16 ms·
Seriously. What's the point of open source if companies just steal it, build billion dollar industries on top, and then lock everything down? Apple is telling
by echelon 6y ago
Seriously. What's the point of open source if companies just steal it, build billion dollar industries on top, and then lock everything down?
Apple is telling us we can't run our own software on their goddamned devices, yet they built their empire on open source.
Look at Facebook, Google, Amazon. They've extracted all the blood they can and given us back scraps. AWS is repackaged software you pay more for. Yes, it's managed, but you're forever a renter.
They've destroyed our open web, replaced RSS with DRM, left us with streaming and music options worse than cable and personal audio libraries.
The web is bloated with ads and tracking, AMP is given preference, Facebook and Twitter are testing the limits of democracy and radicalizing everyone to cancel one another.
Remember when the Internet was actually pleasant? When it was nice to build stuff for others to use?
Stop giving your work away for free when the companies only take.
- part1of2 6y agoWhat billion dollar industry is built on top of faker.js?
- donmcronald 6y agoNone, but think of it in the context of time = money. Discussions about self hosting development environments will be filled with people claiming it's not worth the opportunity cost to spend the time setting up and maintaining anything yourself when you can pay $X per month and make it someone else's problem. In the same context, how long does it take to write something like faker.js? I've never used it, but I see commits that are at least 6 years old and there are 200+ contributors. Is that 1000s of hours? I honestly don't know. Let's say it's 1000 hours just for an example and that someone worth $100k / year could write it. At $50 / hour that's $50k if you have have to build it in house and you lose out on the value of having 200+ contributors that are familiar with part of the codebase plus tens of thousands of users exposing bugs and edge cases. So IMHO when you have codebases like this the corporate donations should be in $10k increments. I would never publish a line of code under the MIT license. It's great for companies that want to popularize their platforms (like Microsoft is doing), but it's terrible for small developers and you'll rarely get any value from those projects.
- jiofih 6y agoAlmost every project I worked on had a shitty version of faker, written in half an hour for specific needs. It’s a very cosmetic thing, as you’d never rely on this type of dataset for testing actual behaviour of critical code.
- ganafagol 6y agoI agree with your sentiment, but this is not the right reaction. It won't improve anything. What's the point of open source if companies just steal it, build billion dollar industries on top, and then lock everything down? You are free to adjust the license to prevent this. But then tomorrow everybody comes and rants about that the GPL is too restrictive. That's the price we pay for this. It's the license that keeps work free. The right reaction is not to stop producing open source software. The right reaction is to adjust the license.
- echelon 6y agoGPLv4 needs to address a number of new problems: * "any user data serviced by this software must be easily exportable; no attempt must be made to block other 3rd party companies or services from consuming this data" * "if this software is itself sold as a service, any automation or tooling built in service of this system must also be made available as open source" * "any devices using this software must not actively prevent or prohibit users from running their own software"
- LukeShu 6y agoTwo of those are already in the GNU AGPLv3 (2007).
- gogopuppygogo 6y agoIt’s like a catch-22 though. If I start a company using open source and must give away the software I then build on top of it as open source then I likely fail to capture revenues and my company fails. What would be a nice option in GPL 4 is a mandatory commercial licensing fee structure to pay either to author of software or to EFF / FSF if the author doesn’t provide payment details. That would give a commercial incentive to startups to pursue using open source AND provide real revenues back to the community.
- StavrosK 6y ago> It’s like a catch-22 though. If I start a company using open source and must give away the software I then build on top of it as open source then I likely fail to capture revenues and my company fails. How is that the open source author's problem? Open source is meant to enable user freedom, not to save corporations money. If you want to use something, contact the author and get a commercial license.
- aboringusername 6y ago[this comment was deleted as HN doesn't pay me to contribute to the discussion]
- arbitel 6y agoWhat? You opted for Spotify model when you sign up for the service. I am pretty sure you are still free to purchase the music or album in iTunes.
- Xylakant 6y agoYou’re even still free to just go buy the CD and rip it, as odd as it sounds.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tpetry 6y agoWhat happens with your iTunes music if your apple account would get locked? Sadly the only option nowadays would be purchasing hard discs, and hope theres no protection on the disk as you are not allowed to break it
- D2187645 6y agoThis is deeply insightful.
- MaximumYComb 6y agoHere in Australia the streaming options for music/video are better than our previous options for CD's/cable. A three month subscription to Spotify costs less than a single album would cost me 20 years ago.... not even account for inflation. A monthly Netflix subscription is 20% of the price that cable would cost here 5 years ago.
- echelon 6y ago> Spotify You don't own the music. You can't share it, use your own software to analyze, shuffle, remix it, etc. > Netflix subscription But now there's Hulu, Disney+, Amazon Prime, HBO Go, Showtime Anytime, Peacock Premium, etc. Except now instead of one easy to use interface to access it all, it's spread out all over the place and inconsistent as hell. And more expensive!
- matlock 6y ago> You don't own the music. You can't share it, use your own software to analyze, shuffle, remix it, etc I'm a consumer of music, not a creator so I don't care that I don't own it. There are tons of ways creators can analyze, shuffle, remix or do whatever with it, but as a pure consumer Spotify is simply much better for me than CDs. I never cared about owning Music, CDs were always just a transport Medium so I can listen to the music. > But now there's Hulu, Disney+, Amazon Prime, HBO Go, Showtime Anytime, Peacock Premium, etc. Except now instead of one easy to use interface to access it all, it's spread out all over the place and inconsistent as hell. And more expensive! They aren't though because you can be selective and cancel anytime and resubscribe. And you can watch exactly what you want at any time compared to cable. As a consumer it is way better because there is way more choice and competition at the moment.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- kgwgk 6y ago> instead of one easy to use interface to access it all one easy to use interface to access whatever was on
- qz2 6y agoWe should fork everything and relicense for the end user’s sake. Have said this for years. Also start looking at a plan B for the www. Gopher is a winner there because it’s difficult to use it for anything other than information delivery. While this is extreme, we need a contrasting platform to fall back on always.
- gkoberger 6y agoHmm, I agree with you, but this is a bit different. It’s not like someone took faker.js and started charging for it. It’s a tool that the author chose to give away, and other companies used. There’s literally nothing even asking people to pay, other than sponsorships at the bottom of the README. You can’t expect companies to pay if you never ask! I’d love to see GitHub create more avenues for paying for software. Shareware-esque licenses with an easy way to pay, bounties attached to Issues, etc. I think companies _would_ pay (if given a reason); right now it’s framed as a sponsorship (not even a donation!) so the thought process for a company (assuming they even notice it and consider it) is “well, I don’t think it’s a good marketing expense for us” and that’s it. I’d say most people using faker.js aren’t big companies trying to fuck over a random dev. It’s an employee typing “npm install faker.js”, and genuinely never thinking about it.
- sriku 6y ago> You can’t expect companies to pay if you never ask! You're right. Sadly, those making use of the software are often not the ones holding the purse. The request gets only to the Devs looking at the software pages and nobody generally writes to management saying "we want to use this open source software in our product and this guy/girl asks to be monetarily supported to maintain the software". Just straight off making a commercial use license is better and clearer. However, often devs can't take on potential liabilities in such cases, which further complicates matters.
- onion2k 6y agoIt’s an employee typing “npm install faker.js”, and genuinely never thinking about it. That's the problem.
- cool-RR 6y agoIt's not stealing when you've given it away, explicitly and out of your own free will.
- rleigh 6y agoYou're right, it's not stealing. You have chosen to give it away for use in this manner. But the other side of the coin is that this is increasingly unsustainable. Free/open source software development works best when it is based upon mutual self-interest fostering cooperation and collaboration. At the extreme, it is increasingly an altruistic/parasitic arrangement (on the part of producer and consumer, respectively) where the producer gets zero benefit from their efforts but the consumer benefits greatly. It has always been the case that there are more consumers than producers. That's an inevitability, and the number of consumers isn't itself the problem. But this simply cannot be sustainable at scale due to the limitations of available developer resources and ongoing requirement for unavoidable commitment. It becomes exploitative because it sets up the expectation and demands that people work for free, writing code, reviewing code, maintaining infrastructure, supporting users etc.. This is one reason I've dialled back all my participation; it ends up costing me greatly in time, resources and stress, for almost zero benefit. At some point, free is actually too costly, and paying for products and services is fairer all around. We have, after all, invented a monetary system, companies and employment laws to ensure that people are properly compensated for their efforts.
- vinkelhake 6y agoWhat a sad zero-sum way of looking at things. Your open source software doesn't go away because some corporation decides to use it. The companies you list have made substantial contributions to open source.
- pitay 6y agoThey've destroyed our open web, replaced RSS with DRM, left us with streaming and music options worse than cable and personal audio libraries. The web is bloated with ads and tracking, AMP is given preference, Facebook and Twitter are testing the limits of democracy and radicalizing everyone to cancel one another. This is the important part from the GP. If they were under the AGPL or say a new better GPL which patches the problems with GPLv3 then those companies that have destroyed the open web would have at least had to buy the work or do it themselves. Even if that doesn't have a huge impact on the state of things, at least project maintainers can say that they are not contributing to it.
- pjmlp 6y agoThat is what happens when the hipster folks attack GPL and push for MIT like licenses. Had Linus not chosen it for Linux and I bet I would still be using a mix of Solaris, Aix and HP-UX on the server room. Dual licensing is the only true path, it was already so in the shareware days, and it will be back to be the daily reality. Bills have to paid.
- keyle 6y agoHow does dual licensing works? Got a prime example simple to understand? Asking for a friend...
- cercatrova 6y agoYou offer a copyleft license like AGPL but also offer a paid license for those who don't want to deal with AGPL. Since you as the creator own the copyright, you can license it however you want, including multiple licenses simultaneously.
- kybernetikos 6y agoIt's a pattern that works very well - many large companies have standing policies that they can't use copyleft licensed software so they have to get the paid license while those happy with the copyleft social contract get to enjoy and contribute for free.
- cercatrova 6y agoCorrect, although not every company shies away from copyleft, namely Amazon which will package your AGPL product wholesale and sell it. They are after all not required to open source their infrastructure code.
- chii 6y ago> package your AGPL product wholesale and sell it. if anyone has a problem with that, then they have a problem with software being open source. Or they are discriminatory and just don't want anyone they personally dont like to benefit.
- stiray 6y agoWell this somehow reflects what I am seeing for last 20 years. Hobby or just passion of open source is fueling the industry to forge massive profits while on other side provide peanuts for authors, far less than if they were their employees (or lets rather say: 0). I was working on multiple close source projects for different companies that were avoiding anything GPL, searching for permissive replacements and in never giving back anything - not even bug fixes. Like openssl[1]. Actually even GPL is not a protection here, with sources given away they become almost a manual how to re-implement it which is far simpler than making it from scratch (oh and yes, people are doing that without copy pasting). What open source has accomplished was for sure making technology more available, but on the other side, to name just a few: - lowered expenses of companies on buying software, especially on various SaaS companies that dont distribute software - keeping the need for experienced developers and vages down while on the other side raised paychecks of system administrators and system integrators - creating a viability to hire anyone as a developer while on the other side driving anything complex out of industry as companies were avoiding doing projects where complex knowledge is needed (I am not talking about top of gauss curve companies) - lowering a quality of software - putting together lego blocks and if they dont fit writing a little glue is hardly ever as efficient as writing tool for problem solving dedicated to the problem. Not to mention free availability of tons of over-complicated "does it all" frameworks that dont really fit to solving any particular problem perfectly, but are good enough to avoid solving complex problem where you have no workforce that would actually be able to solve it. And guess who profits - engineers certainly not. Actually we are denominating our work by giving it out for free (try to get someone to paint your walls, to lay down some ceramic tiles, to fix your car,... for a price of mentioning who did it behind the bumper, under a tile,...) [1] https://www.buzzfeed.com/chrisstokelwalker/the-internet-is-being-protected-by-two-guys-named-st https://www.buzzfeed.com/chrisstokelwalker/the-internet-is-b...
- berdario 6y ago> Actually even GPL is not a protection here, with sources given away they become almost a manual how to re-implement it which is far simpler than making it from scratch (oh and yes, people are doing that without copy pasting). That's quite a gamble, since it falls foul of the Clean Room Implementation criteria https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clean_room_design https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clean_room_design Big companies (faang) won't touch that approach with a 10 meters pole, but obviously I'm not surprised that smaller actors might have a more cavalier attitude to copyright law.
- pmiller2 6y agoThat's all just called capitalism.
- afiori 6y agoor rather it is not paying for free stuff and internet-enabled global scale. Not really sure whether capitalism really plays a significant role here more than simply allowing enterprises to exists
- waynesonfire 6y ago> if companies just steal it just like how biden stole the election? how is using the software stealing when it's used as licensed?
- kome 6y agoPerhaps people should start reconsider using GPL 3... once again, Richard Stallman was right all along.
- chinathrow 6y ago> Apple is telling us we can't run our own software on their goddamned devices, yet they built their empire on open source. Stop. Buying. Their. Shit.
- spockz 6y agoAre you familiar with the TimescaleDB license[1]? It basically means open source but companies cannot just take the product and offer it as a (paid?) service. They are allowed to provide other services services that are built with timescale underneath but not offer the product itself as a service. [1]: https://github.com/timescale/timescaledb/blob/master/tsl/LICENSE-TIMESCALE https://github.com/timescale/timescaledb/blob/master/tsl/LIC...
- StavrosK 6y agoThe TimescaleDB license can only apply to TimescaleDB.
- spockz 6y agoThere is nothing holding you back to create a similar license for your own product.
- StavrosK 6y agoExcept for the fact that I can't afford to pay a lawyer a few thousand dollars to draft a license for my OSS libraries.
- Shorel 6y agoTreat it like code. Do some refactoring and that's it. I do see your point, if the license had to be written from scratch. But you already have a template. Use it.
- orlandohill 6y agoThe Polyform Project has two source-available licenses that achieve a similar result. * Perimeter https://polyformproject.org/licenses/perimeter/1.0.0 https://polyformproject.org/licenses/perimeter/1.0.0 * Shield https://polyformproject.org/licenses/shield/1.0.0/ https://polyformproject.org/licenses/shield/1.0.0/
- jariel 6y ago"companies just steal it," - they're definitely not, they're using it well within the terms into which it's published. Of course, there might hopefully be a better way of sorting this out so that if devs want to, they can also get some kind of 'open comp' as well.
- stock_toaster 6y agoSeems like Feudalism rides again. We’re just peasants working on a new set of kings’ land now.
- frereubu 6y agoWhile I agree with some of your points - which to me mostly boils down to rent-seeking monopolies / duopolies - I think you're seriously underestimating the "Yes, it's managed..." part. People are still perfectly at liberty to run their own servers, and the fees for running servers that handle the kinds of traffic that used to happen "when the Internet was actually pleasant" are peanuts. Running any kind of server used to involve purchasing hardware, bandwidth was orders of magnitude more expensive and so on. This server-as-a-service means that for $5 a month I was able to build a Python Twitter bot that tweets the diary entries of a 17th century English naturalist[0,1]. It means I got to do something fun without the overhead of actually running the server. It's a small thing, and as I said I agree with what was probably the main thrust of what you were saying, but it really feels like you're throwing the baby out with the bathwater through your obvious exasperation. [0] https://twitter.com/gilbertwhitetwt https://twitter.com/gilbertwhitetwt [1] https://gilbertwhitetweets.org/ https://gilbertwhitetweets.org/
- ckastner 6y ago> What's the point of open source if companies just steal it, build billion dollar industries on top, and then lock everything down? That sentence is a contradiction in itself. > Apple is telling us we can't run our own software on their goddamned devices, yet they built their empire on open source. Not on GPL-licensed open source, as far as I know. > Look at Facebook, Google, Amazon. They've extracted all the blood they can and given us back scraps. That is simply not true. A great deal of the open source software I use on a day-to-day basis is funded by some of these companies. The number of GitHub repositories they publish for all to use, under permissive licenses, is immense. > The web is bloated with ads and tracking, AMP is given preference, Facebook and Twitter are testing the limits of democracy and radicalizing everyone to cancel one another. You are right about this, but this is at best tangentially related to open source.
- 08-15 6y agoThe point of Free Software is to protect the freedom of the user. Open Source doesn't have a point and never did.
- billyjobob 6y agoYou’re far too generous. Open Source has always had a point, and it’s succeeded in achieving that point: the point is to take mindshare away from Free Software so developers use non-copyleft licenses that are preferable to big business.
- DougBTX 6y ago> Look at Facebook, Google, Amazon. They've extracted all the blood they can and given us back scraps. Facebook and Google at least have put out a lot of open source code, have you heard of React and Angular? PyTorch and TensorFlow? There are some pretty big names in their list of public open source projects.
- patrickk 6y ago> Serge quickly discovered, to his surprise, that Goldman had a one-way relationship with open source. They took huge amounts of free software off the Web, but they did not return it after he had modified it, even when his modifications were very slight and of general rather than financial use. “Once I took some open-source components, repackaged them to come up with a component that was not even used at Goldman Sachs,” he says. > Open source was an idea that depended on collaboration and sharing, and Serge had a long history of contributing to it. He didn’t fully understand how Goldman could think it was O.K. to benefit so greatly from the work of others and then behave so selfishly toward them. “You don’t create intellectual property,” he said. “You create a program that does something.” But from then on, on instructions from Schlesinger, he treated everything on Goldman Sachs’s servers, even if it had just been transferred there from open source, as Goldman Sachs’s property. (At Serge’s trial Kevin Marino, his lawyer, flashed two pages of computer code: the original, with its open-source license on top, and a replica, with the open-source license stripped off and replaced by the Goldman Sachs license.) From an excellent article[1] by Michael Lewis, on Goldman Sachs' attitude towards open source software. EDIT: typo [1] https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2013/09/michael-lewis-goldman-sachs-programmer https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2013/09/michael-lewis-goldma...
- donmcronald 6y agoThat's a great read. I don't understand the prime number part though: > 3599 = (3600 – 1) = (602 – 12) = (60 – 1) (60 + 1) = 59 times 61. Not a prime number. Where does the (602 - 12) come from? Can someone explain that to me? Also, use a leading space to keep things out of your bash history.
- asimjalis 6y agoThat’s 60^2 - 1^2. The exponentiation was lost in the rendering I suspect.
- keithlfrost 6y agoThat should read as 60^2 - 1^2 -- the twos should be typeset as superscript.
- HugoDaniel 6y agoOne reason why I use the EUPL license for most of my hobbies.
- boublepop 6y ago> Seriously. What's the point of open source if companies just steal it, build billion dollar industries on top, and then lock everything down? You can’t offer people a free lunch and then claim they are steeling if they don’t voluntarily tip you the full cost of a lunch. Open source software is provided under a license and if Apple or Amazon or whoever do not violate that license they are not steeling. If you didn’t want them to use the software under the license you provided the software under chose a different license. The point of open source is exactly to provide software under open source terms. If you want to add additional terms like “unless you make money then I want to get paid”, then just do that! It’s your software and your license! But you cannot have Heisenbergs open source software which is open source only until someone picks it up and makes money at which point it retroactively becomes proprietary in order to force that moneystream past you.
- StavrosK 6y ago> You can’t offer people a free lunch and then claim they are steeling if they don’t voluntarily tip you the full cost of a lunch. No, but I can be miffed if I offer people a free lunch and they turn around and sell the free lunch I paid to make and keep all the money.
- prepend 6y agoYou certainly can, but why? It’s a problem easily solved by not giving away free lunches or adding terms. It seems odd to me to have the solution completely within my power to fix, but not fix it, and complain about the situation. In my view, the license is specifically made to allow reselling. That’s why I pick MIT, Apache, and BSD. If I don’t want people to resell then I pick GPL or some other license.
- StavrosK 6y agoBecause I want to give my software away to individuals and small companies, but if someone gets big enough that they can afford to pay, I want them to pay me then. I don't want to discourage them from using my thing when they're small.
- sargun 6y agoI would disagree about google and Facebook. Both have made tremendous OSS contributions such as BPF LSM, level db, react, and zstd.
- puranjay 6y agoThe internet is now positively a nasty place. Everyone is optimizing for "engagement" which essentially equates to "controversial content". You can't find any genuine advice because Google has been gamed to the point where top 50 pages for any query are affiliate pages. Forums and the communities they fostered are dead. Their replacement, Reddit, has a structure that favors the hive mind. There are ads everywhere and they swing between downright creepy (ads about what you were searching for an hour ago) to completely awful (semi-pornographic Taboola/Outbrain ads). When they're neither of these things, they are just plainly deceptive (sponsored content).
- echelon 6y agoI really hate the internet now. I used to love it so much. It's what taught me my current career and brought me financial independence. If I could press a button and erase Apple, Google, Facebook, and Twitter from existence I would. It's all trash.
- tester34 6y ago>Forums and the communities they fostered are dead. Not really - I still use forums (that use my native language) and they feel great! way better than Reddit and have significant active user base.
- ratww 6y agoThis 1000x. I used to work at a company that pivoted into "growth hacking" and it seriously made me sick how at the end we had 1500 freelancers being paid peanuts to write about subjects they had minimum knowledge about, using other similarly shallow articles as their only reference. Today I can't search anything on the internet without coming across those. It's always the same: a shitty Wordpress blog and a 1500-word article with 1% of the depth of a Wikipedia Article. And some people have the gall to distrust Wikipedia when believing those. We have 50 websites for lyrics and guitar tabs but they are 10% content (and it's always copied from somewhere else, or each other) and 90% advertisement. If you look for software you're are either gonna get legitimate companies (Download.com) trying to inject you with install-spyware, or piracy blogs trying to infect you with legitimate malware.
- sneak 6y agoCopying isn’t stealing when we do it with songs and movies, and copying isn’t stealing when corporate programmers do it with free software we’ve published on the web for all to use.
- nextlevelwizard 6y ago>Remember when the Internet was actually pleasant? That was went it wasn't useful for normal people. You don't want to go back in that time. Most people browsing this site wouldn't have the job they currently have without popularization (and thus pollution) of the Internet. >left us with (...) music options worse (...) personal audio libraries. This has to be hyperbole, right? My music library has exploded since I signed up to Spotify. I get exposed to new artists and genres pretty frequently. Way more often than in the days of sneaker netting mp3s. Not to mention that I get this all legally and guilt free.
- cblconfederate 6y ago> the Internet was actually pleasant? When it was nice to build stuff for others to use? The internet was not pleasant, it was chaotic and that s what made it so fun. And yeah there's nothing like building stuff on an open platform that nobody gatekeeps. A feeling lost for an entire generation of developers now.
- rglullis 6y agoI agree with the sentiment, but the responsibility is as much as (if not more) from consumers as from companies. If consumers only look at sticker price of every product and ignore all externalities, then companies will work to give them that. It is up for consumers to refuse software that takes their freedoms, locks them up in golden cages, makes their lives super convenient at the expense of underpaid/exploited labor, etc.
- HeadsUpHigh 6y agoYes helllo, agpl called, they wanted to let you know to not license your stuff with permissive licenses. If you do stop complaining about the situation
- black_puppydog 6y agoI'm going to replicate one of my recent replies ([4] which unsurprisingly got me downvoted, but I regret nothing) here because it seems relevant. Specifically, Marak seems to grok the exploitatitive nature of the current setup (chosen in part by themselves) but lacks real negotiation leverage because they have no organization behind them (besides people cheering them on in the comments). With this in mind, I think it's okay for me to get the big scary words out here again. :) The problem (okay, "a" problem) here is that it is indeed OSS, and not FOSS, that is being used. It might be worth re-visiting "Post-Open Source" by Melody Horn (boringcactus) [1] on this. You might want to copy/paste that link instead of clicking. :) It has been discussed here before [2] and (unsurprisingly, IMHO) gotten quite a bit of blow-back from the HN crowd. The General Intellect Unit podcast recently had an episode on the piece [3] and I think they made the point clearer (well... also they roll the piece out to 1h 40min) by more openly posing it in a class struggle context. (Side note: please don't post replies attacking this as communist. The podcast has "marxists" in the name, you wouldn't be insulting them, and I'm merely engaging with their content, so if you're gonna try to attack their/my positions, please do the same and don't just throw scary words.) The bottom-line is that Open Source Software has nothing to do with the freedoms of the developers. It is... * a corporate entrenchment scheme: enlarging your hiring pool by establishing your in-house solution as the industry standard, giving you full hiring pipelines and stronger negotiation position against current and prospective employees. * a capitalist commons: by tending to one industry standard, the companies (not their devs, who will still have full work days) save on duplication of effort. At the same time FOSS (which does focus on the freedoms of the devs to read, modify, learn...) kind of misses the point by being... * too obvious a trap, and thus ineffective. No sane capitalist company will go anywhere near AGPL code (and we just had an example on HN of someone trying. it wasn't pretty) * ultimately not even clear on how this will make anyone's lives materially better, even if it were effective. It's not gonna raise your salary, nor give you more paid vacation, health insurance. As a dev, you'll still be producing surplus value (okay, in a hopefully less alienated way) that will then not be paid to you (that's the definition of profit) so from this perspective the "F" in FOSS doesn't really bring much to the table. The GIU podcast concludes that yeah, working in IT was nice for a while, because it posed some fundamental problems to capital and as a dev you were in a much better negotiation position. However, those times are over. Capital has found a way to make IT labour just as fungible as manual labor, at least to the extent that we should expect those "rock star" benefits to dwindle soon. Up to us to realize that and take action. Again: relaying analysis here. Not sure I buy all of it. But even if, please keep your replies centered on the content, not the vocabulary it's presented with. [1]: https://www.boringcactus.com/2020/08/13/post-open-source.htm https://www.boringcactus.com/2020/08/13/post-open-source.htm... [2]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24397552 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24397552 [3]: http://generalintellectunit.net/e/066-post-open-source/ http://generalintellectunit.net/e/066-post-open-source/ [4]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24977616 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24977616
- ForHackernews 6y agoThe FSF has been saying this for decades. I don't know whether to laugh or cry that so many proponents of non-copyleft software are belatedly discovering that grasping corporations will take and take without ever contributing back. Now do you people see why the GPL matters?
- MisterTea 6y agoI said this years ago: open source always the brides maid, never the bride. That or its a bit like atlas, holding up the burden of capitalism. Either way the internet is still just a big ip network. You can still setup a vps and run your own email, website, rss, blog, etc. And I know some people (masochists, psychos?;-) who do but they do that admin work for a living. Yeah, you gotta roll up your sleeves but that's just life: you have to work for it. These companies prey on human laziness and "free" stuff. Just stop using garbage services and take back control. I'm one of those technological troglodytes who refuses to participate in most modern web nonsense. I have a smart phone with only a few utilitarian programs. I don't use any social media. I use bandcamp to stream/download my music collection which I paid outright for. I don't have any smart appliances, TV's or IoT trash. My life is fine and I have plenty of friends and a social life. Don't let anyone fool you into thinking you need to drink the dumpster juice internet koolaid.
- josteink 6y ago> Remember when the Internet was actually pleasant? When it was nice to build stuff for others to use? I do. I definitely miss it. And I fully agree with your post up until this point. > Stop giving your work away for free when the companies only take. Or just use a license which forbids locked down SaaS exploitation.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- indigochill 6y ago> Seriously. What's the point of open source if companies just steal it, build billion dollar industries on top, and then lock everything down? Let's imagine a VPN company is a thin front on top of Tor and they charge $50/year for their "service". They're not stealing Tor. It doesn't mean Tor should stop existing. Sure, it's a scummy thing for the company to do, but Tor is still a valuable resource that remains free for anyone to use. The point of open source is the creation of value. That some companies capture some of that value (usually less egregiously than this example - AWS is actually providing a dynamic host scaling service that happens to host open source software, Apple is providing a software vetting service and top-notch hardware that happens to be built on Unix) is irrelevant in the bigger picture. > Remember when the Internet was actually pleasant? When it was nice to build stuff for others to use? This is still true if open source developers are more focused on delivering overall value than they are on their jealousy that a company is integrating their software and charging for it. This could definitely be frustrating if the developer was hoping to make a business out of their software, but if that's the real problem then the license should reflect that.
- Qwertious 6y agoThere's a certain level of irony when people complain about the morality, after using the term "open source" that was specifically coined to distance itself from the moralizing of "free software". I'm not saying there's a radical difference between "free software" projects and "open source" projects or anything, but it really seems like we ought to stop and reflect on where we might have made mistakes in the past.
- jabl 6y ago> Seriously. What's the point of open source if companies just steal it, build billion dollar industries on top, and then lock everything down? To nitpick: They are not stealing it, they're using it per the license terms. Don't like that? Well, choose a different license. That being said, I think there's an underlying point here. The "business-friendly" open source movement co-opted the idealistic free software movement. It was no longer about making the world better in terms of having a software ecosystem that respects the four freedoms etc., but about reducing wheel reinvention, minimizing transaction costs, attracting good developers to come work for your corporation, and so on. One could argue that the idea of causing social change by coding free software in your basement was always an impossible dream. If you want to see political change, join a political movement and get out on the street protesting or something. And vote! > Yes, it's managed, but you're forever a renter. Welcome to 21st century tenement farming. > Remember when the Internet was actually pleasant? When it was nice to build stuff for others to use? I started hanging around on usenet in the early-mid 90'ies. Let me tell you, it was already a cesspool then (maybe it was better in the 80'ies, but I was too young then, sorry). Of course, back then it was mostly just people being assholes, not billion dollar corporations weaponizing assholes and hatred to drive clicks. > Stop giving your work away for free when the companies only take. I think so far open source has worked out pretty well for programmers, because there's such a huge demand for (competent) ones. If you want a glimpse how it'll look when demand starts to match supply better, take a look at your friends with liberal arts, sociology, politics etc. degrees. Unpaid internships and extensive open source portfolios before you get a real job, here we come!
- harimau777 6y agoGood points! The issue that I see is that many (most?) people want a middle ground: On the one hand, it's not important to them to use some sort of viral copyleft license that forces people who use their project to make their code free. On the other hand, they don't want people who use their project to be aggressively anti-competitive or anti-developer. So for example, it would be fine if Apple charged for their OS and kept it closed source as long as they allowed anyone who wants to develop apps for their OS to do so.
- Qwertious 6y ago
- williamtwild 6y ago>left us with streaming and music options worse than cable and personal audio libraries. The way you word this is like streaming is the only option we have. It's not. Just buy CDs.
- runako 6y agoI'm curious how you would feel about a scrappy bootstrapped startup building their business around your FOSS and then, sometime much later, becoming a large company whose founders become billionaires. (I have a couple of examples in mind where this has happened.) > What's the point of open source if companies just steal it, build billion dollar industries on top, and then lock everything down? For folks who do not work 100% in OSS, there can be many points: - The whole Github-as-resume thing makes it important to have public contributions (most people's day job lives in private repos). To some extent, much of the industry needs OSS in lieu of effective employee screening processes. - It's a convenient way for big companies to exchange IP without formal bilateral agreements. Everyone else just benefits for free. - Your line of work is X, but you built a crude project for Y. You open source it because you don't actually care about area Y at all but hope your work could be useful for someone else. - You write something for yourself and publish in the hopes that someone else will help you improve it for free. You're looking for free work and/or critique of your work. You don't actually care if someone else makes a billion dollars on it because you weren't interested in starting a business around it. Plus, you gain reputational points from having built it (consider Linus Torvalds's ability to get work as a programmer as a result of having started Linux, for example).
- phkahler 6y ago>> Seriously. What's the point of open source if companies just steal it, build billion dollar industries on top, and then lock everything down? If this a a concern, then at least use GPLv3 and not BSD or MIT.