6 ms·
Absent aid, few US cities will be able to avoid austerity
- heurist 6y agoWe are about to learn a lot about which local economic policies work and which do not.
- atmosx 6y agoThe US has a banking system, plus the FED understands what it means for a state to go burst... they won’t allow it. Europeans on the other hand, are ruled by semi-retards who believe that following the random rules made by someone 30 years ago, will save them from what is coming. It would funny if it wasn’t so tragic to be honest.
- somewhereoutth 6y agoI don't think this can be fixed by local economic policies. It will take a national effort, a new New Deal.
- unionpivo 6y ago"New Deal" thats the old deal. The new deal is "Don't be poor"
- mas3god 6y agoWith what money? Printing more would ensure currency debasement. You really think inflation is less than 2%?
- claydavisss 6y agoWithout a Federal effort, people will just move in order to avoid the local taxation required to sustain cities and states. For those in the California cities, the triple whammy of city budgets, CalPERs, and fire recovery will only be solved by huge tax increases.
- svachalek 6y agoThe Fed has changed policy, 2% is not a maximum anymore. With as much government debt as we have now, inflating it away is the only realistic way to get rid of it.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoPrivate debt is subject to inflation too.
- svachalek 6y agoWhat does private debt have to do with Fed policy?
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoHigher inflation reduces debt over time. You take on a mortgage and 10yr later paying it is cake because the debt doesn't track inflation whereas your pay does.
- Jarwain 6y agoThat's only true if inflation is higher than the interest on your debt though, right?
- gridlockd 6y ago> Printing more would ensure currency debasement. Lot of countries around the world intentionally debase their currency to stay competitive. It's a valid monetary instrument. In the short term, currency debasement would lower the standard of living of Americans, but it would make their labor competitive.
- mas3god 6y agoAgreed
- somewhereoutth 6y agoMoney is just a mechanism for resource allocation - there are many unemployed people, and there is much infrastructure that needs fixing (not just physical infrastructure, but also social infrastructure). Let's allocate those resources, through government direction if necessary, and sort out the money stuff later.
- jjoonathan 6y agoSpoilers: the policy of having rich people in your locale will work and the policy of having poor people in your locale will not.
- blululu 6y agoThis is not guaranteed. Recall that in the 90’s Orange County - then a relatively affluent region - had to declare bankruptcy. Just because there are people who could foot the bill, does not mean that they will. If the surplus of wealth is in a community consumed by an inefficient urban structure then a financial crisis will arise just the same. In a lot of suburban areas the density is such that the infrastructure costs more and the property value is lower (on a per lot basis). The end result is that a lot of the wealthy suburbs will go broke. https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2018/9/5/but-rich-people-live-here-so-we-cant-be-going-broke https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2018/9/5/but-rich-people...
- bilbo0s 6y agoIn a lot of suburban areas the density is such that the infrastructure costs more and the property value is lower (on a per lot basis). The end result is that a lot of the wealthy suburbs will go broke. If a suburb or ex-urb's liabilities exceed their assets, weren't they already broke? I'm trying to understand because I don't know a lot about this whole issue. But unless they charge people a whole lot in taxes to live in those areas, I'm not seeing how those places weren't poor in reality from the start? It seems to me those suburbs just managed to have other people pay for their infrastructure and services for so long that they never realized they were broke. But maybe there is some other source of money that they get from somewhere?
- hiram112 6y agoMost localities sell bonds, backed up by promise of future tax revenue. Eventually their bonds are downgraded and they have to pay higher and higher interest rates. Finally, the math comes crashing down and the game is over when the market has no more appetite for the bonds and the state and feds won't backstop them.
- rectang 6y agoThe cruelty is the point. Witnessing the suffering of the dissolute validates the virtuous.
- mandelbrotwurst 6y agoAre you suggesting that they should be able to provide services without any revenue or funding?
- pmiller2 6y agoIt seems to me they’re suggesting the federal government should step in, but they won’t.
- Gibbon1 6y agoLetting cities, business, and people fail provides opportunities for the true wealthy to corner more of the nations wealth. That's why they protected the banks and let 10 million families lose their homes in 2009. A lot of money was made off if that.
- apocalypstyx 6y agoWherefore in order that the happiness of the saints may be more delightful to them and that they may render more copious thanks to God for it, they are allowed to see perfectly the sufferings of the damned. --Saint Thomas Aquinas
- rectang 6y ago"It is not enough merely to win; others must lose." — Gore Vidal
- pleasedontbanme 6y agoIt's not action being done to them, it's them being unable to sustain themselves.
- davidw 6y agoAny discussion of this ought to involve some of the concepts from Strong Towns https://www.strongtowns.org/ https://www.strongtowns.org/ Their book is a good, quick overview of what they're about. It's not perfect, but it has some ideas worth considering.
- cpursley 6y agoYou're getting downvoted, but city design has a big effect on operational costs.
- claydavisss 6y agoCities will be scrambling for basic maintenance, infrastructure improvements will be off the table.
- joejohnson 6y agoThe US is in a death spiral and the income bar required to ignore the problems in society will soon be high enough that nobody can pretend neoliberalism is working anymore. The question is will people see one another as allies and try to rebuild something more equitable that provides for everyone, or will working people remain divided. I’m optimistic but the corporate media wants to keep people mad at the “other side” instead of realizing the entire system is rigged and that all the wealth created under massive productivity gains since the 1970s has gone to the rich.
- mas3god 6y agoThe original sin was the establishment of a central banking system.
- gridlockd 6y agoWhat neoliberalism? Actual neoliberalism worked pretty well. Reagonomics worked pretty well. The economics of today are not neoliberal, they're a charade where we pretend that we can have a market economy without market risk. Pushing through an actual neoliberal agenda in today's political climate would be unthinkable.
- Gibbon1 6y ago> The economics of today are not neoliberal Psst: Your Scottsman isn't wearing pants.
- horsemessiah 6y agoReaganonmics has been a disaster for my generation.
- d33lio 6y agoIt's almost as if the free money raining from the sky has to stop at some point?
- mywittyname 6y agoI'm struggling to see how you got this comment from the article. The article is pointing out that loss in revenue becomes a death-spiral that causes a loss of jobs and a further reduction in revenues. And that cities are largely powerless to stop it because some state government officials, well, they are assholes who welcome the ensuing chaos. If anything, it's merely a warning of what people in much of America should expect in the coming years. If you live in a flyover city, it's probably going to look a lot like Flint in the coming decade.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ardit33 6y agoI live in NYC, and go the occasional reddit boards, and while some are worried that a lot of good jobs will leave, you also hear a lot of "good, let the gentrifiers leave" type of comments, After some digging, I realized that just 10% of the population pays about 71-72% of the taxes. If half of that 10% of the population leaves, the city will have 1/3rd less tax revenue (it will have less than 65% of the current revenue). Also, the city will be limited on what it can tax, as if it raises the taxes more, even more people will leave for low tax states and turn it into a death spiral. The only way to get out of the situation is to have help federally. Meanwhile it will have to cut services drastically.... from trash collection, social services, schools, etc... Apart from the slow trash decay, I think the first shock from some of the folks will be when MTA is forced to raise fares to $4 or $5 (now it is $2.75). As for those 'let the gentrifiers leave' populist folks, Sure, rents will go down by 15-20% but a lot of the folks will be jobless soon, and manny other things will get more expensive.
- gridlockd 6y agoNYC is probably worth more as a largely uninhabited speculative asset, a collector's item if you will. There will still be jobs for people to keep it in mint condition.
- api 6y agoThat's Vancouver with all its absurdly overpriced uninhabited condo towers that exist only to be money laundering and parking vehicles.
- spamizbad 6y ago> After some digging, I realized that just 10% of the population pays about 71-72% of the taxes. Keep in mind you're talking about a local municipality which is going to receive a large chunk of its revenue from property taxes, fees, sales tax etc. From https://www.ibo.nyc.ny.us/iboreports/understandingthebudget.pdf https://www.ibo.nyc.ny.us/iboreports/understandingthebudget.... The breakdown is: 29% Property Tax 17% State Grants 13% Personal Income Tax 10% Federal Grants 8% General Sales Tax 8% Fees and Fines (Non-Tax) 7% Business Income Tax 4% RE Taxes 4% Other Taxes Some of these will hit the wealthy more than others (eg: Biz and Personal Income Taxes) but revenues aren't going to drop by 71-72%. I know in America taxes are super taboo but there's also nothing wrong with raising taxes on the rest of the city to cover any gap.
- gridlockd 6y ago“If state and local governments are condensing their balance sheets, they’re laying people off. They’re cutting spending on equipment. Capital spending is cut early during downturns. All of that is sucking demand right out of the economy.” Clearly, the US is suffering from the Dutch Disease, except instead of oil it's the dollar that is creating the problem. So just let the government hire everybody. Build lots of stuff, housing and factories and infrastructure. Print the dollars to pay for all of it, until the dollar collapses. American labor is now cheap again, so those factories can produce at internationally competitive cost. This is similar to how China does it. The key is that you can't devalue the currency if you have a service economy that relies on cheap imports, but that's exactly the way the US is headed right now.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- hindsightbias 6y ago> Last summer, the Republican speaker of the Texas House Dennis Bonnen was caught on tape gloating: “My goal is for this to be the worst session in the history of the legislature for cities and counties,” Low service state rolls costs down to counties and cities and then kneecaps them.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoAlternatively: Low service state makes cities and towns who want to be high service pay their own way. Yeah the quote is pretty bad if you're on the business end of his proposed policies but whether or not those policies are good or bad totally depends on your ideology.
- spamizbad 6y ago> Low service state makes cities and towns who want to be high service pay their own way. But they already do. The difference is they get "back" less proportionally. Not a bad thing btw, that's the nature of progressive taxation!
- techsupporter 6y ago> Low service state makes cities and towns who want to be high service pay their own way. In Texas, as in many states, municipalities are severely restricted in the types and amounts of taxes they can levy. And, especially in Texas (considering the fight over school funding), the propensity is to further restrict the types and amounts of taxes, not expand them. Most forms of business tax are flatly outlawed. And if a city tries to impose a fee of some sort, the legislature will quickly get around to cutting off that authority. Property tax limits are severely restricted, same for sales tax. For example, transit districts in Texas may not exceed a 1% sales tax and that's only able to be levied in cities that have not used all of their 2% "local option" sales tax cap. Most cities in Texas, levy 1% of the sales tax cap for "general purposes" and then another 1% for "economic development," which should be read as basically giveaways of public money to induce private businesses to locate in those cities. Cities that can't or don't levy economic development taxes are seen as at a disadvantage to the cities with that pot of money. So it's far more complex than "well, high-service cities should just tax more to pay for more."
- mas3god 6y agoThis is a faliure of Keynesian economics. The moment the government had the privilege to spend beyond its means was the moment it ditched savings and high interest rates. Now that were actually in a crisis it caused us to have even less savings and more debt than without a federal reserve.
- pizza 6y agoCan you explain what it is you think the government spent on beyond its means? ie is it one of these: - trillion dollar wars, and in general, multi-trillion dollar military expenditure - subsidized private health insurance (as opposed to a more streamlined/wholesale universal healthcare plan) - social security fund that leaks value over time - massively bailed out banks - widespread quantitative easing In my humble and probably misguided understanding of Keynesian economics, you would want the government to fund e.g. a federal jobs guarantee during a recession. Like, if you had a recession, pay one set of people to dig a hole, and another set of people to fill it up again, because then at least money would still propagate throughout the economy. But I'm not certain that these huge expenditures (above) really did much to help worker or city solvency. Basically unless you are one of the government's top clients, don't expect it to pick up a check pad. I guess I can sort of see how you're saying that it may have been Keynesian-esque for all these various industries but it's certainly not that Keynesian for the little guy.
- mas3god 6y agoMy take is Keynesian economics only benefits those closest to power on the little guy's dime.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- spyckie2 6y agoJust wondering why no one talks about shaving the fat - reducing the budget, lowering costs, being smarter with spend, etc? Is it like some unwritten rule that the price we pay right now is exactly how much we need to pay for the quality of service we are getting? I know that countries like Taiwan have a 4-10x lower level of income as places like New York City and have the same quality of living. Can't we make the argument, in times of prosperity we all paid ourselves a little too much and now we just need to pay ourselves less? Companies do that all the time - they cut the fat in hard times. Why can't cities and societies do that as well? Cutting the fat isn't letting poor people starve on the streets. It's an admittance that we feasted during the times of boom, and at that we can't feast at the same level in times of famine, from all levels of society. Instead, the narrative is always we need to raise taxes, like our over-indulgence, inflated standard of living in times of abundance, and padding our pockets is some sacred right that can never be questioned.