8 ms·
Every time this pops up on HN, people post insisting that it won't all go away, that the skyscrapers will, somehow, still be there. No, they won't. Look at any
by ncmncm 6y ago
Every time this pops up on HN, people post insisting that it won't all go away, that the skyscrapers will, somehow, still be there.
No, they won't. Look at any place in the world where there are mesas. All of the land around the mesa used to be level with the top of the mesa. It has all eroded away, and in only a few million years.
So, the metals will corrode, collapse, and wash away. The stone will erode away. The concrete will erode away. The radioactives will decay. It will all end up as a millimeter-thick layer on the sea bottom, one of thousands of millimeter-thick layers with nothing to call attention to itself. Microplastics will abound, but somebody needs to be looking for them in exactly that layer, the way we found iridium at the K-T boundary layer, after specifically looking. There is a huge overabundance of platinum (parts-per-billion) in layers only 12900 years old, just discovered in the past decade, and only because we are really interested in that layer. (It was the start of the 1300-year Younger Dryas cold spell whose end is the start of the Holocene Epoch.)
Will anything last? Big mining and quarry pits will fill in, but recognizably. Big mine tunnels will fill in or collapse, but recognizably. A rectangular mine shaft dug down through a thousand meters of sedimentary rock will have no other explanation.
Some structures will be buried, instead of eroding away. Those will be deep underground, and then might be exposed again through subsequent erosion or uplift. Again, a brick chimney found buried will have no other explanation, though people will try.
Strictly speaking, one is all you need, but some people ("people"?) need more convincing.
- imglorp 6y agoHas anyone methodically looked for artificial materials like microplastics in the geological strata?
- Retric 6y agoYes, in that people try and identify what’s there. No, in that it’s not expected to find evidence of a prior advanced civilization. The prior existence of oil as an easily recoverable resource is a strong indicator that nothing like our civilization existed in the last several million years.
- DougWebb 6y agoThat's true about the oil; coal too. If we're not completely wrong about how those resources are created (there are some alternate theories) then we're the first civilization to use them. However, most of what I've read about prehistoric advanced civilizations discussed them using crystals (quartz) and deriving energy from the earth. Some form of piezoelectricity. There are theories today connecting earth quakes, quartz deposits, and ball lightning, which could be hinting at an energy source we haven't explored yet.
- vbezhenar 6y agoWe sent humans to space and robots to Mars and other planets, we are extracting energy from nuclear fission, we will likely build an artificial star soon enough. It's extremely unlikely that we could have missed some mysterious quartz power source.
- dr_dshiv 6y agoAfter a couple thousand years of computational evolution, if you don't think there'd be a possible reason for leaving behind massive silicon crystals... Well, you haven't been reading enough science fiction. If you could grow pure crystals more easily (thinking Diamon Age), why not have giant plates serving as a piezo generator or ambient electromagnetic waveguide harvesters?
- jack_pp 6y agoSo a civilization thousands years more advanced than us failed to go to space (evidenced by the fact that they did not leave behind any space junk) but somehow produced energy from crystals?
- TeMPOraL 6y agoFWIW, space junk wouldn't necessarily survive that long. Things on lower orbits would deorbit themselves quickly without station keeping. Things on higher orbit would get pushed away by solar radiation over long time, and degrade under high-energy radiation (such as UV rays). What remains would be hard to find, because space is big, so it would have to be fairly large and/or fairly reflective for us to notice now.
- opportune 6y agoWe know about the KT extinction layer (which contains a lot of iridium, a potentially extremely useful but rare metal) but attribute it to meteorite ejecta. It also coincided with large scale climate and environmental changes. That's the only candidate I know of as a non-geologist.
- saltedonion 6y agoIs total human/intelligent species population not a prerequisite for industrialization. If so, we would expect to see a lot of fossilized remains, which we have not seen.
- ncmncm 6y agoWe have found exactly one (1) skeleton of a Clovis person, the dominant human culture of North America for several centuries, right up until exactly the start of the Younger Dryas cold spell, only 12900 years ago.
- pmiller2 6y agoThose people need to watch a few episodes of the TV series Life After People. Watching it, and realizing that everything around us would literally start to fail in a matter of days without us as its caretakers, really brought home the impermanence of everything. Skyscrapers are certainly not going to outlast ancient cave dwellings. In a matter of a couple hundred years, I would be surprised if a single skyscraper was still standing without us to keep it up. I’ve seen unmaintained buildings falling a part after a mere decade of disuse; a skyscraper lasting for a century or two would be extremely durable on the scale of modern buildings.
- friendlybus 6y agoNobody is building for the super long term, we expect on some level that new will replace the old at some point. This man is trying to build a clock to last 10k years. https://longnow.org/clock/ https://longnow.org/clock/
- jlawson 6y agoI wonder how long the Egyptian pyramids would last.
- lumost 6y agoAs the pyramids are constructed of limestone, they would desolve during the next wet phase of the sahara ( previous wet period ~20kya and 12.5 kya ). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sahara_pump_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sahara_pump_theory
- reachfortheskyy 6y agoFor what it's worth, the Spivey Building is almost 100 years old and it's been abandoned since the '50s. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spivey_Building https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spivey_Building St. Louis has a lot of cool abandoned architecture, although you might want to be careful wandering around East of the river. I wonder how many cities have abandoned towers that became historical places thanks to longstanding traditions of not being able to afford a demolition.
- Veedrac 6y agoThis argument disproves fossils. E: To be pedantic, it only disproves most fossils.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoAnd, as predicted by the argument, the fossils don't abound, and to find them you have to start digging.
- Veedrac 6y agoI agree that they'd be underground.
- lopmotr 6y agoI wonder if that's always been the case. Maybe humans quickly cleaned up all the easily accessible fossils before realizing what they were. Ancient Greeks thought they'd found a giant's bone and other cultures seem to have used dinosaur fossils as inspiration for myths of dragons. Even western researchers a few hundred years ago thought dinosaur bones were just recent animal bones. Imagine how careless every previous civilization was with them. Maybe the biggest obstacle to archeology is having people around who are interested in explaining what they're seeing. Science is a very rare thing for human cultures to spontaneously do. Even the 1000s of years old Chinese civilization never invented science and had to wait for it to be imported. I tend to think that human societies naturally actively discourage science because they'd quickly think up and memetically spread myths for any unexplained phenomena then anyone challenging the popular myths would have to be a misfit and that would come with punishment because misfits were generally harmful to society in the short term.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoInteresting thought in your second paragraph. Through similar reasoning it would also follow that one of the bigger forces promoting science - or at least applied science - would be war. It's one of those things that keep you grounded in reality - the ship will either sail or it will sink; the shell will either land on target or it will miss. When your invention is going to be put into combat use, you can't get away with nice-sounding stories. You get instant and often visceral feedback.
- jandrese 6y agoAt one level yes, most everything built will disintegrate with time, but we have fossilized footprints from dinosaurs. An industrial society disappearing without a trace seems unlikely. Although the vast majority of the evidence would be lost there will always be traces left if you know what to look for.
- withinboredom 6y agoThe thing is, it’s probably unbelievable when you do find evidence. https://archaeology-world.com/200-million-year-old-shoe-print-found-on-a-lump-of-coal/ https://archaeology-world.com/200-million-year-old-shoe-prin...
- bwood 6y agoInteresting article, but unfortunately none of it is verifiable. It cites creationism.org (!!!) as a source and concludes that the fossil shoeprint is regrettably lost.
- dwaltrip 6y ago> It cites creationism.org (!!!) Ouch... that's an enormous red flag. That irrecoverably tarnishes the entire article.
- withinboredom 6y agoYeah, that was part of the point I implied. Much fossils were found before “modern archaeological practices” were invented and used. Now, we only have myths (for lack of a better word) about them. So it only enhances the unbelievability of the item. Another point that I don’t see made, is that if there was advanced tech, the “artifacts” were likely used until they ceased to exist and/or their purpose was lost. Just think about our own society. If our entire power grid was lost, we would probably lose the ability to repair/rebuild them within a few generations. There may be pockets where electricity still runs, and some people will remember, but there will be no way to build new computers or phones, so they will invariably be brought to wherever electricity still exists, but even then, the ability to recreate them will cease to exist.
- pmayrgundter 6y agoI strongly agree with this take. I've been working on a paper comparing the effects of the Anthropocene to mega catastrophes in the geologically recent past. In addition to the Younger Dryas Impact (12kya), there's the Oruani (26kya) and Mt Toba (77kya) eruptions. From my calculations, it seems the climate change from each of these dwarfs any actions humans are currently capable of, namely petrocarbon burning and also total nuclear war. I'm also critical of the account given to these events in the IPCC reports. It seems unbelievable to me that the climate change debate isn't considering these more, so I'm still debugging the numbers and research. But happy to take comments from anyone who's interested! https://docs.google.com/document/d/1yo9yHMfEnEepefDCRdar-B-4DhlPCifnQF1IOv8TcDg/edit# https://docs.google.com/document/d/1yo9yHMfEnEepefDCRdar-B-4...
- ncmncm 6y agoPrevious catastrophes did not vent the millions of tons of hydrofluorocarbons into the atmosphere that we will, that break down into a greenhouse gas thousands of times as potent as CO2. (We thought switching from CFCs to HFCs would save us. Joke's on us!) The total of HFCs currently in circulation, eventually leaked or vented, will produce as much greenhouse effect as all the CO2 currently in the atmosphere. (A sharp minority of the responsible people collect it for disposal.) So, it's not just CO2. The US is supposed to switch from HFCs to something else around 2024. A lot of companies are switching to propane refrigerant ahead of time because it's cheaper, and worry about it igniting has dissipated, vs. looming ecological catastrophe. BTW, to my knowledge the Greenland structure has not been reliably dated, nor even confirmed to be a bolide crater (although it seems like one). YD bolide impact seems pretty secure, though. Temperature change might be a relatively minor effect of the CO2 concentration peak. Ocean acidification causing a collapse at the base of the food web, as marine animals become unable to fix calcium to make shells, might be more important.
- pmayrgundter 6y agoIt's not clear to me that volcanoes don't release both CFCs and HFCs. Do you have a citation? I'm looking at the wiki articles, and then at the related chem articles about HFC types and synthesis. I'm not a chemist, but a quick look around makes me think the known CFC, fluorocarbon and halomethanes in volcanic gases would suggest the same or similar compounds as in our engineering uses. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volcanic_gas#Composition https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volcanic_gas#Composition https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Halomethane https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Halomethane https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrofluorocarbon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrofluorocarbon On Hiawatha, agreed it's not yet dated, though it is recent: "The age of the crater is presently unknown, but an impact sometime during the Pleistocene is consistent with presently available geological and geophysical data." - https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6235527/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6235527/ They also raise the possibility that some of the radar returns indicate it's still hot in the center of the impact area(!). If so, it's probably one of the YDB impactors. Btw, there's been another one discovered near it: https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1029/2018GL078126 https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1029/2018GL07.... They say they don't think it's related, though it does still have large features that should have been eroded away if it were really old. We'll see!
- bufferoverflow 6y agoSome structures should survive millions of years in dry buried conditions. Like bank vaults made of thick stainless steel buried in Arizona.
- yongjik 6y agoForget skyscrapers, instead consider this: footprints. You likely made millions of them in your life. How many of them still exist? Approximately zero. It's hard to think of something more ephemeral. Yet dinosaur footprints have been fossilized. They're found all around the earth. I'm sure our civilization has already created a gazillion things more permanent than them.
- jlawson 6y agoYeah, but consider the base rate. Even if the things we create are more permanent that footprints, there are just so many footprints that some of them, by unbelievable triple-corner case coincidences, end up here for us. Even if the chance per footprint is really low, there are so many of them made over the course of hundreds of millions of years that it doesn't matter. Our 100 year industrial history is nothing compared to that.
- rmtech 6y agoIf someone starts looking they will find this layer containing plutonium-244 (which is made by nuclear explosions, 80 million year half life) and microplastics, and yeah that will make it pretty obvious. But I think you're right that if it was even 5 million years in the future you would really have to be looking for it.
- yxhuvud 6y agoI strongly doubt microplastics would survive heat and pressure well enough to not revert back to oil/gas/coal.