54 ms·
Google sued: Idle Android eats mobile data to send telemetry and preload ads
- realmod 6y agoCouldnt this simply be the result of push notification checking and similar things that are done in the background? I do think the total amount of data used is a bit much but this do not seem unreasonable at all.
- IncRnd 6y agoThe complaint spends several paragraphs detailing the types of traffic, the destination servers of that traffic, and what applications were running. It is doubtful, if the complaint is correct, that this resulted from push notifications.
- izacus 6y agoIf it's correct - it feels like it's grasping at straws towards the end there though. They're claiming Google is preloading ads and charging that as an impression, which I'm (at least with my experience of integrating both Apple and Google Ads) isn't a practice at all.
- geogra4 6y agoI wish Microsoft didn't kill windows mobile. The Android monopoly is terrible
- AsyncAwait 6y agoWhat did that get you that iOS doesn't? As far as I know they didn't allow alternative stores either.
- Closi 6y agoIt got the market multiple vendors, Apple is the only manufacturer for iOS and Android is the only option for all other manufacturers.
- AsyncAwait 6y agoRight. But as a proponent of open devices, neither Google/Android nor Microsoft got me there, because their policies were similar towards the customer, if anything MS was leaning heavier towards the walled garden approach of iOS. So what did the existence of a third player with identical approach bring?
- Closi 6y ago> So what did the existence of a third player with identical approach bring? Like I said, competition with Android. Not just for consumers, but for manufacturers too.
- Yetanfou 6y agoDon't rely on vendors to help you out of this conundrum, instead use what you have at your disposal to escape the duopoly. Get a supported Android device - there are hundreds of those by now - and install an AOSP-derived distribution like LineageOS. Leave out the Google bits, i.e. no 'gapps', no Google account, no nothing. If you need 'apps' which rely on the Google Services Framework use microG [1] but be aware of the fact that even this free software implementation of GSF needs to connect to Google to do its thing, i.e. try to find 'apps' which don't rely on GSF to start with. Use F-Droid or another alternative repository for you 'app' needs and something like Aurora Store (which you'll find on F-Droid) for those 'apps' which can only be found in the 'Google Play store'. Install a firewall (available on F-Droid and elsewhere) and set it to block all traffic by default. Configure it to allow selected 'apps' and system services to access those parts of the network (LAN, WAN, Mobile Data and VPN) you think they need. You can use the Log service to monitor which apps try to access the network. Once you've got something like this set up the way you want it you're mostly there. The radio firmware will still be outside of your control and probably open to exploitation by the Three Letter Agencies of the world, for now there is not much that can be done about this other than to get a device with totally separate baseband processor, i.e. not integrated into the SoC. These used to be common but are as rare as hens' teeth now. There are some - e.g. the Librem 5 - but most devices come with an integrated baseband subsystem. Then again, for the purpose of circumventing the duopoly this is irrelevant so it can be ignored by all but those who also want to limit access to their devices by TLAs. I've been using AOSP-derived distributions for as long as I've been using Android - close to 10 years - and have never found reason to regret my choice. LineageOS has OTA updates just like vendor distributions, the user experience is that of 'clean Android' - no bloatware. [1] https://microg.org/fdroid.html https://microg.org/fdroid.html
- francis-io 6y agoCan this approach still use google apps when needed? I need to use certain things like 2FA apps used by my employer. I want the freedom to be able to quickly install X app if needed.
- danhor 6y ago
- foxrider 6y agoSailfish is still around, and judging by Windows 10 I can't see how having Windows Mobile could improve anything.
- thdrdt 6y agoI really wanted to use Sailfish as Android alternative. But after reading reviews I think it is just not ready and will not be an alternative to Android and iOS any time soon. There are just too many bugs. Linux for mobile is also not an alternative. Since there are so many apps missing it can't be compared with Android and iOS. Well at least for me this includes some banking apps that make my life just so much easier. The only real options right now are the Android forks like LineageOS I think.
- izacus 6y agoWhy would Microsoft help here? Windows has bunch of telemetry too.
- Fnoord 6y agoSupposedly, a device requires an OS (such as Windows Mobile), which supposedly costs money, and does not have telemetry. Microsoft added telemetry to Windows because it is lucrative (up to the point they were giving Windows 10 away). To get rid of that, what we need is legislation, and then hold these corporations such as Google, Microsoft, and Apple accountable.
- swebs 6y agoI've been trying out various FOSS operating systems for the Pinephone lately. Mobian seems to be in a pretty usable state right now. I really think FOSS is the only way forward. Despite their marketing efforts, Microsoft is still the awful evil company its always been.
- tempest_ 6y agoYeah I have definitely been keeping and eye on the pinephone and the various OSs. It doesnt look like it is quite there yet for me but I will be considering something like it in the next couple years.
- lenkite 6y agoAFAIK Windows telemetry can be easily disabled.
- indymike 6y agoWindows mobile wasn't going to change the world. That said, I'd love to see a real alternative to iOS and Android if for no reason than my phone is a very powerful, very real computer and I can't use it as such.
- fctorial 6y agohttps://termux.com/ https://termux.com/
- ocdtrekkie 6y agoYou say this, but in 2020, Google is still working on adding features Windows Mobile had in 2014. As a former WinMo user, it's sad watching everyone else finally catching up.
- noisem4ker 6y agoAny examples? I can think of one, but in the opposite way: how Google removed the Exchange integration service from Android.
- ocdtrekkie 6y agoWatching Apple and Google both adopt dark mode recently was entertaining, Google is still trying to support dark mode across their product suite: Windows Mobile supported dark mode across the entire platform and suggested app developers do as well since the WP7 days. And then of course, you have both Google flirting with Android apps on Chromebooks, and the new M1 Macs being able to run iOS apps, when Universal Windows Apps were a thing over five years ago. They've all had this a little while, but Microsoft was ahead of the game on being able to allow/deny individual permissions to given apps before either Apple or Google was as well. I mean, Microsoft didn't have the market capture, but their platform was technologically in 2015 where their competitors are in 2020.
- swebs 6y agoThere are full Linux distros for phones nowadays. They're still in alpha stages, but they're getting better all the time https://wiki.pine64.org/wiki/PinePhone_Software_Releases https://wiki.pine64.org/wiki/PinePhone_Software_Releases
- deelowe 6y agoUmm. Have you used the retail version of win 10?
- BlueTemplar 6y agoThat might make the issue worse. See one way around it : PiHole. Well Pi has Microsoft firmware and PiHole software and its blocklists are hosted on Microsoft owned Github.
- nunodonato 6y agoI'm usually on the "anti" microsoft side, but owned a Lumia and it was the best smartphone to date! That thing was so fluid and intuitive, simple and well designed. I miss it!
- RonanTheGrey 6y agoYeah, I absolutely loved my Lumia... best phone I ever had. Crushed when it stopped working after... 5 years?
- janwillemb 6y agoGood that the root cause is being addressed. In the meantime, I'll be reducing the symptoms by routing all my DNS traffic through my pi.hole instance.
- rainingcatndogs 6y agoI wouldn't be surprised if these mentioned apps comes with google's dns resolvers baked in, in that case routing through pihole doesn't help here.
- foepys 6y agoAfaik, some apps like Netflix that rely on geo-blocking for their content licensing do it already and it's only a matter of time until they switch to DNS over HTTP so requests cannot be altered at all.
- scoot_718 6y agoThat's just going to break functionality on many networks.
- ugexe 6y agoThere are block lists for DoH servers and other DNS queries can be forwarded to your own resolver.
- smokefreeskies 6y agoI set up a rule on my router to drop any DNS traffic and DoH traffic to well known DNS providers unless it comes from the server running pihole. Otherwise it was proving very hard to find out how to force applications / mobile devices to use my DNS server.
- kazen44 6y agoyou could also just NAT port 52 to your pihole. (translating 8.8.8.8 ofcourse). I don't know if this would work with DoH. (but DoH is terrible anyways)
- DarthGhandi 6y agonetguard is your friend here, turn on access notifications to be disgusted at what your phone does while you aren't looking
- 6510 6y agoI like the angle of privacy depending on how much you pay for not having it. They either 1) need your personal-data to fund the services or 2) they don't need it and shouldn't have it. I don't see a 3rd where they need your personal-data only if you can pay for it. It gets really interesting where the IF is just giving them more of your personal-data.
- hereme888 6y agoEver heard of NetGuard? With it I block all relevant outgoing and incoming connections to doubleclick, google analytics, my carrier (t-mobile), app-measurements, facebook, etc... The phone attempts connection to one of these just about every second, and I block them all. Hopefully the Librem phones will continue to mature and become my future phone.
- scottwernervt 6y agoAlso recommend https://nextdns.io/ https://nextdns.io/ which supports common ad block lists, etc. I have my home router and phone set to it and is crazy how many trackers and ads are blocked.
- gvurrdon 6y agoSeems to be a good service to me. There seem to have been some complaints recently, though: https://www.reddit.com/r/nextdns/comments/ju2hfw/nextdns_privacy_policy_change_now_allows_them_to/ https://www.reddit.com/r/nextdns/comments/ju2hfw/nextdns_pri...
- rfvrgvegbegn 6y agoNetGuard is great, it can show you the requests done by any apps. Thx to it, I discovered that my default camera app on my phone was sending data to Facebook and many other quite concerning stuff. Internet access should be a permission (like camera, mic, etc.) unfortunately in Android it isn't the case and any app can communicate with any server. With NetGuard you can decide which app can access internet or not.
- andysch 6y agoDoes Netguard require to be rooted? Does it show the traffic per app?
- hereme888 6y agoIt does not require rooting. It shows connnections per app, and how much data has been transferred to each of those connections. What I tend to do is: install an app → block it before running it the first time → look at every connection attempt made (usually first through ipv4) → wait a bit more until apps attempt connection through different protocol (ipv6 or U) → block anything I don't like, including ads, analytics, etc → tell NetGuard to now allow the "legit" connections to be made and start using the app.
- izacus 6y ago> Under active use, Android devices transfer about 11.6MB of data to Google servers daily, or 350MB per month, it's claimed, which is about half the amount transferred by an iPhone. Interesting, so 350MB of data per month is abuse, iPhones 175MB per month isn't. I guess Google now has to half their data use for it to be at parity with Apple and we're all fine?
- detaro 6y agoIt doesn't say that, since it says the iPhone uses more. And it's a reference to a different test the article author added for context, not a claim about what's "ok".
- namdnay 6y agoErrr wouldn’t that be 700MB/month for an iPhone?
- izacus 6y agoHmm, I think it's a lapsus in the original text - the data clearly shows that iPhones transfer 50% LESS data than Androids.
- samoa42 6y agolikely depends on the settings. iphones i have set up use about 30MB per month for "System Services" dont know how much of that is from real usage vs. telemetry an stuff.
- dogma1138 6y agoYou have a breakdown of individual services also on iOS push notifications are accounted for in system services. If there is any OS level telemetry it would fall under general which for my iPhone is 105MB in total since I activated it about a year ago. In general over a year+ (11 Pro Max) its 2.5GB with software updates and document sync accounting for over half of it both of which can be explicitly set to use WiFi only same goes for most other services as well. Just to put things into perspective my total mobile data usage on this iPhone is 253GB, all system services is 1% of that.
- 2Gkashmiri 6y agoplease use a pihole. its super cheap, like $5 and works like a charm
- 1023bytes 6y agoPiHole is no use on mobile data
- laszlokorte 6y agosetup a vpn to your home network
- Gabrielfair 6y agoI'm interested in setting up my homelab to monitor and detect rogue traffic that would have caught my phone doing what was described in the article. Does anyone have any open-source suggestions for DIY deep-packet analysis?
- culopatin 6y agoWell for this to matter in a mobile environment you’d have to carry your own WLAN everywhere you go.
- 2Gkashmiri 6y agono. use something like blokada if you are on android. it works just as effectively
- abawany 6y agoI use NextDNS since it also works when I'm not at home.
- hereme888 6y agoI'm removing this comment.
- WayToDoor 6y agoYour comment is still there, and I see no evidence of censorship.
- dalbasal 6y agoThese bits of litigation are interesting, but my usual takeaway is a mild contempt for the whole thing. Whether it's something minor like this or a major antitrust cases (eg, the recent adwords EU case), what is and isn't legally actionable seems arbitrary from a non-legal perspective. Even legislation efforts like european "cookie laws" and such seem bumbling and naive. What's the legal fix to this, assuming google lose? An extra tick box? T&C update? The reality of interacting with large software companies as a consumer doesn't lend well to brick and mortar analogies. A T&C section is not analogous to a rental contract. Even residential or employment contracts are usually subject to legal filters... cultural norms at least. The "problem" here is one of structure. Google own android to (a)dominate the mobile phone market and (b) support the targeted ads business, the main business. Whether or not google are "stealing" data allowance from customers, or acquiring this right voluntarily/contractually from customers is interesting in the abstract, I guess. In is so peripheral to the actual problem though. I realize this case isn't supposed to be dealing with the wider problems of legal monopolies. The legal/legislative whole is. It seems that whatever the goal of the action (from litigation to legislation or regulation), they pick around the irrelevant edges. What, legally, should google be legally allowed to do given that it's leveraging the fact that they control your phone, own a lot of your data, etc. If the answer is whatever the T&Cs say, the answer is "everything."
- aboringusername 6y agoThe answer here has been obvious for many years. Clearly, there is a conflict of interest in having an organization interested in selling ads to also make one of the worlds most widely used operating systems. So we break them up. We regulate their conduct, we interrogate their business and ensure there is no apparent conflicts of interest going on. Mobile OS solutions LTD would develop Android OS, wouldn't unduly favor any given party more than another. It's possible, but you'd need to essentially have complete and total access to the daily affairs and perform audits to ensure compliance. Legislation can fix this but it'd be a mammoth task to challenge Google.
- swiley 6y agoIt doesn't really matter who's involved, the security model in android is extremely user hostile. Many organizations are given super user access on device and the end user isn't. Only one of these needs to be poorly behaved (not even selling ads) for the device to be full of unremovable malware. There's definitely a social problem here, but I think for once people HN are underestimating the importance of a technical problem.
- green7ea 6y agoI recently got a new phone and the battery life doubled once I disabled all the default permissions on google apps. I knew they were consuming battery but that's a lot.
- alok-g 6y agoCan you please share more details. I would like to replicate.
- green7ea 6y agoIf you could replicate that would be very interesting since a single datapoint doesn't say much. Brand new oneplus 8T and I was getting ~1 day of battery life with about 3-4 hours of use. I never enabled any google services and that was the default configuration. I went app permissions and disabled everything that I was able to disable. The only apps that had default permissions always enabled were google services. The battery day is now ~2 days with slightly heavier use and the display running at 120Hz instead of the default 60Hz.
- londons_explore 6y agoThe pixel devices last at least 28 days on battery when all default services are enabled, the phone is connected to 4g and WiFi, and is otherwise idle (including no emails received). To achieve this, you need a mobile network supporting the standards allowing it to sleep for X number of beacon frames. There are also some things the mobile network needs to support. The minute you install any apps, or start syncing any changing data, that 28 days goes down to 1 or 2 days...
- fuzxi 6y agoDo you have any links to more information on this? Sounds interesting.
- yc-kraln 6y agoNever happier to have DNS66 on my phone.
- crazygringo 6y agoPer the link [1] the article refers to, if I understand correctly, Google isn't preloading ads. Google is making it possible for applications that show ads to choose to preload them. And they're not preloaded hours/days in advance -- it's a UX pattern to load them a tap before. So that part of the suit looks like it will fall apart. As for sending telemetry, it's $1/month in data assuming you never use Wi-Fi. Doesn't seem like a particularly unreasonable cost. Especially considering most people spend the majority of their time at work/home with Wi-Fi which means the real number is more probably more like $0.25/mo. I think a reasonable person assumes any commercial OS is checking for push notifications, syncing info (like weather), communicating analytics, checking for updates, etc. in the background. The only question is whether it's unreasonably excessive, which in this case appears not to be. (Really the only main thing is that a device shouldn't download multi-gigabyte OS updates without asking first.) [1] https://www.blog.google/products/admob/preloading-interstitial-ads https://www.blog.google/products/admob/preloading-interstiti...
- dsr_ 6y agoI think a reasonable person has never wondered if their OS is doing something in the background, is shocked when I tell them about it, and then shrugs and goes back to using it because the alternative is to learn something new.
- crazygringo 6y agoWhy would they be shocked? How else would their phone know there are apps to be updated, notifications received, etc.? (On a computer, anti-virus updates too.) How would it know the temperature or stocks as soon as it's brought up, even when there's no cell service? It's pretty common sense. And on iOS and Mac you prominently choose to enroll in analytics when you set up your phone, so the idea of analytics isn't a shocker either. I'm not sure if Android or Windows has the same setup choice.
- dsr_ 6y agoRule of thumb: everybody who has an HN account is an outlier compared to the general population. General people -- even those who are highly educated and use computers all the time -- do not think about their tools. They click on defaults without thinking about them. And Apple and Google and Microsoft know this and take advantage of it.
- mattlondon 6y agoI wonder what people want out of these kind of lawsuits. If you can clearly identify exactly how much data is consumed, and you have a service plan that tells you exactly how much that data cost to use then the damages are precisely computable. So a judge can turn around and just award these people $4.72 in damages or whatever and case closed? What is the angle here, or is it just another "google-is-evil-but-i-still-want-to-use-their-services-for-free" thing?
- asutekku 6y agoIt's that the device should not use user's data at all when it's not in use, considering google does not pay for it.
- refulgentis 6y agoAre there consumer computers that don't use the user's data at all when they're not in use?
- asutekku 6y agoThe least they can do is to not load ads on the background. Sure, almost every device does some basic telemetry but showing ads is not something a device does need to function.
- PersonalOps 6y agoTelemetry is not something the device needs to function either. It's a "value add" in the best possible light, security breach in the worst.
- asutekku 6y agoTelemetry at least is useful for the developers to see how people use their software/devices/whatever.
- luord 6y agoBetween this and Jeffrey Paul's article shared yesterday about Big Sur and Apple Silicon[1], it's becoming increasingly tempting to throw my phone away and keep using only Linux with no applications primarily developed by these giants (i.e. no Chromium, etc). Supporting initiatives like the Librem phone is also moving up in my list of priorities, once I get enough money to spare at least. [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25078034 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25078034
- deeter72 6y agoI personally feel like, Apple is the best choice for the time being until actual daily usable Linux high end phones are a reality. Apple although has highly monopolistic practices are privacy oriented and are interested on just selling the physical device.
- dogma1138 6y agoLinux high end phones will never be a reality, at least not what people here would consider Linux at best you’ll get is Android or Android like OS. Other than that you’ll get low volume low end devices at high end or higher prices due to lack of economy of scale. What most consumers actually want and I’ll put in that list also many many people that say they want a “Linux Phone” but in reality will go back to their iPhone/Android after a week is quite different than what a tiny niche is willing and capable of dealing with.
- t0astbread 6y agoI guess what people want when they say they want a "Linux phone" is a phone that allows them to hack, mix and match their system the way they can on a desktop Linux system.
- dogma1138 6y agoThey can do that with many Android phones it’s not hard to find ones with a boot loader you can open including the Google Pixel. I used Android from day one till the LG Nexus and I switched to an iPhone after having to spend yet another weekend compiling a kernel to update my phone. Most people want a device that “just works”. Overall I would be good money on the fact that the percentage of people that say they want to be able to hack their phone freely and will actually do so is very slim because again Android gives you 90% if not more of that freedom already and some devices even can boot other OSes. Sure things like the blobs on the baseband are still closed but that will always be the case no one realistically is expecting a high end 100% open source phone, and if you are keep dreaming. And yes while having a phone that just works and one that is open isn’t mutually exclusive in principal but it is in practice especially once you account for economics. Like it or not securing an open system is harder, and companies don’t like investing time and money developing features hardly anyone will use.
- sundvor 6y agoThe real kicker for me was Google charging a background preload as a view as such, even though the user may never actually see the ad. Amazing.
- lern_too_spel 6y agoThat is speculation in the article and seems extremely unlikely.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- intricatedetail 6y agoThis should be illegal and Google should be forced to split into small independent companies. Nobody can compete with them so they have unfair advantage. They need to abide by the rules any small business have to follow and pay the right tax. If they managed to amass so much wealth by gaming the system it should be confiscated.
- jayd16 6y agoKind of weird they decided to test with a 4 year old Samsung phone but I guess its popular. I'm curious about the exact breakdown of data. How much of this is because it was a brand new phone?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ankit219 6y agoI checked my phone to see if the same pattern is repeated. Under default settings, Youtube, Chrome, Google play store, and other services do send data to Google. You can disable it, there are options for disabling mobile data, wifi data, and background data. It wasnt as much as alluded to in the complaint, but essentially many apps that you may not suspect, including messaging, send small amount of data to Google whether on Wifi or Mobile data. Power users can always disable it, but would not have known until you see the complaint like this. One more thing: While the system apps do take up, even the apps which do not have permission to run in background use some amount of data. I have apps like amazon prime, Dominos, etc. which I have not opened in months (and restricted background activity) and yet they used some amount of data. If one good thing comes out of this, maybe they should restrict background activity until explicitly specified. (I do understand some of them would be for showing push notifications, but that can be handled differently)
- jariel 6y agoThey should have to pay the carrier for the bandwidth.
- Animats 6y agoDo Android phones do that if you don't sign up for Google? I didn't. When I first powered up a new Android phone, it asked for a Google login. But there's a "Later" option. I did that, and then removed the app that runs on first use, plus various other Google stuff. Installed F-Droid and Fennec. So I've never agreed to Google's terms.
- Gabrielfair 6y agoI'm interested in setting up my homelab to monitor and detect rogue traffic that would have caught my phone doing what was described in the article. Does anyone have any open-source suggestions for DIY deep-packet analysis?
- crtasm 6y agoIs it the Play Store app doing this or some other service? I'm running LineageOS 17 (android 10) + OpenGApps-Pico, am logged into a google account and have turned off as much as I can find in the settings - am curious if my phone is still sending+receiving what they describe.
- throwaway567834 6y agoThey are really going to shit themselves when they learn the technical details of what is being uploaded. Hint: Google Location Services's "telemetry" is just that: extremely detailed logs of location information that though "anonymized" absolutely obliterates privacy and will in itself be a major scandal.
- shostack 6y agoIf it is properly anonymized, how does it obliterate privacy? What data specifically would do that which is not anonymized?
- throwaway567834 6y agoDo you think a GPS trace accurate to the meter and an accelerometer trace accurate enough to count footsteps combined with WiFi signals and barometeric data accurate enough to locate the room and floor of any building is going to be properly anonymized by a randomly generated UID that expires after 7 days?
- skee0083 6y agoAndroid is garbage. do yourself a favor and buy an iPhone.
- MeinBlutIstBlau 6y agoAndroid is a better PDA but iPhone is a better phone.
- jdndbfbf 6y agoIphones are so locked down. You can't access the file system. If you plug it into a computer it doesn't appear as a device you can just copy files to. You have to install some garbage software to transfer the files for you. It can't even play webm videos.
- izacus 6y agoIn this literal same article they talk about how iPhones send this kind of telemetry too. A different kind of MB amount, but they still do this. They're also horribly locked down and their owner thinks you should pay 30% tax on every single payment transaction you do in life. So I'm not entirely sure what your iPhone advertisement is supposed to support here.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ggggtez 6y agoI glanced through it, and can pretty much guarantee there is no case here. I'm no lawyer and have no special knowledge, but this is for "new account" and represents log files, according to the suit. I can almost guarantee Google will show the data is some kind of anti-fraud/spam analysis (thus why it doesn't wait for you to get on wifi). This it's not an apples to apples comparison (they are only guessing the logs are for ads, but the suit doesn't appear to actually show evidence that the data is advertising related). Similarly, they extrapolate that it will continue to log that much data forever, but it may be related to the fact they are new accounts, and data usage may drop off after the account gets some history behind it. But hey, I'll be happy to take a class action payment, I just don't see this actually going anywhere.
- Groxx 6y agotbh I wonder if this is being triggered by ad-using applications (or, well, their frameworks) on the device, rather than an innate behavior. i.e. if you never install a google-ad-using app, does this occur?
- vaccinator 6y agoThats why I use 2gb per month watch only a couple videos... thanks Google, I was really trying to restrict myself.
- baybal2 6y agoVery simple way I know that not many people know: Download a cert from offending Google servers, and blacklist it in Android. The TLS library on the Android will then block it
- foresto 6y agoThis is a neat trick; thanks for pointing it out. Just keep in mind that Google may have a sizable pool of certificates in use across their various servers, and they may rotate them on whatever schedule they like. Keeping up could become a chore.
- baybal2 6y agoAn option: block the root cert
- bnix 6y agoI find it... sad? how knee-jerk people are, especially with the expectation of "perfect privacy" in a country where millions of people's SINs got leaked and that company still functions. Looking forward to that $1/month I'll get if it goes class action though... The cause is always glass half empty isn't it?
- bnix 6y agoI use Linux primary, but also Android, Win10, iPadOS, iOS, macOS every day. Pick a side though.