24 ms·
Tim Sweeney on Apple and Google
- raxxorrax 6y agoApp stores and restrictive operation systems are a real threat in my opinion. We were really lucky that developers and users let at least the Windows store fail. You can earn good and easy money on those under the condition you get a minimal exposure, but I shudder to think this is the future of software. I think Sweeney is correct, although I also think Epic tried to do the same. Their success with some of their games created capital that they used to create their own platform. Maybe as a defense mechanism or maybe because they wanted part of the pie. If a larger developer like Epic has no recourse on store owners, the average developer will have even less. Remember the old times that actually isn't nostalgia? You could just install anything you wanted on your OS that respected your device. Great times.
- brnt 6y agoEpic Store successfully taking games exclusive makes Sweeneys priorities clear: they are no different than Apple's or Google's. I hope Epic fighting this fight will not obscure that.
- fwn 6y agoActions can be judged independent from the actor. If Apple fought against one or many extractive ecosystems that would be a good thing even though Apple itself does profit and plans to continue to profit from their own extractive ecosystem. ...same with Epic.
- dessant 6y agoIn all honesty Satan himself could have sued Apple for all we care, what's important now is that there is someone who has the resources and willingness to fight for our right to sideload apps on our own devices.
- myspy 6y agoSideloading is not the goal. The goal is to establish another store front to sell games with. This is no fight to open up the device, it's a fight to gain profit.
- pharke 6y agoIf they set a precedent then it is likely we will get at least a few more stores if not an abundance. That's at least some improvement. There's an off chance of a complete opening up of iOS devices but I wouldn't bet on it.
- colinmhayes 6y agoI don't give a shit about their goal. If they win precedent will be set to not only allow anyone to open a store, it'll be set to allow sideloading too. The outcome is undeniably good for me, that's all that matters.
- Someone 6y agoDevil’s advocate: you’re free to run whatever you want on the device you bought, but some of the software you licensed prohibits you from running your software on top of it. Also, actually running your software may be a challenge because the boot loader and OS are locked down, but you could have known that when you bought the device. (This is similar to “right to repair”. That isn’t about being allowed to repair your devices, but about making it easier to do so. You’re free to repair your device, but it currently often is almost impossible)
- admax88q 6y ago> you’re free to run whatever you want on the device you bought, Great! > Also, actually running your software may be a challenge because the boot loader and OS are locked down, Oh, so you're not free to run what you want on your device.
- tomohawk 6y agoThis seems like circular reasoning.
- onion2k 6y agoI don't think Sweeney wants the same software to be available on every app store. He wants users to have a choice of which app store to use. Effectively he wants the same deal as there is for PC gaming - eg multiple stores available that users can choose from - to be the case for mobile (and possibly consoles as well).
- luastoned 6y agoWhat? He explicitly forces users to use his/the Epic store, smh.
- sokoloff 6y agoThat’s not inconsistent. Users can choose to use the Epic store or not. If they choose not to use it, they can’t buy games from that store, just like I can’t buy Trader Joe’s food if I decide to not use the TJ’s store.
- pharke 6y agoExactly, people are having a hissy fit over exclusive content that has no further price than downloading a free store app. It's like whingeing about driving to another store to get the brand of ice cream that you like. I have no problem with that as long as the device manufacturer doesn't limit me to a single store. Preferably I'd like to be able to choose any store or independent content. More choices, more freedom, more competition.
- falcolas 6y agoHaving to go to the EGS for a given exclusive game is not choice. It’s not freedom. It’s definitely not competition. Even if I buy a game broadly available on multiple platforms, I’m not getting a discount on it for going to EGS, despite their lower cut.
- OCASM 6y agoIt is in fact those three things. Different stores compete with each other providing different value, both users and devs having the freedom to choose to support one or the other (or all) based on their personal criteria.
- chii 6y ago> Epic Store successfully taking games exclusive exclusive games aren't the same as a monopoly platform. Exclusive games is a choice the creators of the game made. A monopoly platform is when that choice isn't available. If apple doesn't want your app on iOS, they can remove you with no recourse. If Epic doesn't want your game on the Epic store, you have the choice to use steam, or to go alone and distribute independently.
- m12k 6y agoI wish people weren't so quick to jump to this simplistic "who's the good guy and who's the bad guy?" mentality. It's quite possible for Epic to be a bad guy in their own right and still have a valid grievance against Apple, and it's quite possible that it would be better for a lot of smaller devs that this was changed even if Epic is doing this for their own bottom line's sake, not because they are altruistic.
- brnt 6y agoTo be clear: I'm not painting Epic to be bad or good, just that they're as much after their bottom line as the incumbents. That produces a potentially beneficial change for the incumbent platforms, but also a potentially negative change in the same way that having another video streaming service with a proprietary library does not add value at this point.
- simion314 6y agoValve did the same if I am not mistaken you had to install their launcher to play half Life. Now Epic is fighting back with similar tactics and as long as they offer a better deal to the developers, same or better prices for user then I am Ok with it (I did not install the Epic Launcher so far but I claimed a free game just in case)
- Lev1a 6y agoValve was dev and publisher for Half-Life so their game is on their platform. Same with EA, Ubisoft etc. AND guess who? Epic. Dev and publisher for Fortnite. What do you need to install and run to be able to play Fortnite? Epic Games Launcher.
- simion314 6y agoIf I ware Epic I would put Fortnie in Steam but make everything 30% more expensive in Steam (hopefully Steam let's the developer present users information like X is cheaper on Epic and is not like other companies that censors information they don't like). With Fortninte on Steam the dudes that don't want to be bothered with 2 launchers can use only one(you still need Epic accounts like in all MMOs). One of the most popular games is Minecraft and it did not need to be on Steam to get popularity, so it is still possible to host downloads for your game on your servers.
- mattigames 6y agoSteam only reason to be as big as they are is because they went ages without serious competition, so anyone who wants to have the slightest shoot to succeed without such advantage must use exclusives or similar tactics or just die trying.
- DivisionSol 6y agoWhat? How about make a product that actually works? Epic Games Store is a slog to operate, with weird UX decisions across the board. People hated Ubisoft trying to cram their platform down their throats because it was a buggy mess. People are disgusted with the EGS because, likewise, it is a disaster. You don't need a Steam Workshop (a bonus, for sure,) to distribute games. You don't need the Marketplace for Game Economy stuff (a bonus, sure.) You need a way to buy and launch games quickly, which even EGS struggles at.
- madeofpalk 6y ago> Epic Store successfully taking games exclusive People keep bringing this up as a negative, but ignore a) that many games are exclusively on Steam and b) Epic gives guaranteed revenue to developers, derisking development. There is absolutely nothing wrong imho with companies wanting to make their own stores, set their own rules, with whatever exclusivity, to make money for themselves, AS LONG AS there is (fair and equal) competition in the market so if people (developers and/or customers) do not like the rules, they can go elsewhere. Competition is good!
- brnt 6y ago> Competition is good! On Linux, the Epic Store does not compete and therefore it does not add choice for me.
- madeofpalk 6y agoEGS exclusivity doesn't limit distribution for other platforms, im not sure if this also applies for Linux as well. Being on Steam does not guarantee the game will be on Linux. It sounds like your real problem is developers not bothering about shipping their game on Linux.
- smileybarry 6y ago> We were really lucky that developers and users let at least the Windows store fail. This might be an unpopular opinion but: I like the comfort of the Windows Store regarding installation & updates for Win32 apps. The app is installed into its own little corner and a lot of them also come with their own contained registry hive. I don't need a thousand auto update services or an app updating itself only when I open it. And the store requires extensive file signing so as long as I know it's the right developer, the need to manually check installer signatures goes out the window. And regarding minimal exposure, if you simply use it as a download source and redirect customers there, Microsoft takes only 5%. I didn't like S Mode, Windows RT, the restriction to use just the store, etc. That shouldn't be forced upon the already-open PC platform. But I liked having a trusted channel for applications. (I don't mean that every app on there was trustworthy but you get what I mean, like above) > I think Sweeney is correct, although I also think Epic tried to do the same. Their success with some of their games created capital that they used to create their own platform. Maybe as a defense mechanism or maybe because they wanted part of the pie. That's what I think, too. Tim Sweeney likes to harp on about consumer choice, store freedom and such -- but with all the exclusives it's clear they just want to be the new Steam. They want you to have a big Epic Games Store library that you can't give up on, that you would always prefer to add to instead of going to another store. That's why they have these weekly free games, to get everyone to start a foundation of games without having to convince them to buy any for that to happen.
- smichel17 6y agoIn my experience, Linux repositories are all of the upsides you mentioned (trusted, auto-updated, signed (at repo level, at least)) with none of the lock-in downsides, since you can add third party repositories (and then use them via the same workflow you're already comfortable with!).
- darthrupert 6y agoMany of them rely of a free-of-charge labour. Would you volunteer your free time to maintain Apple Store?
- bb123 6y agoFor you a threat, for many others a feature. Lots of people buy iPhones specifically because they are restrictive, and are therefore more robust. Ask an average user which experience they prefer - sourcing software for a Windows PC, or downloading an App for an iPhone.
- realusername 6y ago> Lots of people buy iPhones specifically because they are restrictive, and are therefore more robust Just have a look at a mainstream Youtube video about the latest iPhone and see when they talk about the app review (hint: never). People buy phones based on camera, screen and interface, they never heard about the walled garden or Apple's practices.
- Google234 6y agoI think most users appreciate the lack of malware on IPhones.
- romanoderoma 6y ago> I think most users appreciate the lack of malware on IPhones. Do they? What about bugs? https://www.cvedetails.com/product/15556/Apple-Iphone-Os.html?vendor_id=49 https://www.cvedetails.com/product/15556/Apple-Iphone-Os.htm...
- bb123 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism
- romanoderoma 6y agoThat's where you are wrong If you say "I think US people are happy of having the higher life expectancy in the World" reminding them that it is the lowest in the West is just revealing a lie There is no lack of malware on iPhones. It's a lie.
- pjmlp 6y agoWindows store did not fail as such, it is just uptaking slowly than Microsoft had hoped for. In fact, if it wasn't for the current situation the world is on, Windows 10X would have had UWP/Win32 sandbox only apps.
- cocktailpeanuts 6y ago> I think Sweeney is correct, although I also think Epic tried to do the same. Their success with some of their games created capital that they used to create their own platform. Maybe as a defense mechanism or maybe because they wanted part of the pie. I agree but people who are criticizing Epic for this are missing the real point. It is good if Epic can actually take a big chunk of the pie. Sure you could say they're being hypocrites, but from the point of view of users and developers, it's good to have more competition in the platform arena. Currently it's basically duopoly between Google and Apple. A new actor like Epic can change the dynamics and that is good.
- chii 6y agoEpic's platform is not a monopoly even if they successfully made one. steam is not a monopoly, even if they currently have a large market share, because the user is able to install their software outside of the steam platform. Some games choose to not release on multiple platforms - but that's not a monopoly. And other games _do_ choose to release on multiple platforms, or choose to release independently of a platform. This means the best _game_ wins. Ditto with software.
- LegitShady 6y agoEpic phase to have the monopoly on certain unique products while Tim Sweeney says he values consumer choice. Sweeney is a liar.
- pjmlp 6y agoJust like 80% of the world choses not to use Apple devices.
- cocktailpeanuts 6y ago> Epic's platform is not a monopoly even if they successfully made one Same goes for Apple. The term "monopoly" is not really useful in this discussion. It's more about having a small number of gatekeepers. There are currently exactly 2 gatekeepers of mobile devices in the entire world: Apple and Google. It is possible that Epic could get into a similar position as what Apple is today, but for games. My point is that I support something like this happening, even though people may think that Epic is just another gatekeeper. Gatekeepers can't be avoided, so the solution is to have more gatekeepers, so they can't abuse their power easily.
- flohofwoe 6y agoI've been thinking that the PC as an open platform was a "happy historical accident" that only happened because IBM lost its iron grip over the platform and failed to regain it because hardware clones and Microsoft were quick to jump into the opportunity that had presented itself because IBM didn't look for a second. And maybe Apple is looking at 80's IBM and is now afraid that the exact same thing may happen to them. If this accident hadn't happened, the entire computing world would probably look very different. All the software giants like Microsoft, Google, Facebook, Amazon wouldn't exist because they couldn't have become big on a closed IBM-controlled platform. Apple might only exist because IBM let them live as the convenient underdog, same way as Firefox is being kept alive by Google to thwart off any suspicions that there's a browser monopoly. Maybe PCs wouldn't exist at all and we'd be all sitting in front of IBM mini-terminals now, connected to the cloud running on System/360 mainframes.
- ginko 6y agoYou seem to be completely forgetting all the other PCs and home computers of their time like the C64 or the Amiga. Without Microsoft opening the market for clones the IBM PC might have remained an overpriced office machine and some other company would have created the most popular computer system. In any case, none of these(not IBM, not Apple, not Commodore etc.) restricted what software you could run on your computer.
- flohofwoe 6y agoNot forgotten, I was an Amiga owner myself ;) But somehow these machines feel like belonging to another universe today. Commodore management would have ruined the company either way, this didn't require any help from the PC. Atari would probably have focused on the games console business. Anyway, it's fun to speculate about alternative futures :)
- parasubvert 6y agoThe PC started its life as a hobby platform. And there were attempts to challenge the open model - the game consoles for example required devs to license their SDKs and often controllers publishing / retail distribution. But no one seriously succeeded with a closed PC experience because no one could (or wanted to) do it all - be a fully integrated retail ecosystem - at the time when facing consumers. The internet was arguably a prerequisite for this: all software was sold in physical boxes and unlike game software , the hobby experience meant there was just too much available that was cheap/free/shareware. (My favorite was the assembly hex codes published in magazines like Ahoy! That you’d type in). Plus, the security of a curated store was on few minds until the late 90s with the internet. Viruses and Trojans existed but they were spread through physical media. also, Microsoft already was getting its tax from users in the form of Windows licensing, which eventually was deemed anticompetitive due to their exclusivity arrangements. The closest to a curated ecosystem started with Qlink, CompuServe, AOL and other online services.
- tokamak-teapot 6y agoI believe the current system for protecting iOS and its users could easily be split in two. There could be two exit points from the review process. One would be for apps that don’t want to be on the App Store. They could be cleared as free from malware, egregious behaviour, etc. and allowed to be installed through any independent means. The higher level would be for apps that should be on the App Store. This means they meet the quality standards that Apple would like. This would allow Apple to raise the quality bar for the App Store, while allowing indie development. Loading a non-app-store app could come with forced user acceptance flow, where you’re informed the app doesn’t meet Apple’s standards for user experience but has at least been checked for safety. Independent app ‘stores’ would then be able to exist, and we’d have a compromise.
- blparker 6y agoThis seems like a reasonable idea.
- ginko 6y ago>There could be two exit points from the review process. One would be for apps that don’t want to be on the App Store. They could be cleared as free from malware, egregious behaviour, etc. and allowed to be installed through any independent means. I don't see how such a review process would work for free software. The user should be free to run whatever software they wish on their own device.
- Retric 6y agoThe review process what makes iOS so useful. People can install random software in a way you can’t safely do on Windows. Sure power users might not notice the difference, but people feel safe hand their phones/tablets to little kids and let them install random games. Scaling that review process across every update either means everyone pays a percentage which hurts large business or everyone pays a significant fee which hurts independent developers and discourages bug fixes.
- madeofpalk 6y ago
- Igelau 6y ago> App stores and restrictive operation systems are a real threat What we need is a true champion against this stuff. Someone who is willing to sacrifice normalcy and convenience to be fully committed to software that is free as in freedom, not free as in beer. Imagine a "free software movement". It could center around the GNU toolchain and spiral out from there. Now, where is our hero? We've put up the signal but I do not see him. I hope nothing bad has happened...
- pjmlp 6y agoThe hero is busy reading email messages and web pages sent to him via a gateway system, while everyone keeps pushing for non-copyleft licenses.
- madeofpalk 6y agoThe Windows/Epic situation really is the "best case scenario". You can download and install software from anywhere. Plus, there's an "app store" from the OS vendor, plus a few specality competing ones for things like games, where both consumers and developers have the choice of where they download/publish. Epic competing with Steam has been a great success for everyone I think. Developers get secure funding for games that they otherwise wouldnt be able to make. Consumers get more games, plus they get hefty discounts or even just free games. Ideally we would then see Valve/Steam trying to compete in response. It's win/win/win.
- tpxl 6y agoYou mean consumers need to download yet another gaming service collecting god knows what to get the same games they used to get on Steam? I've no problem with the Epic store, but their exclusives are a cancer and they cost game devs money in lost sales from me.
- viraptor 6y ago> they cost game devs money in lost sales from me. I still don't get how the exclusives are a good deal for the creators. They get more publicity and probably some extra money for the contract. But does it really offset the lost sales? There was a large number of times when I went though: this game looks awesome, I'll buy it, oh it's exclusive for whatever-platform-i-don't-have, ... and likely not remember about it ever again. I even bought similar games which are available on platforms I already have instead.
- tpxl 6y agoIn the case of Epic games, they shovel money their way with a _biiig_ shovel, even for free games. I don't know about PS/Xbox, but the situation is probably similar.
- paulryanrogers 6y agoIs installing another store really so burdensome? It costs nothing but a few minutes of time. GOG Galaxy can even help consolidate them.
- major505 6y agoI don agree, for example in case of android, you do have the option of alternative app store like f-droid and amazon, and is easy enouth for any user to install them. And while of apple you don't have this, when you buy a Iphone your trading this liberty for stability and security. For example, my mother loves to install little games from the store, but she agree with any terms and conditions that pops in the screen. So I feel more secure giving her an Iphone that I know the apps pass for more scrutiny before entering the store. So I don't see as a monopoly, since you do get option of changing platforms and alternative stores. I think in this case epic is in the wrong. They start this on purpose to involve the government in the history, just so they can take a bigger share of gullible people who spends to much on skins in fortinite.
- matz1 6y agoEpic has to step up their game, in order for google to compete in web, they made browser that better than everyone else and they made phone os that actually good to compete in smartphone world. Epic has to do something similar. Sure thats not easy but given they are billion dollar company, they should be able to do it.
- hellisothers 6y agoThis assumes you want to install software from anywhere, or that you want your mom (who you suggested get and iPhone) to be able to install software from anywhere. For similar reasons that hardware admins don’t want you installing anything you like on company hardware, I don’t want my family installing anything they get tricked into installing on their phones. There are other options out there where you can do whatever you want and side load, why not go use those yourself and stop demanding others be subjected to this same situation?
- damnyou 6y agoSideloaded Android software is treated as second class. For example, F-Droid cannot update apps in the background.
- _qulr 6y agoI have nothing against your mom, who I don't know, and I'm sure she's a fine person, but nonetheless, your mom is your problem. Why does your mom become my problem. Why must my freedom be restricted to protect your mom from herself on the computer? Your mom is presumably able to drive a car, which is a killing machine in the wrong hands. Your mom can drink alcohol, smoke cigarettes, buy a gun, use a chainsaw. All of these activities are infinitely more dangerous than using a smartphone. OS lockdown in completely unjustified in comparison. It's a vast overreaction by "helicopter children".
- brendoelfrendo 6y agoThis argument is silly because it can so easily be turned on its head: why should a closed environment be the only option? Why don't you stick to the app store, but allow others to do with their devices as they please?
- kartayyar 6y agoThe difference is the cut that Epic takes is much less than 30% - he is walking the walk rather than just talking about it.
- ngcc_hk 6y agoWhere the money cone from. Who help those small merchant that pay only $99 and some portion to get into such large platform. Still remember the cost of Getting into windows developer. To be honest they are not small player. If they fight for lower percentage for small player may be ... but if rich one do not pay
- sunshinerag 6y agoYes, it can be stopped. All Tim Sweeney is to do is build another mobile hardware/software platform and set the rules for app distribution however he likes. That is the way to beat a monopoly.
- kyran_adept 6y agoThe closer you are to the root of the tree, the harder it is to "build an alternative". It's the same for the road system, power distribution system, mobile platforms(Android, Apple), etc. I can't afford as a customer to buy a device just to play Fortnite, nor should I.
- Zhyl 6y agoYou can leverage existing alternatives, which they already do to some extent. Epic has invested massively in Blender, for example. It's interesting that they've gone the 'pick a fight' route, when 8 years ago when Valve had similar concerns about Windows 8 they did as GP suggested and rolled their own Linux distro and made a bid for the living room space. That particular offensive failed, but Valve's continued investment in the Linux space now means that now, 8 years later, most AAA games without Anti-cheat or some kinds of DRM can be played on Linux seamlessly. If Epic wanted to do likewise, they could invest in Librem 5 or Pinephone and make alternatives more viable.
- tutino 6y agoThat's interesting because indeed Librem 5, Pinephone, etc. could be indeed a unique opportunity for Epic (and Valve) to have their own mobile stores under their own rules. Sure, currently it is insignificant, but so is Linux Desktop, yet Valve invests in Wine/Photon/Wayland/etc. and on the long run it might pay off when they'll have their own consoles. I don't really understand Tim S. , on one hand he hates Apple monopoly, on the other hand he also hates Linux which is the only viable alternative, yet he still supports open source a lot (e.g epic mega grant)
- ecf 6y agoJust because it’s hard to start a new tree when you’re at the root doesn’t mean the up and coming tree can hire a lumberjack to cut down the existing tree.
- aetherson 6y agoApple's defense that they are not a monopolist in any traditional sense is correct as far as it goes. But a novel definition of monopoly may be warranted. As smartphones become more and more a part of the fundamental infrastructure of society, and remain relatively expensive and slow to replace, it's not crazy to say that iPhone users are a market in itself and that market should be protected from monopoly. In the same way that a company in the 1800s might not have been a national or regional monopoly, but very much was a monopoly in their own company town, or how car manufacturers in the 20th Century were forced to allow competition in repair services. I think ultimately, right now, my personal sense is that iPhones don't quite rise to the level of their own market that needs to be opened up, but it's close.
- mcintyre1994 6y agoI heard a similar interesting idea on a recent episode of the Advanced Tech Podcast. Someone on there suggested that the mobile economy might be a legitimate market, and iOS has always had a hugely outsized share of the money flowing through app stores etc.
- whatever1 6y agoFollowing Apples way of thinking, Standard oil was not a monopoly. You could choose to source your energy from coal, power your train with steam etc. But the fact is that it was one.
- 52-6F-62 6y agoThat comparison would be calling every other phone on the market not just inferior, but entirely different technology. Seeing as they all can access the same networks and be comprised of varying hardware and use varying operating systems I just don’t think that’s true. It’s like Apple being the sole supplier of a specific type of unleaded fuel. And people like me choosing that fuel because it might be more expensive and more restrictive, but I don’t have to worry as much about the condition of my car engine on a regular basis for using it. There are plenty of other just as powerful, or even more powerful, fuels on the market that function on the same principles but with different features.
- mlthoughts2018 6y agoI’m surprised to find myself siding with Apple / Google / etc on this. They did the work to build and maintain a distribution platform. They should be able to define its terms of use and costs. If you don’t like it, distribute differently. If everyone uses those companies’ devices, it’s a market endorsement that the world wants the standardization and managed ecosystem of each platform - that it’s a thing of value. I don’t see how there’s any way you can tell Apple how Apple has to run infrastructure to support a distribution channel, but it cannot determine the prices or policies for someone using it to distribute an app.
- devit 6y agoThey don't have to run infrastructure, they just have to update iOS to remove the signature check on binaries and support installing IPAs from Safari downloads, so that there is no need for their app store anymore.
- mlthoughts2018 6y agoAs a consumer of Apple devices, I want the app store, and I only want app store software to be possible on the device. So if Apple needs to meet consumer demands, I’m an example of a consumer who wants the app store to work like it currently does, and I feel Apple’s policies of taking a cut of subscriptions and in-app purchasing is fair. For a system where I want openness, I’ll use Librem 5 for example.
- can16358p 6y agoI've read all of your comments and think that it couldn't be more right! This, this, this! Thank you.
- simion314 6y agoHave you heard about Microsoft or Intel anti trust cases? If it could be done then it must be possible to be done in the present.
- 6y ago
- qwertox 6y agoThe podcast "Acquired" recently did an episode on Epic https://www.acquired.fm/episodes/epic-games https://www.acquired.fm/episodes/epic-games (Season 7, Episode 3, September 1, 2020) It helped me a lot with positioning Epic and Sweeney, with his current actions, into my mental knowledge base, in the context of Doom and what was happening in the 90s and thereafter in the gaming industry. It also touches the current topic. It's worth listening to.
- degosuke 6y agoThank you for introducing me to this podcast. Truly a valuable one.
- CincinnatiMan 6y agoIn the global economy, monopolies become a tougher situation. In some ways I’d rather not split Apple or Google if it were to mean a non-US company takes their place, particularly a Chinese one. I understand Epic Games is partially owned by Tencent, which if I wore a tinfoil hat, may concern me in regards to their motives here.
- libertine 6y agoThe thing is: the world isn't the US and China. What if it was an European or Indian company?
- CincinnatiMan 6y agoWell if I have to pick between my country being the top player versus another country, I’d still always pick my country (US). Though an EU or Indian company would be less concerning than Chinese.
- libertine 6y agoDon't take me wrong, that's precisely the point - admitting and accepting your bias is the way to go, and that's fine. It's just sad that the EU stance seems increasingly naive, the "lead by example" stance doesn't seem to work at all, and we're steam rolled between US and China. Why isn't the EU stopping monopolies from acting in EU territory if it's in the EU best interest? Why not stop predatory takeovers? It's like we're just bystanders watching US and China... just sad. Thank you for your honesty
- justaman 6y agoThe CCP puts the US/EU is a tricky spot because of their state sponsored corporations. On one hand, they adopt capitalism; on the other, communism. If the CCP can pump a near endless flow of cash into something that will compete with a major corporation elsewhere in the world, is this a bad thing? Would Amazon be a monopoly without Alibaba? Is it reasonable to hold the position that both Alibaba and Amazon should be broken up into small companies? I think so. The CCP certainly will not agree.
- oneplane 6y agoWell, until we can play Forknife on Steam I don't see why he has any better position than the brands he mentions.
- NoblePublius 6y agoI think it’s super unfair that I am not allowed to set up a lemonade stand inside of Walmart for free. Monopolistic, even.
- mcintyre1994 6y agoWould this change at all if Walmart was the only store allowed to operate in an area corresponding to about half the US population?
- CubsFan1060 6y agoWould it change at all if that half of the population chose to live there, knowing Walmart was the only store allowed to operate? Would it change even further if people moved there BECAUSE Walmart was the only store that was allowed to operate? And since someone will ask "why would you want that?". The analogy won't completely work, but I'll go with it. When my son wants to buy a bike, they go off and bike a bike. I can be sure that they bought it at Walmart, and that Walmart has done some work to make sure the bike is safe for my son. If I don't have that, then maybe he buys a bike at "Joe's bike shop". Maybe that bike was made poorly in China. I don't know that the bike he bought was safe. I mean, https://www.cnet.com/news/just-as-critics-feared-fortnite-for-android-came-with-an-epic-security-risk/ https://www.cnet.com/news/just-as-critics-feared-fortnite-fo.... And, what do you know, Sweeney was mad at Google for finding it.
- mcintyre1994 6y agoIt's definitely a valid point. I've made the comment before that one of the problems of a more open App platform is that Facebook would replicate their malicious app advertising business on iOS and millions of people would have worse experiences with their phone because of it. It's ridiculous the stuff they're willing to push ads for on Android and Google are willing to host on their store, and it's no loss to iOS that suchs apps aren't available. But a lemonade stand in a Walmart wouldn't necessarily harm consumers, and lots of things Apple blocks or requires a cut of wouldn't either if things were changed.
- pjmlp 6y ago> "Everybody doesn't have a great incentive to challenge Apple and Google's 30% because they want to be the next bastard to charge 3̶0̶ 12%," There.
- KitDuncan 6y agoMicrosoft is apparently not one of the monopolies he wants stopped, because he is incredibly hostile towards Linux and Linux support for games. I can't stand this dude and his ramblings.
- Kuinox 6y agoHate against linux for a gamedev is understable.
- KitDuncan 6y agoI understand not actively supporting it, but why hate or actively try to work against it?
- Kuinox 6y agoPersonally, I tolerate/support linux only because it's the only OSS alternative to windows (Yeah I know about OpenBSD). I absolutely dislike some of linux philosophy like "everything is a file" which I find plain wrong. But I agree that he go too far and hurt users only due to engineering taste.
- pjmlp 6y agoHe is just trying to push Epic Store and getting part of the pie, everything else is mindless blah blah.
- LegitShady 6y agoIt's not mindless it's just he's lying about what he values
- pjmlp 6y agoYep, that is another way of putting it.
- trabant00 6y ago
- coldtea 6y ago>Since then, Sweeney, an iconoclastic executive who owns enormous farms and dabbles in fast cars And overworks his employees to exhaustion, while stomping on their unionizing...
- TheRealDunkirk 6y agoI think Epic has miscalculated the optics on this. There is no underdog in this story. It's just two enormous companies, run by very wealthy men, who put corporate profits and stock options above employee welfare, squabbling over how much of the pie they get to eat, when neither one can finish their first slice. I want them both to lose.
- ecf 6y agoEpic miscalculated because they weren’t ever expecting a real legal battle. They wanted Fortnite to get removed from the App Store in hopes that their rabid fan base of adolescent Fortnite gamers would create insane amounts of bad PR for Apple. But It never reached critical mass and Apple stood their ground.
- r00fus 6y agoInteresting take - what would both of them losing look like?
- jccc 6y agoJust to be clear, this is from the article linked on the phrase "enormous farms": "Through twitter, Sweeney said that when the land was put up for sale, many were concerned that the state wouldn't be able to buy it quick enough. "He said he will own the farm to protect the land's rare oak and pine ecosystem until a permanent conservation home is arranged, which would take two to three years. "According to the Wall Street Journal, Sweeney has spent hundreds of millions of dollars to preserve more than 45,000 acres of forest throughout North Carolina." https://wset.com/news/local/fortnite-ceo-buys-7000-acre-farm-in-halifax-county https://wset.com/news/local/fortnite-ceo-buys-7000-acre-farm... Not defending Sweeney on anything else, just clarifying this specific point about owning huge farmlands.
- Traster 6y agoI think a lot of people have short memories. When Apple launched the iPhone computer security was a disaster, the security of the AppStore was a massive benefit and the fact that we don't have massive botnets of mobile phones is in no small part down to the massive effort that was put into security. But they seem to have solved this problem so well that people have forgotten it was even a problem to begin with.
- nonane 6y agoThis line of argument is incorrect: It’s not the AppStore that makes secure apps possible: It’s the mandatory sandbox that apps run inside that actually makes the system secure. It’s fairly easy to push malicious code to the AppStore but bypassing the sandbox restrictions is what keeps bad apps at bay.
- hortense 6y agoReading the comments it seems that very few people understand this, which seems incredible to me.
- JamesSwift 6y agoYes, this is one of my biggest pet peeves and largest disconnects when reading these threads. I dont understand how people can accept apples privacy and protecting the consumer argument when that has nothing to do with the app store. That is iOS itself and its permission model. Do people really think app store approvers are doing malware analysis on apps and analyzing network traffic to approve them?
- finnthehuman 6y agoConversation on this website is full of people who can't see a mixed bag and acknowledge the bad parts are bad. People who know better tend to have the self control not to engage. I often get baited into engaging.
- nodamage 6y agoI mean, both contribute to the security of the ecosystem. There are plenty of APIs available within the sandbox that are meant to be used by developers to use for legitimate purposes. But those same APIs could be abused by malicious actors as well. That is why Android has historically had more problems with malware even though Android apps are also sandboxed.
- newbie578 6y agoDoesn't matter if you like or dislike Fortnite and the Epic Store, Tim Sweeney here is correct. Doesn't matter if people like it or not, but freedom of choice must be given to users and developers alike. Choice should not be an option, but a basic right. The people defending Apple and it's walled garden of life remind me of Socrates and his "Allegory of the cave" ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allegory_of_the_cave https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allegory_of_the_cave ). This becomes a philosophical dilemma unless you believe freedom and truth should be absolute.
- MrScruff 6y agoWhat about the freedom to choose a highly curated platform because you want that and are prepared to pay a premium for it?
- IncRnd 6y agoWhat about it? You, personally, making that choice shouldn't force everyone else to pay 30% eternally to Apple.
- Google234 6y agoYou don’t have to pay 30% to Apple. Jail break your phone is you want or just buy one of the 1000s of other phones for. Sale
- IncRnd 6y ago> You don’t have to pay 30% to Apple. Jail break your phone is you want or just buy one of the 1000s of other phones for. Sale That's a completely unreasonable sales strategy for a company to take, telling their customers to jailbreak their phones or to purchase a different phone.
- MrScruff 6y agoNobody is forced to pay 30% eternally to Apple. You make it sound as though people switching to Android isn't possible, yet I know many people who've done it.
- kristianpaul 6y agoTwo only choices of mobile OS, thats concerning for sure.
- mrbrianhinton 6y agoDoesn't Epic have a pretty big monopoly in the game industry?
- Zhyl 6y agoNot a monopoly, but they have a captive audience with one of the biggest gaming franchises of the current time. Many of their current practices with the Epic Store could be potentially seen as being anti-competitive, but they are currently being given the benefit of the doubt because they are nowhere near as big as Steam.
- ben_w 6y agoI think: 1. Multiple App Stores would be good for free speech, and for avoidance of USA cultural and legal hegemony. 2. How can this be done without loss of security for typical users? We don’t want phones to become botnets with microphones and cameras — imagine the opportunities for automatic criminal blackmail, theft planning, target acquisition, or 2FA interception. This is bad for the societies we live in even if we here on HN don’t personally install bad apps or bad stores. 3. It does feel like Sweeney is arguing in bad faith. 4. The the money is being raised as an issue implies these markets are now red-water rather than blue-water.
- willis936 6y ago>We don’t want phones to become botnets with microphones and cameras They already are. Walled gardens do nothing to prevent this.
- Google234 6y agoThey do a ton to prevent this. I’ve not heard of issues with botnets on IPhones or Macs
- willis936 6y agoThey don’t. The spying is by design. https://www.wsj.com/articles/once-pariahs-location-tracking-firms-pitch-themselves-as-covid-sleuths-11592236894 https://www.wsj.com/articles/once-pariahs-location-tracking-...
- ben_w 6y agoI absolutely agree that ad networks are spying on users, and violating their privacy to an unacceptable degree — hence my point 1, because I prefer the EU approach. However, that is not a botnet. Those systems cannot, at least not to my knowledge, turn on the microphone in the background and listen for useful blackmail-worthy phrases without alerting the user (like Siri et al are presumably capable of); They cannot subvert the WiFi chip to be a wall-penetrating radar capable of pose detection, heart rate monitoring, etc [0]; They cannot snap random photos, finding out who has anything worth stealing, nor also revealing the shape of their keys for 3D printed replication (ditto audio, at least for the keys) [1][2]; They cannot read your email and SMS messages and take over your bank accounts [3]. [0] https://spectrum.ieee.org/telecom/wireless/household-radar-can-see-through-walls-and-knows-how-youre-feeling https://spectrum.ieee.org/telecom/wireless/household-radar-c... [1] https://kottke.org/20/08/researchers-can-duplicate-keys-from-the-sounds-they-make-in-locks https://kottke.org/20/08/researchers-can-duplicate-keys-from... [2] https://www.wired.com/2015/08/this-app-lets-anyone-3-d-print-do-not-duplicate-keys/ https://www.wired.com/2015/08/this-app-lets-anyone-3-d-print... (not state of the art, but ICBA to go through all the irrelevant links) [3] https://www.zdnet.com/article/android-malware-can-steal-google-authenticator-2fa-codes/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/android-malware-can-steal-goog... (old Android example, but even Google stamped down on this kind of thing because it is a threat to the value proposition of a smartphone)
- isodev 6y agoEpic has monopoly on v-bucks, they need to be stopped.
- ianai 6y agoCrazy idea: if you want a free as in speech App Store then why isn’t the request for a free as in speech mobile OS? The claim is there isn’t a company backing it - presumably from lack of market demand for it. There have been attempts but they’ve not gained steam. Even Google is now moving away from Linux as the core of android. I generally agree that we need some countervailing pressure against the monopolies of today. But I can’t help to suspect there’s an argument to be made that turns the argument on its head: in a free market it is valid to tell someone asking for a product to produce their own desired good. If it’s a popular idea the implementation has a chance at being popular. The counter to this would probably include lack of hardware to really target. Apples not letting anyone side load an entirely different OS on its phones, for instance. Maybe that’s an angle to counter these monopolies without needing to go so far as to dissect them into smaller companies? Simply pass a law saying hardware and software should always be self contained goods - you can bundle them but have to offer them separately too. Ninja edit- I think in that universe with self contained goods that hardware companies would have to make source code for drivers OSS (why should they care where it’s ran?) or enough information to make writing drivers possible.
- cheph 6y ago> Even Google is now moving away from Linux as the core of android. Could not find much about this, could you link to something that provides more details on it?
- onion2k 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Fuchsia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Fuchsia
- pjmlp 6y agoBesides Fuchsia, that no one knows what it might be all about. Project Treble kind of isolates Linux kernel from modern Android drivers, where standard Linux drivers are considered legacy, while Treble drivers follow a mikrokernel like approach using Android IPC to talk to the kernel. https://source.android.com/devices/architecture/hal-types https://source.android.com/devices/architecture/hal-types Also note that Linux specific calls aren't part of the official APIs exposed to userspace, https://source.android.com/compatibility/11/android-11-cdd#3_3_native_api_compatibility https://source.android.com/compatibility/11/android-11-cdd#3...
- drummer 6y agoApple has every right to decide about their platform. What everyone else needs to do, including Sweeney, is stop developing for that platform and choose open/free platforms. Please go have a chat with rms.
- can16358p 6y agoExactly my thoughts. It's their platform, their well-written rules, and Epic always knew it from the beginning. They intentionally made a move against a legal agreement, didn't take a step back despite the warnings from Apple/Google, and now paying a price. Don't want to be devil's advocate here but Apple/Google did the right thing.
- 52-6F-62 6y agoI’ve been mildly vocal in my support for not altering how iOS works. I bought into it explicitly because of how it works. Your comment is my preferred outcome as well. It would at least be a sign of good faith that they’re in it for the values they’re professing rather than only diverting money into their pockets.
- TekMol 6y agoApples not letting anyone side load an entirely different OS on its phones I tend to think that this practice has only downsides for society.
- ekianjo 6y agoSo the NPR is now a mouthpiece of Epic, without any critical comment to any of their ridiculous claims?
- tomohawk 6y agoIBM was investigated for antitrust violations. After many years, they entered into a consent decree which required them to document all of their APIs. And not just that - they were not allowed to have any hidden interfaces that might place IBM application developers at an advantage over non-IBM application developers. As long as you coded to the published API, you were good to go.
- holstvoogd 6y agoMeanwhile you get a fortnite installer on every xperia that you cannot and may not remove... He is probably right, not sure, but he only got on this high horse after Apple and Google told him to get f*cked when he wanted a special deal. So maybe he should sit this one out and let the relevant regulators handle it? He is just in it to cry in the media if you ask me
- fuu_dev 6y agoA lot of the time i see people/youtubers mention that they like the benefits of the App store that would be gone if anything changes. But why is this invalidated by allowing allowing the user to install software from other sources, allow a the user to install a browser that is not a skin on top of safari, allow non apple game streaming services on the platform, allow the use of images/text that mentions or shows competing software company logos/names, allow apps to show price differences in payment processing or allow established payment methods like PayPal to be used on the platform. If would still allow the same user to only use apple pay or the apple version of their loved service of choice but also gives users that don't alternatives.
- circa 6y agoI understand these companies are all different and obviously different in size. But I still get a good feeling of the pot calling the kettle black here.
- tempodox 6y agoSince this war is about making money from controlling access to the users, I don't feel like siding with either Apple or Epic on this. Letting the sheep decide by which wolf they will be eaten isn't that great of a choice. From my own personal perspective, I would like to be able to permanently install an app that I developed myself, on my own Mac, on the iOS devices that I own without having to go through the app store or Apple's review process. But I'm not holding my breath that the outcome of this fight will deliver even that.
- parasubvert 6y agoYou can already install your own software on your own iOS device without review. You can even install it on 3rd party devices (up to 100) without review!
- tempodox 6y agoNot permanently. You have to re-install every week.
- xenophonf 6y ago"These monopolies need to be stopped," says man who wants to create his own monopoly.
- elondaits 6y agoAs a user of npm I'd really like to see some effort to create a framework for trust in open(ish) repositories. Something that includes signing, reputation (beyond "popularity"), trust network (people that vouch for your packages), automated verification to check for obfuscation, etc. I mention npm because it's always in the news, and because it's a much smaller and simpler problem that a whole App Store. If we could fix something like npm the solution could perhaps be generalized or built on to open trustworthy repos for all kinds of content. At that point we would have a very strong working argument against privately-run monopolistic app stores. Until then I prefer Apple as a benevolent dictator to mad-max style libertarianism. I need to use Adobe software for professional reasons, but I'd rather not have to deal with an Adobe app store... or an EA app store... or an Ubisoft app store... or apps stores from a variety of shitty companies with bad practices.
- gimmeThaBeet 6y agoI don't think attacks on Epic's sort of 'suitability' in fighting this dragon are really warranted. Like godzilla vs. king kong, I think the only entities with the financial strength and influence to tangle with apple/google is going to be a bit of a monster in their own right. My feelings about this do tend to vacillate. My opinion right now is sort of circumstantial, in that I don't think it's even tongue in cheek to call 30% the apple/google tax. apple defends itself with the work it puts into maintaining app store quality. But imo enforced app quality and the store experience is something you sell to customers, not developers. So apple talks about how there's so many free apps that never give apple a nickel. I can understand differentiated pricing for different customers, but framing app developers as app store customers is where I feel apple and google run afoul. So it's like, why is it acceptable that mega-apps like fortnite are basically levied to support the app store, that apple turns around and presents to the customer and says "look how nice we made this"? I don't know, it feels like the anti "developers, developers, developers". They don't have to make any concession to promote developers to use their platform, because there practically isn't much of a choice, between the two they're nearly the only game in town.
- parasubvert 6y agoIt is an incredible lack of imagination that people actually think this is the end of history with regards to mobile device operating systems, and we should just declare Android and iOS And their ecosystems public utilities that should be regulated by the government. Because that really is the only recourse here to give people what they want. Markets aren’t created by god, they’re created by customers. If you want to force the creation of an App Store market, one that customers aren’t actually asking for, it will need to be government-mandated. Maybe there will be a weak sauce version of this where the review process isn’t regulated but the commission rates are regulated. We aren’t going back to the PC model where a thousand app stores bloom. No government will force that - there’s too much risk for malware and spyware as it is. At best it will be government-sanctioned stores with a government-sanctioned review process. Windows once had 95% market share (still does!) and this hasn’t happened, even though Microsoft still gets a cut of almost every PC sale. Be careful what you wish for. Folks here really haven’t studied history of antitrust beyond scanning Wikipedia. There is a ton potential for new devices and platforms in VR, AR, and other experiences. The current state of affairs is not permanent. Most historical antitrust actions had very limited positive effects on consumers. The Standard Oil breakup, for example, is often cited. But it’s breakup didn’t really fix anything. Its children became bigger than the parent within a few years! Same with the AT&T breakup. It led to oligopoly. The only real telecom competition has been foreign entrants like T-Mobile. Microsoft’s consent decree had almost no impact on its monopoly status and revenue steam. What mattered was the market changing, to the point we didn’t care about the Windows monopoly anymore. There were other platforms that mattered in iOS, Android. Valve has a near monopoly for PC game app stores and is poised to compete with Facebook and Apple for the next generation of VR/AR. Epic wants in on that. And likely there will be others.
- Slartie 6y ago> No government will force that - there’s too much risk for malware and spyware as it is. Since when does any government anywhere on this planet care about "risk for malware and spyware" on operating systems? If they did, they'd turn up the heat on software developers in terms of responsibility for blatant security violations and security-related software bugs. The fact that no government does any of that tells us that they don't care about secure software. Some governments - I'm not calling names now - may even have active interest in insecure software due to their law enforcement and intelligence arms depending on security flaws for their work.
- compsciphd 6y agoSo I'm of two minds here. On one mind the app stores do provide a mechanism for security, that is of great value to end users. On the other hand, the amount they collect is way too large. I'm wondering if there is a middle path. If one wants to use the app store to make your apps discoverable, you pay the higher fee, but if you just use the app store for distribution (and hence don't disrupt the end user security model) you can pay a smaller fee. so how would users install apps without being able to discover it on the store? via the desktop (and not mobile, if we want to be strict) web. i.e. epic can give users a url that they can use to connect to google' web market (which already allow you to install apps to your device, and apple can do the same). This would be the only way to install these apps (though updates would proceed as normal). if one searches for the app in the marketplace, it wont come up. And as I said, perhaps even on mobile the direct link to app wont work (though of multiple minds on this as well). For app developers that need the app store to drive interest and demand, the 30% cut google/apple take is then reasonable. For app developers that can drive their own demand, they would pay a much smaller cut (perhaps 5-10%, with a decent chunk of that being the normal credit card processing fees that they would have anyways). just a thought
- gok 6y ago> Sweeney founded Epic Games in his parents' basement in the suburbs of Washington, D.C., in the early 1990s and grew the business into a $17 billion gaming empire. Well that's one way to look at it. What made him really rich was selling out to Tencent, who just so happens to also have a mobile app store that they would love to get onto your phone.
- helsinkiandrew 6y agoIf Epic allowed users to create their own outfits and weapons and sell them in fortnite using the users choice of credit card processing service they'd have a lot more legs to stand on.
- koonsolo 6y agoHere's my "old-timer" take on the 30%: I used to develop games and apps for MS PocketPC. Our users could install apps straight from their PC to the PocketPC. But guess how apps were sold: through portals. These portals also took around 30% (Handango and PocketGear were the biggest ones back then). We were also selling straight from our website, where we could have had 0% cost. But guess what: We wanted to reach top 10 on Handango, and the best way to do that was send our customers through Handango. Once in the top 10 (front page), it would multiply our sales. So even on our own site we choose to 'lose' 30%. Just take a look at Steam: it's PC games! You can sell all those things straight to the consumer. But developers still choose to give 30% (or how much is it now?) for the exposure. Conclusion: there will always be some party taking around 30%. Why? Because it's well worth the 30%
- zepto 6y agoTotally - the argument isn’t anything to do with developer’s not paying the 30% - it’s that a whole load of parties want to run their own stores without having to maintain the platform.
- huhtenberg 6y agoWhat "platform" is it exactly they don't want to maintain?
- uncoder0 6y agoiOS and Android + Google Play Services is probably what they are referring to.
- zepto 6y agoIf epic doesn’t need a platform, there are OEM’s who will make them a bare metal smartphone. Everything on top of that is the platform on top of which they are building their system. Anyone who thinks the App Store is just stripe plus a file server simply doesn’t understand what is involved.
- gruez 6y ago
- _aleph2c_ 6y agoIf he loses this fight, he should bankroll a Linux Phone and an iOS/android-app-to-Linux phone cross compiler.
- VikingCoder 6y agoMr. Sweeney is welcome to make his own mobile operating system and charge whatever rate he wants. He's personally worth $5.3 billion. Surely that's enough to take Android Open Source Project and make his own version. It's easy to burn down a store that you think charges too much. It's harder to make a new store that people will like. Maybe take the high road, Mr. Sweeney.
- rphillips 6y ago+1, Sweeney took the low road by violating his contract with Apple, removing Apple IAP from the existing Fortnight on people's iOS devices, and generally making a point by doing it the wrong way. Two wrongs do not make a right.
- tln 6y agoEpic didn't remove IAP... they advertised a lower price elsewhere, which is against guidelines (which is not a contract), and did so via an unreviewed update. Note that updates via webview or JS code are explicitly allowed by contracts, and what Fortnite did is very likely to have used that mechanism.
- rphillips 6y agoCheck out the latest filing by Apple. Epic removed the IAP from Apple and only is allowing the Epic store purchases.
- tln 6y agoThat's interesting. I wonder if they changed it. I was going off screenshots like this: https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EfTZ1pwWkAI3aUH.jpg:large https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EfTZ1pwWkAI3aUH.jpg:large Either way violates guidelines
- Lev1a 6y agoAlthough this time his own OS should have basic features and lessons learned by prior entrants in that sector. Like, if you start an online store have such basic stuff as a shopping cart. Obvious stuff like that.