10 ms·
If I had a dollar for every disaster prepper I've seen in the USA that has many thousands of rounds of ammunition, and none of the following: a) water purifica
by walrus01 6y ago
If I had a dollar for every disaster prepper I've seen in the USA that has many thousands of rounds of ammunition, and none of the following:
a) water purification equipment with supplies/filter changes good for 6+ months of continuous use
b) a stockpile of the most common antibiotics and medical supplies (essentially what you could get spending $700 on a comprehensive first aid kit plus $300-400 of drugs that will require periodic replacement as they expire).
c) knowledge or tools and supplies related to implementing off grid photovoltaic or wind power systems, but lots of gasoline or diesel generators.
d) $400 goose down sleeping bags, 4-season camping equipment, but they do have lots of tactical clothing and accessories, plate carriers, dropleg holsters and such
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoThey're prepping for different disasters than you want them to prep for. When there's a disaster and there's no police to call having guns and ammo you can trade off is likely far better than gold bars, solar panels, etc because everyone without guns and ammo is gonna be wanting enough to keep themselves safe.
- walrus01 6y agoThe people whose preparation supplies seem to be 85% tactical/weaponry related and 15% everything else, whether they will acknowledge it or not, seem to be preparing to become the people who would take others' food and supplies by force in the event of a real nuclear war level catastrophe.
- JakeKalstad 6y agoThey are simply preparing for those "people who would take others' food and supplies by force" in any type of event.
- swebs 6y ago>seem to be preparing to become the people who would take others' food and supplies by force in the event of a real nuclear war level catastrophe Or simply preparing to defend against those sorts of people.
- hannasanarion 6y agoThe thing is, "those sorts of people" don't really exist. There have been PLENTY of disasters resulting in short or long term societal collapse all over the world in the last century, and none of them resulted in widespread banditry.
- lopmotr 6y agoDidn't ISIS do that in Iraq and Syria? Kidnapping is also a common way for armed people to get money from others in insecure countries, possibly more than they could get by directly stealing their possessions.
- hannasanarion 6y agoISIS didn't arise spontaneously after an earthquake. It was intentionally built over a period of 10 years by a coalition of political parties and religious movements as a continuation of the insurgent war against occupiers, with the eventual goal of establishing a new society with new laws: their mission was inherently social and cooperative (by means of military conquest). That's hardly the prepper expectation of "there will be a solar flare and then the whole world will instantly be filled by roving gangs of psychopaths, like in The Walking Dead"
- moduspol 6y agoNot necessarily. The guns and ammunition are more valuable. You could trade them (or your time in protecting them) for the other things without stealing. Besides, I think it's a moot point because I know a lot of preppers and they're all very aware of concerns like safe drinking water and food.
- trynewideas 6y agoThey know exactly what they're preparing for: race and class war in support of active insurrection against the federal government. We got a very brief taste of it in the Boogaloo bullshit that used BLM protests to see exactly what they could get away with. They don't have those other things because they either intend to die "heroically" before they need them, or to take what they need from the people they intend to kill and institutions they'll upend. "Disaster prepper" is just a convenient paper-thin veil over that reasoning that makes it socially palatable to people who don't have to deal with them frequently enough to get to know them. The only disaster they're prepping for is the one they intend to cause. Signed, someone who grew up with rural Louisianians, Texans, and Arkansans, and has to deal with rural Oregonians, Washingtonians, and Idahoans daily.
- 1-more 6y agoThe "antifa bus" incident in Forks, WA this year was eye opening on how the peanut butter of small-town corruption can mix with the chocolate of spoiling for a fight paranoia to turn any situation into absolute madness very quickly. The lone prepper holed up with their canned food and guns is the substrate ideology of the American Civil Religion taken to its conclusion. It's, uh, gross. Not a fan!!
- hguant 6y agoIn the US at least, stockpiling antibiotics is a little tricky - kind of hard to find a doctor who will just write you a prescription for cipro "just in case."
- renewiltord 6y agoPretty easy if you're willing to smuggle drugs across the border, though. You'll get away with a trip to South or East Asia and returning with a stockpile.
- driverdan 6y agoIt's not smuggling when the drug isn't controlled.
- LinuxBender 6y agoOr any medications for that matter. I've gone down this path. The best I could do was to get the doctor to double-up my prescriptions for a while, which gave me a 3 month buffer. That is why I am trying to learn how to make my prescriptions. Super dangerous, but I don't want to rely on fragile economies. I just watched a country lose its mind and take all the toilet paper.
- johndevor 6y agoYou can buy anti biotics over the counter in Mexico.
- LinuxBender 6y agoHow about all the other medications? I stay clear of anti-biotics anyway.
- ghaff 6y ago>I stay clear of anti-biotics anyway. You certainly shouldn't pop them for no good reason. But antibiotics can absolutely be life saving in the event of an infection.
- renewiltord 6y agoThe thing with guns and ammunition is that you can use those to get the goose down from people like me.
- 1-more 6y agoIf it's any consolation, the type of person to do that is the type to have their house burned down around them because the solo king-of-the-castle, all plunder survival strategy has a very limited lifespan.
- moduspol 6y agoOnly in the most simplistic case. In less simplistic cases, people will gather and organize and decisions will get made over how resources will be allocated and distributed. The people who stockpile other resources are unlikely to be in a better bargaining position than those with the guns. And it might not require any shooting. Not that any of this is likely--I just don't think it's limited to Rambo / Scarface types.
- renewiltord 6y agoHaha, you're right. Any notion of private property will be subsumed by the needs of the collective. We already saw that in the early days of this pandemic where it was unacceptable to keep your masks if you had them. Stockpiling goose down will mean that the tribe will decide that the old man gets the goose down. And the doctor.
- moduspol 6y agoMaybe, or maybe not. If they have guns and you don't, it'll be up to them to decide.
- chordalkeyboard 6y agoAnd if one tribe has guns, and the other doesn't, guess who gets more of the goose down and who is tasked with locating more goose down?
- gruez 6y ago>I've seen in the USA that has many thousands of rounds of ammunition, and none of the following: [...] >c) lots of gasoline or diesel generators but no knowledge or tools and supplies related to implementing off grid photovoltaic or wind power systems >d) lots of tactical clothing and accessories, plate carriers, dropleg holsters and such but no $400 goose down sleeping bags, 4-season camping equipment. This is confusingly worded. On first reading it sounds like they don't have "lots of gasoline [...]", but as you read on further it sounds like you actually meant they do have "lots of gasoline [...]".
- walrus01 6y agoyou're absolutely right, I'm not fully awake... the order there has been edited to be reversed now.
- googthrowaway42 6y agoI have never seen a prepper video on Youtube that doesn't mention a, b, and c.
- swebs 6y ago>a) water purification equipment with supplies/filter changes good for 6+ months of continuous use It's easy enough to make a particulate filter yourself out of sand and charcoal. Then just boil the water to kill any microbes
- bigbubba 6y agoYou can also render water relatively safe to drink using small amounts of bleach. I've done it a few times whilr camping. EPA.gov has instructions for it, you only need a few drops of bleach per gallon (roughly 3.75L) of water. One large bottle of bleach is enough to purify water for months at least. https://www.epa.gov/ground-water-and-drinking-water/emergency-disinfection-drinking-water https://www.epa.gov/ground-water-and-drinking-water/emergenc...
- cdubzzz 6y agoIn Peace Corps we used a filter bucket and added bleach. Took very little bleach, though I don't recall how often we had to change the filter. It was essentially this: https://www.outbackwater.com/outback-5-gallon-gravity-powered-nano-purification-system-ob-25nf/ https://www.outbackwater.com/outback-5-gallon-gravity-powere...
- ghaff 6y agoIt's probably a bit safer (easier to control) to use iodine which I carry for camping, even if only as backup. Once it's done it's thing, you can then put in some Vitamin C to neutralize most of the funny taste.
- hinkley 6y agoI realized recently that at some point as the Rugged Individualists have become more shrill, that many of them have crossed the line from Libertarian into Anarchist and I don't think they know they have. What's funny-sad is that I'm pretty sure they (used to) hate anarchists, and now they've become Them. Guns instead of supplies is a very anarchist mentality. Guns make sense (at least in a self-consistent way) when you have something worth taking. If you have the guns but nothing to take, then you have a very different plan for an actual emergency. Whether you acknowledge it or not is a different story.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoIf you have guns and nothing to take you have a commodity that is very valuable among the people who have things to take but no guns.
- centimeter 6y agoI think you're being uncharitable to preppers. Most of the ones I know are into camping, and as such, have basically all of A) and D). Many of them are into SAR/EMT stuff and so have B). C) is just normal to have in many rural areas of the US.
- lastofthemojito 6y agoPerhaps a naive question, but where does one acquire antibiotics without a prescription? Whenever I've needed an antibiotic, I've seen a doctor and that doctor's prescription seemed necessary to purchase the antibiotics at a pharmacy.
- progre 6y agoPet store. It will not have passed the quality controll for human consumption, but it's maybe better than nothing
- ghaff 6y agoA lot depends on what failure modes you're preparing for and protecting against. At the time of the original virus shutdown in the US, I saw a ton of essentially panic buying of things (like canned goods and rice) and bottled water that seemed to be aimed at a complete infrastructure breakdown. Yet, I'm guessing that most of the people preparing to hole up for months lacked many of the other things they'd need if they actually lost electricity and water for an expended period of time. While of course they would need many other things as well, if you actually believe that there's going to be widespread societal breakdown, you probably do want a gun and ammo in addition to food, large quantities of water, and so forth.
- blhack 6y agoI think what those people were trying to hedge against was a short term loss of basic infrastructure like water or power. It wasn't meant to last for 2 months, it was meant to last for a few days.
- ghaff 6y agoI definitely know people who were posting online about how they had 6 months supply of dry and canned goods socked away. A few days makes sense in any case; I actually lost power for 2-3 days this summer just because of a storm. But I could easily cover that with just what I normally have in the house.
- qqqwerty 6y agoTo be fair to those people, at the beginning of the pandemic there was a lot of uncertainty around COVID-19 transmission rates. Buying a few weeks of food was a good way to hedge against the potential case where COVID-19 was so virulent that even going to a grocery store presented a high risk of transmission. Of course, we now know that even in a hotspot grocery shopping using basic precautions is fairly safe. But it was not clear at the time.
- hiddenforest 6y agoMy wife and I prep, but as a former member of the military with a great deal of "field experience", I agree with your assessment of most preppers. We own revolvers, no ARs, no Glocks. No need for that. Even the FBI shows than in drastic situations like home invasions, the average number of shots fired is 3. The zombies are not coming. We are not going to end up in a Walking Dead situation. I know enough preppers and have listened to enough to know a lot of what they write is coded and has meaning. Zombies are not real, even though they use this term in their writings. They are referring to inner-city people or city dwellers (or even the unprepared) who may attack during a protracted emergency like a hurricane that removes power for weeks and people start looting to survive. I based my preps on water purification, medical (wife has doctor after her name), and calories. As a guy who has carried a 65# ruck for hours on end for days, I can assure you, you don't need as much as you think. While the military does have a supply chain for soldiers in the field, there have been times when that wasn't a reality for a week or more and you had to make do with what was in your ruck. The military sends troops into harm's way with 180 rounds of ammunition for rifles, and 45 rounds of ammunition for handguns. That's it. I focused on water purification, caloric intake, regulating body temperature, medical, and have two solar chargers. Have two of everything (two is one, one is none). I'm not worried about a protracted battle with anyone. Smart preppers will avoid any fight because it's just plain dumb as hell to get into it with anyone when there is no medical help around. To the people that have amassed thousands of rounds of ammunition, I laugh. Why? Military experience. I often ask these people when they brag about their "warehouse full of preps", "How many gunfights do you reasonably expect to survive?" What if someone launched flaming arrows into your home in a protracted situation? How will you carry your stash? Do you have children? Any babies? If so, your job is to protect your family by fleeing. Not trying to pretend you're a warrior. Discretion is ALWAYS the better part of valor. Good preps: - Light tent for your family. Waterproof. In warm regions, two light tarps. - Water purification tablets for a year. Takes up no space. Also water purification straws, pref. the 25,000 gallon variety. Again, light and no space. - Revolver with 200 rounds of quality ammunition. One for each adult. - High-quality light rucksack with waterproof cover. - Two folding solar panels. - Two full medical kits. - Steel canteens and canteen cups for cooking and water purification. - 1000' of 550 paracord. - Two fixed blade knives and two folding knives. - Light thermal technical clothing. - Hand warmers and space blankets. - Lighters and matches along with ferro rod for fire. - Compass x2 (learn how to use it. Most people fail land navigation, even basics, because they think using a compass is easy. Get grid maps for your area and learn the difference between grid, true, and magnetic north (declination). Learn the declination for your area and program your compass with the correct settings. At even a mile, the wrong declination will send you off by hundreds of yards. - Safety goggles, shemaghs, and expanding toilet paper wipes (light, 250 take up the space of a can of soda) - Pack according to your weight, height, and abilities. Children should carry their own clothes and water and nothing more. Adults should limit it to 35#. - Firearms should always be out of sight.
- jpindar 6y agoHow many preppers have you seen, as opposed to videos about preppers?
- biztos 6y agoAre the guns & ammo not enough so you can acquire the other stuff from your neighbors? (Putting it more seriously, doesn’t a lot of prepperdom assume there will be warlords and pillaging and all that? And better to pillage than be pillaged?)
- notabee 6y agoHijacking this with a quick tip: don't hoard doxycycline. It'll wreck your kidneys if it's expired. https://boards.straightdope.com/t/expired-doxycycline-what-exactly-breaks-down/542882/3 https://boards.straightdope.com/t/expired-doxycycline-what-e...
- ed25519FUUU 6y agoAren’t we talking about dying from a bacterial infection here in a SHTF situation?
- anitil 6y agoWow I haven't seen straighdope in a while!
- tamrix 6y agoDo you have that stuff?
- fogihujy 6y agoAlso, basic skills: If we experience a true societal collapse, then simple things like basic wood-working skills and tool maintenance are critical. You won't get far in the post-apocalyptic, zombie-ridden wasteland if you don't even know how to sharpen a knife properly.