9 ms·
Being a centrist, I can definitely understand the desire for more conservative policies, and a rejection of more liberal policies. What has been tough for me pe
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
Being a centrist, I can definitely understand the desire for more conservative policies, and a rejection of more liberal policies. What has been tough for me personally, though, is to see a person as amoral as Trump get so much support. I DO agree that Trump has done some good things, things that before him neither the left nor the right was willing to do in a substantial way (mainly his forcing a re-evaluation of our relationship with China). But his utter (and ongoing) disregard for our democratic system, his incessant lying, the fact that all he cares about is loyalty to him but gives no loyalty in return, the insane narcissism, treating the Justice Dept. like his personal legal firm, etc., etc.. I just find it disgusting on every level.
That said, the recent Sam Harris podcast really helped me understand his appeal. And I hope (but am not hopeful) that the left tries to mend their ways by refraining from pushing (mainly white, straight men, but also others, like the religious) many further from the Democratic party.
- CameronNemo 6y agoI really detest the conservative vs. liberal duality. Conservatism is not comparable to liberalism. They are not alternatives. It just means a desire to maintain the status quo. The opposite of conservatism is progressivism, not liberalism. In fact most Republicans in the US are liberal-democrats.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoI mean, I don't disagree with you, but I feel you are missing my primary point, which is that I have no problem with people that have a strong preference for current Republican policy positions (or, on the flip side, Democratic). My problem is that Trump is just a man of such awful character that it hurts to see how many supported him, regardless of policy preferences. I have never felt this way about any previous president, Republican or Democrat.
- beaner 6y agoWhen considering a person of "awful character," a lot of people make the rational decision to nonetheless value the benefit of 320 million people as more important than retribution against that one person, if that person's policies benefit the rest.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoBut that's my point - a huge percentage of Trump supporters (not all, but probably a majority) don't support Trump for his policy positions. Indeed, there are large numbers of people who voted Republican in the past who love Trump despite the fact that Trump has done a complete 180 on policy items that used to be core Republican positions: support of free trade and being against protectionism and tariffs, support for foreign wars, containment of Russia, etc. Most support for Trump is at a deep, emotional level (to be fair, strong support for leadership usually is).
- beaner 6y agoThere was certainly an "anyone but Hillary" contingent, but I think you'll find by actually talking to these people that the venn diagram overlap between that circle and the "actually likes Trump's policies" circle is about 99%. A lot of the points you mentioned are points that people who were not Left, have come to move past on the Right. The Right has changed. Trump does support free trade - if the US is not taken advantage of. Foreign wars are something everyone's tired of. Russia as a major threat is not something people take seriously, unless it's used to influence people against Trump. Etc. Many on the right would classify the points you mentioned as "neocon" or "neoliberal," something they've always been uncomfortable with and seen as an infection of the party and had to grudgingly accept without alternative, until Trump. Support for Trump is at a deep, emotional level for many. But certainly not in spite of his policy positions. If anything, his policy positions reinforce that emotion for most of his supporters. The people most in need of good policy, at the price of an acceptable nonchalance regarding a president's mere presentability - minorities - made their voices heard by voting for Trump. Every single minority demographic voted in higher numbers for Trump this election over last. The only demographic to vote for him less? White men. And that made the difference. The privileged have the benefit of being able to vote based on presentability. The rest of the population cannot afford to in the same way.
- emmelaich 6y agoPerhaps it's often been that way in the USA (and elsewhere). The outsiders make the progress. Reading https://www.amazon.com/Renegade-History-United-States/dp/1416576134 https://www.amazon.com/Renegade-History-United-States/dp/141... "A Renegade History of the United States" by Thaddeus Russell
- Karunamon 6y agoPolitical designations are contextual, not universal. Liberals call themselves liberals and most people in the country understand what that means. Definitions used in other countries are irrelevant.
- CameronNemo 6y agoThey are really not contextual. Americans need to understand each others perspectives if they hope to ever come together. Understanding the political philosophies of liberalism, democratism, socialism, fascism, and anarchism is important. Those philosophies don't change from one country to the next, even if they translate into different sets of policies.
- Karunamon 6y agoIf the "same" philosophy results in different policies when applied in different countries, that to me lends more credence to their contextuality.
- CameronNemo 6y agoDifferent countries can have different challenges and circumstances facing them. The philosophy is framework to draft policies from, not a blueprint for how to run a community.
- tonitosou 6y agowhen you say "Amoral" some facts backing it up would be appreciated for the sake of the debate.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoI honestly don't believe this is a serious question, and anyone paying any attention over the last 4 years couldn't believe it is a serious question either. But to humor you, here is a good summary from Olivia Troye, former Republican member of the White House Covid task force and aid to Pence: https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2020/10/olivia-troye-white-house-coronavirus-task-force-pence.html https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2020/10/olivia-troye-whi... Basically, Trump's only concern about Covid was how it would affect his re-election chances. And this isn't just some "disgruntled staffer". Basically everything she says backs up Trump's own public pronouncements of only seeing Covid as some politically motivated attack, instead of one of the most serious threats facing our nation in decades. Trump has been extremely transparent that he only views events as how they will help or hurt him. That's a very fair definition of amoral to me.
- FpUser 6y ago>"...Trump has been extremely transparent that he only views events as how they will help or hurt him" I'd say that this is the default behavior of majority of the population. Politicians do it probably even more. They just do not admit it.
- pjc50 6y ago> left tries to mend their ways by refraining from pushing (mainly white, straight men, but also others, like the religious) many further from the Democratic party. Genuine question: how can this be done without giving up on the people who don't match that description?
- eric_b 6y agoYou can support people of color without actively denigrating straight white men. Or, you know, we could stop focusing on race, gender and sexuality so fucking much. The most important thing about a person in 2020 is their race it seems. Followed closely by their gender and sexual orientation. That is what needs to change.
- pjc50 6y agoDoes this mean giving up on attempting to prosecute police officers who murder citizens? > The most important thing about a person in 2020 is their race it seems. Followed closely by their gender and sexual orientation All US presidents (until Obama!) have been straight white guys. Was that a coincidence, or was it in fact vitally important in their election?
- hn_throwaway_99 6y ago> Does this mean giving up on attempting to prosecute police officers who murder citizens? I'm not sure how your response there follows at all from the GP's comment of "You can support people of color without actively denigrating straight white men", and indeed I feel like this is a clear example of what I'm thinking about.
- Daishiman 6y agoIt follows because "supporting people of color" is an empty statement if it isn't backed by policies, some of which are quite different from the status quo.
- colinmhayes 6y ago
- gigatexal 6y agoI’d love to see an AOC/O’Rourke ticket sometime in the future. Both sides could do with a culling of the old and an infusion of new blood.
- eric_b 6y agoErmm, I read parent's comment as an appeal to moderation. I'm not sure how AOC is going to help anything?
- _prototype_ 6y agoA person that wants to put Trump supporters on a hit-list (AOC) and someone willing to force weapon buy-backs upon the population (Rourke). What an amazing combination for triggering civil unrest and possible war. Get out of your bubble
- gigatexal 6y agoI think she might moderate over time.
- pluto9 6y agoMaybe, but presumably you want to see her on a ticket because you support her policies right now. If a more moderate candidate is what you want, then why not support someone who's already moderate?
- gigatexal 6y agoNot culling in murder but removal from office. It was a stupid choice of wording on my part.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y ago> And I hope (but am not hopeful) that the left tries to mend their ways by refraining from pushing many (mainly white, straight men, but also others, like the religious) further from the Democratic party. >> Both sides could do with a culling of the old and an infusion of new blood. Don't know if I could have come up with a better example of the unhelpful language I'm talking about if I tried. Why would some white guy, say, in his 50s want to be on board with your "culling of the old" rhetoric?
- sebmellen 6y agoI had a Lyft driver on a business trip in Pennsylvania recently who was a very nice fellow. He was immunocompromised, worried about COVID, and said he hated Trump's character. And yet, he said he was voting for Trump. Why? Because Joe Biden was a pedophile whose son f~~ked underage Chinese children and took money from a Ukranian dictator to influence US policy. He saw Biden as more amoral than Trump. I think this is a significant demographic block that's been ignored, because the media class doesn't really meet with people of these sort. He was extremely convinced, and I'm sure he really believed it. He really seemed upset about the moral quandary of voting for Trump vs. voting for a pedophile.
- throwawaygh 6y agoThe media class is not ignoring these people. It's getting really rich feeding them this poison. The media class consists of more than just a few large center-left outlets.
- sebmellen 6y agoFair point. I was surprised at my blind spot, which I think I have because my media consumption consists mostly of the centrist media outlets you refer to. I never realized how influential Bitchute QAnon believers are or One America News Network is either (mainly due to social media algorithms running haywire). Tristan Harris of the Social Dilemma made some really great points to this effect on his podcast episode with Joe Rogan: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OaTKaHKCAFg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OaTKaHKCAFg.
- easyat 6y agoThe media is not center left. Neoconservatise(Fox) and neoliberal(CNN/NYT) are different shades of right. We are watching different points of view of right wing politics argue. Wall street vs petrochemical companies vs SV, etc... all jostling for position. And all of these people with quite a bit of overlapping interests but slightly different focus i.e. foreign intervention but should the pentagon focus on M.E. destabilization or for African and S.A. lithium?
- heavyset_go 6y ago> by refraining from pushing (mainly white, straight men, but also others, like the religious) many further from the Democratic party. According to these Fox News polls[1], that shouldn't be a problem given their views. This election also saw a drop in white male support for Trump. [1] https://imgur.com/a/YxxnynP https://imgur.com/a/YxxnynP
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoAm I missing something? That imgur gallery has a bunch of polls but I don't see anything about a drop in white male support for Trump.
- robertoandred 6y agoThe left just made a white straight religious man president. Those who feel they're being pushed out are actually leaving voluntarily because they don't like that others are being allowed in.