10 ms·
Since 2009, it has brought in more than $12 billion from individuals. Friendly reminder that IRS enforcement is one of the most cost-effective activities that
by nerdponx 6y ago
Since 2009, it has brought in more than $12 billion from individuals.
Friendly reminder that IRS enforcement is one of the most cost-effective activities that the federal government can engage in, and that Congress has consistently cut funding for the IRS for years and years [0][1][2][3][4]:
Cutting the IRS budget didn’t make sense to [John Koskinen]. It was one of the few areas of government that had a positive return on investment. Koskinen told the Senate, “I don’t know any organization in my 20 years of experience in the private sector that has said, ‘I think I’ll take my revenue operation and starve it for funds.’”
It should be obvious that a politician who votes to cut IRS funding, especially when that funding can go toward enforcement, does not represent the interests of the common people they represent.
If you are a white-collar employee making $100k, $200k, or even higher, you should be especially concerned, since you bear a large portion of the nation's tax burden and expect that your tax money be spent well. 25% marginal tax rate is a bitter pill to swallow when you know that others are not paying their fair share.
[0]: https://www.cbpp.org/federal-tax/depletion-of-irs-enforcement-is-undermining-the-tax-code https://www.cbpp.org/federal-tax/depletion-of-irs-enforcemen...
[1]: https://www.propublica.org/article/has-the-irs-hit-bottom https://www.propublica.org/article/has-the-irs-hit-bottom
[2]: https://www.cnbc.com/2018/05/11/budget-cuts-shrink-the-irs-and-corporations-are-the-big-winners.html https://www.cnbc.com/2018/05/11/budget-cuts-shrink-the-irs-a...
[3]: https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2018/12/rich-people-are-getting-away-not-paying-their-taxes/577798/ https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2018/12/rich-pe...
[4]: https://www.propublica.org/article/how-the-irs-was-gutted https://www.propublica.org/article/how-the-irs-was-gutted
- hombre_fatal 6y agoAt the same time, I've been radicalized by seeing how much effort the IRS put into going after me for $1200 they couldn't even prove I owed from a year I was bussing tables for one summer. The IRS needs to prioritize its resources by going after the big fish, not obsess over kids waiting tables. A bigger IRS doesn't change the fact that it's apparently toothless against the rich and has nfi how to allocate its resources. My attempt at optimism: going through a downsize cycle is perhaps good to compel healthy internal reorganization inside systems (biological, business, etc) that can prepare it better for a future expansion cycle.
- thesausageking 6y agoIt used to work that way but the IRS no longer prioritizes the highest earners because they can't afford to. They've been underfunded for years and auditing high earners is very expensive and often involves long legal battles which they don't have the resources to fight. Audit rates of people making $1m or more are down by 80% since 2011. Now "the top 1% of taxpayers by income were audited at a rate of 1.56%. EITC recipients, who typically have annual income under $20,000, were audited at 1.41%." Source: https://www.propublica.org/article/irs-now-audits-poor-americans-at-about-the-same-rate-as-the-top-1-percent https://www.propublica.org/article/irs-now-audits-poor-ameri...
- hombre_fatal 6y agoMaybe we just need a new agency. One that targets rich people that us plebs can support and politicians can promote. And then just keep the IRS how it is going after plebs for us to hate. Seems like institutional failure if I have to vote for IRS expansion, the same people going after my tiny coffer, for the IRS to go after anyone else. That's a dumb conflict of forces.
- Scoundreller 6y agoOr just start over. Dunno why my dollars that I had to go to work for and do what someone else told me to do is guiltier and more traceable than anything else.
- klyrs 6y ago> That's a dumb conflict of forces. That's deft political engineering. Congress is to blame. They tweak the budget to protect themselves and their true constituents (megadonors and lobbyists). We're in a peculiar situation where democrats and republicans are both on the "right" in their fiscal policies. Any blush of "left" policy is shouted down by bipartisan echoes of McCarthyism. The politicians of both parties are, by and large, upper class, and they collectively pit the middle class against the lower class. We don't need a new IRS, we need a new breed of politician. And enough funding for the IRS that it can audit those politicians and their donors fearlessly.
- ForHackernews 6y ago> 25% marginal tax rate is a bitter pill to swallow laughs in European
- amingilani 6y agoAs someone that recently moved to Canada this almost made me cry.
- david-gpu 6y agoContext for non-Canadians: income above CAD$220K has a marginal tax rate around 53% in Ontario [0]. It's similar in other provinces. [0] https://www.taxtips.ca/taxrates/on.htm https://www.taxtips.ca/taxrates/on.htm
- jonas21 6y agoTo be fair, if you live in California and make $220K/yr, your marginal tax rate on salary is 46% (35% federal + 9.3% state + 1.45% medicare)
- verst 6y agoTax rate is 42% for all income above 55,960 Euros in Germany. That doesn't even include a few other taxes you might likely have to pay. Top tax bracket for the income tax portion is 45%.
- klipt 6y agoBut I assume housing is more affordable than the $2 million houses in Silicon Valley.
- verst 6y agoWages in Germany are much lower. Owning a home in a city like Berlin doesn't seem a lot easier than in SF. People are fine doing long term rentals with rent control. Not everything is about Silicon Valley. You can move away to afford better housing. That's what I did.
- Meekro 6y agoHaving a bored and well-funded cop on every street corner, looking for crimes, is not the best thing for a free society. "Make sure everyone pays their fair share" seems reasonable, but all too often degenerates into "spend years harassing a single mother over the EITC tax credit, then chalk it up as a win when she folds." I've seen those return-on-investment studies saying "for every $1 allocated to the IRS, they collect $10 in unpaid taxes," but how much of that comes from harassing people who end up paying because they can't afford to spend years litigating in tax court, versus people who were actually hiding income?
- nerdponx 6y agoThe point is to specifically fund enforcement against actual tax evaders. They go after small cases because they have no resources to go after anything bigger.
- srtjstjsj 6y agoDo you have any evidence for your speculation?
- twirlock 6y agoOthers have commented with statistics about this basic element of reality in the U.S.
- fortran77 6y agoEITC fraud is a major problem.
- cheezebubba 6y agoThere is no way to correctly assess how much tax should be owed in even moderately complicated situations. Income tax law is way too vague and relies so much on the intentions behind activities. It's also always playing catch-up to new tech. Enforcement involves substantial interpretations that reasonable people in and out of the IRS can disagree on. This is not an argument for more or less enforcement, but I've found people usually neglect this aspect.
- nerdponx 6y agoVery good point. Our massively over-complicated tax code only advantages wealthy people who intend to cheat or skimp on taxes, and tax prep companies like Intuit -- the latter of whom actively and successfully lobby Congress against tax reform. This should be a bipartisan issue, but neither party seems interested in tackling it. A cynic might argue that this is because both parties are interested in maintaining the status quo, their leadership being full of people who benefit from it (or friends of such people). It also helps ensure that running the country is expensive and inefficient, making progressive policy harder to implement.
- OnACoffeeBreak 6y agoThis is an anecdote that I have not tried to verify, so take that for what it's worth. A colleague in the early 2000s immigrated from New Zealand to the US. His wife went to get a job at a grocery store, and he told me that he was amazed that the hiring manager could not tell them how much of her pay would go to taxes. The implication being that this sort of thing is easy to figure out in NZ, but impossible in the US because of complexities in the US income tax system.
- vkou 6y ago> His wife went to get a job at a grocery store, and he told me that he was amazed that the hiring manager could not tell them how much of her pay would go to taxes. The implication being that this sort of thing is easy to figure out in NZ, but impossible in the US because of complexities in the US income tax system. That's because the hiring manager doesn't need to understand tax rates to do his job. He plugs the numbers into the black-box HR system, and the system spits out dollars, that he pays employees with. The reason for why you have no idea how much the government will take in taxes, is because income taxes are progressive, and are charged based on total income earned per year. So, someone working at a $200,000/year job for a year, will have a tax rate of ~26.5% (I'm ignoring Social Security). But if they were unemployed for 9 months, and started working that job on October 1st, they will have a tax rate of ~16.5%. What this means is that when you start a job, you have to guess what your likely annual tax rate is going to be, and set up withholding for that amount. If you underpay by a large enough sum, the IRS will send you a bill, with an extra penalty next April. If you overpay, the IRS will send you a tax return.
- tertiary 6y ago> Congress has consistently cut funding for the IRS for years and years I just want to clarify that de-funding the IRS doesn't have universal support in congress and is actually a partisan policy. I'm guessing you know that and are just toning it down to be less politically offensive on HN. However, this is an important distinction and not for the sake of finger pointing. It's important because it means that we have the power to change our government. We have the power to demand better of our politicians and to refuse to vote for them if they support policies that make it easier for tax cheats to walk while increasing the tax burden on everyday people. I understand why you might want to tone it down and just blame congress and all politicians for this type of policy (because, yes politicians are gross and should be kept at an arm's length), but that breeds the idea that we are just stuck with a broken government that can't be changed. You really can have an effect on government if you are willing to look at who historically votes for policies like this and make the choice that is best for you. If you didn't have power in the process, then our politicians wouldn't be spending so much money on campaigns to get you to their side. From the articles you linked: > The IRS has never been a popular cause on Capitol Hill. But Democrats and Republicans long shared a grudging consensus that the agency’s basic work of tax collection deserved protection. That changed when the Republican Party came into power in 1994 and Newt Gingrich became the speaker of the House. The new majority’s main priority was tax cuts, and vilifying the IRS helped its case. > The notion wasn’t a fringe position within the party. Former Sen. Richard Lugar of Indiana, a respected mainstream Republican, ran for president in 1996 on a platform of abolishing the IRS. A Republican congressman in 1998 introduced a bill to repeal the Internal Revenue Code by 2002. “Abolish the IRS” remains a potent talking point. Ted Cruz, the Republican senator from Texas, campaigned on the slogan when he ran for president in 2016. > Republicans, riding the Tea Party wave, took control of the House of Representatives and started hacking at the IRS’ enforcement budget > Down it went, some years the cuts were steep, some not, as Republican lawmakers laughed off dire warnings about the consequences of letting tax cheats run free.
- cheezebubba 6y agohttps://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/FYFRGDA188S https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/FYFRGDA188S Graph of Federal Government receipts as percentage of GDP. Does this show that gutting the IRS has resulted in lower tax revenue?
- sthnblllII 6y agoNo it looks like revenues have been flat.
- elindbe2 6y agoGlad that was cleared up.
- syshum 6y ago>>since you bear a large portion of the nation's tax burden I noticed that you did not provide any sources for this statement, which is fitting given it is not true. > It was one of the few areas of government that had a positive return on investment Scoping any type of Law Enforcement in terms of "Return on Investment" rubs me the wrong way.
- m463 6y agoWhat's interesting is that a few years ago, Ron Paul made a pretty good argument with respect to abolishing the IRS. He wanted to fund the government with excise taxes and tariffs like it was funded for many years. Thing is, people who are accustomed to the IRS, thought he was a little "out there" because of it.
- rsynnott 6y agoThat would tend to encourage raising tariffs. Which is, generally, bad for business (and gets very complicated in the context of trade treaties and the WTO).
- SamReidHughes 6y agoIncome taxes are a tariff on labor.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Income taxes are a tariff on labor. Payroll taxes are a tariff on labor, income taxes include non-labor (but “long-term” capital only at a favored rate) income, so aren't exactly a tariff on labor, though they also aren't neutral between sources of income.
- gamblor956 6y agoA tariff is very literally defined as a tax on imported goods, so neither income taxes nor payroll taxes are tariffs on labor. They are simply taxes on labor.
- m463 6y agoSo what would happen is that businesses fight for lower tariffs, and are the check on incremental government growth. Instead with the IRS, the taxes keep on going up and up and the little guy can't do anything meaningful to fight the trend. (hmmm... looking at where we are now, maybe the businesses won in their battle to lower tariffs - shifting them to individuals)
- jb775 6y agoYour line of thinking is flawed in multiple ways: 1) The federal government is not a business, it's a federal government. It shouldn't be looking at taxes as a "cost-effective activity with a positive return on investment". 2) The entire concept of increasing the IRS's budget so they can collect more money is circular reasoning that leads us down a race-to-the-bottom scenario, but the "bottom" in this case is maximizing tax revenue to the point where everyone is squeezed dry....because the government apparently knows how to spend their money better. I.E. Increase the IRS budget so we can collect more taxes, so we can increase the IRS budget so we can collect more taxes, so we can... 3) For your final selfish argument, it's debatable to say it's better for you that others spend their money on taxes rather than less on taxes and spending it however they please. Any standard macroeconomics course will show you that people spend most of the money they have access to. In other words, they're injecting that money directly back into the economy, which typically adds ~10x in value to the economy as a whole, as it trickles through the supply chain. e.g. they buy a new couch: delivery guys get paid to deliver it, delivery company profits off the delivery, furniture store salesperson makes a commission, furniture store makes a profit, couch manufacturer makes a profit, company who produces couch cushions gets another order to replace the sold couch, couch cushion company orders more fabric and couch cushion stuffing.....
- gamblor956 6y agoThe IRS collects more money by collecting the money people actually owe but did not pay. Taxes could be reduced by as much as 10% if the IRS was able to collect the underpaid taxes. I don't know why you're against that. For your final selfish argument, it's debatable to say it's better for you that others spend their money on taxes rather than less on taxes and spending it however they please. The IRS doesn't determine tax rates or tax laws, it just enforces them. And to note, all of the infrastructure that pays for the road the delivery company used the deliver the couch, and the forests which provided the lumber for the couch's frame, and the ease of contract which made all of these transactions...were all made possible by the taxes collected and paid by all of these people. Tax is a vital part of the economy. It's the price (fee) you pay for the government services that underpin everything else.
- 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- renewiltord 6y ago>Friendly reminder that IRS enforcement is one of the most cost-effective activities that the federal government can engage in, and that Congress has consistently cut funding for the IRS for years and years It hardly matters whether it makes money. Two things come to mind: * Civil asset forfeiture is one of the most profitable acts for police departments. California outlawed this for money below some large sum. * Traffic tickets are one of the most profitable acts for some city departments. I would far prefer that they reduce that. I don't care that the Federal Government makes money. It is not a good thing that it makes money. It is just a thing. When North Carolina came after me for taxes they thought I owed, only for them to reduce the judgment from the many thousands to a few hundred dollars when I sent them a "yo, I think you're mistaken" letter, I didn't feel pleasure. The fact that they insisted any further appeal could only occur in person, knowing full well that a flight to that state cost more than paying the bill, I did not feel like the government was made better through the experience. If they had decided that they should collect the whole amount I would not feel like they would be doing a better job.
- adir1 6y agoIn my opinion the best solution to this is https://fairtax.org/ https://fairtax.org/
- 1MachineElf 6y agoMaybe the institution with a monopoly on violence shouldn't have a profit center?