10 ms·
I don’t know the particulars of this location; however, often times it’s not dirty industry invading and settling in poor neighborhoods but rather poor neighbor
by mc32 6y ago
I don’t know the particulars of this location; however, often times it’s not dirty industry invading and settling in poor neighborhoods but rather poor neighborhoods sprouting up next to these industries because land is cheaper.
For example the Sriracha company settled in the middle of nowhere, the north San Jose water treatment facility was in the middle of nowhere but now you have housing next to them and people complaining about smells or pollution.
To avoid this you’ll need better more stringent zoning laws with bigger buffer zones.
- MattGaiser 6y agoThen you will have people complaining about restrictive zoning laws. You can’t win.
- Chardok 6y agoThe issue isn't just isolated to those living around it. Methane is an extremely potent greenhouse gas (https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/how-bad-of-a-greenhouse-gas-is-methane/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/how-bad-of-a-gree...), letting it leak out like that for a year has likely caused significant environmental harm.
- floren 6y agoMethane is removed from the atmosphere due to chemical reaction within about 12 years, so good news: with the leak stopped, the effects of the leak will taper off relatively quickly.
- z8rHZM8Svhu8hE2 6y agoNot entierly correct: methane "tails off to about GWP of 28 for a 100-year time frame" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atmospheric_methane#Methane_as_a_greenhouse_gas https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atmospheric_methane#Methane_as...
- pedrocr 6y agoJust because you built something in the "middle of nowhere" doesn't necessarily mean you should get to impose externalities that devalue the properties around you. It depends on what the externality is but zoning may not be enough, you may need to actually own the land you're creating restrictions over for it to be fair. Otherwise there's a first mover advantage in starting a negative spiral. If you don't do it on your land before your neighbor you get all the disadvantages without making money from the use.
- _jal 6y agoThe argument operates on a spectrum of specifics, and line drawing is always going to look absurd to someone. A similar things happens when small communities are encroached by commuters - newcomers get upset about things the locals have "always done", and it almost invariably ends up becoming a class thing. I have a relative who has lived in the same home for almost 50 years. She basically owns a hill with her house on top - it is about 2 acres. Until a few years ago, she'd been routinely burning leaves and lawn debris (or, later had the kid who did her lawn work do it). It didn't matter until some neighbors sold to a developer who put up commuter-McMansions across from her. It threatened to become a huge issue with the new people making bullshit claims about fire risk and whatnot. She stopped, I helped put up a tall privacy fence at a strategic point (that they also hate, but can't do anything about) and she'll be fine. Who was right? Well... I don't think there is a right answer, only a negotiated one.
- pedrocr 6y ago> The argument operates on a spectrum of specifics, and line drawing is always going to look absurd to someone. No doubt. My point is exactly that you have to find a balance somewhere, and it can't just be first come first serve. Because of fire risk we have a law that there can't be trees less than X meters from a house. That means someone can take a lot, build a house on the border and then force the neighbor to remove some trees. For the laws to work well together it should be required that someone building a house outright owns or at least buys the rights to the area that now needs to be cleared of trees. The Sriracha example is another tricky one. Just because when you started there was no one around you doesn't mean you get to pollute the air around you at will, but maybe industrial zoning of the area would have made that use ok. It's all a balancing act. Since local zoning tends to be both short-sighted and corrupt these issues crop up a lot.
- foota 6y agoFeels like the ideal solution would be coupled with lowering prices in other areas through upzoning or decreased regulatory costs in order to not negatively impact those currently making use of the sub-standard housing available.
- ksdale 6y agoMy wife grew up near a naval base and I always thought it was funny how regularly you’d hear stories about people buying houses under the flight path and then complaining to the base. It seems useful to me to allow people to build houses in less desirable locations, and it also seems... not wrong(?) to expect people to deal with a “nuisance” that they knew existed when they purchased their house (especially if they got their house for way cheaper than they would have otherwise!) I understand the impulse of people wanting to make their nuisances disappear, but I’m not sure this particular problem (zoning where people choose to build near industry) is one that needs solving.
- acoard 6y agoIt's also worth mentioning that this can be a financially motivated move if the "nuisance" has an impact on the property's value.
- cjrp 6y agoIn the UK there is a case[1] (based around cricket, of course) which set the precedent that even if you "come to the nuisance", you can still force people to stop. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miller_v_Jackson https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miller_v_Jackson
- corin_ 6y agoInteresting, thanks for sharing! But actually that wiki page says the judgement regarding "coming to the nuisance" was based on precedent set by a different case almost 100 years earlier. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sturges_v_Bridgman https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sturges_v_Bridgman
- wahern 6y agoA famous U.S. case often cited in the context of Law & Economics involves a residential development built near a pre-existing feedlot. Like in the UK case the court found an exception to the general rule that a court won't grant injunctive relief to those coming to the nuisance, and it ordered the feedlot to shutdown. However, the court made the developer pay damages to the feedlot to cover their losses--loss of business, relocation costs, etc. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spur_Industries,_Inc._v._Del_E._Webb_Development_Co https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spur_Industries,_Inc._v._Del_E....
- Schiendelman 6y agoThe best way to avoid this is no zoning at all, and restrictions on what you can emit.
- hinkley 6y agoSome American industries have the foresight to gobble up all the land around them and become landlords. Every few years they get the option to decline renewing a lease and expanding their facilities. But since they control the construction around them, they can do their own zoning after a fashion to avoid worst case scenarios like condo balconies downwind from their exhaust. I’m gonna fault Sriracha here a bit for cheaping out not preventing a problem. Land speculators can’t buy land that isn’t for sale. And they can’t use dirty tricks against another corporation to force a sale, like they might against private land owners.
- DoctorOetker 6y ago> And they can’t use dirty tricks against another corporation to force a sale, like they might against private land owners. so in theory the airports could modify their schedules and air paths so as to game the private housing market? buy affected houses while under your paths, then sell after changing your paths, repeat?
- tobltobs 6y ago> To avoid this you’ll need better more stringent zoning laws with bigger buffer zones. Zone the whole world as industrial zone, climate crisis solved.
- ajsnigrutin 6y agoSame problem everywhere... Not just huge industries.... literally people buying land next to a farm (which has been there for 100+ years), then compain due to animal noises and smell.
- doggydogs94 6y ago25 years ago, Denver opened a new airport; way outside the city. Guess where the first houses sprung up? You guessed it, right under the takeoff and landing flight paths.