11 ms·
An unemployed trader who became a $700M exile
- 3327 6y agoHi - career high-level prop trader here. Not a mid-level got fired type like this guy who at best was a sales trader. There is a reason he was mid-level and fired. All the best traders found jobs easier during 2008 and so forth. Frankly, this guy committed fraud and scammed gov’ts of rebates with fictional trades it seems. Mid-level for a reason, he couldn’t even figure out to go buy some tech stocks and go travel for 2 years. Frauds like him make the legit ones look bad. he should return the funds or the Danish should put a nice bounty on his head and he can see how safe Dubai really is.
- enjoyyourlife 6y agoYour comment history seems to indicate that you are not a "high-level prop trader"
- smabie 6y agoAre you sure you work at a legit prop shop? Maybe I'm being unfair, but from the way you're talking, I find it hard to believe. Source: see profile
- jiofih 6y ago> A small group of agents in the U.K. wrote to Skat between 2012 and 2015, claiming to represent hundreds of overseas entities -- including small U.S. pension funds along with firms in Malaysia and Luxembourg -- that had received dividends from Danish stocks and were entitled to tax refunds. Satisfied with the proof they received, the Danes say they handed over some $2 billion. Yeah, sounds very legal.
- bpodgursky 6y agoIf you think you can determine whether a tax refund is legal based on a two-sentence summary, you probably shouldn't be a tax attorney.
- jiofih 6y agoIt sounds very shady regardless of legality. Laws are made to serve people’s best interests, it is not just a code, and a judge will certainly take that into account.
- CPLX 6y agoSure but it's enough to sniff out that there's maybe a problem with transactions have no underlying economic value and obscured beneficial ownership, which is a category of transactions that tend to cause trouble in taxation discussions.
- ackbar03 6y agoI used to work in trading. Honestly a very large portion of the markets trading type business for investment banks is really just taking advantage one way or another of these kind of regulatory loopholes, not as blatantly as this maybe but some still very questionable. That and ripping off clueless corporate clients with bid-ask spreads. Some traders are still able to convince themselves it's cause theyre some sort of market wizard though cause tbh most of these people aren't that bright. Any other finance guys can correct me if I'm wrong, it could be just because my experience had been working with teams that I was never too impressed with
- EugeneG 6y agoYou're wrong. Few reasons: 1. "A very large portion" - no, there are some motivated by different regulatory treatment for different transactions, but it's not "a very large portion." There's also nothing wrong with the regulatory-motivated trades generally done by banks. It's not the same as what this guy did which is clearly immoral/wrong - he was not doing something in an optimal way to reduce tax burden. He was doing things that caused governments to literally pay out new money - negative tax payments - possibly under fraudulent pretenses. As an analogy for what is appropriate - if you open a Corp in the US but decide to open an S Corp rather than a C Corp for better tax treatment - is that a reg loophole? No you're following the law to get better tax treatment. 2. Wide bid-offer isn't a rip off. Markets are generally competitive, corp clients can easily ask 3-4 banks for a price for the same product. What confuses novices is that in financial markets its typically easy to see the "mid" in addition to a bid-offer and then feel bad about profits. Would you feel equally guilty if you went to the store and saw the "mid" on a $1000 iPhone is $500 - and the bid/offer is 50%? Before you say "it's different!" - consider the complexity involved in arranging a profitable bank that has a competent sales team, trading desk, operations, compliance, capital, legal, etc. etc. - and also does profitable transactions. It's a moat - hard to replicate - and that's what leads to profits.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ackbar03 6y ago
- erikegern 6y agoIt's a loophole in the same way as an unwatched cash register is a loophole.
- hollerith 6y agoThat is not fair to the subject of the article. Not only is what the subject of the article did probably not illegal, but also lawmakers will probably choose to eliminate the loophole (i.e., to change the tax code) rather than to make exploiting the loophole illegal in the future.
- roncohen 6y ago> Not only is what the subject of the article did probably not illegal Why do you say that? The method they used consists of simply filing forms to get withheld taxes paid out that were never withheld. The amounts paid out corresponds to owning all stocks in the actual companies many times over. Sanjay himself went drinking with the employee of the Danish tax authority in Copenhagen who was in charge of approving the applications while the (I'll go ahead and use the word) fraud was going on, presumably to ensure things would continue to go on[0]. The employee has since been jailed for approving fraudulent applications in another case[1] American pension funds who similarly exploited this have settled with the danish authorities and returned all the money they received[2] Sanjay says he suggested a settlement, offering to return 1.9B DKK (~311m USD) in 2018[3] Yes, the danish authorities were sleeping at the wheel, but that does not make it legal. [0] https://www.dr.dk/nyheder/webfeature/milliardkuppet https://www.dr.dk/nyheder/webfeature/milliardkuppet [1] https://www.dr.dk/nyheder/penge/seks-aars-faengsel-til-sven-i-sag-om-udbytteskat https://www.dr.dk/nyheder/penge/seks-aars-faengsel-til-sven-... [2] https://www.skm.dk/aktuelt/presse-nyheder/pressemeddelelser/udbyttesagen-skattestyrelsen-indgaar-milliardforlig-med-amerikanske-pensionsplaner/ https://www.skm.dk/aktuelt/presse-nyheder/pressemeddelelser/... [3] https://www.dr.dk/nyheder/penge/sanjay-shah-jeg-tilboed-danmark-19-milliarder-kroner-undgaa-retssag https://www.dr.dk/nyheder/penge/sanjay-shah-jeg-tilboed-danm...
- bluelu 6y agoLet's hope that they catch all those who did this. In germany, they are also going to vote a law before christmas that the crime can still be followed up after 10 years in order to bring all of them to court who did this in germany.
- vmception 6y agoI get so many lucrative ideas from Bloomberg articles, pretty much every day. Well worth paying the subscription.
- ericmay 6y agoWhat's a past example?
- m3kw9 6y agoHaven’t fully read the article. What other ideas other than scams have you gotten from it?
- gumby 6y agoI assume the GP comment was sarcastic.
- vmception 6y agoIt's not sarcastic. I had never heard of the "Cum Ex" market before this article, and here there are people being interviewed about their experience investing in that market across two decades. People that literally saw a pitch for a market I never heard of, and did it, and made bank. This is not my world, and I want it to be. I know to look across EU and peripheral EU nations for arbitrage and obscure policies, despite having no interest in raiding government coffers due to discrepancies in settlement times, I would have never thought to look at it this way.
- vmception 6y agoThis is one of the reasons I like Europe, a monetary union with wildly disparate "sovereign clearing agents", as in the nation state clears your money from any taxation claims but they all do it differently with no coordination. There is currently no union-wide government you have to pay. There's nothing like it in the world. They formed this union but their own people barely go to the other countries to take advantage of the discrepancies, its just foreigners that see the whole playground in its current state and have no historical opinion that deters them from playing with it all.
- ArnoVW 6y agoMy understanding is that citizens pays their government, and the governments in turn use (some of) that money to pay for the functioning of Europe (generally approx 1% of it's GNP). The European budget is mostly an "investment budget", and represents 2% of public spending in Europe. For 2019, Europe operated with a budget of 165 G$ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Budget_of_the_European_Union https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Budget_of_the_European_Union
- bla3 6y agoMaybe it's because US folks are used to jusrisdiction mostly using a "letter of the law" approach which invites loophole seeking and exploitation, while EU jusrisdictions use a "spirit of the law" approach. Sounds like this guy's defense is based on missing that cultural difference, at least.
- vmception 6y agoAs a US folk myself, does it matter? If I was in the same position I would have made it harder to find and seize my assets while the actual court cases proceeded.
- dnautics 6y agoI don't know if it will take 30 years or 50, but my gut feeling is that "spirit of the law" is much much more tenuous than "letter of the law". Who knows if the US is metastable. Things have been going nuts with the legal system here but it is also 250 years old. Most european democracies are a much younger experiment (and france is on what, attempt #5? Maybe #6 if you count subsumption into the EU as an unrecognized, but fundamental change in political dynamics).
- vmception 6y agoMultiple governments are trying to seize his assets. Unresolved legal issues like like this are why its worth it so always obfuscate the provenance of money. It's only "money laundering" when the origin is illegal, when the source is illicit. Otherwise obfuscation is just you playing around with your own money. Protip: the state can't tell the difference. You can avoid any inconveniences of..... consensus failures.
- coolsnakeman 6y ago“Bankers don’t have morals.” it's a fair point
- mellosouls 6y agoBut in a series of recent interviews from his $4.5 million home in Dubai, Shah was unrepentant. “Bankers don’t have morals,” the 50-year-old said on a video call. “Hedge-fund managers, and so on, they don’t have morals. I made the money legally.” [...] “Prove that any law was broken,” Shah said. “Prove that there was fraud. The legal system allowed it.” At least he's honest in his contempt for normal ethical mores - there's none of the vacillating bull we associate with PR from say, big corporate tax dodgers. Naive, idealistic me has often wondered how possible an abstract law of last resort for prosecuting people who exploit loopholes in what a jury of their peers would consider to be an unethical way; but I guess it would be to open to abuse by dodgy governments and other entities and presumably not compatible with a democratic legal system.
- petermcneeley 6y agoAt some point the disease is worse than the cure. You also use this word "democratic" in a way that does not mean "rule by the majority".
- mellosouls 6y agoI just meant legal systems as exist in developed democracies but that's more long-winded and potentially open to red-herring discussions on which countries are democratic etc.
- goodcanadian 6y agoPerhaps, "rule of law" is what you were looking for?
- mellosouls 6y agoI think that probably also has room for interpretation. Anyway, hopefully most will have known what I meant.
- Privacy846 6y ago> You also use this word "democratic" in a way that does not mean "rule by the majority". I’ll take the bait. “Democratic legal system” is, according to you, an oxymoron because of the “rule by the majority” part? A common sentiment although easily debunked, since there are always rulers in any system with legal codes. In any case this seems pretty off-topic. Another in any case (since I can’t help myself): when political scientists talk about “modern democracies” they mean liberal democracies with rule of law etc. Even though very few modern countries are truely democracies.
- rexreed 6y agoEven here on HackerNews the Cum-Ex trades were documented back in 2018: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18246379 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18246379
- Gunax 6y agoI am familiar with this scandal (but not a finance expert or anything). The problem with loopholes is that it's up to interpretation. Is it intentional? Is it legal? These are hard problems to determine. America famously offered a tax benefit for 'manufacturing'. But what constitutes manufacturing? If I have a restaurant, am I manufacturing food? It's hard to say. I don't think what Shah did was criminal. But I do think the governments should be able to demand that he return the money if a court rules that their interpretation of the law was wrong,
- therealx 6y agoI think it's very unfair to give someone money and then demand it back. It puts people in awful situations financially. I know people that have been ruined via this when it happened with their taxes (and they weren't doing anything illegial) or unemployment.
- guitarbill 6y agoThis isn't a small, poor individual; or even a small local business - so I'm not convinced the analogy holds, or at least I'm much less sympathetic. Going from half a mil to 700 mil has to raise a few red flags. Even if they were forced to give back 80%, they would hardly be left desolate.
- Gunax 6y agoBut it's also unfair to fraudulently receive money from someone. If you accidentally gain because someone gives you money (say they sent it to the wrong bank account) it isn't fair to keep it.
- neonate 6y agohttps://archive.is/x6Nxo https://archive.is/x6Nxo
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> But Shah says he’s being made a “scapegoat” for figuring out how to legally profit from obscure tax-code loopholes that allowed Cum-Ex trades, named for the Latin term for “With-Without.” How does this claim keep getting made? "Cum-Ex" is English for "with-without". It would be Latin for "with-from". The Latin word for "without" is sine.
- Mediterraneo10 6y agoWithout in English means both "bereft of" and "outside of", and even if the latter sense has become archaic it still persists as a learned usage and is a reasonable translation here of Latin ex.
- thaumasiotes 6y agoNo, the sense of "ex" here is very definitely "bereft of", and it is specific to financial English. (Why do you think it's being contrasted with cum?) Buying ex-dividend means you don't get the dividend. It develops, through the phrase "ex-dividend date", from a special sense of ex in Latin when applied to times, meaning "after". (You can see exactly the same thing happening in English phrases like "from now on".) Originally, ex-dividend date referred to a date after the dividend date. This was reanalyzed as referring to a date upon which the instrument becomes "ex-dividend" [nonsensical in Latin], which required a reanalysis of ex as pertaining to the dividend rather than the date. It is an error to talk about translating "Latin ex" here; this isn't a Latin ex.
- thaumasiotes 6y agoI should also point out that "outside of" is not a meaning of Latin ex; you'd want extra.
- betwixthewires 6y agoHe essentially penetration tested tax law in a multinational economic organization. He did not follow prior disclosure guidelines that you'd expect in a penetration testing scenario. In all honesty, disclosing these loopholes would've been unfruitful. Unless exploited, lawmakers would not have put much effort into closing these loopholes, and many would've been very likely to take advantage of them themselves. And big complex entities like the EU would be very slow to fix anything anyway, and it is likely that any fix would've left other openings to exploit. From an engineering perspective, a system like the finance and tax legislation of the EU and it's member states is a massive, monolithic, legacy fraught and overhead encumbered system where the engineers of it cannot foresee exploits in their system, have no tools to test the system before launch, and are often incentivised to deliberately leave openings to be exploited.
- puranjay 6y ago"Bankers don't have morals" Which is exactly why they need to be regulated more. Amoral bankers keep plunging the world into crisis after crisis.
- canada_dry 6y agoCapitalism has no morals. Unbridled capitalism - one with little oversight and regulation - is destroying the US IMHO. Yet this is exactly what the Republicans endgame is.
- divtiwari 6y agoHang the Bankers!!!