11 ms·
> With proper engineering and maintenance, PG&E could probably reduce the frequency of fires significantly, but there's always going to be a non-zero risk of fi
by tshaddox 6y ago
> With proper engineering and maintenance, PG&E could probably reduce the frequency of fires significantly, but there's always going to be a non-zero risk of fire, both from power lines and other sources, and it seems basically inevitable that one of them would have started another fire at some point.
I don’t understand. You’re conceding that if PG&E were a competent and responsible company they could significantly reduce the rate of fires. The fact that some fires might still happen doesn’t mean that 10 fires aren’t better than 1,000 fires.
- cesaref 6y agoNo, the point is I think that they could reduce the risk further, they are currently maintaining their network, the question is what benefit would be gained by increasing the cost of their maintenance, or whether they would be absorbing the risk from someone else's lack of maintenance (e.g clearing forest debris/making fire breaks). Remember, power lines are not the only source of fires, lightning being a much more frequent cause and power grid maintenance isn't going to alter that risk
- legulere 6y ago1000 fires would actually be probably better than 10 because they help keep flammable material at bay and reduce the size of the fires.
- taneq 6y agoSo your saying we should introduce chaos monkeys into power grids to improve robustness?
- TeMPOraL 6y agoNo, GP is saying you need to start doing controlled fires on a regular basis, to reduce the accumulation of flammable material. Power grid is not related to that.
- extropy 6y agoActually yes, since they have a huge incentive to Run to Failure. Chaos monkeys would provide a consistent source of failures to make them do their maintenance. Similar to red teams in security.
- chaz6 6y agoThat makes sense, but can we do it in winter when it is less likely to start a fire?
- WJW 6y agoIsn't the point that starting fires regularly keeps any particular fire small due to lack of fuel (since it has been burned in previous fires)? Seems like doing it in winter would defeat the purpose.
- maxerickson 6y agoThe committee to keep the chaos convenient and comfortable.
- dfsegoat 6y agoWhile I appreciate the merits of chaos engineering, this comment lacks an understanding of the impact of these incidents, particularly in rural areas with a history of forest mismanagement. People die [like my neighbors here in Sonoma, CA] - it's not an EC2 instance that gets replaced. Further, one does not just 'restore' the power grid after an outage: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power_outage#Restoring_power_after_a_wide-area_outage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power_outage#Restoring_power_a...
- sitkack 6y agoYou can do simulations, either run it in forward or reverse. Pick a random town, burn it down, run the flame front backwards and find the paths and lines that caused it. Then look at the probable failure rates of those lines. Run it forwards, pick and event and allow it to run its course. When designing simulation runs there are bunch of dimensions to consider * Fidelity or simulation resolution, spatial and temporal * Number of runs, it is a linear search, spatial search, random, gradient * If you are testing specific parameters, like will this bridge hold this static load, multiple simulation runs are done with the inputs varied slightly, input sensitivity analysis. [1] The simulations don't have to be entirely on the computer, they could also couple with them physical and human components. One could page k/n employees that might be on duty at the random time. Response times in real life could be inferred by response to the actual pages. But people were harmed, no actual failures occurred. If society approached civilization seriously, we would apply the full power of science AND engineering while we fail horribly at the application of engineering and suffer its excesses. Given other pro PG&E comments in this thread, and how so many factors were in play and this and that. It all boils down to money and acceptable risk and how to package that up in a way that PG&E gets a slap on the wrist. Well done! It very well could be that we as a society, decide we are ok with these risks, but that we need mediation. And it could be that we A) turn off at risk lines during likely conditions, as shown in simulation or via direct perception B) Have fire bomber planes in the sky during high likely occurrences. But money is cheaper. You gotta spend it to make it. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sensitivity_analysis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sensitivity_analysis
- Dylan16807 6y agoOnly if they occur often enough. PG&E isn't setting fires often enough to do that, so the downsides of every random fire they set strongly outweigh the upsides. If we need more fires, we should use carefully planned ones.
- chipsa 6y agoPG&E isn't in the business of setting fires, and shouldn't be. It's CalFire's job to manage forest fires, including setting controlled burns.
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoThat's not down to an energy company though, that's down to forest management which is troubled by funding and politics.
- andi999 6y agoIs there data from California about lightning as a fire cause? I read in Canada about 50% of all forest fires are started by lightning.
- dcanelhas 6y agoLightning may coincide with rainfall, I've heard. If this is true one might presume less severe fires as a result.
- mannykannot 6y agoIt is a simple fact that lightning does start fires, especially in places like the American west, where lightning is not always accompanied with much, or any, rainfall at ground level. The severity of any fire is determined by how it develops in the hours and days that follow its ignition, long after the storm has moved on or dissipated.
- Rapzid 6y agoThe LNU and SCU lightning complex fires have burned about 750,000 acres. The August complex(also started by lighting) has already burned 796,000 acres.
- gpapilion 6y agoCoastal California lightning is rarer as is thunderstorms. Eastern California they are more common, but no where near Midwest levels. The storm that can through last month started several of these fires with dry lightning or very little rain accompanying the lightning.
- techie128 6y agoThis is a ridiculous argument. Why don't we forcefully tear down all of PG&E's infra every few years. They'll be forced to rebuild it with the latest safety standards... smh
- viraptor 6y agoIt lacks context, but the idea itself is not ridiculous. That's pretty much how original Australians dealt with fuel buildup. Move and burn often. Given specific ecosystem, in a very literal sense, 1000 fires are better than 10 in the same area over the same time period.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoI lived in Africa. The parks used to run controlled burns, every year or two, of the savanna grass. They tended to do this during the [very] wet season. But PG&E is still on the hook for taking better care of their infrastructure. It all comes down to dollars and [non]sense. Some actuary has determined that an occasional lawsuit and rotten press run is cheaper than maintaining the wires. Here in New York, many of the buried water mains that transfer water to the city from upstate are well over a century old. Many are made of cast iron, and even wood. There’s no plan to dig them up and replace them with more robust materials. They just wait for them to fail, then replace the small part that failed. They do give city water some real taste, though. It’s probably actually nutritious.
- jsymolon 6y ago> water mains that transfer water to the city from upstate are well over a century old. ... They just wait for them to fail, then replace the small part that failed. At some point, all the older parts will get so old that it fails frequently and at a greater rate, that the fix cost will greatly exceed the budgeted amount. Being a quite cynical person, I would say that up to that point management will have collected fat bonuses, then cry poverty and push for ruinous rate increases. Along the same lines, CT just had an issue with a rate increase that doubled most bills. The point being spreading out the cost over years and limiting "downtime" is a lot better than 1 huge event that leaves customers without. (re: Detroit and bottled water) https://www.fox61.com/article/news/local/eversource-and-ui-are-under-fire-with-recent-massive-rate-increases/520-222964e3-063b-4bc1-9ded-285aba930230 https://www.fox61.com/article/news/local/eversource-and-ui-a...
- patcon 6y agoSupport for 1,000 fires being better than 10: https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2019/08/26/a-trailblazing-plan-to-fight-california-wildfires https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2019/08/26/a-trailblazing...
- skytreader 6y agoI think the point is PG&E should be blamed for negligence but not for the fire[1]. They could follow all regulation to the letter and there will still be a non-negligible chance that their infra will cause a fire simply because existing regulation is not suitable for the environment their infra stands at. [1] Although I think the thread is rather vague as to the damages assigned to PG&E no?
- noselasd 6y agoThat's usually not how laws works though. If you act irresponsibly, break laws, don't perform due dilligence and so on, you are also responsible and get blame for the consequences. If you act in good fait, follow all regulations, act responsible, the law might see it as an accident where you don't get blame.
- mensetmanusman 6y agoWith this logic, one would blame welders for the Beirut bombing, because they weren’t wearing side shields on their safety glasses.
- zaarn 6y agoWell, they clearly did not establish the fire load in the immediate area of the weld, as is common safety practise in the industry. You wouldn't want to weld near an active gas line either, you want to ensure it's not filled with gas.
- resonantjacket5 6y agoNo the root of the problem is that there's too much forest that hasn't burned. Blaming PG&E is missing the actual problem. For instance the Beirut explosion was the fault from the welders causing the explosion. Yes, but the larger and more important issue is why are there so many explosives in the first place? California's mismanagement with it's forest is the same issue. These forests should be periodically burned the remove rather than letting them accumulate into such a large blazing fire.
- Akronymus 6y agoThe policy of not clearing underbush at all just seems ripe for even more wildfires.
- mschuster91 6y agoA wildfire that regularly clears out only the underbush is what was the place historically (and the ecosystems have adapted to this), human prevention of these fires plus climate change has led to fires consuming way more material than they should.
- awalton 6y ago> Yes, but the larger and more important issue is why are there so many explosives in the first place? Ah, so the problem is negligence. And what negligence was there? PG&E not maintaining their towers as clearly documented (or rather, not documented as the thread shows), or even possibly the federal government not maintaining Bureau of Land Management and USDA Forest lands? No - it's California's fault, spoken as if even a healthy forest wouldn't burst into flames if someone threw molten hot aluminum on a kindling pile. But where could that idea possibly have come from? Perhaps the Federal govermnent, whose head has basically been parroting that exact line? What an astounding coincidence.
- resonantjacket5 6y agoThe problem has been built up for decades through both democratic and republican administrations.
- klmadfejno 6y agoSuppose the government left barrels of leaky oil around, then you cause a small fire, which escalates into a huge fire as a result. It's fair to say that you caused the fire. It's probably also fair to say that the bulk of damages are due to government negligence. The debate is where we fall on that spectrum. I would think the power company should be punished as if it caused fires on an average managed forest but there's going to be nuance. Point is there's two parties with some degree of negligence.
- baddox 6y agoBut that’s not the full analogy. The full analogy would be that the government left oil barrels around the whole state, and you went around the state starting hundreds of small fires, and if you had not done that, there would still have been a few fires from other sources, but there would be far fewer fires overall.
- macspoofing 6y ago>You’re conceding that if PG&E were a competent and responsible company they could significantly reduce the rate of fires. No. He's saying that even if "PG&E were a competent and responsible company", the fire would still start, but through some other mechanism because it is a powder keg waiting to be set off by something. California wildfires are due to bad forest management policy spanning decades.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]