14 ms·
The author obviously wants you to believe that it was the abandonment of the gold standard, but there are several other theories that have more credence with ma
by bryanlarsen 6y ago
The author obviously wants you to believe that it was the abandonment of the gold standard, but there are several other theories that have more credence with mainstream economists.
The early 70's was the start of a horrible period of stagflation: stagnation coupled with inflation. Some do blame the loss of the gold standard, but the leading theory is the OPEC oil crisis. Others blame market regulations, the EPA was passed in 1970; the late 60s and early 70s saw many financial and environmental regulations passed.
I like the oil price theory. The period of growth was a period of massive decline in the price of energy. We've since had 50 years of stagnation in energy prices. But that looks to be breaking now. If solar energy & battery prices continue to decline the way they have been, we could see energy prices decline at a rate reminiscent of Moore's law.
And energy is a massive component in the price of almost everything we consume.
- coward8675309 6y agoI'm very much with you on this. Increasing standards of living are directly tied to a decreased cost of energy. Aside from property absolutely everything can be decomposed into physical or mental effort — energy [omitted at suggestion of follow-up, merci!]. The industrial revolution allowed the substitution of wood or coal or uranium or PV cells for food that powers oxen, horses, and humans.
- hollerith 6y ago>energy (or energy * distance aka work) Your comment would be improved by omitting the words in parentheses: work is force times distance, and energy and work have the same dimensions (namely mass * distance * distance / time / time). (I agree with the rest of your comment.)
- anovikov 6y agoWhy do you think it has something to do with production? It may be simply redistribution. Less goes to employees, more to profits. Just because they stopped fearing a Communist revolution much as Communism was more and more evidently failing.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoNot in the 1970s. Maybe by the late 1980s, and even more since 1990.
- mymythisisthis 6y agoDemographics. WWII ends, you get 26 - 30 years, of a work force. The WWII generation starts to retire. Also, the factories at that point need retooling. Boomers start to enter their 20s, and start entering the workforce.
- pjc50 6y agoThe thing is, there was a lot going on in the 1968-1971 period. Everything from civil rights to the moon landings. The collapse of Bretton Woods is important, but we have to ask why and what pressures led to that point.
- xfs 6y agoI find Yanis Varoufakis' account of the history leading up to the collapse of Bretton Woods very telling: As the combined costs of the Vietnam War and the Great Society began to mount, the government was forced to generate mountains of US government debt. By the end of the 1960s, many governments began to worry that their own position, which was interlocked with the dollar in the context of the Bretton Woods system, was being undermined. By early 1971, liabilities in dollars exceeded $70 billion when the US government possessed only $12 billion of gold with which to back them up. The increasing quantity of dollars was flooding world markets, giving rise to inflationary pressures in places like France and Britain. European governments were forced to increase the quantity of their own currencies in order to keep their exchange rate with the dollar constant, as stipulated by the Bretton Woods system. This is the basis for the European charge against the United States that, by pursuing the Vietnam War, it was exporting inflation to the rest of the world. Beyond mere inflationary concerns, the Europeans and the Japanese feared that the build-up of dollars, against the backdrop of a constant US gold stock, might spark off a run on the dollar which might then force the United States to drop its standing commitment to swapping an ounce of gold for $35, in which case their stored dollars would devalue, eating into their national ‘savings’. The flaw in the Global Plan was intimately connected to what Valery Giscard d’Estaing, President de Gaulle’s finance minister at the time, called the dollar’s exorbitant privilege: The United States’ unique privilege to print money at will without any global institutionalised constraints. De Gaulle and other European allies (plus various governments of oil producing countries whose oil exports were denominated in dollars) accused the Unites States of building its imperial reach on borrowed money that undermined their countries’ prospects. What they failed to add was that the whole point of the Global Plan was to revolve around a surplus generating United States. When America turned into a deficit nation, the Global Plan could not avoid going into a vicious tail spin. On 29th November 1967, the British government devalued the pound sterling by 14%, well outside the Bretton Woods 1% limit, triggering a crisis and forcing the United States government to use up to 20% of its entire gold reserves to defend the $35 per ounce of gold peg. On 16th March 1968, representatives of the G7’s Central Banks met to hammer out a compromise. They came to a curious agreement which, on the one hand, retained the official peg of $35 an ounce while, on the other hand, left room for speculators to trade gold at market prices. https://www.yanisvaroufakis.eu/2011/02/10/surplus-recycling-currency-unions-and-the-birth-of-the-global-minotaur/ https://www.yanisvaroufakis.eu/2011/02/10/surplus-recycling-...
- bwb 6y agohmmm... dropping energy isn't going to help with the big costs families face in terms of health insurance and costs, day care, college costs, or housing. Am i wrong :)?
- avianlyric 6y ago> And energy is a massive component in the price of almost everything we consume. This includes healthcare, day care, college costs. Even if only indirectly.
- SilasX 6y agoI really don't think colleges were using 10X as much energy to operate since the 70s.
- techbio 6y agoNot wrong, I don't think, except that raising energy costs wouldn't help more :)
- peterhj 6y agoFor something searchable, see “Baumol’s cost disease.”
- lotsofpulp 6y agoI don’t understand how baumol’s cost thing is any different than lower supply of labor causing price of labor to rise, and why it would merit a special name or Wikipedia entry.
- mordymoop 6y agoIt's not just about a lower supply of labor, really. It's not cleanly captured in terms of supply and demand. The reason a string quartet costs more now isn't because there are fewer people who can play instruments, it's because other things pay better. In other words: if the average worker salary suddenly rose by 100% in every area except classical musicians (let's say there's some magical new productivity technology that increases productivity for every job except music, and further say that the workers capture that value) then the classical musician salary would also rise, because otherwise people would stop becoming musicians at the same rates. Nowhere in this thought experiment did the supply of labor change.
- christophilus 6y agoAnother plausible explanation I’ve heard is that you had a massive influx of new consumers (baby boomers) entering the workforce. You almost can’t avoid inflation in that scenario.
- patrickk 6y agoAnother one adding to your point is huge number of women entering the workforce all at the same time. You are drastically increasing families' spending power and discretionary income = inflation. Of course, when you double the supply of something, the price drops, which could partially explain stagnating wages. But in the early post-WWII decades it was a big win. Nowadays the negative consequences of moving away from traditional family roles are more obvious.
- rbanffy 6y ago> You are drastically increasing families' spending power and discretionary income = inflation. At the cost of decreasing their mobility, which prevents them from competing in nationwide labor markets, pushing down local market labor cost.
- treeman79 6y agoPeople always underestimate the cost of regulations. Even when good, the cost is big. Health care is a good example. Keeping patient data private is a good thing. However it’s also absolutely crushing in its impact in the industry. Tiny projects can take months or years. HIPPA terrifies so many IT people. Driving away top developers.
- roywiggins 6y agoIt's spelled "HIPAA."
- backtoyoujim 6y agoI'm OK with the "Move Fast & Break Shit" crowd staying far from my medical history thankyouverymuch.
- ethbr0 6y agoYou say that... but you'd be surprised how chaotically the sausage is manually made in the inner workings of health care. Provider side has it semi-sorted (at least within the same facility). Everyone else (insurance, etc) is attempting to clean semi-structured / inaccurate data passed to them, and generate a coherent result.
- kjs3 6y agoSpouse of a medical practice manager at a mid-sized practice here. Provider data is wildly variable in quality, to be sure. But if the insurance companies are trying to clean the data, they're not using the 'result' to make the system more efficient (except maybe for them at the expense of everyone else), because "we get bad data" gives them another reason to deny the claim. My wife and all of her peers spend inordinate amounts of their time responding to valid insurance denials, quoting chapter and verse of IDC10. Some insurers are so notorious (as in 'deny every claim up front...make them work for it hoping they'll give up') my wife drafts the response to the denial along with the initial request, because she knows it's automatically coming. This makes the automation possibilities that electronic patient management systems offer less effective, because to get paid the practitioner still has to manually intercede in way too many claims. Another bit of collateral damage is the increasing number of providers who no longer take insurance of any kind and put the onus on the patient to file (and fight) with the insurance companies.
- dgb23 6y agoThe graphs show two things: A relative increase of income for the wealthiest and a relative decrease for everyone else, specifically in the US. The 70s and 80s mark a political shift to privatization of public service/infrastructure and deregulation of and trade-agreements for the investor market.
- Zviedris 6y agoYeah, liberalisation just made rich richer. All that government debt went to entrapanuer not working mass. If capital accumulation is too fast then he need to put in somewhere. If that somewhere is housing then normal working people can't compete.
- TwoBit 6y agoI don't see how your first sentence follows when looking at all the graphs.
- Zviedris 6y agoQuestion is - why people where not able to save more money? From 1971 until housing crises in 2008 personal savings diminished. While top 1% earnings increasing. If you look at housing price index Vs salary then real estate rose by 250% while salary not some much. Rent increase proporsonal to housing prices. It just generates so much cash from those who can't buy it. And paying higher rent set you back from saving and buying your own. And without savings you have also limited negotiation options.
- dgb23 6y agoI like this quote from John Locke: > Our incomes are like our shoes; if too small, they gall and pinch us; but if too large, they cause us to stumble and to trip. Liberalism is not at odds with sensible resource distribution. On the contrary: A free society is rooted in participation of all, both political and economical.
- Izkata 6y ago> and a relative decrease for everyone else, specifically in the US. Actually it doesn't. The relative decrease seems to only have affected men: https://wtfhappenedin1971home.files.wordpress.com/2020/06/men-vs-women.jpg https://wtfhappenedin1971home.files.wordpress.com/2020/06/me...
- tboyd47 6y agoDidn't the OPEC oil crisis drive the price of oil higher? But then you say that the problem is that oil prices saw a massive decline. So which is it? When I look at the graph of oil prices between 1970 and 2020, I see it jumping around between $20 and $160, but they are always higher than they were in 1970. What exactly are you saying is the problem with oil prices? Are they too high or too low?
- jrk 6y ago> The period of growth was a period of massive decline in the price of energy. This is referring to the decades before 1970, not after the oil crisis. > We've since had 50 years of stagnation in energy prices. This is the period of 1970-2020. The price of oil has oscillated (jumping around, as you say) during this period, but the overall price of energy has not had a clear long-term trend. The earlier poster's argument is that the stagnation in other metrics (from a period of impressive growth before 1970) may reflect this stagnation in energy prices (from a period of impressive reduction before 1970).
- tboyd47 6y agoThanks. I prefer the Nixon dollar float theory. The OPEC oil crisis was only 6 months. And as you say, oil prices in general have not had a clear trend. So those don't seem related to what is being presented on WTF Happened in 1971. When the government can print money willy-nilly, it can finance any boondoggle it wants to. This free money would pull qualified people away from more productive endeavors. It makes sense that this trend would, over time, impoverish society and enrich those in Washington's orbit.
- iguy 6y ago> The OPEC oil crisis was only 6 months No, prices were super-high for more than a decade, before returning to let's say roughly double the pre-crisis price for the 90s, then spiking again. Or regarding recent decades as normal, 1922-1972 was a window of steady low prices. https://i.insider.com/58593c27ca7f0c20008b6b76?width=800&format=jpeg https://i.insider.com/58593c27ca7f0c20008b6b76?width=800&for...
- raiflip 6y agoA fairly simple explanation that for some reason I don't see a lot of is the drop in union membership density around this time period. Such a drop would decrease bargaining power and therefore decrease the rate of wage increase
- TwoBit 6y agoIs there a chart for that?
- raiflip 6y agoGraph created by the Washington Post: https://www.washingtonpost.com/resizer/7IbsRIhRFbTYRuEjla6kiZQOwvY=/arc-anglerfish-washpost-prod-washpost/public/YC4GHPZ5MI5DHNQVM2TN4E4JZI.jpg https://www.washingtonpost.com/resizer/7IbsRIhRFbTYRuEjla6ki... You can see union membership was on the decline since the 1950s, but it accelerated around the 70s. It is hard to see the timeline in that graph, in this one it is harder to see the acceleration, but it is easier to see the timeline: https://rpubs.com/jncohen/uniondensity https://rpubs.com/jncohen/uniondensity
- xeromal 6y agoYeah, there were a lot of key things that happened but it's hard to pin what caused everything else to blow open
- raiflip 6y agoFor sure
- throwaway-8c93 6y agoAfter having witnessed dramatic declines in union membership in new European Union members, and continuing downward trend in Scandinavian countries, I feel like the drop in membership is the consequence of unions becoming powerless, not a cause. If even the large unions cannot mount any effective pressure for increasing compensation, shrug at layoffs, and are fatalistic about outsourcing, what's the point of being a member? Anecdote from Finland: in a personal conversation, one long-term union representative bemoaned that, until mid 2000s, companies considered unions as partners, consulted difficult staffing decisions with them, or at the very least felt obliged to justify the reasoning behind companies' decisions. After the crisis, the mood all changed - spending cuts, layoffs or any changes to salaries or benefits are now presented as a done deal from higher up, any union negotiations are treated as a mere formality.
- justinzollars 6y ago> "... more credence with mainstream economists" Do you follow main stream economists today? Ray Dalio (Bridgewater), Jeffrey Gundlach (Double Line), Raoul Pal (Real Vision), and Warren Buffet (Berkshire) have made very big bets for Gold and Gold stocks because our currency is being debased at a rate we have never seen.
- throwaway2048 6y agonone of those people are economists, and that is in no meaningful way a statement on bretton woods
- justinzollars 6y agoWe have had 3 crisis in 20 years. Safe to say they have gotten some things totally wrong.
- Afforess 6y ago> our currency is being debased at a rate we have never seen. Looks at $1 gasoline. Looks at $2 eggs. Looks at $3 gallon of milk. Debased. Sure thing. (Maybe gasoline is an unfair example, but essential good prices are largely unchanged in the last decade. The point stands)
- justinzollars 6y agoSounds like you are going down with the ship. Its completely irrational to believe you can print yourself into prosperity. I could just as easily point to Tech stocks, Tesla, gold, silver, bitcoin or any other inflated commodity as a counterpoint.
- CarelessExpert 6y ago> Its completely irrational to believe you can print yourself into prosperity. This is clearly a straw man. MMT provides an alternative theoretical basis that might explain the apparent disconnect between money supply and inflation: https://www.investopedia.com/modern-monetary-theory-mmt-4588060 https://www.investopedia.com/modern-monetary-theory-mmt-4588... > According to MMT, the only limit the government has when it comes to spending is the availability of real resources, like workers, construction supplies etc. When government spending, meaning the amount of money introduced into the economy, is too great with respect to the resources available, that's when inflation can surge if decision makers are not careful.
- neutronicus 6y ago> we could see energy prices decline at a rate reminiscent of Moore's law. Please do not base your vision of the future on exponentially-growing energy consumption
- bryanlarsen 6y agoYes, sometime within the next decade, many environmentalists are going to start seeing solar as the enemy rather than as their friend. It'll provide cheap energy and it uses lots of land. Cheap clean energy by itself isn't a problem, but many of the behaviors it enables certainly are. We should be attacking the problematic behaviors rather than blaming it on cheap energy. The alternatives to cheap clean energy are much worse for the environment.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- AndrewKemendo 6y agoI find the great decoupling fascinating and I don't think it gets enough study. There are a couple other things that I think contributed: The massive increase of women joining the labor market in the US just after 1970 largely as a consequence of the widespread adoption of oral contraceptives in the young population. [1] The People's Republic Of China was formally admitted to the UN in 1971, and following that in 1972 Nixon visited - effectively opening China as an actual labor market. Edit: I think one of the major takeaways should be that, changes in worldwide monetary policy allowed for pent up demand for globalization to be realized and that accelerated shifts from onshore to offshore manufacturing. Basically it allowed the US to stop building, and start buying. [1] https://dash.harvard.edu/bitstream/handle/1/2624453/Goldin_PowerPill.pdf?sequence=4_1 https://dash.harvard.edu/bitstream/handle/1/2624453/Goldin_P...
- taffer 6y agoUntil Deng's reforms in the 1980s, China remained economically irrelevant.
- jasonhansel 6y agoI wonder if this chart is also relevant: https://commons.m.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Global_Temperature_And_Forces.svg https://commons.m.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Global_Temperature...
- rbanffy 6y ago> The massive increase of women joining the labor market in the US This drives down the cost of labor. If, to make ends meet, you need two people working, they won't be able to easily move to pursue better employment unless both find employment at the same place at the same time, or that the new offer is significantly better than the previous one. As this would depress salaries everywhere, that's very unlikely.
- speeder 6y agoWhat is very unlikely? I do not understood what you meant.
- Ericson2314 6y agoI don't buy this because we could have easily kept on building nuclear power plants. There was temporarily an energy shock, but the long-term issue is insufficient demand not (energy) supply.
- jandrese 6y agoNuclear Power Plants don't move people and goods around, at least not with 1970s battery technology.
- Ericson2314 6y agoFalse. Trains. Surely it is no coincidence that high speed rail and nuclear power both became common around the same time.
- spurgu 6y agoMost of the machines that run the world don't run on electricity, but oil. An easy to build open-source pocket sized fusion reactor would be nice.
- Fazel94 6y agoThen a Chernobyl would only bankrupt households and not a bunch of countries. It would be like healthcare in the United States. Families would go bankrupt since their reactor faces problems :)
- Fazel94 6y agoI think the problem with nuclear energy is that it requires prior investment and return on investment is a little bit long(more than 4 years) and doesn't create enough jobs to be a sexy political option.
- hacknat 6y agoPeter Thiel (who I don't agree with on everything) had a really great take on this once (can't find it at the moment), and basically laid out a strong case on how we haven't really recovered from the oil shocks of the 1970s. I do think that the early 1970s was the culmination of a bunch of different cultural, political, economic, and social trends meeting together and creating a very different global consensus. BTW, the Gold Standard was already out the window with original Bretton Woods. Only certain actors (governments and certain NGOs) were allowed to redeem money for Gold. Gradually lots of caveats and weird rules were added to the system because of various structural inefficiencies. The oil shocks just toppled the system, but the financial system of the world was already untenable.
- bwanab 6y agoThe oil shocks were a big deal, but they were exacerbated by the expense of the war in Vietnam which was really never properly accounted for.
- tomp 6y ago> And energy is a massive component in the price of almost everything we consume. Is it really? What would be different if energy was much cheaper? Would we have more advanced rockets or robots or phones? Better CPUs? More and cheaper housing built in dense cities? Cheaper education or medicine? More job security? Even more food? I realize that energy is an important input into some industrial processes, but I don't really think we're constrained by it (or by manufacturing in general) right now...
- spurgu 6y agoSome argue that the economy is directly tied to energy. https://surplusenergyeconomics.wordpress.com/2019/04/05/149-the-big-challenges/ https://surplusenergyeconomics.wordpress.com/2019/04/05/149-...
- shawxe 6y agoWho said anything about better? Cheaper energy = cheaper everything, but that doesn't mean that quality is necessarily constrained by current energy prices (although that also doesn't mean there aren't ways in which it could be).
- JKCalhoun 6y agoIt was only a single point of the OP's that you're targeting but I have to agree (I agree with other OP points though). Would a lower energy cost bring wages up? No reason to believe that would be the case. Would it lower the cost of goods so that at least the working poor could have a better standard of living? Perhaps, but how much of the cost of a good is the energy, how much labor and raw materials? Would we see even more job loss due to lower cost of energy as it becomes even cheaper still to automate? (Edit: to be clear, OP wasn't saying lowering energy costs would do anything more than lower the cost of goods. But that statement alone, coupled with the article showing declining wages, etc. suggests OP was implying lower energy costs could reverse or stop the trends shown.)
- benlivengood 6y agohttps://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=36754 https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=36754 claims about 5% of GDP is energy costs. It is on a mild downward trend since increasing since the 1970s. Considering that percentage is higher than margins in quite a few businesses I'd say it has a limiting effect on the economy.
- JJMcJ 6y ago> oil crisis If the basic stuff that runs the world (energy and chemical feed stock) doubles in price two separate times in the space of 7 years, you just might expect tough times. Interest rates lower than inflation, gold and silver not keeping pace with inflation either, general economic stagnation. Not a good time, no it wasn't.
- Lammy 6y ago> you might expect tough times Unless your currency is the one the oil is required to be priced/sold in worldwide, maybe. Sounds like a great time to have USD to me.
- JJMcJ 6y agoIt wasn't. There is more to life than currency speculation. Basically everything doubled in price in 1973/1974, and again in 1979/1980.
- theroachesjoint 6y agochoosing oil as the standard - for a good reference watch the formula, by no other no-bullshit-taker than McMarlon brando.
- spandrew 6y agoThe removal of the gold standard removed partial value of gold as a world standard for credit. It makes sense that "something else" would take over that hierarchy — in this case oil (as a surrogate for energy as a higher concept). They're not wholly unrelated and pretty obviously has driven economic policy and world relations (modern colonialism at the extreme) to some degree.
- mepian 6y agoI guess the Mansfield amendment of 1969, which ended the golden age of research funding in the US, could also contribute to the decline.
- dehrmann 6y agoBetween 1965 and 1988, the share of women in the labor force rose from 35% to 45% and has held around 45% since then. [1] The added labor could have pushed down the price of labor. Productivity acts as a ceiling for the price of labor, so seem those two track suggests that there was a shortage of labor. While the trend started in the 60's, likely in response to social changes in the 60's, it could have been accelerated by households struggling with 70's stagflation, sending more people to work to overcome stagnating wages. There'd be something like the paradox of thrift, but for labor, where people work more, but aggregate income doesn't change much. Real household income has actually gone up 28% since 1985 [2], so there might be something to viewing this through a household lens, not a wage lens. And as others, and even the link say. there was a lot going on in the 70's, so this is hard to tease apart. 1: https://www.dol.gov/agencies/wb/data/facts-over-time/women-in-the-labor-force#civilian-labor-force-by-sex https://www.dol.gov/agencies/wb/data/facts-over-time/women-i... 2: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MEHOINUSA672N https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MEHOINUSA672N
- lisper 6y ago> The author obviously wants you to believe that it was the abandonment of the gold standard How is that obvious? I see a lot of data, but not many conclusions. And even the data presented doesn't seem to me to present a particularly compelling case that it was the abandonment of the gold standard, among the many, many historically pivotal things that happened in or around 1971, that caused the systemic changes that followed.
- notahacker 6y agoBecause it's an article of faith for hard money enthusiasts[1] that nearly all society's economic ills can be blamed on the abandonment of the last vestiges of the gold standard, which happened in 1971, and yet anyone who pays any attention to the posted charts will notice that 1971 isn't actually the inflection point or even a partiocularly notable date on many of them. As you point out, there are many other historically pivotal things in the mid-late twentieth century that caused systemic changes, and many of those timelines better fit the data. [1]A cursory look at the site's blog posts will confirm the site author is indeed one https://wtf1971.com/page/2/ https://wtf1971.com/page/2/
- AlexandrB 6y agoThe quote at the end of the page is suggestive, both for its content and its authorship: > “I don’t believe we shall ever have a good money again before we take the thing out of the hands of government, that is, we can’t take it violently out of the hands of government, all we can do is by some sly roundabout way introduce something that they can’t stop.” – F.A. Hayek 1984
- nathias 6y agoyea it's a real coincidence that it coincides with the death of representative money
- nwah1 6y agoOr it could be that the stats are cherry-picked and there is no decoupling. The concept of household income is fuzzy and not necessarily related to rewards to labor. Measuring by hours is the appropriate way to measure. Among other issues. https://www.forbes.com/sites/scottwinship/2014/10/20/has-inequality-driven-a-wedge-between-productivity-and-compensation-growth/?sh=77423dae2eb4 https://www.forbes.com/sites/scottwinship/2014/10/20/has-ine...
- dnautics 6y ago> but there are several other theories that have more credence with mainstream economists It's baffling that mainstream economists don't believe this (of course a single event with explanatory power diminishes the utility of the economist profession, and the Upton Sinclair quote comes to mind). In the words of a VERY mainstream economist: https://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/02/13/the-case-for-higher-inflation/ https://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/02/13/the-case-for-hi... "when you have very low inflation, getting relative wages right would require that a significant number of workers take wage cuts. So having a somewhat higher inflation rate would lead to lower unemployment" In short: as a policy, we should reduce the real returns to labor in order to "keep the labor class employed". This policy choice (enabled by the end of bretton-woods) is quite well-captured in all of these graphs. This is how the end of bretton-woods pummeled the lower-income segments of society. As for how the end of b-w benefits capital owners, inflation makes the cost of long-term borrowing lower, which means that the market price of risk is decreased; and folks with greater means are more effective at capturing arbitrage between the real cost of risk and the price of risk. For example, high finance instruments (like options, shorts, FOREX, etc) have a higher cost to execute in an environment with higher interest rates. If you go to, say, hunter's point/bayview you will not find people taking advantage of these instruments. Some will claim "the poor are in debt so they will benefit from inflation" but in reality those debts are typically short-term, high interest rate instruments (sometimes even inflation-adjusted as in the case of some low-end home loans), and so the benefit to diminishing the real value of nominal debt is lower for them than it is for the truly wealthy.
- brnt 6y agoA better observation would be that is the start of the ascent of power of libertarian interests through their useful idiot, Richard Nixon. All the other observations flow from that.
- crazygringo 6y agoAccording to Thomas Piketty [1], it's mainly a result of a bifurcation in education, and dramatically rising managerial compensation helped with tax cuts. I personally also think this is the main answer. In other words, all our massive productivity increases have come from people with a ton of education, and they reap all the rewards, helped with lower taxes. The median worker isn't any more educated and hasn't reaped anything. > ...I certainly do not believe that r > g is a useful tool for the discussion of rising inequality of labor income: other mechanisms and policies are much more relevant here, e.g., supply and demand of skills and education. For instance, I point out in my book (Piketty 2014a, ch. 8–9) that the rise of top income shares in the United States over the 1980–2010 period is due for the most part to rising inequality of labor earnings, which can itself be explained by a mixture of two groups of factors: rising inequality in access to skills and to higher education over this time period in the United States, an evolution which might have been exacerbated by rising tuition fees and insufficient public investment; and exploding top managerial compensation, itself probably stimulated by changing incentives and norms, and by large cuts in top tax rates... [1] http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:x918MB5S9rsJ:piketty.pse.ens.fr/files/Piketty2015AER.pdf http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:x918MB5...
- bko 6y ago> tax cuts Although the top marginal tax rate has changed drastically throughout America's history, if you look at federal tax receipts as a percentage of GDP, they've been remarkably stable hovering around 17% [0] Similarly, education spending on K-12 has grown a lot per pupil (in constant dollars) since 1970 [1]. Its roughly doubled (in constant dollars) between 1970 and 2000 [0] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/FYFRGDA188S https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/FYFRGDA188S [1] https://www2.ed.gov/about/overview/fed/10facts/edlite-chart.html https://www2.ed.gov/about/overview/fed/10facts/edlite-chart....
- crazygringo 6y agoSure, but the entire point for inequality is the tax brackets, not the overall tax receipts. As for education, the relevant factor here is college education, not K-12. It's precisely all the benefits accruing to people with a good college education that aren't accruing to those without.
- faet 6y agoTheir was also the greater shift to non-wage benefits. If you look at total compensation vs productivity the chart tracks much closer. https://imgur.com/Juc8FMn https://imgur.com/Juc8FMn
- gpanders 6y agoDo you have a source for this chart?
- claudiulodro 6y agoHow much of the total compensation is health insurance premiums increasing, though? It doesn't seem like it would improve a worker's situation if the chart just shows that an increasingly greater percentage of their compensation has been funneled to insurance companies over the years . . .
- throwaway-8c93 6y agoThe linked article obviously has a gold-bug agenda. That's why I think it's important to bring one more argument in favor of the root cause being some physical constraint, rather than legal or organizational: At around the same time, the growth of GDP and standard of living dramatically slowed down in the Soviet Union, too. From venerable ~5% per year in 50s and 60s, to ~2% in 70s, to ~1.25% in 80s. Different legal, political, financial and managerial framework, the same decline.
- FrozenVoid 6y agoEarth reached its carrying capacity in the late 1960's https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Green_Revolution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Green_Revolution
- arrosenberg 6y ago...and also legislative reforms that wound up being bad for the regular people, like electronic voting and removing secret votes in Congress. Some of the issues might have been corrected, but the lack of a secret vote meant legislators became less inclined to vote against their backers to the benefit of their constituents. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legislative_Reorganization_Act_of_1970 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legislative_Reorganization_Act... ...and the re-emergence of corporate consolidation and the rise of the conglomerate in the 1960s, which reduced the power of labor to negotiate for a fair share of the gains.
- taylodl 6y agoI've always thought moving off the gold standard was the impetus for the OPEC oil crises.
- stosto88 6y agoYou got to be fucking kidding me...
- runeks 6y ago> Some do blame the loss of the gold standard, but the leading theory is the OPEC oil crisis. The latter is a consequence of the former. The US defaulting on its gold obligation is equivalent to trading oil in exchange for paper rather than gold. Of course the OPEC countries were reluctant to sell their oil for irredeemable pieces of paper rather than something redeemable in gold. Talking about the “oil price” as one thing before and after 1971 doesn’t even make sense, as the US gold default constituted a change in the unit of measurement for USD-denominated prices (gold versus irredeemable paper notes).