10 ms·
I'm always shocked when I read these comments on HN. I swear it must be just the American Amazon that's so shit, because I literally never had any problems nor
by gambiting 6y ago
I'm always shocked when I read these comments on HN. I swear it must be just the American Amazon that's so shit, because I literally never had any problems nor know anyone with these problems here in UK. Just this year I'm on 108 orders and counting, every single one of them was fine, working, definitely not used, definitely not counterfeit and delivered within 1 day as promised with Prime. Last year I've had 140 orders total, year before that 122 orders, and again never had any of those problems. I think the only return I did was a lightbulb that broke after 3 months and Amazon refunded me but only after I shipped it back, which I thought was very wasteful.
- dividedbyzero 6y agoI've had counterfeit issues with chargers a few times, other than that no issues, Amazon Germany in my case.
- outoftheabyss 6y agoI second this. I’ve tried to give other online retailers a shot but nothing beats the customer service and reliability of Amazon in the UK, even if something is slightly more expensive I’ll always go with Amazon
- gambiting 6y agoYep, I recently made a mistake of buying a new Lenovo laptop directly from Lenovo instead of Amazon, and it was a huge mistake - the machine arrived with a broken screen and I waited over 2 weeks for the replacement, their support was generally useless and every time I rang them got a different answer to what was actually happening(they said the replacement is ready, only to say it's not and I'll get a refund 2 days later, to then turn around and say a replacement has actually been shipped, absolute nonsense). Had it been purchased through Amazon I can guarantee I would have just returned the laptop the same day with a prepaid label, had the money back in my account the next day, re-ordered and had a replacement the following day. Well, lesson learnt I guess.
- cesarb 6y agoAt least yours arrived. I also made the mistake of buying a new Lenovo laptop directly from Lenovo some years ago, they canceled the order but didn't give the money back. Their support was completely useless, every time I called they said I had to send an email, and my emails went completely unanswered. When I tried contacting them through the consumer protection organization (PROCON), they sent a nonsense answer (as if I had received a defective laptop and wanted to send it back). I had to sue them in small claims to get my money back (plus moral damages); their defense in court was that I hadn't paid (with a printout of their internal systems showing the boleto as unpaid), even though the initial petition had a copy of the bank receipt. The lesson I learned was to never buy from Lenovo, since I can't trust I would be able to contact their support when needed.
- YZF 6y agoI ordered a laptop directly from Lenovo, I paid less than the price in Amazon by a fair bit, and it arrived quickly and all was good... (Canada, YMMV)
- polskibus 6y agoAmazon has prob. lower market share in e-commerce in EU than in USA. Competition (and more pro-consumer regulation) helps.
- obmelvin 6y agoEh, I mean I understand your comment in general, but I think it's a reasonable hypothesis that the discrepancy could be that Amazon doesn't have a large enough market share in other markets for these issues to have occurred (i.e. EU small sellers have yet to start abusing the marketplace to the extent done in the US). I certainly recognize that I don't have data to indicate either way - but my point is that the lack of problem in UK/EU doesn't necessarily mean Amazon is responding better to competition.
- lowdose 6y agoNo they do not and actually in the G7 already 70% of product search starts on Amazon. Australia had a very fast adoption and most people installed the Amazon app within a year. Their app is the number one e-commerce app in all countries amazon operates on a country specific TLD . In other countries Ali express is the most popular app on App store.
- nextos 6y agoSome of these issues were with Amazon UK, where I've been buying most of my items (around 400 orders). The underwear issue was with Amazon US, and RAM with Amazon DE. But I've found Amazon UK quite problematic too.
- pjc50 6y agoThe UK has working consumer protection and a small claims court. America mostly doesn't.
- schrodinger 6y agoThat may be true but I’ve never had a hint of a problem returning something with Amazon. Yes they do have an annoying counterfeit problem, but at the same time, the second you complain, you get an instant complete refund and maybe even an additional credit as apology.
- kortilla 6y agoWell I think this is just survivorship bias. Nobody really feels compelled to post when they are in the mundane majority of people who didn’t have a bad experience.
- BrandoElFollito 6y agoSame here (France). I will actually pay a bit more for Amazon products because I never, ever had any problem. The closest I had to a problem was when I sent an email stating that a product is not functional after a year and a half. They replied that the 30 days return window is over and that I should contact the producer. I replied that according to the law, I have 2 years of warranty with zero costs from my side. They replied that are very sorry for the misunderstanding (or something like that), together with a return slip. Teh second one would probably be when I was suggested to test Amazon Prime and I was charged 50€ right away. I replied this is a test. They replied that I actually signed for Prime, that it was not a test. To what I replied it was, to what they replied they will reimburse me 50€ minus the fast shipping costs (that would otherwise be included in Prime). To what I replied i was really unhappy. To what they replied that 50€ are on their way to may credit card. This is one of the reasons I buy with Amazon without much fear.
- jliptzin 6y agoBut what did you reply after that?
- BrandoElFollito 6y agoAh yes, I ended up replying to a HN comment :)
- benhurmarcel 6y agoIt's not just Amazon US which is terrible for that. Since moving to Spain I've stopped ordering on Amazon also. At least half the products I've received from them were either counterfeit, or clearly already used. Add to this their terrible delivery service and I don't understand how they're still in business here.
- mcv 6y agoI almost never buy from Amazon anymore. Not really because of any bad experiences, though reports about the high number of counterfeit goods that Amazon sells certainly contributes to my reluctance. Also: Amazon is just too big. I like a bit of competition in the market. Also, in Netherland, Amazon isn't all that big. In the distant past, I sometimes ordered at amazon.com, later at amazon.de. Recently I got an invitation to amazon.nl which apparently just opened, but I really don't see the point. Netherland already had a couple of big online retailers: bol.com and coolbue. They're good, fast, reliable. I don't need Amazon anymore.
- Izkata 6y agoI think it might be just certain warehouses. I'm in the US and have never had these problems either (I'm at 76 orders this year). I do avoid clothes though, it's difficult to find ones that are shaped correctly for my body, so I go in-person to a local store, buy ones that fit, then order more of the same style from their site online using the SKU.
- grahamburger 6y agoI think it might just be coastal US cities? I live in a flyover US state and my experience matches yours. Universally good, overall much better experience with products ordered on Amazon than purchased at the local Walmart. Not that Walmart is a particularly high bar, but still it sets an expectation.
- mortehu 6y agoWe live in Manhattan and order even more stuff than GP (about 25 orders last month) and we've had like two issues this year: a missing knob on a puzzle for toddlers, and paint on three toy vehicles damaged during shipping.
- Zancarius 6y agoI'm suspicious it must just be regional, because my experience is similar. I live in NM and have had only half a dozen "major" (?) issues over the decade+ that I've ordered from Amazon. My experience is posted slightly up thread from yours.
- bee_rider 6y agoCould also be that people's experience depends on how picky they are about sellers. I mostly just go for Amazon or the original manufacturer (I guess I should to the original manufacturer's site, but I don't want to find my wallet...)
- cblum 6y agoI’m in Seattle and that’s been my experience as well in the 7 years that I’ve been their customer.
- robteix 6y agoAgreed. I've tried many times to give other retailers a chance but they always screw up while Amazon Canada has yet to do so.
- mypalmike 6y agoI order around the same number of items every as you from Amazon in America and have never had an issue like the ones mentioned in every hn discussion about the company. Bad experiences stick with people and they are more likely to write about it. Like the one time I ordered Harmon Kardon subwoofer from newegg like 15 years ago and it came entirely missing it's outer case, and neither newegg not Harmon Kardon (I went in person to their service center) would accept the return. It made me skeptical of ordering from newegg for a while, and it was unusual and annoying enough that I still remember it to write about.
- Supermancho 6y agoOf all the people I know order from Amazon (we'll say 200 people if you count all the people on slack channels at every place I've worked) in the last 3 years, I've heard of some computer parts being obviously repackaged twice. That's it. These horror stories of consistent problems is just not something that's common in major metropolitan areas of the west coast USA.
- emayljames 6y agoNope. In UK and I had a tablet I ordered, that was supposed to come yesterday. Says that is delivered, but I never received. None of my neighbours received, so who knows where it is. As for their own brands like thier tablets, they are probably worse quality than some counterfeits/awful brands. They have nasty cheap parts, for example the usb power port breaks in no time. I made the mistake of shopping for that non-amazon brand tablet for yesterday, but what a seriously shoddy company, for many reasons.
- gambiting 6y agoOk, but how is this an issue with Amazon? Delivery company lost the tablet, that's it. The difference is that I can guarantee Amazon will just refund you after few days if you tell them you never got it, while another retailer(ekhm ekhm...pcworld) would just say that the item shows as delivered so you can get lost. That's where the main difference is - Amazon is willing to accept some amount of fraud to offer good experience to legitimate customers experiencing problems.
- usefulcat 6y agoSelection bias. Of course you don't hear anything about the myriad times people ordered something and it arrived more or less as expected. I've ordered at least hundreds, maybe thousands of items from amazon over the years. I won't say everything has been completely perfect, but I also don't recall the last time I needed to return anything.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoAmazon's official policy is they will send you inventory that they didn't source themselves, meaning they don't even do the bare minimum for quality control. Even if this policy results in 99% good experience, I wouldn't want to waste my time with a business that is simply serving as an online flea market when I can go to Aliexpress.com and get the same for cheaper.
- conception 6y agoAmazon used to source everything themselves and as the years have gone by they source themselves things less and less. When almost everything used to have a “sold and shipped from amazon” many things now do not and that’s the root of the issue. They are becoming eBay without really telling anyone.
- brightball 6y agoI’m in the US and we order off of Amazon all the time. I’ve had exactly one problem that apparently came from a vendor with tons of complaints (wrong item and a history of refusing refunds or trying to negotiate a partial due to return shipping costs). Aside from that, everything has been great but I also never order clothes from Amazon.
- Zancarius 6y agoSimilar experiences here. I'm no fan of Amazon, particularly with how they treat their workers. That said, some of their competition just doesn't offer the same range of products at a reasonable enough quality[1] making me suspect that a significant number of their items get returned or tossed. In recent memory, I've had only one bad experience with a 3rd party seller not shipping the item I ordered. Oddly, I ordered twice before from them (through Amazon) and never had an issue. Something changed in the months leading up to the third purchase, because their reviews went from overwhelmingly positive to overwhelmingly negative, and I'm not sure COVID-19 would completely explain it (or maybe it does?). Two months after not receiving the purchase, I sent a dispute to Amazon and they refunded it in full. Can't complain. I did have a product arrive damaged (actually a pack of two; one was fine). Amazon refunded the entire purchase price for both saying they couldn't do partial refunds (understandable). Of the couple of other mistakes I can think of, they'd once sent the wrong item (a consumable) and also refunded without fuss, suggesting I should just dispose of the mistaken item as I saw fit. The other one was a carafe for frothing milk for cappuccinos that didn't arrive at all. IIRC, they refunded and sent a replacement the same day I emailed. Also had a hard drive show up with surface defects (placed in an unnecessarily large box and almost certainly got beat up during shipping), and I got a return label that same day with UPS showing up about a day later to pick it up. (Bonus: I know the usual UPS driver, so it was good to see him!) Never have bought many clothing items from Amazon recently except for neck ties. Watching some YT channels that purchase from Amazon-related liquidators[2], the negative experiences with clothing and personal hygiene don't really surprise me. Worth watching, but be prepared to be somewhat terrified and maybe a little grossed out. [1] I once bought a laptop cooling tray from Walmart out of curiosity. The quality was roughly what you'd expect. The USB cable failed after about a month of use (poorly terminated no doubt) and the tray is of the lowest quality manufacture you can imagine. Ironically, it was more expensive than better quality options off Amazon... [2] https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC8Xi9F_8Sr1-1bKRDlCO1ZA https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC8Xi9F_8Sr1-1bKRDlCO1ZA
- Spooky23 6y agoPerhaps the laws are more strict outside of the US re fraud. Most of the issues I’ve seen on Amazon are directly related to shady third party sellers or commingled inventory. They are responsive to regulatory action - when I filed a complaint about COVID related price gouging via my state attorney general’s office, they acted within two hours of receipt. A firm hand is effective.
- polytely 6y agoI'm guessing it's the end state of Amazon. They are still trying to take over European markets so they have to maintain quality to compete, but once there is no competition it will degrade until it's barely tolerable for the average consumer. You as a person who can spot fakes are an outlier, and a rounding error in their sales, so your boycot don't work. Fake products are the necessary sacrifices we have to make in order to be fulfilled by Amazon. Quality control (like moderation or ethics) just doesn't scale, and we must maintain infinite growth at all cost.
- 0xffff2 6y agoI feel the same way, except I'm in the US so it's not a strictly regional thing. I expect it's just that you're far more likely to hear from extreme outliers in topics like this. I will say that "definitely not counterfeit" is a very high bar these days. I have a pair of Ray Bans that I'm still on the fence about after several years.
- searchableguy 6y agoHighly depends on the sellers and general market in your country, I suspect. In India, Amazon was good early on until it attracted scammers and painful customers. Customer support switched to Indian contractor companies and it is not as nice anymore. Reviews became useless and downright harmful. I have gotten many incorrect items from their fulfilment program in the last 2 years. I never got any before it.
- Bayart 6y agoIn France the only problem I've ever had that was arguably Amazon's fault was a broken glass item (arguably because it's really down to the container used by the manufacturer and the thing being broken anywhere from packaging in China to my postbox, the Amazon packaging wasn't bad). Everything else was 100% down to the manufacturer or negligent Marketplace seller. I have tons of valid complaints about the shitty search engine, the poor quality of filters, the dark patterns pushing shit and the over-abundance of third-party Chinese crap, but Amazon still is more reliable and friction-less than the vast majority of e-tailers. This being said the other sites have gotten much better (not much choice), to the point Amazon isn't my one-stop-shop anymore (as it would have been five or ten years ago).
- eigenvector 6y agoAnecdotally, Canada & US Amazon used to be like you described when they first started becoming the "everything" store but things have really declined lately. 6 or 7 years ago there was a much higher proportion of items actually sold by Amazon. Now it's a morass of third-party sellers with inaccurate listings to the point that even just finding an item is quite a choice. I recently gave up trying to buy kitchen knives because most listings had no OEM part number, a vague description and photo and people arguing in the Q&A section about basic features like whether it had a serrated edge or not. Amazon has become a dumping ground for people who buy things on Alibaba, at liquidation or even just at Costco and try to resell for a markup. Even a search for basic consumer products like a box of cereal will have the top results be these kinds of sellers. For instance, I just searched for "ichiban noodles" (a popular international brand of instant noodles that can be found for <$1/each in any grocery store in Canada). The top result is a pack of 8 for $27! Yes, Amazon still replaces or refunds almost anything that you have an issue with, but I'd rather just get the thing I wanted the first time. A perfect of example of this is a picture frame I bought from Amazon (or rather, third party seller fulfilled by Amazon). It arrived damaged because it was thrown into a too-large box with no padding. I notified Amazon and they sent another one. It arrived identically packaged and also damaged. Then I asked for a refund. At this point, almost a month had passed and I still didn't have a picture frame, despite a huge amount of resources having been consumed by Amazon. No store that actually has to bear the cost of returns themselves would do that, but Amazon made out like kings on the transaction: they got a cut of the original purchase, their FBA fees, then got to charge the seller for disposal of a broken item - twice!
- lstamour 6y agoIn Amazon’s defence, the item sold should have been packaged better by the original seller. A number of my recent Amazon purchases have arrived in original boxes/packaging. And Amazon in Canada does not stock or sell food items at competitive prices if at all. They barely sell a small number of Whole Foods items online. I generally buy local for most food items, except maybe bulk supplements or household items. Some things, especially now under lockdown, you can only find easily on Amazon...
- kelnos 6y agoAmerican here and I've had exactly one bad shipment (counterfeit earphones in 2015) in my ~20 years of buying from them. I don't doubt that the problems described by others are real, but I think there's a lot of variance in the number and kind of problems people actually see.
- JohnBooty 6y agoJust this year I'm on 108 orders and counting, every single one of them was fine, working, definitely not used, definitely not counterfeit I've had the same experience as you, over roughly the same number of orders in the USA. I've also never really heard anybody else complaining about problems with Amazon either. I have a pretty large extended social circle, and I just don't hear any problems. I 100% believe those who say they have these problems! I'm just trying to put things in perspective.
- jki275 6y agoI purchase regularly from American Amazon and have never had any of these issues. No counterfeits, nothing more than maybe a day late, no returns needed.