6 ms·
Have we just stumbled on the biggest productivity increase of the century?
- blakesterz 6y agoIn case you don't feel like clicking through... "If working from home eliminated an hour of commuting, without changing time spent on work or reducing production, the result would be equivalent to a 13% increase in productivity (assuming a 38-hour working work)." I have to admit I've wondered about that. I'm not sure this article answers any questions, but it's a good question.
- xmprt 6y agoAnd the people who think that's a bad thing because now bosses are going to ask for more work... Having more time in your day doesn't mean you have to be more productive at your job. You can do tons of other things, whether that's caring for children, learning a new skill, or working on a hobby/side project.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- AltruisticGapHN 6y agoI don’t understand this at all. Where’s the 13% increase coming from? (if i work the same number of hours)
- cma 6y agoLess hours are tied up with work, if you consider commuting as hours tied up due to work. So: as productive with less hours is a productivity increase (if other downsides don't offset too much).
- cpeterso 6y agoThe article assumes that time you previously spent idle commuting is now spent diligently working.
- Dylan16807 6y agoInstead of spending 43 hours to do 38 hours of work, you spend 38 hours to do 38 hours of work. 43 / 38 = 113% productivity
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- hogFeast 6y agoYes, basically accurate if you produce the same amount in less time...that is productivity growth. But: it isn't sustained productivity growth (it is one-time), there will be losses elsewhere in the economy (won't someone think of the landlords!), and most people aren't going to swap their commute time for more actual production (which is perfectly fine, the purpose of life isn't work...but the point is there will be no output growth, inputs are changing but output isn't).
- Barrin92 6y agoOnly under a static view of productivity, that is to say taking the economy as it is and eliminating commute time (and ignoring the problems associated with working from home). Much more importantly though is the question if remote work facilitates the same degree of long term capital formation that traditional work environments do. Alexander Pentland's work (Social Physics)[1] casts doubt on this. Physical interaction turns out to be quite vital when it comes to cross-pollination of ideas, starting new business ventures and basically just transferring knowledge. It's the casual everyday interactions at the workplace, organic team-building, long term informal relationships formed and so on that are completely missing from remote work, and they have a huge impact. [1]https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/314230/social-physics-by-alex-pentland/ https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/314230/social-physi...
- Olreich 6y agoI’ve very successfully transferred watercooler conversations that “just happen” psychically to a better system of watercooler channels on chat programs. It’s better than just the 2-3 people you share a office with, as you can get ten people cross pollinating all at the same time. Have a novel thought or cool solution to a problem? Post about it and get kudos and feedback. I grew up with chat being the primary way to transfer ideas, especially with peers that weren’t close to me, so it’s more natural to me to do the conversational knowledge sharing via text. The missing piece from a workplace is a shared whiteboard that anyone can draw on. Everyone needs to get a digitizer at the quality of an iPad Pro or Cintiq to really bridge that gap. Hopefully the prices keep going down and that sort of thing can become as ubiquitous as chat.
- chrisco255 6y agoThe missing piece is the 65+% of communication that is nonverbal. Chat is no replacement for a team of highly focused, highly integrated people doing innovative work. It's too easy to give casual criticism or casual kudos on chat. Could something like the iPhone have been created without engineers and designers physically in the same space, debating and discussing ideas? I highly doubt it. If your job is not all that innovative in the first place, and no groundbreaking, chat might be ok for iterative innovation.
- xcambar 6y agoIt is sad that the article shows the additional time available as productive/work time. In my experience, the workforce maintains a similar productivity while working slower number of effective work hours. This boost of productivity is explained by the benefits of the loss of stress and commute, the comfort of home, the additional family time etc. There are downsides of course, such as lack of direct contact, unavailability of an actual office, and mostly the inability to disconnect when everything happens at the same place, aka home. But I'd like the general discourse to focus more on the fact that the direct benefits are for the employee, with positive side-effects for the employer. As in: let's put the employee at the core of the studies.
- Ozzie_osman 6y agoI love this. It's not just about productivity (which is employer-focused), it's about well-being (which is employer-focused). And working from home is double-edged in that regard, though I believe the positives will generally outweigh the negatives.
- corpMaverick 6y agoDid you mean to say employee-focused the second time ?
- Ozzie_osman 6y agoYes thank you!
- esperent 6y agoI agree, but on the other hand, the goal is to persuade companies that it's a good idea to continue this post-covid. To that end, focusing on benefits to the company will be more effective.
- glofish 6y agowhat an absurd article. And if you are wondering and unaware of Betteridge's law, no we have not stumbled into the biggest productivity increase in a century. Working from home does not make most people more productive, eliminating commute does not make you more productive. Productivity has nothing to do with time spent in a location.
- yjftsjthsd-h 6y agoRight, but productivity has everything to do with time spent and work done, so doing the same work with less time wasted on overhead (commuting) means more productivity.
- unabst 6y agoIt's absurd to think "we've stumbled on the biggest productivity increase" by changing the math to include commute. If you work 10 hours and are productive for 10 hours, nothing changes regarding workd done whether you commuted 1 hour or not. It's only when you swap 11 hours for 10 that there is a difference. Nothing agaist saving time, but to say that's the biggest productivity increase is stretching it I think.
- bestnameever 6y agoTrue if you are looking at this from the employers view. But as an employee, They'll be less productive in their lives if they require a hour commute to produce 10 hours of work compared to if they didn't.
- unabst 6y agoNo totally. But even from your own perspective, the output of your day is the same, you're being paid the same, which means to the economy you're also the same. So the title of the article is a bit ridiculous. Formatting the title of the article as a question makes it okay?
- yelloweyes 6y agoWho gives a sh-t? What are you going to do with all this productivity? Buy a bunch of garbage you'll use 3 times and then it'll end up in the ocean?
- edjrage 6y agoSeriously, it sickens me that with all the crap that's been going on the #1 worry for many people still seems to be productivity...
- disboy 6y agoYeah, I live alone and I've seen really miserable during this pandemic while my coworkers praise it for their productivity gains. I'm new in the city and the office used to be the place where I could at least get my base of social interaction every day. Without that it's really just tough. And now my coworkers are talking about just closing the office, since they don't 'get anything out of being there'. Well I did get something out of it, it's just sad.
- perl4ever 6y agoProductivity doesn't inherently mean more consumption. It can just as well mean fewer resources for the same or less consumption.
- thehappypm 6y agoMaybe you’ll have more time to read this article
- ric2b 6y agoIncreased productivity is not just useful for consumerism. It might allow us to retire earlier or have shorter work weeks, for example.
- endymi0n 6y agoI don't doubt the main conclusion of the article for certain tasks at least — what I do think is questionable though is using productivity as the only valid metric without controlling for others, including happiness, loneliness, effectiveness and sustainability. For makers of any kind, I think remote work has mainly been a net benefit. There's a lot of developers in our teams who say they're more productive than ever. For me as a technology manager, I'm more exhausted than ever. Video meetings are a pain. Because of this, people switch to asynchronous communication methods, which is definively more effective, but lacks even more personality. Text has many more layers of ambiguity. People get more aggressive and lonely. Misunderstandings rise. My job is to be aware of the emotional undercurrents of arguments and technology and physical distance just seems to get in the way of that. Any forms of creativity that happens in a group, like whiteboarding together, just isn't the same. So yes, I think I'm more productive, at least in some ways. There are some bright sides, also in my private life from being able to work from home that I'm sure to do more of once I'm able to go back to the office. But I haven't ever been as exhausted, lonely or miserable as right now and I simply can't wait to actually have the choice of seeing people in person again.
- bJGVygG7MQVF8c 6y agoThis all rings true but from my vantage point this kind of management ends up introducing excess overhead that makes my work life more fraught with emotional uncertainty rather than less. I avoid it altogether. I don't want anyone, let alone an EM — someone overwhelmingly likely to have below average emotional intelligence relative to the general population — to be probing into my inner life in 1:1s and playing 4D chess orchestrating the team. I've experienced this. It's exhausting. The whole organizational arrangement is misbegotten. Most companies follow it largely out of faddishness and cargo-culting.
- threeseed 6y agoIt makes you wonder if it will change the way people are managed as well. Instead of traditional management it will shift to a purely results-focused style.
- Inthenameofmine 6y ago
- karaterobot 6y ago> If working from home eliminated an hour of commuting, without changing time spent on work or reducing production, the result would be equivalent to a 13% increase in productivity (assuming a 38-hour working work). Maybe I'm just dense, but I've read this sentence 20 times, and it still doesn't make sense. If you aren't changing the time spent on work, where is the productivity gain coming from? Surely they aren't including commute time in calculating worker productivity?
- ssanders82 6y agoI think they're defining "productivity" as a fraction, i.e you used to be able to do 38 hours of work in exchange for 43 hours of your life. Now it's 38 hours of work while only using 38 hours.
- ksaj 6y agoI still remember Dolly Parton singing about how much a drag it was to work 9 to 5. Most offices nowadays require you to work 8:30 to 5:30 and still call it 8 hours. Remote work at least allows some people to effectively regain some of that hour, since you can discount the travel time, and associated costs for parking, gas, etc, or transit.
- briandear 6y ago8:30 to 5:30 with an hour lunch is 8 hours.
- ksaj 6y agoBut when 9-5 was the norm, it was still considered a 40 hour work week. Presumably lunch was paid back then. The song says 9-5 was "enough to drive you crazy if you let it," but nowadays those hours do not represent regular daily office life. I don't recall my parents ever saying "pfft you had such a short work day, Dolly!" so I can only assume that was the normal grind for them, too. If you are working from home, 9-5 is much more feasible. And without going to/from the office, you have more time for more productivity. That's really the only point I was making. I definitely didn't mean for the observation to be thread-worthy on that specific of a detail.
- aphextron 6y agoI'm definitely more productive working from home. But I'm not as happy. Yes commuting sucks. Yes waking up early sucks. But my coworkers were also my friends. I looked forward to having lunch with my team every day. I miss happy hours and book club meetings. I miss having a back and forth casual discussion on some open ended problem we're dealing with. I miss feeling like a part of something larger than myself, rather than just being some guy who wakes up, types code into a laptop, eats dinner, and goes to bed. Maybe this is different for people with families. But I, for one, am dreaming of the day life can go back to normal.
- nvrspyx 6y agoI think it largely depends on the person. For example, as I am someone that's extremely introverted, going to work and interacting with people outside of my duties drains the hell out of me and makes me miserable by the time I get home. The more conciseness of communicating and lack of socializing with coworkers has made me both much happier and more productive. Granted, I'm on the pretty far end of the introvert-extrovert spectrum and am much happier being by myself for extended periods of time, so I'm sure it definitely varies.
- marmaduke 6y ago> interacting with people outside of my duties drains the hell out of me Do you find the interaction universally draining or a matter of consent? I usually detest the interruptions save a few colleagues which I find fun to talk to.
- nvrspyx 6y agoI find pretty much any social interaction draining. It's been a source for my chronic, major depression. While I don't have any issues socializing, like talking to people, keeping a conversation, or making friends, I just really don't like doing any of those things and I would be most happy never doing those things again, if it was viable and acceptable.
- scarface74 6y ago
- fierarul 6y agoThis is the best and worst thing that could happen for remote work. Some discovered something good for them. But many will forever associate work from home with this pandemic house arrest and will get back among people as soon as it's safe plus swear off the whole idea.
- finaliteration 6y agoThis is my concern, as well. We have some people at my place of work saying, “Working from home has been great! I’ve never been more effective and happy at my job.”, and then we have a smaller but more vocal group that says, “I hate working from home and it’s incredibly stressful. I want to go back ASAP.” I worry that the second group will “win” and the pendulum will swing the other way because of the latter group’s experience. What we should really be aiming for is flexibility. Some people can be in the office, some can stay remote. Personally, I dislike being in an office every day, but even more than that I hate the commute. If my manager forces me back, I’ll probably quit and look for a job/company that plans to allow remote work permanently. I’m trying to remain hopeful, however.
- ghaff 6y ago>and then we have a smaller but more vocal group that says, “I hate working from home and it’s incredibly stressful. I want to go back ASAP.” I hope they can get their way as soon as possible--so long as they understand that a lot of their teammates won't want to join them and that the new normal will be less co-located generally. I have zero problem with people who want work-life separation, so long as they don't insist on others to do the same based on their preferences. (I was remote before anyway so it doesn't really affect me. What's missing now is meeting co-workers on trips.)
- ezoe 6y agoUnfortunately, most people are not get used to the efficient communication by text chat. That's why we are using the inefficient time-wasting communication by video chat. If we were to truly increase the productivity with the remote work, we must abandon the video chat. But most companies relies heavily on face-to-face communication so it doesn't happen in our generation.
- bvaldivielso 6y agoWhat makes you say that face-to-face never is the most efficient way of communication? I would be quite surprised if text-chat was ever proven to be the only kind of communication needed in the context of work.
- esperent 6y agoI have worked from home as a freelancer for several years now. A big part of my communication with clients involves politely deflecting constant requests to video chat. It usually goes like this: Client: explains problem that I understand perfectly in two sentences. Client: "but maybe we can jump on a quick chat so I can explain this" Then I have to come up with some way to deflect the request because I know the "quick" chat will take at least an hour (maybe 30 minutes actually chatting, but one hour productivity cost). If it's a quick fix, I usually just don't reply for a few hours and then send them the fix. If they are persistent, I bill them for the time spent chatting. But I'd rather spend that time being productive. On the other hand, I feel it's important to have one longish video chat with a client when I start a new project, because that gives me a connection to the person.
- Supermancho 6y ago> most people are not get used to the efficient communication by text chat. Text is a terrible way to communicate compared to video (or better, in person). The ability to ad-hoc illustrate (picture worth a thousand words), rephrase/clarify, and use context-specific language necessitates some sort of face to face interaction. Try dating using only text messages, it's pointless. Humans require most than literal communication to coordinate in groups.
- rspeele 6y agoI'm less productive working from home. I'm confident some people are more productive working from home. There's no one-size-fits-all solution.