22 ms·
No Config for Old Men
- TedDoesntTalk 6y ago> The base level of creative computer use is no longer exploring programming or graphics or music, but photographing a meal someone else has prepared and then applying a predefined sepia filter to said photo. Well said. The kitchen analogy is too long. I skipped most of it.
- yoz-y 6y agoExcept that it's only true because way more people use computers now than back then. There might be more indie developers making wonky stuff out there now, that there were programmers altogether in the early 90's.
- saurik 6y agoThe kitchen analogy was not too long as the people who need to read this didn't come into the article agreeing but need to be convinced; if anything I could see the article needing more analogies, but I felt this article struck a good enough balance that I could see recommending it to people who insist on "opinionated software" to seed an argument.
- EvanAnderson 6y agoI am increasingly feeling that computers just aren't "for" me anymore. Maybe they never were, and sheer novelty combined with youthful neuroplasticity helped me push through. (I am willing to chalk-up a significant amount of my dissatisfaction to being an "oldster".) Using computers is significantly less enjoyable for me now than it used to me. Updates being installed without my consent, telemetry and surveillance being forced upon me, loss of functionality when features I use aren't popular enough to warrant continued inclusion in products, and software developers who are actively hostile toward allowing "power users" configuration options all detract from the enjoyment I used to have.
- ur-whale 6y agoTime to switch to Linux and regain your lost freedom.
- lallysingh 6y agoYes seriously. I wanted more control in the mid 1990s and happily made the jump. Now you can buy machines with Linux /preinstalled/ and /supported/. 99.9% of what you use the computer for is online and websites work great on Linux. Seriously, it's one of the best times in my life to have a computer in my control. I've never had to make fewer sacrifices to run what I like than today. Even the phone scene is starting to look like it's going to be opening up in the next few years.
- echelon 6y agoIt's not you, nor is it your age. We've given up on protecting our freedoms, and our devices aren't really our own anymore. And you have people like the die hard Apple apologists / enablers that think it's fine you can't build stuff for iPhone without going through Apple. We're about to enter a trusted computing dystopia. You won't be able to run software on your laptops or desktops, and everything will be tracked. The web was the perfect platform and would have been utopia. Google sunk their claws in and neutered the browser, removing the concept of the URL, forced media companies to use AMP, and crippled ad/tracker blocking. Silos like Facebook rank content that isn't hosted internally lower, so the open web has atrophied. And iPhone has a shitty browser so it can favor apps. I don't hate computers. I hate the grifters and gaslighters that have taken the good parts away and told us our way of thinking is the problem.
- andmarios 6y agoI would add games to this list. Most games for iOS or Android these days are pay to win. Sure, they may not be as important as the things you mention, but when you start hating something that its main purpose is to be fun, is very telling of the situation.
- 6y ago
- toolslive 6y agojust migrate to Linux.
- medium_burrito 6y agoThat's way too high a bar. Linux for a personal computer is often a nightmare for professional programmers like me; for the average user it can be really miserable. Last time I used Linux as my primary environment a decade ago I ended up quitting after two years thanks to Pulse Audio and basically being able to play music 50% of the time. I think we are better off focusing on content generation tools- ie geocities, garageband, gimp, and software that is customizeable by the end user, even if they aren't a programmer- for example being able to skin the UI, or lay things out a certain way.
- zamadatix 6y agoWell I think that's just it - if you want everything to be perfect it's going to be very high bar. It shouldn't come as a surprise you can't have the simplicity and control of an Amiga and the functionality of a modern computer without setting the bar very high. It's not necessarily a failure of anything in the same way it's not a failure of space rocketry to be vastly different than how you could use a bike even though they are both transport technologies we put together.
- captn3m0 6y ago26.6% of developers in the StackOverflow Developer survey use Linux. (vs 45.8% Windows and 27.5% Mac). https://insights.stackoverflow.com/survey/2020#technology-developers-primary-operating-systems https://insights.stackoverflow.com/survey/2020#technology-de...
- loopz 6y agoThis is a fair point. Pulseaudio should be purged.
- zarkov99 6y agoYou are very wrong. Perhaps you were right once, but definitely not in 2020. Linux is, by far, the best environment for professional programmers, unless of course the programmers target the Mac or Windows exclusively.
- Orou 6y agoI'm a relative newcomer to the world of DIY computing. I had always been a Windows user growing up, didn't know how to program, and didn't know what open source was. It wasn't until 2016 when I watched Snowden that I became extremely conscious about taking control of my own devices, but it required a lot of time and effort to even know where to start. I installed Arch Linux and had to learn everything from scratch. I didn't know anything about UNIX, security, config files, environmental variables, compiling code, git, terminals, window managers, ssh, bash scripting, user groups, access control, boot options, or anything else. I wouldn't trade the time I've invested in learning how to operate and customize an open system, but the amount of upfront effort is very intimidating. I can say with confidence that if I hadn't simultaneously developed an obsession with programming that I would have very quickly given up. > The system came with a reasonable set of defaults and when or if they grew more proficient and wanted to change something about their daily working environment, they had the option to do so. This is the root of the issue in my mind, what are the 'sane defaults' for a UNIX system to someone completely uninitiated in how software works? There's so much 'don't know what you don't know' for people that only knew Windows and Mac growing up. I can't imagine anyone that doesn't work with computers professionally or as a hobbyist ever thinking that spending years learning open systems is worth the opportunity cost of the other things they could be doing with their lives.
- loopz 6y agoIt's the benefits that counts, learning and being the master of your own domain. The "cost" of learning and self-sufficiency? Sheesh!
- vangelis 6y agoSometimes you want to use your computer for other things than tinkering with your computer, though.
- c22 6y agoBut if you have the knowledge then these other things become much easier. When I was younger I used to obsessively "configure" my environment(s)... Now I usually roll with the defaults, but the fact that I've been exposed to the paradigms and methods for tinkering with my computer means it's much easier to make a minor tweak when some other task requires it, or even realize that such a tweak may be possible.
- muststopmyths 6y agoI feel the same way many times. I use what I have to for work, but I'd love to dive back into FreeBSD or NetBSD if I had spare time. They seem like they're much closer to what I used to want in computers
- 0x445442 6y agoThe issue I have with the *nix variants is the multi-user bit. This bit is for a completely different use case than personal computing.
- the_only_law 6y agoI really do the like the BSD's, but you have to be vary conscious of the hardware you run it on, as HW support for it can be rough even if it exists.
- gumby 6y agoLet me defend the current situation (more of a devil's advocate, actually, but still: this helps me think about it). The general level of programmer ability is lower than it used to be (and this is a good thing IMHO) at the same time the number of degrees of freedom has increased. Thus the more customization points, the more opportunities for something to go wrong because of some unwitting assumption made elsewhere. Just look at how many problems we still have with i18n: not enough room allocated for strings; grammar assumptions, and let's not get into BIDI. So reduced options will reduce the percentage and total number of user problems. A corollary to this is the deployment of servers: once every server was a snowflake with its own lovingly-chosen name. Nowadays servers are spun up, configured, and then erased and repurposed in an instant with nobody thinking about it. Then there's the spam and attack vectors: no longer to we craft amusing response text to server handshakes ("username accepted -- socket to me!"). You can't just operate an open SMTP server as a favor to someone who might need it. And the fact is >99% of all people cannot defend themselves against a phishing attack or avoid downloading malware that will attack someone else. Finally: the number of possible customization points has actually increased dramatically on the highly personal devices like phones: in those cases rather than expose the options (which can interact in weird ways) they are just continuously automatically tuned based on observing my use. It's all in the name of being more custom to me but I don't like it. ==== All that being said, I agree with the author that it's a shame. But my response has been different: taking a cue from the servers, I try to use as little customization as possible, both so I can switch from machine to machine easily and to avoid the problems of poorly-coded machinery. Even my emacs init file is surprisingly short (and in the 1970s my EMACS init file was a binary image memory mapped into EMACS and (as I later learned) used by a lot of people. Well those days are over.
- m463 6y agoI think of the opening to the show Weeds: Little boxes on the hillside, Little boxes made of ticky tacky Little boxes on the hillside, Little boxes all the same is this what prosperity looks like?
- onecommentman 6y agoThe song, quite popular in the 1960s among some, is titled “Little Boxes” https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Little_Boxes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Little_Boxes From which I learned that no less than Tom Lehrer, someone else youngsters should know about, thought it was “the most sanctimonious song ever written”. And he was right. On the plus side, great children’s tune and the simplicity of the lyrics match the melody and provide a nice counterpoint to the message. It perfectly captures the sour, smug, almost elitist cultural tone set by US 60s coastal urban intellectuals that hasn’t aged well over the years. I suppose you had to have been there. Surprised no one has written a parody lampooning the cultural elites of the era with the same song and lyrical structure.
- brazzy 6y agoI used to love customizing my system as well, but I've grown out of it. A highly customized environment is a timesink of its own, a source of frustration whenever you have to work in a different environment, and 90% of the customizations are pretty meaningless anyway. Give me reasonable defaults and I'm happy.
- andrepd 6y agoThe point is that while that is your choice, it might not be some one else's.
- loopz 6y agoTough luck if it's not your system. Only way forward seems to be FOSS.
- unishark 6y agoNot only that, but it's a choice for "lowest-common-denominator" users, not power users. So they will by definition make a trade off in lower real-world functionality in return for ease of basic use or other things. Like the cooking example in the article. Another example would be to replace your steering wheel without your consent with some stupid new gui and removing the option to put the steering wheel back. It works great for people who don't really know how to drive and would never be able to drive at highway speeds. Of course it does severely limit the places and speeds you can drive in your car now. Oh and of course it causes your car to crash constantly now.
- zoid_ 6y agoWhat! A default, non-personalised vim setup?!
- ziml77 6y agoSame thing here. Infinitely customizable doesn't matter to me anymore, sane defaults do. I think it was putting work into a vimrc that finally changed my mind. It was great customizing vim, getting it to be just right for myself. But there were a few things that ended up bothering me over time: * No end state meant I was just constantly toying with it and wasting time. Sometimes the changes would be minor things that barely mattered, but I couldn't decide which way I liked things more * Not always available, leading to needing to essentially remember two different versions of vim. Mine, and the default. * Keybind clashes. Bringing in new plugins was always a pain because there was a good chance that one of my custom keybinds clashed with the plugin, requiring me to make a mess of the plugin's default bindings or to reassign and relearn the colliding binding. With sane defaults, these problems nearly disappear.
- nbzso 6y agoFor Years Mac OS was "the promised land" with acceptable defaults and way for power user to customise almost everything (https://macgui.com/downloads/?cat_id=10 https://macgui.com/downloads/?cat_id=10). Even iPhone was designed with idea of web apps. After invention of Apple App Store things slowly started to rot. And now we are in moment where after one or two Mac OS iterations you will be totally closed in predictable UX patterns inside walled garden for Security reasons, etc. I am a long time Apple user and I understand that this platform is not for me anymore. Apple undoubtedly will have expansion of user base, M2 will be monster of processor and will eliminate the idea of Mac Pro tower. But trade off will be: no user control over software and hardware. For general user base this is not a problem. They feel at home because this is nothing new for them. This is iPhone and iPad experience all over. So what is the solution? The solution for me is to relearn computing. Actually things that I cannot live behind (yet) are Affinity Designer and Logic. Linux is the way for power user. Arch, Gentoo, Debian, Fedora. Plenty of choices. I discovered that learning Emacs is investment in future in which I will not depend on corporate idea of "user interface". As a long time designer I sketch and draw on paper with pencil and ink brush. In the past I successfully shipped designs with Inkscape (people were unaware of SVG) so in near future my work (if is any left) will be done without new Apple.
- asciimov 6y agoEven Linux has its issues. The groups competing for "the one right way" to do things. And the ever present issue that you are one update away from breaking something.
- loopz 6y agoMint have system restore shipped with installation. Other distros also let you rollback now.
- nbzso 6y agoI am aware of this. But at least there is no one with "Hands gathered for prayer" to babysit me with good intentions(by creating vertical integration and using slaves to maximise profit --- https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2020/11/20/apple-uighur/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2020/11/20/apple-u...). And there is always option to save image of working setup to restore from. This is personal decision and it is a result of slow and painful realisation of reality imposed by Apple ideas for UX over pro user base. And it is simple, it's a choice in experience, when I drive my car I know that I am in control and have responsibility. I just want this feeling to be present when I work - this is my computer and I have a right to control it. Apple idea of personal computer is to be a "licensed dongle" for software access. Yep, it is not exciting experience for me.
- artagnon 6y agoThe choices are still available; it's just hidden beneath layers and layers of commoditization. Gone are the days when we could grow our own spices. Not really: you just have to move out of the city, to a nice European suburb and you can have a garden. Gone are the days when we could forge our own knives. Again, not really. You have to move to some kind of village, where you have access to the local smithy. Let's talk about a trade-off that most people actually face: in the US, they drive in their oversized cars to a mega-super-market and shop for the week. In Paris, I go to my local bucherie for my meats, my local boulangerie for my breads, my local poissonorie for my seafood, and my local fruit and légume marché for my fruits and vegetables. I shop once every few days. It's a big deal for me. I get really high-quality food at good prices, with a personal touch. You'd lament about not having this choice in most parts of the US. Yes, computers have reached a new level of commoditization. So much so, that many users just use a smartphone and tablet. It's a lot more convenient than sitting at a terminal and with a cherry MX keyboard. But those choices are very much available; they just aren't available to everyone. If you really wanted, you can even design your own processor die based off RISC-V designs. And yes, you can totally build your own Linux system from scratch: I'd argue that's there's a lot more choice available in this regard. Remember the days of the simplistic GNU Stow? Today, there's Nix, and you can base your entire system on it. And use XMonad, rxvt-unicode and zsh, if you so desired; they're still maintained, last I checked. I'm sure there are packages for eccentric people to design their own cursors. FreeBSD and OpenBSD exist, and are quite viable. You could even base a system on SeL4, if you're into that sort of thing. I wholeheartedly agree that this kind of commoditization is actively harmful and stifles creativity. Cashiers and librarians are walled into their little interface; in the best case, they might figure out how to play a game of Freecell. It's sad, but this is the price we pay to put multiple little computers in everyone's hands. Choices create fragmentation, and with fragmentation, there's little incentive to keep fixing the bugs on esoteric fragments. Every choice increases the testing burden exponentially, and to avoid special-casing each combination of choices, software ends up being written for the lowest common denominator. The result is something like Linux on laptops today: the defaults are so terrible that you're forced to mess with the touchpad driver to get basic usability.
- onecommentman 6y agoThe first paragraph confused me until I read you live in Paris, I assume in or around what they are calling Paris Centre now. Relatively few (3%) Americans live in the sort of density you would find in Paris (25K/sq mi, Commune of Paris, NUT-3 statistical area). Most Americans have the kind of space to allow them to grow their own veg and herbs, or even forge a knife. (Paris should steal an idea from their more enlightened brethren in the UK and offer allotments in urban areas.) Sadly too few baguettes... Don’t be mislead by US government stats about rural v. urban population. Their definition overstates the number of Americans who live in (what Europeans would define sociologically as) urban areas. I discovered this when I perused a list of US Census urban clusters and discovered Zuñi Pueblo listed there. I can’t see how hobbyist computing with open source operating systems and legacy hardware will ever go away, and with a thriving community of interest to boot. Analog ports forever and confusion to the usurper Apple slabs... The convergence (a big fad term of the 1990s) into infocomputotainment will eventually cloy and kids will rediscover the real world, as they did in the 1970s back-to-the-land movement rebelling against conventional TV culture.
- zaptheimpaler 6y agoThe great beast of late stage capitalism is devouring computers just as it does everything else. You don’t need to control your computer sweetie just come to the store and pay us $200 to do it for you. Collectively, devs have decided that a high paying salary at FAANG justifies whatever trash they inflict upon the world. Even a highly sought after programmer is only a programmer, one cog in the machine. Keep pissing in the common pool and stuffing your own pockets. Keep dissolving every semblance of community (as a force for collective action on the world, not just buddies having a drink). This is what a divided society looks like. Easily controlled by whichever crooks happen to be in charge.
- pram 6y agolol what does this even mean? When was anything you said not the case? Were computers more democratic when they were obscenely expensive time-sharing mainframes living at places like universities and Bell Labs? Were developers ever anything other than a 'cog in the machine' at any point during the 20th century? You can't just say 'late stage capitalism' and somehow have it morph into a meaningful (or even coherent) point jfyi
- zaptheimpaler 6y agoComputers were more open and about as powerful for a brief period a few years ago, say 2012-2018. They were certainly more open for the many decades between when PCs came out and now. We didn’t just jump straight from time shared mainframes to modern PCs... Yes, great developers were much more powerful than cogs in the machine until recently. Being a dev was not a mainstream, sexy, or high paid career until recently. So the kinds of people the profession attracted were quite different. Maybe you feel anything with the words late-stage capitalism can be discarded immediately. Maybe it sounds hysterical or anti-progress. But we certainly can make technology better for non technical people without taking away configurability and freedom for experts to truly own their machine as well.
- pram 6y agoSoftware Development and IT weren't sexy or mainstream during the Dot Com bubble? That is quite an ahistorical opinion imo. I'm old enough to remember the mountain of 'Learn Java in 24 Hours' books at every bookstore in the 90s.
- black_puppydog 6y ago> I'm working against the system instead of with it, and someone else is trying to boss me around. This resonates with me a lot. I started my first "proper" job this year, and the dev env we use is pretty run-off-the-mill: docker, TS, AWS... But there is one big issue and that is that I had to switch to Windows a while back for driver reasons (looking at you, Dell and Intel) and this is the first time in over 9 year that I have used Windows proper. Not a fault of my employer I should add. In academia, and at home, I have been running Linux for ~14 years by now, so I had skipped Windows 8 and this is my first contact with Windows 10. And while I appreciate how much more stable this system is than my XP from way back when, it feels horrible, and pretty much for the reasons described here. It's not that Linux was always smooth sailing, or that it was easy, or user friendly in the conventional sense. But there is a huge difference in my relationship to the system: On Linux (and generally with FOSS software) whenever I hit a problem, if something didn't work, I could be sure that it was not there because someone didn't want me to be able to do it like that. It was always a lack of resources or insight, or both. And people and systems in FOSS are built to enable me to change things. Working on windows, I tried setting up my PC in the way described in the article. Halfway through I realized that I was just fighting against the system, trying to make it do something it didn't want. Needless to say, MacOS is not an alternative to Windows for me. They're both dead to me. Lesson learned, gonna vote with my money from now on. I started by ordering an MNT Reform for my personal use (not speedy enough for work) and I have been getting more into Rust and other tech that should allow me to get more and more of my daily activities out of the realm of "will only run on top notch hardware because we couldn't be arsed to think about performance."
- EsotericAlgo 6y agoWould this influence future employment decisions?
- dxdm 6y agoI'm not GP, but not being able to use a Linux box for work would be a big negative in a future employment decision for me. It's not just a matter of style, but also ergonomics and efficiency (also somewhat in terms of hardware when it comes to Macbook). While I'm open to change that brings improvement, a job forcing me to use tools that I've tried and know will get in my way will make me less inclined to pick it.
- readingnews 6y agoI feel this article actually does not go far enough, or perhaps is not really intended to reach the designers of linux distros, but I certainly feel it today. I am an old hat linux admin, started in 1992 from minix when I read the announcement on usenix. I have been using linux probably since day 2... I recently installed the shiny new Mint 20. I have a lot of experiences that the fictitious cook with the kitchen inspector has. Am I just getting old? Do I just want the kids off my lawn? Why is it so damn hard to find anything now? Case in point, I was using a pretty old distro on my computer, one of those dang mini-itx jobs where the BT and WIFI are impossible to turn off from the bios, but you turn them off in software. Of course, on the old linux, they were just off, you had to configure them. Well, I am hardwired in my house (again, maybe I am too old and need to be killed?) and I do not use wifi for my servers/workstations. Install Mint 20, well, first off, it wants to do WIFI, nope. Hrm, open a terminal, why isn't the wired connection getting an IP? I know, beyond all reason, that my dhcp server is working. I try to do my normal config or look in /etc... nope. It is controlled by some kind of automagic thing now. Ill just get on the inter... oh, yeah, its off. So I look around the gui, that config does not show why it is not coming on? Where is the normal "turn this on/off button in the gui? Why am I using the gui? Oh, right, my old method is long gone now" I feel like although this example could be trivial, but a lot of things seemed to have gone away. I will not rehash the systemd vs init discussion here, but it sure seemed like a lot of configs used to be easier. Here are a few that come to mind: My dns was just one text file away. My network config was a very simple cli change away. I want to change my prompt... wow, why is it referenced in 5 places in this bash file now? My path is referenced all over the place... what happened here, I will just check with the set command. OMG, what is all this stuff now? I think in our quest to make things "easier" for people, we made it a lot more difficult for those who want to change a few things and use the computer.
- pram 6y agoTBH you made the decision to install a distro that literally markets itself as 'easy to use' There are plenty of ancient distros that still need tons of manual janitoring. Slackware is still updated. OpenBSD exists. LFS is always an option. Go out and make your graybeard UNIX dreams of lovingly handcrafted network configs a reality!
- oneplane 6y agoComputers used to be new, and you used to have to do a lot yourself to make it work. This is no longer the case, which has a side-effect of taking that 'self-made' feeling away from it. This is no different than not building your own car anymore or not building your own house from scratch. While it's still possible, it's no longer viable for normal use due to the immense scale and integration required for the mass market. The only way back would be to destroy the mass market and make it small again, but that has its own drawbacks.
- stjo 6y agoLocking users in, removing configuration options and just focusing for the lowest common denominator skill set has nothing to do with “self-made feeling”. The author’s annoying clerk analogy really summarises it well.
- oneplane 6y agoThe author’s annoying clerk analogy completely misses the point. The computer isn't a kitchen, it's the oven. Or the fridge. Those are built to spec and regulation, and if you want to serve others from those you get checkups and clerks all the same. The feeling was that it is 'your domain', which it isn't as soon as you take part in a larger ecosystem (i.e. networked and vendor-supported with many users and shared services).
- asciimov 6y agoI want something in the middle. I want semi-configurable software with boring UIs. Boring because I want predictable, predictable because I want to spend the effort to learn something once and then not have to worry about learning it again.
- ed25519FUUU 6y ago> Hey, enjoy the ten new folders we've littered your home directory with! They all start with capital letters: designed for typing convenience in a case sensitive file system. This bothers me too. Is there some history to using capital letters for home folder names? It seems really out of place in case-sensitive file systems.
- asimpletune 6y agoMy guess is the directory names are meant to resemble what most people consider to be proper nouns. Like, capitalizing proper nouns is the convention, so not so much a computer thing, but a human thing. (Idk about all human languages but I think you get what I mean)
- gitowiec 6y agoIt's so true for me. 4 years ago I was just unable to work in new company where they forced me to use Mac (never used it before). I had very hard tasks and this MacBook Pro looking all sexy and shiny but unconfigurable. I'm using Linux since 10 years and Windows since 25 years. I always used "Power Tools" to configure my Windows instance, Linux has also many tools to change settings. Now in that advent of Apple Silicon I just made sight (because Apple just did beautiful revolution) and told myself "it's sorry it will never run Linux"
- august125 6y agoSadly you missed the golden era for the Mac. Back in the PowerPC days there were lots of developers making fun and useful tweaks and there was a fair amount of configurability built in. It really was a professional's Unix OS back then. Over the past decade or so I've watched the possibilities narrow with every passing version.
- oytis 6y agoUsing Arch Linux+X11+i3 WM. I believe I can configure pretty much everything. Didn't try to change the cursor though, but I can't think why it wouldn't be possible.
- skybrian 6y agoHaving computers that work well for casual users is actually pretty important. Too many people here are dismissive. Anyone who has had to help elderly relatives should know the value of computers that works like an appliance and can't easily be screwed up. Having our own computers customized to our every whim is less important because we can cope. By contrast, when something little goes wrong for less technical people, they might be blocked entirely.
- cJ0th 6y ago> Anyone who has had to help elderly relatives should know the value of computers that works like an appliance and can't easily be screwed up. The problem is they are still having trouble but I cannot help them as often as I used to.
- clircle 6y agoUsing stock Ubuntu LTS is a good middle ground between configurability and usability for me. I don't really configure anything, except a few power settings and I disable the animations. It works with my stuff out of the box. And if I want to make a change, I can apt-get to my heart's desire. I don't really take advantage of the freedom, but it's enough knowing that I could.
- iamtedd 6y agoI gave up on Ubuntu when I had a virtual machine running stock Ubuntu, where I didn't do anything with it except keep it updated, and upgrading to newer versions rendered the machine unbootable. Twice.
- hilbert42 6y agoI fully agree with this story, it's dear to my heart. There's little point in me detailing the various issues as everyone has already done that. So let me give you a very brief overview of my approach to this problem. Here, I'll leave my Linux configurations aside and only comment on Microsoft Windows (for me, installing a Windows O/S is serious business). In brief, these are the steps: • The latest version of Windows that I use (and I'm ever likely to use) is Windows 7. • I turn off Automatics Updates off by default and disable them from starting. • Occasionally, I have to turn on Automatic Updates on to install some stuff, even if the internet is not required/or not connected (Virtual XP mode for example). • When I do this, I occasionally forget that I have left Updates on and connect to the internet. If Updates go so much as even near a Microsoft server site then I erase everything and start again (if that happens I deem the system to be 'unclean' and thus I can no longer depend upon it). • I start with a 'clean' Windows 7 installation disk, specifically one with a Windows 7-sp3 on it. • I have a separate collection of 'known' KB security patches and a few other KB files, such as files associated Windows XP Mode/MS Virtual Machine, that I install. These I install first up. • I then do preliminary/rough settings such as configuring the attributes of the command box, change the Environmental settings so as the TEMP files are in the Root Directory, C:\TEMP etc. (so I can always gain access to them in a split second). • Here, I also do dozens of other tweaks and settings, the first of which is to get Explorer to display 'details' mode everywhere (in some instances this is damn nigh on impossible (why do the pathetically-little-mined authoritarian Microsoft programming Nazis shits insist that we cannot display files the way we want to)? Damn Them! Even after I tweak Explorer, I install probably the best file manager there is, Directory Opus (I can configure that mostly to the way I want). • I then nuke the following useless crap (for me anyway—I never use them), partial list only: Recovery/Restore point, Action Center, Windows Security Center, UAC/User Account Control; then I Kill and disable multiple services (too detailed to mentioned here except to mention that Windows Update is turned off and defaulted 'disabled' (I always put a note on my screen to ensue that I never accidentally enable it.) • I then install one of the greatest and most reliable freeware programs of all time — Ivo Beltchev's wonderful Classic Shell so I get my XP/Windows 2000 looks back — or I should rightly say I revert as close as is possible to IBM's CUA (Common User Access) User Interface. (Incidentally, I've put Ivo Beltchev's Classic Shell on dozens of machines and never, ever had a single moment's trouble with it. When installed, you'd think that how Win 7 came, as it integrates so well and it's so unobtrusive that it becomes 'invisible'. You can go years without realizing it's there. 'Tis a shame that many others don't use it as an example of how to do brilliant programming/programming design.) • I then install another truly essential utility for Windows, ERU for NT (ERUNT). This program automatically backs up the registry for past 30 days and allows it to be resorted instantly (it's saved me many times). • I then install other important O/S related utilities such as Nir Sofer's NirSoft utilities, Sysinternals utilities and Raspopov's excellent USB Oblivion which nukes all that Windows remembers about USB dives (it removes details about which USB drives have been inserted, etc.). • After everything is tweaked and rechecked, I consider State 1 installation to be complete. I then do a mirror backup image of the drive. • From State 1, I then proceed through various stages until I get to Stage 5, that's when I consider everything to be installed. With each stage, I install programs that progress from small, essential, reliable and stable (well know utilities etc. such as David Carpenter's Everything which I couldn't live without), through to large unstable programs such as Gimp, LibreOffice and MS Office (only up to 2003 ver however), etc. • This exercise takes me about three weeks to fully complete and involves literally thousands of .reg registry patches (of which I have a documented library of thousands). • Each stage is backed up separately, this means that if I discover a significant problem in Stage 4, I can reload Stage 3 and then reinstall Stages 4 and 5 from there (this saves a great deal of time as one doesn't have to start from scratch). Also, it's worth noting that the majority of installation time is taken up with fiddly, time consuming O/S adjustments, these mostly in occur in the early Stages 1 & 2. (In one machine, Stage 1 has not required tweaking since 2015, as all other tweaks could be made further up the line.) •Windows is configured so no essential user data resides on the Operating system drive. That's the brief version. Oh, BTW, every change on the O/S is documented, which amounts to several reams/over a 1000 pages of info. Whenever, I blow up Windows or it gets too dirty, it only takes me about 6/7 minutes to stream a fresh working copy of say Windows 7-Stage 5 and I'm up and running again (it's really dead easy and very quick to be back in business). Right, this is one hell of an exercise, but over the years it's paid off big-time. Now you ask yourself, would I ever upgrade to another crappy version of Windows again when these days that exercise would be nigh on impossible with Win 10. Not in you damn life I wouldn't! Right, I'm stuck on Windows 7 forever. Next time I have to upgrade, I rekcon I'll only be left with Linux and its kludged brother, Android. Bye, bye Microsoft. Oh, I forgot to mention the obvious, which is that most of this messing about would not have be necessary if Microsoft had made it easy to configure the Windows Operating System from the outset.
- basicneo 6y agoAs functionality increases, configuration knobs cause a combinatorial explosion in testing and compatibility concerns, which disincentivises them. As an alternative, I choose to use stable platforms that are designed with modularity, strong abstractions and internal programmability, so I can choose when to keep a particular workflow/UX, and when to adopt a newer style. That platform is Emacs.
- drewcoo 6y agoThings made to lock out makers are a slippery slope: loss of the right to configure leads to loss of the right to tinker leads to loss of right to fix Apple, which used to be for hackers, did this when they started selling a machine with no schematics available: the 1984 Macintosh.
- erik_seaberg 6y agoNo schematic, no expansion slots, and a case sealed with security screws.
- garethgriffiths 6y agoThe article correctly argues that we should be able configure computer interfaces to our liking, something that I gave up years ago and now stick to defaults (including non-invert of the yolk in video games). Since accepting the default state when there's an update and the interface changes for the third time in a year I just get on and learn whatever I am confronted with and as a result I have lower blood pressure. The only constant is change. Go with the flow. Yadadadaaa
- lopmotr 6y agoYes. After removing "3D Objects" and other stupid useless folders from File Explorer too many times and having the re-appear randomly some time later, it's easier to just give up and just try to tune out all the rubbish they shove at you.
- kabes 6y agoMaybe this is what linux desktop needed to finally break through. But not yet, only after everyone realizes how much freedom they gave up in a couple more years
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- gorgoiler 6y agoA lot of people on Hacker News are, I imagine, in a place of relative computing privilege. You probably have root / super user status on your work machine. I do not. The IT department is the super user. Everything is a battle. Nothing gets changed without a multi-hour / -day back and forth with the “IT service team”. To be charitable they could be described as a very resource limited team who are forced to ruthlessly prioritize requests. Realistically they are power drunk gatekeepers. The answer is usually always “no”. It’s a whole new world of bullshit that I’d forgotten existed. The last time I encountered this was in the education sector in 2004.
- stjohnswarts 6y agoI worked at a company like that. They worked on top secret projects so everything was locked down as tight as you would imagine. I literally couldn't install anything that wasn't in the approved software library/installer. I had them add a few things (which took weeks) that I used. I enjoyed the programming but ultimately I got tired of it and moved on.
- userbinator 6y agoAs a developer (native code, admittedly), I refuse to work for any company who does not give me root/administrative privileges on my work machine. In your situation, my advice is to make management very aware that it's wasting time, hurting productivity, and ultimately the company's bottom line. Something that impacts profitability is going to get more attention.
- yarcob 6y agoThe problem is that IT departments are really good at coming up with excuses why they need to lock everything down (eg. because of GDPR compliance), so the usual result is that employees just use web apps instead of more secure local apps that they can't install, or just use their personal devices instead.
- toyg 6y ago> employees just use web apps It’s all fun and games until IT ticks the “filesharing sites” option in their censorware proxy config, and poof, no Dropbox, no Drive, no Gmail...
- CGamesPlay 6y agoMy experience in the last few years has been the opposite. I've recently found that my stubbornness has resulted in me investing in alternative solutions to my problems that are hand-tailored to exactly what I want. Some examples: - I take notes profusely, but I'm dissatisfied with every note taking app. I have rigged up Typora (a Markdown editor) to an Alfred workflow to build exactly the solution that I want. I guess Alfred is the "saving grace" here. - I can't find a good podcasting app (I want to listen on my Mac, not on my phone). Eventually I just settled on The Old Reader subscribing to the podcast RSS and download the files manually to play in VLC. Works great, if you don't want a seamless UI. - I, like I'm guessing everyone in this thread, have a very customized terminal shell. The customization environment here is thriving more than ever before and doesn't show signs of being trampled by any integrated solution. What's the common thread? GUIs. GUIs are hard to make customizable, and the returns on doing so rapidly diminish with the number of non-power-users. If you discount GUIs, there's tons of customization to be had on your computer right now.
- jgwil2 6y agoCan you tell more about your Alfred workflow? What problem does it solve and why do you prefer it to a scripted solution?
- CGamesPlay 6y agoI published it here, actually: https://github.com/CGamesPlay/pilikino#alfred-workflow https://github.com/CGamesPlay/pilikino#alfred-workflow That is the repository for a Markdown full-text search engine that I use, although if you wanted you could modify it to use the normal Spotlight search.
- dj_mc_merlin 6y agoThis just reads like someone who needs to install Arch one weekend. It's configurable to your heart's content. Right now my clock is a notification I bring up using a key-bind to a bash command to send the time to my pop-up server (which I also chose). It's absolutely useless and my previous status bar was better but it is configurable.
- walterbell 6y agoSecurity and Configurability are not in conflict. But we need "developer unlock modes" where we can prototype desirable workflows and associated MAC policy. On iOS devices, Apple Configurator is a good start and the XML policy files can be generated by OSS software. But there's currently no user-controlled way to prototype and request new policies, outside of jailbreaking.
- mch82 6y agoRelated to this topic, check out this lecture from a designer with GE appliances... https://youtu.be/TfCn4B8QzXg?list=PLbnsTpgUhcOfzC4qbV3n3R55Zg_HT4tjY https://youtu.be/TfCn4B8QzXg?list=PLbnsTpgUhcOfzC4qbV3n3R55Z... > Now imagine if you couldn't organize your kitchen to your heart's content. Not because you're lacking the funds or skills, but because some federally appointed clerk is constantly coming to inspect it. It turns out we live in this world more than we realize :-) You can buy a handmade car from http://themetalsurgeon.com http://themetalsurgeon.com ...and they’re amazing! Yet, most people buy prebuilt cars from dealers, choosing from just a few options.
- saurik 6y agoAnd yet, there is a pretty intense car aftermarket (minus the now sudden shift to having DRM on engine components). I think you are conflating "able to be modified by the hand of the owner" with "able to be modified at the direction of the owner": the intrinsic complexity increase leading to the former sometimes being unrealistic doesn't imply the latter is as well... my mother didn't build her kitchen cabinets, but she definitely directed the process, and she did not need permission from the company from whom she bought her house.
- jsz0 6y agoBe careful to mid the gap between personal preference and obsessive/compulsive like behaviors. When personal preferences start to become a burden it time to re-evaluate them. Some preferences will be worth keeping but many will not.
- dbsmith83 6y agoUI developers tell us how an app should look, never mind how you would like it to appear... Snap developers tell us they won't let you disable an update on our own systems, never mind if we don't want to update... It feels almost like there is some arrogance going on nowadays in the industry. Nowadays, if software is not customizable or if it forces updates, I will look elsewhere for alternatives. It has actually started to inspire me to start some new side projects.
- andi999 6y agoWell the "Today, I can't even change the system font in Windows. I can select an "accent color", but most applications completely ignore it." part is a bit ambivalent. Doesnt this actually mean, that the programmers have the freedom to ignore the 'accent color' which the article is somehow arguing for. (the alternative would be that the OS mandates functionality of app in a very intrusive way)
- carloc 6y agoI'd go nuts without my arch linux and i3 for this very reason.
- vages 6y agoThis seems like the complete opposite of this post, which was on the front page yesterday: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25232989 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25232989
- hartator 6y agoIt’s odd, I am aiming for almost the exact opposite. Avoid custom configs as much as possible. And stick with the defaults as much as reasonably possible. To continue the kitchen analogy, there is no point of having your oven have a ton of custom configurations: it confuses people who are going to use your kitchen (other softwares which expect download folder to be in a specific spot.) and when you do use someone else kitchen (like pair programming or being a on a virtual severs) you’re lost.
- alecigne 6y agoI think there should be a compromise. Use your own config but be ready to switch quickly to a more "common" config and know how to use it (whatever common means in your context, just adapt to your team). For example I use i3, and I switch ctrl and caps lock. During my first pair programming experience my colleague was struggling with all that and I was feeling quite guilty ("maybe this need to fine-tune everything is just immature after all"). After this I made sure to be able to switch quickly to a "vanilla" Gnome setup. Although coming back to Gnome after using i3 is quite easy since the Gnome paradigm is quite universal, there are some alternative "configs" that I am afraid to adopt, such as exotic keyboard layouts ("bepo" in french instead of "azerty"). Losing the ability to type on this de facto standard layout would be quite problematic.
- oxinabox 6y agoConversely, I feel like a lot of time configuration is lazyiness on the part of the designer of the software. Like "can't workout the best way to do this that works for everyone. Screw it lets put in all the options we can think of and make the user chose and we will have a default of disabling this feature."