17 ms·
For anyone (cough, elderly parents) who aren't adept at discovering hidden features You don't even have to be elderly. The 20-somethings in the office (pre-pa
by reaperducer 6y ago
For anyone (cough, elderly parents) who aren't adept at discovering hidden features
You don't even have to be elderly.
The 20-somethings in the office (pre-pandemic) had no idea that on an inconsistent smattering of Apple apps, if you pull down, a hidden search bar magically appears.
How did that conversation go?
Dev: Where do you want the search bar to go?
Designer: Put it somewhere that no one will ever see it, or ever think to look for it.
Who thought that was a good idea?
I think people in the SV/HN bubble play the "what about the elderly?" card too often, because we're afraid to admit that we, too, don't know how stuff works anymore.
- frereubu 6y agoI couldn't agree more. I once had a really interesting conversation with an accessibility person who said in passing "accessibility is for everyone". He didn't make a big point of it, but it really stuck with me, and I'm always reminded of it when I see things like this. I've been working in the digital world since the late 90s, keep everything up to date, have a recent iPhone etc. etc. etc. and I'm stil occasionally stumped by things like how to turn on repeat in Apple Music on my phone.
- andi999 6y agoGot a new android phone (i think it was huawei), couldnt answer calls. I was thinking I as always has to press or slide the green phone icon, but actually had to move the center grey icon on the green phone icon.
- toastal 6y agoSpeaking of Android, I used my phone as a hotspot for over a year. When I dropped my phone and the screen broke, while I waited for a replacement screen to DIY, I was able to use ADB to navigate to the assistive tools that would screen read. With that I was able to toggle on and off some settings relade to keeping the hotspot on and churning. Accessibility can help normal people in extraordinary situations too.
- pvorb 6y agoOh yeah, this took me several missed calls until I figured it out. I wonder how that UI element emerged.
- Macuyiko 6y agoI was planning to reply to your parent comment that discoverability has always been an issue for me when I work with Apple devices. Whenever I use my wife's iPhone or Mac for a couple of minutes, I get frustrated because everything is all over the place, none of the apps work well together, and everything is hidden. Back on Android, (or Windows, or Linux), it makes sense, whereas she loses her way. Just to point out, a part of discoverability I guess is familiarity with the underlying principles the UI follows as well. To add two more points to this. I think there's one thing platforms in general got very right: simple touch controls. My one year old is discovering that sliding fingers across a screen, touching and pinching (the three basics) does stuff. Hidden menus, press-and-hold, and so on is secondary. Second, icons are something which is wrong. You need to guess their initial meaning, and translate badly in conversations, like recently with my mom: "press the rectangle with four arrows pointing out of it" (fullscreen or whatever it was).
- contextfree 6y agoI appreciated the Windows Phone 7/8 and early Win10 approach to compact icons which was/is: Just have a button next to the icons that expands them to show labels when you press it. Unfortunately later redesigns to Win10 apps seemed to drift away from these patterns towards just having unlabeled icons everywhere.
- phil294 6y agoSounds interesting, do you happen to have an image of this available? I was not able to find any more information about it
- contextfree 6y agoHere's a tour of the application bar control (which follows this pattern) from the Windows Phone 8 days: https://www.c-sharpcorner.com/UploadFile/1e050f/application-bar-in-windows-phone-8-application/ https://www.c-sharpcorner.com/UploadFile/1e050f/application-... Windows 10 introduced the navigation bar, which is essentially a vertical version of the Windows Phone application bar, just using a "three lines" icon as the "show labels" button instead of an ellipsis. https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/uwp/design/controls-and-patterns/navigationview https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/uwp/design/controls... The start menu and inbox mail app use this control, for example.
- teddyh 6y agoAccessibility makes things easier not only for those who need it, but, somewhat surprisingly, also for quite a lot of people who wouldn’t normally think of themselves as even needing or wanting any help. This is usually referred to as the Curb Cut Effect, and has been extensively discussed.
- saurik 6y agoI had actually thought Apple might have removed the Repeat functionality when I upgraded iOS a few years ago; when someone else showed me how to do it--which involved scrolling the entire app to find some new hidden features--it felt more like a prank than real software :/.
- specialist 6y agoThis is a very Donald Norman idea. With examples given like curb cuts for wheelchairs helping everyone, and OXO brand kitchen utensils meant for impaired hands just being better for everyone. Better is better.
- baggy_trough 6y agoEven worse than undiscoverable features are land mine features, where some subtle gesture triggers a wild and unwanted mode change. Extra credit if the mode change is hard to get out of.
- narag 6y agoWindows keys started the nightmare for me decades ago. So nice hitting one of those while gaming full-screen! This conversation happened a thousand times: "but you can hit them again and restore what you were doing"... no, I can't, specially if I have pressed a dozen keys since. I used to buy IBM keyboards from more civilized times, but my dealer disappeared, maybe he was arrested?
- makecheck 6y agoMy favorite is when I use control-L to clear the screen on a terminal and hit Windows-L by accident to lock the entire laptop.
- chrisco255 6y agoGet you a gaming keyboard with a Windows key lock.
- jasomill 6y agoBetter yet, use any keyboard you like, and remap (left) Windows to a different key code, ideally corresponding to some key that's not present on your current keyboard layout and that, unlike the Windows key, is fully remappable by AutoHotkey, in-game options, etc., using something like https://github.com/randyrants/sharpkeys https://github.com/randyrants/sharpkeys
- narag 6y agoI don't play much lately, but I do have a Keyz Iridium. It was the cheapest mechanic keyboard I found, at least what feels more similar to mechanic. Don't get me wrong, the trippy colours are nice too. And... it has a combo to disable Windows keys!! Thank you very much :)
- DonaldPShimoda 6y agoPretty sure the Apple search bars used to be discoverable. When you first opened an app (like Messages), the search bar would be visible by default and you had to scroll down to hide it. Over time, they started hiding it by default and require you to scroll up to access it. I think that, at a general level, this principle of development is reasonable: things that used to require being extremely explicit can become more implicit over time as users become adapted to it. Computers used to feature tons of skeuomorphic design to make it obvious what everything was (so you could think about your computer with the same lens as you thought about your desk, for instance), and now we've mostly done away with that because the vast majority of users don't need it. Where Apple fails in this regard is two things, I think: 1. They assume prior familiarity among groups who won't have it. 2. They do not leave any affordances to even suggest the presence of something hidden for those who won't know it (or have forgotten). For the scroll bar issue, I think they could introduce an affordance in the form of, say, a couple small horizontal bars at the top of the page that kind of indicate "you can pull down on this". While early versions of this same design were pretty large and could be considered intrusive, I think users are familiar enough with the "tactile" touchscreen elements that we could develop a smaller version to use for these things. --- Your point in general still stands, though. Apple has become more and more egregious about this over time. Things used to be very discoverable, and now there's tons of hidden functionality in most of their apps (both mobile and desktop). I think they've succumbed to more feature creep over the past couple of decades than they want to admit.
- saagarjha 6y agoBack when search bars were table view headers, you had to do non-trivial work to hide them by default (which Apple did anyways, because Apple). With iOS 11 search controllers can integrate directly into the navigation bar, and in that case the search bar will be collapsed by default.
- marv3lls 6y agoIntegrate directly? Like is there a magnifying glass icon or ANYTHING to make it discoverable? Or do I just have to guess I should scroll up in i.e. Settings? cough Thanks, Apple.
- dehrmann 6y agoI haven't used Snapchat, but I've heard it has a lot of features like that. I wonder if it's a UX trend that's creeping into places it doesn't belong.
- munchbunny 6y agoI openly admit it these days. If I had a VCR today I'd be the one struggling to figure out how to record something with it, even though as a kid I loved that stuff. And I'm only in my 30's. It's not really about whether I'm able to figure it out (if 8 year old me could figure it out, 30+ year old should be able to as well), it's about whether I have the patience for a badly designed UI. One of the common responses I see when I complain about a bad UI is someone saying "no it's easy you just do ____". It's frustrating because that's not the point - the point is that I had to do research to find the answer! There are cases, especially with specialized tools for complex tasks, where you are expected to spend time learning how to use the tool effectively. Photoshop is a great example. Vim is a great example. Figuring out stupid stuff like whether that grayish light blue vs dark gray fill on the checkbox means "enabled" or "disabled" is not an example.
- Viliam1234 6y agoI am sometimes amazed how complicated UI can someone create with e.g. four arrows and two extra buttons. Like, I would naively assume that the arrows would move your selection up, down, left, right, and one of the extra buttons would be "select/confirm" and the other would be "escape". But no, that would be too easy. Depending on exact position in the menu, sometimes the right arrow, sometimes the first extra button, and sometimes the second extra button selects the highlighted thing. Sometimes up and down arrows increase the selected thing (e.g. volume, brightness) and you need to press one of the extra buttons to stop doing it. Sometimes one of those extra buttons acts as a hotkey that will switch you to a completely different menu, so it will take five minutes to navigate back. Then sometimes a confirmation windows opens, with two buttons "yes" and "no", one of them is pink and another is light blue, if you press any of the four arrows, the colors switch, and you are free to make your guess whether pressing the extra button will confirm the pink option, confirm the light blue option, take you to a completely different place, or turn off the menu.
- projektfu 6y agoMonitor buttons are particularly awesome. Often you can't even see what you're pressing because it's behind the bezel or just an unmarked capsense location, and then whether it's up, down, increase, decrease, forward, back, reset, etc. is all different for each page of settings. Bonus points: turn the monitor to portrait mode and do it sideways.
- SebastianKra 6y agoThis has been changed in most iOS 14 Apps. (I checked Mail, Notes, Files and Reminders. The Settings-App still hides it) It's a leftover from when iPhone screens where much smaller: https://postimg.cc/WFdqPwfd https://postimg.cc/WFdqPwfd
- fizzled 6y agoOn the plus side, we don't really know what the limits of bad UX/UI patterns are until we cross that line. No one can deny that UX/UI patterns are in the Cambrian Explosion phase (for at least the past 15 years and going strong!), and it will take time for the more robust evolutionary designs to emerge. Example: Consider the number of articles on HN devoted to seemingly minute detail, e.g.: whether or not an input element should use a placeholder that vanishes, one that shrinks into the upper left corner when the user starts to enter text or a label abve the input element. We're still figuring this out...
- danso 6y agoMy suspicion is that Apple’s design mentality is to strive toward the minimalist ideal of an interface in which everything necessary fits on one (phone) screen, and users are acclimated to ask Siri for anything/everything else, e.g. “Siri show me a print/download dialog”
- baggy_trough 6y agoUsing Siri is like working in boxing gloves that randomly smash you in the face. It's trained me to avoid it at all costs.
- squiggleblaz 6y agoI use Google Assistant for the only thing it's good for: setting a timer. Even then, for some reason, half the time I say "ten minute timer", it hears only "ten minutes" and for some reason thinks I want it to search youtube for a video of a ten minute countdown. I mean, that's completely insane. Dear Google developers: if you decide to randomly delete a somewhat irrelevant word from a search query and you're left with "ten minute", it's far more likely that a person wants a ten minute timer than that they want to search your database of videos for ten minutes. Also, why do you search youtube instead of the web? Are you doing this specifically to irritate the hell out of me?
- danso 6y agoYep, setting times is easily 95% of my requests to Alexa. The other 5% is either asking about the weather, or joke questions like: "how many fathoms is it to proxima centauri"
- noodlenotes 6y agoBeing tech savvy can be a burden when it comes to discovering new features because you're afraid of making a "stupid" mistake. Accidentally posting to Facebook is something the tech illiterate do, not us, so why would we click a random icon when we're not sure if it will do something embarrassing? I know my willingness to explore UIs went down a lot when 1) All the buttons became icons instead of text that clearly explained what was going to happen and 2) My phone became the place where all of my social media accounts were always logged in and all my internet activity was centralized. It became easy to accidentally share between different worlds.
- temporallobe 6y ago> It became easy to accidentally share between different worlds. This has burned me more times than I’d like to admit. I have a macbook for work and activated iMessages for my personal account. One day I accidentally posted something in a chat room meant for someone I was chatting with in iMessages. It was kind of personal but thankfully vague enough that I could brush it off. I also was on some screensharing sessions when I switched to iMessages which briefly showed personal conversations. After a few times of that happening I disabled my iMessages account for on that machine and made it a personal rule to never mix business and personal activity on any company-issued device, which has served me well over the years.
- SilasX 6y agoYes! I've lost count of how many times I've e.g. opened Google Calendar from my current Gmail window and have it pull up the calendar on a different account with no warning that it's doing that. (If I'm not logged in on the other, it asks me to log in with no option to go to the original.) Somehow they made it impossible to specify or indicate the account in the URL to squash any uncertainty, you just have to hope the cookies are right.
- apetresc 6y agoIt's actually worse than that - the account is indicated in the URL, but it's expressed as an offset into a list of accounts in the order you signed into them! So a ".../mail/u/0/" means the first Google account you're logged into, ".../mail/u/1/" means the second, etc. But if you did it in a different order on a different machine (or even browser), it'll redirect to a completely different one. I would love to have been a fly on the wall in the meeting where it was decided that was a good idea.
- rapind 6y agoI do think age can play a role, or rather experience. As you live through more UI churn the less your willing to invest time into each new UI generation or fad. If an application isn't either essential to me or incredibly obvious to use, I am unlikely to learn it's fancy new UI. Why bother? This extends to APIs and DSLs too since there are often so short lived.
- notacoward 6y agoIt might be not so much age as experience. With experience comes expectations of what a control should look like and how it should behave. * It's the experienced users who were were less likely to recognize the "burger menu" or the three dots (does that have a catchy name) as something potentially useful. They didn't look like "real" controls. It was the less experienced users who just naturally tried clicking on anything near the top that looked interesting, or waving the cursor around looking for hovertext on active components. * Confronted with a landing page that seems to have nothing more than some splashy graphics and a few words - notably no scrollbars - experienced users are likely to wonder if the page is broken for them (because that was a very common experience at the height of the browser wars and still persists). Less experienced users who grew up with smartphones are more likely to start swiping right away. A user who was older but not experienced with computers would align more closely with the young 'uns on most of this. When everything's completely new you just start experimenting. It's when you think you know things work but they don't work that way any more that things start to get frustrating.
- majewsky 6y ago> As you live through more UI churn the less your willing to invest time into each new UI generation or fad. Hell yes. In most instances, I'm way beyond this point at only 30 years old. Come to think of it, it actually makes me wonder how I will feel about UIs at 50 or 60 years old.
- foxtrottbravo 6y agoHeck, I'm know my tech and I can't figure out how to reliably get Safari on IOS to display the bar at the bottom. Makes me crazy
- snypox 6y agoScroll down.
- CarbyAu 6y agoNot parent; your comment made me think, is that?: - swipe down from anywhere in the vague middle of the page? - swipe down on the right hand edge where an "invisble until you need it" scrollbar might be lurking? - swipe down at the "not quite the top/bottom edge of the screen" because you don't want the OS swipe, you want the app swipe. Aarrrgh! I don't even have an iPhone and the options drive me crazy.
- wnevets 6y ago>I think people in the SV/HN bubble play the "what about the elderly?" card too often, because we're afraid to admit that we, too, don't know how stuff works anymore. Perhaps but even when I don't know how an app works I can usually figure it out, either by trying different things or just googling. Older generations tend to be afraid of "breaking" the device and avoid doing anything they dont already know.
- stan_rogers 6y agoNo, they're not "afraid of 'breaking' the device", they simply don't have time for that shit. And there is absolutely no excuse for that shit. If you're writing the latest descendant of Myst, sure, go for it. If it's not an adventure game, there should be no essence of adventure game in the ingredients list. At all. Ever.
- wnevets 6y ago>No, they're not "afraid of 'breaking' the device", they simply don't have time for that shit. When the older folks in my life tell me exactly that I take their word for it. They usually they no issue being brutally honest about other aspects of life.
- myself248 6y agoOr, swipe-sideways on SMS and that's how you can see timestamps! It all sucks. I'm convinced that devs are trying to frustrate me, and it's working. Don't get me started on the icons-without-text design shit.
- SilasX 6y agoOh wow! Thanks! I never knew that. I thought that info just wasn't accessible. It should be always visible ... at least, for the most recent message, since you'll want to know how old it is. Side note, I've always suspected it's an issue of too many cooks in the kitchen. They spend tons on UX but end up with something barely usable.
- epistasis 6y agoThis idea of "reducing clutter" is just ridiculous... we should be focused on accessible information density, not low-information displays.
- strbean 6y agoExcessive information can be overwhelming. I fully hate these design decisions, but I can see where the original drive to reduce clutter came from. This seems like "way too much of a good thing" rather than an outright bad thing.
- marshray 6y ago> swipe-sideways on SMS WHAT?!
- strogonoff 6y agoOnce you discover once that swiping sideways on a message reveals metadata, you notice that this is transferrable to most messengers on iOS (all I use). The first time I discovered that was by accident while playing with the device. I notice that I pretty much never use this feature.
- 6y ago
- HenryBemis 6y ago+1 on that. I had to use a Win10 machine with Chrome. And stupid Chrome has default to open PDF files, while my machine downloads the PDF. On Chrome I could't get the button to appear so I can save the PDF on my drive. Completely frustrating.
- kbenson 6y agoThere's a language to UIs that evolves over time. The menu hamburger, the on/off circle with a line. Take those back a decade or more and you would have the same problems, but eventually they percolate through people's experiences and expectations and you can rely on people knowing what they are now, for the most part (it helps that the on/off icon is used for physical devices too). Pull down for search is something that it maybe Apple is trying to cement (and only for mobile, I guess?), but hasn't crossed (and maybe won't) to Android devices. Apple is known for doing stuff like this and pushing changes, sometimes it takes, sometimes it doesn't (e.g. no floppy in laptops, no CD-ROM in laptops, no Mic jack, etc)
- jchw 6y agoThe reason why they pull the "what about the elderly?" card is simple. Most of us can figure it out, even if it's stupid. My parents however have a much, much harder time trying to figure out how to do something that is counter-intuitive. It's more about problem solving and experience with existing user interfaces than anything else. Designers nowadays definitely design things in a manner that suggests they assume some pre-existing knowledge of UI patterns.
- mark-r 6y agoI'm embarrassed to admit how long it took me to realize what the hamburger button did. Designers just started assuming everybody knew.
- mulmen 6y agoWe have an internal app at work that only has a hamburger button. It makes me sad every time I click on it.
- squiggleblaz 6y agoYou mean the entire user interface is blank, except for three lines? And then you get to decide what you're going to do in the app?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- armandososa 6y agoI am a UI spelunker. I right-click, option-click, dobule-clicke, force-press every little interface element and I am so happy when the software delights me with a surprising feature. I type the konami code as soon as I discover a web app supports keyboard input. I have no problem pulling-to-reveal and shaking to undo. In fact, it makes me feel awesome to know all this little secrets and have people all like: Wait! how did you do that? But when I design software I don't do it for people like me. I want my users to feel awesome and delighted without being UI spelunkers. Good design doesn't make you think.
- dmkolobov 6y agoI’m 28, and I don’t know how to use most apps and websites anymore, and I’m a web developer. My intro to computers was when I was 6 years old, and I was trying to install games on Windows 95 in a language I didn’t understand(English). The consistency of the layouts was the only thing that made that work. So many of my childhood experiences with computers relied on consistent spatial representations. Kids seem to do just fine learning all these unique UI’s, but I can’t help but feel like there’s a loss of “general computing capability”, for lack of a better term?
- totetsu 6y agoI know what you mean. I had so many experiences as a young person figuring out my own and others computer problems but just sort of knowing where to click, and how many times, or how many seconds to hold the button.. resetting the screen resolution with just the keyboard when you couldn't see anything, getting out of crashed full screen windows with "alt+space down M move the mouse"..
- Aeolun 6y agoA while ago I had a discussion about our UI with our designer, and when I mentioned that nothing seems to work as you’d expect, he said he wants people to learn a unique way of dealing with our interface. It boggles my mind how that is something you could actively want.
- sadok 6y agoAs a designer, I'm ashamed of reading this. This is the opposite of what designers are supposed to do. UI is not art, you can't just do whatever you want. You need to abide by user patterns and conventions, because our job is to get people from A to B in the most efficient way possible. Period. Your designer is just bad.
- squiggleblaz 6y agoBut "designers" are surely understood to be engineers. This problem exists because the company creates positions for designers. If positions were created for usability engineers, we'd get a completely different outcome. (I wish repeating this over and over on social media would cause it to happen.)
- nikanj 6y ago> Who thought that was a good idea? A designer. Probably the same person who wanted to turn links from blue-and-underlined to same uniform gray with zero indication
- burntoutfire 6y ago> I think people in the SV/HN bubble play the "what about the elderly?" card too often, because we're afraid to admit that we, too, don't know how stuff works anymore. I suspect I don't know some crucial (in Apple designers' mind) swipes on my iOS devices, because they're just hard to discover.