21 ms·
Can too many brainy people be a dangerous thing?
- surajs 6y agoyeah, for some
- xenocratus 6y agoI believe the article they refer to is this one: https://www.nature.com/articles/463608a https://www.nature.com/articles/463608a (full PDF is available)
- Tokelin 6y agoAlso for anyone interested in the follow up study it's here: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0237458 https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal...
- dtech 6y agoFrom the abstract: > In the United States, we have stagnating or declining real wages, a growing gap between rich and poor, overproduction of young graduates with advanced degrees, and exploding public debt Quite interesting that this article only focuses on the 3rd entry of those
- lwneal 6y agoFor further context: this Economist article [1] references a letter to the editor by Peter Turchin [2], which is itself a response to the Nature 2010 opinion article "2020 visions" [3]. [1] https://www.economist.com/finance-and-economics/2020/10/24/can-too-many-brainy-people-be-a-dangerous-thing https://www.economist.com/finance-and-economics/2020/10/24/c... [2] https://www.nature.com/articles/463608a.pdf https://www.nature.com/articles/463608a.pdf [3] https://www.demogr.mpg.de/publications/files/3706_1264687048_1_Demographics.pdf https://www.demogr.mpg.de/publications/files/3706_1264687048...
- moonbug 6y agoif they dedicate all their efforts to selling adverts, yes.
- akhilcacharya 6y agoThey aren’t though, a lot are dedicating their efforts to providing liquidity in financial markets
- durnygbur 6y agoMany are working on new ways to optimize taxes (not) paid by the largest corporations and wealthiest billionaires.
- boudewijnrempt 6y agoI certainly found Secular Cycles a compelling read.
- erikig 6y agoWill definitely check this out. I find books that take a 50,000ft view of human development deeply insightful even if I don't entire agree with their theses.
- spacemanmatt 6y agoIt's too bad history weighs in so heavily on the danger of stupid people.
- jmeister 6y agoTurchin uses the term “elites”, which is not the same as “brainy”. Genuinely “brainy” people can find new ways to contribute to society, there can never be too any of them. “Elites” on the other hand - highly credentialed and entitled - play zero-sum games. There’s a lot of interesting critique written by heterodox leftists today, in the spirit of Chris Lasch, on how the current progressive movement is just intra-elite competition. Take BLM for example: how are Floyd/Blake policing incidents related to removing entrance tests from the super-elite schools and colleges, or shaking down super-elite art galleries until they show more POC artists? Or having a nominally black VP who’s made a career out of prosecuting black criminals? Or the populist conservative movement appealing to the “non-elite” working class, who the progressives used to represent. This is happening all over the western world. TLDR: Elite vs. non-elite seems exactly right, but let’s not confuse it with “brainy” please
- xenocratus 6y ago> Genuinely “brainy” people can find new ways to contribute to society, there can never be too any of them. > And we should not expand our system of higher education beyond the ability of the economy to absorb university graduates. An excess of young people with advanced degrees has been one of the chief causes of instability in the past. I think he genuinely means that too many educated people (by too many meaning more than society can actually accomodate) is a bad thing.
- devenblake 6y agoI would think that would be an indicator not that the quantity of smart people is bad but that we live in a society built for stupid people (which implies it was built by stupid people).
- luckylion 6y agoIf you simplify it: if you have a lot of architects but very few builders, you're not going to get a lot done. That doesn't mean that society was made for or by the builders. Since academics tend to want to eat as well, you still need somebody to provide the food. If all you have is educated people for whom food production is beneath their qualifications, you're going to end up with starving academics lamenting the cruelty of the universe not providing food to them.
- toolslive 6y agoI often participated in team quizzes, and it was a good thing to have 1 engineer in the team, and it was a _very bad_ thing to have 2 engineers in the team.
- friendlybus 6y agoWhat about 3 for a tie breaker?
- est31 6y ago3 engineers, 4 opinions.
- roenxi 6y agoThe idea that there is some sort of magic cycle that links 1870s to 2020 is patent nonsense. No cycle could survive the technological and political disruptions of the last hundred years. The current problem is the same old one where available real resources are growing more slowly than the population. If real stuff is becoming available faster than the population, we have golden ages. When population grows faster than stuff, the walls fall in and people start fighting each other. It would really be in the best interests of everyone if some of the infighting would stop and people start looking for ways to increase general prosperity by creating more instead of coming up with clever justifications about why we have to take stuff away from people who have it. And fire all the bankers. They aren't fulfilling their part of the social contract and investing in improving the future. We found that out in 2007 and the situation will keep getting worse until incompetent financiers start losing money.
- jmeister 6y agoMalthusian arguments are outdated by atleast a 100 years. Where is the proof that “real stuff” is growing slower than the population? Seems like there is too much stuff TBH. And banker-scapegoating is also outdated by ~10 years. The regulations passed after ‘08 have made banks boring and powerless. The focus should be on the tech industry.
- paulryanrogers 6y agoPhysics has hard limits. Malthus didn't make a perfectly accurate prediction. That doesn't mean it's wise to rely on unpredictable breakthroughs to finance unsustainable lifestyles.
- roenxi 6y ago> Where is the proof that “real stuff” is growing slower than the population? In the US? Government debt is at or approaching an all time high relative to GDP. Corporate debt is rather high although I don't know how it compares historically and there is a massive amount of student debt floating around. There are a lot of people out there who, by the numbers, are consuming quite a bit more than they are producing. US primary energy production has basically flatlined since 2000 [0]. That isn't the be-all and end-all, but it just seems like an easy prediction that long periods of growing population and flat energy consumption is going to lead to problems. The people who can't convince Asians to give them stuff are not going to be rolling in a surplus of stuff, is my read of that chart. I haven't heard good reports about the state of US infrastructure either, but maybe it is better than I think. The States might make it work, but the political situation is developing pretty much how I'd expect it to if there is a large group of people being squeezed out by lack of access to real stuff. There is a big body of people who just aren't producing as much as they are consuming, and the background talk of "we don't need energy to be wealthy!" - I don't see how that squares off against the growing relatively evident growing instability. Trump in particular is not a sign of a thriving economy. Nor is the Democrat rhetoric in response to Trump. Population growth is ~.7-.8% per annum, and real GDP growth is estimated at 2% per annum. Given the expansion of the money supply, and the gossip that the US is a 'service based' economy, it is entirely plausible to me that real stuff is growing more slowly than population and the measured growth is some sort of complicated feedback loop that nobody has tracked down. > Malthusian arguments are outdated by atleast a 100 years. Hopefully. But it is worth being prepared for a world where obvious trends play out to their conclusion. [0] https://ourworldindata.org/energy#energy-production-by-region https://ourworldindata.org/energy#energy-production-by-regio...
- noetokyo 6y agoFearmongering at it's greatest. Instead of looking for possible solutions. It downplays the worst case scenarios by having "Too Many" educated people. Both the article and the study. Instead of asking why we should fear having too many educated people. Shouldn't we instead be asking the question why should we fear them in the first place? Rather, the government policies at place and the systemic issues which affect the people we should "fear". What am I to say. The study itself is from 2010.The effects of it are about to come anyways for the good and bad. It's just about how you deal with the issue. The call for higher education is a bipartisan belief in America. In which both sides already agree that student grants should be in place rather than student loans. While the candidates running may not agree with that in the coming presidential election both republic and democratic leaders agree that grants should replace loans. The main problems which they address really aren't likely to be problems in the near future.
- dalbasal 6y ago"Cliodynamics" sounds a lot like psychohistory. I always appreciated azimov as a sci-fi writer for psychohistory. Sci fi and fantasy have a common form where it's the world and regular people, but a technology (or magic) exists. The world + the fictional technology make the setting for the story. Usually the device is a time machine or magic hat. In Asimov's story, the device is a theory. I always thought making the device abstract was a genius novelty. The whole idea came from what if one of these broad economic disciplines actually worked? Especially marxism, objectivism, and such. As the article mentions, these use economics broadly to explain history... and predict it. "Psychohistories" are compelling, interesting and intellectually engaging. We have a tendency of adopting them though. That's the problem. They aren't scientific. They aren't even theories in a popperian sense. Ultimately, it's punditry. A perspective. I enjoy it. I enjoyed this article. It's neither true or false though, in any kind of global sense. All that said, this take augments the (also economist friendly) "anywheres vs everywheres" take on Brexit. That take also had to do with an increase in uni graduates. A narrower version of Turchin's concept might also be true. Rather than a surplus of (all) graduates crowding the top... this might be an issue of very specific surpluses. EG Journalism, specific government agencies, professorships, political positions... Those are a tiny portion of people overall, but highly influential to the political mood. If most journalists, academics, political aids are competing for a limited pool of jobs... These professions really are tense. Most people who want to can't get a job in these fields. Many want to. There's often no fallback. If you're a journalist/activist/campaigner type... you're either in that insider group or you have nothing. Academics is similar. A phd historian can either be a professor or very little else. No consolation prizes.
- joe_biden123 6y agothe theory works for many kind of surpluses. if there are too many engineers and scientists and not enough jobs for them it's a problem. this also applies to any kind of elites: someone who considers himself above the general population: medieval nobles, roman senators, programmers. too many of them and it's a problem. you can read turchin's scientific articles, he uses data from different societies (widely different) and his equations seem to work to predict instability
- m000 6y agoDangerous for whom?
- SomeoneFromCA 6y agoFor the kind of people, who runs The Economist magazine?
- a9h74j 6y agoAn old trope, perhaps associated with Eric Hoffer, is that unrest stems not from absolute poverty, but disappointment relative to hopes. It can be people who are relatively better off, but let down, who threaten the more established elites.
- lwneal 6y agoIn Peter Turchin's book War and Peace and War [1], the term "elite overproduction" does not refer to an overproduction of smart people, education, or college degrees. Instead, it refers to an overproduction of nobility, individuals who extract income but who do not perform useful work. For example, France during the population boom of the high middle ages overproduced knights and minor nobles from 1200-1300. The nobility increased from around 2% to 4% of the population, while the incomes of the richest nobles soared. Eventually, peasants could no longer produce enough to feed themselves and provide income for all the nobles: this was a contributing factor to the famines and wars of 1350-1400. The most straightforward modern equivalent to Turchin's "elite" nobility would not be people with advanced degrees: it would be investors who do not work for wages. (Not to say there is no overlap between those groups.) [1] Turchin, Peter. War and peace and war: The life cycles of imperial nations. Pi, 2005.
- est31 6y ago> The most straightforward modern equivalent to Turchin's "elite" nobility would not be people with advanced degrees: it would be investors who do not work for wages. (Not to say there is no overlap between those groups.) Investors do a lot of work, because they have to constantly think where to put their money, evaluate alternatives, make sure there is no money wasted on things, etc. Even passive investors who only have S&P portfolios still contribute to the economy by providing capital to companies to invest into new things.
- question000 6y agoYeah but even if we accept passive investment is a form of productive labor, there's a limited number safe/good investments for those good investors. As we saw in the 2008 recession when more and investors pile on even the safest investments (mortgages backed securities) the quality of those investments tends to be diluted (via CDO's, errant ratings companies, exploitative real estate practices) This is what's making me nervous about index funds right now, the demand seems extremely high, but what about the supply how would you determine such a thing? What is investors are smart but there simply aren't enough good investments out there? Are they going to give up and become doctors, lawyers or engineers? Or just spend more time with their kids?
- dusted 6y agoStupid people who think they're smart because they have a fancy education and are rewarded with high salary, that's probably a dangerous "brainy elite". Along with stupid people who just so happened to get a ton of money by no merit of their own, but don't realize this.
- powerapple 6y agoif a person wanted to accumulate wealth/knowledge and did it, he/she is smart. if a person wanted to accumulate wealth/knowledge and failed to so do, he/she is stupid.
- ploika 6y agoTrying and failing doesn't make you stupid.
- xenocratus 6y agoIt does in a lot of courts of public opinion, unfortunately.
- powerapple 6y agoif you keep trying and keep failing, and you do not adapt in the process, it does not make you smart. By failing, we learn and adapt. In theory it would make the next move wiser than previous moves. I agree calling it stupid may not be accurate.
- tartoran 6y agoTrying and failing indeed doesn’t make you stupid but in many circumstances, e.g. being poor, makes you stop trying or the feeling of inferiority seeps in. Also the people around you set a background that make it even harder to escape from.
- paulryanrogers 6y agoThis assumes equality of opportunity.
- 6y ago
- Hokusai 6y agoSo, increased numbers of educated people relate to a rise of expectations on equality, wealth distribution, etc. Status quo fights back and instability grows. A good example is the fight on climate change. The status quo wants to avoid responsibility for past, current and future damage. A growing educated population wants accountability. That creates tension. I agree, as much as I think that to keep leaders accountable is one of the greatest society advances ever. The only way forward is for the status quo to accept change and advance with society and reduce the tension.
- sparkie 6y agoTry to look from another lens. Climate hysterics want to avoid responsibility for the economic damage that their carbon-neutral policies are going to have on society. They want accountability from others, but not themselves. How many have done the calculations to work out the second and third order effects of their zero fossil fuel agenda? Many of the most ardent callers for climate action are themselves not even climate scientists, but merely offload their thought processing to the intellectuals who are. Almost without fail, neither them, nor the intellectual are educated in economics. The reality is that nobody can work out the second and effects and so on for these drastic changes, because they have incomplete information. The intellectuals and 'thought leaders' themselves have a fraction of a percent of the actual tacit knowledge that drives economic activity. The knowledge is very widely distributed, which is why central planning is less efficient than the market almost all of the time. The tension isn't caused by the "status quo" fighting back. It is caused by hysterics calling for action on things they know nothing about. How many extinction rebellion fanatics have read The Moral Case for Fossil Fuels? It's not like they would if they were recommended it - the mere name will put them off because they have a preconceived notion and will ardently resist any information which is likely to cause cognitive dissonance in themselves. Which tells you everything you need to know. It isn't intellectualism driving them - it is misplaced fear due to grossly exaggerated climate scare claims, drummed up by the status-quo. Almost always, it is the same crowds who babble on about equality and wealth distribution too. Many of them from wealthy or middle-classes, who have resources to help the people they claim to want to help, but rarely, if ever, engage in altruistic acts of voluntary work or charity because they'd rather spend the time talking about it. They won't put their own money or action where their mouths are, but demand it of others - many of whom are not in such fortunate positions.
- slfnflctd 6y agoI'm not sure how brainy I am. Perhaps the main reason I came across that way in school is because my mom taught me to read early. In any case, no one in the lower-end workplace has been particularly interested in what brains I do have, or (apparently) anyone else's around me. It's all about how you can fit into the local pattern, which is often suboptimal yet resistant to change. Meanwhile, everything interesting/challenging I might have liked to work on is already being worked on by someone else, who is probably doing a better job than I would have-- so the chances seem low of me making a useful contribution. To say nothing of barriers to entry constantly & furiously being erected. The main danger to me with regard to the question in the title seems to be the realization that despite what I was told as a child, I am pretty obviously redundant and unnecessary. Not needed. The world has enough brainy people already. There is little for me to do but try to care for those in my immediate vicinity as best I can and wait out my time.
- Haul4ss 6y ago> Meanwhile, everything interesting/challenging I might have liked to work on is already being worked on by someone else, who is probably doing a better job than I would have You may be surprised to learn how false and limiting this belief is. Turns out most of those people are also just winging it, so if you wing it too, hey, you may actually reach a better outcome.
- malwrar 6y agoWanted to +1 this, if you’re talking about technical problems that aren’t prohibitively expensive to work on, I garuntee you the world has room for your work. I swear, once you enter a tech company it’s like any given task suddenly takes 10x longer than it would if you pursued it as a personal project.
- wrnr 6y agoExactly, defeatism can be pathologic to individuals and society. It's frustrating that doing anything involves the extra effort of countering this attitude.
- ip26 6y ago
- emailrhoads 6y agoTaleb writes about this with the phrase IYI intellectual yet idiot. His primary concern is that these people don't take risk and become bureaucrats. Not that they are smart, brainy, or any other ad hominem attack masked as a compliment. https://medium.com/incerto/the-intellectual-yet-idiot-13211e2d0577 https://medium.com/incerto/the-intellectual-yet-idiot-13211e...
- johnnycerberus 6y agoTaleb taught me how to protect myself in the face of uncertain situtations, the idea is not to take risks for the sake of taking risks. The problem with bureaucrats is that they are exposing others to huge risks and they don't feel it on their own skin. They are pushing the consequences of the risk on other people.
- jungletime 6y agoThere was an episode on Simpsons where the smart people take over the town, with disastrous results. "The Simpsons" S10 Ep. 22 - "They Saved Lisa's Brain" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=avgMk_w38g0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=avgMk_w38g0
- FpUser 6y agoYeah right. Keep numbers of educated people to a bare minimum so that generic person would have shitty job paying unlivable wage and be happy about it. Educated people (at least ones having good general University type education) at least have better chance finding something useful to do and creating new opportunities. My advice for those "academics" would be to undergo voluntary lobotomy and improve the world in accordance to their views.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoThe company TransMeta was mostly PhDs. They fooled around so long, arguing and redesigning, not releasing, that Intel ate their lunch steadily improving scalar performance. My colleague who was worth $100M in TransMeta options at one point, is back to work with nothing. So yeah, too many brains are a dangerous thing.
- rjsw 6y agoFor me, the most attractive feature of their chip was that it had a built-in PCI host controller, nothing else did at the time. They could have released anything that ran at a reasonable speed and had a market, they didn't need to beat Intel.
- Balgair 6y agoToo many cooks, not enough waiters.
- officeplant 6y agoI love this, but now the Too Many Cooks[0] skit is stuck in my head. [0]:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QrGrOK8oZG8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QrGrOK8oZG8
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- musicale 6y agoPoorly managing your business seems less a sign of "too many brains" than "not enough management." Consider also that a) most businesses fail b) many successful engineering companies were founded and/or staffed by professors, Ph.D. graduates, and Ph.D. students from Stanford and elsewhere, d) intel didn't do so great with VLIW (itanium) or low power/thermal (Atom lost to ARM - and intel seems to have squandered StrongARM/XSCale) either, e) intel probably had many more Ph.D.'s than Transmeta did, and they still hire tons of them. Be that as it may, it's sad Transmeta died and its IP was sold to Intellectual Ventures, a company that has invented interesting things but also seems to make most of its money from lawsuits.
- calimac 6y agoThe hacker news comment section is proof of this.
- cryptica 6y agoThere is a huge difference between people who are educated and people who are clever. These days we have a huge number of educated people, many intelligent (high IQ) people but extremely few clever people. Clever people are those who have common sense and as Charlie Munger pointed out, 'common sense' ought to be called 'uncommon sense' because it's not common at all these days. We have a problem now in our society that the task of capital allocation which used to be handled by clever people who had plenty of common sense has been artificially handed over to highly educated, intelligent people who in some cases completely lack common sense. They've been trying to design an elaborate, controlled economy from the top down... With an artificial government-controlled monetary system to support it. Most intelligent people don't understand the importance of creative destruction; even though this process has proven itself to be the effective for millions of years and is the basis of natural evolution. It seems that most people in power have never heard of Leslie Orgel who once said that "Evolution is cleverer than you are". You need to work with evolution, not against it. The system needs to allow creative destruction and natural selection.
- cryptica 6y agoI think that the critical skill which intelligent people don't have but which clever people have is simply knowing what is important. Unfortunately, the best way to learn that skill is through struggle. Too many intelligent people these days haven't experienced struggle in their careers (aside from the artificial struggles of navigating company politics). Many went through university (often paid for by their parents), then as soon as they finished, they immediately got a huge salary at a big corporation. Many were never in a situation such that their employer could go out of business and they would lose their job and livelihood if they failed to deliver high quality work in a reasonable time. Also, the skills that you learn in dealing with company politics are counter-productive.
- trident1000 6y agoPeople with college degrees get more arrogant and indoctrinated than educated (I graduated from a top university). Almost everything useful I know was attained outside school.
- dave_4_bagels 6y agoThis is how you end up with places like Manhattan and SF. And people wonder why the rich also happen to be smart...
- BenoitEssiambre 6y agoAnyone else cringing at the Nazi subtext here?
- aokiji 6y agoThe Economist is spreading Chinese Communist Party propaganda. Of course, we merely need an intellectual elite and a dumbed-down populace.
- cosmiccatnap 6y agoNo. Not that the title or article have anything in common anyway.
- ur-whale 6y agohttps://archive.is/dNW6U https://archive.is/dNW6U
- ldiracdelta 6y agoReminds me of the concept of Bruce Charleton's "clever sillies" https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19733444/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19733444/
- FooHentai 6y agoApologies in advance for this stream-of-consciousness rambling: A society with too many over-specialized people is a dangerous thing and IMO what's really happening here. The dynamics that play out from that impact all areas of society in deep, negative ways and pose an existential threat that will come home to roost in times of stress (which the situation also makes more likely to occur). "Hard times create strong men. Strong men create good times. Good times create weak men. Weak men create hard times." - G. Michael Hopf Weak in this context is un-resilient, inflexible in thinking and action. Not weakness in the physical sense. With over-specialisation comes implicit neglect of areas outside of the specialization. Producing well-rounded or 'T-Shaped' individuals inherently foregoes pursuing the highest possible level of performance in specialization. Evidence abounds that modern developed society and decades of stability have produced a populace of over-specialized individuals - The net result being that we now have a systemic weakness in cross-discipline thinking and action. Over time more and more of the issues sitting on the society-wide bug tracker fall into this cross-discipline category and we just can't clear the tickets. They are building up. Classic example - politicians are now overwhelmingly career politicians, their skill is in staying employed as politicians. This has transformed politics into a game of its own sake, increasingly unintelligible to those not versed in its lore, networked into its cliques, and thinking in its terms. It has ceased to be an effective means to the ends that it once was and is now an end in itself to its specialists. Outsiders to the political sphere face significant additional resistance in bringing any relevant experience to bear in a political context, which is now actively guarded against such non-specialists (or equally specialist, just of the wrong sort). That's one example but you can find them absolutely everywhere - for the audience here look at how common it has become for technical specialists to fret about how small a cog they have become and how chasing maximum remuneration, recognition, or achievement in their field leaves them fundamentally unbalanced in other areas of their life, but also unable to pivot to anything else. It explains much of the 'stop the ride I want to get off' sentiment from those burning out in their field when considered as acts of mental rebellion against the confines of over-specialisation. The dependencies this brings are where the risk really lies on a wider scale - develop a populace over specialized and you'll see great economic growth from whole new fields of shoelace-tyeres,food preparers, and (nod) telephone handset sanitizers. But now those roles become essential to individual survival while at the same time the importance and complexity of the underlying acts cease to be understood by those outside the specialisation whom depend utterly on their maintenance. Less trite examples are provision of food, water, heat, and shelter. Today shockingly few people are involved in the provision of these fundamental human needs, awareness of how they come about is as low as it has ever been, and doing any of them for yourself is at best considered weird and at worst legally prohibited. I see this on a local level in my field all the time - you want to improve security across your organisation and so you set up a dedicated security team. Then any time security is considered someone from that team needs to be involved, and those outside the team limit their thinking on security-related considerations only as far as passing it off to the team. Net result, the organisation's ability to consider and tackle security is significantly weakened. I don't really know where I'm going with this rant other than a vague attempt to increase awareness of what I believe is a serious fundamental, insidious issue.
- epicureanideal 6y agoStalin certainly thought so! </s>
- erikig 6y agoSo did Pol Pot...<//s>
- mwfunk 6y agoKnowledge or intelligence can't ever hurt. The only things that can hurt a situation are when people have a lack of perspective, or a lack of self-awareness, or Dunning-Kruger type situations where they overestimate themselves, underestimate others, and are short on natural skepticism about their own cognitive processes. But this stuff happens with anyone, and maturity and professionalism overcomes it. But perhaps its more obvious or toxic with super knowledgeable and specialized people.
- makz 6y agoI’m more worried about too many non-brainy people.