think culture plays a huge factor in the way we develop software in general, not just games. Things like how acceptable we see overpromising features in software, or cutting corners or delivering unfinished products, etc. Take the contrast between AAA Japanese games and western games for example. Japanese games are often less ambitious and the scope is smaller but the final product is generally way more polished. The shitshow that is currently going on with Cyberpunk (or back in the day with the mentioned No Man's Sky) would be unthinkable in a FromSoftware or Nintendo game for example. The people at these studios probably go through a good amount of crap as well, but the end product is just so remarkably different. I remember playing Persona 5 on PS3 and the experience was just great. There were obvious visual differences with the PS4 version, but I think the game was just as enjoyable from day one. In the end, some companies have a minimum standard for quality and adhere to it, while others just straight up lie and deceive and have this toxic "anything goes" culture. It's unfortunate that we as consumers still reward the latter kind.
- philipov 6y agoI saw a stream today where they were sponsored to play Cyberpunk. It reminded me to refund the game.
- xwdv 6y agoI hope someone makes an open-world demake of Cyberpunk 2077.
- DevKoala 6y agoThis is the best game I have played in perhaps a decade. There is dozens of bugs, but nothing big enough to break my enjoyment.
- fullshark 6y agoThis doesn't seem to explain how this happened at all, just a rundown of what has happened so far. One thing I'm curious about is how much possible shelter in place / remote working could have impacted this launch. I know on my job, a lot of decisions are made due to inertia and processes that were built when we all could collaborate in person. Feels like there's a degredation in performance but it is not perceptible fully and without in person collaboration we are unable to course correct when absolutely necessary. Note I have no idea what it was like to work on this game post COVID and i'm merely speculating!
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- alkonaut 6y agoThis is still a game with typical 9/10 scores. The PC release doesn’t seem buggier than comparable titles. The last-gen console version obviously wasn’t finished but someone on some level of management still decided that a Christmas release of a buggy game on ps4 was still more important than a release of it in spring and just a pc/ps5 release of a decent game for Christmas.
- willis936 6y ago>This is still a game with typical 9/10 scores. This says far more about the games industry and journalist incest than it does the game itself.
- alkonaut 6y agoDon’t preorder games. In fact don’t even order games, until they are a few months old. Now is when you should be eyeing the releases from the holiday 2019 season.
- enneff 6y agoRight?!? There’s no scarcity at all, now that we have digital distribution. No reason at all to preorder.
- christophilus 6y agoExcept for Nintendo 1st party games. The stache has never let me down.
- drummer 6y agoNight City is beautiful, it just deserves much better AI.
- dschuetz 6y agoCyberpunk without cyberspace is not cyberpunk. It's just punk.
- hfkldjsjfkdj 6y agoKeyword: Wait.
- ab-dm 6y agoGranted I'm playing on PC, but I'm 25 hours in and having an absolute blast, and just like the Witcher 3, I'm having more and more fun the further in I get. Great fun, phenomenal graphics and seems well optimized, It's one of 2 flat-screen games to really keep my interest this year (doom eternal being the other). I think it helped that I didn't really keep up with the hype train, I just watched a few trailers and bought it. Based on that, It's been great.
- bozzcl 6y agoSame experience, 37 hours in. I have a friend who"s 64 hours into the game (he just finished his Ph.D. presentation, so it's a deserved distraction) and he's enjoying it just as much. TBH, even the pretty prevalent bugs are almost "quirky", to the point I've only run into two situations where a bug had gotten on the way of the fun. It's a shame the last-gen consoles are getting such a bad experience.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Razengan 6y agoSo Sony removed Cyberpunk 2077 from the PlayStation Store because it ran like crap and CD Projekt Red did not give refunds to players. THIS is why curated stores are a good thing. You'll almost never see actual users whining about the App Store; usually the complaints about "walled gardens" are from the companies and devs who prey upon users and would love to have a free reign. Too many times I had a shitty experience with an app or service I paid for and Apple refunded me without question, but I've almost always had to fight an uphill battle to get a refund directly from developers/publishers (currently against Couchsurfing, whose app bypasses the standard In-App Purchase system).
- iancmceachern 6y ago"A late game is only late until it ships. A bad game is bad until the end of time" - Shigeru Miyamoto
- nootropicat 6y agoEh I played about 100h on pc and it's great. Bugs were very minor for me. Ai really sucks though and netrunner build is absurdly OP. Once you get suicide and cyberpsychosis + deck that spreads ultimate hacks to two enemies, you turn into a death god, remotely forcing people to kill themselves. Every fight turns into breach->suicide->suicide->suicide at which point all nearby enemies are likely to be dead. Suicide hack really shouldn't be in the game, or at least make it so that netrunners can protect allies and can't be suicided. At first it's fun but gets boring.
- morlockabove 6y agoPC users, wheat from chaff Hoist up roger high and laugh! Never more than ten bucks pay, for Same damn game as yesterday
- ninkendo 6y agoI played through the first 7 hours or so on PC, and, meh, the bugs aren't that bad. The performance is fine, but I'm on a RTX 3080 so that's to be expected. What gets me is how utterly boring games have become. There's not really much of a game to even be played here. There's lots of talking, lots of sections where the characters are doing things and you end up pressing F to engage some action that continues the, erm, "action" to the next section. There are parts where you press W to get out of a pile of rubble (which engages the prescripted animation of your character getting out of the rubble) or "W or S to crawl", where S doesn't do anything and W makes your character continue his prescripted crawling animation. Press F to take your pills and watch your character perform his prescripted pill-taking action, etc etc etc. The actual gameplay is very nearly nonexistent in the first 7 hours. It's just about 98% thinly-veiled cutscenes, where the only say you have in the "action" is pressing a button to make the characters continue to do the thing they're already going to do. Or picking dialog and listening to dialog. With maybe 5 minutes of really mediocre gunplay mixed in. I don't really see how people have the patience for this. None of this is fun, none of this is engaging. None of this is high-quality enough storytelling to be as good as even the worst B-movie dialog and exposition. If I want to watch scenes where characters act out dialog and action happens, literally any movie would be better than this. I play games because I want to take part in what's going on. I don't want to watch someone else do it. But, I recognize that I'm in the minority here, and most people would rank this game 10/10 if they had the right frame rate and didn't have any bugs. Because I guess people like this sort of thing now. Meanwhile I think modern gaming has just about lost me for good. (Until I remember that Doom Eternal came out this year and that it's hands down one of the best games I've ever played, and I remember there's still hope for gaming.)
- martinesko36 6y agoJust curious, can you recommend games that are pure fun gameplay?
- jrpt 6y agoI haven't tried Doom Eternal but it sounds like he's looking for a story-rich, choices-matter game, like The Wolf Among Us, or Life is Strange, or these tags on Steam: https://store.steampowered.com/search/?tags=1742,6426 https://store.steampowered.com/search/?tags=1742,6426 (People really liked Disco Elysium but I didn't much)
- Ninjinka 6y agoI liked the game at first, despite not being able to play it on high settings with my 1070, but today I couldn't launch the game no matter what I tried.I made a copy of my save files, took advantage of their return offer, and will get it again once it's fixed. But I'm not letting them keep my $60 until then.
- shmerl 6y agoIncumbent consoles are really holding the whole industry back.
- ribs 6y agoNot much of a “how” here in this article; little attempt at insight.
- hans0l074 6y agoI have been playing on the PS4 Pro (approx. 10 hours) and so far my experience has been good. Yes, there were one or two glitches - a character walking into the elevator through closed doors, one or two disappearing cars - which can break immersion, I get it, but I have seen such things in a lot of other games at launch. I wonder as a developer myself, why aren't these obvious things not fixed by the studios? Is it so that they are just at the bottom of the "todo" pile? There is a LOT in the game just from the point of view of skills, perks, cybermods and whatnot. And the second patch (another ~18GB one) just arrived last night for the EU region. I hope this will be a great game in a few months and attract new players. I did read some articles about "lack of depth" and "wonky AI" and the way these pieces were written did make me feel uncomfortable - I'll see how I feel myself before judging the game too harshly.
- rishabhd 6y agoBefore the dawn of the DLC/ patching, a release like this wouldn’t even be possible no matter how hyped it was. Games would be delayed, but releasing a broken mess would be a cardinal sin since nothing could patch it once it was on disc.
- progfix 6y agoI hope they treat it like No Man's Sky and not like Anthem. They promised a multiplayer next year so that makes me hope they keep updating it the next couple of years.
- SZJX 6y agoTechnical issues aside, the story has also been criticized as being shallow and of little substance. The most critically acclaimed open world games e.g. RDR2, Horizon Zero Dawn etc. have very deep and intriguing stories while maintaining the world as “open” as possible. Even the Witcher is another example. Cyberpunk sounds like a case of massive overhyping and under delivering. Some fanboys here and there are unwilling to face the reality, but most reviews I’ve read seem to be sober and corroborate the above point.
- ck425 6y agoReally? I've heard nothing but good stuff story wise though I've deliberately avoided spoilers.
- raws 6y agoThey set themselves up for failure when they teased a release date for the game of when it would be "ready" 7 years ago.
- skilled 6y agoThe game lacks smooth open-world interaction. My immersion was instantly ruined when I realized how static the world is when you drive around. Likewise, AI is completely underdeveloped and I was under the impression that it would be more interactive. Other than that, the graphics are good. Story is somewhat good but lacks in general progression for each life path.
- pgt 6y agoThis feels like a Reverse Streisand Effect. I've heard more about this game than any other game launch because of the bugs + people on HN and Twitter saying it's cool, and now I want to play it.
- dharma1 6y agoI’m playing it on PC (3900x and 1080ti) and it’s really detailed and beautiful. The plot is a bit confusing and the NPC stuff pretty rigid. This game would be amazing as an online multiplayer game, and possibly with VR support for full immersion. It’s really beautiful
- myko 6y agoThe game is incredibly good. It must have some serious issues on consoles to get this bad press.
- edem 6y agoI think [these][0] two [guys][1] pretty much nailed both sides of the same coin. [0]:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ws9nljEbBhs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ws9nljEbBhs [1]:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eymHKA7vncc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eymHKA7vncc
- gnrlst 6y agoStadia offers a 10 EUR OFF voucher for your first game when signing up for a Pro 30 day trial. Until a couple days ago, they also had a Cyberpunk special promotion that upon purchase of the game you also got Stadia Premiere edition bundle (Chromecast Ultra + Stadia Controller) for free. Moral of the story, for 50 euros I got: - Cyberpunk, - a 30 day Stadia Pro subscription, - A chromecast Ultra - A stadia controller I'm blown away by the quality of Stadia, and the fact that Cyberpunk is running super smooth and did not experience almost any glitches / bugs. Loving both the game and the platform.
- compscistd 6y agoI regret not jumping on this offer (expired two days ago)
- markbnj 6y agoI'm a Steam addict and don't do Stadia, but I have a chromecast ultra and I'm on love with that thing.
- sor1nmarkov 6y agoWorking rather nicely on Stadia.
- dynamite-ready 6y agoI've been somewhat weary of this kind of approach to videogame development for a while now. You could possibly say that it's a function of the current size of the market. But the demand for videogames was always dynamically tied to the quality of the product. The EA update of Sim City was quite a memorable event of a similar class. My personal bugbear was Street Fighter 5. Duke Nuke Forever, and also, possibly Daikatana, were truly legendary death marches. With these commercial failures in mind, The Last Guardian is actually something of a Sydney Opera House - esque miracle. Especially with the purported performance boost it gains on PS5. A bit of a rambling rant. I hope they have a chance to fix Cyberpunk though, because this result sounds like a team of ambitious artists were bullied into rushing their work.
- dynamite-ready 6y agoMakes me wonder about the link between critical acclaim, commercial success, and production time. Apparently, Avatar 2 has been in production for 13 years..
- sharonmike211 6y agoHis effective powerful prayers brought my lover back just in 24 hours....... He has solution to all relationship/marriage problem and health issues such as herpes…? ???????????? ??? ??? ?? Robinson.buckler @ ‘ ‘ yahoo ‘ ‘ . ‘ ‘ com !!!!!!! Thank you!!!!!!!
- tonfreed 6y agoI can't help but think the media is getting on a hatetrain here, I've not really heard anything bad beyond some hilarious glitches from the people I know playing it. Journos have had it in for this game since they realised that, in a game where literally everyone is sexualised, trans people were sexualised.
- DanielleMolloy 6y agoPeople who preorder games aren’t the brightest, and may not have the best self-control. Remember those death threats? Part of the reason for the review bombings of the recent past is that those same people will write the first user “reviews”. Almost none of the user “reviews” I’ve seen in the beginning seemed to have any thought about the writing, which is the main mission of CDPR. It was all complaints about graphics and bugs. It is like a backlash for the industry that started to milk people who would preorder. (Not trying to excuse CDPRs action to push this game out on base consoles no matter what of course.)
- dusted 6y ago"adolescent tone and its eagerness to objectify women’s bodies", "or the game was crashing so often that it was barely playable. Several scenes were reported to have caused epileptic seizures" This is why we can't have nice things. Stuck up snides, sub-par hardware and a small subset of people with a terrible disability. I'm not blaming epileptics, but is it really fair that _EVERYONE ALWAYS_ must adapt? Sure, an option to turn off those effects would be nice, but I'm sure we will just all have to do without them. I am blaming last-gen support, and probably current-gen too, actually, I'm blaming CDPR for trying to support it in the first place. Just concentrate on making an awesome game on PC, and no, it does not have to run on a 2 year old potato, be cutting edge, set system requirements for tomorrows most high-end gear, if that's what it takes to realize the vision, hardware will catch up. Back in the day, DOS games were released that didn't run well on anything when they came out, but they turned out to be among the absolute best games of their time! (Carmageddon as an example, came out in 1997, but you needed a computer from 2000 before you could run it smoothly in high-res mode at a good framerate). Now we got this 1.05 update, which is clearly meant for the consoles, sure, there were some story-progression edge-cases fixed, but they also seem to have included the console performance fixes, so now the game looks like crap. View-distance is short, everything fades in and pops up.. Distant car traffic is now clearly 2d sprites, and if you go there, there is not even car.. It seems they introduced the road-population algorithm from "sim city 2000", so you will now have a section of road fully backed up, and the cars just dissapear when driving into the next section.. You have npc characters that look so much worse now. They basically sacrificed the good game to make it run on the bad hardware. I'd really like a "Not running on a potato" option, even with every setting at its max, the game looks worse with this patch than before.
- thepra 6y agoI'm having a great time with the game, the bugs weren't such a big issue for me as they are explained everywhere. I guess people are way too sensitive
- utf_8x 6y agoThe game is not nearly as broken as the butthurt "community" on Reddit and other sites would have you believe. I've played this game for about 80 hours on a PC, it hasn't crashed once and I haven't encountered a single game-breaking bug. Sure, there are T-posing NPCs here and there and the vehicle AI could use some work but it's really not that bad... Skyrim has been out for almost 10 years now and at times it still feels more broken than Cyberpunk... What really drives me up the wall however is people blaming CDPR for this. It's 100% the investors' fault. They pushed CDPR to release the game ASAP and immediately after the release started bitching about how the game is broken... The Investor Call transcripts on the CDPR website make for some... interesting reading. And if I may offer a personal opinion, they should've focused on PC and next-gen consoles and left the last-gen port to an external company who specialize in this kind of thing...
- majinuub 6y agoNot going to lie, I feel pretty vindicated about avoiding the hypetrain. I had a feeling something like this would happen. I still want to play the game, but I'll wait for a few patches before I purchase it.
- bananabiscuit 6y agoThe “launch disaster” is possibly more overblown than the game was overhyped. I guess probably avoid it on base last gen consoles. Everyone I know in real life is enjoying this game despite occasional bugs. Cyberpunk is about as buggy now as Fallout 4 is after years of patches. People on the internet get way more enjoyment being overly dramatic about games than actually playing them.
- commandlinefan 6y ago> It might seem impossible that a game this prominent, that’s been in development for this long ... could launch in such a state The author is failing to account for the fundamental rule of software development: no matter how soon the launch date is, project management will demand that you add new features right now but never adjust the release date.