9 ms·
My son's state university is forcing students to return in person. I fully expect a notable outbreak in some college to start a wave of media noise, followed b
by tyingq 6y ago
My son's state university is forcing students to return in person.
I fully expect a notable outbreak in some college to start a wave of media noise, followed by all the universities sending everyone back home again.
Sucks because students are signing leases, moving crap, buying meal plans, etc, right now. Aside from the obvious safety issues.
- epmaybe 6y agoIt's absurd here in my state as well. We have peak number of cases in one of the biggest college towns, and students are moving in as we speak. I give it two or three weeks before we cancel everything again. As an aside, equally scummy are universities that pulled the rug from under students very close to move in. My sister got kicked out of her housing by the university a few days before move in, and basically had to accept that she would be staying home for the fall, as rent prices near school nearly doubled overnight.
- neltnerb 6y agoI hate to be all like "to be fair" but wouldn't it have been even worse if they'd waited until after she moved there and then sent her home and made her move twice instead of canceling a move once? Do you mean they're still having in-person classes required but are just not offering housing? That's definitely scummy, that's the kind of thing that would have changed people's admission acceptance decisions.
- epmaybe 6y agoSome in person classes, yes. My sister luckily only has online ones. Regarding when, I think the obvious answer should have been to cancel in person classes back in may or June.. We knew covid was here to last even then.
- pc86 6y agoAre you in Pennsylvania because that sounds exactly like my experience. I'm extremely thankful that I graduated long ago and don't have children or relatives having to deal with this.
- JCharante 6y ago> as rent prices near school nearly doubled overnight. Wait is that really what happened? I anticipated that rent prices would drop because most students would just go home and there wouldn't be a market for people wanting to live in the college part of town.
- ghaff 6y agoI know a number of students attending virtually in the fall who are renting near campus with their friends.
- epmaybe 6y agoBut isn't that worsening the problem? Going to a college town with friends is a recipe for community spread
- Buge 6y agoWorse compared to what? Compared to living together and attending class in person it's an improvement.
- CincinnatiMan 6y agoThe kids likely don’t care. Their age group is largely unharmed by coronavirus, so the option to be near their friends, partying, and not living at home is probably pretty appealing.
- epmaybe 6y agoI imagine some ended up dropping down, I'd have to ask her
- neltnerb 6y agoLeases seem like the worst aspect of this, at least a return flight is only half a month's rent (one would hope). I agree that you are correct about this, even here in Boston we've just got so many colleges that even if the one I work at has no problems Boston in general seems likely to have a big enough uptick that it will impact everyone. That's a lot of students traveling here by plane all at once and even if they're quarantining when they arrive I bet their parents aren't...
- danso 6y agoStanford cancelling on-campus education definitely feels like a major bellwether. It's hard to think of any school better positioned to make it work. Not just because of its wealth and elite status, but because the climate is so aggressively warm and non-rainy, and the spacious campus absolutely has the space (though perhaps not the seating/tables, at least initially) to accommodate all-outdoor classes and activities.
- gilbetron 6y agoStanford and a number of the well positioned universities can weather the storm, which is why the are cancelling in person after hoping not to. https://www.profgalloway.com/uss-university https://www.profgalloway.com/uss-university
- DataWorker 6y agoAs with everything related to the pandemic, it kills the smaller competitors making those who will survive, schools like Stanford, Harvard, businesses like apple and google, have an even greater market dominance than before.
- kritiko 6y agoApple and Google would be happy to have everybody in the world as their customer. Stanford and Harvard, while offering some non-selective continuing ed / MOOC programs that leverage their name, are not looking to increase their enrollment for traditional degrees. Their exclusivity is part of their appeal.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoUIUC in Champaign/Urbana (Illinois) is still bringing everyone back to campus. A friend just moved his son into the dorms this week.
- kidfood 6y agoNot everyone, most classes are still online, and if you want you can not take any in person classes, even for lower tuition. Many of my friends are opting to stay home next semester.
- dustingetz 6y agoThey are transferring economic losses to the students/parent
- elliekelly 6y agoThis is my biggest concern. They’re going to charge students full price, force them on campus along with all the expense that entails, and once the bursar’s office is sufficiently flush send them all home again. Considering every college in America takes federal student loan money this seems like a really easy place for the federal government to take decisive action to force a semester online and cap charges for the benefit of students and the federal budget.
- pgrote 6y ago>I fully expect a notable outbreak in some college to start a wave of media, followed by all the universities sending everyone back home again. If you are referring to the USA, I disagree. Unless the local county health departments or states require schools to go virtual, I don't see it. If a large public university experiences an outbreak, I don't think they will go virtual until someone dies. I do not think large private schools will go virtual unless the government requires it. The USA has no centralized method of handling the pandemic, so each state is making their own rules and guidelines. We have professional sports teams playing outside bubbles and many college football programs are continuing. Many school districts outside urban areas are opening and seeing outbreaks, but continue to stay open. As a country, we blew it and seem to have decided to go about this piecemeal. I hope your son and your family stay well. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/08/12/us/georgia-school-coronavirus.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/08/12/us/georgia-school-coronav... https://www.axios.com/coronavirus-america-blew-it-b3d84ea3-78b3-4fe0-8dce-1c4ed0ec0a4c.html https://www.axios.com/coronavirus-america-blew-it-b3d84ea3-7...
- tyingq 6y agoMy experience has been that schools cave pretty fast in the face of media pressure. Edit: Especially if fueled by some notable event.
- pgrote 6y ago>My experience has been that schools cave pretty fast in the face of media pressure. Before now I would agree with you. From what has been reported schools in Georgia, Alabama, Mississippi, Oklahoma and Indiana are staying open after large outbreaks. These are elementary and high schools, so maybe it'll be different with universities. https://www.cnn.com/2020/08/13/us/schools-quarantined-coronavirus/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2020/08/13/us/schools-quarantined-corona...
- CincinnatiMan 6y agoUniversities have a brand to uphold and students go to them by choice versus lower education, so I could see there being a difference due to that.
- chongli 6y agoSucks because students are signing leases, moving crap, buying meal plans, etc, right now. This is the whole reason schools want students back. They’re desperate to recover some of this cash flow. They have huge budgets and vast numbers of administrative staff to pay. Without the revenue from residence leases and meal plans, they’re in real trouble.
- watwut 6y agoFrom all these, only mean plans money go to university? If they are signing leases, it suggests they live outside of university.
- chongli 6y agoLots of universities own residence buildings on and around campus. Students sign leases with the university directly.
- owenmarshall 6y agoSome private universities go as far as mandating undergraduates live in campus housing for up to three years.
- __sisyphus__ 6y agoI attended a private college. Not only did I have to live on campus for all four years, but additionally, they forced you to purchase the meal plan. I made most of my meals myself; nonetheless, I had no choice but to pay for the meal plan.
- seanmcdirmid 6y agoSome public universities do that as well.
- bob33212 6y agoThe value offered by colleges is not just an education. It is 4 years of living away from home experiencing whatever floats your boat ( frats, independence, parties, sports, friends, etc... ). There is virtually no demand for online only classes above a 5k/year price point. There is a similar situation with private schools. Some of the demand comes from the fact that it is also a babysitting service, forced social group, networking opportunity for parents.
- huffmsa 6y agoYeah but there are outbreaks of everything at the beginning of the school year, at all levels. Flu, mono, the clap. It's why you're supposed to be up to date on your vaccinations. It's just what happens when a bunch of people who've been in separate microbiomes come together and start sharing the same air.
- chrisseaton 6y agoFreshers’ flu we used to call it. And everyone getting physical in the first couple of weeks means it spreads very quickly.
- huffmsa 6y agoI was sick most of my freshman year. Went to school halfway across the country. Entirely new set of viruses versus what I was used to. Happens to people who move to different countries too. Common enough in basic training that it's got a nickname as well. https://afwm.org/life-during-bmt/bmt-illnesses/ https://afwm.org/life-during-bmt/bmt-illnesses/
- castratikron 6y agoI'm convinced I nearly died during my first semester. Swine flu, pneumonia and a throat infection all in the course of a month. Anyone who thinks this won't spread through a college doesn't have a clue.
- benibela 6y agoBut there is no mono or clap vaccine?
- bachmeier 6y ago> I fully expect a notable outbreak in some college to start a wave of media noise, followed by all the universities sending everyone back home again. I'd be surprised if that happened. Stanford's in a heavily populated part of California. It might make sense for them, based on the student population (mostly rich or at least well off) and location. My university has plans to keep students in campus housing even if we're forced to go 100% online, and I think from a public health perspective, that's a good thing. You don't want college students moving around if you have an outbreak. And once they're home, they're definitely not going to all just sit in the basement - they'll still be going to bars and parties. That would be a disaster. And the only place that there's hope they'll be tested or interact with others that are tested is on campus. > My son's state university is forcing students to return in person. That's horrible. As much as possible, we're accommodating students that feel safer online. About the only way I could see someone being forced to return is if their remaining credits were a lab science class. The worst thing you can possibly do is increase the density on campus. Everyone here is encouraged to work off campus as much as possible. Many of our courses are online or hybrid, where you reserve the in-person interactions for the parts where it delivers real value over the alternative. It's that 20% where face to face matters, not the other 80%.
- matz1 6y agoSo what if its outbreak? Why afraid? We know by now that vast majority of people will be fine.
- amanaplanacanal 6y agoCulling the herd of the weak is probably not the college experience most people are looking for.
- mensetmanusman 6y agoIsn’t that why 25% drop off after the first year? They move on to jobs that take 10-20 years off of their life spans (manual trades, high stess, etc.)
- ketamine__ 6y agoBut also the college students probably aren't interested in policing the cafeteria in an attempt to reduce the 600,000+ deaths from heart disease every year. I'm not sure we can take your comment seriously.
- throwaway0a5e 6y ago>Sucks because students are signing leases, moving crap, buying meal plans, etc, right now. Aside from the obvious safety issues. Follow the money. The colleges are getting paid regardless. The local landlords, businesses, etc. that usually get to skim easy money off college students don't. The colleges have to walk the line between screwing the students by giving them all covid (bad press -> less money) and pissing off the locals, who will just use their voting power to use the local government to take money (less favorable regulator environment -> less money) from the colleges if the colleges don't let them skim enough gravy.
- harambae 6y agoI'm glad someone said this because this was my take as well. Here's Notre Dame's tracker: https://here.nd.edu/our-approach/dashboard/ https://here.nd.edu/our-approach/dashboard/ My theory is that the semester will be shut down just in time for nobody to get their money back (where students otherwise would have taken a gap year or something). Maybe I'm just cynical.
- jnwatson 6y ago"Forcing". There's no one forcing anybody to go to college. This would be a fine time to take a gap year.
- hpkuarg 6y agoNot really! What would one do in a gap year during a pandemic?
- tyingq 6y agoA gap year isn't free, and they are taking classes that are mandatory to graduate off the table for online. Also, a gap year at this time? Fun.
- amanaplanacanal 6y agoExactly! With any luck there will be a vaccine available before fall 2021, which should make things look much better next year.
- draw_down 6y agoThen next year you’re trying to matriculate with the current class plus all the people from your class that skipped a year. I’m not saying people should go to school. I wouldn’t if I were this age. But it’s not exactly as simple as peacing out for a year and then coming back. It will be a huge mess.
- FuckButtons 6y agoAnd do what? Get a job? go traveling? This would be a fucking awful time to take a gap year, the fact that this seems to be the prevailing solution on here is indicative of just how out of touch some of the readership is.
- onecommentman 6y agoIf you are a freshman or sophomore and you have a modicum of self-discipline and motivation, it can be a great strategy. You know those core courses at which you want to excel but will suck up most your time? Do you realize how much easier they will be if you’ve already read the textbook twice over and listened to an online lecture course or two? Maybe even audited an actual online course from another university? Maybe found out what the assignments will be and did most of them. A C in the online audited course at a community college will lead to an A when you actually take it next year and with half the effort. If you get through as much of this year’s core course material as you can stand, keep on going with next year’s courses. "Finish" organic chem the first half-year? "Do" biochem the second. If you nail half the concepts before you take the course, you can focus on the other concepts during the course. Professors start noticing you because you did so well. You bring up advanced topics in conversations and get invited to work in the lab. You get a good rep and the benefit of the doubt. Bonus tip: find a professor whose support you’d like to have and read some of their recent papers or watch their presentations. Contact them with good questions about their work. Free time is an amazing ally if you use it right. No, I’m not an Asian tiger mom...wrong gender, wrong ethnicity.
- chrisjarvis 6y agoYour son wants to be there in person and he is at no danger from the coronavirus... EDIT: *infinitesimal danger
- bitxbitxbitcoin 6y agoThat is a lot of assumptions to be making. It's pretty irresponsible to say that someone is at no danger from coronavirus at this point.
- chrisjarvis 6y agoif that person is 18-22 years old, given the data, how is it irresponsible?
- doctor_eval 6y agoA 20 year old died of cv this week here in Victoria. Everybody is at risk, it’s just that the curve “favours” older people. You know, like professors, admin staff, mature students, parents and grandparents, ...
- ketamine__ 6y agoWas he obese? I only ask because many of the younger patients have comorbities that make them vulnerable to many diseases. And vaccines don't work as well for the obese either.
- doctor_eval 6y agoIt doesn’t matter. The problem is that the people who don’t get sick, make other people sick.
- paul_f 6y ago500 children die of influenza in the US each year. COVID is far less of a threat to young people. We have to make tradeoffs and having kids in college and not at home with parents and grandparents is a good solution
- analog31 6y agoYup, both of my kids are in college, at different schools, and pretty much everybody fully expects that school will last for a couple weeks, then they'll send everybody home. The savvy ones are signing up for exclusively online courses.
- anonytrary 6y agoIf anything, we'll observe the outcome of this experiment and use the results the help inform future course of action. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯