11 ms·
Wage Theft Is a Much Bigger Problem Than Other Forms of Theft (2014)
- projectileboy 6y agoI totally agree that wage theft is a real problem, but the comparison is disingenuous. A more meaningful comparison would be wage theft vs employee shoplifting (which still, obviously, does not justify wage theft, but is in fact a much larger amount).
- aussiegreenie 6y agoTens of billions are stolen from employees and nothing happens.
- paulpauper 6y agoConsider an alternate universe in which there is no unpaid labor . you think that the unemployment rate would be higher or lower? OR that prices would be higher or lower? A variable amount of unpaid labor is built into the economy. Eliminating it would have all sorts of unforeseen and possibly undesirable consequences.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- kevinmgranger 6y agoIf this is remotely true, it's the best indictment of our economic system that I've ever seen.
- tyrust 6y ago>in fact a much larger amount Citation?
- cousin_it 6y agoYeah, I suspect that both wage theft and {employee slacking + employee shoplifting} could aggregate to really large numbers.
- reitzensteinm 6y agoNow subtract unpaid overtime.
- ianmobbs 6y ago"Employee slacking" is not illegal, but wage theft is.
- leetcrew 6y agokinda depends on what type of "slacking" we're talking about. so called "time theft" is essentially fraud, which is definitely illegal. usually not worth the effort to prove when you can just fire people.
- MisterBastahrd 6y agoI did this as a kid. I was 11 years old and hired by a country club to clean restrooms and the grounds around the swimming pool during the summer. I had to be in and out before the first guests arrived because I wasn't a member. They decided to pay me $1.85 an hour when the minimum wage was $3.35 or so at the time, but I had no bargaining power because I was legally under age. Our timesheets were paper and the club had no surveillance, so I gave myself 1.5 hours of work every day because I was a quick worker (the person I alternated with took more time anyway) and they were assholes.
- thebean11 6y agoDo you think salaries are based on employees giving 110% effort every day? People have off days, get bad sleep, get sad etc. All of this is (must be) factored in already. You don't owe them for being human.
- ska 6y agoAre you saying total value of employee shoplifting is higher than total value of wage theft? That sounds surprising, do you have a source? Are you including all kinds of fraud, not just shoplifting? For that matter how are the estimates of employee vs. customer shoplifting separated?
- spottybanana 6y agoQuickly googling, here is an estimate that annual shoplifting value is 15-20 billions. Should be quite easy to find data on this because companies probably research it a lot - might be skewed ofc. https://www.securitymagazine.com/articles/92309-annual-retail-theft-survey----more-losses-from-shoplifters-and-dishonest-employees-in-2019 https://www.securitymagazine.com/articles/92309-annual-retai...
- Apes 6y ago> employee shoplifting ... is in fact a much larger amount Could you share your numbers on this, please?
- jakelazaroff 6y agoHow is the comparison disingenuous? The point is that the attention that different types of theft receive is disproportionate to how much is stolen in aggregate.
- leetcrew 6y agothe linked article is comparing robbery and wage theft based only on the dollar value stolen. by definition, robbery is theft that involves (the threat of) physical violence. when I worked in restaurants, I had a boss that would routinely reach into our tip jar to pay himself back for mistakes we made. it fucking sucked, but not nearly as much as having someone threaten to end your life on the spot.
- mlyle 6y agoIt's completely disingenuous, comparing wage theft to robbery... deliberately excluding burglary which is massive in comparison.
- dredmorbius 6y agoVictims of burglary offenses suffered an estimated $3.4 billion in property losses in 2018. https://ucr.fbi.gov/crime-in-the-u.s/2018/crime-in-the-u.s.-2018/topic-pages/burglary https://ucr.fbi.gov/crime-in-the-u.s/2018/crime-in-the-u.s.-... If these findings in New York, Chicago, and Los Angeles are generalizable to the rest of the U.S. low-wage workforce of 30 million, wage theft is costing workers more than $50 billion a year. TFA: https://www.epi.org/publication/epidemic-wage-theft-costing-workers-hundreds/ https://www.epi.org/publication/epidemic-wage-theft-costing-... Total wage violations estimated at $40 billion: https://i.redd.it/grnr8kxbl6zz.jpg https://i.redd.it/grnr8kxbl6zz.jpg
- mlyle 6y agoYou're missing that they picked "robbery", excluding the much larger "burglary" and "shoplifting" and "fraud" categories. They then say "Much bigger problem than other forms of theft"... Implying "Much bigger problem than [all] other forms of theft" instead of "Much bigger problem than [some] other forms of theft". And, if you're going to go with broadly estimated (and somewhat questionable) numbers, then surely you need to consider the ~$50B estimated lost to retail theft each year. Don't just compare $933 million proven lost to wage theft to the over-precise $340,850,358 aggregated from some robbery reports (really, 9 sig figs?) and call it "other theft". Not to mention that that $933M "recovered" includes many cases of trebled damages... Wage theft is important. But make an honest case.
- dredmorbius 6y agoI gave you the FBI's own burglary numbers. You have issues with those?
- 6y ago
- ojnabieoot 6y agoIt is not “in fact a much larger amount” - it actually looks to be about the same. The article estimates about $50bn wages are stolen every year, while [1] suggests about $50bn is stolen/embezzled by employees every year. I will add that even if the net amount is the same, it is much worse morally to rob a worker than a business. [1] https://www.cnbc.com/2017/09/12/workplace-crime-costs-us-businesses-50-billion-a-year.html https://www.cnbc.com/2017/09/12/workplace-crime-costs-us-bus...
- skrtskrt 6y agoWithout evidence, I would also imagine that the poorest workers are most hurt by wage theft, and not equally "benefited" by theft/embezzlement.
- woopwoop 6y agoColor me genuinely surprised. I would have guessed that wage theft was much larger. Experience suggests to me that ~everyone has been pressured at least once to roll hours forward to avoid overtime, but most people don't shoplift.
- loeg 6y agoThere may be fewer embezzlers with disproportionately high average theft, probably with a much more skewed distribution (a few very large embezzlements covers a lot of minimum wage hours).
- thatguy0900 6y ago
- cbozeman 6y agoThis only works if you're considering work as "hours worked" versus "impact and output". I've had this conversation with several employers. They're not paying me for how many hours I was at my desk, they're paying me for my economic output and my impact on the organization. I get not every single job can have this level of flexibility, but the amount of "theft of time" and "employee shoplifting" that occur throughout America? I would bet my bottom dollar it isn't even close to employers' wage theft.
- walshemj 6y agoThe is the very definition of 99% of salaried grades outside of some edge cases - IE no fixed hours of work I new one company that I worked for where many salaried grades actually worked many hours every week over the "expected time"
- morelisp 6y agoFor 2/3 of low-wage workers to have been affected by wage theft, either most low-wage workers are overwhelming employeed by a small number of companies (which if true is also concerning - but not bourne out by the numbers in the EPI report), or most companies are stealing from at least some workers. That's obscene. The converse is not true. For most stores to have been affected by employee shoplifting only requires a tiny minority of employees - one per store! - to shoplift. There is also an equilibrium; in the general case employees can't shoplift more than the equivalent security measure to prevent the shoplifting would cost. The equivalent limit to stolen wages is considerably more harrowing: the workers' mental and physical health. Collectively this means shoplifting can be addressed by fairly typical business measures - additional security, hiring practices, lawsuits against individuals, etc. The infrastructure for all that is already in place, because capital already put it in place to protect itself and because shoplifting is not the norm. But wage theft requires radical or systemic change to ensure employees have the ability to punish all employers, because capital has again put measure in place to protect itself, and wage theft is the norm. Finally, there is the issue of what you're measuring. Assuming shoplifting and employer theft from low-wage workers occur at the same rate for the same percentage, shoplifting would still dominate because it's much closer to a percentage of total revenue. Obviously total revenue is higher than a fraction of wages! So how, exactly, is that comparison more meaningful?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- leetcrew 6y agoit's kinda apples-to-oranges to just compare the dollar value stolen in each category. like if I get mugged, the problem isn't just that I lost my phone, credit card, ID, and some petty cash; it's also that someone stuck a gun in my face. who knows how close they were to pulling the trigger? an employer shaving a few percent off my paycheck doesn't affect whether I feel safe walking outside the next day.
- kilburn 6y agoThat's true, but wage theft towards the lower-income people is particularly perverse. Life is much harder at those ranks, and there's not much needed to start a seemingly unstoppable demise. Those few percent off of a paycheck can mean you now cannot pay off your month's credit balance. Next month the debt is larger (due to the outrageous interests), but you still cannot pay it off because your car broke down and you had to fix it to get to work. Next month your mother got sick and you had to help her pay for some medication. Now your debt is growing faster than you can pay it off.
- lostmsu 6y agoI wonder if "employee shoplifting" actually involves no crime in its majority. My friends had experienced a few cases where they were never asked to return company equipment upon leaving, and that includes expensive laptops, phones, etc. E.g. the company was supposed to contact them to get it back, but never did. If this equipment is then simply marked as "stolen" to write-off, and this situation is prevalent in tech companies, I could see it being a sizable chunk of the "shoplifting". P.S. I don't claim literal shoplifting is not happening.
- josephcsible 6y agoThe term "shoplifting" applies strictly to goods that the company was trying to sell, not things they were using themselves, so even if non-returned company equipment were counted as stolen, it wouldn't count towards the shoplifting numbers.
- dredmorbius 6y agoFor those who like infographics: https://i.redd.it/grnr8kxbl6zz.jpg https://i.redd.it/grnr8kxbl6zz.jpg https://old.reddit.com/r/dataisbeautiful/comments/7ebdyu/billions_of_dollars_stolen_every_year_in_the_us/#bottom-comments https://old.reddit.com/r/dataisbeautiful/comments/7ebdyu/bil...
- MrsPeaches 6y agoNot sure the references for that one check out: https://www.reddit.com/r/dataisbeautiful/comments/7ebdyu/billions_of_dollars_stolen_every_year_in_the_us/dq3rtgk/ https://www.reddit.com/r/dataisbeautiful/comments/7ebdyu/bil...
- dredmorbius 6y agoSeems reasonably solid AFAICT?
- swiley 6y agoYikes! The biggest box is minimum wage violations. Those are the last people that need their wages stolen.
- spottybanana 6y agoBut the easiest group to exploit, also with least negotiating power.
- tim333 6y agoAlso sometimes the business doesn't make that much money so it's kind of that or nothing.
- dredmorbius 6y agoA business that doesn't make enough money to pay workers but provides returns to owners is a charity operated on behalf of the owners at the expense of the workers.
- zelly 6y agoWhat about employees stealing time from the employer?
- swiley 6y agoThat's probably significant but living in a world where people cared would be extremely unpleasant and likely less productive.
- alistairSH 6y agoWhat about it? It’s a different problem altogether. First, it’s not necessarily illegal. Second, there is a power disparity between employer and employee that makes wage theft hard for an employee to fight. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism
- t-writescode 6y agoCould you provide a definition? Are you suggesting full-time employees who are exempt from overtime laws working less than 40 hours a week some weeks? Or are you suggesting employees who write down that they started at 10:00 and left at 6:30 but really got in at 10:05?
- claudiulodro 6y agoHow do you define "employees stealing time from the employer"? It seems to me the only way to "steal time" from the employer would be if you literally had someone else clock in for you when you weren't there or lied on your time card, both of which generally get the offender fired and are small-scale issues. Once someone has clocked in, it seems impossible to "steal time" from the employer -- the employer is paying for the employee's presence, so it's all just shades from slacking to working hard.
- bloomingeek 6y ago<What about employees stealing time from the employer?> If an employee is caught stealing time from his/her job, they are usually fired, no questions asked. If an employer steals time from an employee, especially when the times of work were preset and agreed upon, if the employee complains usually they are reminded that there's always someone else who can do the job if they don't want to.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- hirako2000 6y agoI'm not sure this is theft.it is abuse or manipulation. The same way ripping a movie or copying an artist is not theft, that's abuse or plagiarism.
- Daishiman 6y agoNo, it's theft, plain and simple.
- cbozeman 6y agoYour second example is copyright / intellectual property infringement.
- steve_adams_86 6y agoI'm not sure I understand your logic. Isn't it abuse or manipulation performed in order to accomplish theft? How is what you're describing not resulting in theft?
- hirako2000 6y agoBecause the laborer can refuse to be abused/manipulated. A worker has all the information at hand to see he is being exploited. To me, theft is when something is taken away from someone without consent. By force or by subterfuge.
- ddingus 6y agoNo. In your infringement example, it is proper to not call it theft. Nobody is denied property they have title to. Here, people are denied property they have title to. It is theft.
- rodgerd 6y agoHonestly the comments on this - fact-free, worker-hostile - are a caricature of everything bad about HN.
- t-writescode 6y agoAre we reading different comment threads? Most people seem to have been neutral.
- cbozeman 6y agoConsider the average reader. Is it any surprise? Entirely too many founder-types think because someone doesn't throw 16 hours a day into their job, they're lazy, not realizing that most people don't share, or even give a shit, about their 'dream'.
- TuringNYC 6y agoTo take it further, a lot of founder types dont understand (or refuse to) the difference in risk-reward across employees, especially employees with different hiring vintages. I've seen orgs where employees have 500 shares, and others have 500,000 and yet others (founders) probably have 5,000,000 -- all with unknown denominators (lol) -- and all employees are expected to work at the same intensity.
- SamReidHughes 6y agoSo measured wage "theft" comes out to $3 per person per year. But it's a contract violation, not violence, so a monetary comparison is completely sociopathic. Also, this headline excludes transfer payments as a form of theft.
- triceratops 6y ago> But it's a contract violation, not violence, so a monetary comparison is completely sociopathic. Theft in general doesn't involve violence or the threat of violence. You're thinking of robbery. One merely has to illegally deprive someone of something they legally own in order to commit theft. A pickpocketing is a theft. A mugging is a robbery. Wage theft is an entirely appropriate name. You could also call it "wage misappropriation" or "wage embezzlement" (though "embezzlement" generally applies to company property) if you want to make it sound classier :-P
- SamReidHughes 6y agoThey are literally comparing against robbery. Burglary is violence too. So is pickpocketing.
- triceratops 6y ago> Burglary is violence too. So is pickpocketing. They literally are not. If I have my pocket picked or my house burgled when I'm out, I may not find out until later. There was no violence or threat of violence employed against my person. Robbery and theft are legally defined as separate crimes. The former is treated far more harshly than the latter.
- SamReidHughes 6y agoIf it takes violence to protect yourself from that trespass, then instigating that is an act of violence.
- 6y ago
- sampleinajar 6y agoFor most of my adult life, I worked hourly jobs in low pay positions and "wage theft" always meant me, the employee, stealing from the company by not working every single second I was there. Interesting to see it defined the other way, "employers’ failure to pay workers money they are legally entitled to".
- maxbendick 6y agoI think another term for that is "time theft"
- walshemj 6y agoFraud and Gross Misconduct are the terms that would be used
- ska 6y agoI think the usage here is the common one, and your idiosyncratic. "wage theft" has been consistently talked about this way for several decades at least among policy types etc.
- sampleinajar 6y agoThanks for the comment. A sibling comment points out "time theft" which I have also heard regarding an employee not working, so to speak. I can honestly say I did not read economic policy pieces until quite recently in my life, so I had not, as far as I can recall, heard it used this way. I can also anecdotally say that most management in lower paying positions in the parts of the US I have worked are rather infamous for malapropisms. edit:typo
- walshemj 6y agoIts a well known hr/ir labor law term.
- qw3rty01 6y agoThis is timecard fraud, not wage theft.
- beisner 6y agoIt’s really telling about what American society values that wage theft perpetrated by the owning class is rarely prosecuted and is considered a civil matter, while non-violent offenses including petty theft and drug possession perpetrated by the labor class (which cause orders of magnitude less fiscal harm) make up something like 90% of all arrests in the US.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoAre there other societies you have in mind where wage theft is a criminal offense? It seems to me that the difference in punishment is because of the mechanism of the theft, not a judgment that the underlying fiscal harm doesn't matter.
- beisner 6y agoI don’t know enough about other countries’ wage theft situation to comment. I would assume countries with larger union representation would experience less wage theft of this kind, but I don’t really know. I do know that other countries don’t incarcerate anywhere close to as many of its citizens as the US, especially for what amounts to a rounding-error’s worth financial loss due to petty theft (a handful of fighter jets worth).
- runako 6y agoIf the only thing that mattered was the fiscal harm, then shoplifting or embezzling or the like should also be a civil matter like wage theft. There's definitely a value judgement involved in the way our penalties are structured.
- nevdka 6y agoVictoria in Australia has recently passed laws making wage theft a criminal offence: https://www.premier.vic.gov.au/wage-theft-legislation-passes-victorian-parliament/ https://www.premier.vic.gov.au/wage-theft-legislation-passes...
- SpicyLemonZest 6y ago
- mkoubaa 6y agoAre we including speeding tickets in the accounting for highway robbery?
- dec0dedab0de 6y agoThis reminded me of an hourly job I had where I was expected to be there 15 minutes early, then I got in trouble for clocking in as soon as I sat down. I just told my supervisor and manager that if I'm there I'm clocking in. After that, I had permission to show up late.
- dang 6y agoIf curious see also 2018 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17216319 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17216319
- luisdfp 6y ago>"Wage theft—employers’ failure to pay workers money they are legally entitled to—affects far more people than more well-known and feared forms of theft such as bank robberies, convenience store robberies, street and highway robberies, and gas station robberies." Are we to ignore the fact that the crimes mentioned involve life-threatening situations for those affected? Apparently, human life is not as important as the amount of money lost.
- Cymen 6y agoCan happen to highly paid employees too. Since 2018, I've been owed over $20,000 USD by Surf Air (the LA-based startup in the airline business) that has failed to pay. Some of the other contractors were based out of California and even going the government complaint route has still not paid off for them. At one point, they setup a payment plan and made the initial 1 of 6 monthly payments and then failed to make the rest of them. As a contractor, I've chalked it up as yet another possible cost of doing business however it is frustrating and there seems to be very little one can do that actually results in getting paid without eating up the majority of the payment. Lawyers? See eating up the payment. Collection agencies? My experience was they were out for a quick buck but it was basically no protection from not getting paid a lesser amount (revised terms that ate into the payment). Government? See the other contractors experience -- probably will pay off but company might go bust before it happens. Going public? I think this might be the best route because at least it warns others (although typically it'll be too late). Stepping back, I'm doing just fine and I'd be far more annoyed for those who have to work off the clock at minimum wage.
- anonuser123456 6y agoYou need a lawyer. They are a cost of doing business in the contracting world. If you don't have a lawyer, you're going to get run over... over and over again.
- Cymen 6y agoUnfortunately, it's not that simple. Maybe we (myself and the other contractors involved) have been unlucky but we haven't been able to get anything done the lawyer route. I'm happy to try again but I've realized which lawyer is important and would love a referral if you have one (my email is in my profile).
- anonuser123456 6y agoThe problem may be, you're getting a lawyer after the fact. Maybe your contract sucks and you have little to no recourse. You need a lawyer up front, reviewing your contract. This is relevant for every contractor: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jVkLVRt6c1U https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jVkLVRt6c1U
- roenxi 6y agoThere are a bunch of studies showing that minimum wages don't cause drop-offs in employment. I'd never really considered that flagrant lawbreaking as a possible option accounting for that anomaly.
- ralusek 6y ago"Theft" is a poor usage of language in this context. These are contract violations, as described.
- mdifrgechd 6y agoThis is silly - it's more about the mismatch between the custom of buying a person's time and paying for the outcomes an employer is looking for. The flip side of this is that employees are stealing from their employer whenever their attention wavers from the job, for example talking with co-workers or texting or web browsing or whatever. The reality is that hourly pay is almost always a poor approximation for the expectations between employer and employee. Calling any deviation from strictly kept time for an employee in 100% service to their employer "theft" is just silly, whether it's an employee chatting about their weekend, or an employer asking for some extra minutes. Each should (and outside of artificial constructs like this article does) weigh total compensation against benefit / effort and decide if the relationship is worth continuing.
- piva00 6y ago> Each should (and outside of artificial constructs like this article does) weigh total compensation against benefit / effort and decide if the relationship is worth continuing. Really fucking hard to do that if you are an employee with no power, easily replaceable and dependent on the job to keep you and your family alive. This kind of hand waving real social struggles down to "they should just personally negotiate and be able to walk away from the deal if it's not good for them" is, at best, myopic. At worst is a lack of empathy and a very narrow worldview of labour.