6 ms·
I really think that false statements made by commercial entities should be prosecuted as fraud. It's one thing to engage in vague sales talk like 'the new Super
by anigbrowl 6y ago
I really think that false statements made by commercial entities should be prosecuted as fraud. It's one thing to engage in vague sales talk like 'the new SuperTech Blinkenlights will turbocharge your actuarial skydiving research!!', but when you're making claims of having actually existing technology (which you may not be ready or willing to patent, but do want to raise money with), the public has an interest in protecting itself from fraud.
Perhaps there should be some requirement to pay for independent professional witnesses, sort of like observers who validate Guinness world records as having met some (negotiable) standard of existing in the real world while being bound not to comment on the specifics of how it was achieved.
- BigCatStuff 6y agoI agree that it should be fraud, but I'm not sure how the SEC defines fraud. To me, the whole NKLA situation feels like a giant Kickstarter scam.
- ganoushoreilly 6y agoI agree. It seems like the Theranos of the EV world.
- roywiggins 6y agoEverything everywhere is securities fraud. > contributing to global warming is securities fraud, and sexual harassment by executives is securities fraud, and customer data breaches are securities fraud, and mistreating killer whales is securities fraud, and whatever else you’ve got. Securities fraud is a universal regulatory regime; anything bad that is done by or happens to a public company is also securities fraud, and it is often easier to punish the bad thing as securities fraud than it is to regulate it directly. https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2019-06-26/everything-everywhere-is-securities-fraud https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2019-06-26/everyt... The problem is, who was defrauded? The investors, I guess, but if they sue then they can only collect money from the company that they own anyway. It's not obvious that's a money-gaining proposition.
- xkjkls 6y agoNot a money-gaining proposition, but that's why some CEOs should go to jail. We need to create an environment where fraud like this isn't profitable or sustainable.
- andrewmutz 6y agoThe investors could bring a derivative suit against the officers of the corporation. They wouldnt be collecting from the corporation, but from the officers of the corporation (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Derivative_suit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Derivative_suit). Presumably it would not be feasible to collect large sums from the officers, but they frequently do have D&O insurance policies that could kick in (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Directors_and_officers_liability_insurance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Directors_and_officers_liabili...)
- xkjkls 6y agoThis is currently the golden age of fraud. Jay Clayton has destroyed any set of teeth that the SEC once had. This is why people have been so critical of Elon Musk. Elon Musk's flippant behavior engenders worse and worse.
- LatteLazy 6y agoFyi, fraud is notoriously hard to convict on and even when large frauds are successfully prosecuted, the penalties are quite small. The SEC also can't be seen to be "hammering entrepreneurs" or let its conviction rates drop. So why get involved?
- Miraste 6y agoApparently institutional investors are just Kickstarter backers with more money.
- ponker 6y agoThe major difference is that Kickstarter “investors” have no upside exposure.
- roywiggins 6y agoAh, but they have an 'airtight' defense! > "Nikola never stated its truck was driving under its own propulsion in the video," Nikola wrote. "Nikola described this third-party video on the Company’s social media as 'In Motion.' It was never described as 'under its own propulsion' or 'powertrain driven.'
- xkjkls 6y agotbh thats probably legalistically enough for them to avoid getting sued But the very idea that "yeah, you're right on all the facts, its just that we didn't really 'lie'" isn't a great defense of the business
- lordnacho 6y agoThe law normally considers what a reasonable person would think, doesn't it? Who would think it was anything other than moving under its own power?
- xkjkls 6y agoIt depends on the circumstance. In the case of an investor, there's much more assumed due diligence than just "what a reasonable person would think".
- lordnacho 6y agoIf the guy shows you a video, are you gonna actually ask him whether it was what it looks like? I guess you ought to kick the tyres on the real thing though.
- awb 6y agoInvestors are supposed to conduct their own due diligence which could include talking to the engineers or setting up a demo under mutually agreed conditions at which point the difference between "in motion" and "driving" would be uncovered. It's definitely not a good look though.
- carriganisms 6y agoThis is called due diligence, and it's on the investor to perform their own due diligence. For a product that isn't commercially available to consumers yet, due diligence should be enough. In the case of something like Theranos, I thoroughly agree. Oversight of a commercially available product, especially one with health implications, is definitely necessary. Although it seems even these systems failed in the Theranos case.
- xkjkls 6y agoThese systems where never triggered because of where Theranos was in the development process.
- R0b0t1 6y agoThe oversight is ostensibly someone figuring out it is a scam and filing a complaint with the district attorney so they can prosecute the scammer.
- sib 6y agoWhile it's true that funders should perform due diligence, diligence for fundraising still relies on an underlying need for the entity raising funds to be truthful. As an example, if you apply for a bank loan and falsify the application, you can still be charged with fraud and go to jail even though the bank potentially could have discovered the falsehood by hiring an investigator before issuing the loan.
- imglorp 6y agoThere is actually the legal test of a Reasonable Person. If they say they're going to sell trucks, and they present a truck doing truck things (moving), most people would assume it's a complete truck as portrayed. An empty shell is just fraud in the court, hopefully.
- awb 6y agoAgreed, but a reasonable person would also ask: "how well does it drive up hills?", "what are it's miles per charge?", etc. at which point the truth is uncovered. It's not a good look, but you also shouldn't be investing based on what amounts to a commercial. This should be another stain for the company and another warning sign for investors, but we don't need a law against misleading promo videos because almost all are short on information and high on emotion. It's the investor's job to get the information behind the video.
- paxys 6y agoThey can, of course, be prosecuted for fraud if someone brings a valid complaint against them. Is there any evidence that any of their investors were tricked into giving them money or were made false promises?
- SMAAART 6y agoDisclaimer: I am not a lawyer. Well, we do have laws about * False Advertisement * Investors' Fraud Unfortunately they are not applied, or not applied consistently; and this is just one of the many examples that I come across on a weekly basis. What makes matters worse is that when talking about it with people at work or so, they don't seem to care enough and feel it's not a problem. It is a problem, it's a slippery slope into lawless chaos.
- markdown 6y ago> Well, we do have laws about False Advertisement If such laws exist, they aren't worth the paper they're printed on.
- kencausey 6y agoI hope you realize that is simplistic. Is the bar for enforcing such laws very high and do many often slip under it? Yes. And yet prosecutions under such laws are happening constantly.
- sschueller 6y agoLike Tesla's full self driving. It doesn't exist and will not exist for a long time.
- bryanlarsen 6y agoOne's a bad prediction, the other's a lie. There is a difference.
- sschueller 6y agoIt's a lie just as Theranos was. It might be possible one day, it isn't in the near future.
- ric2b 6y agoNo, Theranos didn't just make promises, they said "we're doing this right now in our labs and with our partner, Walgreen".
- smt88 6y agoTesla's software is currently called "Full Self-Driving Capability", which is both a bad prediction and a lie.
- the-dude 6y agoIt has the capability, it just does not exercise it.
- colejohnson66 6y agoI think this is the rub. It depends on your definition of “capable.” While technically, it’s “capable” in the sense all Teslas have sensors they claim are enough, it’s not “capable” of using those sensors for self driving if there’s no code for it.
- nordsieck 6y ago
- mschuster91 6y ago> I really think that false statements made by commercial entities should be prosecuted as fraud. In Germany, we have the "Gesetz gegen den unlauteren Wettbewerb", roughly translated as "law against unfair competition". It's a pretty old piece of law (1896), but unlike other laws in Germany this one is held reasonably up to date. Stuff like we see here would be flat out prosecutable by any competitor.
- dsr_ 6y agoIf Matt Levine weren't on break from his Bloomberg column, you can bet this would be an entry in his file "Everything is Securities Fraud". It wouldn't even be a controversial one.
- golergka 6y agoTo build real motivation for start-up founders not to commit fraud, they would have to be persecuted even when they succeed. But now, if you push through and eventually prevail, everybody wins and nobody cares; may be some former competitors who tried to play it right, but now they're history and have no leverage. Who's going to go after Facebook for their previous shenanigans? Unlike Nikola, their early investors are quite happy. And as long as that's the case, people crazy and risky enough to become startup founders will never be persuated not to do it.