4 ms·
> I know a sample size of 1 has an effectively 100% error rate, but, I think Microsoft is losing mindshare with GitHub. Stuff like this doesn't help. I could se
by jcranmer 6y ago
> I know a sample size of 1 has an effectively 100% error rate, but, I think Microsoft is losing mindshare with GitHub. Stuff like this doesn't help. I could see a small company like GitLab needing to toe the DMCA line, but, Microsoft has the deep pockets and could have built some major community will here by handling this better. Unfortunate that they didn't.
If MS didn't comply with the DMCA takedown notice, then the RIAA could go to court and get an injunction to force it down. Depending on how spiteful the RIAA and the judge are feeling, the injunction could be worded to take down the entirety of GitHub over a single repository. And the impact of actions like these is to make it more likely that such an expansive injunction is sought or granted.
- saagarjha 6y agoRIAA taking down all of GitHub would instantly pit them against all of Microsoft, and make every developer who already hates their guts to pick up the pitchforks and march. They won't try doing it.
- sieabahlpark 6y agoMore like RIAA says to all their publishers "don't do business with Microsoft anymore"
- jjeaff 6y agoAnd as much as RIAA is mostly a slimey pit of lawyers, they would stand no chance again msft's goblin hoard of attorneys.
- devwastaken 6y agoMore attorneys does not convince judges more. The RIAA has some merit, therefore they can preliminary injunction github to remove the repo. If github doesn't comply then they receive sanctions. That's simply how it works.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- onli 6y agoThe other commenters here have argued pretty convincingly that the RIAA has no merit at all. Microsoft should have done the same reading of the letter and determined that this is a hill they have to fight on, in order to operate Github effectively.
- jcranmer 6y agoI doubt they'd fear the PR backlash. They didn't fear it before SOPA, and even when SOPA was defeated, it was largely because the backlash was driven by efforts by sites like Wikipedia, Facebook, and Google advertising counter-SOPA messaging, and that drives far more traffic than sites like GitHub.
- saagarjha 6y agoTaking down GitHub would instantly make millions of developers at thousands of companies unable to do their work.
- jcranmer 6y agoI am well aware of that. But RIAA likely doesn't care one iota about that damage. The injunction they'd write would be along the lines of: "It's necessary that the entirety of GitHub be shut down until this case is decided. As noted here, they have persistently failed to adhere to our DMCA take-down notices, and continue to knowingly host content that circumvents our copyright protection schemes. Furthermore, it is not sufficient to just remove this content, because it has been and will be repeatedly readded, and GitHub has taken no action to remove these extra copies. We are likely to succeed on our merits because <blah>. We are irreparably harmed because <blah>." That doesn't mean they'd necessarily win on a broad injunction, but they can still push for one (see Apple v Epic for a recent example). And stunts like this one make it more likely that a judge might agree that a broad injunction is necessary instead of a narrow one.
- Aeolun 6y agoIf we cannot shut down criminal banks because they are too big to fail. Then we certainly cannot shut down Github.
- sneak 6y agoOnly for a few days, critically. GitHub may be the single source of truth, but it’s not the only copy of the data.
- chii 6y ago> RIAA taking down all of GitHub would instantly pit them against all of Microsoft microsoft isn't gonna fight the good fight. There's no reward (to them) for doing so, and there's only a cost. It'd be a stupid business decision. What is more correct is to lobby legislation changes to copyright. Repeal the DMCA, or change copyright law to such that you cannot abuse it this way. And this lobbying is the civil responsibility of everyone, not just microsoft.
- mola 6y agoNo company would fight the good fight for the same reasons. This can only be fixed by changing the law. Not to mention find and persecute the parties who were paid directly or indirectly to pass this legislation. RIAA lobbyists (and all other corporate lobbyists) don't lobby in the sense of arguing for something. They use stick and carrot techniques against legsitlators. It's practically raketeering.
- yoz-y 6y agoMore importantly GitHub could lose the status of safe haven and could be held liable for all repositories.
- matkoniecz 6y agoWhat was submitted was not a DMCA notice, Microsoft was not legally obligated to comply with it. From what I know, DMCA notice requires the identification of claimed copyrighted content and this document does no such thing.