15 ms·
>> Textbooks state that, in the absence of a minimum wage, a worker is paid his “marginal product of labour”, which means the value of what he produces. This s
by aidenn0 6y ago
>> Textbooks state that, in the absence of a minimum wage, a worker is paid his “marginal product of labour”, which means the value of what he produces.
This sentence is just wrong. First of all a rational actor will not intentionally pay a worker the value of their production; you get no profit.
Textbooks actually say that a worker will be paid no more than the marginal product of labor, and if labor is in short supply, they will be paid very close to their marginal product of labor. If there are a huge number of workers willing to work for $5/hr then workers won't tend to make even a penny more than this.
Information asymmetry and differences in negotiating power will further distort this, but the initial premise is already a strawman of basic microeconomics.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- rbanffy 6y ago> First of all a rational actor will not intentionally pay a worker the value of their production; you get no profit. That's true for a single employee, but you don't need to make a profit out of every single employee. If you do, your CEO will be extremely underpaid in relation to the rest of the market.
- aidenn0 6y agoI am willing to work as the CEO of Walmart for say $750k per year. The fact that I don't work there means that either: 1. Voting Walmart shareholders think that the having Doug McMillon for $24M/year is a better deal than having me for $750k/year 2. Voting Walmart shareholders are unaware that reasonably intelligent people with no executive experience are willing to work for a lot less than McMillon. 3. There are other forces at play; e.g. CEOs as Veblen goods or good-old-fashioned corruption. Maybe the board members are also C level employees (at different companies) and they are colluding to keep the C level compensation high. #2 seems rather unlikely so pick one of #1 and #3. #1 Certainly does not contradict my use of intentionally, since they believe that McMillon
- efxhoy 6y ago>> Textbooks state that, in the absence of a minimum wage, a worker is paid his “marginal product of labour”, which means the value of what he produces. > This sentence is just wrong. First of all a rational actor will not intentionally pay a worker the value of their production; you get no profit. In the econ 101 textbook simplified free market that the author is refering to firms do not make any economic profit. If a firm in a free market is turning an economic profit more firms will enter that market, raising supply, lowering price and driving profits to zero.
- crdrost 6y agoThis this this, so much this. The economic definition is for a “perfectly competitive market,” one with extremely low barriers to entry. And one of the arguments about these markets is that they are the least profitable markets because firms in a less-profitable market will want to jump the extremely low barriers to switch into that market; this dilutes per-firm profits in the competitive market and concentrates them in the less-competitive market. Economists consider those least-profits an “opportunity cost” of spending your time in the first place, and if you include that as an explicit cost then the “profit” is indeed zero.
- dmalvarado 6y agoAs an econ major, I've come to the conclusion that the dismal science is equal parts making models and explaining why they don't work.
- mkoubaa 6y agothe dismal science is too generous
- onionisafruit 6y ago“The dismal science” is an established name for economics. Similar to the sweet science or the gay science.
- 6y ago
- dpedu 6y ago>> Textbooks state that, in the absence of a minimum wage, a worker is paid his “marginal product of labour”, which means the value of what he produces. > This sentence is just wrong. First of all a rational actor will not intentionally pay a worker the value of their production; you get no profit. It's correct. You're assuming whatever the worker produces is sold at cost.
- shirakawasuna 6y agoNo? If value isn't defined as the price at which the product is selling (could easily be above cost), what is it in basic econ? 1. Worker(s) make a thing. 2. Worker(s) sell a thing. 3. All the above worker(s) (if there's more than one) receive a portion of the proceeds. If it reflects their actual contribution to that thing at its selling price, it's their marginal product of labor, putting aside things like reinvestment and power imbalances. This leaves nothing left over for profits, for owners / investors to take, who did not contribute the labor to production (otherwise, they'd also be workers and we'd call that part of their compensation, not profit).
- edgyquant 6y agoWhat defines value is a matter of debate in econ but labor theory is only believed by Marxists these days.
- shirakawasuna 6y agoThis isn't even labor theory of value...
- dragonwriter 6y ago> You're assuming whatever the worker produces is sold at cost It must be, in the same idealized (free, perfectly competitive, no transaction costs) market conditions being discussed.
- typ 6y ago> First of all a rational actor will not intentionally pay a worker the value of their production; you get no profit. The sum of the production of workers is not equal to the production of a business. Otherwise, if a business increases revenues significantly by simply replacing its CEO, does it mean that the CEO contributes to the increased revenue all alone?
- aidenn0 6y agoThe CEO probably was able to increase per-worket productivity. With the possible exception of lights-out facilities, the sum of the production of workers is equal to the production of a business, and even with lights out facilities, you would attribute the production of the facilities to those who build and maintain them.
- IncRnd 6y agoThe selection of a CEO absolutely contributes to the benefit or detriment of revenue.
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoBut not in a way that scales linearly with CEO pay.
- IncRnd 6y agoYet, I have stock in companies whose stock massively increased after a new CEO. The stock never rose above a certain point for years, until the new CEO made it drastically rise. The workers seemingly did nothing different, yet the CEO made tweaks here and there and crafted communications in specific ways. A good CEO is absolutely invaluable.
- quadrangle 6y agoStock price ≠ productivity
- mr_toad 6y ago> you get no profit. Marginal value of production is almost always lower than average value, because of diminishing returns. Profits are made on the average value. A Marxist take in this is that labour should be paid on the average value of production, and labour should get all the profits.
- chii 6y ago> labour should get all the profits. and the question becomes "who supplies the capital to enable the labour, if labour gets all the profits".
- lopmotr 6y agoThe other question is what does labor get when there are temporarily low or negative profits? I used to work at a company which gave 10% of its profits to the workers each month as a bonus. But I was only there during some money-losing months so I got zero bonus. Imagine if that had been my entire pay!
- aidenn0 6y agoIf they gave 100% of their profits to the workers as the only pay, then long term workers could presumably self-insure.
- drran 6y agoIt looks like excellent solution for startup: just pay 100% of startup profit to workers by giving them 100% of shares, so they will self-insure themselves and be OK when startup will fail.
- IncRnd 6y agoThat almost guarantees that fewer companies will be started, since your model removes incentive for people to benefit from starting companies.
- 6y ago
- tclancy 6y agoIs that how CAPM works?
- FabHK 6y agoNo, the Capital Asset Pricing Model has nothing to do with this discussion. It takes the payoff distribution of capital assets as exogenously given (and known), then makes assumptions about investors' utility functions to find the price they're willing to pay for these assets, then employs an equilibrium argument and some neat maths to arrive at a linear relationship between the expected excess return of an asset and its beta.
- bumby 6y agoAny suggestions on where one can learn more, particularly with the mathematics involved?
- alasdair_ 6y agoWikipedia is honestly pretty good.
- alasdair_ 6y agoThe concept of beta (and non-diversifiable risk in general) is related to the concept of “economic profit”. They may not be directly related but to claim the CAPM “has nothing to do with this discussion” of economic profit is a bit strong.
- tprice7 6y agoEach employee is payed the marginal product of labour, but the output per employee is the average product of labour. Due to the law of diminishing returns, the average product of labour is typically greater than the marginal product of labour, and therefore there can still be a profit.
- crunchybackbone 6y agothe rational actor would pay the value of production if the actor worked in a worker co-op. then 'profit' doesn't make any sense. if the value of the group's production increases, so does the actor's wages. addiction to profit is a hell of a habit to kick, but it's not impossible.
- Spooky23 6y agoIn a free market you would be bidding up worker salaries to hire and retain the most efficient workers. Demand would often increase the price of labor and perhaps the output. In almost every sector of the modern American economy, the rules benefit capital over competition. In my area in New York, there were dozens of small bakeries pumping out good bread... today we pay more for shitty frozen stuff baked at the supermarket. ISPs were plentiful, now they are a monopolist service that costs 10x more than they did in 1999. We broke up standard oil decades ago... That monopoly is mostly reassembled today and we have weaker competitive forces around prices of fuel commodities than we did in the 90s.
- IncRnd 6y ago> In a free market you would be bidding up worker salaries to hire and retain the most efficient workers. Demand would often increase the price of labor and perhaps the output. That's not necessarily true. You assume that demand for workers exceeds supply. That is true for some vertical skilled labor. The often unspoken truth is that most jobs are commodity positions and people can be interchanged (from a labor standpoint). There is no upward trajectory of salaries for those positions.
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoCapitalism pretends to be an efficient competitive utopia of personal opportunity but in reality it's monopolistic, oppressive, hostile to small businesses, and even more hostile to resilience and collective initiative. It inevitably generates huge concentrations of capital which have immense political, social, and economic leverage, with no effective democratic checks and balances - except patchy application of anti-trust action.
- qubex 6y agoI think it’s time to pull out the ‘splitting’ distinction between “industrial capitalism” and “financial capitalism”. I’m an economist, but in no way enamoured with free markets and laissez-faire attitudes as the default for solving everything. I think Mark Fisher had it right in his Capitalist Realism that Capitalism has totally blinded modern western (and other) societies to the existence of any possible alternative form of organisation. However, the kind of financial capitalism we now live under in most of the West—the kind that generates huge income inequalities, concentrates power in the hands of the financial sector, disproportionately favours incumbents, and corrupts our political systems by means of lobbying by special interest groups—lacks all the oft-cited advantages that Capitalism is supposed to bring in tow in exchange for its shortcomings.
- alasdair_ 6y ago> This sentence is just wrong. First of all a rational actor will not intentionally pay a worker the value of their production; you get no profit. The textbooks are talking about economic profit, not absolute profit. In very in-precise terms, it’s the expected profit for the given amount of risk, which to massively oversimplify can be represented by beta.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- CryptoPunk 6y ago>>First of all a rational actor will not intentionally pay a worker the value of their production; you get no profit. The value of their production is NOT the value of the production of the enterprise in which their production is employed. Take a worker, whose work is worth $5 an hour according to market forces. Employing him to operate a $40,000 bakery, which generates $40 an hour in operating profits sans labor costs, does not mean the worker's labor is suddenly worth $40 an hour. You can 100% pay workers what their labor is worth, and make a profit, and believing otherwise is a layman's understanding of the factors of production and the definition of value, and exactly the fallacy that underpinned Marx's quackery. I see so many of these comments in Hackernews, which misunderstand basic economics, endeavor to expose some Big Lie allegedly being promoted by Economics/capitalists, and seek to defend some allegedly exploited underdog who needs laws limiting private-property/contract rights to be protected from said exploitation. Also, there is no indication of information asymmetry playing any role in contract negotiations. Signals like market prices are an emergent phenomenon that are easily accessible to all prices. They are easily accessible because well-resourced parties are incentivized to carry out actions that make them accessible, like a firm advertising a job opening and the pay offered as widely as possible, to maximize the number of potential applicants that see it.
- koonsolo 6y agoYou are correct that prices are not set by value of what one produces. Prices in the job market are set exactly the same way as any other market: by supply and demand.