10 ms·
I guess it's not surprising but I am super disappointed by some of the comments here that show a total lack of empathy for people who aren't like you. I mean, y
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
I guess it's not surprising but I am super disappointed by some of the comments here that show a total lack of empathy for people who aren't like you. I mean, you love working from home? Congrats, more power to you. But the number of comments stating that "only people who are good at office politics like going to the office", "only incompetent managers need to see you in person", "your co-workers aren't your friends", etc. are, as I would generously put it, tone deaf.
For many (most?) people this has been the worst working situation of their lives, and attempts to minimize that are insulting. I believe it will be especially bad for those early in their careers, trying to find their footing, get mentorship, and build their network.
- dimator 6y agoI think no one is thinking past "but I'm more productive!", that's including employers and employees. Productivity is not the be-all end-all of a career! Human interaction (of any kind) is important, "wasting" time going to lunch with colleagues is important, serendipitous encounters at the coffee machine are important. I know for certain if my employer decides to go permanent remote, I'll be looking for another employer. This is not the way I want to live and work.
- jarjoura 6y agoThe first 2 months of lockdown, I was crazy productive, working till midnight every night. Then little by little I'm slowly finding it harder and harder to concentrate. My productivity has fallen enough that my manager has called it out. So, at this point the commute and my eating habits have been the only thing that has significantly improved from this WFH lifestyle.
- kris-s 6y agoSounds like you are in dire need of a break!
- jarjoura 6y agoYou're telling me!!
- adjkant 6y agoGo take one-two weeks off if you can, seriously. Even if just to stay in your area, maybe do some park/nature walks. The reset truly helps. The need for vacation didn't go away because of quarantine.
- bbarnett 6y agoHeh, an amusing thought. If you've watched Red Dwarf, the entire reason that Rimmer was brought back as a hologram, was so that Dave would not go insane. And another crew member could have been brought back, but Holly determined that Rimmer would be best. The conflict, you see, was required. Many here decry the "waste of time" of being interrupted. Their attention divided. Yet you're indicating that after a few months of endless, day long shifts free of interruption, productivity has dropped a bit. It appears for some, Holly was right. You need a Rimmer.
- nullsense 6y agoWorking until midnight will probably do that to you.
- disgruntledphd2 6y agoUnless you are some kind of super-human (which unfortunately most of us are not), I'd replace probably with definitely. Also, long hours are not equal to productivity, and believing that they are is a quick route to burnout (which sucks, and you should try to avoid).
- hn-throw-22 6y agoYou need to find things you enjoy outside of work and follow a normal schedule.
- Cyph0n 6y agoProductivity has nothing to do with how long you work... but working until midnight does sound like a recipe for burnout. You should take a break to reset, as soon as you can!
- varispeed 6y agoWhy do you work until midnight and blame WFH for that?
- hn-throw-22 6y agoInversely, if my employer will not allow me to be remote, I will look for another job. I think people need to realize that human interaction exists beyond the office.
- ck425 6y agoThat's a hard opinion to push during a pandemic. I might be ok WFH during normal times (I strongly suspect I'd dislike it still) but atm it's nigh impossible to get enough human interaction outside the office.
- hn-throw-22 6y agoWhile yes, we're living through a pandemic. Nobody is suggesting these things should/can happen during the pandemic. People need to decouple WFH and pandemic thinking though. Also, I think we should fully support what's suitable for people. I want to work remotely, but I want you to be able to work the way to prefer as well.
- this_na_hipster 6y agoI completely agree. Additionally, as someone in the thread pointed out, this decision really doesn't make sense by Dropbox. You have a series of problems that I can't see a solution for. 1) If we have Dropbox Studios, who dictates the frequency of those visits? If a manager dictates, there will be resentment of some sorts. If its a democratic vote, what about the people that can't make that date? 2) Assuming the dates have been finalized, the people that cannot make that date are at a disadvantage. They might not be in driving distance to a hub or for other reasons. That would mean information again has to be propagated back virtually for all members. 3) If a date is set and all the necessary people have come together, is it essentially a company day off? If the goal is to meet and talk to people without doing solo-work, I would assume its filled with meetings or events. If this is true, this doesn't make sense to do it too frequently. If done infrequently, it defeats the purposes of these studios. All of the thoughts so far don't even go through the cliques / groups that would form that can be gatekeepers of information for true remote workers that can't meetup.
- marcosdumay 6y agoWhat I expect from something like this is: The visits are either dictated by policy or agreed upon by the participants. A place will probably want both, a low frequency one by policy and freedom for the employees to set any frequency to themselves. Voting doesn't make any sense, you need all the participants to agree on a date. The policy meetings ought to be fixed and with a low enough frequency that people can plan their lives after them. Like once every 6 months. Otherwise people will resent them. After a date is set and the people come together, they can work on whatever they decided to have the meeting for. Of course, it's probably not for doing solo-work, but the company shouldn't dictate a lot here. It would go counter to the goal of the studios. I imagine the company expects every worker to be able to meetup at some point.
- repsilat 6y agoI figure it doesn't make sense to commit to it if they can do it without committing, but not a bad thing to give it a go. I figure - most ideas are bad, - judgement is a crapshoot but improves the odds up to 50/50, - trying and either rejecting or committing (or going bankrupt) gets the odds of the better solution prevailing in the market up to 60-odd percent. Plenty of confounding variables, lots of opportunity to get unlucky and draw the wrong conclusions (or just have your priors overrule weak evidence against them), but it's science and we haven't found anything better yet.
- Def_Os 6y agoI recently pinged 2 co-workers for Friday afternoon remote "water cooler calls". I could send the relief when they had some informal time to vent and freely chat. I can recommend it wholeheartedly.
- tidepod12 6y agoI've noticed this too. I've made it a point now to call up some of my team members at least once a week for no purpose other than to have a venting session. I don't think I ever realized how much of this venting must have subtly happened in person, but since COVID I think most of it gets bottled up and people get very frustrated when they can't casually talk through these issues in person. My team has collectively agreed that these "venting calls" are great if only for the reason that they make you aware that you're not the only one with frustrations, and I think that really helps morale.
- haswell 6y ago> I don't think I ever realized how much of this venting must have subtly happened in person, but since COVID I think most of it gets bottled up and people get very frustrated when they can't casually talk through these issues in person. I hadn't considered this angle before reading your comment, but the psychological impact of this alone is huge. As any therapist will tell you, working through frustrations and integrating negative experiences instead of bottling them up is crucial. This is something I already struggled with prior to COVID, and I've been seeing a therapist for years now for this (and many other) reasons. The thing about bottling things up is that it kind of "works" for awhile. Until it doesn't. So we probably haven't even started to see the longer term impact this will have over time.
- gomox 6y agoOur company uses a Slack bot thing called "donut" that schedules these random meetups for you.
- wuunderbar 6y ago> I am super disappointed by some of the comments here that show a total lack of empathy for people who aren't like you. I've noticed as of late HN has been riddled with comments such as: here is my extremely strong thoughts on X with my personal anecdotal experience Y, and therefore this is how the world should work. > I believe it will be especially bad for those early in their careers Agreed. I think it can be equally has bad for someone midway into their career who is thinking about taking on more leadership opportunities.
- farnsworth 6y ago"as of late"
- halfmatthalfcat 6y agoMy hypothesis is that WFH has been somewhat ostracized, generally, by companies for bad reasons that would otherwise benefit employees who find it beneficial. The pendulum is now swinging in WFH's favor and those who it benefits want to cement it as a very viable and practical alternative to the traditional office model.
- taxcoder 6y agoI wonder if it will swing to an extreme the other way, as many pendulum like responses tend to. In other words, if WFH will become more common than is reasonable as we reach and then pass an ideal.
- Smithalicious 6y agoMany people who thrive working from home have been forced to work in the office for their entire career and are now VERY driven on defending their improved working conditions.
- ghaff 6y agoYes. And the flip side is you have people who hate WFH (especially in the current situation) who liked the everyone in the office model really fear that, even absent 100% remote, the in-office experience will be much reduced with many of their co-workers coming in seldom. And meetings will all still be on Zoom. There are a lot of incentives to stake out positions. People don't really want to be fully remote at a company where most of their co-workers go back into the office most of the time and people mostly don't want to go back into an office where it's mostly just teams having all-day meetings now and then.
- serverholic 6y agoSo basically anti-WFH people are sad that they can't hold pro-WFH people hostage anymore.
- DetroitThrow 6y ago>So basically anti-WFH people are sad that they can't hold pro-WFH people hostage anymore. Ehh I think this comment is what the root comment was critisizing. I think a more empathetic lens is that you can either provide a remote-first or in-office-first experience for a team, and that at a larger office many or most teams being remote-first would detract from the office-first experience. I think it's short sighted to assume that having 200 people primarily in the office would be significantly different than 400 people, for example, but going from 400 to 10 certainly would. The good thing is that after companies finish out corona, engineers will have more remote-first work options and still plenty of office-first options - I don't think there will be much in the way of hostage taking, but I'm sure some folks will be (rightfully) miffed if they joined a team for one experience and post-pandemic are getting a different one. They are also able to find a new job :)
- stetrain 6y agoSee also all the posts about "I had to work from home during a pandemic, with forced restrictions on other activities and social gatherings, while also home schooling my children and dealing with an inordinate amount of stress and disruption to my life, therefore I hate work from home and would never consider it given the choice." The last 6 months isn't really representative of why we should or should not be encouraging WFH, but it at least seems to have opened more doors to accommodating it as an option in companies that would have previously been against it.
- ghaff 6y agoThere's an in-person CIO Symposium event I usually go to and this year it was spread out into a series of short virtual events. One very common theme is that necessity made them do things that they were skeptical about, thought would take too long, would be really hard and... the world didn't end and, in fact, things turned out better than expected. A lot of experiments that people were afraid to perform were performed for them and things turned out not bad. Or even well. Of course, WFH is a mixed bag and I expect 100% remote to be rare but I do expect a lot more flexibility at many companies.
- hombre_fatal 6y agoI agree that the comments you've cited are a bit ridiculous. But it's also important to acknowledge that pre-Covid, only a tiny fraction of jobs were remote at all. People who preferred remote work had very little choice in the matter. Our society assumes that commuting to work and sitting in a cubicle (or worse) is fitting for 99% of the work force. So what I mainly see here aren't the comments you cite, but a "ugh but I like the office", which gets very little sympathy from me in a society where, virus aside, the majority of jobs are office-only. Like, the world is already tipped in your favor. To put it into perspective, I was so desperate for a fully remote job that I took a $50,000 salary for it when I was making $130,000 in Austin, Texas. Now I live in South America on a beach doing exactly what I want to be doing. I don't like the optics of calling Covid a "good thing", but it must be pointed out that it got offices (like my former job) that were adamantly ass-in-seat only to go remote-only. It spurred fundamental (hopefully lasting) shifts in our work culture. And a lot of them were a long time in the making and waiting. How many of these companies that were firmly ass-in-seat are now fully or mostly remote realizing that the sky isn't falling? I hope we reach a better equilibrium. Ideally our employment options would have something for everyone without you needing to go for a $50k job to get what you want. Another culture change I'd like is for WFH options to come with a signing bonus to get your home office sorted out, something that's sorely lacking.
- ashtonkem 6y agoPre pandemic people who preferred to work from home were regularly told that they weren’t actually working.
- serverholic 6y agoIt's also time for us to raise our voices and be heard. If we pro-remote people don't say anything then companies could easily think that everyone wants to go back to the way things were.
- ck425 6y agoThere has to be a balance though. I'm desperately missing the office and have experience moderate depression for the first time in my life working from home. Atm everything I read is 'WFH is the new normal' or 'we'll never have an office again'. If the balance goes too far to home working then folk like me will need to start clamouring for offices. There needs to be a balance and acknowledgment of each others preferences else this will become a crazy unhealthy culture war.
- haswell 6y agoThank you for highlighting this. As others have said, I could not agree more. As a Product Manager, working remotely 100% of the time is absolute hell. And I say this as someone who was already working from home ~70% of the time before (and I was mostly ok with that). I also wanted to pick on a few of the categories you mentioned: > "only incompetent managers need to see you in person" Some of the best work I've done is when I'm able to go brainstorm in a room with my leadership. Lacking the ability to do this as we plan our next release, or the next 3 year strategy or whatnot is extremely difficult. Having competent management means that they understand when this is valuable and when it's not. > "your co-workers aren't your friends" I hear this a lot, and I have to feel bad for people who have never experienced true friendship at work. At each of my jobs, I've made lifelong friends. Friends I've since vacationed with, stood up as a groomsman in a weeding for, etc. This is part of what made those jobs so rewarding. I think the general thought is that "jobs change, so that 'friend' might not be around next week", and that's true. But in my experience, if they're true friends, changing jobs doesn't change that. This says more about me than anything, but where else am I going to meet friends? --- All of this to say, in addition to being tone-deaf in light of the current reality in the world, these sentiments are also suspect under normal circumstances. These things may be true for some people at their place of employment, or for them personally, but it's hard to understand where this comes from.
- e40 6y agoWhy can't you brainstorm in a virtual room? I've been part of that many times over the years, and it works, too. The only thing I miss is taking walks with coworkers. That is where the real value was for me. Something about walking and talking that is so beneficial.
- haswell 6y agoI'm talking about conversations that might take all day, or days. Breaking down enormous problems. Deep collaborative work. Can you do this in a virtual room? Yes. Will you achieve the same outcome? Early results (in my case) seem to indicate the answer is "no". I want the ability to pace around the room at times. Look my collaborators in the eye. Pick up on non-verbal cues that are often impossible to see remotely. Step away as a group to share a much needed lunch break. And when passionate people are involved, and many viewpoints are present, the ability to all argue/debate a topic vigorously - even show frustration at the right moments - and then all share a beer at the end of the day, is critical. Having that same vigorous debate on Zoom and then dropping off to our individual lives doesn't leave room for reconnecting with each other as humans - something that is critical for maintaining relationships. Not every project requires this kind of interaction. But for things that do, the remote format just doesn't work well for everyone.
- rexreed 6y agoGeneralizations are often false. Including this one.
- ccktlmazeltov 6y agoCommuting is destroying cities (we give up space for cars, noise pollution, pedestrian streets, etc.), people (how much time do you lose in commute?), and the world (pollution). Cars were invented in an era where cities were not as dense, and where jobs were mostly done in person. With the advent of the internet and personal computers, this is changing, that you want it or not.
- TillE 6y agoThis is a problem all over, but it's 100x worse in America, where it's basically impossible to survive in 99% of the country without a car. Redesigning cities is glacially slow even with a clear political will, but taking a bunch of people off the roads at peak times is quick and relatively painless.
- hn-throw-22 6y agoI think part of the issue is that the work from office advocates are more concerned about their needs and pushing their needs onto others who may have a different preference. I hope in the future companies will allow people to work the way they prefer, whether that's in office, remote or something in between.
- fpig 6y agoMy issue here is this is not really a honest conversation most of the time. Wanting to work from home generally means just that, wanting to work from home. Not wanting to work from home however usually really means "I don't want others to be able to work from home", it's about taking options away from other people. The exception being people who don't want to work from home because they have a pack of screaming children at home, etc - in their case saying they don't want to work from home is actually honest. Your comment is a good example. For your perceived issues to be resolved, we need to make other people work at the office. The idea that others shouldn't have the option to work from home because them being at the office helps someone else build their network is not something I can agree with.
- abnercoimbre 6y agoI came to say exactly this. In addition, we can't forget the people who have to work in the city but can't afford to live there, so their lives are made vastly more difficult. Sometimes the commute is just too stressful, even if you live in the city. My partner's well-being has visibly improved due to going into the office only when necessary. Maybe WFH should be renamed to something else. It doesn't capture all the subtleties of flexibility and choice we're asking for.
- john4532452 6y agoThe one major reason i fully support remote work is, its effect on "age bias". You may be in your 20's and you may not feel the pressure. Once you hit 35+, you see age-bias everywhere. Its better to have job opportunities based on skill rather than how you look.
- varispeed 6y agoNot sure why working in office isn't considered a luxury? You are literally making your whole team commute from various parts of the city just to have a face to face contact. Mind you that this arrangement has been created because in the past there was no way to effectively communicate, but now this is no longer a problem, therefore commuting is just a thing from the past that some people are too attached to, akin to preferring listening to vinyl instead of Tidal or something. Why people should live in the past? That ship has sailed.