8 ms·
I was thinking about a related idea recently - how much is my grocery information privacy worth for me? Summed up, I'm currently saving just over 11% on all the
by viraptor 6y ago
I was thinking about a related idea recently - how much is my grocery information privacy worth for me? Summed up, I'm currently saving just over 11% on all the groceries + ~7% on fuel cost by sharing that information with 5 companies. (car insurance, CC, shop card, honey, airline)
I'm not attached to this, I'd rather the programs like this get destroyed. But also by stacking the offers, I believe I'm getting more value here than they do.
So for now I'm cool with this exchange. Would others put the privacy/money break-even somewhere else? (This is assuming reasonable shopping - I make a full list before starting to order a pickup, I rarely actually go through a shop, so there's no upsell here)
- grawprog 6y agoSure, until that information is used to give individualized prices and other things. Or used to hide things or show you only things the algorithms decide you like....or should have according to them. Already i've read things about hotel websites and stuff altering prices based on which device you're using to browse their site. In a world where your personal shopping information is bought and sold and things become increasingly online, it'll become a game of individualized shopping lists and prices, individual sales. Another perfectly crafted corporate bubble for people to live under where prices, suggestions and sales are individually tailored and at the whims of people siphoning all your personal information. I don't need my own personal omnipotent digital god dictating everything in my life. Even if it saves me a few bucks.
- viraptor 6y agoIt's much easier to do that for hotels than for groceries since comparison is harder. It will be quite widely known and sightly abused if your grocery chain starts doing that. The shops will always have the reference price in public after all. The pricing difference that actually matters (moving old stock) is already mostly done without personalised data. Sales are a standard.
- grawprog 6y agoFor now, with brick and mortor businesses because it's hard to do that in a physical place. With people increasingly ordering things online it becomes easier and more profitable to do that. If someone has your spending history, sees you buy something frequently, they have no incentive to put it on sale. Likewise, if they see something you've maybe looked at but not bought, they can put it in sale and tempt you. This is just one example. I'm sure marketers can come up with all sorts.
- an_opabinia 6y ago> Sure, until that information is used to give individualized prices and other things. Or used to hide things or show you only things the algorithms decide you like....or should have according to them. If anything, prices would rise for richer people, and decline for poorer people. Is that bad?
- rytill 6y agoPerhaps, but if/when word got out that this was occurring, an arbitrage opportunity would be available. Unless it were only a very marginal amount cheaper that would not cover the cost of arbitrage.
- an_opabinia 6y agoI got news for you, this already happens all the time, without nominally different pricing, just pricing for different SKUs. The arbitrage is realized by producers.
- qazxcvbnmlp 6y agoYeah. And the rich don’t mind, because status signaling is a a thing.
- TheCoelacanth 6y agoI don't think it's that simple. Often it would be the reverse because the richer people have more options of other places to buy.
- imgabe 6y agoThank you for providing an actual, tangible downside to this. I've never really seen one before. So many articles like this end up with people coming up with scenarios like "But what if there's a dictator and he wants to round up everyone who bought a 12-pack of Charmin' last week?" It would be interesting to see the arms race that could arise, though. If individualized prices became enough of a thing, there would probably be personal shoppers who would buy things for you at a lower price with their "poor person" data profile and pocket a percentage of the difference. Or more likely, there will probably be a way to run a browser with the right cookies to give you the lowest price.
- taneq 6y agoIf you want a really evil example, consider a version of Android Auto which knows when you’re low on fuel and auctions your “nearby fuel stations” search result slots to the highest bidders, in exchange for which the bidders get notified that they can jack up their prices on you.
- gretch 6y agoBut in real life examples, the exact opposite has been playing out. Instead of you being sold to the richest, hungriest gas station, it's more like all of the gas stations racing to the lowest price to serve you, and consumers having no brand relationships with gas stations anymore. If Android auto was always serving up expensive gas, users would start using bing or apple maps - I certainly would if there was such a tangible cost difference
- taneq 6y agoHow many people would do so, though? How many non-technical people are capable of untangling themselves from Google’s services? How many non-technical people are even aware that “Google” isn’t the only search engine?
- oarsinsync 6y agoI learnt about Waze many years ago from non technical folks. Drivers have niche communities of their own too, where stuff like this gets disseminated. “Waze is better than google maps for directions” for a long time was true. Then google bought it. If Waze can rise up, so can another. Especially where it’ll save drivers some % on their fuel bills. Even more so in European countries with high fuel duties.
- abhinav22 6y agoGreat insight - thanks
- Scoundreller 6y ago> I don't need my own personal omnipotent digital god dictating everything in my life. Even if it saves me a few bucks. You can opt-out/not opt-in all you want, but as long as enough people opt-in (or don't opt-out), they can just apply an existing model against you, get good-enough results and you're almost as screwed.
- octoberfranklin 6y agoI don't mind my grocery store tracking my purchases because they can't link it to anything else about me. Granted I always pay cash (at those self-checkout machines with bill acceptors -- why can't gas stations have them?) and got a plastic rewards card without giving my phone number. So it is a little bit of work, but it works.
- titzer 6y ago> I believe I'm getting more value here than they do. Well, these huge chains have bean counters that do exactly these kind of calculations, and in general, no. They are making more money in aggregate by doing this data collection than they are losing to discounts. Otherwise they would not do it. The real mystery is the shadow economy behind the scenes of how this data gets packaged, sold, analyzed, and monetized. You should be more curious. In fact, we all should.
- viraptor 6y ago> Well, these huge chains have bean counters that do exactly these kind of calculations, and in general, no. That's why I mentioned selling the same information to 5 companies. I get each of them separately maybe paying a few bucks. I'm assuming that a few of them resell the information to the same market making that information less useful and giving me more value. But at $70+ a month for the very repetitive shopping lists from a single location? My guess is they don't plan for people actually using the offers efficiently. If they did, the rewards would plummet.
- krageon 6y agoBy selling to multiple companies is likely to devalue your information. That has been factored in to the discount pricing (in aggregate, over the entire population of people that use these discounts), because that's the point of the people who calculate this.
- pmiller2 6y agoSure, but it doesn't matter if you sell to 1, 2, or 5 companies: they've all priced this in to their individual models, which means you can't really get any better with any individual company by, say, giving them an exclusive license to this particular data. But, in aggregate, you can do better selling to more companies than any individual model prices in. Which means the Nash equilibrium here is, unfortunately, a race to the bottom, but, it remains to be seen if we've reached that or not. Hmmm.
- atwo 6y agoI subscribe to this logic within some contained settings. Right now, I'm more than happy to grab a new credit card with an amazing bonus point offer, put through the required spend and then churn to another provider in a couple of months. Normally nets me some fancy gadgets round the house each year I wouldn't have bought otherwise (Dyson vacuum etc.). My caveats are: (1) Being thoughtful about where/ what I spend on the card. Nothing to revealing or illuminating (routine spend at local grocery etc.) (2) Being willing to pull the plug as soon as I think the sophistication of the card provider is material. This is still a while away in Australia despite the fairly progressive/ digital banking industry e.g., few banks can easily enrich their data with geo location of the merchant where the transaction took place (but this will be the norm soon) (3) Churning to a mix of institutions so that my spend is spread over time and never holding other products at the same institution (so they have no idea on my deposits etc.) For other elements of my data I am relatively hard line - it's too hard to value the privacy/ money breakeven and my approach is always to withhold wherever possible. In the long run this tends to net me on right side of any scandal even if I am a laggard on some social trend or convenience
- pm90 6y ago> But also by stacking the offers, I believe I'm getting more value here than they do. Your data is valuable not just for the immediate value that its used for (e.g. grocery stores predicting how much they need to restock of product X aggregating over consumer choices of all users). Its also useful as a data point in larger statistical analysis of an "audience" (i.e. a group of people with certain attributes) to marketing organizations. Every datum that they get makes their models somewhat more accurate. Most of these analysis are still pretty primitive today (AFAIK, maybe someone from the NSA or G00G can say otherwise). But these tools are getting better every year, and so is the value of your data.
- 542354234235 6y ago> Its also useful as a data point in larger statistical analysis of an "audience" (i.e. a group of people with certain attributes) to marketing organizations. Every datum that they get makes their models somewhat more accurate. Which is extremely valuable. Without them, a company can see they sell 1,000 units of product X and 500 units of product A. With these data models of individual buying behavior, they can see that 400 of the 500 buyers of product A also bought product X. So they can start marketing product A to product X buyers to boost product A, instead of just trying to market it to everyone and hoping for the best.
- vaccinator 6y agoI'm pretty sure that your credit card company sells your transaction history to other companies and also shares it with the Government.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- surajs 6y agore the privacy/money break even, i think archival data which does not uniquely identify you should form the bulk of any transaction, which would tend to bring your expectations down by quite a notch.
- amelius 6y agoHow do you know that without these programs you'd be paying more than you do now? In essence you should be paying less because these programs also cost money. Just think of all the expensive smart people that make these programs work.
- learnstats2 6y ago> Summed up, I'm currently saving just over 11% on all the groceries + ~7% on fuel cost by sharing that information with 5 companies. I don't think this is the exchange you are making, though. The money you save here is no different from couponing: it's a way for retailers to price differentiate and charge the other customers more. You are being charged a fairer price (still profitable for the retailer), for actively paying attention to what's cheaper; that'll be unrelated to the price or value of your data.
- Rmblnm4n 6y agoSimple additive operation versus economists macroeconomic education for squeezing margins at scale using ML logistics I don’t really see how you think you’re winning when constrasting how those deals are driven, and ignore deflation of your buying power to prop up the wealth of the gerontocracy monopolizing it Glad you got a couple bucks off groceries last month. Your count every nickle and dime ways sure are inspired