16 ms·
Why ‘Civilization’ is a political masterpiece
- samvher 6y agoI have spent countless hours on this game (especially Civ 5) - it just felt so deep. It actually triggered quite some interests down the road around archeology, history, military strategy. Reading about some historic character I really often thought "ha - I know this person from Civilization" and the same game has you thinking about things like geographic choke points for someone else's navy and things like that. I'm really hoping that at some point a version of Civilization will come out with a more realistic AI (I haven't really looked into this but assume that a lot more is possible now than 10 years ago given all recent advancements). To me that felt like the main thing that caused me to lose interest at some point, interaction with AI players was too scripted and a harder difficulty level just meant more units and faster progression for AI players. I never got into multiplayer, I imagine it would be way too slow to keep my attention.
- Tenoke 6y agoThere are mods for Civ 6 and probably 5 that change the AI completely. Worth trying out.
- extremeMath 6y agoCiv5 didn't allow unit stacking which left artillery vulnerable. I couldn't get into it. Civ 4 4ever
- msh 6y agoI disliked civ6 due to the warmonger penalty. It seems like all the other civs will dislike you for hundreds of years for waging even a defensive war agressively.
- colanderman 6y agoThat is fixed with the Gathering Storm expansion. Warmonger Penalties are replaced with Grievances, which each civ tracks individually against each other civ. So long as you have more Grievances against a given civ than they do against you, other civs do not care what you do. It makes fighting defensive/retributive wars much easier. I think it works pretty well overall.
- 24gttghh 6y agoThat's why you just make sure you get 3-5 artillery units able to move into position and attack a city on the same turn, and have shielding melee units. Don't give the NPC civ's time to fight back.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 6y agoI never got that into Civ, so maybe it is mostly my ignorance of 'proper' play speaking, but I actually rather liked the change to non-stacking units as it seemed to make the combat more tactical and less an exercise in simply who had the bigger numbers.
- reincarnate0x14 6y agoThe two big problems with it were that a) the computer player coding was just shockingly bad at dealing with it, particularly around any sort of geographic chokepoints, and b) it was incredibly tedious to deal with moving more than a handful of units. Many other games like Total War series or Age of Wonders dealt with the overall question by having split strategic and tactical game modes, and they're hardly alone in that. Civ5 and 6 tried to keep the bastard child of those two game concepts in the same strategic-map and it just doesn't work that well.
- recursivecaveat 6y agoThere are a lot of subtle consequences of 1UPT as well. You can't let the player produce too many units, or the whole map will lock up. You can't make units too expensive though, or they'll just be hitting next-turn 40 times between each production in the ancient era. So tiny cities have to punch above their weight, and big ones below. Once you do that though you have to heavily penalize expansion. What they really needed was to increase the tile-density of the map several times, give room to maneuver. That would seriously change the city management gameplay though, potentially make it too tedious.
- reincarnate0x14 6y agoI can see a split of using large hexes for cities and strategic deployment but having 7 child hexes inside each strategic one for precise unit movement working out. Effectively limiting stacks to 7 units for combat, and also potentially letting a few groups of units move around each other with multiple turns of micromanagement. The corp/army mechanic could also be tied into that.
- Delk 6y agoYou can still protect your artillery, although it's more complicated. You may need to position melee units tactically so that they and their zones of control [0] prevent enemy units from easily (and quickly, during a single turn) reaching your artillery units. Using terrain tactically not just to get a defensive edge in combat strength but also to make your ranged units less easily reachable to enemy melee units may also become even more important. What I find most difficult about protecting your artillery in Civ 5 is attempting to siege cities with units that have a range of 2, because they'll be vulnerable to bombardment from the city no matter what. But yeah, the artillery is more vulnerable in Civ 5. You can counteract some of that. [0] https://civilization.fandom.com/wiki/Zone_of_control_(Civ5) https://civilization.fandom.com/wiki/Zone_of_control_(Civ5)
- yreg 6y agoThere is a subreddit for reporting on world politics in the format of Civ messages. https://www.reddit.com/r/CivPolitics/ https://www.reddit.com/r/CivPolitics/
- chrisco255 6y agoI haven't played this, but there is an open source Civilization clone that would probably be ideal for AI hacking: http://freeciv.org/ http://freeciv.org/
- raxxorrax 6y agoMultiplayer has advantages and disadvantages. As long as there is no war or certain unit movement, players can play simultaneously, but a single game still takes a lot of time. Played it mostly with 2 friends with beer at rainy weekends and it can easily take 5 sessions à 4 hours. It still was acceptable. On some occasions we had more players and the round timer becomes mandatory and it changes the play style a lot. The general performance of CIV is also ridiculously bad for what is basically a board game, especially in multiplayer, and at some point you just now what the AI will do. I still like the AI since they did a good job at giving the different leaders a personality within the rules of the game. But if you start for the 50th time next to Montezuma you know it might be a good idea to build some military. He will just never accept you.
- mywittyname 6y agoThey do have a flag for random leader personalities. It doesn't help too much since you pretty quickly figure out which archetype they fit into.
- reincarnate0x14 6y agoCiv4 was significantly better than 5 or 6 in that regard in that the computer players weren't so game-ified into sociopathic lunatics that would go from long term allies or trade partners to instant chain-denouncing mortal enemies based on seemingly minor changes in the player's expansion or military strength. Additionally the ability to stack units, while having problems of it own, made it a lot easier for the computer players to pose any serious tactical threat (without a gigantic technological advantage, a careful artillery and melee formation with a few healing units thrown in can destroy any computer-managed army of even ridiculous size; and the various "cheat" modifiers can magnify that to the point that independent city-states have been observed kicking the tar out of computer-player empires in both civ5 and 6 due to the regenerating free era-appropriate units that the tactical code simply can't out-maneuver) Multiplayer in 4 tended to be all early rushes and road-ing/choke-ing (get some early unique units or archers to sit on key resources, stealing workers to build roads in between so your units could mass up to take cities faster). Back in the day I had a friend to play intentionally long games over weekends cooped up in the winter, those were immensely fun with a gentleperson's agreement to avoid direct conflict and try to win via tech/culture with maneuvering by proxy. The Civ4 AI personalities were much better suited to this as well. Never tried MP in 6 but did some co-op in 5 that was reasonably fun, you really had to dedicate multiple evenings to it though so getting more than 3 people was impossible unless you were all sharing a dorm or something. Overall the most fun multiplayer experience in a Civ-like game I've found was in Age of Wonders 3 as the games had a flatter tech ramp, tactical combat modes that took advantage of the hex map like war-games, and a RPG-light cast of semi-random hero generals to level up and give cute magic items to. Plus it had a variety of MP game modes for both competitive and co-op play.
- codeisawesome 6y ago> sociopathic lunatics that would go from long term allies or trade partners to instant chain-denouncing mortal enemies based on seemingly minor changes in the player's expansion or military strength This... doesn't seem quite that unrealistic compared to how states act in the real world!
- reincarnate0x14 6y ago
- danielbarla 6y agoAlong similar lines are some of the Paradox Interactive games, specifically Europa Universalis and Hearts of Iron. The premise is that they start with a fairly accurate representation of the world at various critical moments, and from there, some kind of alternative history takes place. The simulation itself is quite interesting (with things like justifications for wars being a major focus), and the game is sprinkled with fascinating real historical events. Many of these play out as they did in real life, but many also have alternatives. One is often led to a Wikipedia rabbit-hole following them.
- Buttons840 6y agoA turn based game like Civ is the next milestone in AI I'm looking forward too. Researchers have focused on more popular games like DotA or StarCraft, but I would be more impressed with an AI that could beat the best human at pure decision making in a turn based game like Civ.
- jkinudsjknds 6y agoIt's true there's a lot of ambiguity on whether the AI succeeds at "strategy" in Starcraft. But Civ would probably be an easy game for an AI to succeed at. Almost every iteration of Civ has had a fairly clear dominant strategy for the first large chunk of the game, and often the game ends before reaching the latter half of the game. How much adaptive strategizing really exists in the game? Notably, playing with a very competent AI that was trying to win the game probably wouldn't be fun for most players. Players don't like to imagine that their opponents are trying to win the game of Civ, they tend to imagine their opponents are leaders building a civilization for its own sake. When we criticize the AI in Civ, it's mostly due to dumb diplomacy (which designed to be fun, not cunning) and dumb military tactics (for which an exceptionally low bar is set). Both of these are fairly easy to remedy.
- spiritplumber 6y agoYou may enjoy a story in which such an AI (played by 4chan randos, at that) is pitted against the God of the Left Behind series. https://emlia.org/pmwiki/pub/web/LeftBeyond.TalesFromTheBeyond.html https://emlia.org/pmwiki/pub/web/LeftBeyond.TalesFromTheBeyo...
- AQXt 6y agoTalking about AI, I wonder if Civilization is more complex than Go, and, in that case, if AlphaGo Zero could beat human players in Civ.
- Semaphor 6y agofor anyone who likes Civ V but dislikes the balance or the bad AI (and, sorry, is on windows [0]): the mod Vox Populi [1] (formerly community balance patch, formerly communitas) is still in active development and raises the game to a new level. [0] the mod grew too large for pure lua scripting long ago and the SDK was only released for windows. At least that is my understanding. [1] current stable, there have been many beta releases since then: https://forums.civfanatics.com/threads/community-patch-how-to-install.528034/ https://forums.civfanatics.com/threads/community-patch-how-t...
- kazagistar 6y agoFor me it works the other way around: learning history tends to get me in the mood to play a civ game (rather then a better designed and more interesting game in the genre like Endless Legend or Stellaris). Basically, the aesthic of historicity is what brings me to that game specifically, even if it is of... limited depth.
- extremeMath 6y agoMy biggest shock with Civ was funding out that I was a military dictator at heart. I started with hope of a cultural victory. I gave away technology and trade at a disadvantage to keep aggressive allies on my side. Then genghis khan attacks me unprovoked despite previously good relations. He sacked a city and I decided he needed to be completely removed from the game for peace. So after stabilizing, I built up a huge military and defeated him. But now I had a huge military draining my resources. And alexander was pretty aggressive. Before you knew it, my wife was begging me not to attack the last survivor, Gandhi. Which I defeated and achieved world domination. I was literally horrified at myself.
- ajuc 6y agoThe game is set up like that. Military victory has the most mechanics and is the most fun. Other victories are basically watching numbers grow with little interaction with the enemy. There's few games where non-combat mechanics are as fun as combat mechanics. If you like strategies I recommend Crusader King series - it's about dynastic politics and plots instead of combat (combat still exists but it's not the main focus). It tends to generate very dark Game Of Thrones-like scenarios by the basic mechanics not by hardcoded plot.
- pintxo 6y agoCIV VI (and its add-ons) has slightly improved here with religious units that can actively distribute your religion and also fight other religious units. Also the "band" gaining cultural points for your civ are somewhat going into this direction. But I agree, combat still has the most fun game mechanics.
- arkitaip 6y agoGames inherent the biases of their creators, so it's more a reflection of them than you.
- asgard1024 6y agoIf anything, I think Civ tried to subvert the bias of war games by allowing other types of victories than just a military one.
- devit 6y agoWhile Civilization games are fun for new players, ultimately they are quite flawed: - In Civ 1-3 infinite city sprawl is optimal, which is tedious and unfun - In Civ 5-6 one-unit-per-tile creates gimmicky non-strategical combat, forces you to move units individually and is very hard for the AI to use - All the original versions have horrible AI (so bad that you could reasonably request a refund), although the Better AI mods for Civ4 and Civ5 have somewhat passable AI - While the early game is really fun since you have few very impactful decisions, all versions get very tedious by the mid/end-game where you need to make a ton of minor decisions for every city and unit in the empire The last problem is especially hard to fix, and I don't think any similar game has solved it.
- 3131s 6y agoI always liked Alpha Centauri the most out of all these games. I don't think it has any of these problems except for maybe the last (you can automate most repetitive actions, but the control is somewhat too coarse).
- nicolapede 6y agoAlpha Centauri is one of my all time favourite game. Out of curiosity, does anyone know if it is possible to replicate the Human Hive strategy from Alpha Centauri in other Civ games?
- colanderman 6y agoI've always thought the easy fix to the last problem would be to allow cities to be set to "auto" mode, and let the AI decide what to make. You can already get this effect by just always choosing what the advisor suggests. The AI is certainly not very smart, but sometimes I have cities I really don't care about the minutae of: they are already fulfilling their strategic role and can suffer being mismanaged by the AI for a dozen turns.
- jandrese 6y agoThe Advisor is kind of lousy at deciding what to build though. This is also why I don't let workers automate, because they'll chop down my jungles before I have a chance to research Universities.
- richardanaya 6y ago𝘭𝘢𝘶𝘨𝘩𝘴 𝘪𝘯 𝘊𝘳𝘶𝘴𝘢𝘥𝘦𝘳 𝘒𝘪𝘯𝘨𝘴
- jorge-d 6y agoCK is really great, but if one really like to learn things about history / geopolitics while playing a game I don’t thing any game is as rich as EU4 :)
- switch007 6y agoEU4 = Europa Universalis IV, to save other people searching.
- wellthisisgreat 6y agoI never really gave it a fair chance because it seems like more like an optimization exercise than actual experience. The absolutely mind blowing part about CK for me is that I DO NOT MIND LOSING at all. Of course I am playing on Ironman always so there is no /save/reload. It is so AMAZING damn. For example: I would start the new dynasty and the whole thing collapses spectacularly after 3rd generation - great -wow - I had a blast. I spend like 2 weeks on and off conquering half the world, then one evening I get bored, start doing crazy stuff and everything collapses - wow - what a ride. I start out small, my wife dies can't find a fertile concubine my brother assassinates me, my game session is suddenly over in like 30 minutes. I am absolutely delighted. I don't feel like I should correct it all, salt the earth, become the richest king ever etc. etc. It just doesn't matter. Any other game was always - win win win. Crusader Kings is really a masterpiece. I think it's probably the most innovative game since 1990s when RTS / FPS / MMORPG / MMOFPS etc. were suddenly invented seemingly overnight. Sure it's possible to make an indie title that focuses on one interesting mechanic, or produce a game with a decent story and touching dialogues or create a memorable character. But to take something as ancient as a grand strategy (+RTS) genre in all its complexity (economics, armies, diplomacies) and to make something that feels REALLY brand new and also is an absolute blast to play and has one of the strongest "one more year (turn)" hook? Wow. I didn't experience a joy of revelation the first contact with CK-II gave me since maybe Dune-2 when I was blown away by the fact that each of those little soldiers and vehicles are living and breathing and are following my orders in real-time.
- Nasrudith 6y agoOne thing about civ which feels a bit annoying in missed potential is the lack of divergent tech and societal paths when going different directions and choices in directions. Say that if you are in a Inca like geography you have no real reason to develop the wheel until you expand far because it just isn't worth it. Or at every level being able to choose between "swarmer" and "warrior elite" strategy where what pays off varies by tech level just like real life. I understand some of it is design "awkwardness" related from sheer detail of modeling oddball situations alone. Combined with gameplay of "traps" from the freedom to try things which seem like a good idea but run into problems or silly exploits which work mechanically but make no sense.
- jandrese 6y agoI've long been annoyed at how the tech tree basically requires you to research _everything_ to progress. At least in Civ 5. Civ 6 has a handful of dead ends you can ignore, but they're few and far between.
- bcrosby95 6y agoI think Stellaris does tech in an interesting way. Tech trees are much flatter than civ, and you can't outright pick a specific tech to work - you have a choice from a random set, and when you finish that one you get another random set. What shows up in that set is also based upon what is in your empire's space.
- lordnacho 6y agoA fair bit of my education was Civ. There's never enough time in a history class to show you much of what's out there to learn, but Civ was a great way to learn about some cultures I'd never have heard of otherwise. The Civilopedia was pretty good reading for a time before Wikipedia, and it gave you the basic list of what Sid thought were the important cultures. Of course you can always add more, but Civ is a decent start if you want to know about someone other than Greece, the Romans, and Egypt. The list of wonders is also fantastic if you want something approaching a canon of stuff we've built. I haven't dared to go back to the series in the later years, too much addiction potential.
- pjc50 6y agoDefinitely a hugely formative game for me and a lot of other people, that encouraged you to learn the real history while writing your own. While there have been a lot of Civ games, I'd say that there was a "trilogy" of Civ, Colonization, and Alpha Centauri. As a brit, most of the US history I know comes from Colonization. It also had far more of a focus on the economy; military action was so expensive that it was limited to skirmishes until the War of Independence (although this didn't seem to impair the AI). It was more grounded in real history, although there was a recent controversy when it was pointed out that it had almost entirely erased slavery. Alpha Centauri was explicitly a sequel to Civ, set after the disastrous fragmentation of the space colonists into warring splinter groups. Inspired by the Mars trilogy, it put a lot of effort into building a narrative universe around the faction personalities. An epistolary novel in help texts. Possibly my favourite of the three, as you could assemble your own modular units in unusual combinations for specific purposes.
- anotherhue 6y agoMuch of the Alpha Centauri lore comes from Frank Herbert's "The Jesus Incident" [0]. Nerve runners, living planet, etc. 0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Jesus_Incident https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Jesus_Incident
- polytely 6y agoOh very cool, I didn't know that, I really like the story bits in Alpha Centauri, I love how each faction has an arc. I have never found another game that scratched the same itch as Alpha Centauri, truly an exceptional game.
- swyx 6y agosame, it was a huge part of my child hood. just leaving this here in case any other SMAC fans havent seen it https://paeantosmac.wordpress.com/ https://paeantosmac.wordpress.com/
- iso1631 6y ago> As a brit, most of the US history I know comes from Colonization Day of the Tentacle had a fair amount for me - the Cherry Tree (myth) of George Washington, Franklin and the kite, etc. A lot of my knowlege of geography, especially UK geography, came from playing the original Railroad Tycoon.
- 1f60c 6y agoI've never played it, but every other week, I get an email from Steam saying it's on sale. Is it worth it? Which version should I get?
- cainxinth 6y agoIf you like turn-based games, play it. It’s one of the best. Everyone says V is the high water mark. I didn’t pick it up until VI, but really liked it.
- thewileyone 6y agoI have all of them. I agree that V: Brave New World is the high water mark. I play IV: Beyond The Sword on lower spec laptops that can't handle the graphics in V.
- chadwittman 6y agoIt's incredible, especially if you have a bit of time to put into it. I'd recommend Civ IV or Civ V with all of the expansion packs.
- RangerScience 6y agoI'd vote for 6. 4 is the other "local maxima"; IMO 6 is a strict improvement on 5. They essentially just matured all of the mechanics, and then have added some new ones that aren't quite there yet (civ 7 some day...) (Although I do miss single-city runs as Venice in 5...)
- KarimDaghari 6y agoSerious question: I haven't played Civ (due to my then, younger age, although I have heard of it), I'd like to give it a go. Which one should I try out? Why? P.S: I would really appreciate one which favors/fosters learning over "dumb" playing.
- mcv 6y agoCiv 2 is the one I played the most. It's a classic, but probably a bit dated by now. Civ 5 is pretty good, and probably better than 6. Some people claim it peaked at Civ 4. Civ 5 certainly changes a few things compared to earlier versions, but at its heart it's still the same basic idea. I think I'd recommend Civ 5. The lack of doom stacks makes it more tactical, and it cuts down on micromanagement by introducing puppet governments for excess cities. Every civilization has its own special units and special abilities that give a subtle but noticeable twist to the flow of the game.
- 0xCMP 6y agoI would agree with this. Civ 4 is absolutely something some one new to the games should experience. Civ 5 and 6 allow you to control and focus on different things and are definitely, if not improvements, welcomed changes. Humble Bundle has a lot of Civ sales so if you're patient I'm sure you can grab a lot of the Civ games all at once for a small price.
- chadwittman 6y agoHonestly, they are all delightful. My personal recommendation would be to start with Civ III or Civ IV depending on your preference for graphics. If time is limited, get Civ IV and buy all of the expansion packs play on Settler with advisors on and you'll learn it quickly. They are all learning based, with that effect being slightly less as the series has aged... but still great games through and through.
- emiliobumachar 6y agoI've played 3, 4, 5, and 6. 6 is my favorite. Sorry, I can't offer a why. The differences are complex. There's much written online, but I suppose trying different ones is a better time investment than reading opinions. (Beware: you'll be "investing" a lot of time if you do like it.) Roll a dice if you have to.
- dboreham 6y agoExpected this to be about: https://www.amazon.com/Civilisation-Kenneth-Clark/dp/0719568447 https://www.amazon.com/Civilisation-Kenneth-Clark/dp/0719568... Or perhaps: https://www.amazon.com/Civilization-West-Rest-Niall-Ferguson/dp/1594203059 https://www.amazon.com/Civilization-West-Rest-Niall-Ferguson...
- throwawaymanbot 6y agounherd.com employs people who are proudboy sympathizers and who are cook with authoritarianism.. Not gonna read anything from this trash domain.
- segfaultbuserr 6y agoI don't see Civilization as a political masterpiece. It's certainly a great strategy game, but its underlying political message is a Machiavellian one. Unlike the real world where the governors and rulers are (at least on a superficial level) bounded by international duties, social & historical conditions, and the people under governance. In Civilization, the player is free to adopt any economic policies or political systems, as long as they give the maximum material benefits in the current situation. This can lead to some absurd strategies that don't make much sense. For example, abolishing republicanism in favor of absolute monarchy in the 21st century for a few turns before jumping back, without any regards of real-world consequences whatsoever, since the player is the eternal dictator of life. It's a simplistic system designed for game balance, not a realistic analogy of the real world. Thus, while I think it's certainly one of the greatest strategy games, but I don't think the game is a political masterpiece (Nevertheless, I guess the political system in Civilization can be alternatively interpreted as a cautious tale similar to Universal Paperclip's warning - If you let an overlord to optimize the wrong goal function - to produce as many paperclips as possible, or to win the game at all costs, inevitably humanity will suffer). This Civilization mentality can be best summarized by this HN comment under the submission "China’s Censors Ban Winnie the Pooh and the Letter ‘N’ After Xi’s Power Grab". https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16493254 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16493254 > If you played Civ5: no ideology is inherently wrong. As long as the "public opinion" is "content", people would be happy with it. Player would intentionally choose Order or Autocracy to gain some "Tenets". E.g. Order usually gets you better productivity and Autocracy usually gets you better military power. > Right now people in China are mostly content with the current ideology. > This design actually matches reality very well: while US apparently chose Freedom ideology, China chose Order ideology. China would finish impressive large project faster and more efficient, with the cost of dictatorship. > (Civ5 got a lot of these right, including a technology called "the Great Firewall" to counter the cultural influence from other civilizations http://civilization.wikia.com/wiki/Great_Firewall_(Civ5) http://civilization.wikia.com/wiki/Great_Firewall_(Civ5) ) And another HN user provided a counterargument on how analogy breaks down in the real world, > It doesn't match reality at all in fact. The exact opposite is true for nearly all cases (China being the sole exception). > The major liberal economies are radically more productive than countries like China, much less the other 'order' type nations. The order economies, save partially for China (which is still extremely poor in the bottom 2/3), are on average impoverished, backwards, and with very low productivity. Even China is still shockingly backwards at a lot of common economic tasks, such as farming (they have ~1/40th the farming productivity of South Korea). > The liberal economies have dozens of major success stories, from Germany to Canada to the US to Sweden. The 'order' group has one, and only insofar as China liberalized its economy and moved away from a rigid command & control economy. > Autocratic doesn't get you a superior military. It typically gets you an economy that is bled and debased to feed the military, which ultimately is self-destroying. See: Russia, whose people are very poor ($8k GDP per capita; $4,000 median net worth). Meanwhile Putin diverts vast resources they can't afford at all, into military spending. > Liberal economies produce superior militaries pound for pound, because they can afford to sustain them over time.
- rektide 6y agoWish we better enabled others to dabble in building modest world sims. It's hard when there's a whole tech level grind that also has to tick along in the background, fueling the sense of growth & achievement & pushing players ahead. But collecting resources, establishing population centers, weighing civil & diplomatic & religious opinions against one another... seems like a really interesting proposition that we make not just sandboxes but sandbox makers.
- msla 6y ago> It's hard when there's a whole tech level grind that also has to tick along in the background, fueling the sense of growth & achievement & pushing players ahead. I have a real problem with how tech levels are implemented in Civilization, at least in the variants I'm familiar with: There's just a few ways to progress, and advances are always better. Technology is not fitted to the environment, like how wheels don't make a lot of sense on roads which are rocky and often stairstepped up steep slopes; nope, the whole concept of "Inventing Wheel" not being a necessary step to further advancement is lost on the game, even if it's empirically possible to build advanced civilized societies without them. It's like it's insulted by wheel-less-ness, and never understands that facts don't care about its feelings. Further, there's no trade-offs: Iron swords are better than bronze, and never you mind that common iron is worse than bronze; unless you have truly outstanding Damascus steel, you're using sponge iron at best. Of course, sponge iron doesn't require tin, so if you're cash-strapped or just lost a tin-producing province, well, Iron Age ahoy! https://www.e-education.psu.edu/matse81/node/2129 https://www.e-education.psu.edu/matse81/node/2129 I wouldn't care about this stuff if it weren't for the pernicious effect of these games on peoples' de facto history education. They think that if it works that way in Civilization, it must have worked that way in reality, and it's hard to remove a bad education.
- dclowd9901 6y agoNot for nothing, and probably saying a lot about my ability to imagine, but I can scarcely think of a world without the infinite lever that a wheel (gear) is. Unless you’re suggesting society should halt innovation before agriculture, which, maybe it should.
- hn_check 6y agoOrthogonal complaint, but it was a huge loss when the Civilization catalog was removed from GeForce Now. I loved playing Civ while developing on my laptops, without it spooling up my fans, burning my lap or impeding my other processes. Playing it in the cloud was the perfect solution, and it has the perfect "lag doesn't matter" gameplay where a bit of latency doesn't diminish the enjoyment. Whatever their pissing match is, after playing Civ in the cloud I just could never get back to playing it locally. I was spoiled, and as a result I haven't bought two of the most recent Civ expansion packs.
- MrUssek 6y agoI think that Errant Signal's video on Civilization offers a really interesting counterpoint to this view. When you think about it, despite it's cheap cosmopolitanism, it has an extremely narrow contemporary liberal view of civilization, government, technology and "progress". I think it's worth looking into. https://youtu.be/xBlEscMLjy0 https://youtu.be/xBlEscMLjy0
- ng12 6y agoI don't know. This feels pretty similar to criticizing Call of Duty for not exploring peaceful resolution of conflict enough. Civilization is just a skin on a resource management game; popular history is the theme. Criticizing it for not adequately exploring the intricacies and assumptions of western history is missing the point.
- vkou 6y agoIf you can, as TFA, plumb it for deeper political meaning, you can also, like Errant Signal, criticize it for that political meaning being a glorification of a rather weird, authoritarian-nationalist (nearly fascist, with the game's single-minded obsession in directing all resources, human or otherwise towards the service of a single-purpose state) world view, that does not even make any sense in 95% of the time periods that the game covers. Your argument can certainly be made, but it can also be turned against the article this thread is about, with similar levels of success. Errant Signal is not saying that the game is bad. It is saying that the political picture its mechanics paint isn't one with any depth to it.
- twic 6y ago> it has an extremely narrow contemporary liberal view of civilization, government, technology and "progress" Indeed - you can't even marry your own daughter! This comment was made by CK3 gang.
- Barrin92 6y agoI love the Civ games but I definitely agree with that criticism. Civ is to politics or culture what the world music genre was to music. Even the styles of the civ cutscenes, the character design, or the dialogue screnes aesthetically seem to resemble sort of 90s world music album covers. This is why Alpha Centauri is by far my favourite Civ game, it's free from having to deal with a lot of historical accuracy and just has a very strong narrative and great worldbuilding.
- jcadam 6y agoI probably played Civ1 the most, on the Amiga back in the day. IMO, Civ II was the best in the series, and if I find myself craving a game of Civ, I go for FreeCiv. Never tried Civ VI, the last few iterations just did not hook me the way the original did. If I'm looking for a good world sim, I like the Paradox series of games - Europa Universalis, Victoria, etc.
- skatanski 6y agoSimilarly played Civ1 on Amiga 500 a lot. Didn’t know how to create save disks, so just left it running overnight. No game again reproduced that feeling of marvel, getting to know its mechanics first time. It does feel that Paradox games create a better simulation. Even Crusader Kings, albeit on a slightly different level.
- cptnapalm 6y ago/r/shitcrusaderkingssay is certainly proof of being on a different level.
- brobinson 6y agoI like Crusader Kings more than all the others because it results in amazing stories as it's character-focused rather than focused on faceless nations (Victoria, HOI, EU, etc.). I can tell you about the time I conquered most of east India and became a king, swore fealty to the emperor of Tibet for protection, married my daughter to his son for a non-aggression pact with him, then somehow my daughter later ends up becoming empress, and one of my fellow vassals (my daughter is my liege at this point) starts pushing my _wife's_ weak claim on the empire of Tibet in a civil war... And I have tons of stories like that. I have basically none from other grand strategy and civilization management games in comparison.
- zajio1am 6y ago> It does feel that Paradox games create a better simulation. I would say it is complicated. On the first look, EU4 is much more realistic and less stylized/symbolic than Civ, but on the second look, Civ (even the first one) has many important game mechanisms just right to express more realistic dynamic behavior. E.g.: waging war in Civ feels costly, as building capacities are used to build units and therefore cannot build civilian improvements, which leads to long-term falling behind. OTOH in EU4, waging war feels cheap, one can lost all its manpower and there are no significant ill effects, and being in peace while on full manpower is just wasting manpower recovery resource. Even better example is city/province development, where Civ has natural growth, diminishing returns from growth and different results for each city based on local geography and infrastructure, in EU4 it is just paid monarch points and linear effects. One can have satistying pacifist play of Civ, while pacifist play of EU4 would be exremely boring.
- wellthisisgreat 6y agoIf you are remotely interested in strategy games check out Crusader Kings III It's phenomenal (I mean CK II was phenomenal and CKIII just updates it). Truly a unique experience. I cannot stand any games that have NPC interactions with the only exception of CK. It's the closest you can get now to experiencing what it is to read and write a historical fiction at the same time (speaking from experience).
- rauchp 6y agoI haven't really played video games in a few years, but back when I did I was incredibly into Crusader Kings II and Victoria 2. After reading your comment, I am counting down the hours until Friday afternoon so I can buy and binge on CKIII. I just want you to know that you cost me any and all productivity this weekend. Cheers!
- toeget 6y agoI've tried to get into CK three times and I just don't get it. I love all the other paradox games (well, except stellaris, scifi setting is not my cup of tea). I love EU4 because it's a strategy game, where I can replay history and explore alternative paths. But with CK2 and CK3 now it's just not clicking for me. Why should I care about my in-game brother's wife's fictional son?
- AaronM 6y agoI like paradox games, I just dislike their endless DLC, the game always feels in a slighty unfinished state, although they do a better job than other companies that don't release DLC
- haberman 6y agoI've played every Civilization since the first one, I believe. I think 4 was my favorite, especially since it had the best music. I sing old music professionally, and it was such a treat to enter a new era and hear some of the best musicians in the world singing actual music of the era: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7g7jOKLUus8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7g7jOKLUus8 (the music in that video is by John Sheppard, a decidedly Renaissance composer (not Medieval, as indicated by the game), but the music is so good that I can absolutely forgive that inaccuracy). Lately I've been wavering from the series though. My biggest complaint is that every game is so long and requires so much micromanagement in the mid-late game. Even at the fastest setting, a full game seems to take at least 10-20 hours. Sometimes I just want to go through the tech tree in a different world without having to spend such large amounts of time on it.
- hangonhn 6y agoI'm sure you probably already know this but for people who don't follow music as much, Baba Yetu, was the first song from a video game to win a Grammy. It was originally sung by a Stanford a cappella group ( http://www.stanfordtalisman.com/ http://www.stanfordtalisman.com/ ). The composer, Christopher Tin, recently just released a new album called "To Shiver the Sky" ( https://christophertin.com/albums/toshiverthesky.html https://christophertin.com/albums/toshiverthesky.html ). Check it out if you liked the music from Civ 4 as much as we did!
- 29athrowaway 6y agoBaba Yetu is a great song and is now a phenomenon beyond Civ. Unfortunately it was no longer used in the expansions (Warlords, Beyond the Sword).
- gota 6y agoIn one of thr updates for Beyond the Sword they introduced an option to choose the menu. So you can have both the additional features and Baba Yetu! (While you're at it make sure you disable the enhanced espionage mechanics, for better gameplay. But that may be just opinion!)
- AzzieElbab 6y agoindisputably, it kept me off the streets for months...
- spiritplumber 6y agoAlpha Centauri is where it's at for me. Some gushing: https://paeantosmac.wordpress.com/ https://paeantosmac.wordpress.com/
- RangerScience 6y agoAch, had such hope for the remake. Alas :/ Kinda hoping there'll be a new attempt now that core Civ has climate change, since those mechanics could (I hope?) be repurposed for terraforming.
- iso1631 6y agoIn the beginning the earth was without form, and void. But the sun shone upon the sleeping earth, And deep inside the brittle crust, massive forces waited to be unleashed. The seas parted, and great continents were formed. Mountains arose, earthquakes spawned massive tidal waves. Volcanoes erupted and spewed forth fiery lava, And charged the atmosphere with strange gasses. Into this swirling maelstrom of fire and air and water, The first stirrings of life appeared. Tiny organisms, cells and amoeba, clinging to tiny sheltered habitats. But the seeds of life grew, and strengthened, and spread, and diversified, and prospered. And soon every continent and climate teemed with life. And with life came instinct, and specialization, natural selection, reptiles, dinosaurs and mammals. And finally there evolved a species known as man. And there appeared the first faint glimmers of intelligence. The fruits of intelligence were many: Fire, tools, and weapons, The hunt, farming, and the sharing of food, The family, the village, and the tribe. Now it required but one more ingredient: A great leader to unite the quarrelling tribes, To harness the power of the land, To build a legacy that would stand the test of time: A CIVILIZATION!
- rkagerer 6y ago...encounter neighbouring tribes with whom they’d negotiate, trade and sometimes go to war. Or, sometimes not go to war
- WalterBright 6y agoCivilization was apparently inspired by Empire. http://classicempire.com/ http://classicempire.com/ (Yes, I wrote Empire.)
- thewileyone 6y agoEmpire was an awesome game! I spent hours and hours on Empire ... until Civilization came out unfortunately. Thank you so much Mr Bright! You deserve much love!
- WalterBright 6y agoLove won't pay my bills, I want money! Just give me money! -- apologies to the Flying Lizards
- coolgeek 6y agoA+ obscure music reference!
- WalterBright 6y agoIt's my theme song!
- WalterBright 6y agoThanks for the kind words! I spent enormous amounts of time tweaking the computer's strategy so it would play a reasonably competent game. Curiously, each decision looks like a sequence of input values with a coefficient. What does that look like? You guessed it, a neural network! I obviously had no idea what I was doing. I never hit on the notion of generalizing it, and then doing training to find the best coefficients and the inputs that mattered. (Of course, I didn't have the computer power to run 10,000 game iterations, either, when it'd take an hour to run one game.) I bet now one could use neural networks to turn the computer strategy into a formidable opponent.
- tus88 6y agoI haven't played any Civs yet, not sure to go with the original or one of the remastered versions.
- dunnevens 6y agoFor those looking for a stripped down Civ, take a look at Polytopia (iOS / Android). They've done a mostly brilliant job in creating a very minimalistic Civ-style 4x game. Has two modes: a 30 turn game in which the player with the highest score wins. Building wonders and temples gives more points than conquest, so that mode is a very stripped down version of a cultural victory goal. And then there's the free-for-all mode, with no turn limitations and the only possible victory is conquest. I mostly play the latter. There's a simple tech tree. Diplomacy is done in an interesting way, and I wish more games would emulate it. There's no direct negotiations, relationship scores, or anything like that. Instead, you have to measure how they feel about you by the way they act. They give you a greetings when you first meet. If they laugh at you or are suspicious, then they'll probably attack immediately. If they worship you or condescendingly pat you on the head, then they won't attack for a while. And this is also built on by judging them based on further actions. If you move a unit adjacent to theirs, and they don't attack it, then you know they're trustworthy for a time. And you can subtly manipulate their feelings towards you by doing things like not counter-attacking even when they're attacking you. This is useful in a multi-front war when you're losing. You can make the decision to concentrate an offensive on one front when your defenses can possibly hold on a second front. If the enemy isn't hellbent on your destruction, they'll possibly just stop attacking and do something else. If you accurately guess that they hate another nation more than they hate you, then attacking the hated nation will get them to consider you acceptable. It's a bunch of big gambles and an interesting ones. Judging the other nations' attitudes towards you by intuition alone. That definitely adds a little nuance to the conquer-the-world bits. Most games are over in 30 minutes or less, though occasionally they stretch out when you're evenly matched. Even then, it's rarely more than an hour.
- thursday0987 6y agoin my opinion, "Hexonia" is a slightly better variant (at least on Android). The graphics are better, it uses a hex grid instead of a square grid, and the game play is slightly better. Polytopia is better in some ways - some of the specialty races introduce completely new concepts/units/gameplay mechanic, while all the Hexonia races are essentially the same with only some units being different between them. Try both if you're curious. neither of them have ads that break gameplay.
- PeterCorless 6y agoI used to love, love, love Civ games. Civ 4 was definitely my favorite as well. However, just as a kid I finally graduated from boardgames like "Risk" to more sophisticated fare (SPI and AH games), with Civ I finally graduated to Paradox series (EUIV, CK3, HOI4), which each have more verisimilitude and thus feel more real and more satisfying. Oppositely, Civ literally got more cartoony and, in a way, less believable with each new version. So now I only play Civ when I want a "casual" game. I'm never really interested in playing it to completion. It feels "gamey" and mildly unsatisfying once you've mostly explored the world. I have no interest in playing at "hardest difficulties" that are really nothing more than giving more plusses to the AI and more maluses to you. I want more depth of play. To feel like Civ used to feel. Exploring a world. Making alliances that make sense. I believe Paradox has spoiled me utterly in that way.
- vram22 6y agoDistantly related: Gandhi, asked by a reporter what he thought of civilization, is said to have replied: "I think it would be a good idea".
- toeget 6y agoAnd then he launched the nukes.
- rkagerer 6y agoI love this series. I didn't like how many clicks it took each turn to play a Civ3 / Conquests game by email, so I wrote a helper that would automatically launch the game when you opened an email attachment, read pixels from the screen, identify known patterns of graphics, and send clicks to "autopilot" the game into loading up the save and entering your turn. When you finished your turn, it would zip the file back up and send it to the next player. It was a little buggy but proof of concept worked well. Didn't get much chance to use it myself, but later gifted the code to some programmers who ran a fan site and were interested in it.
- simonebrunozzi 6y agoI played all Civilization games from I to 4, and even played a little bit of the 5. Unfortunately, what was once a revolutionary concept, faded into something more ordinary very quickly, at least for me. Every game is essentially an improvement and refinement over the previous one, with no "revolutionary" concepts being introduced. (an exception is Alpha Centauri, which you can consider a spin-off in space, and which introduced several interesting things). It's a pity. I admire Sid Meyer and his work, and Firaxis. But it's a pity that they essentially milked a successful concept without inventing anything truly NEW for about twenty years.
- gdubs 6y agoI have fond memories of sitting in front of my Tandy Sensation, black screen with two or three revealed pieces of a continent. Such a great game.