6 ms·
Also living in europe: > Kids should be taught practical life skills over random trivia. This is parenting vs schooling, ignoring the fact that many schools a
by maccard 6y ago
Also living in europe:
> Kids should be taught practical life skills over random trivia.
This is parenting vs schooling, ignoring the fact that many schools are really glorifed babysitting services.
And more importantly, history isn't "random trivia". While the merits of a degree in history may be debatable, if the majority of the UK had a passable knowledge in why the EU exists, and what the UK did to become an empire, the attitude towards integration with the EU would likely be very different.
> PE in my school didn't teach any theory, which is just stupid looking back.
PE is the bare minimum amount of exercise and movement a child could have without being considered "entirely sedantry". For many kids it's the _only_ exercise they get.
- levosmetalo 6y ago> And more importantly, history isn't "random trivia". While the merits of a degree in history may be debatable, if the majority of the UK had a passable knowledge in why the EU exists, and what the UK did to become an empire, the attitude towards integration with the EU would likely be very different. As much as I agree with other points, I can only strongly disagree here. It strongly implies a condescending attitude that stupid and uneducated decided about British future. If only they could be brainwashed^H taught they would choose the “right” option.
- jonp888 6y agoWell, I strongly disagree with you strong disagreeing. It's not condescending in the slightest, and debate around Brexit revealed that although theres's nothing wrong with being against european integration, a lot of people have almost no idea of what the EU does and does not do.
- maccard 6y agoI never claimed brainwashed, uneducated or stupid. Far from it. But many major important parts of british history are glossed over. Much of the empire is taught as though britain was a trading partner rather than brutal occupier, the Irish plantations are glossed over as an unavoidable famine, ww1/2 are celebrated as the strength of the empire, and the postwar agreements and decisions which led to the current EU are mentioned in a sentence. These are massively important periods which directly explain huge parts of britain's "influence" over the rest of the world, and the information is available quite publicly, just never taught to children. If people at large understood what happened and why we have the institutions we currently have, they are shown to be far more likely to be in favour of them.
- vixen99 6y agoI wonder if you have really tried to understand the intellectual case for Brexit. Your 'if people at large ... ' is merely an exercise in wishful thinking. For serious analyses of the Brexit question by extremely well equipped academics (I rather think they 'understand') and others try https://briefingsforbritain.co.uk/ https://briefingsforbritain.co.uk/
- regularfry 6y agoIt would be unfortunate here to mistakenly leave the impression that briefingsforbritain.co.uk is in some way neutral. Until the start of this year they used to be called "Briefings for Brexit". The content on the site is rampantly partisan. It would also be regrettable if one were to look at their academic qualifications as being somehow indicative of the quality of their arguments, rather than the quality of their rhetoric.
- ThePadawan 6y agoWell then there's not much E in the PE, is there? I completely agree that the physical activity is important, but then let's not pretend that it's educative when it isn't.
- geomark 6y agoI guess YMMV, because at my school (a long time ago) we learned a new sport each term. And it took the better part of the term for the average kid to achieve some level of competency, much like an academic subject. It's certainly different in nature than academics, but you still need to "educate" your brain to arrive at the correct movement, timing and balance for any sport.
- ThePadawan 6y agoI've moved past my bitter feelings about the failings of my sports education. It feels like PE was 2-3 years of gymnastics followed by 6-7 years of "let's just play basketball/volleyball/soccer" with a semester of swimming here-and-there. Certainly no instructions or structure to any of it. As a fat kid, I was always the happiest when sitting out entirely (or swimming, where it turns out natural buoyancy is actually helpful). Always getting Ds and Fs and being chosen last for any team activity led to me spend my college years on the couch. Only through getting back pain and posture problems I found out 5 years later that I enjoy jogging and yoga and weightlifting and isometric exercise - if properly instructed. It feels like I missed out on the years in between simply because PE at school never had the goal of helping kids be healthy - just keeping them busy in any way possible.
- maccard 6y agoIf I had to guess, I'd bet that the majority of kids were happy to kick a football around, and the 2-3 that woild be happy doing something else (i.e us) were just outnumbered. As a teacher, would you rather have 2-3 kids complaining about soccer or 15 kids complaining about yoga because they've never done it?
- 6y ago
- pawelmurias 6y ago> PE is the bare minimum amount of exercise and movement a > child could have without being considered "entirely > sedantry". For many kids it's the _only_ exercise they get. A study has shown that PE in schools have show it has zero benefits and only teaches some kinds to skip classes.
- KineticLensman 6y ago> A study has shown that ... You'll need a slightly stronger argument to meaningfully shape this debate
- rhn_mk1 6y ago> history isn't "random trivia" The discipline isn't, but the way at least I've been taught it unfortunately is... It didn't take me until I graduated to take an interest in history, when I could learn the cause and effect chains without getting distracted by rote memorization.
- jimcsharp 6y agoDo you think what makes you interested in [topic] now would've been relevant when you were a child? If I'm being honest with myself, my answer is probably no. "If only they taught _" for me, can be boiled down to "If only I was 30 in grade school"
- rhn_mk1 6y agoWhen it comes to history... yes, there's a large overlap. The ancient times, the history of philosophy due to the development of ideas, the recent modern times due to their relevance to today's neighborhood politics, are three topics that I am constantly interested in. With the exception of ancient history (maybe due to the dearth of established dates), school had problems teaching me those.
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoThere are huge problems with locking an age cohort with wildly different interests, talents, abilities, and personalities into a room and expecting them to go through puberty together while also learning... something. Even if you select for ability along some axis, you still get different interests and learning styles - and personalities. Learning is basically industrial, uselessly abstracted [1] and commodified, when it could be individualised. A lot of talent is wasted because high school stunts the really bright kids. And given how brutal it is, it seems to damage everyone emotionally. [1] Virtually none of the math you learn at school really makes any sense unless you're one of the small number of people who go into STEM - which is where you finally discover what it's for. Things are a bit better than they used to be, but basic financial math as a specific competence is far more useful to most of the population than even the most basic algebra and trig.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- KMnO4 6y ago> This is parenting vs schooling We (collectively) want all children to have a good foundation of life skills by the time they reach adulthood. Unfortunately there is no curriculum for what a parent must teach their children. Luckily, there is a standardized curriculum in the form of schooling. Instead of assuming all children get good parents (which is obviously a harmful assumption), let’s just take advantage of the fact that we can pretty much guarantee all students will learn the school curriculum and use it to teach important life skills to children who otherwise wouldn’t learn.
- maccard 6y agoChildren only have a certain amount of time in school. We can't just keep adding subjects that everyone needs to learn. Kids already spend a massive amount of time in school and on homework, so something's got to give if we want to add to the curriculum.
- emteycz 6y agoRight, don't forget that we can remove things too, though
- KMnO4 6y agoLife skills are not completely disjoint from current curriculum subjects. You don't need to dedicate an hour every day to a class called "Life skills" (and if you did I suspect many children would pay less attention). Why not use that math class to teach personal finance, mortgage rates, basic economics, etc. Why not couple English with a stronger focus on proper communication (especially negotiation, conflict resolution) etc. Teachers are given a document that says in X weeks you need to cover the following topics/units. Let's fix that document so that we can ensure everyone who graduates the public school system can confidently understand their credit card statement -- regardless of their parental upbringing.
- maccard 6y agoI get your point, but the issue is that people don't grok the link between the fundamentals and day-to-day life. > Let's fix that document so that we can ensure everyone who graduates the public school system can confidently understand their credit card statement I'm pretty sure by age 14 my school math problems were along the lines of "John takes out a loan for $x, with a compounding interest rate of Y%, how much does he pay back in total?" I agree that we could do better at teaching however!
- BurningFrog 6y ago> ignoring the fact that many schools are really glorifed babysitting services I think you need to face this fact to understand schooling in 2020.
- pjc50 6y agoIn 2020 specifically quite a lot of schooling has happened with the kids being quarantined at home. It's been quite messy, especially at the margins, but it provides a sort of natural experiment on what's actually going on.
- watwut 6y agoThere seems to be huge resentment on this site over the fact that kids being in school allows one of parents to get employment. No, it really does not mean the babysitting is the only or primary function and it is definitely not something bad. And if quarantine changed anything, it is that I value school more then before. And I am not one of those people desperate to somehow making remote school and work function, thankfully we had no stressful deadlines during that time. But the kids still missed it and still learned better when in school then home alone.
- benhurmarcel 6y agoWell it's not a bad thing. It's just a fact that working parents need somebody to handle their kids for about 10 hours a day.
- BurningFrog 6y agoYeah, all I'm saying is that pretending school is a purely education institution is awkward at best. It's better if school policy can be discussed admitting it has two main purposes.
- spanktheuser 6y ago> This is parenting vs schooling, ignoring the fact that many schools are really glorifed babysitting services. While this may exaggerate the case, it will continue to largely be true so long as we relegate huge portions of our population to 2-3 jobs while the VC system sustained in part by Ycombinator rewards capital formation to a degree that is damaging to society.
- luckylion 6y agoThe previous two comments mentioned Europe, where "multiple fulltime jobs" is essentially unheard of.
- tauchunfall 6y agoNot multiple fulltime jobs, but in Germany there are 3.5 million people with multiple jobs (350,000 with jobs subject to social insurance contributions "sozialversicherungspflichtig"; 250,000 with "mini-jobs"). More than 50% in a poll give financial issues as the critical factor why they have multiple jobs.
- k1t 6y agoI think multiple "fulltime jobs" is extremely rare. Usually when people say they are working 2-3 jobs I believe they mean they get a couple of shifts a week from a couple of different employers. E.g. 16 hours a week at a coffee shop, 12 hours a week at a restaurant and 2 nights a week as a cleaner.
- luckylion 6y agoThat would sum up to one full-time job, more or less? I understood the comment to be angry about some large injustice, I'm not sure whether they were meaning to essentially say "some people have to work for a living, it's outrageous". With (Western) Europe's extremely strong social systems, the number of people who are forced to work multiple jobs because they wouldn't be able to eat otherwise is minuscule, I believe.
- viraptor 6y agoThe history curriculum really matters and it's almost impossible to generalise over. Mine was ok in the primary school and then degraded to "which army led by whom moved where (occasionally why)". Took me years to realise that if you learn more about the progress of wars than the reasons they started, it's worse than wasted time.
- awinder 6y agoPhysical Education is very much a “get out of it what you put into it” sort of thing, really like any class. And there’s going to be regional/world differences. It’s also partially there for the student athletes, in order for there to be job infrastructure and education/training. Source: father was a physical educator for 40ish years and is a good man The financial education and time management lines really resonated with me from the parent comment. The problem is that there is not anything resembling equal footing at home. Rich kids, realistically the top 5-10%, are going to get financial education at home and the others will have to learn in the school of hard knocks. I had to learn “tough” lessons about finance because the resources for what I needed to know didn’t exist at home. And I talk to people now who are older about how they prep their kids for the world, and it’s just a classic information imbalance. You could do a lot of good by leveling the playing field here.
- ip26 6y agoget out of it what you put into it Physical Education wasn't my favorite class, but never once did anyone talk about the theory behind developing athletic performance or recruiting the proper muscles for a movement or anything like that. It was just "go run" or "play a game of baseball".
- superhuzza 6y agoIn my opinion, you can still get a lot out of PE just by doing it even with little instruction. Being made to play basketball will almost certainly develop team-working skills, hand-eye coordination, fitness etc, with no involvement from the teacher. But I agree that there is some lost potential in terms of building a strong knowledge base about fitness and well-being. The paper below suggests there are likely a lot of moderating factors in the benefits of PE. https://sci-hub.tw/https://doi.org/10.1080/02671520701809817 https://sci-hub.tw/https://doi.org/10.1080/02671520701809817
- jahewson 6y agoWhen 2008 happened I realised that my parent’s generation knows close to nothing about the modern financial system. Meanwhile they prevent my generation from building houses and rob our pensions.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 6y ago> This is parenting vs schooling, ignoring the fact that many schools are really glorifed babysitting services. Modern school systems are pretty much entirely this... only they aren't really glorified. To be fair, a society in which every adult is expected to be working needs some kind of daycare for kids, but there are probably better ways to go about it.
- bawolff 6y agoHistory is not random trivia any more than math is memorizing random formulas.
- alexbanks 6y agoIf the applications of mathematics are not made clear, it is quite literally memorizing random formulas. Which is exactly the scenario you'd find in most public high schools in america. Which, that sentiment applies directly to history.
- Nasrudith 6y agoParenting vs schooling seems like a mistake to divide in that way. If everyone is expected to know it then it should be taught period, otherwise it is left to the "random" potentially lacking the abilities themselves let alone the ability to teach them.