20 ms·
Gitlab Blocked Iranians’ Access
- dijit 6y agoQuick note that anyone using a US based cloud provider will likely be blocking all sanctioned countries. It’s not configurable at all. It was a sticking point for us when deploying the sequel to a game I was working on. Ultimately we determined that the benefits of using the provider outweighed the benefit to users since we weren’t shipping the game there officially anyway. (With one notable exception) It still leaves a sour taste in my mouth. It should be noted that it’s also Cuba and Crimea that are blocked. I was principally annoyed at the lack of usability in Crimea, as any way you slice it it’s part of a country that is not being sanctioned in the same way and the citizenry did nothing wrong.
- da39a3ee 6y agoYou might want to delete the "and the citizenry did nothing wrong" ending to your otherwise reasonable post. I don't think you meant it the way it sounds.
- jrochkind1 6y agoI legit am not sure how it sounded to you in a way that seemed unfortunate.
- da39a3ee 6y agoIt implies that, unlike Crimea, the citizenry of countries _other_ than Crimea (Iran/Sudan/Cuba etc) _did_ do something wrong.
- jrochkind1 6y agoAh, I see. I mean, yeah, I think that kind of is the theory behind US sanctions sometimes honestly. It's pretty messed up. (And the US, which is a "democracy", would want to avoid looking in the mirror too).
- bigbubba 6y agoWhat do you think the citizenry of Crimea did wrong?
- trhway 6y agothey voted wrong way.
- bigbubba 6y agoI'm under the impression that nobody but Russian state media claims that election was legitimate.
- trhway 6y agowrong way in wrong elections :) Of course, like any Russian election it was just a formality, a décor. Nobody really needed it as the will of the people was clear - no more threats of more of those "trains of friendships" full of Western Ukrainian nationalists, especially given all the quiet massive arming of those nationalists that had happened under the cover of the Ministry of Internal Affairs in the run up to the 2014.
- kdmytro 6y agoWhat massive arming?
- f6v 6y agoAh yes, the legitimacy. I don't think it means what it's implied to mean. The USA do many illegitimate things and no-one bats an eye.
- da39a3ee 6y agoNothing; see my reply elsewhere in this thread. I meant the opposite of what you understood me to mean, but I can see why I was misunderstood.
- da39a3ee 6y agoI am being misunderstood because of the wording I used. The reason "and the citizenry did nothing wrong" is problematic is because it implies that, unlike Crimea, the citizenry of countries _other_ than Crimea (Iran/Sudan/Cuba etc) _did_ do something wrong. I was not saying that the citizens of Crimea did something wrong: I was saying the opposite.
- hevelvarik 6y agoIt was obvious and you are dealing with pedants
- lucb1e 6y ago> US based cloud provider Huh, I thought it was GitLab B.V. and that still exists[1], but Wikipedia says they're headquartered in the USA as of 2018[2] and the official "About" page[3] mentions Amsterdam, the Netherlands nor B.V., but does mention a "GitLab Inc.". The history on Wikipedia doesn't mention them having moved and still has the "Tech companies from the Netherlands" category (not sure if that's because they're still originally from there, or because the category was never removed). Not sure blocking Iran would have happened if they hadn't opened a corp overseas. [1] https://www.kvk.nl/orderstraat/product-kiezen/?kvknummer=600348310000 https://www.kvk.nl/orderstraat/product-kiezen/?kvknummer=600... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=GitLab&diff=826856844&oldid=825392993 https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=GitLab&diff=82685... [3] https://about.gitlab.com/company/ https://about.gitlab.com/company/ Edit: slightly older, 2017 reference of USA headquarters https://www.ycombinator.com/library/6J-gitlab-s-secret-to-managing-160-employees-in-160-locations https://www.ycombinator.com/library/6J-gitlab-s-secret-to-ma... Editv2: the TOS still says that the intellectual property is with GitLab B.V. but the branding page says the trademark is held by GitLab Inc. The privacy policy is not GDPR-complaint (on multiple counts and I haven't even read it, just spotted some things like implicit+non-opt-outable consent while looking for who is the data controller) and doesn't mention who the data controller is. It does make clear that all data goes to the USA and you better suck it up. Looks like they fully embraced all of the USA's freedoms including censorship and privacy violations under their home country's law. I'm giving up searching for more info about the move at this point: there is no news article in HN search, the blog search requires me to accept more tracking which (after seeing the illegal-in-the-EU privacy policy) I'm not sure I'm willing to engage in, and the website seems to have had mixed mentions of B.V. and Inc. as of 2016.
- dijit 6y agoGitlab is hosted on google cloud, and fronted by cloudflare... those IP restrictions apply to google cloud, AWS, Azure and Oracle Cloud. (and Cloudflare since that's a US company also)
- miracle2k 6y agoTo my knowledge, services hosted on AWS are not blocked in Iran. Also, if that were the case, literally have the internet would cease to function w/o VPN, which should give pause to those who would shrug off such a policy.
- godelzilla 6y agoImperialism always attacks innocent citizens.
- einpoklum 6y ago> I was principally annoyed at the lack of usability in Crimea, as any way you slice it it’s part of a country that is not being sanctioned in the same way and the citizenry did nothing wrong. If "doing wrong things" is a criterion for being blocked on GitLab, then there are _so_ many organizations and states which should be blocked, and arguably hundreds of Millions of people who serve in military forces which do wrong things etc. So, there is really no justification for this regardless of slicing. IMHO.
- names_are_hard 6y agoIn the past I worked for an Israeli company listed on a US stock exchange. They were proud that they had customers in virtually every corner of the world, and had just six countries they couldn't do business in. One (Lebanon) because of the Israeli government, and five (including Iran) because of the US. Most interesting to me: apparently when they first went public and became subject to US regulation they had to close quite a large number of customer accounts in Iran.
- freehunter 6y agoIt’s interesting to me that the US views Iran more harshly than Israel does.
- mcny 6y agoIran, Israel, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia... There is so much going on there. Are they all at conflict with one another? Who are allies? How does this work?
- Fuzzwah 6y agoOn a long enough time scale, everyone is the bad guy.
- sudosysgen 6y agoIsrael is an ally of the KSA against Iran, though they both pretend not to be for domestic consumption. They are indeed both in conflict with one another, because in truth Iran is really the only country in the Middle East that could threaten to become an independent power, on the level of say, Turkey.
- RedComet 6y agoIt doesn't, the US is just Israel's proxy warrior in this fight. (cf. the Clean Break memo, etc)
- markdown 6y ago
- toast0 6y agoAt least on some clouds, it's configurable, but your lawyers need to speak to their lawyers, etc, to get worldwide access enabled, and annual reconfirmation between lawyers. You would probably have to be in an OFAC exception category, of course. Routing to sanctioned countries from a provider that mostly blocks them probably isn't the best either.
- Symbiote 6y agoI only use Amazon Route 53. Does anyone know if that's ever been blocked in Iran etc? It doesn't seem to be blocked at the moment, but it's also something I can't find any official documentation on.
- f6v 6y ago> and the citizenry did nothing wrong Well nobody is wrong when it comes to Crimea except those who claim it’s part of Ukraine.
- KorematsuFred 6y agoDoes that mean Ali Cloud would be a better option here ?
- dicomdan 6y agoNot really.
- CKN23-ARIN 6y agoOther than GCP, which US based cloud providers do this?
- DetroitThrow 6y agoAWS: https://reclaimthenet.org/amazon-aws-iran-proxies-vpn-sanctions/ https://reclaimthenet.org/amazon-aws-iran-proxies-vpn-sancti... I'm not sure Azure has been available for Iranian IPs for the past few years or ever, feel free to Google "Azure Blocked Iran" though - plenty of petitions.
- CKN23-ARIN 6y agoAWS and Azure prevent Iran-based users from having an account, but if you have an account, you can exchange traffic with Iranian IPs. GCP blocks traffic to/from Iranian IPs for all users. It sounded to me like GP was referring to the latter type of blocking.
- doomlaser 6y ago> GitLab is not the only actor in this discrimination against Persian/Iranian people, we also blocked by GitHub, Docker, NPM, Google Developer, Android, AWS, Go, Kubernetes and etc. US sanctions compliance most likely Edit: confirmed by Gitlab: https://twitter.com/gitlab/status/1312183287402512384 https://twitter.com/gitlab/status/1312183287402512384
- skrebbel 6y agoAlso, nitpick, nobody's blocking Persians. I'm not Persian but if I go to Iran I bet I'm blocked too. I'm strongly opposed to these sanctions, and I also think GitLab should've given people notice so they could get their data out. But I'm not sure it's a good place to pull the racism card.
- AsyncAwait 6y agoI agree it's not racism on GitLab's part, but the U.S. officials behind these sanctions themselves do use phrases like that they want to 'choke Iran's economy', that is in the middle of a pandemic where people's respiratory systems are at risk, it certainly doesn't look good on their part. Also worth noting that GitLab has previously banned hiring from China/Russia, so it's no stranger to blanket bans of questionable nature. 1 - https://www.zdnet.com/article/gitlab-considers-ban-on-new-hires-in-china-and-russia-due-to-espionage-fears https://www.zdnet.com/article/gitlab-considers-ban-on-new-hi...
- microcolonel 6y agoThere is nothing racist about economic sanctions against a country which is in active conflict with our armed forces outside of their borders, which is actively engaged in psy-ops to destabilize American society. Economic sanctions against America would not be racism against scots/germans/west africans or whatever. You can argue against sanctions on all sorts of grounds, but the flimsiest is claiming that they're racist.
- AsyncAwait 6y ago
- monkin 6y agoGitLab can’t do nothing about it, and whining will not help. Everything is on government level.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- arkitaip 6y agoWhat a defeatist attitude. What you unkindly label as whining, I see as advocacy for a good cause. Blocking access to gitlab does nothing but strengthen the autocracy in Iran and prevents Iranian devs from making a living and supporting their communities.
- monkin 6y agoPutting post like that is nothing more than whining, as it doesn’t change anything. Want to do something better? Write some petitions, make a campaign or anything other, but bashing company that have to comply with US laws is just stupid. Sorry if this is unkindly and defeatist for you.
- joshmanders 6y agoExactly, want to do something? Complain to your government representatives, not Gitlab.
- dvtrn 6y agoSecond order thinking means both tactics have value and merit, right? If not, I am open to hearing why.
- dessant 6y agoThey are not whining, and GitLab could have notified them about the account suspension, and sent them a link with their archived account data to download.
- nguyenkien 6y agoWhy whining, just head over gitee.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoOr host your own GitLab instance in Iran.
- ThePadawan 6y agoGitLab (the company) are legally not permitted to export their product: https://about.gitlab.com/handbook/people-group/code-of-conduct/#trade-compliance-exportimport-control https://about.gitlab.com/handbook/people-group/code-of-condu... According to them, that includes downloads. So no luck there either.
- landryl 6y agoOf course they could have done that, if gitlab had at least given a prior warning... Some of the screenshot show them even trying to get a temporary account with support just to get what they've been locked out of to make a backup.
- sschueller 6y agoOpen source code, books and knowledge should never be blocked, until we learn this we are no better than the people we are trying to "punish" with pointless and ineffective sanctions.
- dsabanin 6y agoWhat's your alternative to sanctions that's more effective? War?
- ahelwer 6y agoThe only thing Iran is guilty of is insufficient deference to US hegemony. Any other charge you levy can have its equal found in our so-called allies in the region, or even the US itself.
- christophilus 6y agoYou’re not wrong, so far as I can tell. Not sure why you’re being downvoted. Iran has some serious issues, but they don’t appear to be worse than the Saudis or any number of other countries we (the US) consider allies.
- TheGuyWhoCodes 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran_and_state-sponsored_terrorism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran_and_state-sponsored_terro...
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoOne of the things Iran's unambiguously guilty of is these same kinds of access restrictions. If you've ever wondered why Google's sanctions-related controversy was focused on Google Cloud, it's because that was the biggest Google service allowed at the time - search, Gmail, and Youtube had already been banned by the Iranian government. So while I share the skepticism expressed upthread that blocking websites is effective diplomacy, it's hard for me to look at the situation and see a one-sided problem.
- Clarkson7434 6y agoHAVE YOU LOST YOUR HARD EARNED FUNDS TO THE WRONG HANDS? MEET THE PROFESSIONAL HACKERS FOR HIRE TODAY. [⏱ 1min Read] Hiring a professional hacker has been one of the world's most technical valued navigating information. Regarding: •Recovery Of Lost Funds •Mobile Phone Hack.(Catching A Cheating Spouse). •Credit Score Upgrade, •Email Hack. •Uber free Payment. • Various HACKtivities via (leroysteckler@gmail.com) High prolific information and Priviledges comes rare as it has been understood that what people do not see, they will never know. One of the affirmative ability to convey a profitable information Systematically is the majoy factor to success Welcome to The GlobalKOS hacking agency where every request on hacking related issues are fixed within a short period of time. For more infomation and profound Hacking services, , Visit: leroysteckler@gmail.com..
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jjgreen 6y agoAre there alternatives outside the reach of the US?
- deepsun 6y agoInstall your own GitLab -- it's on-premise.
- nerdponx 6y agoSourcehut is self-hostable too, right?
- zimbatm 6y agoProbably https://codeberg.org/ https://codeberg.org/ since it's hosted in the EU. https://sr.ht/ https://sr.ht/ might work due to its small size but it hosted in the US AFAIK.
- jjgreen 6y agoI'd not heard of those -- thanks!
- Sephr 6y agoGitHub allows open-source contributions from sanctioned countries iirc
- PestoDiRucola 6y agoGitlab blocked Iran's Access* This happened because of US sanctions[0]. [0] https://about.gitlab.com/handbook/people-group/code-of-conduct/#trade-compliance-exportimport-control https://about.gitlab.com/handbook/people-group/code-of-condu...
- 542458 6y agoI’m a little confused at people who are mad at GitLab here. I’m under the impression that sanctions and export control laws tend to be fairly strict, and penalties for knowing non-compliance are harsh, including the possibility of jail time. GitLab’s hands are pretty tied here.
- mirekrusin 6y agoWe shouldn't be upset at github/githlab/npm/dockerhub but our industry and ourselves - how did we let our projects/packages/tools/infrastructure to be hosted on such platforms in the first place? Hopefully this will trigger more activity on decentralised solutions; git is decentralised already, needs some ipfs/torrent/etc wrapper for issues/rest or maybe something based on fossil etc.
- einpoklum 6y agoWell, we put our projects on the most popular platform, for visibility; and visibility is important for FOSS projects. But you make a valid point. Perhaps we should put the "master reop" on something that's decentralized and not subject to US censorship, and only place a copy on GitHub/GitLab/etc.
- closeparen 6y agoI don’t think I want to live in a world where software engineers make up their own foreign policy. At the very least, enforceable sanctions give us options other than war. Giving that up could carry an immense human cost. An understanding of distributed software architecture does not come with the ability to understand and weigh that cost, nor does it make you a legitimate authority on which tradeoffs to choose. It’s probably inevitable, but I’ll be disappointed in our community if it happens.
- goku99 6y agoIsn't sharing project/code, or any intellectual property with Israel or nations which Iran Supremo doesn't approve, banned too? (in Iran) I find this ridiculous, trying to stop flow of intellectual knowledge.
- null_deref 6y agoYes, that's was an interesting case of what you mentioned https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24364793 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24364793
- miracle2k 6y agoIt's also ironic, because this is an Iranian having and using a Github account without being blocked, which some commentators here appear to believe is impossible due to US sanctions.
- vfclists 6y agoWho is the new company Gitlab has switched to, and why didn't Gitlab consider the consequences of their decision? Why doesn't Gitlab simply host their services outside US jurisdiction?
- delfinom 6y agoGood luck? Short of moving entirely to China or Russia, they have no chance of escaping us sanction law. If they wish to hold even a european bank account, their bank will force them to comply with the sanctions or they will be terminated.
- athms 6y agoGitLab has used Google Cloud since 2018 and Microsoft Azure prior. Both cloud providers are required to comply with sanctions. >Why doesn't Gitlab simply host their services outside US jurisdiction? Because GitLab is a US company. They moved their headquarters to California (incorporated in Delaware) in 2014.
- philtar 6y agoYes, gitlab has no choice but to block them. Also yes, gitlab doesn't really care about them or they would have given some sort of notice. Even 24 hours.
- 542458 6y agoDoes the law have an exemption for notifying people and giving them a grace period? As this is sanctions / export control, I was under the impression that deficiencies in compliance had to be corrected as soon as they were noticed - which in this case would mean cutting off business relations and communications immediately.
- hohohmm 6y agoImperialism in its truest form.
- Myrmornis 6y agoWhat steps can maintainers of projects hosted on GitHub/GitLab/etc take to make their projects available to users in countries affected by this US policy? For example, is there an alternative git hosting site where it would be helpful for me to maintain a fork, so that the README is available and people can open issues and PRs? Similarly, where would be a good place to host the binaries built on each release so that they are accessible?
- dilatedmind 6y agoI could be reading this wrong, but it looks like github allows open source contributions from sanctioned countries. https://docs.github.com/en/free-pro-team@latest/github/site-policy/github-and-trade-controls https://docs.github.com/en/free-pro-team@latest/github/site-...
- Myrmornis 6y agoOK, and from the article it looks like GitLab is blocking all access to their site. So is your understanding that GitLab is currently much more restrictive than GitHub in this regard?
- dilatedmind 6y agotheir readme there states > GitHub is committed to continuing to offer free public repository services to developers with individual and organizational accounts in U.S.-sanctioned regions. This includes limited access to free services, such as public repositories for open source projects (and associated public Pages), public gists, and allotted free Action minutes, for personal communications only, and not for commercial purposes. maybe someone can confirm how this works in practice?
- ReptileMan 6y ago>What steps can maintainers of projects hosted on GitHub/GitLab/etc take to make their projects available to users in countries affected by this US policy? If they are under US jurisdiction it is inadvisable to try and circumvent such stuff.
- scott31 6y agoYeah, blame U.S. corporations complying with their law, while your country has not had a single step for resolution of the sanctions. Also if an Iranian developer is unprepared against losing their access to Gitlab, then sadly they are incompetent developers.
- sleepyhead 6y ago> while your country has not had a single step for resolution of the sanctions. Uhm, it was literally the USA that withdrew from the signed deal without any wrongdoings from Iran. You might consider not being so tough on the internet when you are factually wrong.
- miracle2k 6y agoPeople should resist the temptation to defend this. 1. Blocking Iranian IPs, as opposed to accounts, is almost certainly over-compliance. Note that the vast majority of websites do not do this. Even big ones, such as Gmail, do not do this. 2. It does not speak well of the United States justice system if someone could be prosecuted for failure to block Iranian IPs. If this were required, the law should be clear. Otherwise, the US citizens deserve not to be in fear of prosecution. 3. Beyond IP-blocking, if the US government wants to require companies to go actively fishing for possible Iranian accounts, it should clearly codify this. Otherwise, companies should not have to fear prosecution. Summary: Gitlab should grow a pair, and Americans should ask themselves if this kind of legal uncertainty is desirable. Finally, legal effort to make websites inaccessible in Iran is entirely incompatible with being taken seriously when complaining about internet freedom in Iran. Note that this goes so far that the entire Google Cloud network blocks Iranian IPs, including any and all services and websites hosted there, including say resources that might provide valuable information to regime opponents.
- Dunedan 6y ago> 1. Blocking Iranian IPs, as opposed to accounts, is almost certainly over-compliance. Note that the vast majority of websites do not do this. Even big ones, such as Gmail, do not do this. I can tell you for certain that at least AWS and Atlassian do that. I learned that while surfing from an IP address which was mistakenly associated with being located in Iran. I only discovered that, because said websites weren't available. As I got that fixed quite fast afterwards I haven't done more browsing, that's why I can only name these two companies, but I'm pretty sure there are much more big companies doing such blocking based on IP address geolocation.
- cosmin800 6y agoTL, DR; is the Nth time I read the same story, someone losing access to something they think they owned. I don't want to sound too heinous or else ..but please don't be so naive to trust github, operated by microsoft,an usa company, with your life work. You own what you can defend. Your github account is not yours. Sober up. Using any service inside USA is a priviledge not a right.
- tpetry 6y agoSo the consens is that many companies are doing this because of sanctions by the US. What about cloudflare? They are responsible for more and more of the internet‘s traffic. And even if you are a non-us company and have servers not in the US many people use cloudflare because of its ddos protection. Does cloudflare block these countries too as they are an american company despite you not being a us company.
- judge2020 6y agoIt might be over-compliance on GCP’s part, or it might not be. The DOJ isn’t currently prosecuting companies for not complying with sanctions, but that doesn’t mean they won’t decide tomorrow to hit every big US website that doesn’t block Iran IPs by default. The law certainly isn’t clear on where in the OSI model you’re supposed to stop doing business with Iran traffic. Maybe even IX’s are liable if they route traffic that are from Iranian IPs.
- arp242 6y agoOne difference is that Cloudflare doesn't directly do business with you if you visit a website that's using cloudflare, whereas signing up for GitLab (or cloudflare, for that matters) means entering in a legal agreement. I'd have to look at the exact text of the sanctions to see if providing service like cloudflare is a violation, but it's not really the same thing as having an account.
- throw2010251456 6y agoOh noes, they blocked Iranian access to Gitlab?! How about the US blocking Iranians access to life saving medications instead? This is pretty much on the level of being a warcrime!
- Siira 6y agoI am Persian. From what I gather, the middle-plus class here still mostly believes that changing the regime is costly and risky (especially since it might very well lead to a civil war, as the regime has no humanity and has shown that it will kill every single one of the people to survive). These sanctions certainly help align our incentives more with the US agenda, but they do not seem to be enough after all. Obama's strategy was definitely a failure, as well; It simply gave power and legitimacy to the Islamic regime and only got temporary limits in return, limits that ultimately did not abate either domestic abuse or extraterritorial meddling. In the end, dictators know that the Western block is finicky, unstable, and short-termish; This makes it so that high-pressure strategies do not work. I do not know of a solution, frankly; Most of my peers see immigration as the only viable solution. But the blame of the quagmire mostly lies with the democrats and the EU. If they had committed to the high-pressure strategy from the Obama era, a much better compromise would have been reachable with the IR. (The democrats+EU mostly sided with the IR in recent protests as well, just to spite Trump. They are only good for virtue signalling, and do not help the oppressed where it matters.) Western democracies generally are very bad game-theoretic agents; They play repeated games as if they are oneshots. PS: Imagine if the USA sponsored Telegram MTPROTO proxies (and other anti-censorship tools). That'd deal a huge blow to the IR, and make the people more US-friendly as well. Does anyone know why they don't? It's an obvious LHF ...
- crb002 6y agoGrow a pair. Racism to Persians is wrong.
- thaumasiotes 6y agoI have basically no background in the subject, but I'd be interested in your perspectives if you feel like answering any of these questions: - What are the United States' goals with respect to Iran? - What goals of Iran's are being hindered, objected to, or otherwise meddled with by the United States? - In the end, dictators know that the Western block is finicky, unstable, and short-termish; This makes it so that high-pressure strategies do not work. Just to be sure I understand this, you're saying that because Western countries (Europe / the US) cannot maintain a consistent foreign policy, their targets (other countries) see the best strategy for dealing with moments of high pressure from the West as being "wait for the pressure to go away"? - I do not know of a solution, frankly; Most of my peers see immigration as the only viable solution. Solution to what problem? Immigration of who, from where, to where? Western democracies generally are very bad game-theoretic agents; They play repeated games as if they are oneshots. I suspect term limits have a lot to do with this.
- BlueToth 6y agoFirebase also blocks Iranian IP's, which is why I don't use that service.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- aejnsn 6y agoFree software does not constitute a free service. It’s open source, host your own GitLab instance. Furthermore, this is as if GitLab is the only service to block Iran. I didn’t say the Persian people, I said Iran.
- sepisoad 6y agoThat's so lame, basically it has nothing to do with free software and open source, you can still use them if you wish. in fact it is the corporations who are blocking us not the software!!!. Moreover we have to point our fingers toward Iranian corrupt regime because they are bringing misery to the the people. We have to be asking this question every day: why on earth countries like japan or korea never get sanctioned. I guess the answer is simple
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- samim 6y agoWeaponising open source is a new low, even for this particularly clueless US regime. But this is really only meaningful in the short-term. In the mid-term (2030ish), the tech game is very likely to have drastically changed: Other countries will have taken the technological lead (china & co), while the US is still engaged in endless internal conflicts (in effect a mafia-state, akin to what happend in Russia after 1990). All the global talent that once powered the US tech innovation motor (droves of Chinese, Indian, Russian and European PhD students etc.) will have disappeared. At that point, we might see headlines along the lines of "Globally leading open source platform Gitea Blocked US Access". Personally, i would prefer to see yet another scenario, where the entire global Intellectual property market collapsed and was replace by "open source everything" - but that might be a more long term vision.
- jacques_chester 6y ago> Weaponising open source is a new low, even for this particularly clueless US regime. You assume it's about open source in particular. It isn't. US sanctions are very sweeping in scope.
- excieve 6y agoWhat many don't seem to understand about Crimea, is that Crimea is an occupied territory of Ukraine [0] (as understood by UN, as well as most countries except the Russian Federation and several of its affiliated states). As an occupied territory, it doesn't have any legitimate institutions (such as a recognised government, banks, courts, etc.) — only a foreign occupation regime. Same way as Germany's Reichskommissariats and Reichprotektorats during WW2 were never legitimate entities despite being de facto governed by Germany. This means than no contract (private or public) with a Crimean entity can be internationally recognised and will be easily contested by any court/arbitrage outside of the RF. In addition to this, there's a moral concern of giving legitimacy to a foreign occupation. There's just no way to justify this unless one supports the mentioned occupation, with following systemic abuse of human rights, change of ethnic composition and militarisation. [0]: https://undocs.org/en/A/RES/71/205 https://undocs.org/en/A/RES/71/205
- arp242 6y agoOn the other hand, many of the people living there are not at fault for any of this. They just ... live there. This is why I have such mixed feelings about these kind of sanctions: sure, I don't really disagree with what you're saying, but on the other hand in practice it means hurting normal people just building a life for themselves.
- Gibbon1 6y agoI read an opinion piece by Margret Meed (I think, memory may be off). Her claim was sanctions don't work. And all the burden falls on the powerless. All you end up doing is harming people that can't do anything and are blameless. I haven't seen anything in the last 35 years that contradicts that. The worse thing I've seen is the US is now so schizophrenic that countries under sanctions can't trust that making a deal with US to get sanctions lifted won't prevent them from being reimposed because some other fraction gains power.
- arp242 6y agoI think I read the same piece a while ago, or something very similar to it. I'm not entirely sure what to think of it, I'd have to do some in-depth study to really have an informed opinion and chances are the effectiveness depends on the country as well; I'm not sure if generalizing "all sanctions are {good,bad}" across all countries is a good idea, as North-Korea is not the same as Iran. One case where sanctions and other pressure probably helped is ending apartheid in South-Africa.
- stevefan1999 6y agoMy condolences, but on the other hand, you have to understand that not all open source licenses/projects are borderless, like MIT and Apache they are US-based, and so the curse US cast upon will be effectively apply there too. Only libre software like GNU and public domain works will probably give you the complete freedom to not be wary of this kind of nation-to-nation wraith.
- ramoz 6y agoGitlab needs to maintain its dominant position in U.S Public Sector.
- firekvz 6y agoTalking about over-compliance, you should check out Transferwise blocking access to every venezuelan in their system + IP block the access of every venezuelan IP [1], just cause sanctions against few individuals [2]. And then you have to read their BS ads that state: "We’re building money without borders" As reminder, Venezuela is under a heavy economical crisis, where more than 6 millions citizens (9 millions as per unofficial data) out of the 30 million total had to run away, this is more people than syrian refugees numbers (5,6m). What role transferwise had on venezuela? well, some of those that left, were using transferwise to send money to their families and friends still in venezuela, helping them feed themselves and buy medicines and cover their needs. Note that most of the money sent, wasnt even touching venezuelan banking system, as most venezuelans already have US bank accounts, money was just moving from lets say argentina (common country for a venezuelan to immigrate) to US, not to venezuela But transferwise decided that is better to block 20millions possible users in need of humanitarian help [4], because they didnt want to check if those users were in the OFAC list that is not even 100 people long. [1] https://i.imgur.com/26h0u2W.png https://i.imgur.com/26h0u2W.png [2] https://www.state.gov/venezuela-related-sanctions/ https://www.state.gov/venezuela-related-sanctions/ [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Venezuelan_refugee_crisis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Venezuelan_refugee_crisis [4] https://disasterphilanthropy.org/disaster/venezuelan-refugee-crisis/ https://disasterphilanthropy.org/disaster/venezuelan-refugee...
- CIAvash 6y agoThere are a lot of misinformation here. Nobody has to block Iranians. Look at GitHub, they limited Iranian accounts, not block them.
- tryauuum 6y ago(slightly offtopic) imagine running "docker pull hello-world" and getting 403 because you were born in a wrong country I would be mad at the US if this happened to me
- grishka 6y agoI've came across websites that return a 403 to ANY IP located in Russia for some reason. Official website for NSA's Ghidra is one example. Had to use a VPN because I was having none of that bullshit.
- tryauuum 6y agoyes, still doesn't work from Russia — https://ghidra-sre.org/ https://ghidra-sre.org/ I once had a different story — some openstack Q&A website wasn't unavailable from Russia. Turned out it wasn't the website who was blocking russian ips — it was roskomnadzor carpet-blocking whole IP ranges of cloud providers.
- grishka 6y ago> it was roskomnadzor carpet-blocking whole IP ranges of cloud providers. Oh yeah, forgot about it. RKN block is usually an SSL error, a timeout, or a page from your ISP saying "this is blocked by the government, sorry". Never a 403. Thankfully, smaller ISPs are terrifically terrible at complying with this.
- SoapSeller 6y agoDoesn’t work from Israel as well.
- usr1106 6y agoThere are sites that don't work for any address from EU, because they they don't want to comply with GDPR. Not very common, but I have hit a few. However, it's a difference whether a company does not want to serve you or whether a country that says it brings freedom to the world stops information flow for some. China is criticized for the big firewall. When the US does it to others, it's in the name of freedom.
- koalafied 6y agoAs an international student from an embargoed country, I’m increasingly worried if at some point there will be a law resulting in blockage of my bank account. Already I’ve heard news of PayPal causing trouble for some of us, so I’ve stopped using PayPal for good.
- 00__00 6y agoThe internet is not a parallel universe. Of course, if you are in one country and your country has not trade with country B, then you adhere to those rules. There are many examples of this, not just in the sanction sense. People getting pissed. Seriously, this is macro economics!
- CKN23-ARIN 6y ago> The internet is not a parallel universe. John Perry Barlow begs to differ. https://www.eff.org/cyberspace-independence https://www.eff.org/cyberspace-independence
- pabs3 6y agoMeanwhile, Debian has an official mirror (and two others) in Iran: http://ftp.ir.debian.org/ http://ftp.ir.debian.org/ https://www.debian.org/mirror/list https://www.debian.org/mirror/list