8 ms·
At the same time, I've been radicalized by seeing how much effort the IRS put into going after me for $1200 they couldn't even prove I owed from a year I was bu
by hombre_fatal 6y ago
At the same time, I've been radicalized by seeing how much effort the IRS put into going after me for $1200 they couldn't even prove I owed from a year I was bussing tables for one summer.
The IRS needs to prioritize its resources by going after the big fish, not obsess over kids waiting tables. A bigger IRS doesn't change the fact that it's apparently toothless against the rich and has nfi how to allocate its resources.
My attempt at optimism: going through a downsize cycle is perhaps good to compel healthy internal reorganization inside systems (biological, business, etc) that can prepare it better for a future expansion cycle.
- thesausageking 6y agoIt used to work that way but the IRS no longer prioritizes the highest earners because they can't afford to. They've been underfunded for years and auditing high earners is very expensive and often involves long legal battles which they don't have the resources to fight. Audit rates of people making $1m or more are down by 80% since 2011. Now "the top 1% of taxpayers by income were audited at a rate of 1.56%. EITC recipients, who typically have annual income under $20,000, were audited at 1.41%." Source: https://www.propublica.org/article/irs-now-audits-poor-americans-at-about-the-same-rate-as-the-top-1-percent https://www.propublica.org/article/irs-now-audits-poor-ameri...
- hombre_fatal 6y agoMaybe we just need a new agency. One that targets rich people that us plebs can support and politicians can promote. And then just keep the IRS how it is going after plebs for us to hate. Seems like institutional failure if I have to vote for IRS expansion, the same people going after my tiny coffer, for the IRS to go after anyone else. That's a dumb conflict of forces.
- Scoundreller 6y agoOr just start over. Dunno why my dollars that I had to go to work for and do what someone else told me to do is guiltier and more traceable than anything else.
- klyrs 6y ago> That's a dumb conflict of forces. That's deft political engineering. Congress is to blame. They tweak the budget to protect themselves and their true constituents (megadonors and lobbyists). We're in a peculiar situation where democrats and republicans are both on the "right" in their fiscal policies. Any blush of "left" policy is shouted down by bipartisan echoes of McCarthyism. The politicians of both parties are, by and large, upper class, and they collectively pit the middle class against the lower class. We don't need a new IRS, we need a new breed of politician. And enough funding for the IRS that it can audit those politicians and their donors fearlessly.
- StavrosK 6y agoOff-topic, but it strikes me as interesting how everyone always considers themselves "the masses", calling themselves "us plebes" on a forum where a six-figure salary is the norm.
- sarakayakomzin 6y agoit strikes me as interesting that you're apparently not allowed to argue in favor of making things better for everyone at a relative proportional scale given the top .01%.
- sneak 6y agoLow six figure salaries are barely middle class in many cities the US. The kinds of rich people being discussed in this thread are still a very small percentage of six-figure+ earners. I would venture to say (no pun intended) that most HN readers are not accredited investors.
- csomar 6y agoMaybe the problem is that they are a s*ty agency that randomly fines people and expect them to pay up. I don't have knowledge how the IRS works but I know at least one tax agency in this world that would fine you random amounts and just wait for your reaction. They are not in the business of fairly auditing your numbers because they'll lose, so they turn to poorer persons that they can bully. Another thing, many countries expect rich people and rich companies to hire government-certified accountants to verify your fillings (known as a Statutory auditor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Statutory_auditor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Statutory_auditor ). This makes it harder for these companies to do stuff the non-audited guy can easily do.
- perl4ever 6y agoThere is an aspect of seeming illogic I want to call out here. Maybe it's just my lack of understanding. Assuming the IRS is underfunded, saying they focus on low income people as a consequence, when it would be more lucrative to target high earners, makes no sense. The claims could all be true, but they don't appear to be connected. Why would the total amount of funding force the IRS to spend less on individual cases? An alternative hypothesis might be that it actually is more cost effective to target people with less money, for instance, people paid mainly in cash tips, but I don't have any idea if that is plausible, I'm just saying the narrative doesn't make sense to me. In general, targeting rich people seems obvious because rich people "have the money", but mathematically, it depends on how many there are when you multiply it out. Anyway, I am very open to the idea that the IRS is being stupid and counterproductive, or politically avoiding prosecuting the rich, but I think it raises the question of "why" that is not answered by saying "underfunding". They still have funding to go after one or more high earners, right, so the total amount is irrelevant if it's taken as a given.
- clusterfish 6y agoMaybe IRS just knows that they're being underfunded precisely to stop them from auditing Congress's rich sponsors, so they proactively self-censor their audits to prevent further cuts?
- EGreg 6y agoPretty much this. I don’t understand how Republicans can argue cutting funding to the IRS will save the government’s spending. Instead their goal is to make the tax base richer by cutting taxes of the rich. Many of them are all about cutting taxes to the rich and corporations, doubling down on the trickle down. They even blocked payroll tax cuts to the lower and middle class: http://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/house-republicans-defeat-two-month-payroll-tax-cut/2011/12/20/gIQAj8RI7O_story.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/house-republicans-def...
- content_sesh 6y agoWealthy people have the resources to defend themselves in court. If you live paycheck to paycheck, you generally cannot afford lawyer fees, taking time off work for court appearances, or the risk of actually losing a case, or the probably million other things I'm not thinking about right now. It is almost always easier to go after the poor than it is to go after the rich and powerful.
- JTbane 6y agoThis is infuriating, and is basically an admission that the rich are allowed to evade taxes.
- DarkmSparks 6y agoIts called Capitalism. Its always been the case in capitalist society that only poor people pay tax, thats why half the world had revolutions to kick it out.
- acdha 6y agoThat happens because Congress wants it to happen. They have cut funding for high value enforcement and pushed going after low income filers, which is both amenable to their major donors and helps fuel the narratives about big government and taxes being too high. This also plays out in other ways: Intuit spreads a ton of money around trying to prevent the kind of automatic tax and online filing which happens in most of the world because thinking of taxes as hard provides them with a steady stream of customers.
- miked85 6y agoDid you not report tips? It wouldn't be fair if only some people were hounded by the IRS for not paying taxes and others aren't.
- srtjstjsj 6y ago> they couldn't even prove I owed Did you owe it?
- dehrmann 6y agoI like how that comment phased it in a way that didn't deny owing the money. IIRC, the IRS assumes some amount of tips per time worked and expects taxes for that.
- miked85 6y agoInstead they were "radicalized" by the fact they should pay taxes apparently.
- FireBeyond 6y agoKinda. If you document your tips in a manner acceptable, you're taxed on those. If you don't document, then there's effectively a "standard assumption", in cash-heavy or tip-heavy/driven jobs. The flip side of this is that many servers don't document because, well, they make above the standard assumption.
- matz1 6y agoDoesn't matter if we he owe it or not. What matter is can the irs prove it?
- jjk166 6y agoRemember though that tax revenue is actually dominated by the little guy. There are some super rich tax evaders who can hide many millions from the IRS, but they are few in number and it will cost millions to recover that money after going through all the obstacles such rich people can afford to put in place. On the other hand, imagine 100 million people all under-reporting $1200 - that's $120 Billion Dollars, or about 6 NASAs. If you actually had to go after everyone, that would be extremely expensive, but if you go after just a small percentage of people, the rest will be scared into properly reporting their income. We all know one or two people who have run into serious trouble with the IRS: enough that we are familiar with the consequences but not enough that it seems like a common and socially acceptable strategy. This is by design. With the very wealthy, this strategy doesn't really work. Just because you manage to get one bank in switzerland to hand over some data doesn't mean my bank in the caimans is going to do the same. Even if the IRS were to catch up to me, I can afford to wait to cross that bridge when I come to it. You can take billions from certain people and they will still have net worths greater than some nation states - those who can afford to lose can afford to play the game. It's also worth noting that the tax code has plenty of loopholes that wealthy people and corporations can use to legitimately reduce their tax burden. IRS recovery isn't going to be able to do anything about that. If you have billions of dollars, you can afford an accountant who will make sure there's nothing for the IRS to go after. Really changing the funding of the IRS is irrelevant - were we to simplify the tax code to eliminate loopholes and make it easier for people who can't afford armies of accountants to properly pay their taxes we could both collect more money and spend less on recovery. It may be impossible to get congress to actually do that, but anyone talking about playing around with the IRS's funding is just trying to look like they're addressing a problem they really have no intention of solving.
- js2 6y ago> Remember though that tax revenue is actually dominated by the little guy. That's not correct. 4.5% of returns account for almost 60% of taxes. 17% of returns account for almost 80% of taxes. And that was before the Trump tax cuts. https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2017/10/06/a-closer-look-at-who-does-and-doesnt-pay-u-s-income-tax/ https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2017/10/06/a-closer-lo...
- seanmcdirmid 6y agoFinding mistakes and cheating from lower earning tax payers merely takes some computer time. Finding problems with richer tax payers who have more complex tax returns actually takes a lot of manual effort, so budget cuts in enforcement affect the latter much more than the former.
- BurningFrog 6y ago> The IRS needs to prioritize its resources by going after the big fish, not obsess over kids waiting tables If the IRS doesn't go after any kids waiting tables, no kids waiting tables will bother paying tax. And that's, in aggregate, a lot of money. This is a similar fallacy to the idea that cops should not investigate minor crimes - say, burglaries - until it's solved all murder. If they actually do that, burglaries will effectively be legalized, and anarchy ensues. The bigger mental trap here is I guess a failure to consider second order effects.
- nazgulnarsil 6y agoIn aggregate it isn't a lot of money. The top 25% pay 86% of all income tax. The bottom 50% pay 3% of all income taxes. Innumeracy among even educated people is why our policies are the mess they are.
- BurningFrog 6y ago> In aggregate it isn't a lot of money. You may be right. Maybe my point is better made by saying that minor spending enforcing these taxes bring in a lot of money. > Innumeracy among even educated people is why our policies are the mess they are. I'd say it mostly just reflects the relative power of various interests.
- mdifrgechd 6y agoI'm coming late to this, but I think there is a parallel in policing generally, where cops would rather take on low risk, easy win "mall cop" activities like petty drug and traffic enforcement than deal with major crimes that have a real harm in society. Without a much more specific mandate from lawmakers, it is too easy to go after minor infractions by defenceless people instead of doing some hard work.
- ilikehurdles 6y agoAn underfunded IRS can’t afford to dedicate vast resources to go after big sophisticated tax cheats.
- LorenPechtel 6y agoThe problem is it can be so hard to prove misdeeds on the part of the rich. Most of the stuff the average Joe does causes reports from the other side of the deal, the IRS simply needs to match them up. Easy peasy, I get a notice from the IRS that I didn't report $1234 because I slipped up and typed $1233. Look at the various reported tax games with Donald Trump, though--many involve situations where the other side of the transaction is cooperating. If both sides are dirty the IRSs job becomes much harder. Also, the more complex financial transactions can't be distilled down to standardized reporting so well, it's much harder to match both sides.