8 ms·
The things that stand out to me about Japan: * 3rd largest economy. * 11th largest population (top 10 until recently, they basically tie with Mexico). * If y
by roenxi 6y ago
The things that stand out to me about Japan:
* 3rd largest economy.
* 11th largest population (top 10 until recently, they basically tie with Mexico).
* If you look at a table of countries by area, they are there. Even in the top half, thanks to places like Tuvalu.
I think there is a very strong on-the-face-of-it argument that they just have too many people and not enough for them to do, economically speaking. If they could drop their population and keep the economy about the same (and if they have so many dead-end jobs and so few opportunities, they could) then they would be both a wealthy country and absurdly wealthy on a personal level.
- brazzy 6y agoThat's not how economy works. There is no such thing in general as "too many people for the economy". "The economy" is the sum of goods and services produced and consumed. Everyone who lives consumes, and could easily consume more. The economy is generally limited by the ability to produce, and is generally limited by the number of working-age people to do the producing. Unemployment can be result of production being bottlenecked by something else: * raw materials - but Japan never had an abundance of those even when their economy looked like it would dominate the world in the 80s * education - but the people the article talks about have university degrees * capital - again not something Japan lacks So it's not one of those. I submit that it's organization - the Japanese society and economy is extremely rigid and maintains some egregious inefficiencies in the labor market, simply because it's always been done that way. Companies would rather hire a new 22 year old graduate at full pay than give a 30 year old with an even better degree a chance at a 30% discount, not out of concerns over the 30 year old's skills being outdated but simply because hiring new graduates is what you do. They'll hire non-graduates only on temporary contracts when short of workers, but never in a million years consider promoting them and converting them to regular employees, no matter how good they are.
- sprash 6y agoThat is exactly how the economy works. Demand and supply. Oversupply in labor results directly in diminishing incomes and the ability of employers to be extremely picky about who to hire (e.g. like you said nobody over 30).
- brazzy 6y agoWrong because every person who supplies labor also generates demand for goods and services, which generates demand for labor. Simply "removing" unemployed people would not in fact fix the oversupply of labor. I also explained that the problem is not just that employers are picky because of an oversupply, they are picky in ways that are actually not really in their own interest and which contribute to the oversupply problem.
- sprash 6y agoWrong. Additional demand beyond bare necessities is only generated if there is disposable income available which is not the case when there is a oversupply of labor driving down wages. If employers would act systematically against their own interest by hiring only young people it would be easy for investors to come in eliminate them in the market. But they won't because they can't. Employers prefer young people because they are cheap and they hire them because they can.
- brazzy 6y agoOh boy. The bare necessities of someone is already "additional demand" over that person not being present. Disposable income is a completely irrelevant factor here. In fact, disposable income is the part that doesn't generate the same level of economic demand because it can be saved rather than spent. And no, it is not easy for investors to outcompete incumbents simply by being more efficient with their employment policies, especially not in a society like Japan. And my point is that employers are not hiring older people even though they could pay them less.
- roenxi 6y ago> There is no such thing in general as "too many people for the economy". Sure there is. If nothing else, at some point you have more people than can be physically fed with the available land. Each additional person uses up a certain amount of resources. If the marginal resource gain of adding another worker is smaller than that; then economically there are too many people. There is no principle saying that cannot happen.
- brazzy 6y agoI did explicitly explain that the economy can be bottlenecked on other things (which is where that "in general" comes from) and why the one that seems to apply in the case of Japan has nothing to do with there being too many people.
- chii 6y ago> If nothing else, at some point you have more people than can be physically fed with the available land. The malthusian argument has been used since the old ages to argue for fewer people because of resource shortages (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malthusianism#Modern_Malthusianism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malthusianism#Modern_Malthusia...). It has not eventuated. The more people there are, the more minds there are at looking for solutions to problems, the more able the human race will be. But of course, these people need investment to obtain benefit - they can't just be empty mouths to feed.
- roenxi 6y agoWhat is the argument there, that I can't point to Japan as an example of Malthusianism because you don't believe in Malthusianism? There is a physical limit somewhere. Just because we didn't find it in the last hundred years doesn't mean we won't in the future. Real growth in % terms eventually stops because it hits a physical limit; that isn't a controversial idea. It is almost too obvious to state. Humanity can't maintain 1% Year-on-year growth in crop yield indefinitely. At some point; the improvements stop. The longer the improvements have been going on for the more likely it is they will stop.
- 6y ago
- nipponese 6y agoLike others having lived there for a short period of time, I agree with this observation. The cultural premium on risk, that may merely inconvenience someone, is unreasonably high (by my standard, anyway). Ever have to pay a bribe to a landlord to rent an apartment as a matter of accepted business protocol? Look up "reikin". Then you'll realize why some think it's totally reasonable to live out of an internet cafe.
- gfxgirl 6y agoIt's not a bribe. That's your negative spin. The positive spin is it's just 2/26th pre-payment of the rent for 2 years. You then pay 1/26th every month for 2 years, repeat when you renew your contract. Do I like having to pay 2/26th up front (2 months rent?) no. But I also would prefer not to have to put down payments on cars/houses.
- brazzy 6y agoIf it truly were a pre-payment, it would be partially refunded when the rental contract terminates early.
- tasogare 6y agoYou are wrong. Those fees are added to the normal rent, they are not part of it. I choose my current appartment in part because there was no additional "gift money" to pay. Each time one moves place those have to be paid, which makes moving quite costly.
- asdasdasdas5453 6y agoOn HN when people discuss CS/privacy/programming the conversation is very thorough and interesting. When the discussion is about economics (the topic I have studied at uni) most comments are just plain wrong and show a complete ignorance about the topic. If one wants a counter argument to "too many people for the economy" one can start here : https://www.jstor.org/stable/2523702?seq=1 https://www.jstor.org/stable/2523702?seq=1 "Using data from the Current Population Survey, this paper describes the effect of the Mariel Boatlift of 1980 on the Miami labor market. The Mariel immigrants increased the Miami labor force by 7%, and the percentage increase in labor supply to less-skilled occupations and industries was even greater because most of the immigrants were relatively unskilled. Nevertheless, the Mariel influx appears to have had virtually no effect on the wages or unemployment rates of less-skilled workers, even among Cubans who had immigrated earlier. The author suggests that the ability of Miami's labor market to rapidly absorb the Mariel immigrants was largely owing to its adjustment to other large waves of immigrants in the two decades before the Mariel Boatlift." There are many causes explaining unemployment some due to macroeconomic factors such as the monetary policy, others due to regulations of the labor market, others due to the lack of innovation, ..... They have been studied in depth. But "too many people for the economy" is not one of them.
- eru 6y ago> If one wants a counter argument to "too many people for the economy" one can start here : https://www.jstor.org/stable/2523702?seq=1 https://www.jstor.org/stable/2523702?seq=1 Or you can just point out that, well, if there are too many people, just (virtually) split the country down the middle: voila, fewer people in the country. A more sophisticated argument brings up density. But it's usually the sparsely populated parts of a country that are poorer.
- teawrecks 6y agoAh the "snap" strategy.
- squaresmile 6y ago> When the discussion is about economics (the topic I have studied at uni) most comments are just plain wrong and show a complete ignorance about the topic. I think curating a discussion board to have knowledgeable discussion about many things is a really hard task. On many professional boards, discussions about other subjects are put into an OT corner. HN doesn't split discussions into topics so I guess expectation of comments' quality carries over. I would just make a mental note: Oh this is not about CS/privacy/programming and adjust accordingly. I suppose it's one of the reasons one should acquaint themselves with people from a variety of backgrounds and don't run away when others are not as knowledgeable about CS/privacy/programming. Actually
- dustingetz 6y agoEconomies not only produce, they also take. For example, two free people could engage in free trade where one is holding a gun and the other voluntarily gives up their wallet. At scale we call that a Trade Agreement.
- saagarjha 6y agoI'm unsure where you're going with this comment?
- dustingetz 6y agoI'm saying an empire's wealth in large part is a function of it's military - in modern times, that would be the USA aircraft carriers parked off the persian gulf and china https://news.usni.org/category/fleet-tracker https://news.usni.org/category/fleet-tracker
- tonyedgecombe 6y ago>That's not how economy works. >There is no such thing in general as "too many people for the economy". I think you have it wrong as well. The size of the economy doesn't really matter. We don't say Norway isn't viable because its size is only a fifth of that of the UK. There is no point in doubling the size of the population to make the economy twice as big when each person is no better off. Especially when we are increasingly bumping up against ecological limits.
- mschuster91 6y ago> I think there is a very strong on-the-face-of-it argument that they just have too many people and not enough for them to do, economically speaking. Japan's greatest problem is that they have a geriatric population, coupled with low fertility rates, and an extremely unhealthy work ethic/culture. But, as usual with demographic stuff, the nasty effects won't really appear visible for decades - and by then it may very well be too late.
- seniorivn 6y agowhat a ridiculous assumption that there could be too many people and not enough for them to do. in the last decade japanees workforce grew despite overall population decline/getting old. mainly due to women participation increase. If there was not enough to do it wouldn't be possible. almost all on-the-face-of-it arguments are oversimplification of largely complex issues. Sadly most(all of them?) government interventions are done by politicians on the basis of such arguments...
- LatteLazy 6y agoPeople here are disagreeing with you, but I actually think you're exactly right about most modern economies: too many people and too few jobs leads to all sorts of social issues from wealth inequality to excessive hours to crazy house prices.
- op03 6y agoHave you head of the Plant Kingdom? They just stand around doing nothing the whole day.
- paganel 6y agoSo Malthus was in a sense right, as the “too many people” issue has showed up constantly since he wrote his stuff. And before anyone comes and tells me that “he was wrong because the Earth can sustain 8-9 billion humans, like it does right now”, I’ll say that there’s no way Earth’s actual ecosystem can sustain a major part of that population regularly eating beef, or regularly flying, or having scattered individual houses instead of buildings with tens or more flats each etc.
- ben_w 6y agoMalthus’ argument fits your later points, but not why a sub-population is experiencing unemployment. Unlike food, jobs don’t grow on trees.
- primroot 6y agoI'd say this is effectively the opposite of Malthus, since too much food (or rather too many products in general) kills jobs, and more fundamentally, kills the ability to earn rent from investments.
- ben_w 6y agoI don’t think that’s how economies work, but I accept I am likely to have a very flawed understanding of the field. More people means more potential consumers, surely? So the only way there could be “too many people” is if the market is dominated by goods which have a high one-off cost and trivial per-unit costs, such as software or other digital goods?
- mathattack 6y agoTheir population will drop. Each couple only has something like 1.2 kids. Lack of people to pay down their debts will be the long term problem.
- tonyedgecombe 6y agoMost of the debt is held by the Japanese themselves. They control their own currency. It isn't likely to be a problem for them.
- mathattack 6y agoEven still, the debt is held by people who eventually expect to use it to find their retirements. They can avoid external driven shocks, but at some point a smaller population can’t produce enough care for a larger one. That will play out in the debt markets, either with defaults or inflation.
- smabie 6y agoThe BOJ has been trying to raise inflation for like 30 years now and has epically failed. Inflation will not be the problem. The velocity of money in Japan is criminally low.
- cryptica 6y agoIt is going to be a problem because in an inflationary monetary system, you need to give out loans at a constantly increasing rate in order to pay off the debt of the previous generation. If the new generation is not growing fast enough, they will not be able to afford to take out enough new debt to buy assets from the previous generation (thus allowing the previous generation to pay of their debts from the sale or lease of real estate), then prices could crash quickly when the previous generation starts defaulting on their loans. It's also why real estate prices are so high in Japan. The older generation needs to squeeze out as much as they can from each member of the younger generation since there are so few of them in numbers.
- 6y ago
- hindsightbias 6y agoI watch NHK US a bit. Every night they have some show with a westerner riding some train line or riding a bike around and the landscape - which is pretty thin on people. Train lines manned by retired workers just to keep them going. Cyclist stops at at famous peach or strawberry orchards and there is some 90 year old on their knees weeding, kids are all in the city. Of course, it will all become industrial agro-farming once they're gone, but is that the best cultural, social, economic solution? It reminds me of western Ireland. Hiking around for hours through the country and not seeing a living soul. Expensive (holiday I assume) houses with slate roofs on a couple of hectares and empty.
- cco 6y agoThis sounds interesting, I'd love to watch it, could you link to one of those videos? I see lots of video results for NHK US, but a lot don't seem to be of the type that you're talking about.
- legerdemain 6y agoNHK is just a national broadcaster, like NBC in the US. I assume the grandparent means semi-promotional documentaries about the Japanese countryside, like this.[1] [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s6yhndEdqrI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s6yhndEdqrI
- hindsightbias 6y agoYT has mostly clips, not the full shows. These are broadcast on HDTV and probably some cable markets. Cycling shows: https://www3.nhk.or.jp/nhkworld/en/tv/cycle/ https://www3.nhk.or.jp/nhkworld/en/tv/cycle/ Train: https://www3.nhk.or.jp/nhkworld/en/tv/japanrailway/ https://www3.nhk.or.jp/nhkworld/en/tv/japanrailway/ The best series is Document 72 Hours: https://www3.nhk.or.jp/nhkworld/en/tv/72hours/ https://www3.nhk.or.jp/nhkworld/en/tv/72hours/ Some can be seen on demand, others, they’ll give a repeat date. These are fascinating, and be warned, they can swing from happy to gut wrenching. There’s one episode where they’re in a Home Center talking to kids about their projects and the next they’re talking to a guy about kitchen tiles. He talks about his wife always wanting a new kitchen, but he was always too busy... and now she’s dead. So he’s working on the kitchen in her memory. It’s an introspection on a society that is fraying at the edges. The producers seem to be trying to communicate that. As Krugman says, if you want to know our future, look to Japan.
- prichino 6y agoI love how you are exposing the cognitive dissonance between too many people for the economy/world and immigrants do not depress wages. How can someone hold these two views simultaneously are they not the same, just at a different scale?
- Animats 6y agoThe population of Japan is shrinking. A lot. The population peaked in 2011 and is down about 2 million since then. Outside of Tokyo, Osaka, and Nagoya, Japan is emptying out. Japan does not have too many people. India, though...
- sumedh 6y agoIndia's birth rate has been deceasing for 30 years now.