18 ms·
"That evidence does suggest the engineers drew on knowledge and skills they gained from Hooked to develop a product for their new employer––but California’s pol
by Animats 6y ago
"That evidence does suggest the engineers drew on knowledge and skills they gained from Hooked to develop a product for their new employer––but California’s policy favoring free mobility for employees specifically allows that. (See Whyte v. Schlage Lock Co. (2002) 101Cal.App.4th 1443, 1464 [rejecting the “inevitable disclosure” doctrine, under which a claim for trade secret misappropriation is stated if an employee’s new job will inevitably lead to reliance on the former employer’s trade secrets].)"
Which is why Silicon Valley is in California, and why attempts to create a startup culture elsewhere have mostly failed.
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoOf course it would also apply the other way around - if some Apple employees decided to leave and start their own competitive VR project, Apple would be just fine with that. Wouldn't it?
- emteycz 6y agoI don't understand why there is no Silicon Valley in Europe then
- redis_mlc 6y agoThe reasons are: 1) The California employee rights, which allow an employee to resign and start a new company in the same area. Boston doesn't have an IT industry because of their onerous non-competes, even though DEC and Wang were located there. 2) European nations often have onerous pension requirements that must be met even before hiring a new employee. 3) Silicon Valley has willing investors. 4) Governments across the world prefer dealing with large entities because of the overhead in dealing with multiple companies, so without the right startup culture, new companies just won't happen.
- boulos 6y agoThere are lots of theories. One of the main ones is that national policies around employee equity vary throughout Europe and are often severely disadvantageous (particularly Spain and Germany). Lots of European entrepreneurs are calling on policy makers to both normalize this within the EU, as well as making the policies competitive (e.g., [1]). Of course that statement misses some of the “why not < state in the US >”. The tax treatment in other states is the same, and several have similarly employee friendly policies. If anything, Seattle has become a clear rival to San Francisco, and has restrictive employee policies with regards to non competes (c.f., Microsoft used to sue high profile transfers to Google, Amazon sues ~everyone who leaves AWS, etc.). I think the combo of those things suggest that it comes down to density and freedom of movement. Silicon Valley leapfrogged other places thanks to Shockley => various forks => Intel, Apple and others offering serious equity (the Boston scene didn’t keep up on this front). That fed on itself over and over again, leading to persistence. Seattle is now a powerhouse as a legacy of Microsoft and then Amazon, and all the folks that have come out of it. By contrast, Europe has only had a broad single market for ~30 years. But it’s still super fragmented both in terms of laws and some would argue more importantly by language. 45 years ago when Apple and Microsoft were founded, they were able to hire any engineer in the US (and beyond) that spoke English. By contrast, most European companies were highly national with fairly minimal migration between countries. Europe is closer now to the conditions of the initial Silicon Valley setup (freedom of movement, access to knowledge, everyone speaks a common language), but its decades behind in terms of a history of successes. I believe that the companies spawned from Spotify employees, and so on will spread throughout the European startup scene. But it still takes time. tl;dr: Europe still has some structural barriers, and just a much “younger” startup scene. Edit: plus it’s always important to remember that post WW2, most of Europe was spending its time recovering from the war. [1] https://notoptional.eu/en/policymakers https://notoptional.eu/en/policymakers
- tin7in 6y ago> One of the main ones is that national policies around employee equity vary throughout Europe and are often severely disadvantageous (particularly Spain and Germany). Lots of European entrepreneurs are calling on policy makers to both normalize this within the EU, as well as making the policies competitive (e.g., [1]). I would also add that employee perception about the value of equity vs salary varies across countries in Europe. High stable salaries could be preferred over equity in good welfare states with employee-favorable legislation where firing people is harder (Germany & France for example).
- boulos 6y agoAbsolutely. Though even the base salary pay differential between European hubs and the Bay Area are substantial. I think the firing people thing is good to point out, but many startups end up not needing to fire individuals: they just go out of business :).
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bitL 6y agoAversion to risk. I was told by German entrepreneurs that they can get funding only when they give bank/VC/investor a collateral of the same value or if they are already profitable and don't need it anymore.
- garmaine 6y agoAlso German law doesn't make easy allowances for employee ownership / stock options. There's a hack to get around this where you write a contract for a percentage of the eventual exit, but this limits what sort of exits are possible. European laws, regulations, and investor culture are all setup in ways that hurt startups.
- jashmatthews 6y ago> Also German law doesn't make easy allowances for employee ownership / stock options. Airbnb gave me plenty of RSUs while I worked in Berlin. No problem. The Berlin startups with their shit together also know how to use UK (now Irish) Limited companies, which have no issues with offering options to employees.
- garmaine 6y agoIt’s a German tax law issue. It’s legal to do but not advantageous to the employee, because they don’t allow things like 83(b) elections. Not sure how Airbnb made it manageable in your case, but incorporating elsewhere doesn’t fix the issue.
- hef19898 6y agoRSUs are working just fine. I got them from Amazon, I was able to get largely discounted shares from EADS back the day. Tax wise Amazon RSUs were treated like part of my salary, covering taxes when they vested ranged from selling all and selling parts of the RSU or covering taxes cash and keeping all of the RSUs. The discount at EADS was treated as part of my salary. No problem whatsoever. INAL, but all these instnces had in common was the legal entity being stock based (AGs in German parlance). Most companies in Germany end to be GmbHs, in that case ownership is harder to change but accounting is a lot easier. That being said, Berlin start-ups have a tendency to complain a lot. If they wanted, they could make a lot of things work.
- tomp 6y agoAFAIK non-competes are enforceable in Europe, unless they're unreasonable.
- ChefboyOG 6y agoI don't know how much of a role this plays, but even with lower market rates, employing a team in Europe can be an expensive, unwieldy task. Firing in particular seems to be a lengthy, drawn out process. I don't think that's a bad thing, but I can imagine how a significantly increased cost for every bad hire might increase the risk profile of a small startup.
- zdragnar 6y agoIt is also a big brake on salaries, too. If employees are difficult to let go, and the cost of a bad hire is compounded by that, then it stands to reason that you wouldn't want to pay high salaries. Some companies in the US are terrible at getting rid of bad workers- too many cracks for them to fall through. Some, however, are known for paying high salaries and letting anyone go who doesn't live up to them.
- oliverx0 6y agoI think at-will employment in the US is key to their startup ecosystem. It makes their market very "liquid", as you can hire fast and fire fast.
- davidgay 6y ago> I think at-will employment in the US is key to their startup ecosystem. It makes their market very "liquid", as you can hire fast and fire fast. Is that really the case? I would have naively assumed the typical (median) startup path is something like hire, hire, hire, go-bankrupt? And the successful ones more like hire, hire, hire, hire, hire, go-public? Easy firing doesn't seem relevant to either of those?
- oliverx0 6y agoCompanies in Europe are much more reluctant to hire precisely because it is so much harder to fire. When I lived in the US, and got offers, the company’s first question would be: what’s the earliest you can start? In Europe my experience has been long processes that are dragged out unnecessarily. Hiring is riskier, and therefore slower. There are 2 sides to it of course, on one hand employees are much more protected from losing their jobs, but on the other one innovation and fast access to jobs is also slower. Also, it is not only about firing. Hiring is also slower because of all the paperwork that needs to happen. For example, in Spain you cannot just hire someone. You need to draft out a contract, cover every possible detail related to the work that the person will be doing, etc. it is just slower in general. This brings me back to my min point though: employment at will.
- rdlecler1 6y agoTo pile on, Europe also makes it difficult to raise venture capital funds—particularly smaller micro funds as the startup cost is so high. Europe is going to regulate their way back to the dark ages.
- cameldrv 6y agoAlso that Europe lacks large pension funds that are legally allowed to invest in Venture Capital, or a large class of super-rich that will invest in Venture Capital, or a large class of moderately wealthy startup veterans that like to do angel investing (the last one is changing).
- ry454 6y agoI believe Europe can create its own SV by following the USA's route: the Europe's equivalent of DoD (which has access to unlimited funds, tens of trillions of euros), needs to come up with a grand multi-decade project and invest into companies that are going to work on related sub-projects. For USA it was the worldwide surveillance system, but for Europe it may be something else, like ITER (but on a bigger scale) or micropayments system (I don't know if it would be big enough). That grand project needs to be useful and reachable, though. One thing I'm certain about is that VC-style micro investments into micro projects with micro objectives will bring only micro results.
- geomark 6y agoI think many/most people ignore this, that some of the mega defense projects spawned many companies that led to huge growth in tech industries. The VHSIC program was one of them. I saw dozens of people from the big defense tech company I was working at go on to found design software companies after their experience designing VHSIC chips, chips that are small by today's standards put pushed the limits of design tools at that time. Same thing was happening at the other VHSIC contractors.
- pm90 6y agoA first step might be to expand the European University system to handle the influx of Graduate students that were previously headed to the US. Give funding, poach the frustrated non tenured profs from the US. Essentially reverse what happened during and after WW2, when the anti semitism caused Germany and then mainland Europe to lose all the amazing talent to the US.
- barry-cotter 6y ago> A first step might be to expand the European University system to handle the influx of Graduate students that were previously headed to the US. Give funding, poach the frustrated non tenured profs from the US. There is no European university system. There’s a French one, a German one etc. They all pay much, much worse than their US equivalent because they’re substantially poorer than the US. Remember, if Germany was a US state it would be poorer than every state but Mississippi. And this probably understates the difference. By average household consumption the US is $10,000 ahead of Switzerland, number 2 after Hong Kong. The money to massively increase research spending isn’t there.
- 0xy 6y agoBecause Europe is not at all competitive for tech talent. Fresh graduates earn significantly more money in America than senior-level developers in Europe, with the quasi-exceptions of London and Switzerland (neither in the EU). Why would European developers allow themselves to be shafted out of millions of dollars by staying in Europe?
- mywacaday 6y agoLondon is still in th EU, maybe not for much longer but still there.
- libraryofbabel 6y agoThis is false. The UK left the EU on 31 January. It is now in a “transition period” where it follows EU rules and trade is the same. But it is out of the EU. If you’re going to make factual corrections please check your facts.
- 9HZZRfNlpR 6y agoIn London it's only fintech, rest of the IT salaries are a joke compared to SV.
- jokethrowaway 6y agoLots of money, private and public (DoD)
- rvba 6y agoIMHO it is much more connected to lack of capital.
- niihau_island 6y agoMaybe it's because Silicon Valley occurred first, and then oppressed most of Europe's "native" companies? It seems that there are some massive sources of wealth for tech companies, such as search, social networks, and e-commerce companies. In Europe, these have all been supplanted by Google, Facebook, and Amazon respectively. In China, on the other hand, these companies were free to grow and establish their own nexuses of tech talent. As a result, China is the closest to having the Silicon Valley of <x>. Perhaps Europe should take a page from China's (and the US now, I suppose) playbook?
- boc 6y agoDon't mistake government-sponsored protectionism and corporate espionage for innovation. I don't think Europe can copy China's playbook without also banning all American tech from their economy.
- tonyedgecombe 6y agoI expect you will see barriers come up over time that make it more difficult for American tech companies in Europe. It makes no sense for the EU to outsource such a valuable part of the economy.
- boc 6y agoAgain, protectionism is a dangerous road. If the EU blocked American tech companies, the US would retaliate in kind. While it's possible that Europe could eventually become self-sustaining if given a friendly environment to grow indigenous tech companies, losing access to every major OS overnight (as just a small example of the potential retaliation) would be a pretty devastating experience for Europe. You can't replace Microsoft, Apple, and Google overnight.
- tonyedgecombe 6y agoIt already exists, there are tariffs for American vehicles entering Europe and the US for instance. >losing access to every major OS overnight That wouldn't really be in America's interest would it?
- jariel 6y agoIt's funny as workers get caught up in notions of 'individual freedom', which they see as a benefit, but don't realize that systematically what this favours is simply power. A company with 100x the resources of another, never needs to worry about IP or innovating, because it just plucks off other people's work, integrates into it's own machine and receives the market surpluses, risk free. So yes - by getting tons of young people to drink the koolaid 'work hard for startups' knowing the surpluses, if any, will largely be concentrated in the hands of literally 5-10 behemoths, the Valley has played a neat trick. IP rules favour the little guy: it's how they can keep their innovation by being taken from much larger companies. IP filed by large corps is often protective in nature, so as to protect themselves from trolls and obvious copy-cats.
- redis_mlc 6y agoYou're confusing, perhaps deliberately, employee mobility rights in California with company IP. Thus your post makes no sense, in the English language at least.
- centimeter 6y ago> IP rules favour the little guy This is one of the most absurd and backwards claims I've seen on this site. Large companies are members of patent pools that prevent them from being sued by other members, whereas small companies without a large IP portfolio can't do anything without inadvertently violating someone's patent.
- jariel 6y agoYou're raising a secondary IP issue to a concern much larger than it actually is, causing you to misinterpret the situation. IP is one of the very few areas wherein smaller companies can have any hope of leverage over larger ones. That small companies are blocked from some other patents is an issue, but a lesser one - and it applies to big and small alike. "whereas small companies without a large IP portfolio can't do anything without inadvertently violating someone's patent." - is plainly false. Obviously, companies continue to innovate. Large companies have much more to protect, and far from 'being safe' - IP laws make them more risk averse if anything because they put a lot more at risk than smaller one's. Google has outright banned their employees from even downloading MongoDB etc. due to lack of clarity over licensing. Without IP protections, Google wouldn't care one bit what they did. Large companies play against each other mostly in the domain of competition, without IP laws they would step on every smaller company like little ants, without any concern.
- donor20 6y agoLabor mobility is really low in Europe. In france you can be tied up in litigation (tribunel through appeals) for 10 years easily on an employment termination (my info is from 2016 time frame so may be dated). There is no such thing as at-will employment. Also, noncompete's are weird. If someone is receiving full pay on gardening leave they can work for someone else. If you instead have them work till end of notice period you can usually pay some % of salary (ie, 50%) to totally block their ability to work for any competitor. So you can't fire the horrible workers (without insane headaches) and you CAN block good workers from moving too quickly to competitors (ie, take a year or two out of their working life for a price - which is usually tied to cash salary and is low). All to say - not the fluid labor environment that startups would generally be at home in.
- mattmanser 6y agoFrance != Europe. This sort of thing doesn't exist in the UK, for example. As for firing people, perhaps France, but not UK. Most jobs have a 3-6 month probation period, with a week's notice either way, and in the first 2 years you can fire anyone for no reason (apart from reasons of race, gender, pregnancy, etc.). After that, by which point it's obvious they can do the job, generally you have to give a progression of verbal, written, last chance warnings to an employee to change their behaviour before you can fire them.
- reader_mode 6y agoUK is trying hard not to be a part of Europe it seems :) Anyway I've seen similar laws in several countries in EU, but I talked to a lawyer friend and he said he looked into it (briefly) and couldn't find examples of it being enforced through court in my country (Croatia). As for termination - probation periods exist for sure but passed that it's really hard to get rid of people, the two year thing exists if you give someone extended temporary contract but that really sucks for people because it messes with their credit score etc. I remember working in a company where a woman got hired to work in office A she was then moved to office B because of a reorg (15km away from office A) she refused to accept this - got fired - sued - got pay for the time she was without work, times two in damages and got reinstated to previous position.
- bonestamp2 6y ago> Which is why Silicon Valley is in California I don't think that's the reason -- California's labor market hasn't always been so fair and for that reason it makes complete sense why the court ruled in Apple's favor. Apple, Google, Adobe and some other companies used to have anti-poaching agreements with each other. But, then the courts found that to be unfair to the labor market (people) and the companies settled for $415 million: https://www.cnet.com/news/apple-google-others-settle-anti-poaching-lawsuit-for-415-million/ https://www.cnet.com/news/apple-google-others-settle-anti-po... So, now they're doing the opposite and people are upset? I mean, I guess so, it obviously hurt this company. But, in fairness, they did try to do the right thing and in the end they had to hire the people they wanted to hire because that's what the courts told them was the right thing to do.
- fierarul 6y agoThe Apple et all antipoaching agreement was illegal the whole time and they knew it. It wasn't that the courts found it happens to be illegal. What Apple under Jobs' watch did was illegal at a critical time for the industry.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y ago> Which is why Silicon Valley is in California It is absolutely why Silicon Valley is in California. As someone who lives in a state where non-competes and non-solicits are strongly enforced, they completely stifle new company formations. Just look at the "founding" of Silicon Valley with Fairchild Semiconductor, the "traitorous eight", and Intel. Those stories would be impossible with enforced non-competes and enforced non-solicits.
- Thorrez 6y agoAnti-poaching agreements are bad, but they aren't nearly as bad as non-competes. Anti-poaching agreements mean one company won't cold contact employees at another. But employees who want to switch of their own initiative are still able to do so. Non-competes blocks even employees who want to switch of their own initiative.
- 6y ago
- Waterluvian 6y agoRight to work law is really good in Ontario. Heck I had a CEO who threw a tantrum because I took my skills to another company (that isn’t even a competitor) and demanded I quit with threats. My lawyer basically laughed at him and he went away. Ontario’s tech sector is growing a lot but hopefully the salary issues will improve.
- brianwawok 6y agoWhy can no one but the US pay developers well? The GDP per cap is there in many countries... but for some reason developers are only key employees in the US?
- golergka 6y agoDevelopers work in many different companies, and most of them don't make products that can, or could in even in theory make enough money to make paying as much worthwhile. It's a chicken and egg problem.
- runako 6y agoIn my experience, the "Software is Eating the World" thesis is looking largely correct. The number of software developers at modern non-tech companies can be surprising. Even in my limited experience, I have seen big, well-funded software teams in companies doing retail, manufacturing, transportation, shipping, food service, etc. Those developers do not typically make SV wages (and generally have better work-life balance), but they do frequently earn comparably to lawyers in their cities. An example in the insurance industry from Dallas, a city not known for being a tech hub: https://stackoverflow.com/jobs/417604/mid-senior-level-net-developer-pcms https://stackoverflow.com/jobs/417604/mid-senior-level-net-d... Or telecom in Atlanta: https://stackoverflow.com/jobs/392595/senior-software-engineer-t-mobile-usa https://stackoverflow.com/jobs/392595/senior-software-engine... It might be fair to say these industries have more leverage in the US because they can serve a bigger market. But it's not all about the types of products they make, there are definitely bigger issues that drive the comp differential. I would love to learn more.
- ma2rten 6y agoWhich is why Silicon Valley is in California, and why attempts to create a startup culture elsewhere have mostly failed. I doubt that that is the main reason. Also, in this case it worked against the startup.
- jrott 6y agoThe just so story that is told about this is with no non compete there would be no Intel. The founders would have all been stuck at Fairchild.
- nradov 6y agoThat was one key factor behind the original growth of Silicon Valley. The others were the presence of several excellent universities, and a high level of funding from the military-industrial complex during the Cold War.
- kps 6y ago> The founders would have all been stuck at Fairchild. The founders of Fairchild would all have been stuck at Shockley.
- vmception 6y agoIts a key reason. Mindshare evolves faster because cognitive IP is usuable. What happened to the startup is the expected outcome and they should have known not to use California’s courts. The CEO of Hooked missed their shot by declining the first offer. All of their employees were at-will and could always have been extended offers which is what subsequently happened. Press F to pay respects.
- dev_tty01 6y ago>Which is why Silicon Valley is in California, and why attempts to create a startup culture elsewhere have mostly failed. Silicon Valley's origin pre-dates these labor laws. Hewlett-Packard was started in the late 1930's. Silicon Valley's success has much more to do with a critical mass of talent and infrastructure that started a long time ago. The labor friendly laws were created as part of California trying to nurture that success.
- hardwaresofton 6y agoDon't forget a lot of government investment.
- dantheman 6y agoThere has been lots of government investment in many areas - the question is why was SV different.
- twblalock 6y ago> The labor friendly laws were created as part of California trying to nurture that success. Which ones? Because California has banned noncompete agreements since the 1800s, and that is a big reason Silicon Valley ever got off the ground. Fairchild was literally founded by people who left their employer to compete with it directly, and they definitely took their knowledge with them.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoAnother commenter already responded, but some more details: California's pro-employee stance starts with section 16600, which states "Except as provided in this chapter, every contract by which anyone is restrained from engaging in a lawful profession, trade or business of any kind is to that extent void." That was passed in 1872 and has effectively banned non-competes in CA.
- lambdasquirrel 6y agoBah humbug. Westinghouse was in New Jersey, as was Bell Labs, and IBM was in New York. And there was, at the time, a much larger population base in the East Coast. California had to try harder, and in the end, they won.
- ChuckMcM 6y agoExactly correct. I tried to explain this to a public official from an east cost town who was flying back from the Bay Area trying to "learn the secrets" of creating an innovation hub. When I explained this situation (non-competes are illegal, stuff you do at home is yours) to him he literally said "That's crazy! Why would anyone hire anyone if they knew they could walk out the door to a competitor, or even to start a competitor? We would never allow that in our town." I tried to explain that it puts the onus on the company to adequately reward their employees with equity so that they want this company to be successful, not the possible other company. And it encourages management to be a better place to work than their competitors. Both things lead to better employee engagement and better results. But they couldn't get past the fact that there was no issue with leaving a company and going into competition with it. Ultimately I believe (but cannot back it up with any sort of data) that non-technical folks don't appreciate how much crappy work is involved in starting from a blank sheet and coming up to being competitive with an already up and running company. But what ever the reason, the unwillingness to "go there" with this sort of protection time and time again has killed innovation. Even when an example that it works, and works well, has decades of history demonstrating that it does.
- twblalock 6y agoYep, and the thing is, this is better for workers too. We get more competition in the marketplace, and workers get paid more because their employers want to retain them, because workers have the freedom to go work for a competitor anytime they want.
- lowdose 6y agoAlthough we also know that Amazon wouldn't be such a big success without all the NDA's. There is no knowledge dilution because of this legal setup and this secrecy of real innovation in Bezos company has given him a three year advantage with AWS on Azure around the corner and Google cloud in Silicon Valley not to speak of Apple. While you could rent GPU's in 2015 from AWS the competition could not deliver a GPU without calling it Alpha until the end of 2018.
- travisjungroth 6y agoYour comment reminds me of this tweet: https://mobile.twitter.com/zackkanter/status/1304938616519417856 https://mobile.twitter.com/zackkanter/status/130493861651941... The cognitive dissonance humans are capable of is amazing. To actually say “We would never allow that in our town.” in the pejorative while flying back from a trip specifically meant to learn how to be like another town. If you’re not going to act on an author’s central point, don’t try to do any of the other parts (they’ll probably actually be harmful). If you’re not going to copy the central parts of something successful, don’t bother copying the other stuff. The recipe for success of Silicon Valley is pretty straightforward. It has great colleges, great weather, and weak noncompetes. So people go there to start companies. And now it has a compounding cycle of attracting capital, founders and talent (recent events aside). But a government employee from Boston can’t say that, cause they can’t do shit about it. It’s not like they’ll fix the weather or the noncompetes (too many entrenched medtech companies to change that now). So they’ll say “they have accelerators!” and open a city sponsored accelerator and maybe some successful company will pop out in the next ten years.
- burtonator 6y ago> Which is why Silicon Valley is in California, and why attempts to create a startup culture elsewhere have mostly failed. Except Apple and Google both hate it when it's done to them which is why they illegally colluded and agreed to not poach from one another and why they lost a lawsuit for $415M: https://www.cnet.com/news/apple-google-others-settle-anti-poaching-lawsuit-for-415-million/ https://www.cnet.com/news/apple-google-others-settle-anti-po...
- shadowgovt 6y agoLong after neither of them were startups anymore, yes.
- sandGorgon 6y agoIndian labor laws across the whole country operate like this. Non-competes are useless..
- kamaal 6y agoIts a little different in India. Legal knowledge is negligible among most employees. Even thought the law says a thing, intimidation and threats always do the trick. No one really drags companies to courts given the long intervals of a case, costs, plus mind boggling amounts of corruption involved in anything. Secondly even things like notice period are not enforceable. I have seen situations where a manager would block a person's relieving letter for standards 3 months waiting, while the receiving company wants the candidate to join in a month. The candidate asked for manager to give it in writing in a mail and the manager instantly approved the notice period to be reduced to a month. These days the internal separation portals block such approvals, and getting it changed is a long drawn process which will spawn beyond a person's notice period. And if a person requests a change while they are employed they will be fired. Existence of a law means nothing in India.
- sandGorgon 6y agothat is a very scary FUD perspective you have and it is not based in reality. Non competes have been tested in indian courts and thrown out. This is fairly established and not a situation that is common practice. the other things you talk about are not standard practice and things that may happen anywhere
- kamaal 6y ago>>Non competes have been tested in indian courts and thrown out. Are you from India? People here are afraid to approach the police station even for small issues, let alone take on billion dollar firms and fight expensive cases for years. Even winning means losing in a context like this. People even settle traffic violation tickets with bribes, and you are talking about taking on billion dollar companies. Also no one even goes this far. Programmers earning 4 LPA are not going to spend years in court, many times its just a hack and most people understand this is just how the system works, and get over it.
- chmod600 6y agoReally naive question: I can see why an individual company would include non-compete clauses if legally allowed to. But who actually benefits from non-compete clauses being allowed? Aren't companies hurt more with hiring difficulties and unmotivated employees sticking around than whatever benefit they get avoiding raises? Are there really a bunch of managers thinking "I want an engineering team that is stuck here and just plods along fixing one bug a week".
- filmgirlcw 6y agoIt’s not about the employees being stuck there. The employee can quit for a new job and then just gets sued before they can start work. So then the employee either has to wait out the non-compete period (sometimes these are paid out), losing valuable work time, or they have to get a job in a demonstrably different sector/area, where skill transfer may not be as advantageous. You’re right that this does create a toxic, unmotivated workforce. That said, it can also instill fear in employees from looking for other positions and helps keep wages depressed, since people can’t be persuaded to leave for competitors with higher salaries. It’s about control.
- eecc 6y agoIs that the only fundamental reason for SV? I thought it was an historical process with billions of government subsidies spent in military tech and research that drove the belt. I admit my ignorance about the place so you might have a point, but it feels a tad too ideological to take it at face value. ;)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- anonymousDan 6y agoI'd love to believe this, but given the law is California wide why doesn't this also apply in other California cities (e.g. LA, San Diego)? Or does it?
- fnord123 6y ago>Which is why Silicon Valley is in California, and why attempts to create a startup culture elsewhere have mostly failed. FWIW, non competes aren't enforceable in much of Europe unless the employer pays the person who left. This is known as Garden Leave in the UK.
- regulation_d 6y agoFor a pretty length defense of this thesis (specifically comparing SV with Route 128), see Ronald Gilson's article, The Legal Infrastructure of High Technology Industrial Districts [1]. And for a more global perspective see Anupam Chander's How Law Made Silicon Valley [2]. [1]: https://www.nyulawreview.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/08/NYULawReview-74-3-Gilson.pdf https://www.nyulawreview.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/08/NYUL... [2]: https://law.emory.edu/elj/content/volume-63/issue-3/articles/how-law-made-silicon-valley.html https://law.emory.edu/elj/content/volume-63/issue-3/articles...
- deepnotderp 6y agoI'd recommend reading Regional Advantage, the dominance of Silicon Valley/Bay Area is a lot more nuanced than just noncompetes, good universities, etc.
- jiveturkey 6y agoThat has almost nothing, if not nothing entirely, to do with why SV is in California. Also, are you stating that no other jurisdictions, at all, have this in place? SV is in California because William Schockley moved to California. It's that simple.