9 ms·
> an equity package which is simple and standardized enough to be comprehensible by ordinary humans > deceptive equity packages What do you mean by "deceptive
by kelnos 6y ago
> an equity package which is simple and standardized enough to be comprehensible by ordinary humans
> deceptive equity packages
What do you mean by "deceptive"? The standard for pre-IPO seems to me to be N number of options, at a particular strike price, 10-year expiration (or 90 days if you leave the company). That doesn't seem all that complicated to me, or deceptive.
What can get deceptive is if the company is trying to lowball you on salary and tell you that your equity will become worth millions some day as if it was a sure thing, which is of course a scummy practice. And the whole expiration after 90 days thing is garbage. But deceptive? Complicated? I don't think it is.
I really don't see what's not simple or standardized about what I described above. Granted, the last time I joined a startup (which is not a startup anymore) was 9 years ago, but I haven't read anything to suggest that this has changed drastically.
- mehrdadn 6y agoAny thoughts on the AMT trap, and the potential inability to exercise (or go bankrupt with AMT) when you leave? It's not exactly written in red warning letters on offer packages, right?
- eanzenberg 6y agoIf you’re hitting ATM you’re doing extremely well for yourself and are privileged.
- mehrdadn 6y agoYou seem to be unfamiliar with the AMT trap? I would recommend Googling it. It impacts people who are not well-off prior to exercising their options by triggering AMT upon exercise.
- eanzenberg 6y agoRight, but why exercise the option without next selling it? If you’re quitting, that’s a risk. And AMT is applied on the gains. So your strike is $1, valuation currently at $100 and you pay tax on the $99 gain. Unless it’s Theranos that valuation wont go back to $1, so yes, you’re privileged.
- mehrdadn 6y agoYou need to read up on the issue. Links to get you started: - https://www.holloway.com/g/equity-compensation/sections/the-amt-trap https://www.holloway.com/g/equity-compensation/sections/the-... - https://thestartuplawblog.com/immediately-exercisable-isos-the-problems/ https://thestartuplawblog.com/immediately-exercisable-isos-t...
- eanzenberg 6y agoIt’s a great problem to have. I’d love to have that problem. Give me that problem. You choose how much to purchase and wait for the wealth to materialize. I’m sure most people would love to have this kind of problem. Gimme. Gimme.
- mehrdadn 6y agoOK. You posted this unsubstantive comment 3 times...
- rpedela 6y agoIn private companies, you often are unable to sell your shares because it requires board approval. The AMT trap, in oversimplified terms, is being wealthy enough on paper, due to shares, to trigger AMT but unable to sell shares to cover the taxes.
- eanzenberg 6y agoIt’s a great problem to have. I’d love to have that problem. Give me that problem. You choose how much to purchase and wait for the wealth to materialize. I’m sure most people would love to have this kind of problem. Gimme. Gimme.
- rpedela 6y agoGrass is always greener... It can be a tough decision, but I have been through it enough times that I don't really care what the options package is. I just want one if everyone else gets one, but otherwise I look at salary and benefits. Because most likely the shares will become worthless, and if not, I most likely won't be around to see the liquidation event. I never exercise unless I know for a fact a liquidation event is coming.
- imtringued 6y agoThis entire subthread is about "people who are doing well" getting shafted.
- s17n 6y agoSolution is to get rid of the 90 day limit for ex-employees, which is also just the right thing to do in general. Doesn't totally solve AMT, as there are other reasons to want to exercise other than "because your options are about to expire", but it does fix the worst common issue.
- x87678r 6y agoAMT has changed a lot since Trump adjusted the tax rules. I suspect it isn't relevant any more. > The number of households owing AMT rose from 200,000 in 1982 to 5.2 million in 2017, but was reduced back to 200,000 in 2018 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alternative_minimum_tax https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alternative_minimum_tax
- dasil003 6y agoLess relevant on the margins, but for the people who get hosed the worst (ie. owe the IRS millions when you never seen cash anywhere near that) the trap is very much still there. If you have ISOs with a low strike price with a private company that is approaching IPO—especially considering the insanity in the stock market right now—you better take a long hard look at the numbers before exercising (or leaving your company and being forced to exercise)
- joshuamorton 6y ago90 days if you leave is deceptive and will lock you to the company unless you're independently wealthy. A less deceptive thing is a 7-10 year window if you leave, because that isn't "you forfeit your equity when you leave if you aren't already wealthy." Equity pricing is also nonsense for many private companies. I was offered 1 million dollars in equity in a company 4 years ago assuming a multi-billion dollar valuation. It's unclear if the company has even achieved that valuation now, four years on. And they're still private.
- rpedela 6y ago90 days for ISOs is US law. They can be converted to NSOs to get a longer exercise term, but there are different tax implications too. Some companies are offering the conversion now.
- est31 6y agoA link going into further details: https://carta.com/blog/pte-90-day-window/ https://carta.com/blog/pte-90-day-window/
- spearo77 6y agoI think dilution is something that makes the package deceptively complex. Subsequent rounds of funding diminish a previously healthy looking equity package. How should you factor that into your expectations for the future of your equity package? I think that's complicated. Does anyone ask for or receive a re-calculated salary based on the change in equity that results from dilution?
- numlocked 6y agoAssuming an up round, dilution causes you to own less of a company on a percentage basis, but the actual dollar values of your shares will be worth more. If things are going well (which is admittedly rare, and the lightning you’re trying to bottle) dilution just makes your piece of the pie grow somewhat sub-linearly to the overall equity value creation, but certainly isn’t making it negative. I find it much easier to reason about equity comp on a per share basis rather than a percentage ownership basis (and frankly don’t understand the constant advice to try and think about it on a percentage basis - though will always happily share that with job candidates). Additional equity grants are what can make up for dilution, not additional cash comp. I also believe that cash and equity are fundamentally different types of compensation, given for different reasons, and are not particularly fungible. I always try to make equity as comprehensible as possible, but the reality is that it IS complicated - and worth spending time to actually understand because, while there are ways to get misled, it’s also the path to wealth creation.
- nandhinianand 6y ago> reason about equity comp on a per share basis The one reason I find this highly skeptical, is that this is in some sense a made-up figure. In Options, It's an estimate of a per share once the company goes public. In other cases, it's something the founders have estimated based on market potential and other things.
- michaelt 6y ago> Assuming an up round, dilution causes you to own less of a company on a percentage basis, but the actual dollar values of your shares will be worth more. If you're at a $10M company and you're thinking "I will own 0.1%, so in a few years I can look forward to a payday of $10,000" then you're right: getting diluted 10x to own 0.01% of a $100M company is the same value. But if your thinking is "I will own 0.1%, and if I owned that much of WhatsApp when it sold to Facebook I'd have made $16M" then a 10x dilution would reduce that to $1.6M Now, you might argue the second line of thinking is wrong and a fantasy valuation, but we all know no-one's getting hired away from FAANG by the promise of an uncertain, one-off $10k in a few years.
- rectang 6y ago> What do you mean by "deceptive"? A package which appears to the novice to be worth N dollars, but where statistically speaking many employees end up in the hole because they mishandle the tax implications, or where statistically speaking many employees end up in difficulty attempting to sell their shares because they miss some deadline or fail to meet some other condition, etc. There is a need for simplification and standardization because the average employee offered options today does not have the qualifications to assess the value of an equity package — it's not like direct monetary compensation which is easy to understand. Or at least there's such a need for reform from the perspective of the employee. From the perspective of an employer, if statistically speaking many employees mishandle their complex options packages, then the company ends up money ahead, having driven down labor costs by offloading hidden risk onto their employees.
- kevinburke 6y agoYeah, agreed, I don't really think the core premise is that deceptive. I will say though one trick I've seen (I should write about this) is multiplying your common stock through by the latest price of the preferred stock and presenting this as the "current value" of your equity offer. Your common stock is not worth as much as the preferred stock.
- m0zg 6y agoIt's usually deceptive all the way throughout: 1. Not disclosing the valuation details 2. Not disclosing who owns what and with what liquidation preference (this alone means you don't know what you're getting even in the unlikely event the startup succeeds) 3. Creating unrealistic expectations about the value of your "equity" package ("0.5% is a lot of money, man, we'll be a unicorn"). Quoted because if it's not equity if you can't sell it or can't get a dividend from it. 4. Requiring that you sell your _exercised_ shares back to the company at the price of board's choosing if you left voluntarily or otherwise. This is called the "clawback" clause. 5. Requiring that you forfeit your _vested_ but unexercised shares if you were terminated "for a cause", in addition to #4. A "cause" can easily be manufactured shortly before acquisition. There are precedents. 6. Abusive terms in case of acquisition 7. No acceleration in case of acquisition 8. Super short exercise window if you leave on your own volition. With all of the above combined, you're at the complete mercy of the company in whether you get anything at all even if you work there for years. Do I need to continue? I had all of these at one point or another and I only evaluated offers from 2 startups so far. My lawyer extensively redlined both of them. In one case the board agreed to the revised offer. In another it did not, so I did not join. Such redlining only works if you're a very early employee and you're very senior. But regardless, I'd argue that if you're taking a pay cut, you should at least know what you're getting yourself into, and $500-700 for counsel is not too bad. If you don't like the underwater rocks your lawyer identified, demand more cash or walk away.
- laumeeyen 6y agohow do you find a lawyer that does this sort of thing? how specific of a speciality should I be looking for if interested in finding one?
- munchbunny 6y agoWhat can get deceptive is if the company is trying to lowball you on salary and tell you that your equity will become worth millions some day as if it was a sure thing, which is of course a scummy practice. And the whole expiration after 90 days thing is garbage. But deceptive? Complicated? I don't think it is. For people fresh out of school or people who have spent many years in public companies and haven't had to think about how much the options are actually worth, there's likely to be a disconnect between what is written on paper and what is perceived. The equity clauses in the typical employment contract, for example, won't tell you about AMT taxes, liquidation preferences, how hard it actually is to decide to exercise 90 days after you leave (you'll mostly likely leave before the cash-out), or how unlikely that equity is to be worth much. Those things aren't said or written but are important to understand. The recruiter won't tell you that either because they want you to join. That last item is entirely about your ability to accurately assess the value of the company, which is usually a crapshoot even when you have complete information, which you don't. Plenty of people I know/knew, including a younger version of myself, think about it subjectively and don't have a cynical enough view on the chances of cashing out. It might not be deceptive, but it certainly is complex, and you're probably not being told the most important parts of the deal. The saying "caveat emptor" comes to mind, which is definitely about surprises showing up after you commit.
- lumost 6y agoHow often is the strike price the fair market value of the employee equity pool? Most VCs carry preference stacks to either 1x or 2x of the current valuation, Leaving the options structurally underwater unless the company increases in value by 3x. To take home the strike price equivalent per option could require up to a 6x increase in valuation. This is a non-obvious way that employees are often screwed on options.
- dbt00 6y agoThe “at a valuation of” numbers you see thrown around in funding rounds are preferred shares and have a higher cost than employee equity. As a result, companies can use that risk factor to push down on employee strike price, aka 409(a) valuation of common shares, to keep buy in costs low until a liquidity event that equalizes risk preferences (or, if it’s a crappy exit, doesn’t). The company and employees have a common interest in keeping that price low.
- lumost 6y agoUnfortunately the only options I've seen in 2 private companies were post-preference with a strike price tied to the valuation of the common equity. At the end of the day the company is acquired for a fixed price which goes to the preferenced shares first, leaving little on the table. Straight IPOs have become rare, and the few times I've been a part of one my grants per year increased following IPO as the value was clear. It's possible there was a mechanic at work that would have made the equity worth more at the ~6x valuation increase, however these companies were already worth ~200 million-1 billion. If the company wanted to incentivize extreme upside they should have increased the strike price, and increased the number of options granted. Spotify provides this option to employees where you can choose cash, RSUs, options, or "high-risk" options. You can get 8x options relative to RSUs with a strike price that's double the current stock price. If the company 4x'd in value over 4 years you'd make 4x on these compared to RSU's enabling a public company to offer "lottery" ticket equity packages. Ultimately if a startup is trying to offer a lottery ticket to employees to lure them from top-tier companies, then they'll need to make real lottery tickets with real payouts at the end. That means that a startup with an expected 100 million dollar exit in 5 years will need to grant 2% of the company at exit to a top-tier engineer in the average case ( with appropriate vesting ).
- switch11 6y agoYour answer illustrates what he's talking about You are not even realizing what he's actually saying HE's not talking about lowballing on salary He is talking about what percentage of the company you are going to get, how soon you will get it, and other details * Most people won't get this. I will still try A) What percentage of the company are you getting? B) What dilution is going to happen? C) When can you sell your stake in the company? D) How soon and in what manner does it vest * People fixate on things like 1,000 options without considering what it really means Please consider what you wrote: The standard for pre-IPO seems to me to be N number of options, at a particular strike price, 10-year expiration (or 90 days if you leave the company). That doesn't seem all that complicated to me, or deceptive. NOWHERE in that is What value do I bring the company IN RETURN what percentage of the company am I getting AT WHAT RATE will I be given that share of the company
- alonmower 6y agoYou should absolutely ask about A) and be very suspicious if they refuse to tell you. No one can answer B) with any real confidence because they don’t have a crystal ball. C) is almost always going to be at IPO or when the company sells, though maybe if you’re extremely important they’ll let you negotiate to sell some at a later round, though given this complicates things in most cases they’ll likely not want to bother with it unless you have a ton of leverage. D) is almost always going to be one year cliff, then rest monthly over four years. That should also be extremely easy information to get.
- est31 6y agoRegarding C, usually you need to wait a bit post IPO until the investors had opportunity to sell their stock. Only THEN it's your turn. It's called lock-up period and lasts usually 180 days (half a year). Just keep that in mind. Also during sale, investors might choose to execute their liquidation preferences, which means that your shares might become worthless. Employees who paid hundreds of thousands of USD annually in opportunity cost have no such clauses to get their money back.
- 6y ago