11 ms·
How about we go back to where we were in the beginning: Apps can be free or cost money. If they cost money, Apple can take a cut. Apps can sell anything they
by alkonaut 6y ago
How about we go back to where we were in the beginning:
Apps can be free or cost money. If they cost money, Apple can take a cut.
Apps can sell anything they want that’s part of the app (game levels) and must then use in-app purchases.
All other sales both physical and non-physical (media, tickets, parking, ...) you can sell how you want.
Are these terms really that absurd?
- oh_sigh 6y agoCan I sell a non-physical item, like a ticket, which when you type its ID into the app, it unlocks a new level?
- alkonaut 6y agoThat would seem like you just sold the level to the AppStore reviewers
- 0xCMP 6y agoThe terms are not absurd, but currently the fight I've seen is around: a) Being able to provide a free app with a subscription you can not buy in the app because of the 30% with IAP you're required to use b) The ability to purchase tokens/credits in a game to then purchase other stuff. So it wouldn't resolve the current major fights IMO.
- gamblor956 6y agoHow about we got to a place where Apple isn't taking 30% from companies just for the privilege of putting an app in the store, even when payment streams are completely unrelated to the app store and are merely provided as a convenience to customers? Apple taking 30% (or trying) from every app is bad for everyone.
- WWLink 6y agoHow about a point where Apple doesn't expect a kickback from every transaction that occurs on an apple device?
- TuringNYC 6y agoWhat happens now if the account is created now on iOS, but then I do a transaction, say via the web? Does AAPL get a share of the offline transaction also if done via the same account? A good example might be something like the Starbucks app.
- gamblor956 6y agoIt's a physical product, so currently Apple isn't attempting to levy a 30% charge on the transaction. Apple is having enough trouble getting retailers to accept Apple Pay as it is; attempting to tax physical sales would kill Apple Pay and likely bring about the immediate ire of pretty much every government of every jurisdiction they do business in.
- pwinnski 6y agoThe vast majority of apps in the store are free, which leaves Apple footing the enormous bill for providing the apps. The original idea, which worked for a few years, was that 30% of the for-fee apps helped cover the costs of the free apps. For the first few years, Apple operated their App Store at a loss, and aimed for break-even. I think subscriptions is ultimately what broke that model.
- suprfsat 6y agoThe App Store drives trillions of dollars in sales of iPhones. That's your break-even.
- singhrac 6y agoTrillions is a bit of an exaggeration, but not much. The iPhone is somewhere around 150-200bn of revenue a year.
- dane-pgp 6y agoActually, as the parent comment didn't say "per year", and the App Store was opened in 2008, "trillions" (as an aggregate) doesn't seem like an exaggeration at all.
- vbezhenar 6y agoLet me host my app on my own servers, I'll pay the bills.
- ksec 6y ago>The vast majority of apps in the store are free, which leaves Apple footing the enormous bill for providing the apps. Enormous bill of what? And lets not forget, and needs to be repeated every time this is mentioned, people are paying $99 dollar a year just to submit these "free" apps.
- zuppy 6y agoand let’s not forget about the huge markup on iPhones themselves, this should cover whatever their owner ever downloads.
- Shivetya 6y agoOh I can see a whole new method here. Buy an iPhone for %15 off price if you use Apple's App store or buy it at full price if you don't use Apple's App store. As in, let Apple subsidize the cost of the phone with the app store, I suspect a significant number of people would go for it even with just a five percent price drop. The problem currently isn't that Apple is charging what they do for the App store, the problem is they are in effect selling customers of their hardware for that amount.
- muro 6y agoAs they set the price of the iPhone, they would just increase the "non subsided" price.
- kempbellt 6y agoThey aren't taking 30% from anyone. That is their price for services provided. You are making it sound like thievery. It isn't. People know this price going in and agree to it. If you don't like the price, use (or create) an alternative.
- cma 6y agoDue to user lock-in through things like sticky iMessages, plain inertia, network effects, and anticompetitive practices, it is sort of an extortion.
- kempbellt 6y agoSome of the things they do are anticompetitive within their ecosystem, yes, and these things should be addressed. But charging 30% for using their app store is not. It's the price for access to the clubhouse that they built. If you don't like the entry fee, build your own clubhouse or find another one. Every reason you provided is more reason to build a competitive solution. None of them are incentive for Apple to lower their prices. You don't have to use Apple. You can send snail mail or use pigeon carriers like in the olden times if you want to communicate with people. And of course, you can always use the string and paper cup method to talk to your friends, rather than Facetiming. The cost you pay is for the convenience, and despite being very used to it, most people can live without it.
- stale2002 6y ago> But charging 30% for using their app store is not. The issue is not that they charge this fee. Instead it is that they prevent competing app store on their platform, through the use of anti competitive practices. If, instead, it was quick an easy to install a different app store on the iPhone, then few people would complain. > Every reason you provided is more reason to build a competitive solution Apple prevents competing app stores. Thats not really possible to get a different app store on the iPhone. This is anti-competitive, due to the size of Apple's market share, which is around 50% of the US smartphone market. This anti-competitiveness is therefore illegal, according to section 2 of the sherman anti-trust act. > If you don't like the entry fee, build your own clubhouse or find another one. You missed the other option. Which is to prosecute apple for their illegal, anti-competitive practices, and make them follow the law by allowing competing app stores.
- devmunchies 6y agoi wouldn't mind apple taking 30% on anything in the app store as long as they allowed a user to download my app from my website. Just like desktop computers. Nobody is complaining about Apple taking a cut from the Mac App Store. Personally, it's nobodies place to dictate how much Apple charges. The main complaint is over Apple's monopoly over the channel for getting apps onto your mobile device.
- gamblor956 6y agoPersonally, it's nobodies place to dictate how much Apple charges. Actually, it's everybody's place to dictate them, through commercial negotiation. Antitrust generally applies where, as with the App Store, traditional market dynamics do not apply to constrain one participant's market actions. The main complaint is over Apple's monopoly over the channel for getting apps onto your mobile device. No, that's the foundation of the antitrust claims. The main complaints are that Apple is abusing its power over the app delivery channel to force other market participants to put up with a variety of things they would otherwise never agree to if market dynamics were functioning correctly, like giving up 30% of all their income even when it's unrelated to the app itself (e.g., ticket sales), or preventing competing apps (e.g., browsing engines, mail apps like Hey, etc.), banning third-party apps from using API features in the OS or from certain forms of outreach but letting first-party apps violate those restrictions (see, all Apple apps released in the past 3 years).
- tyingq 6y agoIt sounded weird to me from the start because it doesn't match any traditional thing I'm aware of. Payment services are in the 3% range. Realtors are in the 5% range. Talent agents might be 10-20%, but usually 10%. Apple's 30% just seems outrageous.
- 1123581321 6y agoIt has its origins in the fees that game consoles and software distributors charge.
- gamblor956 6y agoConsole fees can and are negotiated by publishers. Epic, etc., are not paying MS and Sony 30% of all transactions. You can't negotiate the Apple tax, which is is a sign of market dysfunction.
- 1123581321 6y agoThat may be the case. The OP was just struggling to think of anything mainstream in that range of revenue share.
- tyingq 6y agoYes, I didn't know the gaming space was also that high. I wonder what a mob protection racket's percentage is.
- 1123581321 6y agoThis is just the start of research, but apparently Sicilian mob extracts 1.6B euro from the island with 80% of businesses paying, and the GDP is about 90B. So those businesses are perhaps losing 2.5% although the article makes it seem like they tend to be small or individual businesses that pay, which would increase that. Obviously very rough and I’d like to know more. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pizzo_(mafia) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pizzo_(mafia)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- wayneftw 6y agoHow about we just let people install whatever they want on their own pocket computers that they fully paid for? Sounds crazy, I know.
- WWLink 6y agoI agree!
- alkonaut 6y agoI wouldn’t want that. If there was a switch on my phone where I disconnected from the AppStore and could side load what I wanted I wouldn’t switch it. I quite like the service the App Store provides for the apps themselves. But I just want them to charge a cut for apps.
- ReverseCold 6y agoWhy not both? You get the AppStore and are allowed to sign apps for your own devices. (We actually already have a workaround for this: https://altstore.io/ https://altstore.io/ but it still requires Apple to sign your apps and is relatively difficult to use)
- wayneftw 6y agoOK great. I have no problem with that. I’d choose the opposite... if I had that choice. Why should we not have that choice though?
- wltprgm 6y agoThat is because apple fanboys like @alkonaut does not allow sane discussions pointing out apple flaws on iOS on Hacker News Can't you tell from his attitude? Even if you can, I still need to point that out because nobody else will
- entropea 6y agoIf you didn't want that, that's ok, but let the rest of us who want to do it, do it. I am perfectly happy with FDroid on Android and get a lot of my apps from there.
- JMTQp8lwXL 6y agoYou could attach a piece of paper to virtual purchases to get around Apple's cut. "See, I sold a physical good". Even though, that physical good could be a sheet of paper with an access code to a virtual good. Maybe you e-mail a receipt that happens to list the paper's contents for 'quicker delivery'.
- alkonaut 6y agoI mean you could get away with it for a while but if Apple think you are only circumventing then they’ll have you thrown out. Which I think is fine. You can’t have rigid rules, you need a human to interpret.
- google234123 6y agoI think Apple would rightly judge this as violating the terms of service.
- graywh 6y agoApple wanted a cut of physical packs of Pokemon cards when the code inside that pack was redeemed inside the online game on iOS. Pokemon had to disable code redemption for iOS.
- lscotte 6y agoYes. Forcing a company to use in-app purchases, rather than their own subscription model (for example), just so the app store can get a cut is wrong.
- foxtr0t 6y agoIf you want to use market power to force your anti-competitive business model on 3rd party companies or you're a corporate bootlicker defending a 2 trillion dollar corp then these terms are totally rational, not absurd at all.
- diebeforei485 6y agoThey are absurd, because of things like virtual/livestreamed fitness classes. Apple isn't providing the infrstructure or bandwidth for streaming, their role is the same whether the class is real-world (impossible during covid) or virtual. But they take 30% of revenue if it's virtual.
- megous 6y agoWhy do fitness classes need to have a special app on appstore?
- cma 6y agoApple doesn't allow web notifications for things like fitness class start time but does allow it for apps.
- megous 6y agoI guess that's nice to have, but not necessary at all.
- cma 6y agoThere are other issues, apps can be switched to the background and maintain some level of communication with the server while tabs die out faster in the background. Look up an appointment in another app or tab while the instructor is on a short break and you get disconnected in a way the app/instructor can't tell if was connection issues or just temporary, etc.
- TuringNYC 6y agoI'm not in the space, so apologies if this question is offbase. What happens if Apple takes a 30% cut of the app revenue, but you book the class offline (say, via web). But then you view via your iPad? Another example might be the various learning apps. I purchased a Coursera class via the web, but then I added via my iPad -- does Apple get a revenue from this?
- sreekotay 6y agoIf app developers are allowed to price differently on Apple platforms (pass on the costs) .... it's a good start.
- colejohnson66 6y agoThey already allow that. You just can’t tell the user that it’s different. That’s what upsets people.
- echelon 6y agoHow about we go back to a place we can install whatever we want on our computers? (The phone is a computer, not a "device" or "appliance".) If you want to use Apple's discovery and distribution system, you pay a cut. If you want to train your customers how to install on their own, you pay nothing, but have to distribute the app yourself. The DOJ needs to force Apple to allow this, because they've unfairly strong armed their way into being middle-man for over 40% of Americans for all of the computing they do.
- jbob2000 6y agoNo they don't. If you want that, you can use Android. You can develop Android apps and buy devices that use it. There is no reason to force Apple to change when there is an equal competitor in the market that allows what you want.
- nvr219 6y agoWhy would you tell somebody to use Android? Super rude.
- suprfnk 6y agoHow is it rude to suggest buying another brand of the product?
- hu3 6y agoHave your tried telling an iPhone user to use Android? Outside our bubble, most don't even know what are the implications of switching.
- imtringued 6y agoApparently I'm rude to myself
- bobthepanda 6y ago> unfairly strong armed their way into being middle-man for over 40% of Americans What about the actual selling of iPhones counts as "unfair strong-arming"? No one's getting their arms twisted to buy a phone they don't want.
- criddell 6y agoIf Apple is going to set new terms, I'd like one more added: Apps that allow you to sign up / subscribe to a service in the app must have an equally prominent and easy way of cancelling / unsubscribing in the app. No additional steps can be required (ie no calling a retention specialist).
- sova 6y agoYes, because line 4 lets me circumvent lines 2 and 3.