18 ms·
The IRS Sets a Trap for Cryptocurrency Tax Cheats
- Schweigi 6y agoNo paywall: https://archive.is/fFni3 https://archive.is/fFni3
- murbard2 6y agoGreat product placement.
- nerdponx 6y agoSince 2009, it has brought in more than $12 billion from individuals. Friendly reminder that IRS enforcement is one of the most cost-effective activities that the federal government can engage in, and that Congress has consistently cut funding for the IRS for years and years [0][1][2][3][4]: Cutting the IRS budget didn’t make sense to [John Koskinen]. It was one of the few areas of government that had a positive return on investment. Koskinen told the Senate, “I don’t know any organization in my 20 years of experience in the private sector that has said, ‘I think I’ll take my revenue operation and starve it for funds.’” It should be obvious that a politician who votes to cut IRS funding, especially when that funding can go toward enforcement, does not represent the interests of the common people they represent. If you are a white-collar employee making $100k, $200k, or even higher, you should be especially concerned, since you bear a large portion of the nation's tax burden and expect that your tax money be spent well. 25% marginal tax rate is a bitter pill to swallow when you know that others are not paying their fair share. [0]: https://www.cbpp.org/federal-tax/depletion-of-irs-enforcement-is-undermining-the-tax-code https://www.cbpp.org/federal-tax/depletion-of-irs-enforcemen... [1]: https://www.propublica.org/article/has-the-irs-hit-bottom https://www.propublica.org/article/has-the-irs-hit-bottom [2]: https://www.cnbc.com/2018/05/11/budget-cuts-shrink-the-irs-and-corporations-are-the-big-winners.html https://www.cnbc.com/2018/05/11/budget-cuts-shrink-the-irs-a... [3]: https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2018/12/rich-people-are-getting-away-not-paying-their-taxes/577798/ https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2018/12/rich-pe... [4]: https://www.propublica.org/article/how-the-irs-was-gutted https://www.propublica.org/article/how-the-irs-was-gutted
- hombre_fatal 6y agoAt the same time, I've been radicalized by seeing how much effort the IRS put into going after me for $1200 they couldn't even prove I owed from a year I was bussing tables for one summer. The IRS needs to prioritize its resources by going after the big fish, not obsess over kids waiting tables. A bigger IRS doesn't change the fact that it's apparently toothless against the rich and has nfi how to allocate its resources. My attempt at optimism: going through a downsize cycle is perhaps good to compel healthy internal reorganization inside systems (biological, business, etc) that can prepare it better for a future expansion cycle.
- thesausageking 6y agoIt used to work that way but the IRS no longer prioritizes the highest earners because they can't afford to. They've been underfunded for years and auditing high earners is very expensive and often involves long legal battles which they don't have the resources to fight. Audit rates of people making $1m or more are down by 80% since 2011. Now "the top 1% of taxpayers by income were audited at a rate of 1.56%. EITC recipients, who typically have annual income under $20,000, were audited at 1.41%." Source: https://www.propublica.org/article/irs-now-audits-poor-americans-at-about-the-same-rate-as-the-top-1-percent https://www.propublica.org/article/irs-now-audits-poor-ameri...
- hombre_fatal 6y agoMaybe we just need a new agency. One that targets rich people that us plebs can support and politicians can promote. And then just keep the IRS how it is going after plebs for us to hate. Seems like institutional failure if I have to vote for IRS expansion, the same people going after my tiny coffer, for the IRS to go after anyone else. That's a dumb conflict of forces.
- Scoundreller 6y agoOr just start over. Dunno why my dollars that I had to go to work for and do what someone else told me to do is guiltier and more traceable than anything else.
- miked85 6y agoI don't see how this is any sort of trap. It just removes the possibility the tax payer can feign ignorance about having to pay taxes on cryptocurrency transactions.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y ago> For their part, many crypto users are angry with the IRS’s guidance, which treats bitcoin, ether and their kin as property rather than currency. So if a crypto holder uses it to buy something or exchanges one cryptocurrency for another, there’s usually a capital gain or loss to report on the tax return. I was confused by this statement, as my understanding is that treating it as a currency would result in worse tax consequences.
- vmception 6y agoCan you elaborate? Currency treatment wouldn’t make sense for most digital assets but what way would the tax treatment be worse than unclassified property?
- sokoloff 6y agoIf I buy Euros with USD and then buy a meal or hotel stay with those Euros, I don’t pay any US tax (and importantly, I have no IRS paperwork obligation) regardless of whether the Euro-USD exchange rate changed on the meantime. The same is not true if you replace Euro with Bitcoin above.
- vmception 6y agoThat doesn’t answer the question, that was an unnecessary example about the status quo, how would it be worse if the IRS treated them like currency because you just wrote an example showing how it would be better. Let’s just wait for the person I originally responded to then
- funkaster 6y agoI got a letter from the IRS a few months ago and the text said something along the lines of “we know you have accounts on cryptocurrency trading services. Please be aware that crypto trading is taxable and you can face severe penalties and even jail if you don’t report them”. I do have accounts but I have not traded with them... My guess the account they’re referring to is the one in coinbase, which I have not used since they announced the service.
- vmception 6y agoMy annoyance with the Coinbase data is that even Coinbase assumes your crypto is a capital gain or capital loss. Paying an invoice? Never considered that! Tax deductible transaction? With crypto huh, never asked! Receiving crypto for services rendered? What do you mean using crypto for what it was designed for I’m so confused! The asset doesnt matter, only the nature of the transaction matters
- mrgordon 6y agoIsn’t this how the IRS treats it so that’s how Coinbase has to treat it? If one buys a bagel with Bitcoin, then one needs to treat it as a sale of Bitcoin to US Dollars
- ibeckermayer 6y agoYes, hence the entire crypto fad is a mass delusion built on lies. It’s regulated like a security, hence you’re not going to be able to use it like currency. Ever.
- shiado 6y agoGiven that crypto is regulated as merely being property, it seems quite arbitrary to ask questions specifically related to it. Where is the Beanie Baby question or the question about my old Magic cards sitting in a box?
- dawnerd 6y agoYou’d be reporting a loss on those!
- vmception 6y agoBetter tax laws will help with tax compliance. Can I deduct transaction fees? Maybe only business transaction fees? There are a lot of unanswered questions. I plan to on my 2020 tax filings next year. I’ve never had an issue reporting crypto assets on my taxes since 2014. I wouldnt have been included in the “only 800 people that reported” according to the IRS’ flawed study which was just a search string for bitcoin or btc, as I was mining litecoin back then and receiving capital gains in litecoin back then. I looked and I literally had typed in LTC in a capital gain document. These guys are so far behind reality. The new question should be “are you yield farming and did you claim any liquidity mining airdrop?” but sure lets just wait till 2027 for them to catch up
- Scoundreller 6y ago> In late August, the agency released guidance affirming that taxpayers who receive crypto for completing “microtasks” must declare it as income. What if I received valuable content in exchange for identifying fire hydrants or traffic lights?
- edoceo 6y agoIt's income
- sokoloff 6y agoSame tax treatment as if you watch ad-supported broadcast TV. De minimis value rules come into play if nothing else applies.
- rossjudson 6y agoCryptoholders should consider themselves lucky it's not considered a "collectible". For example: "For federal income tax purposes, gold is considered a collectible - just like art, stamps, or those baseball cards you've been hoarding. What that means is that instead of a maximum long-term capital gains rate of 15% for most taxpayers (20% for high-income taxpayers), you'll pay a maximum long-term capital gains rate of 28%."
- gamblor956 6y agoIf you receive enough valuable content in exchange for that menial task, you report it on your income tax return and pay taxes on it. Generally, the value of the content you receive (to you) is so immaterial that you would have to spend your entire year on it to receive enough of it to be subject to tax.
- bgitarts 6y agoHow is this question not a violation of the IRS bill of rights #7, the right to privacy?: https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/taxpayer-bill-of-rights-7-the-right-to-privacy-0 https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/taxpayer-bill-of-rights-7-the-r...
- javert 6y agoHey, this is a really good question. Any tax lawyers here? Has anyone tried to bring this to court?
- octoberfranklin 6y agoI would guess that the Taxpayer Bill of Rights is one of those silly "does not create a private right of enforcement" non-laws. As in yes, it's a law, but nobody who cares about it has the right to enforce it in court.
- javert 6y agoI would guess that too, but it would be nice to hear from someone who actually knows.
- heimatau 6y agoThe IRS is the law. If you have specific questions, hire your own advocates.
- javert 6y ago> The IRS is the law. If you have specific questions, hire your own advocates. This is such a mean, nasty thing to say to me. What's wrong with you?
- ac29 6y agoThe question is: "At any time during 2020, did you sell, receive, send, exchange or otherwise acquire any financial interest in any virtual currency?" and right #7 says: "Taxpayers have the right to expect that any IRS inquiry, examination, or enforcement action will comply with the law and be no more intrusive than necessary" Whats the confusion? The IRS has a legitimate power to ask taxpayers about their income, in compliance with the law. Asking the question doesn't appear to be "more intrusive than necessary".
- king_panic 6y agoSpicy title
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- neonate 6y agohttps://archive.is/fFni3 https://archive.is/fFni3
- twirlock 6y agoHow about they just collect fucking taxes?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- unnouinceput 6y agoQuote: "In late August, the agency released guidance affirming that taxpayers who receive crypto for completing “microtasks” must declare it as income. This applies to users of firms like StormX, which makes tiny payments in crypto to people who do small tasks such as playing games, answering surveys, or evaluating products." Ahhh, but this is heaven. If I'd be an US citizen doing crypto transactions I'd made sure after each of them to write them down already prepared. Then when tax declaration season comes hit IRS with a bag of 20 kilos of paper in declarations. No more than 1000 people to do this and trust me, IRS will change their tune so fast your head will spin.
- paulgb 6y agoThe way US taxes generally work is that you don't provide the transaction-level details to the IRS when you file your taxes, just the aggregate. You only provide the transaction-level details if and when you are asked to during an audit.
- unnouinceput 6y agoRead the article. In regards to crypto they expect exactly that. Here is another quote from article, above: "“Buying a sandwich with cryptocurrency shouldn’t be a taxable event,” says Sean Cover, a New York City cryptocurrency holder who works in finance for a nonprofit group. He says that in 2017 he had more than 500 transactions on several platforms, and it took him 10 hours to prepare his crypto tax forms even though he paid for special software. "
- paulgb 6y agoOh, you're right, it looks like the IRS requires every crypto transaction to be listed on form 8949. My mistake.
- gamblor956 6y agoA crypto transaction is a transaction of a capital asset, so yes, it is exactly that and Sean should choose to use regular USD next time if he doesn't want to track all of his capital asset transactions. You live by the sword, you die by the sword, and all that. But generally if your return would exceed a certain length you now have to file electronically.
- castratikron 6y agoIt doesn't say "crypto" currency, it says "any virtual currency". So what do they mean by any virtual currency? ACH direct deposit? Starbucks gift cards? RuneScape gold? Virtual currency is just currency that isn't physical. Bitcoin was not the first virtual currency (nor the first decentralized currency). They should just remind everyone that cryptocurrency counts as income. No need for a question that has an ambiguous answer. This is going to confuse a lot of people.
- bastawhiz 6y agoACH direct deposit is absolutely not a currency in any sense of the concept. It's a vehicle for USD—direct deposit has no value, it's a transaction. Gift cards can maybe be considered a form of currency, but they're hardly able to be treated as one since you can redeem them in exactly one way, and the issuer needs to count them as a liability in the currency they were issued in (mining a bitcoin doesn't create debt on Satoshi's corporate ledger). You can argue the semantics all day, but nobody is buying up and trading millions of dollars in Starbucks gift cards. Arguing that these rules are for any purpose other than cryptocurrency is wild. The IRS doesn't create rules for things that aren't a material concern, and cryptocurrency is the only recent "virtual currency" that is a material concern.
- akimball 6y agoTaxation is obsolete as a revenue mechanism for a monetary sovereign. The only value of taxation is to discourage an activity. To discourage the generation of income is profoundly counterproductive.
- darthvadr 6y agoThey already did something similar last year so this comes as no surprise. There are tax calculation services like https://koinly.io https://koinly.io you can use to speed this up (for free)
- codecamper 6y agoIf the IRS wants to tax crypto gains, it must also offer credits for crypto losses. That seems problematic. I would imagine the total reported crypto losses > crypto gains.
- codecamper 6y agoAlso, since crypto gains are considered capital gains, then any capital losses you have been accumulating can now be used vs your capital gains. The problem here is.. how the heck can the IRS verify your claim that some gains were capital gains? What if you sell drugs for a living and invest poorly in the stock market. You just send your drug sales gains in as crypto gains, and so you have effectively washed your illegal gains, giving you the benefit of being able to not pay tax on that bc of your capital losses. This system is ripe for abuse.
- greenyoda 6y agoThat's exactly how it works - you pay taxes on net gains (gains minus losses) in a tax year, and if there's a net loss you can deduct and/or carry it over. Why is that problematic? It's exactly how gains/losses work when trading shares of stock. For more information: https://www.irs.gov/individuals/international-taxpayers/frequently-asked-questions-on-virtual-currency-transactions https://www.irs.gov/individuals/international-taxpayers/freq...
- habosa 6y agoIn 2017 I played with a bunch of cryptocurrencies and made a small amount of money, which I decided to report. Oh my god was that a pain. No help from the exchanges whatsoever. Had to compile a huge spreadsheet myself to make a big custom 1040/8949. I hope it's easier now. I'm also glad they're trying to enforce this now. I know many people who made money speculating on crypto and not one of them reported it. The crypto community has a really nasty anti tax undercurrent (see: crypto communities moving to Puerto Rico)
- AYBABTME 6y agoSame, and it made me decide I wouldn't deal with cryptocurrencies until this stuff has proper infrastructure around it. It was such a pain in the behind to write scripts to reconcile all the weirdly formatted transactions and movements across exchanges. I'm not even sure it worked out properly in the end, but after spending 5 days doing it, I decided what I got was probably close enough to the truth, and I called it day. If the IRS is ever unhappy about it, I wish them good luck figuring out the actual number. I'll happily pay the penalty if they make the calculation for me and save me the trouble!
- jrnichols 6y agoLet me get this straight.. I open a Coinbase account. I feed it $50 for some bitcoin, and use a small amount to pay for a web hosting package somewhere. I then have to pay taxes on whatever bitcoin is left if the value of BTC goes up? this sounds... way more complicated than I thought.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- greenyoda 6y agoYou need to pay tax on any capital gain you incurred when you converted the bitcoin to dollars to pay for that web hosting package. For example: On 1/1/2020 you bought $50 worth of bitcoin. On 6/1/2020, you converted your bitcoin to dollars to pay for hosting. By that point, let's say, the price of bitcoin had doubled, so you sold half of your bitcoin to pay your $50 hosting fee, thus getting $50 for bitcoin that you bought for $25. Your taxable capital gain would be $25 ($50 - $25). (I'm assuming that even if the hosting provider accepts bitcoin as payment, the price of their services is denominated in dollars.) The bitcoin that's left in the account (now valued at $50) is not subject to any taxes until the year when you sell or exchange it. In general, on your 2020 tax return, you'll be reporting income (including capital gains) that you received in the 2020 calendar year. For more information: https://www.irs.gov/individuals/international-taxpayers/frequently-asked-questions-on-virtual-currency-transactions https://www.irs.gov/individuals/international-taxpayers/freq...
- BMSmnqXAE4yfe1 6y agoI remember ticking this box on 2019 tax form, so that's nothing new.
- greenyoda 6y agoAs the article explains, the new thing is that on the 2020 form everyone needs to answer that question: "The crypto question first appeared on the 2019 tax form, but on a part of the return that not all filers had to answer. Now it’s moving to the 1040’s most prominent spot, just below the taxpayer’s name and address."
- BMSmnqXAE4yfe1 6y agoInterestingly, I used taxact and taxact programmers thought that all filers had to answer that question. In case of a Yes, they added a Schedule 1 form with that question on top.
- matt-attack 6y agoSo why does it not list “hold” as needing reporting? If I merely own coins do I need to say yes?
- greenyoda 6y ago> So why does it not list “hold” as needing reporting? Because merely owning an asset does not create any federal tax obligations. > If I merely own coins do I need to say yes? The question on the form is: "At any time during 2020, did you sell, receive, send, exchange or otherwise acquire any financial interest in any virtual currency?" So if you merely owned cryptocurrency that was acquired before 2020, the truthful answer would be "no".
- t0mmyb0y 6y agoCrazy how the irs can do this when the feds own the largest exchange!?!?!?
- Terretta 6y ago> ”At any time in 2020, did you even crypto?” See, this is why you HODL: Hodl (/ˈhɒdəl/ HOD-əl; often written HODL) is slang in the cryptocurrency community for holding the cryptocurrency rather than selling it. A person who does this is known as a Hodler. It originated in a December 2013 post on the Bitcoin Forum message board by an apparently inebriated user who posted with a typo in the subject, "I AM HODLING." In 2017, Quartz listed it as one of the essential slang terms in Bitcoin culture, and described it as a stance, "to stay invested in bitcoin and not to capitulate in the face of plunging prices." TheStreet.com referred to it as the "favorite mantra" of Bitcoin holders. Though originally used in relation to holding Bitcoin, it is now also used to describe holding other cryptocurrencies and tokens. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hodl https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hodl
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]