26 ms·
Judge temporarily blocks U.S. ban on TikTok downloads from U.S. app stores
- Polylactic_acid 6y agoRather than blocking a single app, they should bring in GDPR style laws that make apps like tiktok banned by default unless they change to be strongly privacy protecting.
- Barrin92 6y agothat'd probably kill every American social media app on the app stores as well, not sure they're ready to do that.
- ikerdanzel 6y agoNope. Only specific instances. And in this case POTUS has the power when it comes to foreign entities. It is enshrined in the constitutions. By the way, India and China are even doing this without even a single judicial recourse. USA simply is the best country that has been setup to allow and disallow this kind of things some hundreds years ago.
- AmericanChopper 6y agoThe powers that POTUS has over international trade (including tariffs, blocking imports, blocking transactions) were actually granted by Congress through various pieces of legislation.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> And in this case POTUS has the power when it comes to foreign entities. It is enshrined in the constitutions. No, it's not. The power the President is asserting might be authorized under statute, though that's actually one of the questions in dispute.
- asou 6y agoYes! Shut em all down ! https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Facebook–Cambridge_Analytica_data_scandal https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Facebook–Cambridge_Analytica... https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/press-releases/2019/09/ftc-sues-owner-online-dating-service-matchcom-using-fake-love https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/press-releases/2019/09/ftc-s... https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2018/04/03/599069424/grindr-admits-it-shared-hiv-status-of-users https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2018/04/03/599069424... If you can't give a shit about the security of your user's personal information / safety , you shouldn't exist.
- Spivak 6y agoI agree with the activist spirit! But you have to realize that the incentives of legislators are to first create a strong economy and to maintain the dominance of the US tech sector. If you come to them with a plan that will seriously harm their operations then you won’t even get a meeting.
- asou 6y agoI'm dreaming here, no regulation will take place. You need to self regulate though and assume all data you give these companies will be sold. At this point unless it's ride sharing , apps don't get my location. If they means I can't use the apps, that's fine. It wouldn't be the worst thing if tommorow Social Media was effectively banned. It's done enough wrong in the world
- pjmlp 6y agoIf you start making everyone suspicious of doing business with US, that dominance will slow fade away as each market tries their home grown alternatives. Yes they will suck during the first years, get barely enough customers to survive, but eventually they will get there with enough perseverance. The current administration is only making everyone aware that the globalisation days are over.
- manquer 6y agoThis requires long term thinking. Neither the companies (Q-on-Q) nor the politicians (4-6 years ) have long term incentive to do lasting change by pushing unpopular policies.
- kennywinker 6y agoHas GDPR killed social media in europe?
- thereare5lights 6y agoAnd therein lies the true motivation for blocking TikTok. This has nothing to do with privacy and everything to do with politics.
- shadowgovt 6y agoThat doesn't generally align with America's approach to these sort of things. A law like that would have made the internet itself very hard to develop.
- MereInterest 6y agoNo, it would have made targeted advertising on the internet be very hard to develop. The internet existed before targeted advertising, with site-specific advertising based on the interests of a site. Stalking users across sites for the purpose of targeted advertising is a much newer development. I agree that this doesn't align with the US's general approach to this sort of thing. That is a fault with the US's general approach, not with privacy protections.
- marsrover 6y agoTargeted advertising is a major reason for the Internet’s success. It has allowed many companies to become extremely wealthy and invest back into the ecosystem.
- kennywinker 6y agoTo create more targeted advertising companies. Huzzah!
- MereInterest 6y agoTargeted advertising on the internet as a general practice did not start until the mid to late aughts, long after the internet was a success. Targeted advertising is not a reason for the Internet's success.
- Drew_ 6y agoThe internet in the mid to late aughts is not considered a success by today's standards.
- 6y ago
- yurlungur 6y agoI think that's the best thing to do for the general public. Most social media already obey GDPR for European users (I suspect TikTok included), so having this law in the US will benefit every user everywhere by forcing companies to treat everyone uniformly with a higher level of protection by default due to the majority of their userbase being covered by such laws.
- sytelus 6y agoIf other government owns the data, no laws can be applied to them in war times or from preventing to gather intelligence.
- LurkersWillLurk 6y agoWe need to push back on this nonsense in journalism in which journalists don't include a link to the opinion when writing an article describing that opinion. There is not enough information included in the article to meaningfully comment on the situation. Edit: here is the order, which is very short: https://www.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.dcd.222257/gov.uscourts.dcd.222257.29.0_8_1.pdf https://www.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.dcd.222257/... The opinion is under seal, and the parties have been directed to raise objections to unsealing it, if they wish.
- bigpumpkin 6y agoI think the judge said the opinion is temporarily under seal for some reason.
- lstamour 6y agoThe Verge backed it up in their article. It’s unclear who’s in the (virtual?) courtroom or how they sourced this info, but it kind of makes sense. Courts aren’t well-known for publishing courtroom activities in real-time and online (Zoom) trials that result in the death penalty are getting extra attention even as other cases (Assange) apparently suffered from a lack of press coverage or public attendance. Hard to say what the right answer is here, but I agree that a small (as short as necessary) press release from a courtroom website would be appreciated for any decision. In this case though, it’s hard to say a decision either way isn’t political, seems to me that would be why it’s still under seal?
- retox 6y agoMaybe not in this specific instance, but the times I have tracked down original sources they often disagree with the way the journalists have framed things. They know most people won't bother to do any original research or even read past the headline in a lot of cases. It's easier to tell people what to think than give them the facts and let them reach their own conclusion.
- lol768 6y agoDitto for scientific papers. I want the DOI and/or a link to the original (ideally open access!) paper which the article has been written about.
- Firebrand 6y agoI get the feeling the Trump Administration’s lawyers are going to fumble the full ban lawsuit in November allowing Bytedance to retain control of TikTok. If this were an actual national security issue then you’d think they’d come up with more compelling reasons to remove it from the App Store.
- tootie 6y agoThere's a valid concern but the administration's approach is heavy-handed and impractical. They seem intent on simply stealing a successful company from China and letting american companies earn the rewards and maybe get a kickback in the process. They should use either their national security powers or, better yet, an act of Congress to ban the specific objectionable activities and let the markets sort themselves out.
- echelon 6y ago> stealing a successful company from China Only its US operations.
- kabacha 6y agoI'm sure it's not a coincidence that one of the biggest western social media apps - Instagram - launched a direct clone of tiktok. So far IG reels are dead but if TikTok gets banned there's an undeniable benefit for IG, right?
- sudosysgen 6y agoIt very likely isn't a coincidence as the main manager of Instagram has been lobbying for the ban of TikTok.
- tatrajim 6y agoNice to know that Apple was given equal legal consideration in China in 2016 when its iBooks store and iTunes movie store were suddenly ordered shut after six months of operation. Oh, wait. . . they weren't given any legal recourse at all and the Obama administration did nothing about it while Silicon Valley grandees kept conspicuously silent. https://www.nytimes.com/2016/04/22/technology/apple-no-longer-immune-to-chinas-scrutiny-of-us-tech-firms.html https://www.nytimes.com/2016/04/22/technology/apple-no-longe...
- nkozyra 6y agoI don't see how those are analogous. Shouldn't you be complaining that a Chinese court didn't temporarily block the Apple ban?
- tatrajim 6y agoPrecisely. There is no legal remedy in China for cases such as Apple's, a situation that the Hacker News et al. communities blandly accept in silence while valorizing attempts by ByteDance and WeChat to game the US system for profitable access. Why the Western world accepts as legitimate the products of a closed society that relies on ubiquitous censorship and withholds free access to the outside world through a national firewall is hard for me to fathom. I have lived in China, South Korea, and Taiwan off and on for decades and believe the people of PRC deserve better.
- YarickR2 6y agoMost of the world should ban US-originating social networks, then ; also cars, planes, music, movies, and intellectual property
- HeyZuess 6y ago> Why the Western world accepts as legitimate the products of a closed society that relies on ubiquitous censorship and withholds free access to the outside world through a national firewall is hard for me to fathom. I have lived in China, South Korea, and Taiwan off and on for decades and believe the people of PRC deserve better. I agree, people of many countries deserve much better. However restricting trade, sanctions, undermining diplomatic relationships etc rarely do anything other than harm the citizens of the country. It's difficult but not impossible to tell someone off while doing the same thing yourself. As far as national security goes, the US has a checkered history of interfering with other countries. As far as the rights of citizens within a country again a checkered modern history. As far as political manipulation .... etc etc, I think you get the picture. I am not saying the US is as bad as China, but some of their actions would surely deserve reprimand as well. But I doubt the US is sitting there and doing this for the "concerns" of the residents of these countries. Now in the case of TikTok, I think this is a great case for protection of data in ALL countries. GDPR is a good example of this.
- localhost 6y agoUnlike some other commenters below, I don't believe that this is a privacy issue. Instead, I believe that it is a national security issue because TikTok is controllable by the CCP which is ideologically opposed to the United States. The next global conflict will likely be one between the east and the west, with control of information being advantageous to both sides in the conflict. China already blocks the western Internet, so they have an advantage by default. This position is covered much more eloquently than I put it above in Ben Thompson's "The TikTok War" [1]. [1] https://stratechery.com/2020/the-tiktok-war/ https://stratechery.com/2020/the-tiktok-war/
- schoolornot 6y agoWhat exactly is the national security risk with TikTok?
- DLay 6y agoSomething revealed in the recent court filings was how Bytedance spent over $1 billion in advertising on Facebook/Instagram, YouTube, and Snapchat. Apparently they were spending $10-$30 to acquire an active user and expecting to generate $5 of revenue per user in the US, implying a revenue payback period of 2-6 years. Some ugly unit economics.
- philliphaydon 6y agoThink it involves TV adverts too.
- senkora 6y agoThat’s probably fine for a growth product. They’ll increase monetization once the network effect is well-established.
- bduerst 6y agoYeah, a $30 CPA isn't anything suspicious when there's upsell to a $20/mo subscription.
- bagacrap 6y agoon what planet do millionsn of teens have $20/mo to spend on tiktok
- bduerst 6y agoIn which comment did I say millions of people upsell to subscription? A 2 yr product lifecycle would be a $240 CLV meaning you just need 12% conversion rate to break even, which you don't even care about in growth mode. $30 CPA is more than reasonable.
- dicomdan 6y agoIt's a tool of the government, not a company. It's not meant to make money.
- sheeshkebab 6y agoIt’s an interesting argument that probably won’t end well for bytedance and other foreign controlled apps and software... if executive branch can’t control which of them are allowed to be present in country and distributed by us entities, it’ll be just a matter of time before a law is passed that would let them, or probably an existing one amended (similar to patriot act). I bet it would be bipartisan law as well.
- ausjke 6y agoIt's a national security issue. Plus, if you sue the government order from any courts in CA, you will win anyways these days. CA is too liberal to remain in US, I remember they were saying CA-Independence from USA after 2016, I can't wait to support it, but those people somehow did not proceed, very disappointed.
- ciarannolan 6y agoI don't think most Americans would be too keen to forfeit 15% of the country's GDP [1] to own the libs. [1] https://www.statista.com/chart/9358/us-gdp-by-state-and-region/ https://www.statista.com/chart/9358/us-gdp-by-state-and-regi...
- jerrysievert 6y agoI'm sure that they would, but wouldn't understand until it was too late. when you cripple education systems, fewer people can think critically about issues and the ramifications of decisions are much more abstract.
- IfOnlyYouKnew 6y agoHave you heard of "Brexit"?
- sudosysgen 6y agoIronically, secession of California would have Xi Jinping pouring champagne. How does abdicating to China to own the libs sound?
- mullingitover 6y ago> CA is too liberal to remain in US The problem with this is that if the liberal states are allowed out of the union, the conservative states will run out of other people's money to spend.
- djsumdog 6y agoYou do realize that Texas is a mostly right/republican state that also gives back to the Federal Government more money than it takes in, right? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S92fTz_-kQE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S92fTz_-kQE
- buttholesurfer 6y agoYayyyyy, nothing like allowing people to be Chinese agents unknowingly!
- dirtyid 6y agoPolitics aside, it's crazy Facebook / Instagram / Youtube haven't successfully cloned TikTok yet. No doubt network affect plays a role, but from what I've read, western clones have been very lacking. Maybe US is just not competitive when it comes to quickly copying and iterating designs like China is. It's a skill. Google Meet apart from great transcription feature still feels miles behind Zoom. Wonder how Indian developers are doing after the ban. JioMeet is pretty much a 1:1 Zoom clone, anyone comment on what replaced TikTok?
- soared 6y agoReels on Instagram launched a couple weeks ago and it appears to be pretty active. I haven’t seen usage numbers yet
- matsemann 6y agoReels suck, though. Maybe that's because Instagram's explore algorithm sucks, though. I mostly follow sports/cycling/ski stuff on Instagram. What is the most liked/viral content in any category..? It's probably a woman with tight or almost no clothes on. So even when I get a ski video, it's often some babe posing in ski boots and nothing else. Or for cycling it's a woman with the top unzipped. Opening Instagram is basically NSFW even though I've never liked a picture like that or follow those kind of accounts. And well, most of the content on Reels are reuploads of TikToks or old viral videos. So not much interesting to see.
- bhashkarsharma 6y agoThere are a couple of Indian apps[0] trying to replicate Tiktok functionality. Many of them saw a surge in usage after Tiktok got banned. Not sure about the current numbers though. [0] https://indianexpress.com/article/technology/social/mitron-chingari-roposo-indian-tiktok-alternative-6483058/ https://indianexpress.com/article/technology/social/mitron-c...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- pcbro141 6y agoThe judge is a Trump appointee interestingly. That means Trump can't blame it on liberal judges sabotaging him like he has in the past.
- irrelative 6y agoWant to bet?
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoI wouldn't, he's flipped his opinion on people so often and so easily.
- pcbro141 6y agoPornhub is a foreign company, perhaps Trump should ban that too. It could be a national security threat for a foreign company to know the porn habits of government officials, they could use that to blackmail military generals and the like. /sarcasm
- mdorazio 6y agoThis is a poor argument, including the sarcasm. Pornhub is a Canadian company. Last time I checked, Canada was still a democratic country with an ideology roughly aligned with that of the US.
- pcbro141 6y agoWe're going to have to look at their investors very strongly. Many people are saying they're being funded by China. Maybe they are maybe they aren't, but it could be a national security threat if China is funding them. We have the best porn, that I can tell you. America First!
- stale2002 6y ago> maybe they aren't They aren't though. Sarcasm, to attempt to make a point just comes off as disingenuous trolling, by the way. You would be better served by directly trying to make your point, instead of phase your "argument" in the way that you did.
- ckocagil 6y agoLast time I checked Saudi Arabia was a fundamentalist, religious kingdom with many known inhumane acts and practices. Yet they control a ton of US companies.
- mdorazio 6y agoAnd I've always been in favor of ending that situation and US relations with them entirely. Not sure what your point is here.
- dilap 6y agoIt's strange how so many in the US have adopted the mindset that it's important, for national security, to deny its citizens access to foreign social networks. Previously, when China did the same, this was widely viewed as an unfortunate restriction their freedoms -- the actions of an intrusive, authoritarian government. Now that the US is itself considering doing the same, many in the west have suddenly adopted the attitude that China had it right all along. Very surprising!
- dannyw 6y agoThe US is a democratic government with the rule of law, as seen in this very example with a judge blocking the order.
- avanti 6y agoThe US is a democratic government with the rule of law, as seen in the case of slavery.
- edgefield0 6y agoI see you're drinking the koolaid...
- pjmlp 6y agoI have seen very democratic arrests going on as well, pity that the person getting arrested can't testify any longer.
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoThe US tries to keep up the outward appearance of that, but underneath it is or is quickly becoming a fascist police-state oligarchy.
- sneak 6y agoIt seems that the US has the rule of law only in cases where the rule of law is not in conflict with the military dictatorship. In the cases where the military dictatorship wants to jail a journalist (Assange) or has some protesters for a photo op, law no longer rules and instead the military just does what it wants without consequences.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- p1necone 6y agoYou know you don't have to argue about who's in the wrong here? It's okay to accept that both the USA and China are in the wrong, not everything has to be a fight with a winner. China for having uncomfortable amounts of government control/vision over the data and operations of Chinese social media companies. And the USA for singling out Tik Tok seemingly arbitrarily, and banning it for "national security" reasons without going into any detail about what they are or what evidence they have for them. (And it potentially violating 1A rights, being inconsistent with treatment of other foreign companies etc etc).
- p1necone 6y agoThere's another argument to be had about whether Chinese spying is "worse" than western spying because it's officially legitimized by the policies of the Chinese government. And whether it's also "worse" because China is more authoritarian and oppressive with it's own citizens. I'm making an assumption here that because of these two things it's mostly generally accepted that the Chinese surveillance state is "worse" than the USA surveillance state (and I largely agree with that take, but figured I should still state my priors here in case this isn't uncontroversial).
- mechnesium 6y agoI don’t think Chinese surveillance is worse for people outside of China. Your local government’s surveillance will always be worse, because it has the capability to act upon the data collected on you, since you are in their jurisdiction.
- mechnesium 6y ago> USA for singling out Tik Tok seemingly arbitrarily, and banning it for "national security" reasons without going into any detail about what they are or what evidence they have for them. It’s McCarthyism all over again. This type of behavior, coming from the very top of the US government, is unacceptable. It’s an erosion of your freedoms and needs to be vehemently fought.
- 6y ago
- MetalGuru 6y agoPeople claiming this isn’t a Chinese company (“it’s incorporated in the Caymans! Hurrdurrr”) are either misinformed or not being honest. From the Wikipedia link for ByteDance: > ByteDance's first app, Neihan Duanzi, was shut down in 2018 by the National Radio and Television Administration. In response, Zhang issued an apology stating that the app was "incommensurate with socialist core values", that it had a "weak" implementation of Xi Jinping Thought, and promised that ByteDance would "further deepen cooperation" with the ruling Chinese Communist Party to better promote its policies.[7][8][9] > It has garnered public attention over allegations that it worked with the Chinese Communist Party to censor and surveil content pertaining to Xinjiang re-education camps and other topics the Party deemed controversial.[18][19][20] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/ByteDance https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/ByteDance
- drivingmenuts 6y agoHonestly, this sounds more like a dick-waving contest than a national security issue, from the way it’s being ham-fisted. While there may be legitimate security issues, the timing seems oddly-aligned with the government’s insistence that the Chinese government is responsible for a great number of problems in the US and this right before an election. It smells like blame-passing and extortion, among other things.
- baby 6y agoA lot of people being brainwashed by the US government in here.
- ahmedalsudani 6y agoIt’s the typical measure of rubes. I still remember the “freedom fries” and WMD hysteria. Back then a certain group had to be bombed back into the Stone Age. Today, that same group is being oppressed by the evil totalitarian regime which is also on the verge of destroying all of your freedoms. In both cases, a collection of plugged in, “informed” citizens, whose brain matter has been shaped by a constant drip of state propaganda, were doing the mental gymnastics required to justify evidence-free actions of their government. This will play out as well as the last attempt did. “Mission Accomplished.”
- csdffsdfsdfsdfs 6y agoSo our freedoms are not actually under threat? Not even the freedom to use TikTok, I guess, despite of the US government trying to ban it? Everything is fine!
- ahmedalsudani 6y agoHave you not learned yet that some freedoms are not really freedoms? :D If it’s not in the brochure, it’s not on offer.
- gandutraveler 6y agoYes any Chinese owned company is a potential national security risk. CCP is already known to manipulate their citizens with propaganda on their news and media sites. Tiktok gives them that acres to manipulate/meddle in other countries. What I'm strongly against is handpicking tiktok and wechat. This should be a law passed by congress which effectively limits companies blacklisted countries like China,Iran to US market. I know this defeats the openness of internet but it is indeed a serious threat.
- chrischen 6y ago> Tiktok gives them that acres to manipulate/meddle in other countries. This is a really naïve world view—not that TikTok isn't potentially a channel of propaganda, but that we somehow are free of propaganda in the US. The Trump administration is a source of propaganda. The Democratic party is a source of propaganda. Propaganda is basically any speech from any biased source. The only significant difference between China and the US isn't that one practices propaganda but that China limits their propaganda to only one source. Blacklisting "propaganda" from sources you don't like is in fact censorship. If we start blocking China because we don't like what they are telling us, why stop there? Why not start blocking propaganda from the Trump critics.
- academia_hack 6y agoI have always liked that America had an open internet, unlike China. Obviously this is tit-for-tat with CCP treatment of American tech companies, but I don't want America to be equal to China, I want it to be better.
- richrichardsson 6y agoWhy does everyone here have a problem with referring to the Communist Party of China with its correct acronym: CPC. If I decided to start calling it PHTT (Protocol for Hyper-Text Transfer), I'd be rightly viewed as a complete idiot.
- fsflover 6y agoBoth acronyms are equal: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_Communist_Party https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_Communist_Party
- swiley 6y agoI really wish we could have blocked all the social media apps.
- dfischer 6y agoThe reason why it’s an issue: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perception_management https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perception_management The internet has turned into a war zone of perception management involving state and non state entities. The non state entities are able to do things in quite powerful ways never before possible for a civilian level technology. Any hacker with creativity and GPT2 can manipulate hordes of people with a human in a loop pattern.
- jl2718 6y agoAlso, what is the ‘ideological’ difference between US and China? The mere mention of communism suffices in most government circles, but that doesn’t explain any of their tactics, and certainly not strategy or objectives. I would like to know what you (HN) think.
- whiddershins 6y agoThere’s no formal and credible-sounding assumption of anything that resembles the bill of rights. There’s not an equivalent of the notion that every human life has intrinsic value, which is traced back to Christianity. Therefore there isn’t a specific reason why it is wrong for the government to kill an arbitrary number of innocent people if it furthers the overall good. That’s just one example. Edit: I didn’t mean a specific reason, I meant a specific and overwhelming, basically non-negotiable reason, which maps to an equivalent in to the U.S. as an example.
- mechnesium 6y agoWelcome to the Red Scare 2.0, comrade. TikTok is under fire because it’s a piece of software from China. We’ve turned a blind eye to hardware security and the fact that the iPhone and nearly every other mainstream consumer device is manufactured in China and likely contain backdoors far more sinister than userland applications can muster. We can not and should not have such double standards when it comes to foreign policy. The cherry on top, though, is that Western governments are far more sinister than China. Your local government has the capability to act upon the surveillance data that they collect on you, since you are in their jurisdiction. China, by comparison, can’t do anything to you except protect you from such local surveillance. If the US dislikes China so much, place an embargo and see how long it takes for Uncle Sam’s evil empire to crumble.
- helloooooooo 6y agoWhat are you smoking? I want some of it.
- mechnesium 6y agoA hybrid strain of critical thinking and anti-nationalism.
- will4274 6y agoAnd genocide apologia.
- tylermenezes 6y ago> TikTok is under fire because it’s a piece of software from China. Don't forget: TikTok is under fire because Zuckerberg convinced Trump that it should be.
- ecmascript 6y ago> Western governments are far more sinister than China Oh really, I didn't know my country was doing things way worse then putting people in concentration camps, harvesting organs, putting people in prison because they had group sex, putting people in prison for years because they legally protested etc. Thanks for the information! But just for future discussions when I try to talk down these pesky people that try to harass the beautiful country of China, the perfect state that never does anything wrong, can you provide some examples on how the western democracies are worse? These horrible right wing extremists always seem to want some kind of source for the claims when it's so obvious to us comrades.
- robomartin 6y agoI think the problem is far greater than TikTok. At a simplistic level I believe countries should use what I call the "mirror principle" to business and legal relationships. In other words, if you think it's OK to steal our intellectual property, then we do the same. OK, to ban, block and force business structures, we treat you exactly as you treat us. Ban chunks of the international internet? No problem, you are treated the same. Yes, I know this is simplistic. Yet, I think there's merit to the idea that we treat each other as we each choose to treat the other. I don't say this in a religious sense at all (atheist). I say this as a starting point from which a relationship can be refined and framed in less sophomoric terms. The alternative is to start from a position of absolute contempt for the other it is difficult to shift the relationship towards the middle. Just look at the, sadly, plentiful history of contentious divorces for examples of this. BTW, I am not saying this in a US-centric fashion. China has been predatory to almost every nation of the world. From the tip of South America to the northern reaches of Europe and everything in between. They ought to live by the same rules they impose on everyone wishing to do business in China. Another thing that deeply bothers me are the Chinese companies listed in US stock exchanges, none of which seem to comply with US regulatory and accounting requirements. In other words, they are likely as opaque as can be, or worse, they could be fabricating financials. US and other investors could be in for a horrific awakening as investment in these companies could very well be a house of cards. I do believe framing the TikTok problem in terms of national security is wrong. The correct term would be "global security". The US happens to be mounting resistance at this stage, yet other nations should think this through carefully. The most important fact to understand here is that the Chinese Communist Party has their hooks into absolutely everything in China. It might look benevolent when you buy your $28 blender at Walmart, but, in the long term, the equation that drives decision-making at the CCP isn't one that seeks to improve the lives of the Walmart shopper. Read Sun Tzu, it's all there. Now add ideology, motive and objectives. As a parent I do not want my kids anywhere close to these algorithms. I also don't care for my kids to be anywhere close to the Facebook algorithms. Imagine, if you will, if the US federal government had --by force, by law-- full access to all of the data from Facebook, Google, YouTube, Twitter, Instagram, etc. Would you be comfortable with that reality? I would not. Not one bit. Why then, is it OK for the CCP to have their hooks into everything that reaches international shores that has "Made in China" in it? I think it is fair to say that nobody is comfortable with their own government (anywhere in the world) having detailed access to all of their most intimate social media/internet data. How could anyone be in favor of the CCP having exactly that access through, quite literally, every Chinese company doing business internationally? For me, from a Libertarian/Classical Liberal perspective, this isn't about hating China --I do not, they should be free to do as they please within their own nation. This is about a general principle: No government in the world should be allowed to sink their hooks into internet companies to turn everything we touch with our phones, computers and TV's into surveillance data from birth until death. That would be --and I hope everyone agrees with this-- unequivocally wrong, evil, disturbing and can lead to nothing good in the long term. This is not how free human beings are supposed to live on this planet. Going from free animals roaming the plains to being entries in massive databases with unique identifiers tattooed on our backs is far from freedom. It's the internet turning humanity into cattle. Add the power of government to that and anyone should be able to understand why this TikTok mess is the right fight to have at this moment in time. If not now, when?
- kryogen1c 6y agosam harris just talked about this. https://youtu.be/1se6POdUcWM https://youtu.be/1se6POdUcWM i dont accept US moderation in my life with YouTube, twitter, or facebook. the fact that we're arguing the merit of CCP moderation of our youth is strictly a nonstarter; its crazy talk.
- throwaway13337 6y agoI'd love to see a response from other countries where they block Facebook and Twitter permanently or at least force them to change their newsfeed algorithm. These services are causing the world to become politically unstable by stoking up rage for the purpose of selling ads. This is the biggest threat to our shared future. Now that America has lead the way, it's hopeful we'll see such a response.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]