11 ms·
This is why Warren’s plan included a provision that doesn’t allow a company that runs a marketplace to also participate in said marketplace. Edit: Since a lot
by jedberg 6y ago
This is why Warren’s plan included a provision that doesn’t allow a company that runs a marketplace to also participate in said marketplace.
Edit: Since a lot of people aren’t familiar with the details, the plan only kicks in once the company reaches 25 billion in revenue.
- latortuga 6y agoHow does this work for B&M companies? Think Walgreens or Target. They have plenty of in-house brands and also major 3rd party brands. Are they allowed to continue having in-house brands?
- ocdtrekkie 6y agoI don't think anything good would be lost if store brands went away as an anti-monopoly measure. They're usually just rebranded from some other company anyways. No need for the retail store to be double-dipping.
- AdmiralAsshat 6y agoYou'd lose Costco's Kirkland brand, which is one of those rare instances of the store brand often being better than the name-brand.
- codegladiator 6y agoWhy can't they still sell it at stores which they don't owe?
- Miraste 6y agoBetter to cancel the line than supply competitors with better cheaper products than your own store.
- codegladiator 6y agoSorry I don't get the point. Costco's competitors selling Costo's cheaper product would still harm costco ? Does costco get some extra benefit if the consumer buys Kirkland from costco ?
- Miraste 6y ago> Does costco get some extra benefit if the consumer buys Kirkland from costco ? Yes. Costco positions their store brand as a major part of their appeal. This attracts more consumers to their stores, which A. Increases membership, for which there's an annual fee, and B. Increases traffic, increasing sales of high margin items as well as the low margin store brand.
- B_ryJenkins 6y agoIf Costco sells their products at other stores they are effectively shooting themselves in the foot: It is providing the lower price of their products to be accesed without paying for a membership; which is how Costco makes money.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoCostco's value proposition is that they make (on average) no net income from sales of their products, and that you will find no other competitor who can sell the same quality products at a cheaper price (because costco's already selling them as cheap as possible). In exchange, they ask you to pay a membership fee, which is their net income. If they were to give away their reputation to other sellers by letting them sell their QC'd products, they would be lowering the value of their memberships.
- indymike 6y agoThat's not always the case. Sometimes the white label results in a small decrease to the name brand and captures sales to a different market.
- AdmiralAsshat 6y agoBear in mind, I have no idea how wholesalers work in this day and age. But once upon a time, a wholesaler like Costco sold stuff at cost (e.g. they charge what they paid the supplier for the product), and their revenue derived from the annual membership fees. So it's not in Costco's interest to start selling Kirkland Brand Extra Virgin Olive Oil at Safeway, because it wasn't a profit center to begin with. The whole point of selling their own branded product was: a) To reduce costs by controlling the entire means-of-production b) To ensure quality control on the product and build faith in the brand, which in turn c) Pulls people into the store, forcing them to buy a Costco membership if they want the product.
- gamblor956 6y agoWith regards to (a), Costco doesn't do that. Their entire Kirkland line is white-label products, excepting their pizzas which use dough made by regionally locally bakeries. They do have employees oversee (b), but they don't oversee the actual production; they conduct random inspections of shipped products. For example, Kirkland coconut water is simply white-label Vita Coco, and the made by label indicates it is packaged for them by the same company that produces Vita Coco.
- e_y_ 6y agoI'm not sure about the old days, but I believe Costco has stated they cap their markup at 15% -- which along with membership fees pays for employee salary, operations, and profit. I'm guessing that's overall and some products are more profitable while others (like their rotisserie chicken) are subsidized.
- triceratops 6y agoOne of the reasons I keep a Costco membership is for access to Kirkland products. And I think they know that a lot of their customers feel this way.
- mtgx 6y ago> one of those rare instances You said it, not me. We can't have policy revolving around a single company. The net positive would be greater in the market if platforms wouldn't be able to double-tip.
- gamblor956 6y agoMost of the Kirkland brand products are white-label products made for them by companies that sell competing name-brand products. Costco has employees that oversee the QC of these white-label products.
- true_religion 6y agoQuality control is basically the differentiator in modern manufacturing. Intels high price chips, and low price chips are often the same chip except the low priced one failed quality control and had some of its circuits turned off.
- LordDragonfang 6y agoThis common process is called binning, in case anyone wants to read more on it. Wikipedia article, as a primer: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Product_binning https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Product_binning
- e_y_ 6y agoChip binning is something of a special case. Most of the time, when part of a product fails, you have a useless/unsellable product that needs to be reworked or scrapped.
- bradstewart 6y agoThe inhouse brands are quite often cheaper for the consumer. That's worth something.
- ocdtrekkie 6y agoThey're cheaper because they're not "brand name". That doesn't mean the not brand name option needs to be owned by the retail store.
- scarface74 6y agoAnd then they would be more expensive because they have to advertise and have their own supply chain. How does that help consumers?
- p49k 6y agoThere are grocery stores which sell cheaper off-label products that aren’t their own. The makers of those products don’t advertise and thus pass those savings to the consumer. It’s a system that’s already proven to work.
- scarface74 6y agoAre we trying to protect consumers?
- Cerium 6y agoI'm not sure about this. I think a lot of why store brands work is because you trust the store not to cheat you. If the product is bad you know who to blame. The store wants the product to be good because they will loose customers of they make bad house brand products.
- p49k 6y agoA store that sells third party off-label products can still do quality control on those products and can take responsibility for what they sell, just as they would remove faulty brand-name products to protect their reputation.
- scarface74 6y agoSo now we are going to pass laws that disallow cheaper house brands to “help” consumers?
- yourapostasy 6y agoWith the rare exception like Costco, cheaper house brands often imply they're equivalent to brand name goods, but take unadvertised shortcuts in process and/or feedstock, misleading consumers who don't take the time to carefully compare to weigh whether the shortcut is worth the value to them. I wouldn't mind house brands as much if supply chain information and process information was transparent across all companies, but that supply chain information is a pseudo-trade secret (and for real-time supply chain information, definitely a trade secret) [1], and you can forget about obtaining process information. I do use house brands for some goods personally, but this is the result of many years of a lot of careful vetting and monitoring ingredient lists that I know is not commonplace nor even feasible with many retail consumers. House brands can be a useful tool in the market, but they can be abused in too many ways for me to relax my vigilance as a consumer. They also can be abused in too many ways in their distribution channel role to obtain highly-granular, time-sensitive competitive information that normally wouldn't be available in the open market, for me to completely accept their unregulated deployment. I wouldn't go as far as to say ban house brands by law. But I wouldn't want to keep them completely unregulated in all contexts like we are currently doing, either. Happy to change my mind with any new information anyone cares to share though, as this isn't an area I keep a close eye upon. [1] https://www.importyeti.com/ https://www.importyeti.com/
- scarface74 6y agoHousebrand OTC drugs in particular are the same as the name brand equivalent. There was a Freakonomics episode where they said pharmacists overwhelmingly choose house brand OTC products. House brands of any product have to pass the same relevant regulations.
- yourapostasy 6y agoYep, likely because OTC pharma is a tightly-regulated market? However, there are still gaps I haven't found explanations for yet, so I must be misunderstanding how house branding works. For example, house brands have not materially impacted the insulin market [1] even though it is quite regulated to my best understanding. Even when insulin patents expire, there haven't been house brands introduced on more modern formulations [2] [3]. Nor have house brands moved into vaccine production. There is probably much, much more than meets the consumer retail eye to house branding, and I'd love to get an insider's look at the factors and considerations around the decision to roll out a house brand product. [1] https://insulinnation.com/treatment/why-walmart-insulins-arent-the-answer-to-high-insulin-prices/ https://insulinnation.com/treatment/why-walmart-insulins-are... [2] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4955122/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4955122/ [3] https://www.pbs.org/newshour/health/insulin-market-shakeup-patients https://www.pbs.org/newshour/health/insulin-market-shakeup-p...
- JackFr 6y ago> I don't think anything good would be lost if store brands went away A cheaper alternative for consumers? Consider some consumer good made overseas produced at the same factory for both the name brand and store brand. As a consumer why should I have to pay for the huge marketing spend the name brand needs to recoup? I don't see how harming consumers is a useful end of anti-monopoly laws.
- srtjstjsj 6y agoNo-name brands don't have to be store brands, and aren't always.
- reaperducer 6y agoThey're usually just rebranded from some other company anyways This is a common belief, and also mostly false. I think it's common because it used to be true, but isn't anymore. With the economies of scale that a company like a Target or a Wal-Mart have these days, plus the ever-declining cost to manufacture goods, most store brands are actually run for those stores, and not re-labeled big brand goods, or seconds that were rejected by the primary contractor.
- delfinom 6y agoDepends on the product really. Some name brands don't even formulate the product themselves but rather just stamp their name on it just like the stores would. The result is the true manufacturer is able to manufacture the same good under multiple brands rather easily.
- pcdoodle 6y agoConsidering Walgreens and Target don't own 50% of the offline marketplace, Perhaps that could be a factor.
- scarface74 6y agoAmazon has 5% of retail. Walmart is still larger. https://www.mediapost.com/publications/article/331054/report-walmart-continues-to-gain-market-share-in.html https://www.mediapost.com/publications/article/331054/report... Geeks have been complaining for decades that companies shouldn’t be able to patent stuff because “it’s on the internet”. Why limit the relevant market to “on the internet”?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- CarVac 6y agoI don't think brick-and-mortar stores are operating a marketplace the way Amazon is, though.
- notyourwork 6y agoHow are they different?
- spockz 6y agoThey still source their products from the same manufacturers as the brand products. It is just the label or the fragrance that is slightly different. In Amazon’s case it sources it’s copied product from different manufacturers. So once you get a successful product you cloned by a powerful Amazon. And Amazon can always do it cheaper than you.
- rrobukef 6y agoAs long as I remember there have been no complaints about restricting advertisements. (Although plenty of other anti-competitive behaviour) Amazon touts a 'free' marketplace where anybody can sell and advertise their product. Yet it uses its monopoly on ads within their domain against others.
- CarVac 6y agoBrick and mortar stores buy from wholesalers and resell. Amazon facilitates direct transactions between buyers and sellers. It also participates as a seller.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- darksaints 6y agoThey own the inventory and therefore take the risk of selling it. Amazon doesn't own the inventory of its marketplace sellers, and they can do anything they want to put them out of business at no financial risk to themselves.
- jedberg 6y agoThose aren’t marketplaces. They have to buy the products they sell.
- baskire 6y agoThey actually don’t buy all the products they sell. They often only pay the manufacturers after its sold. And sometimes don’t return the units which don’t sell
- jedberg 6y ago> They actually don’t buy all the products they sell. This is not true at all. Costco buys everything they sell. > They often only pay the manufacturers after its sold. This is true, and may be where your confusion lies. They buy on net 30/60/90 terms from their vendors. This means they have 30/60/90 days to pay them. Because they move inventory so quickly, they have often sold an item before they have to pay for it. But they are still buying it and still taking the risk that it won't sell. > And sometimes don’t return the units which don’t sell This is only true because as I said before, they own the items.
- sib 6y agoPerhaps, but Walmart (and many other retailers) do not pre-buy all the products that they sell.
- notatoad 6y agodo you have a source for that? because my understanding (from my time working in that industry) is that everything is sold in exactly the fashion that the parent describes - wal-mart purchases from suppliers and sells to customers. they purchase a lot on credit, but no supplier is giving wal-mart terms like "just hold this in inventory for as long as you want and pay us whenever it sells"
- HenryBemis 6y ago
- scarface74 6y agoDoes that also mean that Nintendo and the other console makers can’t produce first party games? Does Roku have to get rid of the Roku Channel? Can Epic no longer release Fortnite on its own platform?
- jedberg 6y agoHer specific plan had a lower bound of 25 billion in revenue.
- scarface74 6y agoMicrosoft and Sony both have more than $25 billion in revenue. What happens when a company gets above $25 billion in revenue? Do they have to divest? Also, that means that none of the cloud providers could have a marketplace where they sell third party solutions. ElasticCo, Mongo, and plenty of the open source companies sell software through the marketplaces of all three cloud providers. Would that be disallowed to? Do you think any of those companies that sell through the cloud provider’s marketplace would like that outcome?
- jedberg 6y ago> Microsoft and Sony both have more than $25 billion in revenue. What happens when a company gets above $25 billion in revenue? Do they have to divest? That is the expected outcome, yes. That the spin off their marketplace business as a separate entity. > Also, that means that none of the cloud providers could have a marketplace where they sell third party solutions. ElasticCo, Mongo, and plenty of the open source companies sell software through the marketplaces of all three cloud providers. Would that be disallowed to? Do you think any of those companies that sell through the cloud provider’s marketplace would like that outcome? They would probably be ecstatic. Those marketplaces would either be spun out or be replaced by a third party market, that would have an incentive to feature their products above the cloud provider's own products if those products brought more money to the marketplace.
- scarface74 6y ago
- dangero 6y agoIt’s funny because some places actually go the other way —- they start off only selling their own stuff and then they invite others into the marketplace. This is one way to overcome the marketplace chicken egg problem of having both buyers and sellers. This would stifle that. Valve launched Steam originally only with its own games then invited others to join. Now it’s a completely open marketplace.
- ShinTakuya 6y agoI mean, Valve's games (as few and far between they are these days) did and still do get preferential treatment. It just so happens that because Valve doesn't really make games anymore, Steam works out being mostly fair. But if Valve went and released HL3 tomorrow, you can bet it'll be at the top of the store for half the year.
- kroltan 6y agoWould it? Alyx didn't really overstate its presence earlier this year either.
- eropple 6y agoAlyx is also a VR game. Bit more niche.
- kroltan 6y agoSteam has a very powerful recommendation engine, and knowledge about the hardware of its users. I would be surprised if they weren't able to focus their marketing to VR owners if they wanted.
- gommm 6y agoIn the past year, I've used my steam account for VR games 50% of the time roughly and they still didn't really push Alyx all that much. That said given I mostly only do short game sessions , maybe they figured that I wouldn't be that interested in it?
- amadeuspagel 6y agoThis is a terrible idea. It's almost impossible to bootstrap a marketplace without participating in it. Amazon as a platform that people can sell their own stuff on is only possible because people were already using it to buy things directly from amazon.
- reaperducer 6y agoIt's almost impossible to bootstrap a marketplace without participating in it. This is obviously untrue. Walk into almost any store in the world, and you're in a marketplace where the owner is not also selling his own competing products. There are vanishingly few exceptions, like garden centers, big box stores, and supermarkets.
- amadeuspagel 6y agoThere are three different things happening on amazon: #1 Amazon selling third party products. #2 Third party sellers selling their products. #3 Amazon selling their own products. You're pointing out that #3 isn't necesary, and that's true, but my point is that #1 is necessary and is how every store starts, then they might expand into #2 and #3.
- amelius 6y ago#1 isn't necessary if amazon started as a logistics company, with smaller shops as their clients.
- srtjstjsj 6y agoAnd those stores arent as good as Amazon, according to millions of customers.
- ByteJockey 6y agoStores aren't marketplaces, at least generally speaking. Consignment shops might count. At a store (once again, generally speaking), the company buys things and re-sells them. In a marketplace you're buying directly from someone else (and they usually pay the marketplace operator a cut of sales afterwards, or an upfront fee to sell there).
- durovo 6y agoWould love to see how this applies to Apple App Store and Play Store.
- Shivetya 6y agoJust love arbitrary dollar numbers so that they can claim to not target specific companies. How about laws the apply equally to all. Seriously, go across the magical threshold and then what? You have to leave your own market place? Do we have then a list of exceptions and exceptions to exceptions? Mickey mouse legislation is the reason the system is in such shambles and there are legions of lawyers just to navigate it all. Government which operates off the petty whims of the politicians is subject to abuse by all sides and you just best hope you stay on the right side.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- guerrilla 6y agoQuestion for anyone who might know: how does this currently work with stock markets? Would it have to change?
- t-writescode 6y agoThis plan seems like it would have a LOT of collateral damage that we don't want to have. I still want Valve to still be able to sell games on Steam. I want Epic to be allowed to make games. I want Costco to still have the Kirkland brand. And so on.
- flavius29663 6y agotypical socialist ideas, sounds good to the masses, but with potential consequences that are the opposite of what they want.
- t-writescode 6y agoWell, it isn't a socialist plan. That would be more like obligating the employees to all be stockholders proportional to the number of employees in the company; but, nice try :)
- CogitoCogito 6y ago> typical socialist ideas, sounds good to the masses, but with potential consequences that are the opposite of what they want. This has nothing at all to do with socialism. In fact, those that support such an argument seem to do so because they believe it _increases_ competition. It might actually be the polar opposite of socialism.
- srtjstjsj 6y agoSpin off the house brand from the house.
- zaptrem 6y agoWhat if half the people work on both?
- gnicholas 6y agoSo how would this rule apply to the Apple App Store, for example? Presumably it wouldn't prevent them from making free stock apps like Mail, Safari, and Maps, right? Would they still be allowed to offer these apps, so long as they are free and are not privileged over third-party apps? Or would Apple be prevented from offering any apps whatsoever? I would think a rule like this would be bad for consumers, and would also lead Apple to draw different lines between what is an app and what is a built in OS functionality (i.e., migrate app functionality into the OS itself, in order to avoid the rule).
- jedberg 6y agoImagine a world in which only third party app stores are allowed on iPhone. Now imagine Apple having to compete with all the other Maps, Mail, and Web Browsers. Do you think their native apps would be chosen over the others in a fair competition?
- m463 6y agois "25 billion" forward looking or a specific carveout against specific companies (basically gerrymandering)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]