8 ms·
An Elderly Mathematician Hacked the Lottery for $26M
- Scoundreller 6y ago> The State Lottery made a mistake in all this. They listed the odds of winning that was associated with each combination of numbers. I don’t see why this is a mistake. Every lotto should do it, but I can see why they don’t.
- dangus 6y agoRight, that wasn’t the mistake. The mistake was designing a game that is gave the player the house advantage.
- joosters 6y agoNot really. The lottery organiser didn't lose out on any money here. The total prize money is going to be paid out to someone. In fact, the operators, through this mis-design, might have encouraged more lottery ticket buying than there would have otherwise been (e.g. this guy started buying thousands of tickets) - so this 'flaw' would have made the lottery more money! It all starts to go wrong when the secret gets out; ordinary lottery players might avoid the game because they see it as rigged, so the revenue goes down. At this point, the lottery organisers have to do something.
- mikewarot 6y agoIt's not a mistake at all, it's an advertising campaign for numeracy.
- toyg 6y agoIn a proper lottery (i.e. balls randomly extracted out of a machine), the odds are the same for each combination of numbers, surely...? How did they produce these odds, artificially?
- mlyle 6y agoI don't think the game is really flawed, per se. It's just that during the weeks with these roll downs, the expected value of a ticket can be positive. Effectively, players during weeks without rolldowns are subsidizing excess prizes for weeks with the rolldown rule in play. This is probably a feature you don't want in the game, but it's not too different from games where when the jackpot is particularly high that the EV of a ticket can exceed its price.
- bluGill 6y agoThat is a dangerous game though: some weeks there are two winners and then the expected value goes negative even though the total payout is more than the cost of buying one of each ticket.
- mlyle 6y agoSure, but that's something that's easy to model in your EV and volatility calculations, too, even though forecasting total sales and the distribution of peoples' number choices (non-uniform == better for you) is a bit of a trick.
- adolph 6y agoJerry studied those winning odds, and the timing of those Roll Downs. He realized that, statistically, a single one dollar lottery ticket was worth more than one dollar in those final weeks. The state's error was being too slow with "Roll Downs." 10 years, $26M revenue, $8M profit. $800K/year; I guess taxes were counted in the $18M expenses. Nice "side-gig" to running a convenience store! [edit: 10 years, not !0 years.]
- Scoundreller 6y agoI’d imagine some of the revenue was their commission from selling tickets. At least where I am, vendors and their family are basically prohibited from playing/winning after they were found to be winning way too often. What was happening is they would get to know which players don’t check how much they’ve won and declare you’ve won $100 when you really won $1000. Or worse.
- driverdan 6y agoIt's not a mistake, it's a legal requirement in some places. It's poor writing.
- choeger 6y agoQuestion: How can he be right about the estimated value of a ticket when the number of buyers is unknown? Should the game not swing back once the "hack" is made public?
- kyleblarson 6y agoAssuming they sold lotto tickets at their convenience store and that the couple actually worked at the counter, they could probably get a pretty solid gut feel for the relative demand of each drawing based on the number of tickets they sold.
- toast0 6y agoMy (general) understanding is in these lotteries, whenever there's a rolldown, all tickets are positive EV, regardless of the number of tickets bought. Although, it certainly would get slim if the number was very high. I think there were three known large scale buying groups for the MA rolldown lottery? The exciting technique was determining when your buying could trigger a rolldown, possibly without it being previously announced.
- lazyjones 6y ago> whenever there's a rolldown, all tickets are positive EV, regardless of the number of tickets bought This is probably likely, but wrong in general. If the tickets cost $1 and the total prize money is composed from e.g. 50% of the ticket prices plus a fixed amount of leftover prize money, when enough tickets are bought for the rolldown round, the leftover prize money isn't enough to cover for the 50% of the new tickets that doesn't go in the pot. Example: $2m leftover money in the pot, 5 million tickets bought for $1 each. EV = $2m + 50% of $5m = $0.9 per ticket. Now, if you buy enough tickets to guarantee e.g. 4 correct numbers and know for a fact that due to a rolldown the minimum payout is going to be high enough to cover the cost of that (at least with a high probability), then you're fine. I'd assume that's what the couple in the story did.
- choeger 6y agoSo basically you are betting that not many other people have the same winning combination. Sounds like a good deal for the house to me.
- lqet 6y ago> The math explanation could fill an article itself. If you are interested in how exactly he did it, here is a more detailed description: https://math.berkeley.edu/~kpmann/ellenberg.pdf https://math.berkeley.edu/~kpmann/ellenberg.pdf
- dmurray 6y agoThe main strategy is the tremendously complicated scheme of "buy as many tickets as you can physically key in, any time the prize pool goes above $x." Everyone who played the Michigan or Massachussets lottery that week was "hacking" the lottery the exact same way! That's not quite the optimum solution - what if you accidentally played the same numbers a million times, instead of a million different sets of numbers? So you should make sure you spread out your plays. However, I believe spreading them randomly is "good enough": the interesting maths only improves your edge a tiny amount.
- at-fates-hands 6y ago>> the interesting maths only improves your edge a tiny amount. Its only anecdotal evidence, but this would support your idea. I used to work for a mom & pop company. The owner was really wealthy. He would only play once the pot got to an insane amount (I think it was over $5 or $10 million) and then on his way into the office, would stop at 5-8 places, buying anywhere from $1-$3K in tickets a shot. I still vividly remember huge stacks of lottery tickets sitting on his huge desk in his office. He never did win the big pots, but did win a $1K or $2k amounts by matching a few of the numbers. But very clearly, he spent WAY more then he ever won.
- themodelplumber 6y ago> But very clearly, he spent WAY more then he ever won. Which, in a recreational context, one could argue has more potential upside than a lot of other recreational activities (at least it's on the table, unlike other activities), and a pretty high baseline thrill as well.
- 6y ago
- muststopmyths 6y agoTFA is, to put it politely, incomplete. They played both the Michigan and a later Mass state lottery. It looks like the Michigan lottery may not have detected them. https://highline.huffingtonpost.com/articles/en/lotto-winners/?utm_source=inccommurphy https://highline.huffingtonpost.com/articles/en/lotto-winner...
- Udo_Schmitz 6y agoI remember that one. The medium article looks like a summary.
- muststopmyths 6y agoIt's worse though. Because it completely ignores the Massachusetts lottery, which was where the MIT team actually came in.
- kevinwang 6y agothis is the best article on the topic. Probably my favorite article ever, actually. I also like how it frames Selbee as an average joe-turned-convenience store owner with a side interest in math, instead of how TFA frames him as a mathematician. Previous discussion on the good article: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16494280 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16494280 Honestly, the currently linked article seems to me like low-effort blogspam.
- mywittyname 6y ago> All they’ve done is renovate their house and pay for their 14 grandchildren's college funds. State lotteries love to go on how their proceeds are used for education. But I bet 14 full rides to college on $8MM is a greater impact on education than what the state achieves with the same amount.
- an_opabinia 6y agoThey created 14 college funds because each individual 529 allows a lump sum $150k married gift tax free. With that only totalling $2.1m of tax free income, I’m confident they did a lot more stuff with the remaining $5.9m. Anyway it’s kind of ironic you are comparing the state’s education spending to a tax avoidance scheme.
- SomeHacker44 6y agoI would imagine the price for college exceeds $150,000 in many cases. I have a savings target well in excess of that for my son.
- an_opabinia 6y agoI mean this in the best possible way, try punching "529 Plan" into Google. The point of the comment, which I'm not sure why it was being downvoted, is why something might sound newsworthy (14 college funds?) when it really has a simple, logical explanation if you're sophisticated with money. And in the same breath, in applause of a guy performing a tax optimization, the original poster shits on the state - did it create this tax loophole? Do you think the people running government want college to be expensive? Rich people, really everyone with heritable wealth, love the 529 plan. If you understood that it is used to create multi-purpose, heritable investment accounts tax-free in vast excess of the actual cost of tuition - that anyone who would have a hard time paying Harvard's tuition goes for free anyway - you would detect some insincerity in "14 college funds" too! And maybe consider that this 529 plan remains the status quo, this total tax dodge, because of people who have this romanticized picture of it being used to pay expensive college tuitions. We're talking about a family so sophisticated that it's probably going to change legal guardians on those very same children in order to benefit from free tuition anyway. It's a great story. We certainly want our brainiacs spending resources "hacking" some shitty institution like the lottery. On the other hand, you think he doesn't take beyond his measure from the government too?
- phreeza 6y agoWhy on earth is there a stock photo of a "High Class Mature Man", captioned as "Author" opening the article?
- actusual 6y agoI think that's what we in the business call a "joke"
- OJFord 6y agoI think the funniest part is the original (stock photo listing) caption: "high class mature man"...
- mandelbrotwurst 6y agoProbably an elaborate ploy by the subject of the photograph to generate positive AI bias for himself.
- driverdan 6y agoThis article was written by someone who doesn't understand math or the history of people beating lotteries. There are many lotteries that have times with an expected positive payout. The key is that the payout can't be shared. Most of the big lotteries have times like this but the chances of having to share it ensure the payout is never positive.
- EvanAnderson 6y agoI love that this guy pulled this off. It's a great story. I was reminded of the story of Mohan Srivastava[1], an MIT/Stanford-trained statistician, who found a flaw in the Ontario Lottery's "Tic-Tac-Toe" instant game. There's a great quote from Mr. Srivastava re: his morality and exploiting the flaw he found: "People often assume that I must be some extremely moral person because I didn't take advantage of the lottery," he says. "I can assure you that that's not the case. I'd simply done the math and concluded that beating the game wasn't worth my time." [1] https://www.wired.com/2011/01/ff-lottery/ https://www.wired.com/2011/01/ff-lottery/
- Upvoter33 6y agoI have a different reaction: it is not an ethical thing to do. There are lots of things people can do to get money - but this doesn't mean people should do them. Isn't the ethical thing to do to report the problem so that the system can't be gamed by others?
- bluGill 6y agoI consider gambling unethical, and thus all forms of cheating are the only ethical way to play such games.
- sdeep27 6y agoWhere'd you come up with this logic? It's similar to saying I find modern banking unethical, therefore its only ethical that I hack in and steal both the depositors and the corporations money. Also why do you find gambling unethical? Do you also find poker unethical? What about trading stocks?
- justinclift 6y ago> Where'd you come up with this logic? Maybe because gambling companies whole purpose in life is to rip people off, so it's fair play to do that back to them? :)
- mandeepj 6y ago> He buys a full $8,000 in tickets An average person will NOT do it. Is it really a hack? I believe he increased his probability of winning chances
- JackFr 6y agoI don’t understand why the state would care. They take their cut off the top. If there is excess unclaimed jackpot money that accumulates week to week until expected values go positive why does that hurt them?
- Maxburn 6y agoThe house hates it when people hit them for big wins.
- 35fbe7d3d5b9 6y agoMost of the "houses" you reference don't have the privilege of paying you for your winnings and then taking a large percentage back as taxable income.
- bluGill 6y agoNo, the house loves it when someone takes a big win. They have already made their money, the winnings is something they have already budgeted to pay out so it isn't even a loss to them. The big winners tend to brag about their winnings and this free advertising is worth a lot to them.
- ajarmst 6y agoOld person here. Why is "elderly" sufficiently germane to appear in the title?
- gnicholas 6y agoHe won $26M but spent $18M to do so. Still very impressive, but not quite the impression given by the headline. > But at this point, Jerry had won more than $26 million dollars from the state lottery. After deducting for expenses, they took in more than $8 million in profit.
- ogre_codes 6y agoA lot of gamblers ignore the "expense" column when talking about their winnings. I had a friend would would go to Reno 2-3 weekends a month and brag about winning $500 or 1000. He never really talked about the fact that on most weeks he came home with empty pockets.
- m3kw9 6y agoMost true even with stocks
- jacquesm 6y agoHere in NL it was the state that hacked the lottery. They did not advertise the fact that all the unsold numbers competed for the prize as well and inflated the number of tickets to ensure that this was very often the case.
- mhb 6y agoThat's all of a piece with the other state "hack" of advertising one "prize" and actually paying an annuity based on that amount (or the value of the annuity).
- the_decider 6y agoReminds me of the story of Voltaire hacking the lottery. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Uzr1TPmIJT8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Uzr1TPmIJT8 History repeats itself!
- iainctduncan 6y agoSo this is basically like old black jack card counting but on a lottery. Wait till the deck is hot and then play, play, play. What a great story!
- mxie-ca 6y agoThis indeed reminds me the blackjack movie 21
- mhb 6y agoHow a Group of MIT Students Gamed the Massachusetts State Lottery and Won Millions https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2016/02/how-mit-students-gamed-the-lottery/470349/ https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2016/02/how-mit...
- czottmann 6y agoThey didn't "hack" anything. They used math and knowledge of statistical probability. I don't think the headline "Old man used math to win $26M" would've fared worse.
- fortran77 6y agoHe wasn't a mathematician by trade, and the ageist term "elderly" bothers me. He was 62. That's 4 years older than I am.
- RaymondFish 6y agoOh my, I LOVE reading stuff like this!
- m0llusk 6y agoHow is gaming a lottery a subject for a founders handbook? That seems like over emphasis on the role of chance in starting companies and arguably the opposite of achieving market fit.
- disown 6y agoI remember one of my math professors ranting about lotteries being an "idiot tax" and that you should never play them. Seems like he should have tried gaming the lottery instead of ranting against it.
- jo6gwb 6y agoThis story has been discussed before - See: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16494280 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16494280 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20144870 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20144870
- fitzroy 6y agoThis seems to be a hastily-written 'summary', complete with misattributed photos, of a much better long form piece from a couple years ago. https://highline.huffingtonpost.com/articles/en/lotto-winners/ https://highline.huffingtonpost.com/articles/en/lotto-winner...
- Hickfang 6y agoDispensing with all the folksy prose, buy enough lottery tickets and you'll win on the lower draws.
- DoctorOetker 6y agohow is this not random feel good advertisement? people always assume that when an entity momentarily loses that it was gamed, while that entity may profit in the long run from allowing to be occasionally gamed, which then after the fact spreads like wildfire and while most readers eventually give up trying to find a flaw, it did succeed in obsessing them for a prolonged amount of time that they just roll with it and go out to buy some tickets even though they didn't succeed in finding a flaw...