18 ms·
The best Parts of Visual Studio Code are proprietary
- 1337shadow 6y ago> If you have good suggestions for strong collaborative development tools that are open source, please let me know What about screen + vim|emacs ? That's how pair programing have been going for ages right ?
- pjmlp 6y agoJust like many other products, developers have bills to pay.
- Dylan16807 6y agoHuh? The developers at microsoft get paid no matter how the company licenses things.
- toadi 6y agoHuh, where is the companies money coming from ?
- Dylan16807 6y agoSelling windows and office, generally. The licensing of these extensions is mostly irrelevant to their plan and the reason they spend money on this development.
- pjmlp 6y agoThese extensions are gateways into selling Microsoft infrastructure services.
- tenuousemphasis 6y ago1. Azure public cloud, Windows Server, SQL Server, GitHub and enterprise services ($13.4b) 2. Windows, search, Surface and Xbox ($12.9b) 3. Office, Dynamics and LinkedIn ($11.7b)
- pjmlp 6y agoMicrosoft is not a charity, they also need to get money.
- Dylan16807 6y agoAnd they wouldn't get money if they licensed these extensions differently?
- pjmlp 6y agoFor the same reasons that not all compilers built on top of LLVM are 100% open source, monetization strategies for other products. In this case, selling Azure based services on Microsoft infrastructure.
- nudpiedo 6y agoCan't they keep this marketing strategy in order to keep their platform competitive or whatever strategic plan they follow?
- diffeomorphism 6y agoFreedom != free beer
- pjmlp 6y agoMany here seem to share other opinion. Every time there is a product being post, rains posts of free beer alternatives with half of the features.
- mFixman 6y agoVim?
- sudhirj 6y agoYes and no. The complaint is that some widely used extensions are proprietary. If these extensions require MS servers, then they have every reason to be. Even if they don't, there's nothing wrong with a company holding back some stuff they consider strategic, they're not obligated to release them. If we're debating the OSS credentials of VSCode, it'll need to be based on the code already released (which makes it a pretty great OSS editor) and the current team of people the company has devoted to maintaining that OSS section of the product (also pretty great). Arguing that there are some extensions that are closed source and that's bad is a bit weird, especially when we can just make an open sourced extension that does the same thing.
- readarticle 6y agoSome additional salt in this particular wound is that the use of the Marketplace of VS Code extensions is also proprietarily licensed. So all these open source developers are shoving their extensions into a competitive advantage for one of the world's largest tech firms. What does this mean in practice? I guess it protects from the competition. Such as the VS Codium project which provides VS Code binaries without the proprietary parts. But also, as a consequence of this, without the Marketplace of extensions.
- CiTyBear 6y agoI don't think it says "Software not open-source is bad". But more something like "It is marketed as open source but it is not". Developers should be aware that VSCode is not as open source as it claims it is. In my circles, developers could swear VSCode is fully open source without even knowing VSCodium. If people were more aware about this, they might think twice before using VSCode for everything and getting lock-in (just like the article says)
- GordonS 6y agoI know full well about VSCodium, but choose not to use it. For all intents and purposes, VSCode is open source - the source code it freely avaibale on github under an MIT license. AFAIK only the installer and some extensions are not open source - that plainly doesn't mean VSCode itself isn't open source. VSCode is a fantastic tool, and I'd prefer to use it directly from Microsoft. I am aware that there is telemetry, and as someone conscious of privacy concerns I've looked at what telemetry is sent - I'm satisfied it's anonymised sufficiently and benign enough not to affect my privacy. If the VSCode team really find this data useful, then I'm happy to provide it and help improve VSCode. I do however think that telemetry in VSCode should be opt-in rather than opt-out.
- the_gipsy 6y agoJust use vim.
- sjellis 6y agoI really like VS Code, but am definitely wary of the way that it intermingles open source, proprietary code and remote services. For that reason, I use the VSCodium build most of the time. You definitely need to take responsibility and read the documentation for each extension that you decide to install. You may be surprised. I would also disagree with the article and recommend that you disable telemetry, unless you specifically decide that you want that copy of VS Code and those extensions to send data. I understand the value of telemetry data, but I think that turning it on by default is unethical: software should not be written to automatically transmit data to remote systems without explicit user consent.
- mschuster91 6y ago> but I think that turning it on by default is unethical Not to mention illegal in the EU without explicit informed consent. Accept-by-default etc have been ruled illegal by courts many times.
- blackoil 6y agoDoes telemetry include any GDPR data?
- mschuster91 6y agoOf course it does, the IP address alone is viewed as PII.
- esperent 6y agoWhat makes you think they log IP addresses?
- mschuster91 6y agoUnder GDPR any kind of data processing falls under the protection umbrella. And that includes the data processing that automatically happens during the creation of a TCP/IP connection - where the recipient party automatically gains knowledge of the IP address of the other side. For a web site itself this is generally fine as it is a technical necessity and intended by the user... however stuff that is not necessary to fulfill the user intention such as any kind of tracking or telemetry is opt-in only. And yes this was and is the explicit intention why the GDPR was passed in the first place: get rid of involuntary tracking, telemetry and other data thefts.
- skohan 6y agoI can be counted as one of the skeptics of MS's open-source efforts. It just seems to me that MS's history and recent investment in open-source puts us in a quantum state between two possibilities: 1. MS has changed their ways, and has become an altruist organization which just wants to give developers things of value for free so they might hopefully choose Azure when they decide what cloud provider to run on. 2. MS is embedding themselves in the open-source community in such a way that it's almost unavoidable to make use of their proprietary tools without even realizing it, and they will use that to their advantage against competitors and developers. It's just hard for me to think that the second possibility won't become increasingly true to the extent that MS gains the leverage to get away with it. As a side-note, I think MS's marketing for VSCode has been very effective. As an editor, I don't see an advantage over 𝚖̶𝚘̶𝚛̶𝚎̶ ̶𝚘̶𝚙̶𝚎̶𝚗̶ less corporate alternatives like SublimeText, and I actually don't like the "install this plugin" spam in the bottom right corner.
- chongli 6y agoMS is embedding themselves in the open-source community in such a way that it's almost unavoidable to make use of their proprietary tools Embrace, extend, and extinguish [1]. It’s practically Microsoft’s motto. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Embrace,_extend,_and_extinguish https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Embrace,_extend,_and_extinguis...
- skrebbel 6y agoHow is Sublime Text more open? It's closed source.
- Deukhoofd 6y agoThe best parts of Code are the editor functions. If I had to name the good parts of Code I wouldn't even think about LiveShare, it's mostly a gimmick I've looked at once or twice. As for the marketplace, most extensions link to their github repositories, from where you can download and install the extensions. The marketplace itself is mostly a convenience thing.
- ShamelessC 6y agoI had never even heard of LiveShare until today.
- naikrovek 6y agoLiveShare is pretty great.
- AJRF 6y agoTrue that the marketplace has some weird rules (I think there is an online instance of VSCode, that scrapes Github for plugins that have permissive licenses to show them in the Marketplace tab - essentially a forked marketplace) - but the best bits of VSCode are open. Remote plugin, terminal, marketplace are less valuable in an engineering sense than the actual editor itself. Monaco, Monarch & LSP are projects that are directly or tangentially related to the VSCode project are they are MIT licensed and have astounding capability. Have a look at the editor API for Monaco - its extremely well engineered. I for one am extremely thankful that these projects are open source because those are they genuinely impressive bits of engineering from VSCode.
- sorennielsen 6y agoThat's one reason that I have started paying attention to the Theia project. I like to keep things open. Link: https://theia-ide.org/ https://theia-ide.org/
- fergie 6y agoIf, as the author says, live collaboration is important, then its probably much better to rely on GNU screen or similar. It follows therefore that you should then be using an editor that can run inside of a terminal such as Vi or Emacs. Also, the revelation that Visual Studio Code is not in fact as open source-y as it could be should come as a surprise to nobody
- recrof 6y agoIs android not considered opensource enough because it uses google play services?
- ShamelessC 6y agoI mean, yeah? That's a common attack against Google and the reason ungoogled forks of Android exist.
- rubber_duck 6y ago> It also frustrates me that this prevents someone from building a compatible plugin for VIM or any other editor. This would be much more powerful if it could be in all the IntelliJs as well. VS Code implementation could be used to implement VIM because VIM can use language server infrastructure etc. IntelliJ would be a game changer for me but Microsoft OSS-ing their implementation would have 0 impact on this - IntelliJ uses their own language analysis infrastructure, FS, etc. and they shown no interest in using language server protocol.
- anaisbetts 6y agoI mean, if you don't like that then you probably shouldn't be using Google Chrome because it has similarly proprietary bits (geolocation, translation are a few examples, but there are afaik ~30-50). Firefox most likely does as well.
- dependenttypes 6y agoI think that most linux distros package chromium instead of Chrome for this reason.
- diffeomorphism 6y agoIf you don't know, you shouldn't throw accusations. Also at least for firefox and chromium (but not chrome) you can look at the source.
- anaisbetts 6y agoI absolutely Do Know
- brainless 6y agoWould anyone think this is any different from open core offerings from many other companies?
- AshamedCaptain 6y agoAnd even the C++ intellicode/parser extension is proprietary. But no, last time this was mentioned, it was downvoted to oblivion. "But, you see, they put the intellicode C++ extension in Github, so it must be opensource!" Wrong. They are just using Github to distribute binaries. If you download the vsix file from either github or the vscode extension repos, you will find a 10MB binary called cpptools that was not there in the source tarball. The extension does nothing without it.
- acqq 6y agoYour claim is supported by the "Offline installation" section of: https://github.com/microsoft/vscode-cpptools https://github.com/microsoft/vscode-cpptools "The extension has platform-specific binary dependencies, therefore installation via the Marketplace requires an Internet connection in order to download additional dependencies. If you are working on a computer that does not have access to the Internet or is behind a strict firewall, you may need to use our platform-specific packages and install them by running VS Code's "Install from VSIX..." command. These "offline' packages are available at: https://github.com/Microsoft/vscode-cpptools/releases." https://github.com/Microsoft/vscode-cpptools/releases."
- AshamedCaptain 6y agoNo, not at all . Platform specific does not mean proprietary. In fact, the same vsix also contains a lldb and a mono binary ( which are platform dependent) but these are opensource and in fact build scripts are provided. It is the hidden cpptools binary which has no source that is the problem. And that one is not that well announced. So lot of people think the extension is opensource when the important bits are not.
- acqq 6y ago> It is the hidden cpptools binary which has no source that is the problem. Anybody knows what that binary does?
- 6y ago
- zxter 6y agoThis feels like free to play but pay to win kind of games, or cheap base game to release to poison, countless expensive DLCs. But instead of money, it is freedom. Just because of this I prefer open source projects from smaller developers that are built with labor of love, instead of from big corporate businesses that will eventually try to use you for any kind of profit. Since topic is similar, I would like to recommend onivim 2 [0] for who prefer vi bindings. It is almost out of alpha and in pretty usable stage. Currently they are integrating open-vsx. Project is open source with dual license and it is currently very cheap for who wants to support, or free to build from source to try. [0] https://www.onivim.io/ https://www.onivim.io/
- x3c 6y agoIt's the same strategy that Google follows for Android. The secret juice of the Android app ecosystem is in the Google Play services... And that's entirely proprietary. So even though the OS is open source, it's impossible to truly build an alternative ecosystem. I agree with the author that the marketing rings falsey.
- PostThisTooFast 6y agoMy favorite is how there's no way to PRINT. Pathetic.
- nudpiedo 6y agoI do not understand people with allergy to non OSS. Compare that to any google service which barely releases the clients as open source, and the clients usually are so complex that may need quite long time to get any professional developer productive in such complex code bases. Also being tied to a controlled protocol, set of libraries, cloud infrastructure which does actually keep your data is in fact the actual evil that Free Software wanted to save us. At the end it is just corporations fighting for their users and giving free candy (OSS Clients) so they get some traction. I do not expect that to change and I do not thing companies should either keep their servers OSS just for the sake of keeping OSS folks happy. I am more concerned about law compliance and companies respecting my rights, and providing good user support when necessary. Also the next freedom battle should be to accept any system to plug in to any other "cloud" provider service (as much as we do with electricity, phone, etc) and in this regard Microsoft is way ahead of Google and Apple yet still far from an utopian free interexchangeable stack.
- fsflover 6y ago> I am more concerned about law compliance and companies respecting my rights What about rights to study, modify, share the software? Yes, sometimes they are important: https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/free-software-even-more-important.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/free-software-even-more-impor...
- nudpiedo 6y agoThese aren't rights under any legal system but concessions given by a license (or privileges if you prefer this term). Actually the OSS movement and FS won the battle long ago: we are flooded with millions of OSS projects and the largest problem we have it is not anymore closed protocols or lack of knowledge anymore. And I do not think it is reasonable to expect every single project from every single company to be open source just for the sake of it. I think these privileges you mention are very important but if I am honest with you I do not think we have the moral right to demand companies to release all of their IP and code, specially if it is running in their servers and just because we stablish a customer-vendor relationship. It would feel crazy to demand such lack of privacy in other professional relations.
- alkonaut 6y agoSo don’t use liveshare? It’s still a compelling (Open source) editor without liveshare. I don’t think LiveShare is a top-10 feature of vscode. It’s one of the better unique features but that’s something else.
- chriswwweb 6y agoI thought the same, the article title is (deliberately) misleading by using the word "parts" instead of being clear and stating that some extensions that you can get from the store might not be opensource ... I had never heard of LiveShare before and have no need for it, I have lots of extensions installed and don't think any of them is proprietary
- mothsonasloth 6y agoOn the other hand you have IntelliJ which is closed source, and doesn't have any live share feature. Despite it being a highly voted feature on their feature/bug tracking site https://youtrack.jetbrains.com/issue/IDEABKL-708 https://youtrack.jetbrains.com/issue/IDEABKL-708
- matt_LLVW 6y agothe base install is open source tho: https://github.com/JetBrains/intellij-community https://github.com/JetBrains/intellij-community
- GordonS 6y ago> Despite it being a highly voted feature To be fair, this is a really complex feature to add, so it would be a serious commitment from JetBrains to build it.
- moron4hire 6y agoIt runs in a browser shell. It's got WebRTC ready to go. The hardest part of WebRTC is dealing with whatever bullshit Mozilla and Apple are doing this week, so given that browser shell is Chrome, and you can hardly walk through a computer science journal without tripping over a consensus algorithm paper these days, it's really not that complex.
- nhooyr 6y agoIntelliJ does not run in a browser shell.
- moron4hire 6y agoSorry, I still had VSCode on the brain
- jake_morrison 6y agoThe tech giants leverage the profits they get from dominating one area to compete in another. You can't build a hyperscale cloud without being able to spend billions. Amazon subsidizes AWS using their e-commerce business, Google with advertising, Microsoft with Windows/Office/etc. Microsoft has a long history of giving things away for free in order to hamstring their competitors. Netscape is the prime example. MS is very good at developer tools. How can any commercial editor compete with the amount of resources they are putting into making VS Code and giving it away for free? MS fundamentally needs their remote editing tools to support developing for Linux-based containers on Windows. Then they leverage it to debug containers running in the cloud from VS Code. But then they keep competitors from using the server side extensions. We need an open source server for this. Anti-trust needs to look at more than the monetary cost to consumers. It should consider the long term health of the ecosystem.
- nova22033 6y agoAmazon subsidizes AWS using their e-commerce business, Pretty sure AWS is more profitable and doesn't need any subsidy.
- platinumjesus93 6y agoI might have missed a key paragraph, but what is preventing anyone or any company to develop a Remote equivalent for vim or any other editor? If not already done.
- diffeomorphism 6y agoThat it is proprietary? > I read a piece of license that said that LiveShare could only be used with the Visual Studio family of products
- platinumjesus93 6y agoFrom a license specific stand point, what is exactly preventing a company or an individual to create an equivalent or even better Remote and LiveShare feature on another code editor?
- m0zg 6y agoAnd this is why, after flirting with VSCode I'm back to vim+YouCompleteMe+ctrlp. Does everything I need, 100% FOSS, works anywhere, and doesn't need a GUI.
- ciroduran 6y agoThis sounds like a very similar argument for other IDEs, such as Eclipse. You have a free IDE, with open source code, and a giant plugin ecosystem, but the plugins themselves aren't free nor open source. What's new under the sun?
- worble 6y ago>Such as the VS Codium project which provides VS Code binaries without the proprietary parts. But also, as a consequence of this, without the Marketplace of extensions. It's worth noting you can easily switch vscodium back to using the official extension marketplace by changing the product.json file as noted here: https://github.com/VSCodium/vscodium/blob/master/DOCS.md#extensions-marketplace https://github.com/VSCodium/vscodium/blob/master/DOCS.md#ext... They note the legality of this is dubious. I'm no lawyer so I can't say I understand the intricacies of this, but as far as I can tell, it's merely against the TOS of the marketplace. At worst, I imagine Microsoft would just lock the marketplace down and prevent vscodium accessing it in the future, if they see it as a big enough problem.
- naikrovek 6y agoVscodium isn't different from vscode. It IS vscode. Vscodium is merely some scripts to download the vscode source, and compile it while removing Microsoft branding.
- coldtea 6y ago>It makes me uneasy to accept VS Code as an "open" project in any wider meaning of the word when compelling features are legally locked to only work inside the family of Visual Studio products. Yeah, so? I'll still use it. And those "compelling features" were only added in the last year or so. VSCode became immensily popular sereval years before they landed. Plus, if somebody likes, they can create the same functionality as open source extensions upon the open source VSC core. Microsoft also has to create something to differentiate themselves, right? Or should it all be just free foss stuff?
- yurlungur 6y agoI can see how remote can be a vital plugin these days for some...although I can't say it makes vscode what it is. there are workarounds and it's not like remote doesn't have its own problems. LiveShare though doesn't convince me because there are existing ways of code sharing and collaboration that doesn't involve google doc style live sharing at all. In fact that pattern sounds a bit weird to me. I guess it enables pair programming if you really need it but it's completely useless to me. I use git+reviewboard to share my code and they work just fine. That said, I do think the author's larger point stand. Microsoft's good will to be open source extends only to where it wishes and in this case it's a rather limited range. I believe in the spirit of sharing code and I think sharing more is better than sharing less, which is better than not sharing at all.
- fadzlan 6y agoThe extension by design is made to be optional to use and are not integral (I would argue) to the vanilla experience of VS Code. That also means that if other people wants to create their own proprietary extensions they can do so. The basic experience of the plain VS Code does not change. Now one can say indeed that the Remote and also LiveShare is the best extension there of, and since the extension author decides not to share the code, then it stays proprietary. It's just that this time the author is Microsoft itself. But because the extension itself is not integral to the VS Code itself and merely an extension, there is no stopping anyone to create open source version of the same experience. However, where I have issues with is that, if you were to base you own editor with VS Codium (the open source, without the telemetry), you still can't use the service that is the extension marketplace for VS Code. Yes, even if it still works, and even if the extension itself is open source. Hence, just because VS Code has a lot of extensions that is open source, does not mean it is readily reusable, because the extension service is off limits. Of course, one can also publish the same extension in another public directory if they want, but currently there is no such directory exist. And it has to be republished to the new public extension directory. So yes, VS Code is open source, but the access to the extensions is not currently.
- swsieber 6y agoThere is an alternative public directory: https://open-vsx.org/ https://open-vsx.org/ It's used by vs codium and theia. It's not just those two plugins, it's also the ms-code.cpptools which has proprietary parts. And that's sad because other plugins are built on it like platformio. Which prevents platformio from being added to ovsx because the cpp tools can't be added to ovsx. Which stinks for me because the cpp proprietary parts are windows only, and all I want to use platformio from is theia running on Linux, but I can't. VS Codium: https://github.com/VSCodium/vscodium https://github.com/VSCodium/vscodium Theia IDE: https://theia-ide.org/ https://theia-ide.org/ More details about PlatformIO not being to be added to OVSX: https://github.com/open-vsx/publish-extensions/issues/86 https://github.com/open-vsx/publish-extensions/issues/86 More cpp tools licensing details: https://github.com/microsoft/vscode-cpptools/issues/5784 https://github.com/microsoft/vscode-cpptools/issues/5784 Edit: you can run theia from one computer and use it via the browser on another. That's why I was so excited for it. Edit 2: VS Codium, not open codium
- luma 6y agoThis is quite a reach. VSCode is open source. Some popular extensions are not. Neither extension used as examples here are ones that I use, so they certainly aren’t critical to the product functionality. The argument here feels akin to saying Linux is open source, but some applications available for Linux aren’t, so Linux is thus somehow not actually open source.
- HelloNurse 6y agoBeing used to the real Visual Studio, I've always regarded VS Code as a disposable, low-investment casual tool: it cannot make use of the project and solution files of its big brother, it lacks major features (e.g. the remote debugger), it is also casually engineered (e.g. no proper extension configuration GUI and very loose file caching). It's just an advanced text editor to edit files (of all types in principle, mostly Python, JavaScript and JSON in practice) and to make Git commits, not an IDE to base important work on; I've never tried to set up any sort of "project" or complex configuration. As an end user (as opposed to an extension author or "open source" contributor) I'm not particularly worried about lock-in and proprietary features because the cost of not using VS Code any more is limited to switching to a worse editor.
- lorenzfx 6y agoI don't think this is a fair assessment. This post is about two plugins (`LiveShare` and `Remote`), both by Microsoft, not being open source. None of these plugins are even mentioned on Microsoft's Visual Studio Code homepage [0]. At least LiveShare is marketed as a separate tool for which a Visual Studio Code plugin exists (as well as a Visual Studio plugin). [0] https://code.visualstudio.com/ https://code.visualstudio.com/ [1] https://visualstudio.microsoft.com/de/services/live-share/ https://visualstudio.microsoft.com/de/services/live-share/
- lozenge 6y agoMicrosoft's Python support just went closed source(pylance vs python language server) the closed sourceness is creeping in on multiple sides. IntelliCode is another closed source aspect.
- acdha 6y agoMore precisely, the Python extension is open source but the Pylance language server is not: https://github.com/Microsoft/vscode-python https://github.com/Microsoft/vscode-python https://github.com/microsoft/pylance-release https://github.com/microsoft/pylance-release
- WorldMaker 6y agoPylance is built upon the Pyright language server which is open source: https://github.com/microsoft/pyright https://github.com/microsoft/pyright I'm curious what research/IP has lead to this being a source turducken of open-closed-open, but it's not entirely closed.
- acdha 6y agoHas anyone said definitively that it wouldn't be open-source in the future? I know sometimes this is due to things like joint or contract development where the lawyers need to hash out the rights first.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- kartayyar 6y agoI am grateful that VS code is free and if they want to monetize this by having some kind of paid upsell to another product, then all power to them. They made a good product and if this is a way to fund improvements, I say it's a good thing.
- gitowiec 6y agoI don't think it is a problem (which I understood that for author is). It seems that VS Code is a platform to provide content. Plugins are this content and some are open source and others are closed source. Another thing is that I prefer Jetbrains IDEs. They have real power of refaktoring and sincerely who writes imports nowadays (talking about Typescript)?
- acd 6y agoI think its great that Microsoft has made a great open source code editor/ide! If one wants a full open source eco system there is always Eclipse/Atom/Emacs/Vim. The paid Vscode alternative is IntelliJ but that is crippled with extensions in the community edition so you have to buy the commercial IntelliJ edition to get language extension.
- Bloggerzune 6y agohttps://www.bloggerzune.com/2019/11/best-way-to-get-rid-of-all-malware.html?m=1 https://www.bloggerzune.com/2019/11/best-way-to-get-rid-of-a... Some additional salt in this particular wound is that the use of the Marketplace of VS Code extensions is also proprietarily licensed. So all these open source developers are shoving their extensions into a competitive advantage for one of the world's largest tech firms. What does this mean in practice? I guess it protects from the competition. Such as the VS Codium project which provides VS Code binaries without the proprietary parts. But also, as a consequence of this, without the Marketplace of extensions.
- znpy 6y ago"Microsoft <3 Open Source" /s
- moron4hire 6y agoHell of a lot of people in this thread insisting that a glorified chatroom shuffled off into the extension gallery is "critical, core functionality". I guess they must have been former Emacs users.
- submeta 6y agoI am very skeptical of Microsoft, even in 2020, with a visionary, embracing CEO. VS Code is a beautiful product with very nice defaults out of the box, very polished workflows and user-experience when it comes to extending it. With this free offer MS drove many competing products out of the market (Sublime Text anyone?). Google trends for VS Code is sky rocketing. Thank you Microsoft, but I stick to the intelliJ family when I need a serious IDE and Emacs for all other text related stuff.
- haolez 6y agoIt's time for a rebirth of Atom, then! Except it's "owned" by Microsoft as well. Oh, well... let's revive LightTable, then :)
- globular-toast 6y agoOf course it is. VSCode is attractive to people who should be using Emacs, but were too afraid to try it. But unfortunately what you get is not Emacs, it's a Microsoft product and if you think they made it because of "love" then you are incredibly naïve.
- neurobashing 6y agoI was at Pycon - even at the MS booth! - when the Remote stuff was announced. There was a lot of pushback on why it wasn't open. At the time the story was, opening it didn't provide much benefit at the start, but was possible in the future; I recall the all-over-the-place nature of the code was stated as one of the "there's no benefit" (eg they don't want 100 pull requests to fix trivial things or formatting or issues they already know about). They may never open it. Open source isn't magic pixie dust you sprinkle on software to make it better, but it does make for a weird experience to see them open some things and not others.
- physicles 6y agoIs VS Code lean anymore? I switched to it long ago when Atom got too slow, but I’m using VS under Ubuntu for Go development on a brand new X1 Carbon and it’s laggy as hell — probably 200ms average between keypress and response, and sometimes up to a second between clicking to open a file and getting focus in the window. I mean I love the extensions and everything but I’m probably gonna use this as motivation to learn vim.
- skyfaller 6y agoWhat open source alternatives are there to LiveShare? I've become rather reliant on LiveShare, I had never checked whether each extension I was using was open source. Teletype for Atom appears to be under an MIT license, and it seemed to work fine for me before I switched to VS Code (after M$ acquired Github and I figured Atom was doomed). https://github.com/atom/teletype https://github.com/atom/teletype
- zimbatm 6y agoI know that the author wants to use VS Code. But for those reading here and live in the terminal, tmate[1] is truly incredible. Install and type `tmate`, and you have a tmux session that people can SSH into. I have used it countless times and is a great complement to a video sessions. Much better than pixelated fonts in a screen share. [1]: https://github.com/tmate-io/tmate https://github.com/tmate-io/tmate
- zeroego 6y agoI can't wait to try this, thanks for sharing!
- chillee 6y agoI don't think tmate allows you to edit text separately, right? It simply allows you to both control the screen. VSCode Live Share allows users to independently move. So, if you're pair programming and want to check something, you don't need to awkwardly ask to switch files.
- esalman 6y agoLately I have become fully dependent on the remote development extension for my research, and this makes me very uneasy. I do not want to be restricted to using proprietary tools in case they change something down the line that is not to my liking. It was a lot of trouble moving on from Matlab to Python already...
- ilaksh 6y agoI think TextAdept is underrated, and it's very easy to extend with Lua.
- aliswe 6y agoThe .net core debugger is also similarly proprietary. Why is that you think? Serious question.