18 ms·
Google: Open Letter to Australians
- slater 6y ago404. Got a copy?
- skissane 6y agoIt appears they've blocked access to it from non-Australian IPs. Here is the HTML they serve to me: https://gist.githubusercontent.com/skissane/05bac6c78d99e359a004e4a4e034048d/raw/1bbf121d720775778270cb40beda2a071afbf1f7/an-open-letter.html https://gist.githubusercontent.com/skissane/05bac6c78d99e359... Text: Open letter to Australians We need to let you know about new Government regulation that will hurt how Australians use Google Search and YouTube. A proposed law, the News Media Bargaining Code, would force us to provide you with a dramatically worse Google Search and YouTube, could lead to your data being handed over to big news businesses, and would put the free services you use at risk in Australia. The way Aussies search every day on Google is at risk from new regulation You’ve always relied on Google Search and YouTube to show you what’s most relevant and helpful to you. We could no longer guarantee that under this law. The law would force us to give an unfair advantage to one group of businesses - news media businesses - over everyone else who has a website, YouTube channel or small business. News media businesses alone would be given information that would help them artificially inflate their ranking over everyone else, even when someone else provides a better result. We’ve always treated all website owners fairly when it comes to information we share about ranking. The proposed changes are not fair and they mean that Google Search results and YouTube will be worse for you. Your Search data may be at risk You trust us with your data and our job is to keep it safe. Under this law, Google has to tell news media businesses “how they can gain access” to data about your use of our products. There’s no way of knowing if any data handed over would be protected, or how it might be used by news media businesses. Hurting the free services you use We deeply believe in the importance of news to society. We partner closely with Australian news media businesses — we already pay them millions of dollars and send them billions of free clicks every year. We’ve offered to pay more to license content. But rather than encouraging these types of partnerships, the law is set up to give big media companies special treatment and to encourage them to make enormous and unreasonable demands that would put our free services at risk. This law wouldn’t just impact the way Google and YouTube work with news media businesses — it would impact all of our Australian users, so we wanted to let you know. We’re going to do everything we possibly can to get this proposal changed so we can protect how Search and YouTube work for you in Australia and continue to build constructive partnerships with news media businesses — not choose one over the other. You’ll hear more from us in the coming days — stay tuned. Thank you, Mel Silva, Managing Director, on behalf of Google Australia
- slater 6y agoNice one, thanks! Maybe also do an archive.is link?
- skissane 6y agoarchive.is only wants to archive the 404 page. I think to archive this you need either (a) an archiving service with servers in Australia or (b) an archiving service that archives it using your browser (instead of their servers) and then uploads it to their servers. I can't find any archiving service for which either (a) or (b) is true
- slater 6y agoah, ok
- vital_beach 6y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20200817020923/https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache%3AnebjTKsl_IAJ%3Ahttps%3A%2F%2Fabout.google%2Fintl%2FALL_au%2Fgoogle-in-australia%2Fan-open-letter%2F+&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us https://web.archive.org/web/20200817020923/https://webcache....
- vmception 6y ago> It appears they've blocked access to it from non-Australian IPs. Wow, just turned on my residential VPN and selected my Australian server, can confirm it does load. Didn't even have to clear cookies. Very sketchy google. Even if the Australian law has issues and alternatives cannot deliver for free, I would not support Google aims here. They are the big news business they are gaslighting into Australians into being afraid of. I think I now want an auto-loader to compare websites accessed from different locations.
- duud 6y agoThey're not gaslighting. This is about News Corp (former owner of Fox News) and a few other multi billion dollar albeit unprofitable media companies using their political sway to extort Google. It will almost certainly result in a worse experience for consumers.
- minimike 6y agohttp://g.co/australia-letter http://g.co/australia-letter
- tech234a 6y agoThis should be the link for this thread.
- vital_beach 6y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20200817020923/https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache%3AnebjTKsl_IAJ%3Ahttps%3A%2F%2Fabout.google%2Fintl%2FALL_au%2Fgoogle-in-australia%2Fan-open-letter%2F+&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us https://web.archive.org/web/20200817020923/https://webcache....
- dang 6y agoFixed now. Submitted URL was https://about.google/google-in-australia/an-open-letter/ https://about.google/google-in-australia/an-open-letter/.
- plasma 6y agoFeels related to this article from June 2020, https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-53176945 https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-53176945 "Google to pay for 'high quality' news in three countries"
- ImaCake 6y agoLink to the draft law is below [0]. Quoted from that page: >The code also includes a set of ‘minimum standards’ for: >providing advance notice of changes to algorithmic ranking and presentation of news; appropriately recognising original news content; and >providing information about how and when Google and Facebook make available user data collected through users’ interactions with news content. This sounds great to me. Australia has a history of producing consumer friendly laws (although I am sure we have our share of bad laws on this), and I consider google to be working against my personal interests, so I think this law is probably good (for consumers and news media, but not google/facebook). 0. https://www.accc.gov.au/focus-areas/digital-platforms/draft-news-media-bargaining-code https://www.accc.gov.au/focus-areas/digital-platforms/draft-...
- throwaway45349 6y agoAFAIK you're missing a crucial point - they're trying to require G/FB to pay out billions to old (read: dying) media publications, which will crush small publications. On the Open Web, ABC News should get the exact same treatment at JoeBloggsYT2020.
- searchableguy 6y agoThat's my main problem with it. Extend those minimum standards for everyone regardless of revenue and other selective filters. Can someone explain what this means? > providing information about how and when Google and Facebook make available user data collected through users’ interactions with news content. Is it saying google or facebook need to tell news publication about when/which users are accessing thier content?
- spauka 6y agoThis reads to me more as if though G/FB have to tell news organizations what data is being collected, rather than disclosing the actual data. A quote from the Q&A seems to clarify: > give news media businesses clear information about the nature and availability of user data collected through users’ interactions with news on their services;
- louisstow 6y agoOpen letter to Australians We need to let you know about new Government regulation that will hurt how Australians use Google Search and YouTube. A proposed law, the News Media Bargaining Code, would force us to provide you with a dramatically worse Google Search and YouTube, could lead to your data being handed over to big news businesses, and would put the free services you use at risk in Australia. # The way Aussies search every day on Google is at risk from new regulation You’ve always relied on Google Search and YouTube to show you what’s most relevant and helpful to you. We could no longer guarantee that under this law. The law would force us to give an unfair advantage to one group of businesses - news media businesses - over everyone else who has a website, YouTube channel or small business. News media businesses alone would be given information that would help them artificially inflate their ranking over everyone else, even when someone else provides a better result. We’ve always treated all website owners fairly when it comes to information we share about ranking. The proposed changes are not fair and they mean that Google Search results and YouTube will be worse for you. # Your Search data may be at risk You trust us with your data and our job is to keep it safe. Under this law, Google has to tell news media businesses “how they can gain access” to data about your use of our products. There’s no way of knowing if any data handed over would be protected, or how it might be used by news media businesses. # Hurting the free services you use We deeply believe in the importance of news to society. We partner closely with Australian news media businesses — we already pay them millions of dollars and send them billions of free clicks every year. We’ve offered to pay more to license content. But rather than encouraging these types of partnerships, the law is set up to give big media companies special treatment and to encourage them to make enormous and unreasonable demands that would put our free services at risk. This law wouldn’t just impact the way Google and YouTube work with news media businesses — it would impact all of our Australian users, so we wanted to let you know. We’re going to do everything we possibly can to get this proposal changed so we can protect how Search and YouTube work for you in Australia and continue to build constructive partnerships with news media businesses — not choose one over the other. You’ll hear more from us in the coming days — stay tuned.
- stirlo 6y agoIt's been highlighted below but the reason this is posted here and up voted is that Google choose to 404 any requests coming from non Australian IP addresses. Hardly seems to be the thing you do when you're acting above board...
- jp0d 6y agoI'd probably trust the Australian govt to protect my data better than Google or even worse Facebook. The way the article has twisted the words in Google's favour is commendable though. Marketing really is everything.
- iamshs 6y agoLooking at how many people opted out of MyHealth over the concerns of Government having their data, I think your reason will not resonate with many.
- mickotron 6y agoI really hope they made good on that. Can we confirm that if we opted out, we indeed don't have a my health record, or whether they just set one up regardless?
- shakna 6y agoThey may have set one up regardless, as the basic registration data comes from MyGov, and you may have a user. However, it would require your health professional to upload data to the service - and most have simply refused. But to actually check if one's MyHealth record exists and has data, one must first opt-in to MyHealth, which is a bit chicken/egg.
- AbrahamParangi 6y agoI can't agree, but to each his own.
- shakna 6y ago> I'd probably trust the Australian govt to protect my data better than Google or even worse Facebook. I would not. The Australian government seems entirely incapable of creating any technical project of a decent size correctly. The list of disasters is quite long, but a few from recent memory are ones such as the census website which collapsed when people tried to use it [0] and the myGov project which has had so many data breaches [1]. Atop of which, the government's usual response to someone exposing flaws, is to attack them. Whilst I don't want Google or Facebook to have my data, because they will use it in ways I don't appreciate, my government will leak it. And then claim it wasn't serious and excuse themselves from any repercussions. [0] https://www.abc.net.au/news/2016-08-12/census-2016-site-up-and-running-in-australia/7722738 https://www.abc.net.au/news/2016-08-12/census-2016-site-up-a... [1] https://www.smh.com.au/technology/revealed-serious-flaws-in-mygov-site-exposed-millions-of-australians-private-information-20140514-zrczw.html https://www.smh.com.au/technology/revealed-serious-flaws-in-... [2]
- steve1820 6y agoI'd definitely encourage more regulation in this area. It's going to be a balancing act but at the moment, its is way too skewed towards the big corp in the corp vs consumer arguement.
- throwawaynothx 6y agotbh im sick of seeing posts about stupid "kmart shopper finds.... bla bla bla" show up in my news feed
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Mandatum 6y agoAnd surprisingly, not one mention of Murdoch. Let's be honest - this is old media trying to push their weight to keep margins. Facebook and Google have effectively replaced both clickbait and tabloid news sources, as well as the well-resourced, quality journalism by taking ad revenue off their hands. Google could easily setup a news sourcing hub themselves and self-cite news rather than relying on their external data feeds. This is political. Neither Google or Facebook is going to be paying a cent here. I find Google citing data safety annoying.
- h0l0cube 6y ago> And surprisingly, not one mention of Murdoch. "The law would force us to give an unfair advantage to one group of businesses - news media businesses - over everyone else who has a website, YouTube channel or small business." This wording doesn't suggest that Murdoch would have a better advantage than any other 'news media business'. Is there anything in the new laws to suggest, apart from capital/resources, that this is set to benefit any particular Australian media business over another? > Google could easily setup a news sourcing hub themselves and self-cite news rather than relying on their external data feeds. So they'd be paying for news content from established media enterprise, or paying journalists to write their own - as opposed to leaching off them. Seems like a win?
- cyphar 6y agoI agree with your broader point, though it should be noted that public broadcasters (namely ABC and SBS) will not be able to make use of certain rights under the new legislation (namely the forced arbitration system). So it does give slightly more favour to private media organisations -- though you could argue allowing the ABC or SBS to exercise those powers would violate their own charters (their duty is not to be competitive with other media).
- rswail 6y agoWhere in their charter does it say that it is one of their duties not to be competitive with other media? The only mention in the charter (it's really short) is: > (2) In the provision by the Corporation of its broadcasting services within Australia: > >(a) the Corporation shall take account of: > >(i) the broadcasting services provided by the commercial and community sectors of the Australian broadcasting system; It's a Murdoch/Nine/7West continuous whinge that ABC/SBS compete "unfairly", yet when it comes to actual community needs (eg emergency broadcasting, rural and regional reporting etc), they do squat in return for their spectrum and cable licenses.
- ThinkBeat 6y agoI think, the best solution here will be for Google to sell all its assets and business in Australia to a company to be named by the Australian prime minister. If they wish to continue to offer search there that is.
- hujun 6y agoand give google 45 or 90 days to comply
- vermilingua 6y agoThat would be NewsCorp. I really hope your comment is a joke.
- dodobirdlord 6y agoI'm pretty sure it's a joking reference to Trump's executive order forcing a sale of TikTok.
- reaperducer 6y agoTo all the people (hopefully Australians) who paint this as the government propping up legacy media: Isn't it better to have control of your media in local, Australian-owned and regulated megacorps, rather than some faceless megacorp in another country?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- StopHammoTime 6y agoJokes on us, our media is run by a faceless megacorp in another country anyway (News Ltd).
- reaperducer 6y agoAccording to Wikipedia, it's not in another country. Unless "Surry Hills, Sydney" is another country. If Wikipedia is wrong, you should update it for the benefit of the rest of us.
- spacehunt 6y agoIf you look a few lines down in the same infobox, you'll see its parent is "News Corp" which is in the US.
- austhrow743 6y agoGoogle's Australian subsidiary is registered as and headquartered in Pyrmont, Sydney. Guess there's no problem with it controlling Australian media!
- grecy 6y agoIn theory yes, but in reality the Australian-owned megacorps are all owned by a single person, and every single one of the media outlets they control endlessly pushes the political message of just one side. So although they're "Australian owned", they're very far from good "neutral" sources of information. (Source: am Australian) EDIT: For those wondering, it's like virtually all of Australia's media being run by Rush Limbaugh. And he has a cozy relationship with the government, so all of this is just a way to force Google and FB to pay him more money.
- wombatmobile 6y agoPot. Kettle. No such thing as a free lunch. Shoshana Zuboff on surveillance capitalism | VPRO Documentary https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hIXhnWUmMvw&t=29s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hIXhnWUmMvw&t=29s
- skissane 6y agoLink that works globally (not just in Australia): http://g.co/australia-letter http://g.co/australia-letter @dang, can we change the link on this submission please?
- dang 6y agoYes. Changed from https://about.google/google-in-australia/an-open-letter/ https://about.google/google-in-australia/an-open-letter/. Thanks!
- gitgud 6y agoI initially thought this was going to be about the new [1] anti-encryption law's in Australia... another concerning matter of government intervention... [1] https://fee.org/articles/australia-s-unprecedented-encryption-law-is-a-threat-to-global-privacy/ https://fee.org/articles/australia-s-unprecedented-encryptio...
- DoctorNick 6y agonope, Google doesn't give a shit about that. They just hate having to pay for displaying content from news media.
- dontblink 6y agoRightly so. This is a shakedown by Murdoch
- 0xy 6y agoWhy would anyone be thrilled about having to funnel cash to News Corp? The news business is dead, and good riddance because it descended into yellow journalism and clickbait garbage. Check the News.com.au homepage and observe it looks like a worse Daily Mail.
- ricardo81 6y ago>The news business is dead, and good riddance because it descended into yellow journalism and clickbait garbage. I think it could be the other way around, where people expecting news online and free has meant declining revenues, click-bait and ad-infested news articles. News aggregators get the user's onto their site without the overhead.
- nailer 6y agoKeep in mind Google are being forced to display the content AND pay for it.
- Jabbles 6y agoWell they did say this: https://www.reformgovernmentsurveillance.com/rgs-statement-on-the-australian-parliaments-passage-of-assistance-and-access-bill/ https://www.reformgovernmentsurveillance.com/rgs-statement-o... Not sure what happened after that...
- perryizgr8 6y ago> could lead to your data being handed over to big news businesses Coming from Google, this is a bit funny. I expect Google to be bigger than the combined Australian newspaper industry.
- zmmmmm 6y ago> News media businesses alone would be given information that would help them artificially inflate their ranking over everyone else, even when someone else provides a better result I'm not sure how Google wins this one because it seems like an easy comeback is "well why don't you just be transparent and tell everybody that information". Ultimately, as long as they have anything resembling "secret sauce" they will be in the cross hairs of regulators for unfair treatment (even if just alleged, not proven), and the minute they don't they will lose their competitive advantage. Perhaps the worst thing seems to me that it prospectively constrains what kinds of algorithms they can actually apply to things they can tell people about. So all kinds of approaches with poor explainability (say, deep learning) will get put aside for things that are empirically worse (more biased, unfair, less equitable, etc.) but compliant with the law because Google can "explain them" to people.
- darawk 6y ago> I'm not sure how Google wins this one because it seems like an easy comeback is "well why don't you just be transparent and tell everybody that information". Ultimately, as long as they have anything resembling "secret sauce" they will be in the cross hairs of regulators for unfair treatment (even if just alleged, not proven), and the minute they don't they will lose their competitive advantage. Because then people would game it.
- uluyol 6y agoExactly, the ranking needs constant tweaking to deal with spam/SEO.
- schemy 6y agoWhich is what's happening right now. The only difference would be that you don't need to do industrial espionage on google to see what works first, so the cost of the seo would drop.
- ricardo81 6y agoYes, same as the phone book for AAA Plumbers. Playing devil's advocate, gaming search engines used to be about keywords then it became more about links. SEOs nowadays talk about "EAT", expertise, authority, and trustworthiness. It's still possible for marketers to mimic quality signals but it's less easy. It would be much easier if the author of webpages were to declare themselves, sort of a Pagerank but applied on a person/topic level. It could/can be done with structured data. This of course has privacy implications but it keeps the publishers as transparent to the search engine as possible. Verification of sorts would be needed so other people don't use your authorship details on their own site. It's the kind of social fabric/data Google could've perhaps used Google+ for. Slightly more on topic, marketers used to be able to do accurate keyword research with Google, and also see the keywords that people searched for when landing on their site, which is quite useful for figuring out their intent. Google keeps all that data to themselves now. I find their "concerns" about "use of private data" a bit laughable, considering they used your personal search history to try and target you on sites you visit across the web via ads. They don't mind retaining data about users, they just don't like having to share it with anyone.
- lancewiggs 6y agoI am delighted at whatever law is driving that letter and want to lobby to introduce the same law here in NZ.
- BLKNSLVR 6y agoBe careful what you wish for. This law is Australian government protectionism for the already-corrupt and thankfully dying status quo: the lumbering dinosaur that is News Corp. IMHO, what makes it obviously corrupt is that News Corp pays little to no tax and is owned offshore, and yet the Australian government protects it as if it's local (whilst at the same time cutting funding from the local news organisation the ABC). There's most definitely a void opening up for quality news and media, which is being filled by social media opinion pieces (which, to be fair, is no different from what I'm writing here) which are lacking in any of the quality, research or integrity that news reporting should have. Having said all that, history shows that what news reporting "should have" (quality, research, integrity, fact-checking etc.) has been bent in various directions since the very inception of news media. So what we're getting is just a changing of the guard as opposed to anything necessarily worse than before. However, this law the Australian government is attempting to push is a delaying tactic against the changing of the guard. It's protecting something that never really existed.
- tjpnz 6y agoGiven how easily NZ politicians have caved to US corporations in the past (Hobbit Law, S92A etc) I'm not holding my breath.
- actuator 6y ago> You trust us with your data and our job is to keep it safe. Under this law, Google has to tell news media businesses “how they can gain access” to data about your use of our products. This corpspeak wording seems very broad. I wonder what Australia is gunning at here, if they are really asking Google/FB to share user insights about users visiting these news sites, that doesn't sit well with me as an user.
- rossjudson 6y agoGood news! You can replace corpspeak with legalspeak. https://www.accc.gov.au/focus-areas/digital-platforms/news-media-bargaining-code/draft-legislation https://www.accc.gov.au/focus-areas/digital-platforms/news-m...
- jojobas 6y agoPay corporate income tax here and then will talk.
- BLKNSLVR 6y agoYou talking to Google or News Corp? You're flipping a single-sided coin. Heads you lose, and that's the only option.
- jojobas 6y agoIs News Corp pretending it doesn't turn any profit by offsetting it to an Irish entity? I always understood it's deliberately run at about breakeven, it's a political tool, not a money-making enterprise.
- BLKNSLVR 6y ago> deliberately run at about breakeven, it's a political tool, not a money-making enterprise. Well, that's worse, or at least no better, and makes it much harder to defend the writing of new laws to protect it (except when you're the one both writing the laws and using the tool). Just writing that makes my skin crawl. Admittedly, that's a different topic to tax avoidance though.
- spacehunt 6y agohttps://www.afr.com/rear-window/is-news-corp-still-paying-zero-tax-20190509-p51lqe https://www.afr.com/rear-window/is-news-corp-still-paying-ze... > ... there’s the withholding tax [News Australia Holdings] pays on interest it pays to a News Corp associate offshore, which News likes to lump in with income tax. (AFR is Fairfax / Channel 9, take that what you will.)
- kyrra 6y ago(googler, opinion is my own) My understanding is that Google is locally incorporated in australia, as you can see on this page[0], at least for Ads, likely other businesses. If you select Australia on there you will see Ads payments are made to "Google Australia Pty Limited". [0] https://support.google.com/google-ads/answer/2375370?hl=en https://support.google.com/google-ads/answer/2375370?hl=en
- discordance 6y agoGoogle evil etc etc aside, they have been decent custodians of their users data. I don't really want to trust Google, but they behave much better than the Australian government, who recently admitted they spy on their citizens [0], can coerce citizens and companies to install backdoors into their companies software [1]. I trust Murdoch less than the government, and much much less than Google. Remember when Murdoch institutions illegally wiretapped celebrities, politicians, royal family members and relatives of dead British soldiers [2]? 0: https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2020/aug/06/peter-dutton-confirms-australia-could-spy-on-its-own-citizens-under-cybersecurity-plan https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2020/aug/06/peter... 1: https://www.wired.com/story/australia-encryption-law-global-impact/ https://www.wired.com/story/australia-encryption-law-global-... 2: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/News_International_phone_hacking_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/News_International_phone_hacki...
- berkes 6y ago> I don't really want to trust Google, but they behave much better than the Australian government, If you ignore who does it worst in pracice, the most important argument becomes apparent: The Austrialian government is a democratically assigned entity; one that has (or should have?) checks and balances in place; one that is closely monitored as your various references prove. Google, a foreign private entity has no such checks and balances in place. We don't vote in general elections for the new CEO of Google, we don't elect representatives into the board, and we cannot lean on transparancy laws to look into the kitchen at that private entity.
- vermilingua 6y agoDiscussion on the law itself here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24006150 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24006150
- dannyw 6y agoAustralian here. Fuck News Corp, one of the most corrupt entities in Australia that directly collude and interfere with our elections for the benefit of themselves and Big Coal. I hope Google don’t fuck around.
- Polylactic_acid 6y ago>corrupt entities in Australia They have also seriously damaged the media in the US and the UK. Its no wonder all 3 countries are having serious issues with news.
- thu2111 6y agoThat's an anglo-centric perception. Which countries has Google News been banned in? Spain. China. Germany briefly until Google told the news orgs they'd never pay, so could license their content for free or disappear from News and search. Newspapers trying to screw Google out of money by pressuring politicians is not an Australia or News Corp specific problem. It's happening everywhere. Really, all it reveals is how cravenly controlled by journalists supposedly independent politicians really are. We always "knew" it, but now we know it.
- TheRealSteel 6y agoThe comments you were replying to are about News Corp, who have done done very specific damage to the Us, UK and Australia specifically. As far as I know they operate in those 3 places. I'm not aware of any operation they have in Germany.
- thelastname 6y agoI don't know why this gets a so downvoted, it's correct. There was/is a huge pressure made by French and German media owners.
- blaser-waffle 6y agoYou're not wrong, but News Corp doesn't hold a lot of power in FR or DE. Meanwhile Fox News is still poisoning minds in the US, and basically calling the shots in Australia. Plus all the UK hacking, etc. I'll give a shit about what AFP or Deutsche Welle are doing when they start becoming a tool of the US GOP that openly pushes for invading Iran.
- blargmaster33 6y ago"Google Search and YouTube to show you what’s most relevant" Then you f-ing failed Google, your adds are always for crap and YouTube adds are for even shittier things.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- paulie_a 6y agoOpen letter to Google Earth. Fuck off
- poma88 6y agoLet's google win the next elections
- andrewstuart 6y ago<deleted>
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- czardoz 6y ago> Google pays a trivial amount of tax here. Google provides a lot of value with their free products too. Aren't you discounting that?
- tjpnz 6y agoThat's debatable but ultimately meaningless when it comes to tax obligations.
- xiaodai 6y agoWe need to unite the world under one government. The system should be democracy but no longer country based. Instead, it's region based. A successful party in one region can enter election in any other region and get votes. So it's like war, but with voting not weapons! We can solve the taxation issue that way, since the world is whole so only one money system and we make it electronic so transactions will be taxed!
- xiaodai 6y agoTime for Yandex and Baidu to come into the Australian market. Baidu has shit tech so Yandex it is.
- squiggleblaz 6y agoI guess you're not an Australian. It's a national sport to get access to American products which the companies don't make available in Australia. If Google dropped out of the local market, everyone would just get access to it via a VPN. (Probably one that Google makes available in exchange for private data.)
- ggm 6y agobetween competing commercial entities and the government, I am unsure who is more likely to invoke "the law of un-intended consequences" as an explanation for their behaviour. Lets just say all of them are likely to do this: Not just note that there is an un-intended consequence, but actually acting to bring it on.
- aussieguy1234 6y agoGoogle should just de-list News Corp and the other big media companies that dominate the Australian media industry and who often manipulate elections for their own benefit with one sided heavily biased coverage. Give some breathing space to the smaller players.
- sthnblllII 6y agoWouldn't that just be Google manipulating coverage for Google’s benefit? I don’t think Google should be blessing any publishers with special “news section” status. Let websites compete organically. Any media with finance capital backing is going to be biased in favor of wars and against labor.
- ehsankia 6y agoThere's a difference between giving special treatment and fully de-listing, kinda like what happened in Germany and Spain with Google News. This is a direct and targeted attack by NewsCorp, abusing their influence in australian politics to force a bill that benefits them. Why should Google help someone that is trying their best to attack them?
- sthnblllII 6y agoBeing a neutral platform for speech is not ‘helping’ anyone. It helps the ideas the public agrees with the most, which is why Google and Newscorp are fighting to control internet media with backroom ‘partnerships’ rather than giving viewpoints that are actually popular a fair playing field.
- Polylactic_acid 6y agoThe quality of news would triple if they removed all newscorp sites. They could just use ABC news purely and the quality would be far better.
- golemiprague 6y agoDominate or not they represent half of the Australian population more or less. You can't just bring news from the Guardian and expect it to appeal to all Australian. The question is, if you don't want to show News Corp what else will you show in order to give a voice for the Australians on the right side of the political map?
- holografix 6y agoIf anyone is smart enough and patient enough to understand the new law could they comment on these points? 1. How will Johnny little guy’s “news blog” benefit from this? Could they require google pay them to display their headlines on search? 2. Will the revenue passed on to the Murdochs be taxed by the Aus gov? Ie: another way to capture tax from Google operating in Aus? 3. What are the foreseeable outcomes of say, no news results are displayed on Google search and people have to visit the news websites directly? Ie: what I often do when I see an interesting article I can not read, I google for it and find a news site that _will_ let me read it.
- hkt 6y agoI tried to work out why I'm so unbelievably torn about this, and I've concluded that it's because this is a "whoever wins, we lose" circumstance. Both the press and Google are nightmarish creatures.
- fouc 6y agoI don't like the "free services" wording in the letter. Free services shouldn't be a justification for anything.
- ricardo81 6y agoIndeed. Free here = subsidised by the not-so-privacy-sensitive ad system, and their argument is worrying about user privacy.
- wombatmobile 6y agoObviously the Australian government is trying to make google pay just because Murdoch told it to. But the pretense is bizarre - that google has to pay Murdoch because it steals his content. Google doesn't republish News Corp content! It just lists headlines with URLs that readers click to go through to News Corp! Google is giving News Corp 70% of its traffic. Bizarre. What's to stop google from simply ceasing to index News Corp at all? The fact that it doesn't, and instead runs a scary PR campaign, tells me there's something going on that I don't understand. But what?
- sossles 6y agoI imagine Google would rather continue to serve up those search results if possible. And if they did omit the search results their argument that they treat content fairly falls apart.
- eru 6y ago> And if they did omit the search results their argument that they treat content fairly falls apart. Why? That's just the same as respecting robots.txt, isn't it?
- sjy 6y agoNot indexing news content in order to avoid submitting to the proposed new law is itself prohibited under the new law.
- LatteLazy 6y agoConspiracy theory time: that's what this is really about. Murdoch (Fox etc) know that they are next after Facebook gets done banning qanon nonsense. If Google audited the accuracy of Murdoch owned sources, it would have good reason to start delisting them. Murdoch knows he can't afford that. So this isn't about getting 1p per 1000 views or something. It's about being assured a high search result placement for his disinformation.
- 6y ago
- DecoPerson 6y agoThe legislation [0] gives all news businesses (including smaller ones) a pathway to force Google to enter into an agreement with them. It opens up Google and Facebook to world of costly business dealings. With little effort, I could start “Deco’s Local Newspaper” and publish a few issues online. This will give me a pathway to force Google to “deal with me.” This negotiation, mediation and arbitration could incur Google thousands of dollars in employee time, arbitration fees, and paying for half of the legal costs. Google cannot say “no” from the start. They can’t even ignore me without being in violation of the new legislation. Relevant snippets: “... news media businesses can participate in the code if: - They predominantly produce ‘core news’, and publish this online: [...] - They adhere to appropriate professional editorial standards: [...] - They maintain editorial independence from the subjects of their news coverage: [...] - They operate primarily in Australia for the purpose of serving Australian audiences: [...]” “If the parties have not reached an agreement for the inclusion of news on digital platform services within three months of negotiation, and the parties have attended at least one day of mediation, news media businesses can elect to commence arbitration.” “Arbitration under the code would be performed through ‘final offer arbitration’. The digital platform and news media business (or a collective of news media businesses) must each submit a final offer on the remuneration to be paid by the digital platform within 10 days of the commencement of arbitration. Parties would then have a further 5 business days to provide comments on each other’s offer.” “After receiving submissions and comments from the parties and the ACCC, the arbitrator would have 30 business days to choose one or the other of the parties’ ‘final offers’, which would form a binding agreement between the parties.” Therefore: I can force Google to enter into an agreement with me (even as a small business) and incur thousands of dollars of overhead costs in the process. I’m not one to use hyperbole, but this is insane. I would not be surprised if Google turns off Google Search entirely for Australia when this code passes. Also, this legislation is specifically for Google and Facebook: “Digital platforms must participate in the code if the Treasurer makes a determination specifying that the code would apply to them. The Government has announced that the code would initially apply only to Facebook and Google. Other digital platforms may be added to the code if they hold a significant bargaining power imbalance with Australian news media businesses in the future.” This also seems strange, though I’m not against legislation specifically for mega-corps. Small businesses / startups are already hard enough to start with all the legislation they need to comply with, so protecting them from irrelevant codes like this is healthy for industry. [0] https://www.accc.gov.au/system/files/DPB%20-%20Draft%20news%20media%20and%20digital%20platforms%20mandatory%20bargaining%20code%20Q%26As.pdf#page5 https://www.accc.gov.au/system/files/DPB%20-%20Draft%20news%...
- harry8 6y agoOpen comment from an Australian to google: "Pay your f#$king tax like the rest of us or shut the f%$ck up." This comment stands apart from any and all implications of their special interest policy pleadings above which are all pretty tedious in comparison. Google don't pay tax for profit made selling in Australia. To hell with them and literally any case they have to make.
- nl 6y agoBe that as it may, News Corp doesn't pay tax in Australia either, and I don't see why Google should have to pay what is effectively a tax to them! Make them pay tax by all means, but why should it go straight to news corp?
- knorker 6y agoTo hell with "them"? Are you saying Australians should cut off their nose to spite their face? I think you missed the whole point of this letter. Let me clarify: "Oi mate, the government wants to force us to fuck you royally. We don't want to. Please help stop yourself getting fucked. Cheers, cunt."
- chris_wot 6y agoAnd here is another Australian who says "Oi mate, Google don't want to pay taxes for profits they made in Australia. They don't want to invest in schools, universities, infrastructure or anything else through reasonable taxation. Google are fucking over Australians".
- knorker 6y agoBut it's orthogonal. It's like you're saying you want to be fucked by both Google and the government. Why do two wrongs make a right, to you? Again: cutting off your nose to spite your face.
- shard972 6y agoWhy would it be a net loss to australia or any other nation if they instead just developed search engines locally? Is search really so impossible that only in America can they can possibly get enough talent to do web search? At a time when Australia is wanting to expand it's technology sector, seems like a simple solution if google just leaves and it's replaced by an local company that is willing to pay its fair share.
- einpoklum 6y ago> The law would force us to give an unfair advantage to one group of businesses - news media businesses - over everyone else They already give unfair advantage to mainstream news media over other sources of news and commentary. They artificially boost "credible sources" or "reliable sources" or whatever they call them; and also refrain entirely from recommending some sources which they disapprove of (right-wing, left-wing, world states which oppose the US etc.). On YouTube this has been very apparent in the list of recommended videos (at least if you're reading about US and world news). On the search engine itself it may be less pronounced, but they are actively doing that as well to some extent; see: https://www.wsj.com/articles/how-google-interferes-with-its-search-algorithms-and-changes-your-results-11573823753 https://www.wsj.com/articles/how-google-interferes-with-its-... or if you can't get past the Paywall, see: https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2019/11/18/pers-n18.html https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2019/11/18/pers-n18.html
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- cryptica 6y agoThis letter is seriously weird. Shows a clash between two different lobby groups; neither of which actually cares about citizens. I think the quality of news has degenerated severely since it's been put in the hands of Google and Facebook and so I don't even know how to think about this issue. This does make a case for increased competition in both the search and news space though.
- markthien 6y agoFascism australia
- kelnos 6y agoI imagine there's going to be a very strong knee-jerk anti-Google reaction here, but let's stop and think about the law itself. If it actually does what this open letter says it does, then it's a bad law, plain and simple, and we should support and applaud efforts -- even Google's -- to inform the public with the hope of changing things.
- mianos 6y agoI'd vote they just delist news.com.au. It's a PIA when some search returns tags.news.com.au that is blocked by pihole. It's a cesspit of news biased news anyway. Sure, other newspapers are biased as hell and many just a voice for some ignorant opinion or blind agenda, but they are quaint in the naivety. News.com.au is an organised propaganda machine.
- rapind 6y agoIf the problem is that Google will be forced to share data with news media... maybe just stop collecting data then, so there's nothing to hand over?
- 9nGQluzmnq3M 6y agoThe Australian Competition & Consumer Commission's response: https://www.accc.gov.au/media-release/response-to-google-open-letter https://www.accc.gov.au/media-release/response-to-google-ope... HN discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24185374 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24185374
- paulcarroty 6y agoI just remember for non-Australians and Australians too: if you still use Bitbucket, Jira, or another Atlassian products - think about the privacy right now.
- TheButlerian 6y agoAustralia is a authoritarian hellhole, check their Covid-19 response for example or the crazy society controlling laws they have in place. A possible way to counter it would be for the big IT companies to grow a pair - when someone puts such crazy regulation - ban ALL the country from the services and leak ALL the citizens data they have - photos, emails, videos...
- dutch3000 6y agogoogle search is already going down the tubes. for example, i search every variation of “when is grass fungus active” and am served up with results on how to cure grass fungus. just one example of many in how there search engine cannot deal with different angles to a search and has huge delivery buckets that aren’t useful, if you need a more granular search ability
- 627467 6y ago> A proposed law, the News Media Bargaining Code, would force us to provide you with a dramatically worse Google Search and YouTube, could lead to your data being handed over to big news businesses, and would put the free services you use at risk in Australia. The last point particularly reads as extortion. I get why those under Murdoch umbrella hate it so much but is picking another evil the only option?
- runxel 6y agoWhat we see here is a final rebellion of the big media companies worldwide. In Germany we have seen something similar. In the end, it's highway robbery: Google is made to pay to the mediacorp, but it is not allowed to de-index them either. Perfect scenario – you've succesfully made a cashcow! Google is by far not the good guy here, but rest assured, I hope all those big media outlets burn.
- liveoneggs 6y agoFrom the letter: > We’ve always treated all website owners fairly when it comes to information we share about ranking. Really? https://twitter.com/methode/status/1166643751659429888 https://twitter.com/methode/status/1166643751659429888 > The law would force us to give an unfair advantage to one group of businesses - news media businesses - over everyone else who has a website, YouTube channel or small business Google is concerned it can no longer pick winners and losers. I don't prefer News Corp, obviously, but it's just lies lies lies on both sides trying to control money funnels. I assume google has other knobs like just making advertising in .au super expensive (they have a monopoly on that side too) but the battle will end up being bloody.
- runeks 6y ago> Really? https://twitter.com/methode/status/1166643751659429888 https://twitter.com/methode/status/1166643751659429888 What is this about? I can’t tell from the tweet.
- liveoneggs 6y agoit is a google employee picking a winner of an algo update
- program_whiz 6y agoSurprised no one is saying this. Every generation has to relearn what many have realized over the centuries: power corrupts, absolute power corrupts absolutely. The only way to avoid people "abusing" other people is to make that situation impossible (both parties having power that other cannot take). If you create a situation with the tools of power just sitting in the open, and only one party can use it, then you will have abuses. This logic applies to governments, corporations, and ordinary people (think of the tyrannical managers we've all had at some point). Its an unchangeable facet of human nature. As long as the weapon/tool is on the table, and there are enough people, someone who is a bit more sociopathic, greedy, or has more emotional turmoil will pick it up and wield it against other people for their own gain. For examples see: all of history whenever a person / civilization had any advantage over another person / civilization and sufficient time elapsed. Its kinda crazy but everyone always thinks that some new power / invention that creates a one-sided situation like this will "only be used for good", imagining that the people using these tools will be benevolent (for all people who could use the tool, and all the time the tool exists).