7 ms·
It's ridiculous that we couldn't coordinate a rent/mortgage forgiveness plan alongside all the customer bans put in place across the country. If a restaurant ca
by paxys 6y ago
It's ridiculous that we couldn't coordinate a rent/mortgage forgiveness plan alongside all the customer bans put in place across the country. If a restaurant can't stay open, they shouldn't pay rent. If the property owner isn't getting rent, they shouldn't have to pay mortgage. And so on, up the entire chain.
- JMTQp8lwXL 6y agoThat's exactly what an economic contraction is. A long chain of payments not being made (regardless of one's legal obligation to do so). Breaking the chain causes new problems. It reduces spending and purse strings get tightened. When the mortgage doesn't get paid, the mortgage backed security isn't getting its repayments. The retirees living off the dividends from the REIT don't get paid. Then the retiree spends less in the economy, which would've paid the restaurant worker's wages. When the chain breaks, the whole system is impacted. Think of it as a graph. When payments aren't flowing from one node to the next due to crisis, the solution is to have the government ensure those payments be made via taking on debt in bad times (and less borrowing in good times).
- jjeaff 6y agoYes, but let's be honest, most retirees today aren't living off dividends. Except for those who are indirectly living off them through pension plans. And those huge pensions and funds will be the first to receive a bailout. The vast majority of the ownership of the stock market is owned by the very wealthy. Most of main street's wealth is in their home, and while home values dropping can hurt them, these assets aren't usually income generating.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- kgc 6y agoWhat's at the top of the chain though?
- davidw 6y agoThe Federal Reserve? It seems like it could have all sort of just been put on 'pause' for the duration of the pandemic.
- bitcoinbutter 6y agoThe Federal Reserve seems primarily focused on keeping asset prices high. Their policies seem to react directly to downward pressure in the equity markets. When you consider that the appreciation of these markets only serves to widen the wealth gap, it becomes clear that the Fed's mandate is to preserve the wealth of the rich. They're pursuing "trickle down" economics at full speed, despite the overwhelming evidence that "trickle down" is a myth. The US population is too busy arguing over race issues and partisan politics to realize the financial system is stealing from the poor and giving to the rich.
- MiroF 6y ago> The Federal Reserve seems primarily focused on keeping asset prices high Pshh - the Fed is focused on hitting unemployment and inflation targets. Low yields in the credit market shifts investment demand towards equity. The "downward pressure in the equity market" is also deflationary pressure and accompanied by a rise in unemployment. Just because the two coincide doesn't mean the Feds principal goal is high asset prices.
- Weebs 6y agoThe race issues are part of the financial theft. Racism is used as a tool of division to keep the poor fragmented, people are rightfully trying to destroy that tool.
- jccooper 6y agoBanks and/or the Fed. Which also happens to be the easiest place to implement fiscal relief via debt or just plain creating money.
- alecco 6y agoTop of the chain is "dumb money". Like pension funds and municipal or foreign funds. Those got destroyed in 2008. The Fed can only absorb so much (currently at a record 30% of mortgage bonds). Banks and the financial markets are not stupid and quickly resell everything. In 2008 they were caught with just ONE batch of mortgage backed securities and it bankrupted a couple. It's not going to happen again. It's dismaying how GP proposes such a terrible idea. And what worries me the most is the majority of voters have the same feel-good ideas. We are going to get screwed from both sides.
- notyourwork 6y agoRight - the money handed out isn't going to save businesses that cannot operate safely. Movie theaters and gyms to name a few others also fall into this category.
- pfisch 6y agoWhen you go up that chain you will eventually run into a very serious monetary crisis that would crash the banks, the real estate market, and the entire economy.
- twblalock 6y agoNo, you would end up with another bank bailout, except this time the banks didn't do anything wrong and it was the government's fault for screwing up the pandemic response. In other words, it would be compensation for the government's failure, not a bailout.
- nartz 6y agoEveryone wants to blame someone - e.g. its the governments fault! In reality, its just an external force that everyone is dealing with, a plague, if you will - its not anyone's fault; it just must be faced, that during a plague, there will be suffering, and there will be casualties. It's that simple.
- twblalock 6y agoNo, it is not that simple. There are various ways to respond to a plague, and some are better than others. Some responses result in far more casualties than others, in addition to the economic damage. We can all see that some governments responded well and others did not.
- serial_dev 6y ago> we can all see that some governments responded well and others did not. Can we, though? We are not even half time yet (most likely). How are we going to judge a government in the beginning of a pandemic as if the pandemic was already over? Maybe what looks like a poor strategy now will turn out to be the best later. Same true for the economic bailouts, some countries went harder than others, and it's not yet clear which will work better. There are some anomalies that's difficult to explain (Sweden, for example). Sure, we can retrofit some model, and imagine we have it all figured out, but could you have predicted it correctly?
- rudedogg 6y ago"Trickle-Up Debt Forgiveness". It sounds nice, but I think it benefits the poor too much to catch on.
- rayiner 6y agoWhich country implemented rent/mortgage forgiveness? The US implemented mortgage deferral, plus SBA loans for rent for small businesses. The lack of general rent deferral was to force larger companies to bear some of the cost of shut downs. France and Germany didn’t do appreciably more—they simply imposed deferrals or moratorium on eviction.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- AniseAbyss 6y agoBankruptcy is a form of debt forgiveness. I don't see the problem, I see restaurants close only to see a new one move in a few months later. Even during good times its a risky business.
- postpawl 6y agoIt’s a problem when you consider the trillions more the fed sent to loans for big businesses + banks, buying stocks, and buying mortgage bonds (which also kinda went to banks).
- anovikov 6y agoHow are you going to bail out landlords then? The money isn't going to come from nowhere.
- hieunc229 6y agoIf there is forgiveness in the hard time, there should be more to pay in the good time
- sdoering 6y agoProviding space for rent, especially to restaurants, is a gamble already in normal times. So one could argue that missing payments is part of the natural risk property owners have to bear. On the other hand one could argue, that a government has to pay damages for business lost if they implement regulation shutting down that business. At least, that is something that is part of modern international trade agreements. I know I shortened the argument here. What I am trying to get to is the fact that there are no easy answers and that potential solutions will necessarily be colored by political leaning. This is a situation that is new and not solved with an easy fix. Sadly.
- nartz 6y agoThis is over simplified. It's better to lose a finger to an infection or cancer, versus have it spread to all parts of the body. Its the same thing with fiscal policy.
- paxys 6y agoExcept in the present case we ended up with both.
- skybrian 6y agoI think it’s unsurprising that big changes to the legal system can’t easily be made on an ad-hoc, emergency basis. But that’s no excuse for not preparing for the next crisis. Contracts should have a “disaster clause” suspending payment during an officially declared disaster. Perhaps Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae could require this for home mortgages?
- sitver 6y agoLook up “Force Majore”
- tuatoru 6y agoNitpick, that's "force majeure". French always sounds more impressive.[1][2] Lawyers love to sound grand, as though they're worth what they're paid. 1."Paté de foie" sounds a lot nicer than "liver paste," n'est-ce pas? 2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Force_majeure https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Force_majeure
- skybrian 6y agoLooks like it's often insufficient: > Q: If a contract does contain a Force Majeure clause that includes “epidemic” or some form of the “other causes beyond the reasonable control of a party” language, does that mean one or more of the contract parties do not have to perform, as a general rule? > A: Not necessarily. First, it should be noted there is not much jurisprudence in the U.S. that address “epidemics” as a Force Majeure event. So the courts have not, to date, had an opportunity to provide clear interpretation or guidance. That is likely to change soon. Second, there needs to be a real causal connection between the occurrence of a Force Majeure event and a party’s ability or inability to perform under the contract. By way of an over-simplified comparative example, consider today’s situation, where there is undoubtedly an “epidemic” of COVID-19 occurring. Most homeowners cannot simply stop paying monthly home mortgage payments even if the loan documents contain language that includes “epidemic” as a Force Majeure event. This is because the Force Majeure event, as expressly stated in the contract, has not directly created an effect that excuses the homeowner’s performance – to pay monthly installments to the mortgage company. In contrast, if a public school district engages a consultant to observe and evaluate students’ use of a new technology in the classroom, and the contract contains similar Force Majeure language, the government’s decision to temporarily close all public schools because of the epidemic precludes the consultant from completing the evaluation.. Very likely, the Force Majeure clause would excuse the delay in the consultant’s performance. > In between these very simple examples are countless real-world situations that will likely arise as businesses try to predict their respective futures. https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=5e3f36b8-6ce8-4d44-ae38-9503b87e3ff8 https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=5e3f36b8-6ce8...
- altdatathrow 6y agoPPP funds were designed for that (60% to payroll, 40% to rent/utils). However, they only provided ~2.5 months of coverage, and we're well beyond that.
- issa 6y agoAlso, they were very difficult to get. Especially for smaller businesses without bank relationships.
- travisoneill1 6y agoHow do you have a business of any size without a banking relationship?
- troydavis 6y agoRather than “bank relationship,” a clearer phrase would be “existing bank loan.” https://libertystreeteconomics.newyorkfed.org/2020/05/where-have-the-paycheck-protection-loans-gone-so-far.html https://libertystreeteconomics.newyorkfed.org/2020/05/where-... examines this: > For this reason, we turn to testing the hypothesis that variation in the share of small businesses with existing bank financing explains the variation of PPP loans approved across states. The top panel of the figure below shows the share of small businesses with bank financing in 2019, while the bottom panel shows the share of firms receiving PPP loans. > We can see that there is strong similarity in shading between the top and bottom panels, consistent with the lenders’ preference explanation. This relationship is further confirmed in unreported regressions. Our interpretation is that banks’ preference for their own customers causes the PPP to favor firms with existing lending relationships.
- _heimdall 6y agoEconomics isn't that simple, you can't invent demand out of thin air and printing money is a very short term solution with huge long term impacts. Dealing with debt is risky, whether you are the lender or the borrower. I completely agree with opinions that it is utter BS that the government effectively bailed out banks and corporations while leaving the rest out to dry, but the solution isn't further bailouts. Life sucks sometimes, governments can't fix that. A pandemic spreading fast enough to bring broad shutdowns doesn't come free, and unfortunately small businesses sitting on piles of debt and tight margins are the first to bleed. Economic systems have pros and cons; with Capitalism we often get accelerated growth and innovation but the downside is that when things go south it can be a much faster and deeper cut.