13 ms·
The Modern World Has Finally Become Too Complex for Any of Us to Understand
- kungito 6y agoI'd wager it was way worse "before" when there was way less access to information. Nowadays you can at least google almost anything which isn't intentionally obscured while "before" there was no "global knowledge storage". I feel like the article is mixing "scale" with "obscurity". Yeah things are more automated but they are doing the same thing many more times before, it's not like the average person cannot comprehend what is happening if they invested enough time to have the necessary knowledge
- vidanay 6y agoIt's amazing how we have forgotten that until relatively recently, the average person's "world" consisted of a 10 mile radius around their village. It's much easier to comprehend that world than the modern world - of course, that's until some invaders come over the hill or sea that you've always wondered "what's over there?"
- newsbinator 6y agoThere was a time, not long ago, when a person could wonder about something that is well understood, try for an hour to get the answer, fail, and give up. Now with every passing month the set of known things that are hard to find out gets smaller and smaller. Or even the set of speculative things. You want to know how a warp drive might work? There's a Youtube video for that. You want to know what that Youtube video about how warp drive might work means? There's a Youtube video for that too.
- vidanay 6y agoThat was me in elementary school trying to do a research report at the crappy local 1970's era library.
- mikem170 6y agoThe problem isn't that the average person can't understand all of the modern world, the problem is that them and the politicians they elect and the experts they count on can't understand it well enough to avoid really large mistakes in interconnected systems that can affect everyone.
- robocat 6y ago> Nowadays you can at least google almost anything which isn't intentionally obscured Pick one “simple” part in say an iPad. You might be able to get a general overview on how the part is made, but if you try to drill down the slightest then there is immediately huge swathes of questions that are unanswerable without deep industry knowledge. A recent example was a “simple” cellphone PCB[1] that was very well documented, plus the help of the manufacturer, yet on every single step in the article there are large quantities of unanswered questions. Mind boggling complexity. [1] https://www.bunniestudios.com/blog/?p=6011 https://www.bunniestudios.com/blog/?p=6011
- richardwhiuk 6y agoThis isn't really new. It's existed in human inventions for a long time, and the natural world forever.
- hindsightbias 6y agoBefore, you only needed domain experts. Nobody thought they could do more complex things w/o education. Now, knowledge is google/wiki shallow even in simpler domains. I've seen "experts" who really did not invest in depth and before they couldn't even try because it was obscured enough that you had to actually work to find it. It scares me to think how much engineers or doctors may be just googling around because Material Thermodynamics/Vascular course got split up into electives because the domain wouldn't fit into a semester anymore. Chip engineers tell me they used to actually understand what was going on and could converse about any part of the chip. They understood a lot about the fab process. Software people knew a lot about the chip. Now, no one has the big picture. Scale this up to airplanes, civil construction, large embedded systems, power grids... people may know their domain if lucky but the integration of complex projects is filled with gaps people don't know how to bridge - they don't even know where the gaps are. It's not brand new - no known engineer/software person grok'd speculative execution exploits for the two decades it was possible. Now, kernel people know a lot more about chip pipelines and cache architectures because they got bit.
- kungito 6y agoOh please, only thing happening was people shot themselves in the foot more often. This reminds of the whole debate "C engineer who never makes security mistakes vs 10 years younger Rust developer who uses a tool which makes sure it doesn't happen". Planes didn't suddenly start falling from the sky because people chose wrong electives. That why we have PROCESS where we make sure dumb things cannot happen because we explicitly check for them. When you add automated checking on top of that you get way further than some galaxy brain old school chip designers. Besides, things are moving way to fast for people to get to know too much about one thing
- ivan1783 6y agoI work in automotive, its the same here. There isn't a single person who you can find that has a big picture detailed understanding of the whole system.
- Geminidog 6y agoThe world has always been too complex too understand. Even before human society became complex, the natural world around us was already immensely complex. Additionally human society was already too complex too understand from before we were born. This title implies he was waiting for the complexity to happen. "Finally." Things may appear more complex because of the internet and social media. Really what's happening is there's a lot more information that's accessible to us and a lot of it is useless. One thing people don't realize is they think society is falling into chaos with the pandemic trump and all the garbage they report on the media. What they don't realize that there has never been a time in history where the world is more at peace then there is now. We are extraordinarily lucky to live in these times, source: https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2014/12/the-world-is-not-falling-apart-the-trend-lines-reveal-an-increasingly-peaceful-period-in-history.html https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2014/12/the-world-is-not... But humans like drama so to get more views people have to dramatize everything. Really nothing is happening. Trump or Biden being president is more likely to change what you see on the news over an actual change to your way of life.
- NoOneNew 6y agoYay, someone else that's sober. I dont understand the constant need to radicalize every problem as we technically are "fixing" things. Less war, less natural cause deaths other than old age, less world wide poverty, the world is getting better on a whole. Still plenty of serious problems. No one should discount that. But I had to stop watching the general news the past few months because it seemed like we were living during the black death, world war 1 and 2, and the American civil war (I'm in the US) all at the same time. We're not. Things aren't perfect, but holy shit things were far worse roughly 100 years ago. Theres a point where every radical on any political spectrum needs to get hit with a belt in the ass and told to stand in the corner, same goes for the general media. We all need to take a deep breath, be grateful that things aren't as bad as during our grandparents time, quit thinking the world will end tomorrow, and calmly fix things together. But hey, that's all crazy talk and doesn't produce ad clicks for google, facebook and twitter.
- RGamma 6y ago
- fithisux 6y agoNo, it has not. It is easy to understand.
- jakeva 6y agoIn which case it should be easy for you to explain, yes?
- postalrat 6y agoAs easy as it would be to explain the color blue through text.
- gshixman 6y agoChallenge acccepted: Blue light is defined as roughly 380nm-460nm range of wavelengths in electromagnetic radiation, however the human eye perceives blue when observing light with a dominant wavelength between approximately 450nm-495nm. Objects coloured blue typically reflect or diffuse this range of wavelengths more efficiently than others wavelengths, rendering these objects the appearance of the color blue. Sources: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Visible_spectrum https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Visible_spectrum
- postalrat 6y agoI don't think that will help a person who was born blind know what blue means to people with sight.
- gshixman 6y agoI beg to differ, on a technical level electromagnetic radiation can be perceived as a physical force, similar to the sensations felt by an MRI machine. Your counter point appears to be around the emotions blue, or other colours, convey which is actually easier to explain than what a colour actually physically is. We use words to convey emotions all the time and to describe blue, adjectives like calm, cool, cold, sad, open, broad, easy, etc. etc. can be attributed to the colour blue.
- dustingetz 6y agoIncomprehensible to an infant human, certainly. Perhaps all is revealed if we iterate the human for N seconds. N = what?
- TheJoeMan 6y agoCouldn’t make it through the first paragraph. Maybe leave politics out of your tech blog.
- vb6sp6 6y agoMaybe don't get so offended if someone mentions Trump in a slightly negative way
- mrlala 6y agoCareful, HN doesn't like bad talking of Trump for some reason. They like to pretend that the way he acts is normal and acceptable for a person in such power. Hint: it's not.
- YinglingLight 6y ago'On November 8th of 2016, half the country learned that everything they believed to be both true and obvious turned out to be wrong. The people who thought Trump had no chance of winning were under the impression they were smart people who understood their country, and politics, and how things work in general. When Trump won, they learned they were wrong. They were so very wrong that they reflexively (because this is how all brains work) rewrote the scripts they were seeing in their minds until it all made sense again. The wrong-about-everything crowd decided that the only way their world made sense, with their egos intact, is that either the Russians helped Trump win or there are far more racists in the country than they imagined, and he is their king. Those were the seeds of the two mass hysterias we witness today.'
- joering2 6y agoI chuckled alot when I read this so thank you for the laughts. Its hilarious to go online today and hear all Trump supporters to scream “fraud” and trying to argue that it has to be fraud since Biden broke all possible records including number of votes, number of black votes etc. Its even more laughable since it comes from exactly the same people who like you claimed huge Trump 2016 victory and were proud Trump broke all the records.
- hirenj 6y agoApart from the financial system complexity, I actually struggle to see how the systems mentioned are too complex to understand. They’re big, yes, and full of detail - but incomprehensible doesn’t sound right. However, I’m sure that this is true in certain cases, and I would appreciate reading about specific examples of complexity that are well hidden, so the exact nature of the complexity can be described. What complexity do people systematically underestimate? What defies all understanding? Throwing our hands up and saying it all is incomprehensible is akin to ceding control over everything to the few that have understood everything.
- wintorez 6y agoMaybe by “Any of Us”, the author meant “Me”. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- jxramos 6y agoOr was rediscovering the "invisible hand".
- pixl97 6y agoEh, nobody understands everything simply because you need to sleep around 8 hours a day, and give at least a few other hours for other functions. There are limitless rabbit holes you can fall into and never gain mastery in the subject. Like describe the supply chain for iron, now do it for gasoline, now do it for silicon, copper, gold, crops, etc. No matter what your think, there isn't some person that understands all of this. They farm off the technicalities to people that are dedicated to it.
- hirenj 6y agoDo we need one person to understand everything? I don’t believe so, but there could be limits to the efficiency of collaborative understanding and action on complex systems, such that we have to have one person understanding multiple systems. To play devils advocate, I see this in science all the time where the great insights come from people with deep knowledge in multiple areas.
- mellosouls 6y agoThis is an excellent article - if marred slightly by the red-herring political moaning - but the central thesis, that we've finally crossed some sort of threshold seems a little off - the world has always been too complex to understand in the way he suggests; the difference now is the incredible scale.
- anm89 6y agoAgreed, this has probably been true for fifty years. It is certainly orders of magnitude worse now and getting worse at an increasing rate.
- mikepurvis 6y agoIt's a fuzzy line, though, because abstractions and pedagogy get better over time too, especially for long-standing systems which become increasingly well-understood over time. Basically, I'm saying that the world of 50 years ago is probably much more comprehensible to a highly skilled 2020 human than it was to someone actually living in it. It wouldn't be totally comprehensible to either, of course, but certainly the added context brings a lot of advantages.
- fn1 6y ago"The greatest shortcoming of the human race is our inability to understand the exponential function” - Albert Allen Bartlett
- Koshkin 6y agoThis has been upgraded to quantum mechanics.
- soneca 6y agoI would phrase that the humanity understanding of the world has always been just behind its complexity. As we advance in our understanding of the world, world’s complexity advances a bit more.
- 6y ago
- hpoe 6y agoWhat I find much more intersting about this is that this is the centeral thesis of Scott Adam's "The Dilbert Principle" that was published 2 decades ago. I'll also put out there that it was probably one of the most informative business books I ever read.
- specialist 6y agoI'd like someone, maybe me, to synthesize Adam's confusopoly, cybernetics, Graeber's bullshit jobs, and Shirky's prior distillations wrt attention and power laws. -- I'm intrinsically a deeply cynical, skeptical person. And I've never been more optimistic. We're finally able to start answering some of our millennia old philosophical questions. It's an amazing time to be alive. I can't wait to see what happens next.
- bmallerd 6y agoI would read this!
- medium_burrito 6y agoIt's time to build a computer to answer these questions. Let's call it Deep... I dunno... Thought?
- sunshinerag 6y ago42
- throwdour 6y agoThe incompetent leadership, contagious disease, and false beliefs described in the first paragraph are par for the course in human history. The author opened with a list of things that seem impervious to the ramping complexity, instead of vulnerable to it.
- t0mbstone 6y agoGood thing we have GPT-3 now. We can just ask it complex questions about the world and it will tell us the answers via auto-complete prediction of the next word in its sentence!
- ziroshima 6y agoThis is an interesting premise, but I don't think it really holds up. The world is absolutely too complex for any of us to understand everything, but this is not a problem. You can abstract everything away to 'black boxes', and there are always a few people that understand what's going on in those 'boxes'.
- dlp211 6y agoUnderstand is doing a lot of lifting here, it's also probably wrong that all the black boxes are understood. No one actually understands economics, we are all using a bunch of decades/century old models that don't really hold up in the real world and when they don't are dismissed as being influenced by outside factors in a complex system. See raising the minimum wage causes unemployment and inflation is a monetary phenomenon for 2 examples.
- Raidion 6y agoEconomics as a concept is a bad example for a black box because what would you say the input and output would be? Isn't economics the study of all the different black boxes and how they interact in general? Like if you took the honey market, someone out there understands the honey market, who is buying, who is selling, and why the prices are where they are. You repeat this for all markets (or parts of markets) and someone understands either the black box, or the way black boxes usually work together. When you have a large number of black boxes, the system can behave in weird ways because the behavior of the system is defined by each of the sub-systems behaving in a certain range. When that range changes wildly, the system can behave in unpredictable ways. Economics simply defines general rules for these complicated systems and so are heavily dependent on all the sub systems to function in a prescribed range. I don't feel like you can call economics a black box, but you could say that no one understands those particular problems you put forth because we don't have enough data (and enough correlation) to really determine what that change to a bunch of subsystems has on the system, especially when other factors (bull/bear market, global uncertainty, etc) will probably have a biasing effect.
- jmiskovic 6y agoThe issue being raised is that while individual black boxes can be understood, the whole system (interaction between boxes) has become too complex and too fast for human cognition. Automation solves it only for unchanging conditions. Automation could also spiral out out control when only optimization metrics are profit seeking.
- rektide 6y agoTechnology has become too impervious, too far off, too remote, too in the cloud, for society to begin to grapple with any of what is happening. The truth is occluded. I think of myself as atheist/agnostic in nature, but the way we have been creating technology flies against the face of God. Humankind, the tool maker, has gotten this way by meddling with & learning about their environment. Computing is, in almost all cases, invisible, something done in a way that we can not see. It is a violation of nature. It is unlearnable. The modern world is not too complex for any of us to understand. It is too resistant to observation to allow understanding to begin. The world must open itself again, or we face existential peril as a species; we will have trapped ourselves inside endless boxes.
- hyko 6y agoNo. You can only cross a rubicon that actually exists. The world has always been too complex for any of us to understand. Edited to add: if you find the modern world unintelligible, wait until you study the prehistoric one upon which that modern world still depends. It has absorbed millennia of investigation by the best minds in history so far, with no end in sight.
- rhencke 6y agoThe more I learn, the more I realize how much I still don't understand.
- elevenoh 6y agoThe more I learn, the more I cringe at those who make high conviction statements on 'what causes / leads to what'. More often than not, there's much complexity / intersecting forces to discern causality.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- heavyset_go 6y agoThis is also the thesis in "HyperNormalisation"[1] by Adam Curtis, who is quoted in this article. Like anything by Curtis, it's a good watch[2]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HyperNormalisation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HyperNormalisation [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=thLgkQBFTPw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=thLgkQBFTPw
- gambiting 6y agoI also cannot recommend Hypernormalisation enough, it's a fascinating watch, every single time.
- cecilpl2 6y agoThis is reminiscent of the short story I, Pencil [1], which was written in 1958 about the very same topic. > I am seemingly so simple. Simple? Yet, not a single person on the face of this earth knows how to make me. This sounds fantastic, doesn't it? [1] https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/I,_Pencil https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/I,_Pencil
- jxramos 6y agoThought the same thing, there's a modern equivalent/updated version found someplace written from the perspective of an iPad or an iPhone I think.
- btilly 6y agoI prefer the pencil. It is a piece of innocuous technology that looks so simple that everyone thinks they could figure out how to make one. The fact that even something so apparently simple is so complex, makes things that look complex even more astonishing.
- dredmorbius 6y agoA deliberate, ad as it predictably turns out, fslse, piece of propaganda. https://crookedtimber.org/2011/04/16/i-pencil-a-product-of-the-mixed-economy/ https://crookedtimber.org/2011/04/16/i-pencil-a-product-of-t...
- dredmorbius 6y agoGah. Softkeyboard strikes agan. A deliberate, and as it predictably turns out, false, piece of propaganda.
- throwawaysea 6y agoI'm not sure what to make of this article. It had potential but it is intermixed with political ranting that is unproductive. This is disappointing both because politics seems irrelevant and also because the unsubstantive political jabs undermine the credibility of this entire effort by giving away the author's bias. But leaving the political bits aside, I can't help but think this is an article written for the uninformed. Complexity isn't a bad thing. It is the consequence of specialization and technological advancement. A lot of people bemoan things like complexity in our financial system without understanding why things are the way they are, and without honest consideration that this complexity might actually make sense. That ignorance then causes them to distrust the system or pursue change for change sake, which is what it seems like this article is setting up for. For me, I can accept complexity in many aspects of my surroundings because people voluntarily built up much of that complexity through mutually-beneficial transactions (that is, free trade, supply-demand, and other market dynamics). It means those complexities have survived Democratic policy-making processes, survived market pressures, survived individuals accepting the beneficial tradeoffs that come with complexity, and so on. Without knowing specifics about some complex system, there is automatically a lot for me to trust and accept as a black box. The reality is that complexity and lack of understanding is inevitable, and it has also always been the state of things even before human-created complexity. No matter what, an individual will not be omniscient and will need to take some things as they come. Some aspects of life and our environment will remain black boxes. That doesn't mean they are broken or need adjustment to fit our fragile egos. It means we need to accept this situation with humility, and learn more about some area with earnest curiosity rather than viewing it as "too complex".
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 6y agoI don't think it's worth arguing about when this threshold was exactly crossed. The point, and it's a good point, is that every time this threshold is crossed, it puts some weird kind of new restriction or constraint on us. And this isn't a kind of scientific complexity like how biology is and always has been too complex for us to understand. This is the things that you and I use and rely on being too complex to understand. There is a famous talk by Milton Friedman forty years ago about nobody knowing how to make a standard pencil anymore. The red rubber tip, the yellow paint, the graphite, that little metal brace. Most of us could probably re-create most of it, but nobody could create the whole thing by themselves. (edit: apparently the pencil point (ha ha) was famously made by others going back to at least 1958.) In my mind there's a (pretty weak) analogy to the gold standard for money, or having an alternative when negotiating. With the gold standard, if somebody offers you one bitcoin (or equivalently X gold) for your widget, and you know how you value your widget and how you value gold, it's easy to decide whether or not to sell (weak analogy, full of holes, I know). Or if someone is offering to pay you some wage, but you could go back to the family farm and just make more food for yourself than that wage would buy you, then there is some kind of grounding of that wage in terms of concrete do-it-yourself alternatives. The more the things that we rely on and depend on (like the Internet) are so complex that the only alternative is whatever else happens to be furnished by "the market," the more of life turns into sort of a Keynesian beauty contest in a bad way, without a concrete grounding, and only a "what you think other people think that other people think that..." equilibrium instead. Not that the alternative is any better. I like my computer and my Internet and my prescription glasses and my ballpoint pen. It sucks that I'm practically required to have them, but I really do like them.
- ssivark 6y ago> And this isn't a kind of scientific complexity like how biology is and always has been too complex for us to understand. This is the things that you and I use and rely on being too complex to understand. The same is true for biology and ecosystems; we just don’t think about it even when effecting large scale ecological changes. We might well be depending on un-understood delicate balances that could easily be thrown out of whack by Eg: hunting certain species to extinction, releasing genetically modified mosquitoes, building dams, climate change, etc.
- LeonM 6y agoI found the example of the automated email to the ship's captain a bit weak. > The point is that we don’t know, the captain of the ship itself didn’t know, and that nobody may know It all boils down to abstraction. Just like the captain doesn't need to know why a certain type of steel is used for the hull of his ship, or how the software works that monitors his engines. The captain doesn't need to understand the calculation that goes behind the optimal arrival time of his ship. But I'm sure that, if he's curious enough, he can contact the right people at his employer to tell him why certain decisions are made.
- ardy42 6y ago> The captain doesn't need to understand the calculation that goes behind the optimal arrival time of his ship. But now he can't monitor its performance and intervene when it's wrong or offer feedback. He's turned into an automaton, and we're assuming his central planner has all the knowledge and understanding necessary to successfully manage a central plan and react to (perhaps unexpected) changes. And that's only considering the perspective of task performance, which is not the only angle here. Is it really a better world if all the tasks are performed perfectly, but if almost everyone's reduced to a deskilled, mind-numbed, burger-flipper?
- quintushoratius 6y ago> Is it really a better world if all the tasks are performed perfectly, but if almost everyone's reduced to a deskilled, mind-numbed, burger-flipper? In your metaphor you're assuming that the captain becomes a low skill automoton. Is he that, or has automation allowed him to set aside drudge and concentrate on the interesting parts of his job? Do you think calculators make us dumb, or do they help us with the arithmetic while our minds can turn to the important, interesting parts of the problem at hand?
- natmaka 6y agoThe "technique" isn't confined into menial tasks. It gains speed on interesting parts and noble avenues, for example automated theorem proving.
- carabiner 6y agoTong: Exactly. They dug their own grave, JC. We're going to eliminate global communications altogether. JC: I don't know... sounds like overkill. Tong: As long as technology has a global reach, someone will have the world in the palm of his hand. If not Bob Page, then Everett, Dowd... JC: Another Stone Age would hardly be an improvement. Tong: Not so drastic. A dark age, an age of city-states, craftsmen, government on a scale comprehensible to its citizens.
- reificator 6y agoI never asked for this quote.
- dredmorbius 6y agohttps://www.pcgamer.com/the-deus-ex-decision-which-ending-did-you-choose/ https://www.pcgamer.com/the-deus-ex-decision-which-ending-di...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- cryptica 6y agoWell I understand what's happening at a high level (in the economy, society, politics) but the typical HN reader will not like to hear it so I'm just going to keep it to myself.
- jmiskovic 6y agoCan anyone shed some light on this paragraph? > The global supply chains, with their mega-scale engineering projects and infrastructures, exist primarily because global wealth inequality makes it cheap to have stuff made in certain countries — even when you have to ship it halfway across the globe to sell it for a profit. By leveraging stark gaps in wages and standards of living as efficiently as it can, the supply chain network is actively enforcing that global inequality. I understand how wealth inequality is leveraged, and that it's in shipping companies financial interest to have highest margins, which doesn't really help the inequality. Still, it doesn't follow that they are actively enforcing inequality (they are after all flowing the capital toward poorer parts of world). If they are, which mechanisms are being used?
- johnmaguire2013 6y agoIf I have you produce 100 widgets at $0.10/widget, and then ship each widget for $0.20/widget, and then sell each widget for $1.00, but Amazon takes a 30% cut... - The shipping company received 2x what the producer received - Amazon received 3x what the producer received - I profited 4x what the producer received So some capital is flowing to the poorer producers, but not nearly as much as is flowing to every single other person in the supply chain. And if the amount flowing to the producer is only the bare minimum required to live...
- vladTheInhaler 6y agoWho specifically has control of that capital? I'd be willing to hazard a guess that it's not the Bangladeshi textile workers or Congolese miners. And meanwhile the real, tangible wealth is leaving their countries in shipping containers. So on balance, a bunch of resources (labor, fossil fuels, raw materials) are being expended in order to transport valuable goods from a poor place to a rich place. And in exchange a couple of bits were flipped in an account belonging to a local power broker. Hard to see how that does anything other than further impoverish the "client" nation. And all the companies involved are incentivized to perpetuate the status quo, in order to maintain access to cheap labor and natural resources. And we have seen that historically they are more than willing to undermine countries that are threatening their profits [1] [2] [3]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1953_Iranian_coup_d%27%C3%A9tat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1953_Iranian_coup_d%27%C3%A9ta... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1954_Guatemalan_coup_d%27%C3%A9tat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1954_Guatemalan_coup_d%27%C3%A... [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overthrow_of_the_Hawaiian_Kingdom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overthrow_of_the_Hawaiian_King...
- carapace 6y agoI threw in the towel (on predicting the future) when Twitter became a thing. I remember reading a "Penny Arcade" comic about Gabe (or is it Tycho?) "micro-blogging" about his defecations, and being deeply puzzled. Pretty much my rule of thumb is, if you didn't predict Twitter you have no idea what's going on. Even Alvin Toffler didn't predict Twitter. - - - - FWIW, I think the sane response to complexity of modern society is a kind of physical conservatism, similar to how the Amish live (but with slightly more technology.) The idea is that you rely on old highly-stable systems (not to be obscure but I'm talking about mimicking ecosystems for our fundamental needs: food, clothing, housing, [most] medicine) and then introduce carefully those aspects of our "modern space-age-a-go-go" civilization that are really indispensable and low-risk.
- aogaili 6y agoYeah, I think that would be reasonable approach..
- Benjammer 6y agoThis just in, complexity is hard, more at 11 We can think effectively about complexity the same way we've always done it, abstractions, facades, black-box thinking, compartmentalization, etc. The concept of "understanding" a complex system in its entirety is futile to begin with, that's why we call it "complex," that's what that word means. Are we really going to sit here and say that any one person, at any point in time, was ever capable of grokking an entire societal system of any kind? You think the village chieftain of a 300 person village back when humans first discovered agriculture was capable of "understanding" the entire system required to simply feed his village on a daily basis? This all seems like pandering to identity-driven, individualistic cultural trends rather than any actual analysis of humans or society or complexity in the world.
- natmaka 6y ago> The concept of "understanding" a complex system in its entirety is futile to begin with, that's why we call it "complex," that's what that word means. Complex: "a whole made up of complicated or interrelated parts" Complicated: "1: consisting of parts intricately combined a complicated recipe complicated machinery 2 : difficult to analyze, understand, or explain" The thesis here seems to be that an excessively complex system becomes complicated, and that nobody is able to understand a very complicated huge system to the point of being able to control it. "Jacques Ellul’s claim that technique became an autonomous phenomenon during the middle of the 20th century, and subsequently a system, means that the influence people have on technique is much less decisive than the influence technique has on people." (Willem H. Vanderburg, 2004)
- btilly 6y agoThe series looks to have a lot of interesting information, but a lack of understanding of important economic principles leads the author to believe that the result is much worse than reality. It is absolutely true that our globally connected infrastructure allows supply chains to explicitly take advantage of the fact that there are places where people are willing to work in sweatshops. And this results in creating more sweatshops. BUT, as is documented in Pinker's _Enlightenment Now_ and elsewhere, this is officially a Good Thing. The reason why people are willing to work in those sweatshops is that it beats spending your day bent over in a rice paddy and praying that you'll grow enough not to starve. And once there is a sufficient supply of people with the skills to work in a factory, a better class of sweatshops move in, and pay higher wages. This eventually forces the bad sweatshops to find a new place where people are still desperate to move in to. The result is that the Industrial Revolution is not done. Its leading edge is textile sweatshops. They move in, and improve life. And when they do, it is a signal that life is about to get better for everyone. And when it gets good enough, they move out. To give a sense of scale, in recent decades, we've averaged that 250,000 people PER DAY come out of extreme poverty. Historically extreme poverty was the norm for over 90% of the human race. And today we are looking at ending it entirely within our lives. Then we'll have to face a change in dynamic. Once there is no place where a sweatshop is an improvement over existing life, the textile industry will have to reform. But for now, they are the first rung on the ladder to prosperity. And a system that makes it more efficient to offer that rung to those who are still desperate is helping create a future with prosperity for all.
- imbnwa 6y ago> And once there is a sufficient supply of people with the skills to work in a factory, a better class of sweatshops move in, and pay higher wages. Why does that necessarily happen?
- danielor 6y agoThe flip side of this argument is that there exists someone that can make sense of these complex systems. What is true is that no one single person can understand every aspect of the complex world we live in. I am not too sure that is a problem, as long as you are willing to accept that your agency and understanding are rather limited.
- odorousrex 6y agoMoloch the incomprehensible prison! Moloch the crossbone soulless jailhouse and Congress of sorrows! Moloch whose buildings are judgment! Moloch the vast stone of war! Moloch the stunned governments! Moloch whose mind is pure machinery! Moloch whose blood is running money! Moloch whose fingers are ten armies! Moloch whose breast is a cannibal dynamo! Moloch whose ear is a smoking tomb! Moloch whose eyes are a thousand blind windows! Moloch whose skyscrapers stand in the long streets like endless Jehovahs! Moloch whose factories dream and croak in the fog! Moloch whose smoke-stacks and antennae crown the cities!
- cambalache 6y agoThis is a very weak article.It's very telling about the naivete(or arrogance?) of the author to conflate the US with the world. No, dear hipster "novelist", the world didnt suddenly turn out incomprehensible since some Americans chose Trump.Read some history, travel a little more, leave your coastal liberal bubble and you will see that as long as there have been humans in significant numbers the world has been complex and chaotic. You wont explain anything of value in your upcoming articles.
- Triv888 6y agoAI will fix that, then there will only be AI that we won't understand.
- lcall 6y agoMore things convince me that trust is earned by behavior over time, not by anything else, including promises, words, appearances, group membership, etc. (Forgiveness is required; trust is earned.) And trustworthiness matters very much. To choose whom to trust, it seems one needs to have and look for core principles, starting perhaps with honesty, kindness, etc.
- juancn 6y agoThe world has always been too complex for any human to understand. Any time we thought it wasn't it was just an illusion. The only difference is that now we have more information and information moves a lot faster than before. So the time we have to digest and filter out the noise is much less, so we feel confused, worrying about things that should be of no concern to us, since we cannot possibly do anything about them. I think we collectively worry too much. Before there were gods and kings whose job was to take the worry away, we don't have that anymore.
- WarOnPrivacy 6y ago> In other words: No one’s driving. I offer that throughout modern history, awful people were driving. Often monsters. Maybe no one will be better.
- known 6y agoReminds me https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Complex_interdependence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Complex_interdependence by https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joseph_Nye https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joseph_Nye
- ivan1783 6y agoWhat's crazy to me is: I work on one of the more complex electromechanical systems in passenger cars. It has gotten to the point where there is no single person that understands the entire system and all of interdependencies. But...it WORKS. I guess you can scale this to the world, nobody understands it but somehow it still works. Pretty cool.
- devnull255 6y agoHas it really though? Or is it more the case that most modern humans are being flooded with unprecedented loads of data about the world and have not been sufficiently educated in systems thinking to recognize the world as interlocking systems? The opening bit in the article about the shipping container captain receiving electronic orders to slow the ship's speed doesn't necessarily show our willingness to accept orders without question from an algorithm. But it does reveal a lot about how the author may not quite understand how shipping schedules work, or grasp how things like overcrowded shipping ports, available dock personnel and functioning equipment may result in congestion that delays or even prevents unloading product from the ship. It seems more likely that because information technology has become so ubiquitous in our lives, modern humans have become more detached from the world it, unable to recognize the real-world objects and processes it represents.
- aogaili 6y agoI'm interested in the topic complexity in and managing it, and would love to hear any suggestions/sources to read. As for this thread, what I'm seeing is: - the thesis of this article is that the world is getting more complex for humans to understand - Some argue the world was always complex but now we're understanding it more - Some say yes but we are adding our own complexity to the natural world - Some say, it not not necessarily much more complex it just that there is a lot information out there for any individual to grasp in their lifetime. There seems to be some truth in each of those arguments. So to sum up, the world was always complex, but recently we started to uncover this complexity, and in order effort to uncover and manipulate the physical world, we've introduced our own complexity and systems. Makes wonder, once most of human needs are met and we stabilize with the ecosystem, will the complexity we introduce to the world also stabilizes?