14 ms·
Congressional inquiry faults Boeing and FAA failures for deadly 737 Max crashes
- t3rabytes 6y agoGreat. Now what we do to keep it from happening again? How do we reduce corporatocracy and regulatory capture?
- Operyl 6y agoIn classic American fashion it’ll be increased as the solution!
- gmac 6y agoIf the US system is even slightly functional, the FAA will get beefed up and we'll be fine for a decade or two. Then people will again start saying "we've had no accidents for years, therefore flying is really safe, so why all this burdensome regulation?". Regulation will get scaled back, something like the 737 MAX will happen again, the FAA will get beefed up, and so on, ad infinitum. It's this sort of regulatory boom and bust that makes me feel humans shouldn't be allowed to do anything that's dangerous on a really large scale (such as nuclear power).
- joss82 6y agoNuclear power is not that dangerous on a large scale compared to coal power. Or burning any fossil fuel for that matter.
- sgt101 6y agoJuggling chainsaws is not so dangerous compared to Russian roulette.
- joss82 6y agoWell, I cannot undo years of pervasive anti-nuke sentiment in a small hacker news comment. I was like you before, it's the "default" sentiment to feel like nuclear power is dangerous and dirty. Please do your homework and collect information from reliable sources on the matter. It might change your mind, or at least give you a more balanced viewpoint.
- bob29 6y agoOr do your homework and find that it’s actually far worse than pro-nuclear propagandists constantly claim. Huge increases in rates of multiple forms of cancer near nuclear sites, while the rest of the country is seeing decreases - but not attributed to nuclear. Huge environmental problems and costs pawned off on the US dept of energy and taxpayers, but not attributed to nuclear. Assassinated whistleblowers. Nuclear industry is a textbook example of regulatory capture. If the renewable guys were anywhere near as good we’d see 0 deaths from solar and wind. “The solar panel didn’t kill him, it was gravity and a slippery ladder”
- joss82 6y ago> Or do your homework and find that it’s actually far worse than pro-nuclear propagandists constantly claim. Well, I did. And did not find any convincing claims. Try to take a step back and not see everyone as either anti or pro. Show me your evidence for your claims. "Assassinated whistleblowers" is a pretty strong statement, it requires pretty strong evidence.
- bob29 6y agoKaren Silkwood?
- yrro 6y agoSo far, no. But a single nuclear power plant has the potential for continent-wide devastation. Is the same true of the world's largest coal power plants (~6.7 GW)?
- joss82 6y ago> But a single nuclear power plant has the potential for continent-wide devastation. This is not true. The space destroyed to make way for coal strip-mining in Germany alone, is larger than Tchernobyl exclusion zone.
- Schiendelman 6y agoA nuclear power plant from 50 years ago, yes. A new one can’t do that.
- ekianjo 6y ago> It's this sort of regulatory boom and bust that makes me feel humans shouldn't be allowed to do anything that's dangerous on a really large scale (such as nuclear power). You had a good comment except for the last line. Nuclear power is the safest form of energy production out there (and by far).
- furyg3 6y agoHis point is not that nuclear power is not dangerous, his point is that according to his theory, humans will get complacent and walk-back regulations when nothing happens, leading to potential nuclear accidents that were needless.
- ekianjo 6y agoHow long do we have to wait to see this prophecy realize? Because nuclear power has been around for a long time already, and the industry remains extremely regulated.
- jsjohnst 6y ago> Because nuclear power has been around for a long time already, and the industry remains extremely regulated. The industry was very heavily regulated globally before Chernobyl and Fukushima, but look what happened. I’m not saying I’m against nuclear power (as I’m not). I’m not saying that any industry regulation is generally ineffective most of the time, especially when financials and greed gets involved (even though it appears to be true). I’m just saying humans are bad at moderating risk over long periods of time.
- sofixa 6y ago> The industry was very heavily regulated globally before Chernobyl and Fukushima, but look what happened Gross incompetence and huge design issues 40 years ago on one hand, and complacency+incompetence that required a huge natural disaster to pose a problem, and even then it resulted in less death and destruction than the evacuation, the natural disaster itself or your regular fossil fuel power plant? Not sure that's a good example.
- DangerousPie 6y ago> If the US system is even slightly functional I have some bad news for you...
- bufferoverflow 6y agoNuclear power in western countries has been regulated to the crazy safety standards (not to confuse with the military fuckups).
- notimetorelax 6y agoI think it’s an optimization problem and incentives problem. We should be reevaluating level of funding over time, otherwise government organizations will grow indefinitely, but here’s where the incentives come in play, who would be interested in doing this evaluation gradually and with the backing of data? I believe the latter depends on the society and the politics.
- ethbr0 6y ago> regulatory boom and bust The root cause is pretty easy to describe: benefits are apparent and risks are hidden. It's much harder for people to weigh things that might happen against things that will happen. Especially when the former is negative and latter is positive (positive outcome bias). Consequently, in meeting after meeting, risk safeguards are erroded. Because each meeting has a relatively minor "Do we want this benefit, or to hedge this risk?" decision, and in aggregate, people pick the former.
- emarsden 6y ago> It's this sort of regulatory boom and bust that makes me feel humans shouldn't be allowed to do anything that's dangerous on a really large scale (such as nuclear power). For more thinking along these lines, see the book “Normal Accidents: Living with High-Risk Technologies” (1984) by sociologist Charles Perrow (concerning nuclear power), the book “The Limits of Safety — Organizations, Accidents and Nuclear Weapons” (1993) by Scott Sagan concerning nuclear weapons, and the work of philosopher Hans Jonas on the “imperative of responsibility” (1980s).
- Chris2048 6y agoFine if humanity will never have to tackle anything complex for it's own survival, e.g. deflecting an asteroid on a collision course with earth (or evacuating the planet before it does), dealing with global warming, or some other planetary change (natural or otherwise), dealing with overpopulation / resources etc. It would also require every other nation on earth to agree with the restriction, which isn't really compatible with the premise in the first place; if the regulations are self-imposed, people will stop following them.
- mcny 6y agoI still believe capping executive pay is a necessary (though not sufficient) part of any practical solution. At least for publicly traded companies, we must cap compensation at no more than 50x minimum wage or something. No, executive compensation does not "come from a different pot" or any such nonsense. Don't listen to such silly arguments. Literally no shareholder wants to pay executives more unless they are executives at a different company where their buddies are on the board. Some HN readers apparently don't like to hear this but I don't see any other way. As for how we can reduce regulatory capture, I don't believe there is any good solution other than constant vigilance.
- tremon 6y agoSome things come to mind: - Better whistleblower protections - Personal liability for making false or misleading statements to a regulatory agent - Corporate death penalty. No more "too big to fail" nonsense. If there were actual competition among aviation manufacturers, the government could just dissolve the company and auction off the product lines to competitors. Safeguarding against capture from the regulatory side is more difficult. But I guess term limits for decision-making positions could help, or having a good process for identifying and declaring conflicts of interest?
- sneak 6y agoNot only would such a corporate death penalty never, ever get used against Boeing by the USG if such a thing were to exist, the USG would not advance such a circumstance where it could exist in the first place. There are a number of industries and companies that will exist as long as the current USG does, at least for our lifetimes, due to decisions that were made long ago. Examples include Lockheed, Boeing, and Microsoft. Any solution to the problem needs to accept and address the levels of deep integration between these companies and the state.
- xxpor 6y agoThe first step could be forcing Boeing to spin out McDonnell Douglas again. The real issue is there are 0 alternatives to Boeing right now for US based design for the DoD.
- redis_mlc 6y agoIt's worse than regulatory capture. The FAA delegates oversight to non-FAA contractors working and being paid at Boeing. If they don't agree with Boeing mgmt., they are fired. Also, the FAA manages safety using paperwork. The submitted paperwork did not match the excessive MCAS trim rate. "The problem is it was compliant and not safe." is a false statement. MCAS performance did not match the paperwork filed with the FAA. The Republican comment about it not being a system problem is also false. The FAA has a history of losing control until an accident. The result of the 1956 Grand Canyon accident was that they determined the ATC system "was not a system." In the case of the 737 MAX, the FAA latitude given to Boeing allowing it to outsource everything and self-certify bad designs is a system failure for airliner design and mfg. Midair collision between a Trans World Airlines Lockheed 1049A and a United Airlines Douglas DC-7 https://lessonslearned.faa.gov/ll_main.cfm?TabID=1&LLID=50 https://lessonslearned.faa.gov/ll_main.cfm?TabID=1&LLID=50 Equally disturbing, and it illustrates Boeing's extreme mgmt. dysfunction, is the gamifications with the meeting room shotclock and the Southwest $1 million penalty per plane for a different sim. Source: commercially-rated airplane pilot.
- yholio 6y agoA big part of the solution that does not involve the government is the market reaction driven by sometimes irrational consumer behavior. Some passengers are now weary of all recent Boeing designs, and even of the excelent 737. The margins are razor thin and if 5% decide to book elsewhere, it can turn a profitable route into a flop. So Boing will pay not only the massive costs of withdrawing the MAX since orders for it are plummeting. But this event will affect all its business. This is why there is lobbying/political pressure to divert at least some of the blame, the implications are in the tens of billions in the next few years. So the good news is that the company will be forced to clean-up its act voluntarily, a similar safety disaster could mean extinction.
- tboyd47 6y agoI wish that kind of free-market-driven correction were possible, but passengers have no control over which airplanes they fly in. You don't book tickets with Boeing or Airbus; you book tickets with Southwest or Spirit, and even if they tell you the make of the plane you'll be flying, they can change it up at any time without refunding you.
- yholio 6y agoMany european airlines announced a no questions asked refund policy on 737 Max tickets. Even Ryanair who initially rejected the idea, latter made a U-turn under pressure from concerned passengers: https://www.independent.co.uk/travel/news-and-advice/ryanair-boeing-737-max-cancel-flight-refund-nervous-flyer-a9375746.html https://www.independent.co.uk/travel/news-and-advice/ryanair... The refund would be made at gate level, since the plane allocations are made in the last minute. It's certainly a factor behind the hundreds of MAX orders that were canceled thus far. Fitch lowered it's delivery estimate from 700 to 75 MAX planes for 2020.
- dirtyid 6y agoActually punish white collar crime.
- lordnacho 6y agoNot meaning to open a whole can of worms, but it might be the case that the US needs a better constitution. It seems like the current two-party system is in fact part of the "corporatocracy and regulatory capture", but with current electoral law they are unlikely to ever be dislodged.
- dane-pgp 6y ago> with current electoral law they are unlikely to ever be dislodged. Fortunately, the individual states are not prevented from implementing reforms like Ranked Choice Voting, which would allow new parties to form and gain a reputation in politics at least at the state level. If a party repeated that success across multiple states, that could be used to pressure the largest two parties to support similar reforms, like making Congressional districts return multiple representatives (proportional to the vote within that district).
- dfxm12 6y agoHow do we reduce corporatocracy and regulatory capture? There are elections coming up in November. You'll have at least 2 federal races on the ballot. Figure out where the candidates stand with regards to corporatocracy and regulatory capture and vote accordingly. If you don't like where any of the candidates stand, there will be another election in 2 years. In the mean time, let the candidates know how you feel. Donate to, or volunteer for the candidates who you want to win.
- tremon 6y agosigh. > Republicans on the committee did not endorse the investigative report. [..] criticized Democrats for an investigation that "began by concluding that our system was broken and worked backwards from there." So, do many republicans hold the view that killing 346 people in the first year of service is acceptable business practice?
- dboreham 6y agoBecause money.
- deugtniet 6y agoEven if the republicans are right in how the process was performed, it doesn't make the democrats wrong. Sounds a lot like whataboutism to me
- DaniloDias 6y agohttps://youtu.be/YjVdq5tJSto https://youtu.be/YjVdq5tJSto
- pc86 6y agoThat's not remotely an example of "whataboutism."
- jonplackett 6y agoIt doesn't really matter if you work backwards or forwards if you can prove your conclusion.
- rjtavares 6y agoIt also seems reasonable to assume that such an extreme situation is the result of a broken system. The tricky think is to identify what exactly is broken.
- koolba 6y agoYes it does. Working backwards from a desired claim to generate only supporting facts would reinforce only that claim. It’d be like the police only investigating the one usual suspect and refusing to look for evidence that did not pertain to that suspect. Working forwards from gathering facts to a conclusion may lead to the same place or somewhere entirely different.
- golergka 6y agoI still don't understand how you guys managed to build a country where a major defense contractor and a government agency can be found guilty. There's just too many reasons for this to fail to all the different level of corruption; I look at this marvelling at how the hell does it still work. If you don't see it as an incredible achievement and don't feel proud of it, you don't have any perspective on what's the other parts of the world are like, and were like for the most part of history. Don't take things like this for granted.
- WJW 6y agoThey're not found guilty, government officials have "found that mistakes were made and the culture is rotten". The first brings legal punishments, the second can be waved away and swept under the rug with promises like "we'll do better next time". Maybe a few pawns will be fired to appease the public.
- golergka 6y agoThat's still quite incredible.
- salawat 6y agoYou've actually got a decent point, even if you haven't exactly grasped the nuances of what is going on. This is more of a public statement of intent that may turn into something, or may not. It's just the assembly making a statement. A conviction in the court of public opinion does not a conviction in a court of justice make, or an actual remediation of the regulatory process create. What it means for the parties involved is far from settled even though the entry in the history books is written. This'll make good fodder for campaigns, may shift the color of up and coming civil servants' careers, and will almost certainly pave the way for any type of criminal probes going on. Even with those, however, the criminal proceeding must be conducted against specific individuals, who will be exceedingly difficult to pin down beyond a reasonable doubt, or otherwise against the company itself likely on some other much lesser charge that will likely get negotiated down to something not terribly satisfying in the grand scheme of things. I mean, look at PG&E for an example of the outcome of a corporate actor being found guilty. Boeing (or at least it's civil aviation aspect) has much more to pull from in terms of slush expenditure to dedicate to softening the blow of this hiccup short of concerted political action or punitive lawmaking. It's a sign. Encouraging to some, but empty, dust filled, and tasteless to many who expected much more of the system. I'm hoping these deaths will not be in vain and that this may kindle a political will to encourage greater corporate accountability and responsibility down the road; but beyond doing my small part I can't say as I entertain an excess of confidence of that happening. No offense meant, but it is also cold comfort indeed to be taking solace from, "we could be even more corrupt". Then again, maybe, just maybe we'll manage to pull a rabbit out of this. After all, it was an act of Congress, and if a bunch of people have done it, well... Stands to reason yet another group of folks can do it.
- bufferoverflow 6y agoI hope prison time for the execs. But probably will not happen.
- sebazzz 6y agoRemember Equifax? We don't talk about that.
- avsteele 6y agoAre there any experts here who have read the report? If so I have two questions. 1) How qualified are the congressional investigators to evaluate technical decisions in the MCAS design? 2)Second point: Notably, the article is quite vague about the actual mistakes that where made. Is there any specific bad decisions it notes that would be errors without the benefit of hindsight?
- wil421 6y agoFor point 1 I don’t think it matters if they understand the technical design. As long as they understand the failures that led to a flawed design. Mostly likely the FAA trusting Boeing and a lot of managerial failures on Boeing due to management glossing over engineers and pilot feedback.
- salawat 6y agoI read the FAA's final report, and to be frank, I feel like many punches were pulled. There were mountains of evidence of a dysfunctional culture and cavalier attitude toward regulation at Boeing. Despite the punch pulling, there were also admissions that the plane (without the MCAS flight law) would not have passed certification requirements for carrying passengers, cementing a solid motive for regulatory obstruction and perception management. Mary a mention or touching on any of that in the report. It went to great lengths to show that the "process worked as followed" yet never addressed the issue that said process led to 346 deaths. It's frustrating, because I left the report with the feeling the conclusion was "Process is fine, people just need to follow it better" when the entire point of having a process is to take into account human capacity to err and designing it out. I think Representatives are basically applying their plank to the report. Which is bloody stupid, because they need to be reading between the lines and focusing on the problem, not whether their party leaders approve of their approach or output.
- jacquesm 6y agoNary?
- 6y ago
- phkahler 6y ago>> the horrific culmination of a series of faulty technical assumptions by Boeing's engineers, a lack of transparency on the part of Boeing's management, and grossly insufficient oversight by the FAA. That is being very kind to Boeing management. Its blaming the engineers and the FAA but the management was just not transparent? Boeing fought hard for their autonomy and ability to self certify, so I guess the FAA failed by allowing that. But that doesnt exempt the management at Boeing who was supposed to create an organisation with processes in place to design and build safe airplanes. They had such an organisation but failed to maintain it as such. That's more than a lack of transparency.
- raxxorrax 6y agoAnyone working in engineering knows that any form of resistance would have been futile. I bet the engineers of MCAS didn't even have a view on the overall system and their solution probably fits the risk- and requirements analysis. You should be able check that, that is why we focus on documentation in security relevant branches. Responsibility is for the stupid, certainly not for management.
- moeris 6y ago> I bet the engineers of MCAS didn't even have a view on the overall system By system so your mean the MCAS, the airplane, it Boeing. I don't think you're correct if your mean the MCAS or how it integrated with the airplane. You don't think they had any sort of integration tests established? Also, one one the failings was that the system only relied on input from a single sensor, so that failing should have been extremely obvious. Unless by system you mean Boeing as a whole. I'm sure that as a part of the requirements process they were told that the system can be deactivated (which it could be), and I'm sure they were probably unaware that pilots were not being trained in disabling the MCAS. That makes those technical failures still obvious, but nonetheless understandable and maybe even acceptable in that context.
- jcims 6y agoDepends how the engineering teams are partitioned really. MCAS could be built as a closed system with a set of interface specs that the avionics teams would then have to integrate and test. That said, someone definitely should be doing integration tests.
- bearjaws 6y agoWho would have thought that after decades of privatization and corporate lobbying, the FAA would no longer be functional enough to prevent this kind of disaster? This same story is repeating throughout all the American regulatory bodies and it is only going to get worse.
- varispeed 6y agoThis is a case of privatisation of profits. The company for all intents and purposes is a state run company through regulations. Corruption and greed enabled to side step these
- known 6y agoProper Whistle blower program would have prevented these failures
- known 6y ago"The significant problems we have cannot be solved at the same level of thinking with which we created them" --Einstein https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Snowden_(film) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Snowden_(film)
- tuna-piano 6y agoI understand there were problems at Boeing and the FAA that lead to the unexpected first crash. I'm honestly not that bothered that a plane crashed (besides the general sadness of any loss of life tragedies). Sometimes bad things happen... these are complex machines and regulatory systems. The process seems to be working and problems are being addressed. Plane crashes are super, super rare. What I don't understand, and does bother me, is why the plane continued to fly after the first crash and even, inexcusably, for days after the second crash! That seems to me a bigger indictment of Boeing's and the FAA's reluctance to put safety over money.
- supernova87a 6y agoAs with so many "root cause" investigations, there are deeper issues the more you dig. And these issues turn out to be both a gradual evolution of circumstances that changed Boeings, Congress's, and our collective responsibility for the matter when you peel back the layers. It turns out (in my view) that this is just the inevitable result of a slow abandonment of the role that the military, federal government, and the US people elected to play in the development of civil aviation in the last century. Maybe many have forgotten, but our civil aviation legacy largely came from R&D and production of aircraft during WW2 and later. Boeing, McDonnell, Grumman, Northrop, these were all companies that formed from that legacy. But what they produced besides planes was a government infrastructure that was expert in procuring, regulating, and evaluating the performance of not just aircraft but also companies. And it also produced aircraft companies that worked closely with government -- but most importantly, with their concerns in mind. They were partly the customer! Over 50 years, the pressures of public debt, cost of employees, efficiency, etc. meant that that expertise in the regulatory bodies gradually began to be hollowed out. Experts in government found themselves too bothered by the heavier and heavier constraints of government, and lured by the higher salaries of the private sector. The leaders of a new field were replaced by mere maintainers of it. We all know what happens as that changes, I think. Government gradually also became less of a "customer" in the design and production of planes. And the airplane companies themselves became more profit-need-driven. They are basically like the auto manufacturers with huge workforces that need their insurance and IAM wages paid. So what do you get in a situation like this? The inevitable: Aircraft manufacturers that start to optimize their designs and production for low cost and "simple" variations on old designs (don't want to invest in from-scratch new planes). Regulators who don't know how to evaluate properly new designs, and anyway whose responsibilities are basically staffed for and by the airline because few people want to be regulators. And a public that incentivizes this all because we have other debts to pay and don't want to cough up the $ in ticket prices or taxes. Until a plane crashes. Anyway, that's my take. So if they were honest, Congress would point the mirror at themselves too, in this exercise.
- varispeed 6y agoSurely it was engineers decision to do short cuts. This is just appalling. All managers should be in prison.
- stjohnswarts 6y agoI think any engineer who won't refuse to work on dangerous projects and not take precautions is as guilty as the manager pushing for any unsafe changes. You have to step up and let them know you'll leave if they don't change. Talk to their managers if you don't have to. Save your emails too. Don't be party to stuff like this, a big spot of blood will be on your shirt at the end of the day if someone (or multiple someones) dies as a result. No one can forsee everything but if you do and you don't do anything about it you are as guilty as anyone down the chain of "unfortunate situations" that allowed it to happen.
- renewiltord 6y agoDespite the fetishization of “real engineering” and “standards”, once again we come down to the bare truth: software engineers are the only ones with true ethical standards. Easily measured by numbers of people killed. In fact, web front-end engineers are far more ethical than any others. If you work at Slack you are a better engineer than Boeing aeronautics. Never forget this.
- thehappypm 6y agoThis is totally nonsense. You think drones have no software in them?
- renewiltord 6y agoWell, drones don't have any Slack instances running on them. If you want to exclude all defence contractor software-engineers from the list of software-engineers that's fine. I am comfortable with that. Though I suppose when your job is killing people, killing people is a sign of competence. I think Boeing wasn't trying to kill people with the 737 Max, but I'm no expert on corporate psychology. The important thing to remember is that true engineering is building Electron and React apps not whatever nonsense all these guys who go around constantly accidentally killing people do. Aeronautics, such a poor field with poor standards. Any guy using React+Redux is a superior engineer. After all, he won't be killing anyone by accident.
- thehappypm 6y agoI know you’re trolling, but even your troll argument is flawed. WayFair sold furniture (ahem, cages) to ICE. Facebook monetizes murderers with ads. People suck. Engineers in general are trying to make a better world. Sure “better” might mean “my missile is better than my enemy’s missile”. Or “my ads are more engaging than my competitor”. But engineers are building things. Through and through, engineers build. Not too many professions can honestly say they create.
- renewiltord 6y ago