12 ms·
There’s a lot of talk in the HN comment section recently about the death of general computing and the open web. I’m not convinced. There’s definitely closed p
by mulmen 6y ago
There’s a lot of talk in the HN comment section recently about the death of general computing and the open web. I’m not convinced. There’s definitely closed platforms both hard and soft but the web still exists and general purpose computers are still available.
When I see these complaints I see people talking about how they want other people to use the Internet and computers. That smells like authoritarianism.
If you want to contribute to an open web then do it. It’s not your job to get our metaphorical racist uncles on mastodon or something. Why would you even want that?
The romanticized “old web” was just a product of massive selection bias that still exists. If you want that experience it is still out there. Just stop worrying about what other people are doing.
- chii 6y ago> they want other people to use the Internet and computers.' they want other people's content to be available on the open web (not just their own content).
- fractalb 6y ago> they want other people's content to be available on the open web (not just their own content). It’s precisely because of that the biggest corps of the current day came into existence. Is it even possible for Google, Amazon, Facebook to become this big without the free software that was available on the web?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mulmen 6y agoCould free software exist without closed hardware and software? Was anything created in an ideologically pure vacuum?
- anonymou2 6y agoOriginally all software was free, it just wasn't called that because there was no closed software. It was shared like cooking recipes.
- raxxorrax 6y agoFacebooks success wasn't certain, but it did happen. You can start a better social network now, but success is far less likely than that of Facebook was previously.
- op03 6y agoBut the content is not unique. And its much more apparent when 4 billion chimps have been brought into one zoo, are watching each other 24*7, copying each other at the speed of light based on some weird ass reward system that props up the most over energetic over confident characters in the world. The Newton's and Van Gogh's of such a world are never going to surface.
- mulmen 6y agoThe greatest insult you can speak on HN is to tell someone their post sounds like it belongs on Reddit. There is no Internet with 4 billion hypothetical 1990s Internet users. We are living the Eternal September. To some extent closed platforms are the tourist districts of the Internet. They keep the unwashed masses away from the valuables.
- 0xbadcafebee 6y agoEven completely closed systems can host open systems, as long as contracts don't forbid it. It's really all about the money. AOL, ISPs, POPs, Microsoft, etc were never either stupid or philanthropic. They saw money in the distance and they built platforms to collect it. The best way to "save the open web" is to make money off it.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tehjoker 6y agoThis idea means whatever exists on the open web is trying to exploit whatever people use it for money. Not thanks. Another possibility is a strong enough social movement to demand the de-commercialization of significant parts of the internet. For example, nationalize facebook, make it more difficult to spend money on the internet, ban or severely limit advertising, and other ideas if one were to be so bold as to suggest them
- shadowgovt 6y agoIn essence, I'll worry about the death of the open web when people can no longer make mcbroken.com
- jakelazaroff 6y ago> When I see these complaints I see people talking about how they want other people to use the Internet and computers. That smells like authoritarianism. It's authoritarianism to politely suggest that people do things differently? No one is proposing that we outlaw the corporate web… we're just trying to make the web a little less corporate.
- mulmen 6y ago> It's authoritarianism to politely suggest that people do things differently? There are frequent demands in the comment section of HN to break up Google, Facebook and Amazon. There is a comment in this very thread suggesting nationalizing Facebook and banning advertising. So no, your straw man does not stand. There is already an open web. You are free to host whatever you want. The authoritarianism I speak of is when you tell other people what they can and cannot do, politely or not.
- sk2jwhfid 6y agoThe people who want to break up tech monopolies aren't doing it because they want to tell people what to do. They want to break them up because they are strangling competiton and leaving consumers with less choice. You are acting like people using these apps is a sign that they like things better this way. Consider that, once the network effects are large enough, the end user doesn't really have a choice. So you can't claim people prefer things the way they are. This thread is proof that there are many people who want the web to be more open, but feel stuck with more centralized options.
- mulmen 6y agoI agree there is an argument to me made that competition has been stifled, in fact I agree that it has. But that is separate from the romanticized "old" or "open" internet I am speaking of. You have again invoked users. I'm making the argument that the romanticized "old" or "open" Internet is actually an exclusive clique populated by the Intelligentsia and it still exists. The people who use Facebook didn't leave this old internet, they were just never on it. And beyond that, if they did join it they would just ruin it anyway.
- mrtksn 6y agoThe web is horrible now because of the tooling and the functions. The tooling is bloated, very heavy codebase and the million ways to do the same thing even gave a way for Google AMP and despite developers hating it AS A USER I always tap on the search result with the lightning icon because it means that it will load fast and give me the text I am looking for right away. Also, the functionality or business model usually needs to recognise you. So the first time you visit a website you have to go through the install process. To use a website, the first thing is, you need to decide how much you should be tracked so you have to deal with the tracking settings(BTW, no EU doesn't make anyone to put tracking consent popups, it's just that somehow the Web people decided that they must track and this is the way to do it). The next step of the website installation process is, creating an account. If the website provides periodical content it will slap you the "subscribe to our mailing list" pop-up. For some reason the close buttons usually work slow for me, takes multiple taps on the (X) to close this. It will have this annoying fade-in, fade-out effect with the content barely visible beneath it. Then comes the monetisation part of the install process. I will be presented with %80 suggestions to do something else instead of using the website that I just installed(in other word, ads) and there would be %20 content and most of the times that content would disappoint me because it is yet another low quality thing that was made to take me there and show me the %80 of the page and collect my information. Do you know why the old web was great, in my opinion? Because we were freeloading the great pre-web content and the tooling was just advanced enough to show it to us but not advanced enough to make money from us. The interactivity made the fun even greater but what we were doing was freeload the old content, create some new content and do all this on some investors dime. Now these investors own the thing and want their money back back and they are not sponsoring the "open web", so anyone trying to do anything on the web must pay from the pocket or make the experience horrible so can monetize it. The web is dying because no one wants to pay for it. The people who used to pay for it (the investors) no longer pay, the remaining good quality web is just a sidekick for their actual business.
- Proven 6y ago> AS A USER I always tap on the search result with the lightning icon because it means that it will load fast and give me the text I am looking for right away. Nothing wrong with that but that is a choice. I installed that extension that loads AMP pages as HTML so that I never use AMP. I don't need to save that 1s and I am not ignorant enough to be tricked into using it.
- ISL 6y agoAgreed in part (and upvoted), however, I understand the frustration as an open web advocate when interacting with walled gardens like Instagram and Facebook. Rather than competing on the product/network alone, Instagram employs dark patterns like allowing only a single link ("link in bio") to the wider web. Links in comments don't work, nor do older links-in-bio persist with their original post. Facebook Groups is cannibalizing a dearly beloved two-decade-old backcountry ski forum ( turns-all-year.com ) because the user-onboarding is effortless, familiar, and integrates with other familiar walled-garden features. With the FB interface, the discussions are shorter-lived and the archiving of trip-reporting information is no longer effectively searchable. I don't know how an open-web forum with limited resources can compete against FB effectively -- suggestions are very welcome. Strategies like these are designed to gently carve users away from the open web and gather them within the garden. While not impossible to combat, they are a stout challenge for sites in the modern era.
- spunker540 6y agoI don’t think instagram’s link policy has anything to do with dark patterns. Rather it is a distinct design choice for a social network to avoid spam. Another key decision instagram made was preventing shares/retweets, with the intended effect of promoting original content. These two consequential decisions (both made very early on in Instagram history, likely even before the fb acquisition) made original photos the focus. It’s an opinionated app and has succeeded because of it — I don’t believe either decision should be called a dark pattern.
- scbrg 6y ago> Rather it is a distinct design choice for a social network to avoid spam It's not clear to me how blocking read access prevents spam.
- raiyu 6y agoDon’t forget that Instagram was originally just an app with no website. The fact that you got a website to see some posts technically is a step towards openness. =]]
- fractalb 6y ago> If you want that experience it is still out there. Just stop worrying about what other people are doing. You’re right that the old web is still there if you look for it. But there’s a difference between searching for needles in a needle-box and a haystack
- mulmen 6y agoThen build a needle box? Do your needles exist in a world without hay?
- matheusmoreira 6y ago> but the web still exists and general purpose computers are still available For how long? Computers are simply too powerful and subversive. The powerful and wealthy don't think people should have unrestricted computers. Corporations locking down computers for the sake of copyright is nothing compared to governments cracking down on truly subversive technology such as encryption and anonymization tools. It's only a matter of time before truly free computers become a thing of the past.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- iso947 6y agoDan would eventually find out about the free kernels, even entire free operating systems, that had existed around the turn of the century. But not only were they illegal, like debuggers—you could not install one if you had one, without knowing your computer's root password.
- johncolanduoni 6y ago> The powerful and wealthy don’t think people should have unrestricted computers. Citation needed on that one, big time. All of the locking down by computer vendors we’ve seen to date is pretty well explained by more boring but strong commercial benefits (e.g. app stores) and catering to users who couldn’t care less about whether their phones are “general purpose computers” and just don’t want to have to think too hard before they download an app or click a link. It’s also unclear to me how computers being able to run arbitrary code is the part these puppet masters would care about. As long as these devices have browsers (and they pretty much all do, even game consoles now) pretty much all the practical ability to be subversive is still there. I’ll worry when they outlaw/restrict at least one of: unrestricted browsers, wordpress, wordpress hosting. As long as those are around (and right now they’re highly commercially desired, so good luck to the puppet masters) you can get your thoughts out on the internet for chump change. If fixing the current state of discourse on Facebook is the last great hope for maintaining heterodox thought, we’re totally screwed even if we nationalize it or whatever.
- Qwertious 6y ago>When I see these complaints I see people talking about how they want other people to use the Internet and computers. That smells like authoritarianism. >If you want to contribute to an open web then do it. It’s not your job to get our metaphorical racist uncles on mastodon or something. Why would you even want that? Because you boycotting things won't change anything, only you plus a likeminded demographic. If you want that demographic to work with you, you have to communicate - you have to evangelize.
- solatic 6y ago> There’s definitely closed platforms both hard and soft but the web still exists and general purpose computers are still available... The romanticized “old web” was just a product of massive selection bias that still exists. If you want that experience it is still out there. Honestly, I think this is somewhat of a misnomer. You're correct that you can decide to host your own Mastodon instance if you like. But on what? If the open web really depends on general purpose computers, then it's somewhat disingenuous to suggest that people should just spin up instances on some cloud provider, because that locks people into that cloud provider. The old web didn't have that property - if you used a colocation provider and wanted to switch, you drove down, picked up your hard drives, and left. The real reason why the internet centralized was because decentralization was never truly feasible. ISPs almost never granted static IP addresses to residential customers. Today, even residential fiber connections often don't offer symmetrical speeds. And why not? Because regulators never required it of residential ISPs. You can't sell a networked appliance that preserves user ownership and control on a remote-access featureset if your market doesn't have access to ISPs that will permit that! Is it any wonder that most "smart home" appliances and gadgets connect out to a central remote service to offer access outside the home? The old web may have seemed decentralized, but it was never democratic. It had many "centers" that were non-corporate (and so, never aspired to reach the size of Facebook etc.), and with a strong selection bias for people willing to deal with colo-providers and shared hosting. Forget the decentralized web - we will never have a democratic web until people have been empowered to treat service hosting the way we think about our other rights secured under the Fourth Amendment - our persons (i.e. biohacking), houses (i.e. home appliances), papers (i.e. our personal data), and effects (i.e. wearables, automobiles).
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- iso1631 6y ago> If the open web really depends on general purpose computers, then it's somewhat disingenuous to suggest that people should just spin up instances on some cloud provider, because that locks people into that cloud provider. The old web didn't have that property - if you used a colocation provider and wanted to switch, you drove down, picked up your hard drives, and left. Same now, easier in fact. If I want to migrate from linode to digital ocean I simply restore my backup image. Indeed I do this automatically -- I have a site running on an AWS lightsail instance, which is backed up nightly to a linode server, and that backup is restored automatically onto linode with a minor script that changes the URLs from my production site to my test site. It's far more accessible than running my own server in a colocation.
- krageon 6y ago> That smells like authoritarianism. It might surprise you that the entire world is not the US, with a huge "muh freedom" fetish that somehow transcends good sense in every conversation. Just because you don't like it when people judge others for ethically reprehensible practices does not mean that suddenly they're "authoritarian". Even if it did, that wouldn't be a bad thing. Keeping society ethical is hard work and sometimes that means calling people out on their bullshit.
- raxxorrax 6y agoNot from the US but it isn't that hard to imagine where removing "ethically reprehensible" content will lead to, especially with a global perspective. I take the freedom, thank you very much. You think there is a consensus about that and there is mostly on the worst stuff out there, but that is where this common sense ends.
- johannes1234321 6y ago> Not from the US but it isn't that hard to imagine where removing "ethically reprehensible" content will lead to, especially with a global perspective. Well, in the US you don't use "ethical" reasons to remove things, but use copyright. The issue however is the same: Globally the understanding of what is "inappropriate" is different and there are overreaching attempts to take things down and different rules globally make this really hard. However "anything goes" can't be the answer either. I guess most could agree on child abuse to be unacceptable. Beyond that it becomes complicated.
- krageon 6y agoIf all you can see is "nazis everywhere" and "literally nothing allowed", yes it's going to be a disaster. The point is that there are things to discuss and agree about internationally. That's what it means to be an adult and have international politics. Black and white thinking is for primary school, when brains are still too underdeveloped to understand nuance.
- tannhaeuser 6y agoIt's not about romanticism. It's about the fact that almost all value is extracted by Google and Facebook, that the web doesn't inspire a younger generation, that reviews are gamed, that even politicians, authorities, and public broadcasters post on proprietary message boards to feed polarized masses, that there's an industry employing extortionate practices (blackout shops and restaurants not willing to pay from public presence through network effects), aggregators taking undue money for payment services, musicians having to go to "platforms" where they get screwed, citizens and pupils needing to kiss the ring of an ad company to access information, monopolies taking over web and IP infrastructure and standardization to create enormous craptastic media formats to make it impossible to create browsers from scratch, ever again. Hell, even F/OSS developers have been brainwashed to bring all their traffic to github and create fscking webapps. The web was supposed to work like http://person/thing http://person/thing but turned into http://thing/person http://thing/person. We didn't need that; that was exactly what we had before. When was the last time you went to a new website? Listen to new music? The web isn't dying; it's dead already. The only question is if we can eventually come up with a truly recommendable way to author and distribute text and other media digitally that'll serve us as well as books.
- girvo 6y agoWhat’s a blackout shop? I googled it but didn’t find much (this has become more common. Google’s search seems to get less useful for finding new info daily)
- pjmlp 6y agoFor me it just represents Linux generation coming to grips with reality, most of it they have to blame themselves by shitting on the GPL, and pushing everyone to adopt Chrome. For me, growing up with closed platforms, shareware, and tools that people actually paid for, it is business as usual.
- raxxorrax 6y agoWhat do you mean about shitting on GPL and adopting Chrome? Most Google fanboys I know have come around and accepted that it is now a publicly traded company and not the small underdogs where good engineering and design came first.
- pjmlp 6y agoIt is quite visible here every time someone posts a GPL based library/application, or the recurring mentions of using Electron, Chromebooks or Chrome developer tools.
- TeMPOraL 6y ago> When I see these complaints I see people talking about how they want other people to use the Internet and computers. That smells like authoritarianism. That's not authoritarianism, it's a reaction to authoritarianism. Internet is mass market now, and mass market is distributed authoritarianism. Individuals have no meaningful say over how computing looks for them. General-purpose computers are still available, but it's not a given there will be for much longer. There are many market incentives working against them. Music and movie industries wants to get rid of general-purpose computers to a) eliminate problem of piracy, and b) exploit customers more. Web industry side-stepped general-purpose computing entirely, by providing software as a service, hosted on company-owned infrastructure. Corporations want to control the machines people work on for reasons like espionage prevention and liability (the true meaning of "security"). This creates strong business incentives for things like Trusted Computing. Most end-users don't even understand what "general-purpose computing" means, much less care. Those who do care, are too small a group to form a market-significant niche. If talk about open web and general-purpose computing seem authoritarian, it's because it's either that or nothing. As a developer, I can spend my time optimizing my little subspace of computing for sanity and ergonomics, but I still have to interface with increasingly closed world to do anything. Despite web technologies technically being somewhat open, I still have to deal with shitty garbage websites of my bank, of stores and restaurants I order from, etc. - because I have only so much spare time to up-fix things myself. The only way we get less shitty computing is if the market is forced to deliver it.
- hedgedoops2 6y agoOne problem with the coexistence argument is state regulation. Because so much of the web is a corporate-operated SAAS, regulation is being made that assumes that everything on the internet is a corporate-operated SAAS. The people who make the laws don't understand (or really care about) the potential of networked general purpose computers who can send arbitrary messages and perform arbitrary computations. What they know is platforms and services: Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, Signal, ... The problem is that things that don't fit this mold will 'accidentally' become illegal by virtue of compliance being impossible for the authors of such software. Look at the upcoming EU regulation about encryption, terrorism related content, copyright enforcement. Everything is aimed at the platform companies but in effect regulates all software as though it were a platform. There always has to be an employee who can process takedown requests, or provide access to cops. In the eyes of "serious people" making laws, this problem does not exist, because everything that lives on the internet is a platform, backed by a corporation. There is no attempt to suppress alternatives, they are just not acknowledged to exist and matter, and thus become banned by collateral damage. If they did exist and had tons of users, those laws could never pass. The internet used to be a series of tubes, now it's a series of platforms.
- mschuster91 6y agoWe as citizens have a duty to keep politicians accountable - and that includes campaigning against those unwilling to educate themselves and getting rid of them.
- einpoklum 6y agoYou're assuming the "other side" politicians would not act very similarly. Unfortunately, that assumption is usually wrong, so merely campaigning against such candidates is really not enough.
- girvo 6y agoCurrently that’s most politicians, and effectively all politicians that are in the majority parties worldwide.
- 6y ago
- ddevault 6y ago>When I see these complaints I see people talking about how they want other people to use the Internet and computers. That smells like authoritarianism. Your comment smells like libertarianism. Exercising some influence over how others behave is not authoritarianism. You have to consider that (1) most users are ignorant of how the web works and are vulnerable to being exploited by those who are; and (2) that exploitation has a chilling effect on the rest of the open web. Technology workers have an ethical obligation to be good stewards of the technology experienced by the techno-illiterate.
- raxxorrax 6y agoI think they have the obligation to give the "techno-illiterate" the possibility for growth beyond the diagnosed illiteracy and little else, basically the exact same tools the previous generation had until it got the understanding. Don't buy an iPad for your kid. It will just get dusty because it already has a phone, which can do the exact same things. Some people think computers are too complicated for kids. I think they themselves could use an outline instead.
- snarf21 6y agoI don't think it is this. It is about monopolies. The FTC and SEC have failed us. Monopolies tend to have some positive aspects because of economies of scale but it destroys innovation and competition. Just because an unusable piece of tech exists, doesn't make it open web. Just look at the rise of Slack: IRC has been around forever but never used en masse. There should be forced interoperability given the amount of government money spent on research that created the internet and its tools.
- stjohnswarts 6y agoI think as long as there is a profit to be made it will be healthy and happy both the open web and hardware. I'm more concerned about governments removing protections like Section 230 and principles such as net neutrality. It's also why I would like to see huge companies like Facebook and Google busted up into 3 or 4 pieces. You can get "too big". I'm afraid the capitalism fails at such ludicrously large legal entities and history has shown us this.
- higerordermap 6y agoI don't think it's so much about promoting Mastodon than worrying Google Chrome may become next Flash.
- astine 6y ago"When I see these complaints I see people talking about how they want other people to use the Internet and computers. That smells like authoritarianism." Complaining about social, political, or economic trends is not authoritarianism.