12 ms·
Face retouching settings should be off by default
- amelius 6y agoBut another important question: is using filters in photos you post online bad for other people's mental health?
- elil17 6y agoI think it’s well established that it is
- Atlantium 6y agoBut not well accepted by enough of the population.
- wutbrodo 6y agoI'm not sure that's true. I think most people probably have an intuitive sense of this. They just don't care.
- searchableguy 6y agoIs it? Isn't there research showcasing that beautiful things make people feel better? https://www.sv.uio.no/psi/english/research/news-and-events/news/why-we-look-at-pretty-faces.html https://www.sv.uio.no/psi/english/research/news-and-events/n... Although, there are more concrete results about surrounding environment than people specifically. Anything more I can read about this?
- amelius 6y agohttps://www.businessinsider.com/how-retouched-photos-impact-our-mental-health-2018-3 https://www.businessinsider.com/how-retouched-photos-impact-...
- searchableguy 6y agoIt doesn't have any studies listed. I am more curious about any wide scale studies. I have seen some stuff on impact of social media standards and how it affects people but is there anything separate? A study that removes social media and then test out filter applied pictures? Original post: https://www.sheknows.com/health-and-wellness/articles/1138660/retouched-photos-mental-health/ https://www.sheknows.com/health-and-wellness/articles/113866...
- aaron695 6y agoThat's a really good point. Both are true. Beauty in the world really matters. Both people and things. But expectations being set to high on oneself is bad. Can you have one without the other and how much are each weighted. You can also throw in beauty is a service industry that creates jobs and personal satisfaction. Which every UBI talk says is what we will be doing when we can't work.
- searchableguy 6y agoRight, but we should be able to calculate the impact of various factors. Industries could be using wrong types of filters or social media magnifies the filters in wrong ways. For example, instagram algorithms specifically pick certain kind of body features and people to throw in your feed. https://voxeurop.eu/en/the-skin-bias-in-instagram/ https://voxeurop.eu/en/the-skin-bias-in-instagram/ Algorithms could also be causing a significant cognitive dissonance by making people feel excluded. If I don't see enough people that shares some resemblance to locals (however beautiful or filtered they are), there is some stress.
- klyrs 6y agoI guess the real question isn't if beauty makes people feel better. Fentanyl makes people feel great. I think that the better question is, what are the long term effects of unrealistic portrayal of human beauty?
- 3131s 6y agoWhy do people find these retouched images attractive? I'm a good looking guy (in shape, did modelling, etc.) and I just can't understand it. It's like makeup to me... wrinkles, freckles, scars, and everything else have never affected my perception of beauty because I tend to like an exotic, atypical appearance. Health and physical fitness have a much larger impact on attractiveness for me and all this stuff just seems like a poor imitation of what it actually is to look healthy.
- mensetmanusman 6y agoThis was highly discussed on ‘unbox therapy’: https://youtu.be/Q3GGdtn9poo https://youtu.be/Q3GGdtn9poo
- dehrmann 6y agoIt sounds like this might have been a bug: https://www.theverge.com/2018/10/23/18011814/iphone-xs-beautygate-fixed-ios-12-1 https://www.theverge.com/2018/10/23/18011814/iphone-xs-beaut... > Essentially, Smart HDR was choosing the wrong base frame for HDR processing when you took a selfie. Instead of choosing a frame with a short shutter speed to freeze motion and preserve detail, it would sometimes choose a frame with longer shutter speed. The front camera also does not have optical image stabilization, so it takes blurrier shots at the same shutter speed as the rear, stabilized camera. The result is a loss of detail that looks like smoothing on the front camera.
- xattt 6y agoConspiracy perspective: beauty filters are affecting their ML training.
- Grazester 6y agoIf it only smooths over the skin then it would not affect it.
- jwblackwell 6y agoWhy is that?
- dirtnugget 6y agoFor anyone interested: watch "The Social Dilemma" on Netflix. They show stats on mental health and suicide and how they may be related to the introduction of the smartphone.
- troughway 6y agoWhat's the age/sex demographic of most of these suicides?
- dirtnugget 6y agoMostly young women. The documentary is worth a watch.
- troughway 6y agoI was just curious because I keep hearing how younger people are committing suicides but nobody wants to explicitly break out the statistics. As for the documentary, although friends have recommended I see it I am up to my neck in propaganda from every which way from news about this, a documentary about that, so-called expert said so-and-so, et cetera. Just the stupidity on HN is enough for me to call it a day sometimes. I'll sit this one out.
- dirtnugget 6y agoI found it interesting because they were interviewing former managers and engineers of google, facebook, twitter etc. They were not saying "This is the cause because X and Y.". Often they were not even able to formulate the "problem" with social media. Because it is not that black and white.
- searchableguy 6y agoBecause they aren't child psychologists and therapists who deal with actual cases?
- isabelc 6y ago>There are a few studies that show such functionality can have a negative effect on mental health, and as a result, Google is now turning them off by default on its own phones Google has all kinds of activity tracking enabled by default on Android phones. I wonder what impact that has on mental health.
- Jarwain 6y agoUnless you're someone who gets really anxious/paranoid about being tracked by a BigCo, I can't imagine it making an outsized impact. The weirdest thing might be how that activity tracking is used to try and sell stuff to you, and sometimes that advertising is pretty compelling as a result. But I'm not sure how that compares to the more active influence of "influences" and social media across the larger population.
- searchableguy 6y ago> Unless you're someone who gets really anxious/paranoid about being tracked by a BigCo, I can't imagine it making an outsized impact. I can't say anything with absolute numbers but subreddits such as privacy, privacytools, degoogle, minimalism, and alike places have seen massive growth in recent years and I regularly find people (especially teenagers) who are severely affected by this. So I wonder how long will it take google or any other tech companies to take an opt in approach to tracking.
- srtjstjsj 6y agoThe problem with advertising overlaps wkth the problem with social media -- harming people's self-image to pressure them into "retail therapy".
- astrobe_ 6y agoWhen you know you are being watched, your behavior changes, for better or worse [1] [2]. But it's true it is a bit different for BigCo. Not only they watch, they also have an active role by modifying what you see - e.g. the ads and news they display [3]. Does this qualify as "outsized impact" or do you want moar? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hawthorne_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hawthorne_effect [2] https://www.harvardmagazine.com/2017/01/the-watchers https://www.harvardmagazine.com/2017/01/the-watchers |3] https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2014/oct/02/facebook-sorry-secret-psychological-experiment-users https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2014/oct/02/facebook-...
- ncmncm 6y agoRetouching is Women's magazines' stock in trade. They actively seek to make women insecure about their appearance, and collect advertising from outfits that promise to correct it. One of the promoted tropes is that overspending on a putative remedy is giving yourself a treat, rather than giving the vendor a treat.
- esperent 6y agoI don't think magazines are at fault here. It's social media where most of these photos will end up and be judged.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 6y agoYou're giving them way too much credit. There's no strategem or design to hurt women's self esteem. They sell what people want to buy.
- dylan604 6y agoI think you have that backwards. They sell what they've made people want to buy with their advertising.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoPeople will always want to better themselves versus another, it’s part of the mating process. If it’s not appearance, something else will be used to signal rank.
- TheRealSteel 6y agoI'm furious at HTC and Samsung for ruining some of what would've been very precious photos I took with filters that they have on by default and don't tell you. There are some particular ones that were great moments that they absolutely destroyed, on purpose. Why would I want my phone's camera to deliberately change the shape of me and my friend's faces and replace our skin with porcelain?!
- cryptoz 6y agoI honestly never saw this coming. It's the craziest dystopia nobody talked about. Cameras aren't even cameras anymore! Are there some phones with camera-filters on, without the option for you to turn them off? Cameraphones need to make a comeback; you know, phones with cameras and not some sci-fi CGI BS. I don't trust anything coming from a smartphone camera now. Even my own phones. Maybe related: I've noticed on iPhones and Samsungs that I cannot get a picture to match reality. I feel like it was easier to get a picture with colors that closely matched reality YEARS ago. Why have cameras gone downhill? Or is it my imagination? When I take a photo of the grass and sky with any modern smartphone it never looks right. I try and try and try to adjust the settings and I can just never get a good photo anymore. Edit: Example: I couldn't take a picture of the smoke on the West coast recently. The dark grey and orange skies would all come out looking blue or something. It's like the 'camera' is telling me I'm f'ing crazy for taking a picture of smoky skies, and surely I want to pretend the smoke isn't there at all! That's why I'm taking a picture right? So I can pretend that reality isn't real. I have no photos that match the smoke. I have only my memory and other people's photos. WTF.
- snazz 6y ago> Edit: Example: I couldn't take a picture of the smoke on the West coast recently. The dark grey and orange skies would all come out looking blue or something. It's like the 'camera' is telling me I'm f'ing crazy for taking a picture of smoky skies, and surely I want to pretend the smoke isn't there at all! That's why I'm taking a picture right? So I can pretend that reality isn't real. I have no photos that match the smoke. I have only my memory and other people's photos. WTF. That's automatic white balance adjustment. It's not used to an orange sky, so it can't figure out what color should be considered "white". If you want an example of why this is important, turn off automatic WB and take a photo under fluorescent light followed by a photo lit by candles. I have no idea about Android phones, but iPhones do some amount of denoise, contrast adjustment, and a few other limited postprocessing steps automatically.
- neom 6y agoOriginal Blogpost: https://blog.google/outreach-initiatives/digital-wellbeing/more-controls-selfie-filters/ https://blog.google/outreach-initiatives/digital-wellbeing/m...
- dang 6y agoThanks. Changed from https://www.androidpolice.com/2020/10/02/google-says-beauty-filters-are-bad-for-your-mental-health-pixel-cameras-wont-use-them-by-default/ https://www.androidpolice.com/2020/10/02/google-says-beauty-.... We also changed the title from the clickbait of "Google says 'beauty' filters are bad for your mental health" and the bland corpspeak of "More controls and transparency for your selfies" to what appears to be a representative sentence from the article.
- akerro 6y agoI don't believe in Google being interested in our mental health. Can this be because "filtered" photos make our faces harder to recognise by their AI and produce higher false positive?
- scarmig 6y agoAn interesting conundrum: if some apps automatically apply beauty filters and others don't, over time the ones that do could outcompete those that don't, even if it's to society's collective detriment. "The default camera on the Pixel is so bad, I always look so ugly in it!"
- Jabbles 6y agoA Google Play policy that enforces this in other apps would be the next step.
- michaelbuckbee 6y agoThis has happened in the fashion industry where there is size "inflation" as sizes don't correspond to physical measurements. Size 5 in Brand A is tight so consumers prefer Brand B who has size 5 clothes that fit better.
- crooked-v 6y agoThis kind of thing is why I'm happy that mens' clothes often use actual inch measurements rather than abstract 'sizes'.
- humbledrone 6y agoAt least for popular brands of jeans, the "inch" measurements have succumbed to the exact same nonsense: https://www.esquire.com/style/mens-fashion/a8386/pants-size-chart-090710/ https://www.esquire.com/style/mens-fashion/a8386/pants-size-...
- dane-pgp 6y agoThat article was written in 2010, but I can't help agreeing with its conclusion: "But vanity waist sizing is so entrenched, it couldn't possibly be changed overnight, at least not without a government mandate. The only solution seems to be a gradual, year-by-year shaving of quarter-inch by quarter-inch until, in 2021, men's pants finally correspond with the label numbers — conveniently just in time for the New World Order's switch to mandatory full jumpsuits." That sounds terrible, but it could still be an improvement over 2020.
- NE2z2T9qi 6y agoHonestly, the premise seems exactly backward to me. I remember taking a selfie of myself on two different phones to compare their forward-facing cameras. The image quality on both was roughly the same, but one had subtle skin smoothing and lighting adjustments, the other one didn't. The one with "beauty filters" generally matched what I assumed I looked like to other people. The one without the "beauty filters" made me look much worse than my own mental picture of myself. I'm sure the one without beauty filters was more accurate, but it made me more self-conscious about my appearance and kinda made me realize "shoot, I'm actually uglier than I thought", and that bummed me out. It certainly didn't help my self-esteem or self-confidence! I rather suspect that subtle automatic retouching would actually be good for one's mental health.
- xwdv 6y agoBeauty in general is bad for people’s mental health, the only difference is that filters and retouching create beauty at scale. People can still encounter beauty in real life and despair that they will never attain that. I find that people say retouched or filtered photos are not “real life”, but I’ve definitely seen people in real life who are just as attractive as any person that uses a filter. It can definitely be “real life”, but encountering these people is rare enough that people assume that level of perfection cannot possibly exist. In reality it just doesn’t exist at the frequency in which filtered images would have you believe.
- srtjstjsj 6y agoSo everyone will turn on the "value-free" (yet for some reason worth building) options.
- kennywinker 6y agoYeah "value-free" seems pretty laughable. We're "retouching" your face to make it look different, not better? Not credible. By using code words, all they're doing is avoiding blame for the harm they are doing.
- fortran77 6y agoSuggestion: Let's mandate filters that make everyone equally ugly, so nobody feels bad or pressured by beauty standards.
- surround 6y agoLike Harrison Bergeron?
- Smithalicious 6y agoI'd like to submit a bug report; it's not working, my face still looks the same!
- shalmanese 6y agoFun anecdote: When Alipay originally rolled out its "Pay by face" feature in stores, the uptake was far below their expectations. They did some research and realized that Chinese customers were so used to seeing their face with a beauty filter applied that the image of their unbeautified face was disconcerting and they avoided using face verification. Alipay rolled out automatic face beautification and their usage shot up. https://qz.com/1657653/alipay-to-add-beauty-filters-to-facial-recognition-payment/ https://qz.com/1657653/alipay-to-add-beauty-filters-to-facia...
- sundarurfriend 6y agoThe article doesn't say anything about usage shooting up after the change. To me it sounds equally plausible that this was a publicity move to get people curious about this "better than a beauty camera" feature and just use that as an opportunity to get the face-pay feature into the news.
- shalmanese 6y agoI heard about the usage going up from a PM at Alibaba.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- rland 6y agoThis discussion reminds me of a short story, Liking What You See: A Documentary by Ted Chiang (same guy who wrote the plot of the movie Arrival). There might be a pdf floating around on the internet, it's a 20 min read. Basically, it's about a reversible procedure called "calli" that turns off the neurological response to symmetry, smoothness, and "aesthetic" of a human face. So someone with the procedure can recognize different faces, but they don't feel any better about a pretty face than an ugly one. The story follows a girl who had calli done as a young child, and then decided to go to college with it turned off. When she's there, there's a push on campus to mandate the procedure, to combat "lookism." The story is written like a documentary film, so it has little snippets of interviews, news articles, etc. about the debate. The range of emotions we get from looking at other people's faces is intrinsically worth saving. But, people get a huge advantage from being good-looking. It's effectively discrimination to consider people who are good looking more trustworthy, nicer, etc, yet all of us do -- it's hard wired. The world is not really fair to someone with a bad looking face. These apps aren't calli but they do mediate how we see the world, ourselves, and others to a huge degree. I don't envy any middle school girl who has to navigate this landscape. Anyway, I highly recommend the story, it was such an interesting way of looking at the issue.
- ColanR 6y ago> there's a push on campus to mandate the procedure, to combat "lookism." That sounds incredibly dystopian.
- Aeolun 6y agoNot once everyone has it done automatically and society accepts it. It’ll be something like a vaccine against the measles.
- monadic2 6y agoGiven that it's a work of fiction, it's literally dystopian!
- rland 6y agoJust to play devil's advocate: I mean, yes, this hypothetical procedure does sound dystopian on its face (haha). But then again, imagine if you just judged people by how nice they actually were, not by what their face looked like? Imagine if you were evaluated by the merits of your mind, of you, not the 'flawed' representation of you (your face) given to you by your DNA? I've been helped enormously in almost every area of my life by the way I look and how I'm able to present myself physically. Much of that is because of my DNA -- something I didn't work for or ask for. It was given to me for free. Likewise, others are deprived through no fault of their own. Of course, that's the way it is. I like being attractive and having attractive friends and romantic partners. But what if it didn't matter? Would my life be richer?
- Camillo 6y agoOne problem is that selfies have an inherent uglification effect due to the short distance from the lens. Unretouched selfies actually look _worse_ than what you look like to other people. That's one big reason why mirror selfies are popular: the additional optical distance due to the mirror reduces the geometric distortion. (The other big reason is that bathrooms somehow tend to have excellent lighting.)
- sp332 6y agoIt's nice to have a filter. It feels like you're not being so vulnerable when posting your face. Maybe I want to send my Instagram followers a smile without sending a perfect likeness of myself, you know? They don't need to know how much sleep I've been getting or the last time I scrubbed out my pores.
- 627467 6y agoI'm actually amazed (maybe I shouldn't) that face retouch became so universal in most (all?) contemporary smartphones with seemingly no ethical considerations. How could the likes as samsung switch this feature on by default like it was some minor optimization? How many customers did you gain because you didn't require them to turn a switch on? Was it worth it?
- Aeolun 6y agoWhy are you amazed? If all professional photos are retouched, then this is the standard that people will hold themselves to, and their pictures seem nasty by comparison. When you turn on automatic retouching, everyone suddenly feels like they take professional/promotional quality pictures.
- monadic2 6y agoWhat is a "nasty" photo? One that looks like it's not staged to hell?
- Camillo 6y ago> We set out to better understand the effect filtered selfies might have on people’s wellbeing—especially when filters are on by default. We conducted multiple studies and spoke with child and mental health experts from around the world, and found that when you’re not aware that a camera or photo app has applied a filter, the photos can negatively impact mental wellbeing. These default filters can quietly set a beauty standard that some people compare themselves against. Hm, I find myself unable to say whether I agree or not. I would say I am 70% confident that these filters can negatively affect people's wellbeing (based on my intuition/bias), and 15% confident that we can get a scientifically valid answer to that question (based on the track record of social psychology and related disciplines).
- userbinator 6y agoI wonder how many others also find "retouched" photos have a bit creepy, almost uncanny-valley quality to them, especially those of people we've seen in reality with our own eyes. I've also heard stories of others buying a recent camera, and seeing there was something subtly off about the faces in the pictures it created, later finding out there was a "face beauty" option that was on by default.
- vl 6y agoArgument presented in article about filters and re-touching is mostly self-contradictory: image from modern camera is heavily processed anyway. Anything from color balance, lens distortion to edge enchantment and smoothing is corrected in software/firmware. I.e. any modern smartphone camera is firmly in computation photography territory - what comes out is not what sensor “sees” anyway. So a question of additional filter being on by default is really a matter of preference, because so many filters are already on anyway.
- dehrmann 6y agoIt's definitely creepy. What's weird is that you can repair minor blemishes in Photoshop and it's incredibly hard to tell, but these filters do so much more processing than using the healing brush on 2% of a face.
- AuryGlenz 6y agoI spend a good portion of my days retouching portraits in Photoshop. Most of the filters do things I’d never imagine doing to a client’s face, like making eyes bigger. Most of what they do is smooth out the skin to a ridiculous extent. My way takes 10 minutes vs. an app taking a millisecond, but that’s all in the name of making the image look flawless without looking retouched.
- megous 6y agoWhy take selfies at all?
- mlindner 6y agoIndeed. I don't understand it. The only time I take photos of myself is when I use it in place of a simple mirror. (For example taking a look at the skin in some part of my body I can't physically look at normally (my back for example).
- identity0 6y agoThis seems like saving Android's brand by Google. I don't know about anyone else, but the on-by-default face retouch on my old samsung phone looks horrible. It makes my face look like melted plastic and makes the lens extremely blurry. A Samsung camera could have a million megapixels or whatever and it would still look like crap because of the filter, and it makes it seem like all android phones have garbage front cameras.
- perryizgr8 6y agoWhy? Google's pixel line of phones uses incredible AI/ML techniques to improve low-light photography. They even suggested in a blog post that they are using their trained models to infer color and detail information which is simply not present in the raw sensor data. So retouching is totally fine if google does it. But how dare Korean and Chinese manufacturers (who are targeting a certain market) use the same techniques on faces?!?! The hypocrisy is strong with this one.
- SimonPStevens 6y agoSurely the real problem here is not when face retouching filters are on or off by default for your own photos. It's when other people use them and you don't know if they have them on or off. That's what quietly sets the new beauty standed because everyone sees these retouched photos and assumes they are representative of reality. What I'd like to see is something in the image metadata that stores what filters were used so apps could display that info. I can't see that happening though.