13 ms·
This is something that still completely baffles me about the "IoT"/"smart devices"/"connected devices"/"whatever you want to call it" space. If someone adverti
by xg15 6y ago
This is something that still completely baffles me about the "IoT"/"smart devices"/"connected devices"/"whatever you want to call it" space.
If someone advertised a device as capable of doing X without it in fact being able to do X, they'd be liable for false advertising.
If someone sold you a device, then took it back or destroyed it, they'd be liable for theft or destruction of property.
Nevertheless, if someone sells you a connected device and then completely alters the rules by which the device operates at an arbitrary point in time after the sell, that's perfectly fine.
Have we really given up basic consumer rights that easily?
- ccktlmazeltov 6y agoYou need internet to download games to your oculus quest, so it makes sense to have an account to keep track of what games you own no? I still don't understand what people have against this change. You needed an oculus account prior to this, now it's a facebook account, what's the big deal?
- achr2 6y agoReally? I have never and will never have a facebook account, so this expensive device is now a paper weight..
- jjaredsimpson 6y agoKinda absurd. You can setup a one time email, and one time facebook if you really want to segregate. Sure you win on principle, but that's just the same as losing.
- TT3351 6y agoActually you can't, because Facebook will lock your account for inauthentic behavior. Try making a fake account, and see how long you can hold on to it without being extorted for personal, identifiable information.
- cortesoft 6y agoI set up a fake Facebook profile 10 years ago, because I needed a profile with no friends that I could use for testing some stuff at work. It is still alive and kicking; Facebook keeps sending it emails suggesting friends.
- gopiandcode 6y agoWe can spend all day arguing anecdotes. As a counterpoint, I've never used Facebook, but once tried setting up an account to participate in a group event organized by some friends - by the next day, before I could even use the account, Facebook had locked my account, and wanted a photo of my ID to let me access the account. Needless to say, I abandoned the account.
- cortesoft 6y agoThe person who I replied to made a personal challenge to try creating a fake account, so I responded with my personal experience doing just that. I was not making any claims about the likelihood of an account being banned.
- quinndiggity 6y agoYour experience is about 10 years out of relevancy, but it was a good story, bro
- distances 6y agoThat won't probably work any more. I have a couple of old test accounts, can't create new ones without them being locked right away.
- ccktlmazeltov 6y agosame, I have a fake account and no issue with it
- quinndiggity 6y agoKinda absurd. You can't setup a one time email, and one time facebook if you really don't want your movement online all linked to a government issued ID. Sure you're sort of an idiot to make those assumptions, but I'm sure you already came to this realization about yourself years ago.
- jjaredsimpson 6y agoWhat if I'm too stupid to introspect?
- Dylan16807 6y ago> now January 2023
- smileybarry 6y agoUnless they want to sell it used, in which case the value tanks because starting October setting up an Oculus device requires a Facebook account. (And for that reason I stopped considering Oculus for my first headset)
- antihero 6y agoFacebook account bans are often for absurd reasons and there is basically zero accountability. Post a pic that an algorithm flagged as a nude? No Oculus for 30 days and needing to send them a passport scan!
- paulnechifor 6y ago> You need internet to download games to your oculus quest, so it makes sense to have an account to keep track of what games you own no? Not really. If they're downloaded, why would you need to look up remotely what you have locally.
- quinndiggity 6y agoYeah, I thought the same thing too, in order to give the fake like/follow some artists require before making their music available to download; took 10 minutes, my account was banned for "suspicious activity" (meaning I didn't start posting pictures of myself like a pleb), and a government issued ID demanded of me. Fuck that
- EmilioMartinez 6y ago>it makes sense to have an account to keep track of what games you own no? Not in the least
- JMTQp8lwXL 6y agoConsumer protection laws generally lag behind these problems, so it might be premature to say we've given up. We have to know the problem exists, and then we have to go through the (slow) legislative process.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoIn a democracy laws always lag whatever the opinion of the majority is on the issue.
- amelius 6y agoI think the problem is that the "masses" would still buy the Oculus product as if nothing was wrong with it. From there, it's pretty difficult to convince people (e.g. a regulator or a judge) that your item is of no use to you anymore.
- thephyber 6y agoThat's moving forward. This problem has as much to do with past expectations that changed as it does current expectations for the future.
- javajosh 6y ago>Have we really given up basic consumer rights that easily? Well, yes. I don't know if you've noticed, but short-term convenience trumps all other concerns. The market can't really deal with these issues, because they are too subtle and expensive for individuals to work out for themselves. We really do need collective action, by way of regulation, similar to how we recognized as a society that workplace safety laws were not something private businesses were ever going to compete on, and we just needed to force them to comply. And no doubt the same howls of protest let loose then, too, about how "the extra costs will put me out of business", etc. It was then, as it is now, hogwash. And in fact I would argue this kind of regulation not only important for consumers, but for national security. As more and more individuals lives become dependent on centralized information infrastructure, the more damage espionage (foreign or domestic) can do, not to mention the effect of wide-scale DoS attacks. Imagine a world where all smart devices are bricked...so much of the old infrastructure is gone - phones, phone books, maps, manuals. In some cases you might not even be able to vacuum your house (Roomba owners), or make a POTS phone call. So yeah, its bad on multiple fronts, and I fear that the correcting event will be catastrophic (like, supply chain catastrophic, leading to starvation).
- ooobit2 6y agoWe're seeing this right now with Epic's Tim Sweeney suing Apple for its mandatory cut on all digital goods. Yet a large number of people, people who claim to be pro-99%, anti-technocracy, anti-corporatism, are shilling the rhetoric that "it's Apple's platform" and "Epic knew what the terms were." Well, yes, but that's exactly what SV activists and social activists are claiming has to stop. It's absurd that these same people are willing to defend the iPhone/iOS/Apple Services pipeline of proprietary anticompetitive dependencies. I hope Epic wins this case against Apple. It's a precedent that needs to be set for limiting anticompetitive business and manufactured monopolies. Nothing Apple has in its portfolio is absent a perfect substitute in the very same market Apple is selling their products. But Apple has used proprietary inputs as a gatekeeper for their revenue. No one should have to buy a $49 dongle to plug an HDMI cable into their iPhone when every Android/Windows/Linux-based device has built-in support within the device. And if someone tries to push a "Lightning" to HDMI cable, Apple detects and deliberately locks off device content. Too many big, beloved logos are built on anti-free market tactics, both by lobbying policy and private act. The sheer volume of this that Steve Jobs did in his lifetime made it hard for me to feel anything when he died. I genuinely felt relieved that this tyrant in technology, a man whose every product idea was just enough of a change of someone else's existing work product, slapped with intentional proprietary inputs to limit competition within the Apple eco-system, was finally gone. And then Tim Cook sashay'd on in.
- latenightcoding 6y agoIt baffles me too. My Samsung smart tv started showing me ads in the control panel/home screen. I paid full price for it, why am I seeing ads. I wish I could return it, but the snakes waited until the return period was over.
- Maha-pudma 6y agoThis happened to me to. It now is not connected to the internet and never will be again. It's also the crappest TV I've ever owned. My old dumb TV is better.
- samename 6y agoYou can set the DNS on the TV to NextDNS to block the ads and tracking, so you can use the internet again.
- WrtCdEvrydy 6y agoThis is some bullshit. I would blackhole whatever fucking API they are using... just limit the incoming, but allow outgoing so their ad networks begin counting it as a non-shown ad.
- greycol 6y agoProblem is that there is at least one smart TV that gets stuck in a boot loop when it goes to update it's ads and can't. Support in that case tells them to connect to the internet and it'll work (which ofcourse will grab the new batch of ads). There are plenty of other cases with smart TVs losing actual functionality when the server that serves ads is blocked and because it's an updateable service you can't really tell which smart TV will sting you.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- propogandist 6y agoyou should stop your tv from making outbound calls. Many "smart tvs" are mining details on what you're watching and sending it back to the mothership, including conversations it may hear in the room, if your TV has voice activation features You should disconnect your TV from the internet and not let it connect. Run a barebones version of Firestick (ideally with piHole) as it is constantly phoning home to Amazon. Roku is a popular alternative, but it too is constantly phoning home. Two random articles, which includes coverage on the Samsung & Smart TV problem https://www.cnet.com/news/samsungs-warning-our-smart-tvs-record-your-living-room-chatter/ https://www.cnet.com/news/samsungs-warning-our-smart-tvs-rec... https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2019/09/18/you-watch-tv-your-tv-watches-back/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2019/09/18/you-wat...
- nomorealoha 6y ago> Have we really given up basic consumer rights that easily? Is there anything I can do as a mere consumer to lobby for my rights?
- grillvogel 6y agoPKD predicted this 50 years ago https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/7444685-the-door-refused-to-open-it-said-five-cents-please https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/7444685-the-door-refused-to...
- maerF0x0 6y ago> then completely alters the rules by which the device operates at an arbitrary point in time after the sell You usually agree to a EULA that allows them to do that. If you cannot agree to the EULA then you return the product. Now, I will give full credit that no one reads those, but Legality doesn't care if you fail to do due diligence.
- Dahoon 6y agoYou have some basic rights and an EULA, TOS or a contract cannot take those away (at least not in the EU). So no, that wouldn't cover a situation where a device is crippled later on. You'd have a right to get your money back.
- xg15 6y agoI mean, then the easiest thing for companies to do would be to write "You agree that we can do anything we want with the device" into the EULA. As long as they behave reasonable in the near term and only go crazy after public attention has moved on, they'd probably get few customers to notice.
- charles_f 6y agoGood point, that being said market pressure can sometimes influence that. Sonos was a hair short of bricking their old devices a few months ago, then backtracked after getting a lot of fire from their customers. I'm wondering if this would be true for larger companies / acquisitions though. Would they have done the same if purchased by Google or Facebook?
- awinter-py 6y agoit's a different world sometimes things get bricked, other times they get new features for free teslas couldn't self-drive and then, one OTA update later, they could companies release security updates society doesn't know how to regulate OTA; change is sometimes bad for users but not always.
- markdog12 6y agoI've always thought it was odd how they can advertise Google Assistant, Siri, etc.., as if it's some magical thing that understands everything you say, but in practice it's worse than useless. It gives you hope that it works, but it never does, it only frustrates you. In my experience, anyway.
- fizzled 6y agoRights are something you need to constantly fight for, otherwise they absolutely will go away. Portland isn't just bored, they're ahead of the curve.
- noduerme 6y agoAs someone who lives in PDX, owns an Oculus Rift and has always refused to have a Facebook account, I can only say that mass bitching appears to have done very little to change anything. Civil lawsuits are a better approach.
- shrimpx 6y agoWhat’s the context of the Portland reference?
- tfigment 6y agoThe US Fed govt sent unmarked, masked troops to Portland who then detained people without identifying themselves using rental vehicles and not disclosing why during the riots. Basically what happens during a kidnapping. Also I believe after mayor and governor ask them to leave. Not the first time in current events either.
- josteink 6y agoTo be fair, Portland is in completely chaos and disarray[1]. Innocent people are getting attacked, mugged, and almost killed by ANTIFA and BLM[2], without any police-intervention. (Because, as BLM has taught the incompetent Portland-mayor, the police are the bad guys.) Someone sending in troops to try re-establish law and order is not only a good thing, it's paramount. Normal, non-radicalized citizens have a right to safety, and that right is not getting honoured right now. [1] https://twitter.com/hashtag/PortlandRiots https://twitter.com/hashtag/PortlandRiots [2] https://twitter.com/Timcast/status/1295350888509382661 https://twitter.com/Timcast/status/1295350888509382661
- Can_Not 6y agoHere's a follow up video that's more neutral and fact based compared to the other comment. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=uglv-fV1CqI https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=uglv-fV1CqI
- 127 6y agoIt's not just that, it's also the store. If you choose not to log with the Facebook ID, do I also lose access to all of my purchases? It seems extra scummy.
- bserge 6y agoNah, this is how laws are made. Someone keeps pushing the limits of what they can do to other people, then enough people have enough of it and push back, companies are fined, legislation is created, bs stops happening for a while. Same shit, different day (at least until we change the shit out of the climate/environment, heh).
- EmilioMartinez 6y agoHow do we create laws for these contingencies? Should we list all the possible manners in which consumers shouldn't be screwed? Should we provide flexible guidelines? It risks becoming a regulatory hell too for small developers to navigate. If regulation is weak, it risks becoming some pointless step in the way (a minor point in an EULA, or cookies-like popup) that people would ignore anyways. One way or the other, it's easy to spin as a feature: "Our VR set has a social focus (eg. we post your daily usage). For this, login in to you account is necessity". There. Now not only you need to log in, you are also publicly shamed for your usage just for them to save face. Sadly, it boils down to human decency to make a human product.
- Mandatum 6y agoIn Australia after some "on the box" features were no longer applicable to the product I bought, I was able to refund the product. This has worked for; - Consumer devices (cloud support dropped within the lifetime of the device, features dropped likely as a cost saving measure to the manufacturer) - Software (features removed or culled after buying) - Smart TVs (claiming support for different platforms) - Gaming consoles (OtherOS on PS3) This usually hurts the retailer - they don't want to risk going after the manufacturer because they want to sell their products. I've been banned from buying from one store after returning a product and then posting about it publicly, many others returned as well when they realised it was possible - I can assume some took advantage of this fact as a "I paid full price for this 1.5 years ago, it's now worth 50% less, I can return it and buy a better model from somewhere else" endeavour.
- ViViDboarder 6y agoThis same thing just happened to Belkin WeMo. Looking forward to the class action. I bought a bunch of switches because the offered local control and no account needed, now an account is required to set up anything new and local control is apparently going away. I’m now wary of anything that needs a proprietary app at all which would give them the ability to do this in the first place.
- StavrosK 6y agoI can recommend Sonoff switches and any bulb that runs ESP8266, you can usually easily flash those with open source firmware. I do it when I receive them, and they've been rock solid.
- ksrm 6y agoSounds like something the EU will look at in the future if they aren't already.