19 ms·
Nvidia's Arm deal sparks quick backlash in chip industry
- novaRom 6y agoWhat we observe right now is the beginning of AI tech wars. I hope it will stay cold and will boost new peaceful applications.
- krona 6y agoUnfortunately, the more Chinese companies complain, the more likely the deal will go ahead unopposed by US/UK/Japanese regulators.
- swarnie_ 6y agoCould be a nice one for UK regulators to hold over the world, need some ammo for those various trade negotiations that are on going/up coming. The US have exercised the same form of economic warfare (and when that fails actual warfare) for decades now, might as well take a turn.
- thelastname 6y agoUK or EU?
- cheschire 6y ago> Nvidia will retain Arm’s United Kingdom headquarters - which exempt it from many U.S. export control laws I was not aware that all it took for a U.S. company to profit from bypassing national security concerns, human rights protections, and weapons proliferation limits[0] was to simply open a foreign HQ or buy a company with one. Not that Arm or Nvidia plan to do any of those things, but it sounds like a regulatory moat to me. 0: https://2009-2017.state.gov/strategictrade/overview/index.htm https://2009-2017.state.gov/strategictrade/overview/index.ht...
- throwaway4good 6y agoOr they just want to protect themselves and their customers from an US administration gone off the rails.
- victords 6y agoAnd so they have an office in a politically stable region: The UK!
- krona 6y agoARM will still be a separate legal entity. Nvidea is a corporation, afterall.
- zekrioca 6y agoNvidia
- turbinerneiter 6y agoWhich is interesting, because the US regularly enforces their own law outside its own borders.
- greatpatton 6y agoBut how do you define a US company? In a globalized world it is very difficult to pin point a company to a country, so the headquarter is one way to defined it. Though it is not going to prevent the US to impose sanction to whoever they want.
- azernik 6y agoThat site phrases it as "US-origin dual-use goods". It's not enough to have a foreign HQ, but if you have a separate development organization abroad and a clear delineation between their technology and your US-developed technology, this seems very workable.
- elmo2you 6y agoYou make it sound as if the USA has a high standard from any of those topics. Its national security concerns keep violating laws and even the constitution. Or, take violating laws abroad and numerous international treaties. It doesn't fully implement something as basic as the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. Or, just take what Amnesty International reported already years ago about all US states violating the country's international obligations regarding accountability for police violence. As for weapons proliferation, that has to be the biggest joke of them all. It blatantly makes false claims about other countries, only to have a justification for unilateral withdrawal from treaties and expand nuclear weapon productions. Or, just take the countless wars it has started around the globe, both to make a killing on weapons sales and cynically use them as testing grounds for new weapons. But indeed, none of all that is relevant in this particular case. Even thought the deal is bad news for a number of other reasons. Maybe first and foremost because it is a US company getting its hands on foreign assets. nVidea certainly knows how to evade taxes, so who knows how much of the deal money actually shouldn't be theirs in the first place.
- someperson 6y agoBeing able to block ARM reference designs from Huawei's HiSilicon and other fabless Chinese semiconductor firms like Rockchip and Allwinner has a huge impact on the United States' ability to block China's technological ambitions. Right now I'm not interesting in having a debate about whether or not that's a good thing, but it would be good to have a realistic and sober discussion about the impact on this acquisition on China's technological ambitions. There have been recent reports that China's leading semiconductor firm (called SMIC) will be added to the Entity List, which will blocks its access to western technology. If true, this effectively scuttles China's attempts to compete with Taiwan's TSMC and reach semiconductor fabrication parity. SMIC's ambitions heavily rely on freely accessing US-aligned technology: specifically lithography equipment from the Netherlands-based ASML and engineers poached from Taiwan's world-leading semiconductor manufacturing firms. On the x86 front, when AMD was desperate for cash a few years ago they setup joint ventures with China (THATIC and Hygon) and were transferring AMD's then current-generation Zen 1 architecture to China. Further transfer has also been blocked via the Entity List. It's also worth noting that AMD is in a much better financial position after the success of their Ryzen product line, so has less need to make difficult trade-offs by transferring their current-generation technology in exchange for short-term cash injections, so it seems very unlikely they will applying for an export license. At this point, if I was China, I would invest heavily in RISC-V based cores, and openly release highly competitive designs.
- roenxi 6y agoIt'll be a real test of China as we watch how this tech blockade plays out. 60s China would starve all the peasants to make a point. If 2020 China manages to avoid that rookie blunder, it is difficult to see how the knowledge transfer will be stopped. The US is reliant on bullying to make this work - that is not a strategically dominant position, to say the least. Particularly looking at the Soviets, it is remarkable how often the US's serious adversaries in the last century choose to disembowel themselves. It is a great game to see which government fails beyond recovery first.
- jsjohnst 6y ago> It is a great game to see which government fails beyond recovery first. The scary thing is, it might be the US next.
- varbhat 6y agoGood time to look at RISC-V . Some companies in chip industry may do it.
- gridlockd 6y ago> "China is going to hate it" The upside is that when mainlanders are upset, they can use their smarts to push forward RISC-V. > South Korean chip industry officials and experts said that Nvidia’s Arm buy would intensify Nvidia’s competition with Samsung, Qualcomm and others in self-driving cars and other future technologies, while raising concerns that Arm could hike licensing fees for competitors. Oh no, more competition! Maybe Samsung can ask its little brother, the South Korean government, to intervene.
- supernova87a 6y ago>Being able to block ARM reference designs etc.... has a huge impact on the United States' ability to block China's technological ambitions. Practically speaking, aren't ARM designs so widely used among the major chip manufacturers that Chinese companies/agencies are likely to have copies of important stuff anyway? Or does the implementation of ARM designs work somehow more proprietarily (or opaquely?) than just the customers receiving files full of chip designs? Because I imagine that the prohibition against being able to use ARM is really only meaningful to legal and royalty-paying law-abiding customers. If a rogue agent has the designs already, what's to stop them from using them? I'd be curious to know how ARM protects the designs from just being copied, or what the mechanism here is. Or maybe their designs are useless without the supporting software, etc. ? ARM's value is the licensing of the designs and that they hold patents/copyrights, not the absolute knowledge of the designs -- is that right? Are their designs themselves that hard to copy?
- nabla9 6y agoIt's not about having the designs as you think. It's about the ability to sell products based on ARM IP. * "rogue agent" can't sell products with ARM based technology inside. * "rogue agent" can't produce ARM based chips in foreign fabs (TSMC, Samsung)
- colinmhayes 6y agoWith it looking like SMIC will be added to the excluded company list I don't think they'd mind producing unlicensed chips. I doubt the Chinese government would ban their sale either.
- teruakohatu 6y agoAt a guess I think exports would be the issue. As soon as products containing unlicensed chips leave the country, they could be seized.
- YetAnotherNick 6y agoWhat about updates/extensions? They would have to wait till the spec gets released to the public to bring new compatible functionalities to their chip.
- phendrenad2 6y agoTo those of you who haven't made a CPU before: CPU technology is more like a javascript framework than a natural resource. When someone says "block China from US CPU ISAs" think "block China from US javascript frameworks". Then you'll have the appropriate sense of how silly it is.
- polymorph1sm 6y agoIf javascript frameworks is patented then yes, you can. For reference ARM big little scheduler is patented[1], you need to license from ARM if you use any of their big little design. RISC-V under BSD license might change this. [1] https://patents.google.com/patent/US9710309 https://patents.google.com/patent/US9710309
- dash2 6y agoIf push comes to shove, why would you expect China to respect a set of patents that strangle its economic growth?
- Andrew_nenakhov 6y agoBecause that would result in a more devastating response from the side that holds patents. If china stops respecting international trade laws and agreements, other nations will hurt china's interests in return. Given the scale of the things, the weak spots will be found inevitably.
- michaelt 6y agoJudging from China's policies towards Uighur Muslims and Hong Kong, I think China isn't very worried about foreign censure.
- Andrew_nenakhov 6y agoThere is a difference. Nobody in the first world really cares about Uighurs or Hong Kong. However, there are quite a handful of parties who do care about patents (and resulting profits).
- ferros 6y agoSeparating the ARM specific concerns could someone shed light on the generalised apprehension around Nvidia?
- ckastner 6y agoWith NVIDIA relying on Samsung for fabbing their new Ampere line of GPUs using their 8nm process, and Samsung now relying on NVIDIA for ARM, I wonder how this relationship will develop. I'm guessing that NVIDIA will try to squeeze value out of this acquisition (though not as aggressively as, say, Qualcomm would), but going too far might backfire on them.
- FpUser 6y ago"...Nvidia took great pains to emphasize that Arm will continue to act as a neutral supplier..." Yeah, right. Even if by some magic nVidia has this intention (hard to believe) it will only last right up until Trump or his successor decide to use it as a club against whatever country they decide not to like at the moment.
- mlvljr 6y agoThose arm dealers :)