12 ms·
This isn't a matter simply for the young. The young are definitely hit harder, but the real issue is that "work" is not valued as it once was. The 'economy' i
by sandworm101 6y ago
This isn't a matter simply for the young. The young are definitely hit harder, but the real issue is that "work" is not valued as it once was. The 'economy' is doing great. Stocks go ever higher despite pandemics and money trends. Taxes are low. Luxury spending is at an all time high. Investors, be them wealthy independants or pensioned former workers, are generally happy. Young people own nothing and so the bulk of their income must come through wages rather than investments. It is those workers, those who don't own their sources of income, that are struggling to make rent.
- iagovar 6y agoAverage account balance before the pandemic was 3K for <30yo in Spain. I heard it was even less in the US. That has a lot of implications, and none of them good IMO.
- swiley 6y agoIn most countries holding cache is a net loss due to low interest rates so that's not necessarily a good argument.
- tafox 6y agoYes it is. That 3K is the average young person's only asset and it is just getting eaten by inflation anyway. These people struggle to pay rent each month let alone think about "investments".
- yelloweyes 6y ago????????????????? Sure you will lose a little bit, like 2 or 3% a year. But if you have nothing saved then what will you do in case of an emergency? such as losing a job?
- cpursley 6y ago29.99% interest credit cards.
- reallydontask 6y agoThere is the idea of having an emergency fund, which given its nature, should be stored in an instant access savings accounts. This is money for when you lose your job for instance Your appetite for risks and circumstances determine how big it should be (a good rule of thumb is six months worth of salary) but there are countless stories of people trying to be clever with their emergency funds and storing them in ETFs or riskier investments only to find that when the need comes, their fund is not enough and get in financial distress.
- jcalvinowens 6y agoIf you're a US citizen, "I Series Savings Bonds" are fantastic emergency fund vehicles. You can cash them out instantly after holding them only one year, mine are paying just under 2% right now.
- conceptme 6y agoBut is that everybody under 30? Makes much more sense to measure 25 - 30. As most will start to have a real job by that age.
- Shared404 6y agoI would track 18-30, as that catches those who are likely to be living independently.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoAnd it lumps them in with those who are likely still in school and have no real job yet thereby making it basically impossible to draw (useful) conclusions about independent young people.
- Shared404 6y ago> And it lumps them in with those who are likely still in school I won't argue that one, but where do you draw the line with > have no real job yet I would argue that as long as you are working, you have a real job. Probably the best would be to track both 25-30 and 18-30 and see how it changes.
- throwaway0a5e 6y ago>I would argue that as long as you are working, you have a real job. If you're working nights in a warehouse while you finish your degree that will get you into an industry with nearly six figure starting salaries then I would argue that you're not "working yet" you're just a student with income.
- Shared404 6y agoWhat does salary have to do if somethings a "real job"? Or what about blue collar workers who aren't going to school, and are at that same warehouse? Are they not working at a real job?
- entropea 6y ago60% couldn't afford a $1000 emergency in USA, in 2019. $3k? Probably a lot higher number. https://www.cnbc.com/2019/01/23/most-americans-dont-have-the-savings-to-cover-a-1000-emergency.html https://www.cnbc.com/2019/01/23/most-americans-dont-have-the...
- cryptica 6y agoIt's not just that 'work' is not valued. The problem is that 'value creation' is not valued (particularly in the tech sector). There are plenty of highly paid bullshit jobs. Tech corporations are essentially empty shells; their market caps are not based on the value that they create for society but on the rate of money printing by the reserve banks of the world. Because tech corporations are not subjected to free market forces like everybody else, they eventually lose their ability to create new value (and the kinds of people who join these companies and stay there do not have a value creator mindset). Indeed, if you compare the price of S&P500 companies relative to most stable-value commodities such as gold, it would seem that the S&P500 hasn't grown at all in the last 5 years. However, S&P500 correlates strongly with the growth in M1 and M2 money supply. This indicates that the growth in nominal price of stocks in the past 5 years is entirely artificial. Young tech workers cannot compete with corporations because the playing field is not even. If your competitor is getting free money from someone, how can you possibly compete with them in any market? This is why all young people in tech these days are eventually absorbed into corporations. Whether through employment or phony acqui-hire. It's also why big corporations like Google used to buy up startups and then kill the project immediately afterwards. It's mostly phony money transfer with hidden motives and it's not related to value creation.
- cryptica 6y agoBTW, the main reason why this is getting downvoted is because the wealthiest investors already know all this and many of them read HN... They think they can keep manipulating the economy forever to keep their stock prices up through money printing and they want to suppress this information because they don't want shareholders to realize it and dump the stock before they do. There is tremendous peer pressure right now to suppress this kind of content for insiders and employees to not sell their shares... But the bad news for these people is that the last people to sell their stocks are going to lose and it's a very fragile situation. It wouldn't take many employees to dump to cause a stock market crash now. Usually employees and small shareholders are the losers. If you look at who is buying Bitcoin now, it's MicroStrategy, Greylock partners and A16z (smart money)... Many are also moving into gold and silver. Do you seriously think that the rank and file corporate bureaucrat/employee who's been sitting through useless meetings every day for 10 years is worth the $2 to $10 million in corporate stocks that they own? Did they deliver that kind of value to society? No. If I owned corporate stocks worth even $100K and the bosses kept discouraging selling of stocks by employees, I would sell everything right now and change companies. You will never see such good valuation again. As always, the first to jump on the new trend always win and it's always going to be the smallest group possible. The majority always loses.
- Ericson2314 6y ago> The real issue is that "work" is not valued as it once was. And the work indeed is more bullshit than it used to be! I'm afraid we cannot turn back the clock on this one, so we have to find another way. eyes UBI
- burlesona 6y agoI don’t disagree with you about UBI, but I have to say it makes me feel sad. In my experience most people really want meaningful work, and the fact that it puts food on the table makes a lot of otherwise meh work more satisfying and meaningful. At the end of the day it’s more important that people can meet their needs, and if UBI does that, a lot of people will be able to improvise some interesting things to apply themselves to, which I think will be great for them. But a lot of people will also sit on the couch and watch TV all day, feeling there’s no point to life. We’ll have all kinds of new and unforseeable second order effects. I also worry that the fundamental problem is not so much income but cost of living. The way things work today, any amount of UBI that you pay but just drive up the rent. If we don’t significantly increase housing supplies to meet demand, I don’t see how we can break that loop.
- Ericson2314 6y ago> I don’t disagree with you about UBI, but I have to say it makes me feel sad. In my experience most people really want meaningful work, and the fact that it puts food on the table makes a lot of otherwise meh work more satisfying and meaningful. I think the remaining work will be such more meaningful that it will be net dealienation. I think less stress and more free time begets curiosity, so I think it's fair to say people could get a lot out of work than they do from their current drudgery. In the long term, think large amounts of leisure time but ones does "tours of duty" in each of the core industries that power modern society as part of liberal education of how society functions. > I also worry that the fundamental problem is not so much income but cost of living. The way things work today, any amount of UBI that you pay but just drive up the rent. If we don’t significantly increase housing supplies to meet demand, I don’t see how we can break that loop. See https://phenomenalworld.org/analysis/universal-basic-income-the-city https://phenomenalworld.org/analysis/universal-basic-income-... for the results of some modeling. Rent in absolute terms and as a portion of income went down!
- netcan 6y agoAn aspect of this, in much of the west, is political demography. The voting population is getting older all the time. Politics increasingly serves their interests. Often these are directly orthogonal. Labour vs capital. Real estate values vs housing costs. Opportunity vs stability. Even this pandemic, sadly, creates opposing interests. Younger people need workplaces to operate. Older people are more susceptible to the virus. Since the stock markets are fine, retired people don't generally have financial interests at stake.
- C1sc0cat 6y agoMY ISA and Pension Funds are still down from where they where pre covid. 25 % of people in the uk have < 1k in savings
- fxtentacle 6y agoGood work is still highly valued, it's just that the value is not paid to the worker, but to the company owning the work. If you increase a company's profit by $500k annually through setting up a new automation system, you'll still only get your $40k internship salary. And the company will pocket the remaining $460k, to be paid out to the owners as profits. So yes, I fully agree with you. This hits the young people the hardest because they are the ones to own the least, on average. But more in general, everyone who is not part of the elite owning those companies and their preferred stocks is suffering. It's almost a cliche "owners vs. workers" class war at this point. But for some reason, everyone in the US expects to enter the owning elite within years - no matter how ridiculously improbable that is - so nobody is willing to stand up for the workers.
- lordnacho 6y agoThis is not far from the true numbers. I've known several management consultants - the young, educated hustlers who are on their first job - who discovered from their clients what the bill actually was. Ratios of 6+ are common.
- JAlexoid 6y agoI worked with enough consultants to now that the good ones subsidize the salary of the bad ones.
- AlexTWithBeard 6y ago> the company will pocket the remaining $460k First, in most companies it's very hard to say who exactly managed to increase the profit. Is it you who came up with the idea? Is it your boss who picked this specific idea out of fifty other ideas you came up with last week? Is it the QA team who managed to catch the bug which would've erased all the profits? Is it HR who hired you among other candidates? Second, no, the remaining is not $460k. In a Big Greedy Corporation I work an average annual cost of employee in "primary" location is around $200k (pre-covid). It includes office space, technology, infrastructure, salary, taxes, fees, insurances and so on. Third, that's the premium the company gets for the risk. Intern will get his salary no matter what. The company makes a bet though. You want to own part of that risk? Build your own company.
- pehtis 6y ago> It is those workers, those who don't own their sources of income, that are struggling to make rent. That is exactly how social classes are distinguished in Marxism: "[T]he class of modern wage labourers who, having no means of production of their own, are reduced to selling their labour power in order to live" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marxism#Social_classes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marxism#Social_classes
- animal_spirits 6y ago> "Young people own nothing" I wouldn't say that. I am 24 and I have some pretty incredible tools in my pocket right now that someone in 1991 couldn't have even dreamed of. The problem is, instead of owning a good car or having an apartment to live in, I have the pinnacle-of-technology swiss-army knife of information processors (smart phone, macbook pro, desktop computer) within reach. That is where I think the value of things have changed over time. It went from the opportunity to _have_ to the opportunity to _learn_
- tehjoker 6y agoIn more marxist terms, we have traded variation of consumer goods for precarity in our ability to live our lives. You can play video games, but your boss can fire you at a whim and your landlord can kick you on the street. You can't become class mobile without taking on huge debts and possibly not making it.
- pram 6y agoYou could still learn stuff in 1991 jfyi
- animal_spirits 6y agoOh yes of course but its way way way easier today with magnitudes more subjects covered in depth
- tspike 6y agoThe rewards for finding the information needed to learn were geometrically higher relative to the difficulty. It's easier to learn today; the (monetary) value of that learning is lower.
- cwbrandsma 6y agoFinding the information was harder. There were libraries, my town library was in the basement of the city hall building, and my local mechanic has a larger building. If the library didn’t have it, you could hit a small book store, whose specialty was romance novels for local farm wives. Basically, anything you would actually want would be special order, hoping the book dealer knew what you were talking about in the first place.
- dustingetz 6y agoUS stocks are up because the federal government is buying stocks (illegally) for the first time in history
- mc10 6y agoCurious, in what way is the Fed’s bond purchasing program illegal?
- anovikov 6y agoAbsolutely vast majority of income of everyone apart from billionaires/top 0.01%, comes from work rather than investments... Yes even for top 1% apart from top 0.1%, share of income from investments is negligible. Total value of U.S. stock market is $35T and given the traditional 4% "safe" withdrawal formula, it is about 7% of GDP or 10% of overall income, as profits. About half of it going to the top 0.01%. Problem maybe is that there are no highly paid jobs available for unqualified young people anymore.
- mythrwy 6y agoAgreed. And this is a good part of the "real" grievance of both young people and working class minorities, especially in big cities in my opinion. It's not working class wages haven't risen, they have. But, the costs of housing, healthcare, education and many other necessities have risen at a much faster pace, particularly in cities. These rises in cost are of course profits to someone so the economy is "booming. But it's become so distorted that it's becoming increasingly hard to keep up for the lower wage earners with no end in site. Of course the owners of assets don't see the problem. Their properties and stocks are appreciating nicely. And the fed has been encouraging this. Now, one argument might be that if this wasn't occurring that low wage earners would be even worse off with no jobs and and there may be some validity to that point of view but the inequality of this isn't just an abstract ethical problem at this point but rather a system threatening problem. I don't know that there is an easy fix either. It often seems trying to fix one problem with rent controls, wage floors, progressive taxation etc. results in other problems. But the increase in costs of housing, medical care etc. while wages grow at a much slower rate isn't sustainable imo.
- neilparikh 6y agoThe solution is to tax the unproductive part of society, which only extracts wealth from everyone else: landowners. This allows us to shift the burden away from labour.