11 ms·
And unlike a natural gas plant, it costs 3-10x what the equivalent generating capacity in renewables would cost. I come to post this Same Thing every time this
by ajross 6y ago
And unlike a natural gas plant, it costs 3-10x what the equivalent generating capacity in renewables would cost.
I come to post this Same Thing every time this discussion comes up. It's not about safety. Everyone serious understand nuclear, even current technologies, is "safe enough" to be useful to build out.
Nuclear is outrageously expensive, though. And new reactor designs don't seem to be making much progress on that.
Look, I think nuclear is fine. But as a numerate and earnest environmentalist, I don't see where the case for it lies. Right now, we should be building out solar and wind as fast as we can, because they're good and safe and CHEAP. And when we get to that last 5-10% where we need buffering capacity that we're currently getting via gas? Yeah, maybe then we can talk about nuclear.
But even then... meh. What's the case on trying to finish the job on electrical generation vs. putting those same dollars into low hanging fruit in other areas of the energy puzzle?
Nuclear needs to make its case on a balance sheet before it makes sense to talk about.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoSo, why did so many countries/companies originally build nuclear reactors, if the economics inherently don’t make sense? Has something changed?
- layoutIfNeeded 6y agoYes. Regulations.
- dv_dt 6y agoI think a lot of countries built reactors when the economics of Nuclear reactors as well as the economics of renewables were unknown with respect what they would look like in scaled deployment. Modern looks at the operating costs vs time to build, vs modern construction practices from the US, France, China, et al seems say the economics of Nuclear reactors have stalled or increased, while the economics of renewables continue to make accelerating improvements.
- Baeocystin 6y agoThe economics are what they are do to the legal burden and regulatory overhead more than the technology itself, at least here in the US.
- wrsh07 6y agoYes we have more stringent safety requirements on nuclear, driving up costs
- ajross 6y agoTo make bombs. And what's changed now is we have enough bombs. Seriously, even the reactors that aren't expressly breeding fuel were designed with an eye to the technology and as part of programs in the 50's-70's to build out expertise in this critical technology area of national security. Countries wanted bombs. To make bombs you need a nuclear industry. Ergo, everyone who wanted bombs built civilian reactors, without exception.
- dirtyaura 6y agoThis argument doesn’t hold. There are several countries such as Finland that have operated nuclear power plants for decades and do not have ambitions for nuclear bombs.
- ajross 6y agoIf you want to go with that argument: cite Japan, not Finland. But it doesn't have to be 100% true to be largely true. The overwhelming majority of nuclear capacity has been built out by nuclear powers or aspiring nuclear powers. And with few exceptions the end of their warhead buildout happens to correlate with the end of their megawatt buildout.
- pfdietz 6y agoJapan has a stockpile of separated reactor grade plutonium sufficient to make thousands of bombs. This is a deniable kind of proliferation. If push came to shove they could weaponize that material without having to make new plutonium. (And, yes, reactor grade Pu CAN be used in weapons, with proper design.)
- bananabreakfast 6y agoExplain Japan's nuclear power plants.
- nine_k 6y agoProducing plutonium, I suppose.
- kolinko 6y agorenewables were 10-100x times more expensive back then
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoBut we also didn't know about climate change yet (for the most part), right? So nuclear was competing with oil.
- nine_k 6y agoTwo questions: (1) Night time. (2) Quiet time. Of course there are batteries! But factoring them in seems to increase the cost significantly. Power lines and cross-continent smart grids are fine, too — but also not free to build and operate. So a self-contained unit that does not depend on weather, does not need refueling, and includes its own energy accumulator has some appeal.
- ajross 6y agoRight. So show me the balance sheet where building out reactors makes sense. Because as of right now it clearly doesn't, and the proof is that no one is building reactors but everyone is building windmills.
- littlestymaar 6y agoEveryone is building heavily subsidized windmill. And nobody is building reactors[1] mostly because it's really unpopular (which it pretty much deserves IMHO after decades of shady practices) but it's not a matter of technical merit (and it's never the case). [1] except those who do, China leading the pack.
- jasonwatkinspdx 6y agoI'd suggest looking through Lazard's levelized cost of energy slide decks. The unsubsidized price of renewables is indeed substantially less than nuclear. Next look at the time scales for building new nuclear. Then look at the trend lines in the cost of storage, particularly utility scale lithium batteries. You don't have to be a genius to realize this makes new nuclear a bad bet purely on the finances. Even if you waved a magic wand to eliminate any environmental opposition, the only way new nuclear is getting funded is if government picks up the tab. And that's what we see globally. One of the reasons NuScale and the linked company above are getting investment traction is exactly because they're attempting to reduce the capital costs and timelines. That's a bet investors are more willing to take, even if the technology is unproven yet.
- 6y ago
- littlestymaar 6y ago> the equivalent generating capacity in renewables would cost But most of the time, the “cost” of renewable is undefined, because you simply can't use it: you need the grid to compensate for the intermittent generation. No battery won't be enough unless you are in a really specific situation: - hydroelectric source available, in which case, it's a no-brainer, but most of those sites are already exploited (hydroelectric power was historically the first to come). - if tpu want to go for solar power, you need tropical or subtropical area, where you have the same amount of sun during the whole year. Otherwise you either need to have batteries able to sustain the whole winter, or dimension your system for winter (which dramatically increases the cost and you end up with a lot of unused power during summertimes). - for wind power, you need a regularly windy area (the top of a hill, the middle of the sea) and batteries because the world best wind power sites still don't produce every days (storms means shutdown for instance). If you don't have the perfect spot for one of those, the batteries aren't even a solution[1], because you'd need something like two to four weeks of power in terms of storage… Or, you could go for a mix between fossil fuel and renewable, which is why the oil and gas industry is making a big push towards renewables …
- kolinko 6y agoyou missed judrogen electrolysis which comes out comparable in expense to nuclear when deployed on top of renewables, amd gives the same level of stability?
- littlestymaar 6y agoYield is a problem, as well as rhe ability to store hydrogen safely (injecting it in the natural gas grid isn't possible when we're talking about off-the-grid scenarios). And we where supposed to talk about renewable “3 to 10 times cheaper than nuclear”, so bringing a storage technology with an higher investment per Watt than nuclear pretty much defeats the argument.
- jay_kyburz 6y agoNot to mention the waste which needs an armed guard almost forever, making the total cost of the energy almost infinite.
- WalterBright 6y ago> an armed guard almost forever Things that have long half-lives are not very dangerous, as in order to have a long half-life it must be emitting radiation at correspondingly lower levels. For example, something with a half-life of 100,000 years is emitting 1/100,000 of the radiation that one with a half-life of a year is.
- jay_kyburz 6y agoI actually have no idea how long waste needs to be kept out of the hands of criminals, but I assume it's "a long time". My comment was mostly facetious, but the point I was making was serious. We never really take the full cost of disposing waste and pollution into consideration. I think, when you buy a new solar panel, you should also pay the full cost to pull it apart and dispose of it as well.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tdy721 6y agoThat’s a carbon tax right? How much should a gallon of gas cost?
- jay_kyburz 6y agoNot just carbon, but plastics and all kinds of pollution. Even the clean up of recyclables like glass and metal should be paid for upfront rather thank asking society to pickup the tab after the fact.
- orthecreedence 6y agoAt this point, probably $20-30. Then we'll see how "expensive" nuclear is.
- remote_phone 6y agoI’m okay with costs being 3-10x for something with zero emissions. And the more we build the cheaper it gets. We have to invest in the future technology. Solar is a good 20th century technology but it is poisonous and degrades over time. Wind is useless.
- leptons 6y agoThere are quite a few ways to generate electricity from solar, and not all of them degrade over time or are "poisonous". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mojave_Solar_Project https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mojave_Solar_Project
- godelski 6y ago> But as a numerate and earnest environmentalist, I don't see where the case for it lies. There's two main benefits to nuclear: 1) The big case is the lack of good power storage. While areas like the South West US have plenty of sunshine to go around, most other places don't have this luxury. Therefore you need substantially more storage. I'll give you an example, I've been sitting in Oregon for the past week and sun levels have been pretty abysmal, the past week. Dust and ash are covering panels, making things worse, and this is the sunniest time of the year. There's plenty of times I don't see the sun for a few days straight. Same with wind. Because of this we need to mix up our power sources a bit. I mean you also don't want to depend on only two power sources. I think most of us in the nuclear community agree on: wind + solar + hydro + nuclear as the model. Without good enough batteries nuclear is a great option for baseloads. Remember that you need enough battery storage for rare events where there isn't much sun and wind. Current solutions aren't quite there yet without massive footprints, CO2eq costs, and a high price tag. The unfortunate fact is that wind and solar can't stand up by themselves. They need support. People talk about how you can do it with batteries, water storage, whatever, but until it is implemented I'm not holding my breath. 2) Nuclear has a small physical footprint. This means less disruption of local wildlife, homes, etc. This is a big environmental factor to me. As to what these people are doing, there's a few factors they are banking on (bets). It'll be interesting to see how that pans out and if their bets can pay off. - With small modular designs they can get the benefits from economies of scale. This hasn't ever really been a thing for nuclear in the past. This has been a big driver for the huge costs. - Small reactors should be cheaper to insure (this still needs to be resolved from what I'm aware of and has historically made small reactors unattractive). - Small and modular enables the ability to better fit the local environment and meet the specific needs. Southern California? Probably don't need any. Alaska? Few would be nice. The idea behind these is that you don't have to transmit energy far (lower loss due to transmission), can add independence from the grid (to corporations or universities), and you don't need to put them in areas that can better rely on wind and solar, i.e. better scaling than conventional nuclear plants. Of course, this is still a bet and has been one people have been talking about for well over a decade, but why dismiss it before they place their chips? If the bets pay off we should welcome them with open arms. If they don't pay off, well we're on a forum hosted by a startup company where we all know most startups fail. Glad someone at least tried. We're not talking about enough investment money that it would sway the scales and it is good to spread out your bets.
- ChuckMcM 6y agoPicking a nit here. You wrote: > Nuclear is outrageously expensive, though. And new reactor designs don't seem to be making much progress on that. Nuclear plants are expensive the way GE and Bechtel build them not inherently so. At some point I got to look at the Diablo Canyon cost-to-build breakdown and about 2/3ds of the cost were litigation, licensing, and specialized site and construction prep. Finding people who could do the kinds of welds they needed, build structures in the right way, inspect, inspect, inspect, and litigate dozens of lawsuits asserting on form of harm or another. It was pretty amazing. This particular company can build the reactor in their factory. All their specialists are in one place, you can have permanent inspection equipment with costs amortized over all the reactors you build, and the safety systems this reactor design purports to have means no additional site prep (no backup generators, no double containment vessels, no borosilicon sandpits under the reactor to slag into glass while "catching" a meltdown. If I were to guess, while the pitch is all about safety, this design screams that it is all about cost. When you factor in that the design in modular, so making a 100MW power station with 20 of these gets advantages of scale that multiplies the cost advantage. When I read this I see those cost savings and recognize this could be both cheaper than renewables and way more reliable. A solid base load solution to kill the last of the coal plants.
- godelski 6y agoMy guess is that the pitch of safety is to the public (experts already know it is safe enough and that insurance more than covers expenses). And that modularity/size is a pitch to investors over cost. From my understanding, small reactors haven't been popular in the past because they still have the same insurance premiums as large reactors. If I'm wrong, or this changes, then that's a big reduction in cost alongside the aspects you mentioned.
- guscost 6y agoIf this team convinces the insurance folks that their design really is safer, and so their premiums should be low enough to make small reactors competitive, it could be a huge breakthrough.
- pfdietz 6y ago
- hairytrog 6y agoI don't think they're necessarily chasing grid power at first anyway. They seem positioned to tackle mass market electricity last, after addressing smaller higher price markets.
- macspoofing 6y ago>it costs 3-10x what the equivalent generating capacity in renewables would cost Except renewables can't actually replace fossil fuels. They need baseload provided by fossil fuels to be viable. They are also defuse energy sources, and so require huge surface area and lots of materials for collectors - not great for a growing world, both in population and per capita energy needs. Oh, they are variable across days, seasons and inter-year periods, but there is no battery technology coming that is able to store even enough power to a moderately sized city for a few minutes, much less the weeks it would need. >And when we get to that last 5-10% Try 50%.
- pfdietz 6y ago> Except renewables can't actually replace fossil fuels. They need baseload provided by fossil fuels to be viable. False. Renewables could get to 100% of the grid. A key is using hydrogen for the last 10% or so. This is not currently competitive with fossil fuel, but then neither is nuclear.
- bananabreakfast 6y agoSo, what? Just use hydrogen like a gigantic grid sized battery? Also, nuclear is only not competitive due to strangling regulation, not fundamentals.
- pfdietz 6y agoBurn the hydrogen in combustion turbines, just like natural gas. You repeat an excuse, but nuclear builds have failed, and continue to fail, not because of regulation, but because of the high unforgiving complexity of nuclear power plants. The post mortems at huge cost overruns point to management failures, not new regulations sprung out of nowhere.
- macspoofing 6y ago>Burn the hydrogen in combustion turbines, just like natural gas. That simple? Anyone in the world actually using hydrogen in this way? You can dissmis nuclear all you want, but doesn't change the fact that renewables (outside of hydro/geothermal for which you need special geography) do not work. There is no nation on this planet that is powered by renewables. There is no nation on this planet that is planning to be powered by renewables. Germany believes in renewables so much they are signing multi-decade contracts to ship gas from Russia and building new pipelines!
- nwah1 6y agoIf it can be combined with desalination, and profitably create medical isotopes, that could help balance the books. But yea, you are right. And solar keeps getting cheaper.
- pfdietz 6y agoThe cheapest technology for desalination is reverse osmosis, which uses mechanical power, not heat, to drive things.
- jeffreyrogers 6y agoAnd renewables are cheap because peaker plants exist, which allows the price of storage to be externalized to the peaker plants.
- imtringued 6y agoWell, you also have to consider that many gas plants emit less CO2 than coal plats. You're going to need them either way because it's the fastest way to reduce the CO2 footprint of your nation's electricity mix.
- hwc 6y agoI really hope *all" natural gas plants emit less CO2 than coal. Joule for Joule, burning C produces more CO2 than burning CH4.
- johnisgood 6y agoWell, I am still hoping for ITER.
- pfdietz 6y agoIf its gross fusion power were converted to electrical power at 40% efficiency, it will have cost $100/W(e) to build, an order of magnitude more expensive than fission power plants. (Its net power output would be negative, btw, and there won't be enough tritium to run it for more than a few weeks total, as it's not going to breed its own tritium.)
- belorn 6y agoThe growth numbers currently show that for every extra watt of renewable energy consumed globally, 10 more watts of fossil fuels get consumed. (https://ourworldindata.org/energy#energy-consumption-by-source https://ourworldindata.org/energy#energy-consumption-by-sour...) Looking at the multiple data sources at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cost_of_electricity_by_source https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cost_of_electricity_by_source, there is several patterns that should be fairly clear. Gas and oil is very cheap to build, and the market price they can get out per generated MWh is higher. > Look, I think nuclear is fine. But as a numerate and earnest environmentalist, I don't see where the case for it lies Lets put this is in numerical estimated numbers. An investor builds a wind farm. On average they produce a MWh that costed $35. For the period which the energy was produced they managed to sell it for $85 netting them a profit of $50. An other investor builds a natural gas power plant. On average they produce a MWh that costed $45. Since they can choose when to produce it they managed to get an average price of $150, netting them a profit of $105. As a balance sheet, $35 is a cheaper price than $45 when producing 1 MWh. $50 is however much less than $105, making the more expensive energy source the more profitable choice of investment. Cost is just half the picture in any commercial venture. The daily energy price for 1 MWh varies heavily based on demand and supply. $50 per MWh one day could be $500 a few days later when supply is low and demands is high. I would also describe myself as numerate and earnest environmentalist, and my view is similar to your but with a clear distinction. Right now we must stop burning fossil fuels. If it cost $45 to produce and they can earn $150, investors who only care about money will continue to invest in fossil fuels. That must stop. The climate will have won a partial victory when the investment into fossil fueled power plants are a proven poor investment, and then we can move on to the transport sector.
- belorn 6y agoThe downvotes demonstrate quite clearly what earnest environmentalist think about continuing the existing trend of fossil fueled energy.
- PopeDotNinja 6y agoThink of smaller nuclear reactors as an option for places where renewables might not make sense, like in mining. Building power generation that costs 10x some renewable source will never make sense. However, building small scale nuclear as replacement for onsite diesel generators could make a whole lot of sense. Illinois Energy Prof has a good video on this => https://youtu.be/7gtog_gOaGQ https://youtu.be/7gtog_gOaGQ