18 ms·
Netflix boss: Remote working has negative effects
- ffggvv 6y agoglad i dont work at netflix
- ZanyProgrammer 6y agoI sorta had the impression that they were going to be WFH for the duration of the pandemic, so unless the boss is trying to prepare the ground for a change, I guess he's just complaining?
- ffggvv 6y agoyeah but alot of companies are also becoming more open to longer term wfh arrangments
- 46Bit 6y ago> Netflix's chairman has said working from home has no positive effects No positive effects for him. Maybe. And even that is pretty dubious considering we're in a pandemic and nobody is at their best.
- alexbanks 6y agoAnd the layers and layers and layers between Netflix' CEO and non executives probably mean he has almost no idea what he's talking about wrt general employees.
- qzx_pierri 6y agoThe layers of "Yes men" are likely in agreement with whatever he believes
- WalterSear 6y agoAnd in all likelihood have very little to do but attend and hold meetings.
- jjeaff 6y agoYa, I suspect this very fact is going to keep wfh from becoming a broad reality. There is a lot of upper middle management that have nothing to do but meet with people. If talking and collaborating is all you do then you are going to push for in person.
- xenator 6y agoSome things are working for some companies some not. I work from home/remote most of my life. But honestly most of companies I’ve worked was never effective as it can be. I must admit, that many companies can be more effective when people work face to face. But they never try to be productive on any reasonable level. And I’m not talking about sacrificing all time, life and energy to boss. I’m about not wasting time on visibility of work.
- myvoiceismypass 6y agoEh. It’s a pretty flat org - not a lot of layers between Reed and most employees. He was pretty approachable too - could often be found mingling with employees on campus at lunch, for instance.
- alexbanks 6y agoA quick google search shows a pretty typical layered corporate structure.
- marcinzm 6y agoYeah, I mean I assume most anyone with younger kids is going to have trouble being productive (kids stuck at home, no childcare, no babysitters, no older relatives to help, etc.) which says little about WFH in general.
- noneeeed 6y agoYeah. I have two kids. Now that the older is back at school and the yonger is in nursery or with her childminder when my wife is working, it is significantly better working from home. After five months of working a weird split shift pattern it's really nice to be back to a more regular pattern. (This is in the UK, where our infection rate is pretty low now, how long that lasts remains to be seen)
- satysin 6y agoYes this nullified his argument to me. Do I think WFH is some magical solution to everything? Hell no. But to claim it has "no positive effects" is disingenuous.
- thinkingkong 6y agoI mean its sort of a blanket statement. Do I believe remote work is harder for c suite and writers? Absolutely. Is it harder for engineers? Probably less so.
- bluedevil2k 6y agoWhat’s best for the company doesn’t mean it’s best for the individual employees. People need to focus on what’s best for them because we’ve probably all learned at this point that the company puts their needs above your own.
- ictebres 6y agoYes, the same guy thinks sleep is a competitor of Netflix. So no, I do not think he has the best interest of other humans. [1]: https://www.fastcompany.com/40491939/netflix-ceo-reed-hastings-sleep-is-our-competition https://www.fastcompany.com/40491939/netflix-ceo-reed-hastin... edit for possible misunderstanding that I'm critisizing the OP
- CinchWrench 6y agodid you know netflix's first CEO is Edward Bernays' great-nephew?[1] Makes a lot of things make sense. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marc_Randolph#Early_life_and_education https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marc_Randolph#Early_life_and_e...
- saagarjha 6y agoI think you're putting far too much weight on a great-uncle who Randolph may not have never met.
- srtjstjsj 6y agoIs team netflix really afraid that if they made quality instead of quality that people wouldn't subscribe? $4/week for 1 excellent movie and 2 good TV shows week, for the whole household/freeloaders, including offline and HD, is a pretty darn good deal and everyone gets to sleep.
- aokiji 6y agoalso Netflix boss: we are fine with advancing the pedophile agenda of normalizing sexualization of minors [1]. [1] - https://www.ccn.com/netflix-cuties-scandal/ https://www.ccn.com/netflix-cuties-scandal/
- animationwill 6y agoI have been remotely working for years, and had thought about applying to Netflix, but if they don't have plans for remote work to continue, then I'll consider other jobs.
- runawaybottle 6y agoSo glad remote work is simply a bigger undeniable phenomenon that the suits can’t wish away. Even a four day work week with one day remote for most white collar jobs was a foreign concept until this year. The quality of life improvement for everyone is insane. People have more time to spend with family, cut entire commutes a few times a week, getting that extra hour of sleep, or have that extra hour or two after work, it’s about as close to the mythical European quality of life Americans hear rumors about.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- neonate 6y agohttps://archive.is/6iK6Z https://archive.is/6iK6Z
- boplicity 6y agoDo you have a suggestion for how WSJ should fund it's journalism? Maybe copyright infringement isn't an answer to that question.
- aaomidi 6y agoThis is not the point of this article sent. If you want to start a discussion about funding newspapers make a new thread. Don't hijack this one.
- ivalm 6y agoAs a former wsj subscriber I wish I could pay a la cart for the article. Perhaps $1-2? $37/month is high for a news source I usually read less than 5 articles per month. I already pay for Bloomberg/Economist/NYT/New Yorker but that’s because I regularly read double digit number of articles from them per month. At the same time when social media (like hn) sends me to wsj I would gladly contribute proportionally to my utilization.
- tzs 6y agoSo you'd pay $2/article, and read about 5 a month. That's $10/month. You can actually effectively kind of do that by getting an Apple News+ subscription. That's $10/month and includes WSJ articles. If you are reading on an iPad or iPhone and see a WSJ link on HN, hit Safari's share icon, and select News and it opens in the News app.
- ivalm 6y agoI didn't know about this, I'll give it a go! Thanks! Edit: this is kind of interesting. I looked at Bloomberg and a few others and the subscriptions were comparable to their normal digital options. But WSJ is much cheaper on Apple News, why is this so? Is there some catch (like 2nd year is expensive)?
- claudeganon 6y agoWasn’t there a story awhile back about how Netflix does like ritualized firings, guided by all kinds of weird dark, internal politics? Probably harder to do over Zoom.
- chromedev 6y agoA lot of employers have turned their culture more into a cult than anything else. I feel the same way about working for AWS.
- xoxoy 6y agoi’ve read articles that suggest the line between work and life is actually more blurred due to WFH and people just end up working longer. logically it makes sense when it’s all happening in your home.
- vikinghckr 6y agoYou just need to ask any PhD grad student why work from home is harmful for work-life balance. Once the boundary between home and work gets blurred, stress from work starts seeping into your personal life. Burn out rates among software engineers will be through the roof if WFH continues for a few more months.
- tma28744 6y agoFor some maybe, but some people have no problem separating work and personal life. My guess it that the people that have the most trouble with this are the ones that have no hobbies outside of work, so they just end up working more since they have nothing else to do.
- Aaargh20318 6y ago> Once the boundary between home and work gets blurred, stress from work starts seeping into your personal life. For me the fact that the line between work and home gets blurred reduces stress by a huge amount. No longer do I have to do all my work in a specific 8-hour window. I don’t have to be ‘on’ for 8 consecutive hours anymore. I can do a few hours of work, do some mindless chores around the house, then go back to work. If I’m stuck on a problem, I can just take a break instead of sitting at my desk going in circles. I’m more productive and more relaxed since the start of the lockdown. In addition, just the fact that I have access to a fully equipped kitchen makes a world of difference when it comes to breakfast and lunch.
- johnnyfaehell 6y agoWhat I've noticed at my company is, the people who were massive fans of working from home are now the people who are missing the office the most, except for one or two people. Working from home has it's benefits but it's really not for everyone. I, personally, am looking forward to going back to the office full time. I can go to the office just now but without other people there it just seems pointless to go.
- vikinghckr 6y agoI never liked WFH, but even I didn't realize how much I enjoy working from office. It has made me absolutely resolute not to EVER consider remote work as an option ever again.
- akmarinov 6y agoWould you still like working in the office if your coworkers were wfh and you were mostly by yourself? No judgment just wondering.
- Aeolun 6y agoProbably. As long as there is one other person in the office, and maybe even without. Having the separation between work and home area is fairly important to me.
- johnnyfaehell 6y agoThere is one guy at my company that goes to the office every day. He is often the only person in the IT department. Considering that even before Corona because was had a distributed team it's not so much different except for lunch.
- Scoundreller 6y agoI'm in that camp, but for other reasons. I live close to work, but others are doing 1.5-2 hour round-trip commutes. I was pushing for more WFH to keep them sane. It also helps with recruitment: Your catchment area is bigger if someone only has to come in the office 3x/week vs. 5x. I guess we need to differentiate between 100% remote, and partial WFH. Just about everyone will be in favour of the latter, but pushing everyone into the former has its consequences.
- vikinghckr 6y agoFully agree. Working from home is pure hell. I can't wait to go back to in-person office, once the vaccine is out. And if my employer mandates WFH policy even after vaccine, I'll look into renting a personal office space at least 2-3 miles away from my home. Just so I can get my commute and structure back into my life.
- katbyte 6y agoWhy do you want a commute?
- vikinghckr 6y agoBecause the commute worked as a great buffer to get into "work mode" in the morning and then transition back into "home mode" in the afternoon. Without this well-defined separation, I never get the productivity boost for work in the morning, and nor do I get the "work done for the day" feeling at the end of the day. Commute and getting out of my home is absolutely essential for me to remain productive and happy.
- jedberg 6y agoOne trick I learned a long time ago is take a walk around the block in the morning before walk, and do the same walk in reverse in the afternoon. It tricks your brain into saying "this is my commute". Ideally you have a work laptop or some such that you can take out in the morning after your walk and put away at night before your second walk.
- takeda 6y agoNice idea, and also a positive for a well being.
- Volundr 6y agoOne of my co-workers setup and office in his garage for this purpose. Even though he had an "office" of sorts in his house with his computer and all, it didn't provide enough separation to switch his head-space, especially because he'd potentially be in there on his computer for reasons besides work. So he setup a separate office with separate equipment for work. When done, he just leaves the garage. The point being the commute might not need to be that long. Just a signal to your brain your done.
- remir 6y agoThe Wall Street Journal newspaper asked Mr Hastings if he had seen any benefits from staff working from home. "No. I don't see any positives," he replied Not even a tiny bit of positive? I would be curious to know Netflix's workers point of view on this.
- rrobukef 6y ago"We didn't shut down" is apparently not a positive.
- tayo42 6y agoHow does someone in such a high position see things so black and white? Either way, this world wide work from home experiment isn't even a good one because there's a massive pandemic going on that... Judge wfh after the world is vaccinated.
- mderazon 6y agoExactly. I've been working from home for years. I thought this was finally the tipping point for WFH but I now starting to realize people are forming bad opinions about it but due to the circumstances, this is not really a proper "clean" WFH experiment due to the pandemic
- syndacks 6y ago>How does someone in such a high position see things so black and white? The CEO of Netflix is a brand in itself. The guy is selling a message, a vision (and a book!) My guess is, deep down inside, he sees several positives of WFH, but that doesn't vibe with his overall message or the culture he's trying to cultivate.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jedberg 6y agoThis doesn't surprise me. Netflix was always very anti-WFH. When I was there I know of only one team that did it, and that was the OpenConnect team (Netflix's custom CDN). And the main reason that was allowed was because the team was spread all over the world. The Netflix culture is very strongly built around in-person collaboration. One interesting way this manifested itself was when the new HQ was built, it had a ton of 2-4 person meeting rooms, more than I've seen at any other big tech company. This was a reflection of the many 2-4 person meetings that were scheduled every day. In the old building, you'd often see a 10 person room being used by two or three people because there were no small rooms left. Sure you can replicate this on zoom, but it's just not quite the same as sitting across from someone reading their body language.
- bastardoperator 6y agoHad about 30 of these small meetings rooms on each floor at my last company. I find that most people use them to isolate themselves from all the interupts in the office.
- jedberg 6y agoThere were "phone booths" for isolating oneself from the office, but it was generally frowned upon to use a 2/3 person room for oneself, unless it was just a quick phone call.
- bengale 6y agoThe trick is to book them with a couple of like minded people. Nice quiet private office basically and your calendar looks like it’s already full so people don’t book you into useless meetings.
- crispyporkbites 6y agoIt’s not the same- why try to replicate an inefficient process anyway. Most meetings are a colossal waste of time.
- ralph84 6y agoAs long as Netflix continues paying top-of-market they'll have no problem attracting talent regardless of whether they allow WFH. It's the companies that don't pay top-of-market that have to think longer and harder about WFH.
- thiagocsf 6y agoWhat data did you use to make this assertion? I know of at least one counter-example. Maybe it’s the exception that proves the rule but I’d rather see some numbers before believing it.
- drewcoo 6y agoIf you consider ability to work flex hours or WFH as part of your employment package, they don't offer WFH but they do offer more money. Overall comp is still high. What additional data do you need? Relative value of WFH vs cash to various demographics?
- throwaway45349 6y agoI'm going to go against the vibe on this site and agree with him. The next Apple or Google definitely will not come from a remote working startup, and there's undoubtedly a lot of value from in-person collaboration. In a bigger company like Netflix this might be less important. A big part of this is the transfer of knowledge, which isn't as easy over Zoom calls.
- 29athrowaway 6y agoI bet the next Apple or Google will use Linux, an operating system developed by a globally distributed remote team, or other open source technologies.
- znpy 6y agoUhm... You're vastly underestimating the amount of work that companies like red hat and size put into both GNU and Linux. Yes many of the maintainers and key people are allowed to work remotely, but a lot more people work in the office. I don't want to against the general WFH vibe, but that statement is hardly 100% true.
- RandoHolmes 6y agoUnless those companies are all in the same building, that's also distributed...
- znpy 6y agoLol ok I guess?
- walshemj 6y agoAnd you point is Linux is a commodity bet they will use structured cabling also. You don't get a paradime busting product without a tight co-located team
- 29athrowaway 6y ago
- mlthoughts2018 6y agoOne of the big downsides I’ve found with my company being remote for about 6 months now is the nearly constant issues with tone and attitude in communication channels like video calls and Slack. I listened to one coworker tell another that they had no sense of humor and were too “by the book” and it was disrupting the ability to communicate. When a fraction of people worked remotely, this virtually never happened, because with only a small set of people working remotely, people had the mental bandwidth to devote a little extra time being sure to interpret their tone charitably, check for assumptions and follow up more often with them to fill in communication gaps that in-person gestures and signals would avoid. But when everyone is remote, it’s like taking the attention and time budget you have and dividing it by a much larger pool of people. It’s simply intractable for a human to spread their attention like that and remain diligent and focused on communication metadata about every pairwise colleague interaction channel. It spreads you too thin and you run into extremely exhausting ego depletion and decision fatigue from all these little micro communication assessments you have to make that our brains are just not setup or wired to handle because we’re so adapted to analog facial and voice analysis with gestures and cues. I despise loud, distracting open floor plans deeply, but the pandemic time period has made me deeply question whether fully remote work would actually be better. I feel way more tired and mentally exhausted from remote work, and casually I’ve noticed many, many more arguments and short fuse communication issues with everyone in my company. I think it speaks to the evidence that the most cost effective office environments for knowledge workers, even in dense urban centers, from the point of view of pure short term cost savings to the company, are environments where every individual knowledge worker has a private office with a door that shuts, combined with separate communal workspaces for the extreme minority of people who either need a mix or need more extraverted / social work environments instead of quiet / private workspaces. That way meetings naturally happen in person and it’s low-cost to setup meetings, grab coffee together, grab lunch, etc., while still preserving the remote work benefits of privacy and quiet. Unfortunately though my experience working remotely has taught me that avoiding a commute is deeply not a good reason to be remote, because the costs in terms of worse work experiences and worse communication are way too high.
- chromedev 6y agoI stopped subscribing to Netflix. Their recommendation engine is honestly terrible. They'd be much better off using curated genres.
- boring_twenties 6y agoTheir recommendation engine is beyond terrible. It sucks so bad that a flat list of all movies in alphabetical order would be much, much better. I would say that I am able to find something I want to watch on Netflix about one out of every five attempts. The other four end with me giving up in frustration after 20-30 minutes of looking. I wouldn't pay even a single dime for the service, myself. My partner does, and every now and then I get bored enough to give it another shot. Usually I regret it.
- pizza234 6y agoI suspect that they have an overengineering vision. This could originate from a culture very strongly (excessively, in this perspective) centered on engineering. They have a very positive view of their recommendations, like they have of their customized thumbnails. Yet I, and all of my friends, find the recommendations nearly useless, and I also find the thumbnails mostly ugly.
- rurp 6y agoYeah it's really bizarre just how bad the recommendations are, even after all of these years of development and data collection. Offsite lists and personal recs are the only ways I've found new Netflix shows I like.
- srtjstjsj 6y agoYour confusion is because that you represent a niche use case, while Netflix optimizes for the masses who use Netflix so they can think less, not more.
- nabla9 6y agoRemote working has positive and negative effects. First come the positive, over long term the negatives become self evident. Hopefully Covid-19 exposed people to the positive effects and there will be more remote work opportunities than before. People frequently working 1-3 days a week from home in many professions might become accepted norm.
- thiagocsf 6y agoAre you saying you don’t know what the negatives are or have they not become self-evident yet? I think there are immediate negatives, like collaboration, synchronous decision-making. I wonder what the long-term ones are.
- dmitriid 6y ago> I think there are immediate negatives, like collaboration, synchronous decision-making. This hits companies with teams who sit in the same office. Companies that are more spread out didn't suffer as much. My team of four people is spread of four cities, so we were always remote to each other. The negatives come from equipment and socialisation: - most homes are not equipped to be offices (anything from lack of proper chairs to lack of proper quiet places at home, especially if kids are on vacation) - you do miss interactions with other people at the office even if they are not on your team: lunches together, coffee breaks etc. This can be mitigated (just ask freelancers how they cope), but it will eventually affect most people - You often end up working more at the detriment of your work-life balance due to some routines just not being there. No one asks you to join them for lunch? You end up skipping lunch because you're working. People are not leaving for home en masse, you end up staying way beyond work hours hacking at "just one more bug and PR, and I'm done".
- biztos 6y ago> what the long-term ones are Work-life balance is really hard to maintain long term when you're WFH; and you don't have the "sniff the air" kind of awareness of politics/power-struggles/etc taking place in the office, which can easily cap your mobility, which anyway is pretty limited; you can end up stuck in one job if your lifestyle depends on WFH; and finally, it's difficult to power through when your motivation is low. Of course that's from the employee's point of view. From the company's point of view, I think the only long-term negative that's not already evident in the short term is that you miss chances to develop and promote your top remote talent to maximize their contribution. WFH folks tend to get stuck in a role or at least a very narrow silo. (Remote-first companies try to solve that of course, but I've never seen one up close so I have no comment.) Source: I'm WFH for about 11 years on the current gig, which I guess counts as "long-term."
- Rainymood 6y agoComing to the office once a week on friday made me realise how starved I was for social connection.
- ilamont 6y agoReed Hastings just released a management book (written before the pandemic) which is heavy on traditional, in-person management styles. I think the statements in the book make it difficult for him to suddenly welcome remote work on a permanent basis. In addition, certain (but not all) aspects of the media business such as creating media do work better in person. This is true of many industries, not just media, and may explain some of his thinking.
- oreaway 6y agoIt's amusing reading all of the HN comments that insist that any attempts to not work remote must be some ploy by "the suits" and act like remote work is some panacea for all the problems in the world. My very large tech company did a survey this summer about remote working conditions. Out of tens of thousands of respondents, less than one third said they wanted to continue working 100% remote. Nearly half said that their work/life balance was worse when working remotely. Over one third said they are less productive. HN lives in a bubble of pro-remote talking points. In reality, most of the tech workforce (to say nothing of the non-tech workforce, which I assure you is much more anti-remote) does not enjoy it.
- Spartan-S63 6y agoI would posit that a lot of those negative reactions to remote work is because the company culture has been sufficiently altered to support it. Most negative experiences I've observed have come from split companies, where two classes of employee occur, or from companies who say they're "remote first" but have a culture that hasn't evolved past the office. With the right process changes and the right culture, remote work can be enjoyable, rewarding, and more productive. Not to mention the big advantage: no commute.
- oreaway 6y agoNice hypothesis, but incorrect. This is at a company that has always had a large remote workforce, and if you do want to work remote, it's always been an option, and there is an actual culture to support it (and in fact, all of our internal tooling is built with remote work in mind. All meetings happen via Zoom even if you are in an office (partly because of lack of meeting rooms, but also because we don't want to disadvantage remote workers)). We've been trying to grow our remote work force because of lack of office space, but filling these remote roles has actually been hard. It turns out that there's a reason that most of our people choose to not be in those remote roles. They genuinely do not enjoy it.
- mrep 6y agoWhere are you located and what do you pay for local and remote workers?
- pjbk 6y agoFrom my experience at some workplaces, Netflix was 'a pure negative' for office work. Every time there was a popular show, which was several times a month, productivity at the office noticeably took a toll. I particularly remember some colleagues behaving like zombies for a couple of days after spending their night sleep hours binging on the platform.
- yumraj 6y agoTalking of Netflix, genuinely curious about something... I know that they have a leadership position today and supposedly hire great engineers, pay them very well and are doing very well in the stock market. But, in view of numerous other streaming services, purely in today’s context, do they have an engineering edge that is a key strength that will help them keep their leadership position or is that engineering edge no longer relevant and leadership in streaming services would simply be determined by who has the content.
- dmitriid 6y agoIt's no longer the question of "engineering edge". People will subscribe to Disney+ even if it only offers 720p streams with long buffering times. Even now in some countries (I'm writing this from Sweden) Netflix is 70% Netflix content, 5% a small number of fairly recent movies, and 25% a hodgepodge of movies not more recent than 2005. For the sole reason that the main content hoarders, ahem, rights holders have stopped their broad licensing deals with Netflix (Disney, WB etc.) and are openly hostile towards Netflix. If you don't have content, your technical edge means nothing. Netflix understood this the moment Disney (or was it WB?) announced they would cancel their licensing deal with Netflix a few years back, and Netflix started pumping billions of dollars into producing its own content.
- Thaxll 6y agoContent is one thing but engineering is really important to properly deliver that content, no one wants to buffer videos, have bad UX ect ...
- FalconSensei 6y agoI (partly) agree with you on that. As an user, I want: 1 - speed and quality - 1080p, no buffer 2 - Good interface - netflix has great interface, Prime video is ok-ish, Crunchyroll is so damn hard to navigate 3 - just works, everywhere - Netflix has an app for most devices, works on any browser, and streams to chromecast and smart tvs. Prime doesn't cast to chromecast, doesn't work between android and smart tv app (I can't control TV on my phone). Crunchyroll... well... nope. Pirate websites have a better player than crunchyroll... Guess which service I don't pay for?
- raverbashing 6y agoFrom their Culture Slides and overall stories about Netflix, it seems they are a bit different from most companies, read: move more slowly but more predictably. Yes, as a lot of people I've been feeling negative effects of prolonged WFH however this talk of WFH "makes debating ideas harder" just makes me roll my eyes. I don't think there was anything I didn't manage to do over a quick zoom call compared to what's doable in person.
- anotheryou 6y agoReading the absolute claim in the title ("no benefits at all") makes me dismiss his opinion instantly. You can claim it's net negative, but not seeing anything positive probably just means you are a workaholic with no life and can't fruit a good debate about it.
- FalconSensei 6y agoYeah, in my company we are seeing a lot of positive impacts, especially for those who live far from the offices, and are saving 10~15 hours a week from commuting. People can focus more on work, than spend time and energy commuting, and dreading the long commute home
- anotheryou 6y agoI totally can see negatives: - no water cooler talk and lunchs > bad for team spirit/work friendships - heated discussions going stale and ending up in resentment > easier to resolve in person when you get a good feeling for how the other feels (and interact about non-problematic things, e.g. the mentioned lunch together) - grabbing a busy person when you feel the time is right - harder to motivate yourself when you are on low-energy or stuck (And yet I think the positives even that all out)
- FalconSensei 6y agoIn the end, everything depends on the team and the person right? I would like going back to the office. I miss the espresso machine, the snacks, seeing people, playing boardgames after work. But that's because it's a 10 min. walk for me to go there. For some coworkers, it's a 1 hour drive each way, having to pay for parking, and needing to leave work no later than X because otherwise they have to pay extra. Also, I can concentrate more at home. In my previous job, I ended up moving to a small cubicle that was not being used, because I couldn't stand the noise of other people talking around me (had some loud speakers there).
- ghufran_syed 6y agoThe “principle of charity” would suggest interpreting the title as “no net benefit”. FWIW I personally think that remote work is hugely beneficial to the employees - but I don’t have enough data to figure out what the net impact is on the employer
- dang 6y agoUrl changed from https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-54063648 https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-54063648, which points to this.
- dan_m2k 6y agoI’m so pleased that someone isn’t afraid to reject the WFH kool aid. Just because certain personality types work better in solitude doesn’t mean it’s one-size-fits-all. Others are suffering loneliness, marginalisation, are struggling inside their own heads, are stuck in tiny apartments or don’t have access to outdoor space. If you hate the office that badly, you’re probably working at the wrong place. And yeah, a truly creative collaborative working environment can’t be replicated over video call.
- tashoecraft 6y agoThere is very rarely a one size fit all solution, I don’t think many advocates of WFH support everyone doing it. Also comparing Covid wfh with normal wfh is vastly different and incomparable. Many of us are stuck inside, whereas normal work from home you could go to a coworking space, or a coffee shop, are the beach. Being forced inside is totally different.
- theodric 6y agoI don't hate the office, I hate the commute, the food prices, and having to wear pants. Not everyone is you-- some of us really are happier this way!
- onion2k 6y agoAnd yeah, a truly creative collaborative working environment can’t be replicated over video call. Replicating a truly creative collaborative working environment is impossible everywhere. Truly creative environments are grown from the resources and people available. You can't copy something that worked elsewhere with different people and expect it to work again. Also, entirely anecdotally, the band The Postal Service are so called because they created their album by sending each other tapes through the post. They were very creative, and living in different cities, so creative remote work has been achieved at least once.
- Volundr 6y ago> If you hate the office that badly, you’re probably working at the wrong place. That's quite a departure from "WFH isn't one-size-fits-all". If working from home isn't for everyone, why do you assume the office is? > And yeah, a truly creative collaborative working environment can’t be replicated over video call. Strongly disagree. I don't think you even real-time communication, much less video is required to have strong collaboration. There are certainly times when it helps, but even in those times I've never felt held back by jumping on a quick call vs an in-person meeting, and we almost never do video.
- theodric 6y agoLooks like I'll never work at Netflix!
- ErrantX 6y agoAll I'd say is; Netflix have a pretty extreme culture[1]. From the outside it looks pretty solid, but I understand the reality is that if you are not above average for two performance cycles in a row they let you go. There is an expectation of drive, and constant commitment (no judgement; it works for them, though I'd never work there!) WFH naturally allows more flex into your real life. This will not vibe well with Netflix's culture IMO. 1. https://jobs.netflix.com/culture https://jobs.netflix.com/culture
- pizza234 6y ago> All I'd say is; Netflix have a pretty extreme culture[1] > 1. https://jobs.netflix.com/culture Scary. From some extracts, it seems more a cult than a company: > You question actions inconsistent with our values > You seek what is best for Netflix, rather than what is best for yourself or your group > You accomplish amazing amounts of important work They're taken out of context, but could be interpreted as hints to how the company really works.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- anoncareer0212 6y agoIf it is, I'm leaving my FAANG role for Netflix - it's very refreshing to hear people might be motivated by larger causes. Most of my last week was spent trying to avoid fallout from our team's massively skewed performance reviews: our first promotion case in 2 years is the colleague who performatively did no work for months while the manager was out, bullied me for continuing to schedule and work with our partner teams, and encouraged another co-worker to have a meltdown about it that cost them significantly.
- verticalflight 6y agoFAANG = Netflix
- 6y ago
- unnouinceput 6y agoI see a lot of comments about pro WFH (family, more relaxing work schedule, kids/pets around) and against WFH (less collaborative, can't read body language, a quick IM is slower then a simple live question for next chair) and while Netflix mainly talks about them - it actually boil down to one thing only -> SEX. Humans are a social animal and we like crowds. And with less physical work required then in past centuries jobs became more a brain exercise and less muscle required and with that means our brain requires more stimuli. And what is the easiest way to entertain brain? SEX. It's way more easy to work with a beautiful colleague alongside, it's more easy to take a coffee break and stroll through HR area to "cleanse the eyes" over "Janet" there. That's all about for those who hate WFH and are missing office. They can say a crap load of reasons why they don't like WFH but it boils down to one reason that absolutely nobody will talk about and that's SEX.
- nslocum 6y agosaid the office creep.
- unnouinceput 6y agoLol. You clearly missed my entire point altogether. Also if you even bothered to read any of my other comments you'll see I am WFH for a dozen years already, as freelancer. But this comment really shows your biased.
- aaomidi 6y agoWhat on earth are you on about
- dstick 6y agoRiiiight... * slowly backs away*
- mratzloff 6y agoWhat the fuck?
- ornornor 6y agoThat doesn’t make much sense.
- efficax 6y agoI can’t imagine anything more “pure negative” than a business culture with stack racking and firing people who aren’t “keepers”. Netflix’s success is from being first to market, pure and simple, and has nothing to do with a toxic management structure that, from all accounts, is abusive to its workforce.
- marcinzm 6y ago>Netflix’s success is from being first to market Plenty of companies are first to market and don't win the market. Also, Amazon Video predates Netflix streaming and Hulu was out only a year later.
- laluser 6y agoWhy do you think they are abusive to their workforce? They are clear about their culture and pay top dollar for engineering talent. There are no surprises when you join.
- yibg 6y agoStack ranking and the "keepers" test are not the same things. There is no stack ranking at Netflix. i.e. they don't let go of the bottom x percent. In practice every company does a version of the "keepers" test. The difference is where the bar is for keeping. At the very least companies will fire people that are just plain incompetent. That is deciding the keep line is basic competence.
- onelastjob 6y agoIn the article he says he'd be up for 4 days in the office and 1 day work from home after covid. These CEOs just can't let go of the 5 day work week. It's so frustrating. 5 day work weeks don't leave enough time for employees to take care of their personal lives, in my opinion. This results in employees taking more sick days and not concentrating at work because they have to deal with their personal business while at work. I think we need to move to a 30 hour work week. Four 7.5 hour work days would vastly improve working in my opinion, whether it is remote or in the office.
- mathattack 6y agoI would even settle for 4x10. :-) We either need entrepreneurs who are willing to test this as a way to get better talent, or engineers willing to take a pay cut. Either way, it won’t happen at big companies.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Aeolun 6y agoSo far my big company seems better at this than any startup I have worked for.
- dominotw 6y ago> I think we need to move to a 30 hour work week. why not 25 though? I personally think, 20-25 is the sweet spot.
- onelastjob 6y agoI agree. I think four 5 or 6 hour days would be the best and would actually be very productive, probably even more productive than the current 40 hour week. I think it's realistic for an employee to put in a solid five hours of focused work for four days in a row, which is way better than an unfocused 40 hours.
- warent 6y ago
- bamboozled 6y agoWorking remotely for years and I’ve never found it to be as good of an experience is a flexible office job. One of the things I hate the most of the fact people just disappear and things then take way longer to get done. The best jobs I’ve had is probably what Reed is describing in terms of attendance. 3-4 days in the office, flexible hours and some work from home options. It’s a good balance and I don’t have to sacrifice some part of my house to being an office.
- auggierose 6y agoI mean, they are a glorified streaming company. Probably hard to keep up the motivation for that at home.
- supernova87a 6y agoI've mentioned this before, but WFH has a huge difference in result depending on who you are, when you are (in your career), and where you are in a company (or organization). -- For the budding young developer who can't wait to show ideas to teammates and demonstrate being a go-getter by asking random questions and finding unaddressed issues to innovate on, WFH might be terrible. You're going to schedule time to fortuitously run into the senior person who takes an interest in your idea? -- For the working parent whose productivity has been slashed by 50% and stress has gone up by 50% due to parenting obligations, WFH might be terrible. -- For the middle manager who can coast along and not need to move greatly in his/her career, WFH might be great. -- For the developer who works by tickets on very concrete things and this is nothing new, WFH might be great. -- For the small company CEO who relies on force of personality and everyone in the same room urgently working to get something done, WFH might be terrible. There's a huge variability in what WFH means, depending on what you want from the situation. For some people, remote working is really not good. And that's aside from the point that, when everyone is remote, you're also competing with the world who is also remote. Jobs and job qualifications (and competition) may change...
- DeepThoughts 6y agoI’d like to propose a reframing of your scenarios for objectivity: WFH is horrible for some people in some scenarios. WFO (work from office) is also equally terrible for some people in some scenarios. It’s just that people have generally normalized and accepted that these horrible WFO situations are required to feed yourself. Barring jobs where you cannot function without physical presence, I’d say we need to fundamentally rethink why WFO is a default. And why we think a baseline of suffering for some people is generally OK.
- Rafuino 6y ago"Politics is tough because in many ways people elect people who lie a lot. In business, we really try to avoid that. The skills to succeed in politics are really quite different than in business." I disagree with this on multiple fronts, but certainly lots of business is built around lies and perception.
- pvelagal 6y agoI always wondered how most of the open source software like apache projects .. linux etc got built ? I guess it is “Work from home”.
- bigbassroller 6y agomy take on wfh trend is that it turns the workers office into a gig economy and by 2021 having a job with an actual office in the same metro will be a perk. Then the start of a new cycle will begin.
- syndacks 6y agoI'm noticing a theme in this thread, which is the literal interpretation of the CEO's comment, paraphrased as "WFH has no benefits". Try to understand that this guy is cargo-culting. He's selling a vision (and a book) -- that the Netflix way of doing things is superior to the average way of doing things. I'm sure deep down inside he knows WFH has benefits, but acknowledging them would go against the culture he believes is required to keep Netflix at the top. Many times he used sports as an analogy, and I will too -- the greatest coaches in history say and do odd things to inspire greatness. You might not agree with them, but you can't deny the results.
- aeternum 6y agoThis is my take on it as well, and some other quotes like this one also show that he's somewhat exaggerating for effect: WSJ: Do you have a date in mind for when your workforce returns to the office? Mr. Hastings: Twelve hours after a vaccine is approved.
- switch11 6y agoThis is a very interesting comment so will add some thoughts to this WFH has a huge difference in result depending on who you are, when you are (in your career), and where you are in a company (or organization). * agreed 100% -- For the budding young developer who can't wait to show ideas to teammates and demonstrate being a go-getter by asking random questions and finding unaddressed issues to innovate on, WFH might be terrible. You're going to schedule time to fortuitously run into the senior person who takes an interest in your idea? * yes, for people who don't know how stuff works, company culture, how to get things done this is very bad -- For the working parent whose productivity has been slashed by 50% and stress has gone up by 50% due to parenting obligations, WFH might be terrible. * pretty sure there are more parents who wish they could WFO than want to work from home and also homeschool their kids -- For the middle manager who can coast along and not need to move greatly in his/her career, WFH might be great. * depending on company 'coasters' can be 20% to 70%. For all of them WFH is superb because no one knows whether they are working hard or coasting. All their tricks like having certain things set up and certain screens on their monitors etc. - not needed any more -- For the developer who works by tickets on very concrete things and this is nothing new, WFH might be great. highly focused developers who like to shut off everything. WFH is great Except the PM/Project Manager/Tech Lead goes crazy because then developers start making what they find interesting and there is no way to keep them on track -- For the small company CEO who relies on force of personality and everyone in the same room urgently working to get something done, WFH might be terrible. * yea, this is absolutely terrible for anyone who has a leadership role much of the work you get done is by leadership, and sometimes by leadership by force of personality or by 'created' consensus good luck getting that in a WFH scenario * The real test of WFH will be when we see how companies that choose WFH after Coronoavirus, do compared to companies that go back to WFO lots of tech companies are slobbering at the thought of cutting out office costs and paying employees less my money is on such companies getting trounced by teams that work together and interact in an office environment Right now we are in the honeymoon phase of work from home and very few (if any) real products are being launched that were started after coronavirus forced work from home let's see how people feel in a year or two It just takes 1 or 2 lazy people to bring down an entire product launch. WFH makes it very hard to figure out who these slackers are, and even harder to cover up their mistakes/flaws Mythical Man Month is even more dangerous when WFH scenarios are involved
- jinonoel 6y agoMy company has been WFH since mid-March. I've loved being able to just start working instantly after waking up and finishing my morning routine, but one thing I've really missed is the 30minute drive home after work. That period of time was effective in resetting my brain from "work-mode" to "home-mode". It's been hard going from shutting down my laptop straight to playing with my kids, it seems like I'm part-zombie at first and not as lively as I would be later in the night with them.
- thedevilslawyer 6y agoThere has to be a better solution that WFO. For example, step out for a 10 minute walk outside.
- rajacombinator 6y agoWhat do work do people at Netflix do anymore besides writing blank checks for D-tier Hollywood garbage that no real studio wanted? Their app has been stagnant for the past 5+ years and the delivery issues seem to have been solved some time ago.
- Hypergraphe 6y agoThis is an obvious statement. Working at the office surely has negative effects too. This is a really personal matter.
- pwinnski 6y ago"Debating ideas is harder now... I don’t see any positives. Not being able to get together in person, particularly internationally, is a pure negative." Some of this might be personality differences, but it sounds like how Reed Hastings experiences work is very, very different from how I experience work.